GPT-6.2 Astra 1.77×

Harness: Codex · switches: BAGEL_GRAPH_DECODE=1 BAGEL_PACKED_KV_READ=1 BAGEL_DEVICE_TIMESTEP=1 BAGEL_SPLIT_EXPERTS=1 BAGEL_EXACT_RMS=1 BAGEL_PACKED_ROPE=1 BAGEL_REWARD_OVERLAP=1 BAGEL_REUSE_UNSHARD=1 BAGEL_OFFLOAD_FROZEN_SHARDS=1

Judged
1.77×
Tier
N0
Self-best
1.81×
Rounds
15
Hours
10.0
API cost
$50.0
Input tokens · 97.7% cached
63 M
Output tokens
0.3 M
Requests
436
Raw work log15 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — unchanged reference profile
- 20:03:37 launched the judge's profile --from 2 --iters 1 on targets/reference, PID 834489, log /tmp/r3-profile-1.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-1. GPU lock acquired 20:04:01. Profiles the first generation step after warm-up has exercised both phases.
- Frozen judge baseline: windows 23.0652, 23.4813, 23.8307 s/step, reference spread 0.0169. The bootstrap full check of unmodified upstream was UNAVAILABLE (no benefit); bootstrap quick check was PASS (N0).
- Reference profile completed OK: rank 0 self CUDA time 7.686 s, self CPU time 13.431 s. GEMM mm 42.28% and addmm 4.64% of self CUDA, mul 10.38%, index writes 6.26%, copy_ 4.97%, comms 4.43%. 107,185 DtoH copies; 100,912 scalar extractions, 3.043 s inclusive CPU (22.65%). Many short launches, including 10,696 small GEMMs of one shape. The upstream log shows the text loop every generate and refine; every token dispatches 28 layers with repeated KV length checks and host syncs. Chosen bottleneck: host dispatch in autoregressive decoding, not changing GEMM or flash-attention algorithms.
- Experiment /tmp/r3-experiment-1, opt-in BAGEL_GRAPH_DECODE=1 (/tmp/r3-decode.json). Replay the same GPU token-forward operations in CUDA graphs. One-token query length is known; the static KV capacity bound is checked before decoding. Graph lifetime is one rollout with one fixed set of full weights. Sampling, probability and EOS handling remain eager. py_compile and git diff --check passed.
- 20:16:21 launched judge time on the experiment, PID 890400, log /tmp/r3-time-1.log, output /tmp/r3-time-1.
- Offline trace breakdown supporting the choice: first to last multinomial in the reference profile spans 7.718 s of *profiled* wall time, with only 1.412 summed device seconds over 335,234 device events. From the last sampled token to the last denoiser flash call: 4.038 summed device seconds (50.4% GEMM, 12.2% indexing). The optimizer/training tail after VAE: 2.029 summed device seconds. These are attribution numbers, not timing-run results.
- Round 1 measurement finished 20:27:47. /tmp/r3-time-1/time.json: OK, windows 17.9870, 18.5126, 19.0234 s/step, mean 18.5077, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.2675, peak allocated 130.76 GiB. Entry committed separately as bd55b54 (N0 target). 20:28:13 launched the follow-up deterministic check --quick, PID 1016676, log /tmp/r3-quick-1.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-1.
- Round closed at 20:28:48 with bitwise follow-up pending. Follow-up finished 20:40:00: /tmp/r3-quick-1/check.json PASS N0: all 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensors, 235 reward requests identical; no differing tensor kinds.
0.6 hRound 2 — profile with text graph enabled
- 20:40:31 launched profile --from 3 --iters 1 on bd55b54 and submitted switches, PID 1127910, log /tmp/r3-profile-2.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-2. Refine step after both phases have run. Isolated worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-2 starts at the N0-verified version.
- A full check of round 1 is justified by the 1.2675x time screen and N0 quick result. Queued at 20:40:46, PID 1127937, log /tmp/r3-full-1.log, output /tmp/r3-full-1; it starts only after profile 2 exits, no overlapping measurements. Full-check time is outside the round budget.
- Profile 2 held the GPU lock from 20:40:54 and finished OK at 20:52:00. The full check took the timing lock at 20:52:25. The profiled refine step had 19.813 s summed self CUDA: mm 37.29%, mul 8.46%, index writes 6.06%, copy_ 4.02%, varlen flash 3.70%, addmm 3.17%. The denoiser (linspace to VAE) spanned 12.485 s on the trace but only 8.213 device seconds, with 92,582 scalar reads (4.652 s incl. CPU), 12,096 nonzero (0.973 s incl.), and 12.7% of its device time on indexing. Token stage was 2.980 device seconds, training/VAE tail 7.531. Attribution only.
- Chosen class: redundant host round trips constructing denoising inputs. Two independently selectable parts: BAGEL_PACKED_KV_READ computes read-only KV lengths/bounds once per constraint branch and concatenates the original prefix/query slices in unchanged order for the same flash kernel. No additional persistent KV allocation. BAGEL_DEVICE_TIMESTEP materializes the scalar broadcast directly on device instead of copying one scalar per latent token through Python. Stochastic, floating-point and optimizer operations left alone. Implementation in /tmp/r3-experiment-2, config /tmp/r3-flow-inputs.json, submitted tree remains round 1. py_compile and git diff --check passed.
- CPU raw-bit and layout probes passed: 30 K/V tensors including variable-length, empty-prefix and empty-query sections, and 15 timestep vectors incl. signed zero. An initial expand().clone() kept a zero stride for singleton vectors; switched to repeat() to reproduce reference strides too. At 21:02:15 queued the combined denoiser-input time after the full check: PID 1313060, log /tmp/r3-time-2.log, output /tmp/r3-time-2.
- Round-1 full check finished at 21:14:28: /tmp/r3-full-1/check.json PASS, speedup 1.2822x, N0 bitwise. Round-2 timing can now use the GPUs. Kept profile-1 table, summaries and logs; removed the no-longer-needed 1.3 GiB trace and round-1 exploratory worktree.
