GPT-6.2 Sol 1.59×

Harness: Codex · switches: BAGEL_REUSE_ROLLOUT_METADATA=1 BAGEL_GRAPH_TEXT_DECODE=1 BAGEL_KEEP_ROLLOUT_EXPERT_SPLIT=1 BAGEL_REUSE_EDIT_IMAGE_PREFIX=1 BAGEL_FUSE_RMS128=1 BAGEL_FUSE_QK_ROTARY=1 BAGEL_FUSE_RMS3584=1

Judged
1.59×
Tier
N0
Self-best
1.61×
Rounds
14
Hours
10.0
API cost
$12.4
Input tokens · 97.3% cached
61 M
Output tokens
0.3 M
Requests
437
Raw work log14 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — baseline profile
- Start/GPU lock: 2026-11-17 20:04:38 UTC, unchanged upstream 761b0b0.
- Profile (steps 10–11): PID 834539; launcher log /tmp/r3-round1-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round1-profile.
- Baseline: 22.6326 / 23.3627 / 23.0419 s/step; frozen spread 8.49%. Bootstrap quick check: PASS (N0); bootstrap full check: UNAVAILABLE (no benefit, 0.9206×).
- Baseline profile: the rank-0 generate/refine steps have GPU activity on 41.5% / 48.4% of instrumented wall. aten::item accounts for 17.3% / 16.6% of wall (103,341 / 141,155 calls), aten::nonzero 2.6% / 2.3%, and CUDA runtime synchronization 15.4% / 16.2% (overlaps the op totals). Index kernels account for 8.4% / 9.5% of summed GPU intervals; NCCL 5.9% / 2.7%; FlashAttention 3.3% / 5.4%. See /tmp/r3-round1-profile/summary.txt.
- Stopped the profile after a complete 3.4-GiB Chrome trace was exported: the judge’s optional key_averages() post-processing still held the GPU lock five minutes after trace export. The exported trace, not an instrumented timing, drove the change.
- Hypothesis: rollout code repeatedly transfers the same scalar timestep and reconstructs identical KV-cache geometry for each decoder layer. This is a host/sync hotspot, not a change of attention backend or precision.
- Prototype in /tmp/r3-round1-tree: BAGEL_REUSE_ROLLOUT_METADATA=1 broadcasts timesteps on device and scopes one cache layout to each inference forward. Uniform cache update and varlen prefix merge still use the original FlashAttention calls; the layouts are discarded before any sequence-length change. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- CPU probe: 48 cases (empty/nonempty prefixes; one/many sequences; uniform/varlen queries; indexed/full batches; read/update) passed exact comparisons of the packed FlashAttention arguments and cache writes with mocked attention. Timestep broadcast matched the baseline tensor in fp32, fp64 and bf16. This is not gate 2 evidence.
- time: PID 930574; launcher log /tmp/r3-round1-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round1-time; candidate config /tmp/r3-round1-switches.json.
- Timing result (20:33:41 UTC): ok, 1.1313× frozen reference; 20.0745 / 20.3030 / 20.6468 s/step, 130.72 GiB allocated peak, 0.758 GPU-hours for timing. Passes screening for more work, but below the frozen-spread full-check threshold of 1.1698×.
- Round ended 20:34 UTC; deterministic validation follows the timing round. check --quick: PID 1057054; launcher log /tmp/r3-round1-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round1-quick. Pending; the submission remains unchanged.
- Deterministic validation finished 20:47:48 UTC: PASS, N0, 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensor digests, 235 reward requests, exact. Promoted as commit dd216aed and enabled its switch. Library versions unchanged. Retained torch/FlashAttention kernels, with the shared metadata path enabled only for a static cache and a fallback to unchanged per-layer layout otherwise.
0.7 hRound 2 — accepted-candidate profile
- Start: 2026-11-17T20:48:38Z. Rank-0 refine step 11; one step to limit profiler post-processing. PID 1168637; launcher log /tmp/r3-round2-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round2-profile.