- Round 2 screen (/tmp/r3-time-2/time.json) held lock from 21:14:54, completed OK 21:25:06: windows 16.0353, 16.8270, 16.8317 s/step, mean 16.5647, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.4162, peak allocated 130.76 GiB. Joint increment over round 1 screen: 1.9430 s/step, 1.1173x. The two denoiser-input switches were screened together; no isolated per-switch timing is claimed. Separate commits 49af212 (prefix plan) and 25c4346 (device timestep). Round closed 21:25:29 (about 22 min excluding the full check); quick validation started then: PID 1564014, log /tmp/r3-quick-2.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-2.
- 21:36:13 /tmp/r3-quick-2/check.json PASS N0, exact on all 14 steps, 3,200 tensors, 235 reward requests. Promoted the tested tree and identical switch file. The previous full-checked configuration remains available at bd55b54 and /tmp/r3-decode.json.
1.6 hRound 3 — profile after removing denoiser host syncs
- 21:36:51 started profile --from 2 --iters 1 on submitted 25c4346, PID 1675278, log /tmp/r3-profile-3.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-3. This profiles generate, complementing round 2's refine trace. Next experiment isolated in /tmp/r3-experiment-3.
- Profile finished OK at 21:45:01. Self CUDA 7.421 s: mm 36.68%, mul 8.98%, indexed writes 6.36%, comms 5.86%, copy_ 3.88%. Denoising spans 4.037 profiled wall seconds and 3.833 summed device seconds (108,316 device events): 54.4% GEMM, 11.5% index/gather, 6.5% copy, 4.7% flash. Now substantially device-bound. Chosen class: redundant packing/unpacking of MoT expert token rows between projections and residual branches.
- BAGEL_SPLIT_EXPERTS=1 validates the canonical, equal-size image query layout and carries separate contiguous hidden states for the two experts during read-only denoising. Restores the original row order for rotary/attention; GEMM sizes, operands, dtype conversions and normalization kernels are unchanged. Other layouts, prefill and training use the old path. py_compile, git diff --check passed. A lock-protected CUDA equality probe compared both paths with the same two-layer MoT, true hidden/intermediate/head sizes, heterogeneous prefix lengths and 1/2/4 sequences: all output bits matched at shapes (18,3584), (132,3584) and (4104,3584); hooks confirmed both paths executed. No independent timing.
- 21:50:47 launched judge time on /tmp/r3-experiment-3, config /tmp/r3-split-experts.json, PID 1731027, output /tmp/r3-time-3, log /tmp/r3-time-3.log.
- 22:01:16 /tmp/r3-time-3/time.json OK: windows 15.3122 / 16.6746 / 16.5206 s/step, mean 16.1692, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.4509, peak allocated 130.76 GiB. All three windows improved over round 2; increment 0.3955 s/step (2.45% speedup, modest relative to noise). Committed independently as 124a0e3. Round closed 22:01:49; follow-up check --quick PID 1857171, log /tmp/r3-quick-3.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-3, launched at that time.
- 22:12:10 /tmp/r3-quick-3/check.json PASS N0: 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensors, 235 reward requests all matched. Promoted 124a0e3 and the tested switches.
2.2 hRound 4 — profile after expert layout rewrite
- 22:12:45 started judge profile --from 3 --iters 1 on submitted 124a0e3, PID 1968460, log /tmp/r3-profile-4.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-4. Isolated worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-4. Full check of the submitted accumulated optimizations queued behind the profile: PID 1968462, log /tmp/r3-full-3.log, output /tmp/r3-full-3; full check is outside the round time budget.
- Profile 4 (lock 22:13:08) finished OK. Whole refine step: 18.965 summed self CUDA seconds; mm 39.66%, mul 9.17%, copy_ 4.56%, flash 4.31%. Denoiser alone: 7.319 device s vs 7.817 profiled wall s, mm 51.1%, mul 13.0%, indexed write <0.1% after round 3. Correlating GPU events to CPU external IDs for the eager pow/mean/add/rsqrt/mul/to/mul sequence identified 12,204 RMSNorm calls using 1.119 device s (15.3% of denoising). Chosen hotspot: eager RMSNorm chains between dense projections, not GEMM arithmetic. Full check 3 took the timing lock at 22:22:44.
- Experimental BAGEL_EXACT_RMS=1: inference-only CUDA/Meta operator for the two observed widths and contiguous input, preserving the installed ATen ReduceOp<float,MeanOps,...,4,4> reduction partitions, opposite cross-warp and within-warp merge directions, intermediate types and independent RN arithmetic. The weighted backward path is untouched. Live first-call raw-byte verification per width/dtype/device; optional installed extension, eager fallback. 22:24:53 queued an offline candidate-env wheel build (PID 2042115, /tmp/r3-rms-build.log) for the full check's *record* phase to avoid interfering with timing. Lock-protected raw-bit/graph probe queued after the full check (PID 2045437, /tmp/r3-rms-probe.log, probe source /tmp/r3-rms-probe.py). No claims yet for this experiment.
- Build completed successfully 22:32:54 (full check entered record at 22:32:24): bagel-exact-rms==0.1.0 installed only in /opt/candidate-env, wheel SHA-256 d55fac436b2936f37d109f656ce8f99f5aa0a3dbf8a1e5ead4f5bfefa429149f. CPU-only library load and Meta dispatch passed. Conditional time queued 22:33:34, PID 2168654, log /tmp/r3-time-4.log, output /tmp/r3-time-4; runs only after a successful locked probe.
- 22:42:19 /tmp/r3-full-3/check.json PASS N0, 1.4635x on the submitted tree. Probe completed by 22:42:38: PASS on 272 raw-bit tensor comparisons (including different row regimes, wide/small values, signed zeros, infinities and NaNs) and two graph replays. All 8 tested calls to the stock functional RMSNorm differed from the reference, ruling that shortcut out. Candidate time is running.
- Round 4 screen held the GPU lock at 22:42:54. 22:52:32 /tmp/r3-time-4/time.json: OK, windows 14.3999, 15.3836, 14.9084 s/step, mean 14.8973, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.5747, peak allocated 130.76 GiB. Improvement over round 3 screen: 1.2719 s/step, 1.0854x; no live bit-check failure or extension fallback logged. Commit 6be73db. Round closed 22:52:54 (about 19 min of profile/probe/timing excluding the intervening full check). Started check --quick then, PID 2405557, log /tmp/r3-quick-4.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-4.

- 23:02:44 /tmp/r3-quick-4/check.json PASS N0: 14 optimizer steps, all 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests identical. Promoted 6be73db and its five switches.
3.0 hRound 5 — profile the verified exact RMSNorm version
- 23:03:13 launched the judge's profile --from 3 --iters 1 on 6be73db, PID 2517101, log /tmp/r3-profile-5.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-5. Isolated experiment worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-5. Queued the full check for the same five switches after the profile exits, PID 2517102, log /tmp/r3-full-4.log, output /tmp/r3-full-4 (the round 4 worktree is identical to the promoted commit).
- 23:03:36 profile acquired the GPU lock; 23:11:52 profile OK. Self CUDA: mm 43.56%, mul 6.27%, varlen flash 4.85%, addmm 3.63%, copy_ 3.09%, cat 2.85%. Offline attribution of judge trace: 2.517 device seconds between first/last sampled token, 6.601 denoiser, 1.347 reference, 1.679 policy and 4.202 backward. In denoising, 1,512 query/key pairs each perform the same mul/slice/slice/neg/cat/mul/add twice (0.495 device seconds, 7.5%, before two casts and two expert joins). Identified new fusion opportunity, not an attention backend change. Offline tables in /tmp/r3-profile-5/{stage-attrib,chain-attrib}.txt. Full check 4 took the GPU lock 23:12:19.
- Experiment: BAGEL_PACKED_ROPE fuses inference-only rotary elementwise operations and BF16 output conversion, directly assembling the two experts where applicable. Same scalar FP32 round-to-nearest products/addition and explicit intermediate BF16 roundings for BF16 operands; no GEMM, reduction, attention or RNG replacement. Supports Q/K of 28/4 heads × 128; eager fallback and live first-use raw-bit comparison. py_compile and git diff --check passed. At 23:15:34 queued lock-protected comparison/graph probe after full check 4 (PID 2594177, /tmp/r3-rope-probe.log), then conditional judge time (PID 2594178, /tmp/r3-time-5.log, output /tmp/r3-time-5).

- Full check 4 finished 23:31:00: /tmp/r3-full-4/check.json PASS N0, 1.5746x for the submitted exact RMSNorm version. The initial RoPE probe rejected an FP32 subnormal × infinity case before any timing. Generated PTX showed Triton's libdevice mul_rn and add_rn enabled FTZ; unary minus also lowered to zero-minus. Used explicit gradual-underflow RN PTX and sign negation in the experimental kernel. At 23:37:42 launched the corrected locked probe (PID 2828052, /tmp/r3-rope-probe-b.log) followed only on success by judge time (PID 2828053, /tmp/r3-time-5b.log, output /tmp/r3-time-5b). The first conditional time was not run.

- Corrected probe passed 160 tensor bit comparisons and 12 graph replays (mixed FP32/BF16 inputs and phases, split and unsplit layouts, 1–4,104 rows, finite and nonfinite values, subnormals and signed zeros). Judge timing 5b started; round 5 remains isolated.
- Timing held the lock 23:38:15; at 23:47:45 /tmp/r3-time-5b/time.json was OK, windows 13.5974, 15.0326, 14.8702 s/step, mean 14.5001, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.6179, peak 130.76 GiB allocated, 133.73 GiB reserved. All three windows faster than round 4 screen; mean reduction 0.3972 s/step (1.0274x incremental). No rotary fallback logged. Committed 2447bc5 in the experiment. Closed 23:48:12 (under 26 min excluding the intervening full check); follow-up check --quick PID 2954480, /tmp/r3-quick-5.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-5.

- 23:57:53 /tmp/r3-quick-5/check.json PASS N0: 14 optimizer steps, all 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests exact. Promoted 2447bc5 and the six-switch config.
3.9 hRound 6 — generation profile with rotary fusion
- 2026-11-17 23:58:25 launched profile --from 2 --iters 1 on the submitted version. Round 5 profiled refinement; this trace covers a generation step for comparison. PID 3065776, /tmp/r3-profile-6.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-6. Experiment /tmp/r3-experiment-6. Queued the full check of identical 2447bc5 in the round 5 worktree after the profile exits, PID 3065777, /tmp/r3-full-5.log, output /tmp/r3-full-5.