- GPU lock at 20:49:01 UTC. Rank-0 refine profile: 64.2% GPU-active; matrix multiplies 48.5%, indexing 9.6%, attention 5.8%, and NCCL 2.5% of summed GPU event time. Trace details: /tmp/r3-round2-profile/tiered-summary.txt. aten::item fell from 141,155 to 26,139 calls; nonzero from 12,860 to 371. The decode span still accounts for ~34% of instrumented step wall, at only 22% GPU activity (GEMM 51.4% of decode GPU time); focus is kernel submission, not changing math.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round2-tree: BAGEL_GRAPH_TEXT_DECODE=1 replays the existing one-token decoder for each active batch size. Cache lengths and selected sequence IDs are live graph inputs; logits, sampling, generator, and EOS handling remain eager. Each graph dies before rollout weights can be resharded. Fallback: no static CUDA cache, dynamic RoPE, insufficient capacity, or fewer than eight remaining iterations for a new shape. No timing/determinism-specific dispatch.
- Locked single-GPU probe (3-layer bf16 MoT, active batches 4 then 3, valid diverse KV lengths, /tmp/r3_graph_probe.py) matched tokens, full sampled probabilities, K/V cache and generator state with deterministic algorithms both on and off. Syntax/whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 1264581; launcher log /tmp/r3-round2-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round2-time; config /tmp/r3-round2-switches.json.
- Timing result and round end (20:49:01–21:14:11 UTC): ok, 1.3931× frozen; 15.8295 / 16.6412 / 17.0857 s/step, 130.76 GiB allocated peak, 0.682 GPU-hours for timing. Replay saves 3.8226 s/step (18.8%) versus the round-1 run's mean; this is screening, not the verdict. The complete round-2 profile also returned ok.
- check --quick: PID 1390757; launcher log /tmp/r3-round2-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round2-quick. Validation follows the timing round. The submission retains round 1 pending this check.
- Quick result 21:26:14 UTC: PASS, N0, all 14 steps, 3,200 tensor digests, and 235 reward requests exact. Promoted as commit 961202a7 with both switches enabled.
1.8 hRound 3 — full-pass candidate profile
- Start: 2026-11-17T21:49:25Z. Profile committed stack (generate/refine steps 10–11). PID 1739552; launcher log /tmp/r3-round3-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round3-profile.
- GPU lock at 21:49:49 UTC, profile OK. Rank-0 generate/refine GPU-active 70.9%/77.0%; GEMM 46.7%/48.2%, indexing 8.1%/9.5%, and other kernels 27.7%/29.5% of GPU event time. FlashAttention 3.5%/5.8%. Decode only 21.5%/13.0% of the instrumented steps. Trace ranking across both: index-put ~5.4%, FP32 mul variants ~4.9%, two copy/cast variants ~4.3%, and neg/cat variants ~2.0% (whole-step shares, not all exclusively rotary). See /tmp/r3-round3-profile/tiered-summary.txt.
- Current prototype in /tmp/r3-round3-tree, only new switch BAGEL_FUSE_ROLLOUT_ROTARY=1: fuse pointwise rotation and the following BF16 cast in MoT image inference. All reductions, group routing, attention calls, and training/backward stay unchanged. Contiguous supported FP32 Q/K only, dimension 128, no grad. Disable FMA and use the original two FP32 multiplies and FP32 addition; same final BF16 store. First eligible call checks every output bit against eager; unsupported workloads fall back to eager.
- Locked GPU op probe: 20 exact comparisons with deterministic algorithms on/off, including 4,104 tokens, 28 Q / 4 KV heads, FP32/BF16 cos/sin, signed zero, and subnormals. Syntax and whitespace checks passed. No promotion pending full workload evidence.
- time: PID 1835301; launcher log /tmp/r3-round3-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round3-time; config /tmp/r3-round3-switches.json.
- Timing result and round end (21:49:49–22:14:59 UTC): ok, 1.4147× frozen; 15.5565 / 16.7024 / 16.5405 s/step, 130.76 GiB allocated peak, 0.669 GPU-hours. Mean 16.2665 s/step vs 16.5188 for round-2 timing and 16.3473 in its full check. Increment is only 0.5–1.5%, within noise with one window slower than round-2 full. Not promoting on this evidence.
- check --quick: PID 1961524; launcher log /tmp/r3-round3-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round3-quick. Checking exactness separately because this changed a kernel; the full-pass submission remains unchanged.
- Quick result 22:27:42 UTC: PASS, N0, 14 steps, 3,200 tensor digests and 235 reward requests. Commit bafb827a retained in the experimental worktree only. No promotion: timing improvement is too close to noise.
2.4 hRound 4 — generate-step profile
- Start: 2026-11-17T22:28:12Z. Profile the full-pass stack again (generate step 10), focusing on the post-graph gaps and phase attribution. PID 2073002; launcher log /tmp/r3-round4-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round4-profile.
- GPU lock 22:28:36 UTC. Generate step 71.8% GPU-active; 46.9% of GPU event time in GEMM, 27.9% other, 9.0% NCCL, 8.2% indexing. Transfer attribution showed 0.37s summed CUDA malloc/free runtime, including 0.26s after text sampling. Round-3 refine trace had 1.49s summed malloc/free runtime, 1.32s after sampling. Collectives overlap execution and can include rank waiting; did not change collective scheduling. See /tmp/r3-round4-profile/transfers-and-packing.txt and /tmp/r3-round3-profile/transfers-and-packing.txt for instrumentation-only breakdowns.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round4-tree sets BAGEL_CUDA_CACHE_HEADROOM_MIB=2048: trim on low free CUDA memory rather than at every existing rollout and buffer boundary. Uses the same native allocator and allocations; no other math or stream changes. Default retains upstream unconditional trim. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 2168539; launcher log /tmp/r3-round4-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round4-time; config /tmp/r3-round4-switches.json.
- Mocked headroom probe passed the retain, low-memory trim, and default unconditional-trim cases.
- Native allocator result 22:47:06 UTC: ERROR (no speedup); rank 2 OOM allocating 1 GiB with 862 MiB globally free and 6.84 GiB reserved/unallocated. Do not promote. Screen the same cache policy with expandable segments within this allocation round.
- Expandable time: PID 2264162; launcher log /tmp/r3-round4-expandable-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round4-expandable-time; config /tmp/r3-round4-expandable-switches.json. This is independent of the submitted switches.
- Round end 22:58:56 UTC. Expandable segments avoided OOM but regressed all windows: 17.5440 / 18.2876 / 17.9697 s/step, 1.2832× frozen, 130.67 GiB peak, 0.695 GPU-hours. No exactness run for the rejected allocation-only variants (no arithmetic change). Experimental commit ee9eb1d0; not promoted.
2.9 hRound 5 — refine profile
- Start: 2026-11-17T22:59:54Z. Profile the full-pass stack (refine step 11) for conditioning/prefill and packing costs. PID 2390270; launcher log /tmp/r3-round5-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round5-profile.
- GPU lock 23:00:18 UTC. Refine step was 81.9% GPU-active under instrumentation; GPU event shares: GEMM 48.7%, other 29.6%, indexing 9.5%, flash attention 5.8%, NCCL 2.6%. Decode was 13.7% of step wall at 65.6% GPU activity, with 3,851 scalar reads and 3,857 CUDA synchronization calls; image prefill was only 4.1% of step wall. See /tmp/r3-round5-profile/tiered-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round5-tree batches sampled tokens and their original fp32 probabilities into one host transfer per iteration (BAGEL_BATCH_TEXT_READBACK=1). EOS decisions use host copies, not per-sample scalar lookups. Same graph, softmax, RNG calls including the discarded sample after EOS, and active-sequence ordering. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 2486053; launcher log /tmp/r3-round5-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round5-time; config /tmp/r3-round5-switches.json. Full-pass submission remains unchanged.
- CPU control-flow probe (/tmp/r3_round5_readback_probe.py): 90 exact cases, including partial/all EOS, forced EOS, greedy/top-k/top-p, and both deterministic settings. Tokens, probabilities, positions, cache lengths/data and generator states agree. This is not gate 2 evidence.
- Timing result and round end (23:22:33 UTC): ok, 1.3917× frozen; 15.6693 / 17.1200 / 16.8157 s/step, 130.76 GiB peak, 0.668 GPU-hours. No incremental gain (16.5350 s/step vs 16.5188 for round-2 timing, 16.3473 for its full check). Not promoting.
- Deterministic follow-up check --quick: PID 2612182; launcher log /tmp/r3-round5-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round5-quick. Round ended at the timing decision; this validation runs on the detached prototype, not the submission.
- Quick result 23:34:32 UTC: PASS, N0. Commit 365ed00 retained only in the experimental worktree. No timing gain, so it stays off.
3.5 hRound 6 — per-stage refine profile
- Start: 2026-11-17T23:36:59Z. Profile the full-pass stack at refine step 11, with separate denoising and training attribution. PID 2723520; launcher log /tmp/r3-round6-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round6-profile.