- 2026-11-18 00:05:45 profile OK (lock 23:58:48). Generation mm 46.96% of self CUDA, parameter communication 5.12%, addmm 4.29%, mul 4.10%, flash 3.33%. Denoiser 2.890 device s (70.2% mm); rotary now one op at 0.9% of denoiser time. Between first VAE convolution and reference forward: 4.094 s profiled wall but only 0.130 device. Offline host event attribution (pack-attrib.txt): a 3.617 s gap after reshard/allocator release before the first reward-dependent collective, with no rank-0 main-thread ATen or CUDA work. Corresponding refine gap 2.250 s. Source waits on pending GenEval HTTP futures at this point. Reference + policy forwards use 0.721 summed device s for generation and 3.026 for refinement and do not consume rewards or advantages. Full check 5 started timing at 00:06:14.
- Experiment BAGEL_REWARD_OVERLAP=1 moves packing and the unchanged reference/policy forwards ahead of resolving reward futures. The original reward requests, buffer, group reductions, actual FP32 advantages and loss/backward order remain; packer records lengths per sample/round and materializes actual advantages before loss. No new thread, additional forward, or RNG draw. py_compile and git diff --check passed. 00:09:57 queued judge time after full check 5, PID 3126868, /tmp/r3-time-6.log, output /tmp/r3-time-6.

- CPU-only side probe queued 00:11:25 (PID 3161612, /tmp/r3-overlap-probe.log, ran during full check's record phase): PASS, all input/loss tensor bytes, layouts, nested values and metadata identical for 10 full synthetic packings with CFG text/image, mixed rounds, and signed-zero advantages. The reward-resolution body including all reductions and barrier is AST-identical to the original, apart from the new return of its outputs.

- 00:24:50 /tmp/r3-full-5/check.json PASS N0, speedup 1.6512x for submitted 2447bc5; 14 optimizer steps, all 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests identical. Experiment 6's time run follows.
- time held the lock 00:25:13. At 00:34:22 /tmp/r3-time-6/time.json OK, windows 13.2470, 13.6112, 13.5885 s/step, mean 13.4822, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.7400; peak allocated 130.75 GiB, reserved 133.73. All windows improved over round 5; 1.0179 s/step lower mean, 1.0755x incremental. Committed a93122a. Round closed 00:34:48 (about 17 min excluding intervening full check). Launched check --quick, PID 3485598, /tmp/r3-quick-6.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-6.

- 00:44:11 /tmp/r3-quick-6/check.json PASS N0: 14 optimizer steps, all 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests exact. Promoted a93122a and seven switches.
4.7 hRound 7 — refine profile with reward work overlapped
- 00:44:29 launched profile --from 3 --iters 1 on the current N0 submission, PID 3596841, /tmp/r3-profile-7.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-7. Detached worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-7. Queued full check of identical a93122a behind the profiler, PID 3596842, /tmp/r3-full-6.log, output /tmp/r3-full-6.

- Profile acquired the lock 00:44:53 and finished OK 00:52:38. mm 45.95%, flash 5.14%, mul 4.81%, addmm 3.94%, communication 3.02%, copy_ 3.00% of self CUDA. Offline attribution found the same 59 FSDP parameter groups, including all 28 LLM blocks, gathered twice: once before rollout and again for the policy forward. That policy stage spent 8.5% of device time in communication and 0.381 s inclusive host in cudaMalloc; backward reported 0.529 s cudaFree and 0.250 s cudaMalloc. VAE/pack to reference now spans 0.659 s versus 3.030 s before overlap. Full check 6 acquired timing lock 00:53:03.
- Selected the duplicated unsharded policy materialization. Opt-in BAGEL_REUSE_UNSHARD: successful training rollouts keep the exact gathered buffers for the same policy's next forward, with FSDP hooks/checkpoint wrappers restored. Unused groups are explicitly resharded before clipping/AdamW; on rollout exceptions and during evaluation, release as before. No new weight copies, no cached weights across updates. py_compile, git diff --check passed. At 00:54:14 queued judge time after full check 6, PID 3670276, /tmp/r3-time-7.log, output /tmp/r3-time-7.

- CPU lifecycle probe (queued 00:54:50, PID 3670311, /tmp/r3-reuse-probe.log): all four ordinary/retained, successful/exceptional simulations restored pre-hooks, checkpoint forwards, grad/training mode and the expected reverse release order.

- 01:11:00 /tmp/r3-full-6/check.json PASS N0, 1.6353x for submitted a93122a, exact on 14 steps, 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests. Its windows were 13.0983, 16.3848, 13.9202 s/step: the middle window varied materially from time-6's 13.6112; the other two beat the corresponding windows in both round 5 runs. The 1.7400x screen is not the full-check result. The retained-weight experiment acquired its timing lock at 01:11:26.
- 01:20:33 /tmp/r3-time-7/time.json OK: windows 12.7386, 13.8236, 13.3013 s/step, mean 13.2879, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.7654, peaks 130.77 GiB allocated / 133.73 reserved. Compared with time-6, mean is 0.1943 s/step lower (1.0146x incremental), first and third windows faster, second 0.2124 s slower. All windows beat full-6's timing. Modest relative to run variability. Committed 83c4eeb, round closed 01:21:16 (about 18 min excluding full check). Started check --quick, PID 4032429, /tmp/r3-quick-7.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-7.