- GPU lock 23:37:23 UTC. Round-6 refine profile: 86.2% GPU-active; GPU event shares GEMM 46.1%, other 28.0%, NCCL 7.7%, scatter 6.1%, flash attention 5.5%, gather 3.0%. Denoising was 37.4% of instrumented wall and 94.8% GPU-active; 9.7% scatter and 3.3% gather (1.027s summed GPU events). The corresponding R5 attribution was 13.0% too. See /tmp/r3-round6-profile/stage-summary.txt.
- Additional trace attribution for future rounds: packing took 0.494s of instrumented wall, with 20,516 .item()/synchronization calls and only 12.2% GPU activity. See /tmp/r3-round6-profile/packing-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round6-tree: BAGEL_KEEP_ROLLOUT_EXPERT_SPLIT=1 keeps text and latent residual rows separate in read-only static-cache MoT inference, merging Q/K/V for the same FlashAttention call. Model uses the path only with a verified full row partition and no training or gradients. Keeps expert GEMM/RMSNorm inputs and rotary layout, leaving RNG, cache and training path unchanged. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 2819028; launcher log /tmp/r3-round6-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round6-time; config /tmp/r3-round6-switches.json. Submitted stack is still the full-pass round-2 stack.
- CPU probe (/tmp/r3_round6_expert_probe.py) matched complete FlashAttention arguments and outputs byte-for-byte for eight cases (bf16/fp32 residuals, partition/fallback, deterministic on/off). KV storage and RNG did not change. This is not gate 2 evidence.
- Timing result and round end (23:59:05 UTC): ok, 1.4409× frozen; 15.5142 / 16.2359 / 16.1626 s/step, mean 15.9709 s/step, 130.76 GiB peak, 0.657 GPU-hours. All three windows beat round-2 time; 3.3% less time per step than that run. Await N0 before promoting.
- Deterministic follow-up check --quick: PID 2945261; launcher log /tmp/r3-round6-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round6-quick. The validated submission remains unchanged until a result.
- Quick result 2026-11-18 00:10:39 UTC: PASS, N0. All 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests matched exactly. Promoted as commit f1e21b6 and enabled its tested switch.
- Full check: started 2026-11-18T00:11:13Z on the promoted tree. PID 3056506; launcher log /tmp/r3-round6-full.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round6-full. Separate from the timing round.
- Full check result 2026-11-18 00:32:27 UTC: PASS, N0, 1.4363× against the frozen reference, /tmp/r3-round6-full/check.json.
4.5 hRound 7 — packing profile
- Start: 2026-11-18T00:33:11Z. Profile the latest full-pass stack at refine step 3, after step-0 evaluation and both rollout modes have run, to capture packing with a shorter warmup. PID 3293480; launcher log /tmp/r3-round7-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round7-profile.

- GPU lock 00:33:35 UTC. Refine step 3 was 78.6% GPU-active; top event shares GEMM 50.7%, other 30.6%, flash attention 6.2%, scatter 3.7%, reductions 3.2%, NCCL 2.5%, gather 2.3%. Packing was 0.473s, only 12.7% GPU-active, with 20,516 scalar transfers accounting for 55.7% of packing wall. See /tmp/r3-round7-profile/stage-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round7-tree: BAGEL_PACK_SCALARS_ONCE=1 converts each scalar timestep and dt once per packed latent, before repeating it in the existing lists. Same fp32 tensor constructors, same ordering and CFG decisions. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 3365729; launcher log /tmp/r3-round7-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round7-time; config /tmp/r3-round7-switches.json.
- CPU probe (/tmp/r3_round7_pack_probe.py): all packed model inputs and loss metadata matched byte-for-byte across six conditional/CFG cases with fp32/fp64/bf16 scalars, including masked timesteps and signed zero. This is not gate 2 evidence.
- check --quick queued to start after a successful timing run. PID 3367116; launcher log /tmp/r3-round7-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round7-quick.
- Timing result 00:52:57 UTC: ok, 1.4485× frozen; 15.3255 / 16.1739 / 16.1622 s/step, 15.8872 s/step mean, 130.76 GiB peak, 0.659 GPU-hours. Only 0.5% better than round-6 time and effectively tied in the last window. Not promoting on this timing evidence. Quick check follows as queued.
- Quick result 01:03:44 UTC: PASS, N0. GPU work finished before the 30-minute round limit; final input verification completed afterward. Commit 56ed726 retained only in its detached worktree. No promotion because the timing effect is too small.
5.0 hRound 8 — image-conditioning profile
- Start: 2026-11-18T01:04:22Z. Profile the current full-pass stack at refine step 3, separating image prefill from autoregressive text and denoising. PID 3603507; launcher log /tmp/r3-round8-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round8-profile.

- GPU lock 01:04:46 UTC. Refine step 3: 78.5% GPU-active, GPU event shares GEMM 50.9%, other 30.5%, flash attention 6.2%, scatter 3.7%, reductions 3.2% and NCCL 2.4%. Image prefill was 0.902s (3.8% of instrumented wall), 81.5% GPU-active, mostly GEMM (47.5%) and attention (16.0%). See /tmp/r3-round8-profile/stage-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round8-tree: BAGEL_REUSE_EDIT_IMAGE_PREFIX=1 replaces the duplicate eval-only VAE/ViT prefix prefill in refinement with a deep copy of the conditional image-only cache, before edit text is appended. The CFG cache has independent storage and sequence/position metadata. The standard image transform is deterministic and eval Gaussian encoding consumes no RNG. Other paths fall back to the existing forwards. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 3675654; launcher log /tmp/r3-round8-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round8-time; config /tmp/r3-round8-switches.json.
- CPU probe (/tmp/r3_round8_prefix_probe.py): five cases matched all prefix bits, lengths, positions and generator state with independent cache storage. Covers standard eval, stochastic fallbacks, nonstatic request and disabled text CFG. This is not gate 2 evidence.
- check --quick queued after successful timing. PID 3677050; launcher log /tmp/r3-round8-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round8-quick.
- Timing result 01:23:48 UTC: ok, 1.4694× frozen; 15.3651 / 15.9630 / 15.6556 s/step, mean 15.6613, 130.76 GiB peak, 0.650 GPU-hours. All three windows improve over round-6 time, with 1.9% lower mean seconds per step. N0 quick check running before any promotion.
- Quick result and round end 01:34:29 UTC: PASS, N0 (14 steps, 3,200 tensor digests, 235 reward requests). Promoted as 079e18f, enabled the tested switch.
- Full check: started 2026-11-18T01:35:11Z, PID 3913471; launcher log /tmp/r3-round8-full.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round8-full. Separate from the timing round.
- Full check result 01:55:51 UTC: PASS, N0, 1.463× against the frozen reference, /tmp/r3-round8-full/check.json.
5.9 hRound 9 — kernel and operator profile
- Start: 2026-11-18T01:56:44Z. Profile the full-pass stack at generate step 2 after the initial evaluation/refine warmup; attribute denoising kernels to CUDA launches and linked normalization ops. PID 4150675; launcher log /tmp/r3-round9-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round9-profile.

- GPU lock 01:57:08 UTC. Generate step 2 was 56.5% GPU-active under profiling; GPU event shares GEMM 51.3%, other 30.6%, NCCL 5.0%, flash attention 3.9%, reductions 3.6%, scatter 3.3%. Denoising was 93.9% GPU-active; linked square, mean and reciprocal square root consumed 2.2%, 2.5% and 0.3% of its GPU event time, plus separate full-width multiply passes. The trace identifies ATen's float32 four-accumulator mean kernel. See /tmp/r3-round9-profile/stage-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round9-tree: BAGEL_FUSE_RMS128=1 targets 128-channel no-grad Q/K RMSNorm with contiguous input and at least 16 rows. Preserves torch 2.9.1's four squares per lane, increasing shuffle offsets, BF16 cast before scaling, and no FMA. Unsupported shapes use eager; live first-call comparison guards each dtype signature. The full-pass submission is unchanged.
- Locked single-GPU probe (/tmp/r3_rms128_probe.py): all 40 comparisons passed byte-for-byte, including real denoising Q/K row counts, both weight/input dtypes, deterministic algorithms on/off and CUDA-graph replay. Syntax and whitespace checks passed. This is not gate 2 evidence.
- time: PID 12530; launcher log /tmp/r3-round9-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round9-time; config /tmp/r3-round9-switches.json.
- check --quick queued after successful timing. PID 12531; launcher log /tmp/r3-round9-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round9-quick.