- 01:30:41 /tmp/r3-quick-7/check.json PASS N0: 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensors, 235 reward requests exact. Promoted 83c4eeb and eight switches.
5.5 hRound 8 — steady-state generate/refine profile
- 01:31:16 started profile --from 12 --iters 2 on N0 83c4eeb to examine both phases of the variable middle timing window, PID 4143582, /tmp/r3-profile-8.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-8. Experiment /tmp/r3-experiment-8. Full check of the same commit queued behind profile to confirm the speed screen, PID 4143583, /tmp/r3-full-7.log, output /tmp/r3-full-7.

- 01:31:39 profiler acquired lock; 01:42:19 profile OK. Across steps 12–13, mm 47.56%, varlen flash 4.80%, mul 4.76%, addmm 4.07%, copy_ 2.97% self CUDA. Between first/last sampled tokens: generation 1.535 s wall / 1.074 s union of recorded device events, 2,777 scalar reads, 2,780 synchronizations, 180 dynamic nonzero; refinement 2.683 s / 1.921 s, 4,455 scalar reads, 4,458 synchronizations, 322 nonzero. Device gaps longer than 50 us sum to 0.268 and 0.430 s respectively. decode-attrib.txt in the profiler output contains the offline counts. Full check 7 took timing lock 01:42:44.
- Selected host bookkeeping between single-token forwards. Experiment BAGEL_DECODE_BOOKKEEPING: copy the current active token vector to a pinned host buffer before its forward, wait only on that copy's event, maintain surviving row order on the host, update only continuing slots and transfer the unchanged sampled probabilities at rollout completion. EOS rows still undergo their final model forward and original sample, including the draw discarded after forced EOS; no batching of arithmetic or randomness. py_compile / git diff --check passed. 01:50:16 queued locked GPU correctness probe (PID 157721, /tmp/r3-bookkeeping-probe.log) after full 7 and conditional judge time (PID 157722, /tmp/r3-time-8.log, output /tmp/r3-time-8).

- 02:00:26 /tmp/r3-full-7/check.json PASS N0, speedup 1.7461x for submitted 83c4eeb, windows 12.8055, 14.0114, 13.5306; 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensors, 235 reward requests exact. Both steps in profile 8 had 59 rollout groups and zero reference or policy FSDP all-gather regions, confirming the previous optimization. The locked decode probe passed 72 trajectories with/without graphs, mixed/all/no initially finished rows, early/forced EOS, caps 0–21, int32/int64 token storage, greedy/top-k/top-p sampling. IDs, raw probability bits, caller token/position tensors, cache lengths and final RNG state all matched. Judge time-8 follows.
- Timing lock 02:01:00. 02:10:06 /tmp/r3-time-8/time.json OK: windows 12.8498, 13.5434, 13.3625 s/step, mean 13.2519, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.7702, peak allocated/reserved unchanged 130.77/133.73 GiB. Only 0.0360 s/step (1.0027x) better than time-7; two windows slightly slower, one faster. This screen does not resolve an incremental benefit. Committed 4a332de in isolation. Closed the round at 02:10:50 (about 22 active minutes excluding full 7); started check --quick, PID 426560, /tmp/r3-quick-8.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-8. Leaving the full-passing version submitted pending stronger evidence.

- 02:20:08 /tmp/r3-quick-8/check.json PASS N0, 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensors, 235 reward requests. The timing result remains inconclusive, so 4a332de is not submitted.
6.4 hRound 9 — refinement on the full-passing version
- 02:22:27 launched detached judge profile --from 3 --iters 1 on 83c4eeb, isolated worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-9, PID 537751, log /tmp/r3-profile-9.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-9. It acquired the lock at 02:22:50. No intervening full check.

- 02:30:33 profile OK. Whole step: mm 46.63%, varlen flash 5.23%, mul 4.93%, addmm 3.99%, copy_ 2.99% self CUDA. Between last token sample and denoising: 0.877 s profiler wall / 0.638 device; GEMMs 46.7% of device time, splitKV 17.4%. prefix-attrib.txt correlates the two edit-image branches: both show 31 encoder convolutions and 336 mm calls in the same embedding-delimited groups. The repeated image-only group took 355 ms of profiler wall and 240 ms in directly correlated kernels, not counting external-ID-free flash kernels. Chosen hotspot: redundant identical VAE, ViT and LLM image prefix calculation before CFG refinement.
- BAGEL_SHARE_EDIT_PREFIX=1 retains the image-only prefix from the conditional context. The text-CFG context snapshots its host lengths, positions and device lengths before appending edit text to the conditional. Both reference the same preceding KV rows, but never write those rows again. The separate image-CFG context, random draws, model calls on differing inputs and order of all samples remain unchanged. Only eval-mode standard VAE with deterministic standard transforms and a static cache qualifies. py_compile and git diff --check passed. 02:31:21 started judge time, PID 609820, /tmp/r3-time-9.log, output /tmp/r3-time-9; queued check --quick behind it at 02:31:43, PID 609841, /tmp/r3-quick-9.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-9.