- Timing result 02:17:12 UTC: ok, 1.4923× frozen; 14.6617 / 15.9108 / 15.6896 s/step, mean 15.4207, 130.76 GiB peak, 0.663 GPU-hours. 1.5% lower mean step time than round 8 time, driven mostly by the first window. Quick exactness is running; repeat the timing in a full check before deciding on promotion.
- Quick follow-up result 02:28:11 UTC: PASS, N0, all 14 steps, 3,200 tensor digests, and 235 reward requests. The timed round ended at 02:17:12; the cold deterministic follow-up completed separately. Experimental commit 52d56dc.
- Full recheck on the experimental tree: started 2026-11-18T02:29:15Z, PID 250237; launcher log /tmp/r3-round9-full.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round9-full. Submission remains the round-8 full-pass stack until repeat evidence.
- Full recheck result 02:49:58 UTC: PASS, N0, 1.4831× against the frozen reference, /tmp/r3-round9-full/check.json. Full-check windows 14.8659 / 15.7837 / 15.9289 s/step vs round 8's 15.2800 / 16.0046 / 15.9125. Both independent measurements favor the new kernel; promoted 52d56dc and enabled its switch.
6.8 hRound 10 — denoising Q/K path profile
- Start: 2026-11-18T02:51:24Z. Profile the full-pass RMSNorm stack at refine step 3, attributing remaining Q/K layout and rotary cost. PID 487508; launcher log /tmp/r3-round10-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round10-profile.
- GPU lock at 02:51:48 UTC; profile OK. Refine step spent 76.1% of instrumented wall GPU-active. GPU event shares: GEMM 52.8%, other kernels 29.0%, attention 6.2%, scatter 3.8%, reductions/norms 2.6%. Denoising was 94.1% GPU-active, led by GEMMs at 57.6%, other kernels 24.1%, attention 11.1%, scatter 4.0% and gather 1.5%. Linked mul, cat, neg and FP32 copy variants accounted for 10.3%, 1.4%, 0.6% and 3.5% respectively (not all Q/K preparation). See /tmp/r3-round10-profile/stage-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round10-tree, BAGEL_FUSE_QK_ROTARY=1: for the no-grad split MoT path, fuse RMSNorm of FP32-promoted projections, rotary and routing scatter to the packed BF16 outputs. Retain FP32 intermediate rounding, the existing exact RMS128 reduction, and unchanged projections, cache handling and FlashAttention. No submission changes pending evidence.
- Locked probe (/tmp/r3_gen_attention_probe.py): all eight actual-width cases took the fused path and matched eager Q/K/V attention arguments, complete layer output and the untouched KV cache byte-for-byte, with deterministic algorithms on and off. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 560257; launcher log /tmp/r3-round10-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round10-time; config /tmp/r3-round10-switches.json.
- check --quick queued after successful timing: PID 560258; launcher log /tmp/r3-round10-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round10-quick.
- Timing result and timed round end 03:15:33 UTC: ok, 1.5271× frozen; 14.3969 / 15.3911 / 15.4195 s/step, mean 15.0692, 130.76 GiB peak, 0.643 GPU-hours. Each window improved, with a 2.3% lower mean versus round 9 time and 2.9% versus its full check. Quick validation is running on exactly the timed prototype.
- Training attribution from the same judge trace (/tmp/r3-round10-profile/training-summary.txt): training backward outside recomputation 47.2%, forward/clip 42.7%, checkpoint-recomputed GEMMs 9.2% (lower bound), AdamW 0.9% of training GPU events. Optimizer fusion is not a priority.
- Full follow-up queued after a quick pass and a locked probe: PID 692283; launcher log /tmp/r3-round10-full.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round10-full. This second worktree registers the same kernel as a CUDA custom op with fake implementation and verifies its first live result per signature against the eager path before reusing it.
- Quick follow-up at 03:25:51 UTC: PASS, N0. Promoted the timed and bitwise-checked prototype bc9415b; the previous full-pass tree remains reproducible by disabling the new switch. The guarded custom op also passed the eight-case locked probe with all eligible signatures verified. Its full run acquired the GPU lock at 03:26:23 UTC.
- Full follow-up completed at 03:45:42 UTC: PASS, N0, 1.5301× against frozen timing, all 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensor digests and 235 reward requests exact. Promoted the custom op with live verification as commit 1511293.
7.7 hRound 11 — remaining GPU work and sharding profile
- Start: 2026-11-18T03:46:11Z. Profile the committed stack on refine step 3. PID 1036539; launcher log /tmp/r3-round11-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round11-profile. Focus attribution on remaining data movement and all-gathers.
- GPU lock at 03:46:35 UTC, profile OK. GPU-active 78.9% of the instrumented step, led by GEMMs 55.0%, other kernels 26.0%, attention 6.6%, scatter 3.4%, NCCL 2.8%. Denoising was 95.1% GPU-active; GEMM 64.8%, other 16.1%, attention 12.5%. Linked pow and mean still account for 1.5% each of denoising GPU time after the Q/K fusion, plus weighting and conversion traffic. Linked training all-gathers and copy-outs are 0.216s total (includes overlap; not all avoidable); denoising KV prefix materialization is 0.130s or 2.0% of the denoising phase. See the summaries in /tmp/r3-round11-profile.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round11-tree, BAGEL_FUSE_RMS3584=1: no-grad 3584-channel RMSNorm, fuse square, mean, rsqrt, normalization and scaling. Match ATen's 28 vector chunks per lane, accumulator combination, increasing shuffles and BF16 rounding. Use contiguous shapes with at least 16 rows, fake implementation and a live verification guard; other calls use eager. The full-pass submission is unchanged.
- Locked probe (/tmp/r3_rms3584_probe.py): 32 byte-exact cases including 4096 rows, both input/weight dtypes and deterministic algorithms on and off, with all four live dtype checks accepting the fused kernel. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 1109038; launcher log /tmp/r3-round11-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round11-time; config /tmp/r3-round11-switches.json.
- check --quick queued on successful timing: PID 1109039; launcher log /tmp/r3-round11-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round11-quick.
- Timing result and timed round end 04:08:28 UTC: ok, 1.6115× frozen; 13.7312 / 14.6969 / 14.4117 s/step, mean 14.2799, 130.76 GiB allocated peak, 0.621 GPU-hours. All three windows improved over round 10; mean step time is 5.2% lower than its time run. Experimental commit 0d29ee3; submission remains the full-pass round-10 stack until quick validation completes.
- Full check queued after a quick pass: PID 1236381; launcher log /tmp/r3-round11-full.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round11-full. Code and switches match the timing run.
- Quick follow-up at 04:18:44 UTC: PASS, N0, 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 optimizer/parameter tensor digests and 235 reward requests exact. Promoted 0d29ee3 with the new switch enabled. The repeat full check is in flight.
- Full check completed at 04:38:39 UTC: PASS, N0, 1.5819× against frozen timing; 13.8648 / 14.9799 / 14.8309 s/step. All 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 parameter/optimizer tensor digests and 235 reward requests exact. Both timing runs favor the new kernel; retain 0d29ee3.
8.6 hRound 12 — training layout profile
- Start: 2026-11-18T04:39:28Z. Profile the committed stack at refine step 3, focusing attribution on indices and copies in policy and frozen reference training forwards and checkpoint backward. PID 1584900; launcher log /tmp/r3-round12-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round12-profile.
- GPU lock at 04:39:52 UTC, profile OK. Step GPU event time: GEMM 56.7%, other 22.9%, attention 6.8%, NCCL 4.2%, scatter 3.5%, gather 2.6%. Training was 96.8% GPU-active with 47.9% GEMM, 5.3% scatter and 4.3% gather (0.706s combined), including 0.219s linked to backward index-put. See /tmp/r3-round12-profile/stage-summary.txt and /tmp/r3-round12-profile/training-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round12-tree: BAGEL_KEEP_TRAIN_EXPERT_QK=1 normalizes each MoT expert's projection directly, skips the temporary packed Q/K before normalization, then packs the same Q/K/V for unchanged rotary and attention. A disjoint full partition is verified once per packed forward. Restrict to CUDA BF16 autocast and unfrozen understanding rows. All six projection GEMMs and their inputs are unchanged.
- Locked probe (/tmp/r3_train_qk_probe.py): four actual-width attention cases with unsorted valid partitions matched forward and all input/parameter gradient bits, including non-reentrant activation checkpointing and deterministic mode. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 1657467; launcher log /tmp/r3-round12-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round12-time; config /tmp/r3-round12-switches.json.
- check --quick queued on successful timing: PID 1657468; launcher log /tmp/r3-round12-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round12-quick.