- CPU raw-bit probe (/tmp/r3-prefix-probe.py, /tmp/r3-prefix-probe.log) passed for both static packing paths, three layers and three heterogeneous length/batch cases including empty prefixes. Timing lock 02:31:44. At 02:40:51 /tmp/r3-time-9/time.json OK: windows 12.7389, 13.6200, 12.7945 s/step, mean 13.0511, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.7975, peak allocated/reserved 130.77/133.73 GiB. time-7 mean 13.2879, so 0.2368 s/step lower (1.0181x incremental), two windows faster and one effectively unchanged. Committed 5fd36d4 in isolation. The queued check --quick acquired the lock at 02:41:19.

- 02:47:51 /tmp/r3-quick-9/check.json ERROR: rank 1 OOM in loss.backward(), 740 MiB allocation failed, 129.78 GiB allocated plus 3.89 GiB reserved but unallocated, 140 MiB free. This was not a bitwise verdict; cannot claim N0. Closed round 9 at 02:48:25 (26 min from profile lock). Do not promote despite the speed screen; the reduced rollout cache changes allocator reuse. The full-passing round 7 code stays submitted.
6.8 hRound 10 — training allocation profile
- 02:48:51 started detached profile --from 3 --iters 1 of the current best 83c4eeb, worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-10, PID 822571, /tmp/r3-profile-10.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-10. Focus the trace accounting on peak training allocations after the preceding experiment failed in backward.

- Lock 02:49:14; 02:56:59 profile OK: GEMM mm 46.59%, varlen flash 5.23%, mul 4.88%, addmm 3.94%. Reference/policy/backward 1.50/1.58/4.24 summed device seconds. /tmp/r3-profile-10/loss-attrib.txt shows two policy log-softmax forwards, but the duplicate accounts for just 0.45 ms device. In contrast the training region has 91 cudaMalloc calls (0.526 s API time) and 110 cudaFree (0.746 s). Some overlaps device work, so these totals are not expected step savings. This trace and the quick-9 fragmentation evidence favor a configuration experiment before changing loss or gradient arithmetic.
- Testing PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True, off by default, with the eight proven switches and no model changes. Existing TP/FSDP, CUDA graph capture, allocator purge sites, reward service and math are untouched. Preset is scripts/rl_switches/expandable_segments.json in the experimental worktree. 02:58:31 launched judge time, PID 894636, /tmp/r3-time-10.log, output /tmp/r3-time-10. At 02:59:07 queued conditional check --quick after successful timing, PID 895587, /tmp/r3-quick-10.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-10.

- Timing lock 02:58:54. 03:08:35 /tmp/r3-time-10/time.json OK: windows 15.0054, 15.4748, 15.6004 s/step, mean 15.3602, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.5273. Peak allocated 130.67 GiB (−0.10), reserved 133.73 (unchanged). All windows lost to time-7; mean is 2.0723 s/step worse. Preset committed as a45c6b1 in isolation. Round concluded 03:09:11; no performance justification for a full check. check --quick took the lock at 03:09:00; the outcome cannot change the decision not to promote.

- 03:18:25 /tmp/r3-quick-10/check.json PASS N0 for the isolated allocator preset, which remains disabled because of its regression.
7.2 hRound 11 — generate and refine after allocator screen
- 03:09:35 queued a two-step profile --from 2 --iters 2 after quick-10 so both phases can be attributed. Current best 83c4eeb, isolated worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-11, PID 1022129, log /tmp/r3-profile-11.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-11.

- 03:18:51 lock; 03:27:19 profile OK: across generation/refinement, mm 46.96%, varlen flash 4.75%, mul 4.73%, addmm 3.99%. From VAE decode to reference forward, generation was 565 ms wall / 107 ms device, refinement 631/135 ms. /tmp/r3-profile-11/scalar-bursts.txt: 16,392 / 20,516 scalar reads, 16,410 / 20,518 stream synchronizations. Long runs alone contain 16,392 and 20,480 reads. The packing code repeats the identical 0-D CUDA timestep or delta in a Python list for each image token and then passes that list to torch.tensor. This is a host-sync bottleneck, not a convolution bottleneck.
- Experiment BAGEL_PACK_LATENT_SCALARS=1: perform the same scalar-to-host conversion once per nonempty latent span, then repeat that host value for packed inputs and loss metadata. CFG comparisons, original tensor construction, all RNG and arithmetic remain unchanged. Non-scalars follow the original path. py_compile, git diff --check and CPU raw-bit checks on 10 complete mixed CFG/non-CFG batches passed (/tmp/r3-pack-scalars-probe.log). 03:28:16 started time PID 1204191, /tmp/r3-time-11.log, output /tmp/r3-time-11; 03:28:44 queued check --quick on successful timing, PID 1204831, /tmp/r3-quick-11.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-11.

- 03:28:39 timing lock. At 03:37:50 /tmp/r3-time-11/time.json OK: windows 12.8521, 13.4626, 13.8659 s/step, mean 13.3936, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.7515, peak 130.77/133.73 GiB. The middle window improved, but the mean was 0.1057 s/step slower than time-7 despite cutting the profiled scalar copies. Profiler overhead and overlap with the reward service make the trace durations a poor estimate of exposed time here. 16cdfb7 committed only in the experimental worktree. Closed screen at 03:38:50; check --quick acquired the lock 03:38:14. No full check or promotion warranted.

- 03:47:07 /tmp/r3-quick-11/check.json PASS N0: 14 steps, 3,200 tensors, 235 reward requests. Kept isolated on performance grounds.
7.6 hRound 12 — steady-state FSDP and training memory
- 03:40:03 queued profile --from 3 --iters 1 of the submitted 83c4eeb, worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-12, PID 1331822, log /tmp/r3-profile-12.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-12, after quick-11 ends. The memory pressure in round 9, and worse performance from expandable segments, motivate accounting for resident weights and allocator pressure without changing arithmetic.