- Timing result and timed round end 05:01:27 UTC: ok, 1.5957× frozen; 13.7748 / 14.6331 / 14.8561 s/step, mean 14.4213, 130.77 GiB peak, 0.615 GPU-hours. Slower than the round-11 time run (14.2799 s/step), faster than its full check (14.5585 s/step); the window changes are mixed. No clear gain and no promotion. Keep experimental commit 8c9a67e only in the detached worktree; quick exactness validation follows.
- Quick follow-up finished at 05:11:46 UTC: PASS, N0 (14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensor digests, 235 reward requests). Still not promoted because the mixed timing does not establish a benefit.
9.1 hRound 13 — inference memory traffic profile
- Start: 2026-11-18T05:12:17Z. Profile the submitted stack at refine step 3, focusing remaining inference pointwise and MLP activation traffic. PID 1895423; launcher log /tmp/r3-round13-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round13-profile.
- GPU lock at 05:12:41 UTC; profile OK. Refine GPU event time: GEMM 57.1%, other 23.1%, attention 6.9%, scatter 3.6%, NCCL 3.6%. Denoising was 94.0% GPU-active; GEMM 71.5%, attention 14.0%, other kernels 8.6%. SiLU and all linked multiplies were 2.3% and 3.1% of denoising GPU time; the dominant BF16 multiply kernel alone was 2.8%. See /tmp/r3-round13-profile/stage-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round13-tree, BAGEL_FUSE_SILU_MUL=1: for no-grad BF16 MLPs, fuse SiLU and the gating product. A per-device 128-KiB table holds ATen's SiLU output for every BF16 input bit pattern, preserving the intermediate rounding; the Triton op only looks up that result and multiplies in the original precision. Guard the first call against eager, register a fake implementation, and leave all three linear projections unchanged.
- Locked probe (/tmp/r3_silu_mul_probe.py): all 65,536 BF16 bit patterns with several multiplier distributions, real 4- and 4096-row shapes, deterministic algorithms on/off, and CUDA graph replay matched byte-for-byte. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 1968021; launcher log /tmp/r3-round13-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round13-time; config /tmp/r3-round13-switches.json.
- check --quick queued on successful timing: PID 1968022; launcher log /tmp/r3-round13-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round13-quick.
- Timing result and timed round end 05:33:25 UTC: ok, 1.5930× frozen; 13.7251 / 14.7100 / 14.9032 s/step, mean 14.4461, 130.76 GiB peak, 0.618 GPU-hours. The first two windows were effectively unchanged versus round-11 time, and the last regressed. No promotion; commit b84ecfd stays in the detached worktree. Quick exactness check follows.
- Quick follow-up finished at 05:43:47 UTC: PASS, N0 (14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensor digests, 235 reward requests). SiLU fusion remains unsubmitted due to timing.
9.7 hRound 14 — rollout-to-training sharding profile
- Start: 2026-11-18T05:45:01Z. Profile the submitted stack on generate step 2, focusing on policy-owned parameter all-gathers and renewed unsharding before training. PID 2206288; launcher log /tmp/r3-round14-profile.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round14-profile.
- GPU lock at 05:45:25 UTC; profile OK. Generate step GPU event shares: GEMM 60.5%, other kernels 21.3%, NCCL 5.3%, attention 4.6%, scatter 3.1%. Linked all-gather plus copy-out accounted for 0.122s during rollout and 0.136s during training; the previous refine profile showed 0.216s during training. These are summed GPU intervals, including overlap. See /tmp/r3-round14-profile/training-summary.txt and /tmp/r3-round14-profile/stage-summary.txt.
- Prototype /tmp/r3-round14-tree, BAGEL_REUSE_UNSHARDED_POLICY=1: hold the policy's unchanged FSDP2 compute weights between rollout and training instead of re-gathering them; keep normal hooks, backward reductions, clipping and optimizer. After backward, reshard any unused layers before clipping. Eval-only callers and rollout exceptions still release immediately. Check memory on the judge; the full-pass submission is unchanged.
- Locked four-rank FSDP2 probe (/tmp/r3_fsdp_reuse_probe.py): outputs, gradients and AdamW states exact over repeated steps, with deterministic algorithms on and off and an unused wrapped layer. Syntax and whitespace checks passed.
- time: PID 2262236; launcher log /tmp/r3-round14-time.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round14-time; config /tmp/r3-round14-switches.json.
- check --quick queued on successful timing: PID 2262237; launcher log /tmp/r3-round14-quick.launch.log; output /tmp/r3-round14-quick.
↑ R3