- Lock 03:47:33; 03:55:29 profile OK. mm 46.52%, varlen flash 5.25%, mul 4.82%, addmm 3.94%, peak allocated/reserved 130.67/133.73 GiB. /tmp/r3-profile-12/shards-attrib.txt: 59 rollout all-gathers and zero in the frozen reference forward, training forward and backward. Those 3 stages call cudaMalloc 91 times (0.502 s of API time) and cudaFree 110 times (0.747 s). From the checkpoint header, 14,607,260,128 elements imply about 13.6 GiB per GPU of frozen original FP32 shards; FSDP is already retaining their gathered BF16 compute weights. Chosen bottleneck: unused high-precision shard residency leaves little room for the variable training allocations.
- BAGEL_OFFLOAD_FROZEN_SHARDS=1 enables the native FSDP2 CPUOffloadPolicy only for the frozen reference with reshard_after_forward=False. Original shards keep their original precision; reference GEMMs and all other operations still use the original GPU mixed-precision policy. No policy, optimizer, distributed topology or sample changes. py_compile and git diff --check passed. 03:56:08 launched judge time, PID 1513992, /tmp/r3-time-12.log, output /tmp/r3-time-12; timing lock 03:56:32. 03:56:26 queued check --quick behind successful timing, PID 1514016, /tmp/r3-quick-12.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-12.

- At 04:06:04 /tmp/r3-time-12/time.json OK: windows 12.8537, 13.5326, 13.0456 s/step, mean 13.1440, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.7848. Compared with time-7, 0.1439 s/step (1.0110x) faster; the first window lost 0.1151 and the other two gained 0.2910/0.2557. Peak allocated 117.16 GiB versus 130.77, saving 13.61 GiB as predicted; reserved 133.45 versus 133.73. a76d20e committed separately. check --quick acquired the lock at 04:06:32. Submitted tree remains the full-passing round 7 version until the bitwise gate returns.

- 04:15:56 /tmp/r3-quick-12/check.json PASS N0: 14 optimizer steps, 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests exact. Closed in 28.4 min from the profiler lock. Promoted a76d20e and its nine switches because of the lower mean and substantial reduction in live GPU memory.
8.3 hRound 13 — refinement profile with frozen shard offload
- 04:16:23 started profile --from 3 --iters 1, PID 1751518, log /tmp/r3-profile-13.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-13, on a76d20e in /tmp/r3-experiment-13. It acquired the lock at 04:16:47. Queued the full check of identical a76d20e in the round 12 worktree after the profiler, PID 1751519, log /tmp/r3-full-12.log, output /tmp/r3-full-12.

- 04:24:59 profile OK. mm 46.97% overall. Refinement denoising 6.073 summed device s, 64.8% mm, 13.8% varlen flash, 6.5% addmm, 2.8% mul, 2.3% silu. /tmp/r3-profile-13/swiglu-attrib.txt correlates actual mm → silu → mm → mul → mm chains to their own device kernels: 3,024 MLPs in denoising (137.54 ms SiLU + 170.14 ms multiply, 5.1% of its device time). 56 more in each of reference, policy and checkpoint replay (165.15 ms for the 3 pairs of totals combined). Selected the materialized BF16 activation between these two elementwise kernels, not the GEMMs. Full check of round 12 acquired its timing lock at 04:25:23.
- Experiment BAGEL_EXACT_SILU_MUL=1: a pointwise Triton kernel indexes an on-device table computed by the installed ATen SiLU across all 65,536 BF16 encodings; multiplies the rounded BF16 activation by the unchanged up projection with explicit mul.rn.f32, then rounds to BF16. Native SiLU backward for gate gradients; distinct original BF16 multiply/rounding for the upstream gradient. Only dense compatible BF16 tensors on Hopper qualify, with a raw-bit initialization check and standard fallback. No model parameter, RNG or GEMM-size change. Syntax, diff check and CPU Meta dispatch passed. At 04:28:42 queued locked CUDA raw-bit/MLP/graph probe after full 12, PID 1825171 (/tmp/r3-silu-probe.log), and time conditional on that probe, PID 1825172, log /tmp/r3-time-13.log, output /tmp/r3-time-13.

- 04:43:54 /tmp/r3-full-12/check.json PASS N0, speedup 1.7350x for submitted a76d20e: 14 optimizer steps, all 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests exact, timing windows 12.9593 / 13.8669 / 13.7596 s/step. Slightly lower than full-7 (1.7461x) although its separate timing screen was higher; incremental speed is within variability. The 13.61 GiB live-memory reduction is reproducible and useful. The subsequent locked SiLU probe passed 126 raw-bit comparisons, including all BF16 gate encodings with 18 distinct partner patterns under both deterministic settings, both gradients, full 3584×18944 MLP parameter/input gradients, non-reentrant checkpointing, and 3 graph replays. 04:44:26 time-13 acquired the lock. 04:44:25 queued a conditional check --quick after time, PID 2061803, /tmp/r3-quick-13.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-13.

- 04:54:01 /tmp/r3-time-13/time.json OK: windows 12.3663, 13.5315, 13.3426 s/step, mean 13.0801, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.7935. Mean 0.0639 s/step below time-12 (1.0049x incremental), with one clearly better, one flat and one worse window. Peak allocated/reserved fell to 115.75/131.74 GiB (−1.41/−1.71 from time-12); incremental time not resolved against run variation. Committed 9023449 in isolation. Closed screen 04:54:25, 19 min excluding the intervening full check. Quick lock 04:54:30, no promotion on this screen alone.

- 05:03:54 /tmp/r3-quick-13/check.json PASS N0: 14 steps, 3,200 tensors and 235 reward requests exact. The isolated kernel is available for later combined screening; a76d20e remains submitted.
8.9 hRound 14 — guidance context preparation with memory headroom
- 04:55:23 queued judge profile --from 2 --iters 2 after quick-13 to examine both rollout phases at the new memory baseline. Full-passing a76d20e, isolated worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-14, PID 2188941, log /tmp/r3-profile-14.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-14.

- 05:04:23 profile lock; 05:13:20 profile OK. mm 47.14% across generate+refine. Refine prefix: 0.870 s wall, 0.638 s device, 46.7% GEMM and 17.4% splitKV. prefix-attrib.txt shows the second identical edit-image context consuming 359.6 ms of profiler wall (31 encoder convolutions, 336 mm, 240.0 ms correlated device). context-copies.txt: generation makes six 154 MiB D2D copies before sampling, including twice copying the CFG text cache backing; refinement makes four 378 MiB copies to establish independent caches. Unlike the failed aliasing experiment, the current submission has 13.61 GiB additional live headroom.
- BAGEL_SNAPSHOT_PREFIX=1 keeps the original independently allocated static CFG buffers. After the deterministic image prefill it copies the prefix slab, position lists, and lengths into the already allocated text-CFG destination before appending edit text. Generation likewise snapshots the system-prompt prefix rather than allocating a second full clone. No storage alias, cross-step caching, arithmetic changes or skipped random operations. Unknown/stochastic image paths retain the original prefill. CPU snapshot probe (/tmp/r3-snapshot-probe.log) compared all bytes for five variable/empty length batches after overwriting the entire source; syntax and git diff --check passed. time started 05:14:09, PID 2371274, log /tmp/r3-time-14.log, output /tmp/r3-time-14. 05:14:38 queued check --quick after successful time, PID 2372009, log /tmp/r3-quick-14.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-14.

- Timing lock 05:14:32. 05:23:59 /tmp/r3-time-14/time.json OK: 12.7331, 13.4181, 13.7639 s/step, mean 13.3050, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.7632, peak allocated/reserved 117.16/133.45 GiB. First and second windows improved versus time-12, but the third was 0.7183 s/step worse and the aggregate mean was 0.1610 s slower. c17e777 committed only in the isolated worktree; no promotion/full check. Quick lock 05:24:26. Closed timing screen at 05:26:08.

- 05:33:42 /tmp/r3-quick-14/check.json PASS N0: 14 steps, 3,200 tensors, 235 reward requests. The independent-cache implementation resolved the prior correctness run's OOM, but the timing screen did not justify promoting it.
9.4 hRound 15 — packed training layer layout
- 05:26:22 queued profile --from 3 --iters 1 on full-passing a76d20e to localize indexed row movement in the largest training phase. Worktree /tmp/r3-experiment-15, PID 2498901, log /tmp/r3-profile-15.log, output /tmp/r3-profile-15. Waits for quick-14.

- Lock 05:34:10; profile OK 05:42:31. Whole step mm 46.74%. Ref/policy/backward spend 8.0% / 7.5% / 5.3% of summed device time in _index_put_impl_; routing-attrib.txt gives 453/453/987 calls and 120.8/120.3/220.3 device ms. index adds 25.9/26.3/51.9 ms and fill 14.7/15.0/54.3 ms. Source gathers contiguous experts, scatters normalized states into packed arrays, gathers them back for projection, then scatters/reads Q and K again before normalization. Selected this repeated MoT routing, not the attention/GEMM reduction algorithms.
- BAGEL_TRAIN_EXPERT_LAYOUT=1: validate that understanding+generation row IDs form a complete permutation, then keep the residual stream in expert-major order across the MoT stack. Each expert's unchanged contiguous GEMM and norm operand retains its original row order. Restore original positions for RoPE, flex/SDPA attention, and the returned hidden states. No-grad reference and gradient-bearing policy share the route; other dtypes, layers, freeze settings and layouts fall back. There is still one tensor at every FSDP/checkpoint boundary. Syntax/diff checks passed; AST comparison limits changed methods to the packed MoT attention, decoder and model training forwards plus their shared attention helper. 05:43:49 launched locked probe (PID 2681122, /tmp/r3-training-layout-probe.log); PASS on 158 raw output/gradient comparisons including unsorted row partitions, 3584/18944 full width, SDPA, flex, checkpoint, inference and autograd. 05:44:10 launched time after probe (PID 2681486, /tmp/r3-time-15.log, output /tmp/r3-time-15), then 05:44:29 queued check --quick (PID 2681508, /tmp/r3-quick-15.log, output /tmp/r3-quick-15).

- Timing lock 05:44:34. At 05:54:01 /tmp/r3-time-15/time.json OK: 12.5437, 13.4076, 13.0116 s/step, mean 12.9877, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.8063. All windows improved versus time-12 (0.3100, 0.1250, 0.0340 s/step lower); mean −0.1563 s (1.0120x incremental). Peak allocated/reserved 116.89/133.07 GiB. Commit d0dfb7a remains isolated until the real record gate. Timing screen closed at 05:54:28; quick lock 05:54:29.
↑ R3