DeepSeek V4.1 Flash-1017 1.19×

Harness: DeepSeek's own harness · switches: none

Judged
1.19×
Tier
N0
Self-best
1.28×
Rounds
16
Hours
10.0
API cost
$1.93
Input tokens · 99.5% cached
182 M
Output tokens
0.5 M
Requests
441
Text-decode CUDA graph
tried, reverted: bitwise identical, 1.42× on the timing side, but backward OOM in the deterministic record run; only the one-graph-per-full-batch version passed once (1.28×), OOM again on rerun, finally turned off
Reward wait hidden behind forward
✓ full check 1.14× → 1.17×
Rollout-side bitwise fused kernels
tried, reverted: RoPE fusion 1.175× (no change), RMSNorm tail no gain and made the record run OOM
Train-side bitwise kernels / freeing memory
✗ (peak 130.7 GiB)
Other main levers
static KV length read once per forward, timestep t.repeat(n), packed scalars read once
Raw work log16 sections
0.4 hRound 1 — profile the unchanged reference (18:18–19:05)
Command: bench.py profile --tree /submission/r3 --from 10 --iters 2 --out /tmp/p1 (2 optimizer steps = gen step 10 +
refine step 11, rank 0, torch.profiler). The bench's own key_averages() table never finished (rank 0 spun in
key_averages for >6 min after the 3.6 GB trace was written); I killed the run and analysed the trace myself
(/submission/analyze_trace.py, analyze3.py; raw numbers in /submission/logs/analysis1.txt).

Findings (trace = 54.09 s for 2 steps, i.e. 27 s/step under the profiler; unprofiled reference is 23.4 s/step):

* GPU busy only 26.65 s of 54.09 s (49.3%); the 27.45 s idle is spread over ~1.7 M tiny gaps (top-25 gaps sum to
  only 3.06 s). → the step is host/launch bound, not GPU bound.
* 1.74 M GPU kernels in 2 steps (~870 k/step); cudaLaunchKernel 1.32 M calls = 8.33 s of CUDA API time (6.3 µs each),
  cudaStreamSynchronize 263 649 calls = 9.13 s (34.6 µs each), cudaFree 399 = 1.27 s, cudaMalloc 402 = 0.56 s.
  Total CUDA API 21.2 s of 54.1 s; the remaining ~33 s is Python/ATen dispatch + allocator.
* aten::item 244 496 calls (9.76 s self) + aten::nonzero 19 317 ≈ the 263 330 Memcpy DtoH (Device->Pinned):
  every one is a full stream drain. They come from (a) _static_kv_cache_attention /
  _merge_static_kv_prefix_and_query: ~7 .item()+~6 mask-nonzero per layer per forward, and (b)
  rollout_controller.add_latent storing *0-dim CUDA tensors* in [timestep]*1024 / [dt]*1024 lists that
  _convert_to_tensors later turns into torch.tensor(list) → one D2H per element (bins 33/92: 16 k–20 k syncs in a
  single burst).
* Phase map (0.5 s bins, see analysis1.txt): step 10 = text-gen 0–8.5 s (19% GPU busy, 22 k kernels/0.5 s) +
  denoise 8.5–15.5 s (65% busy) + reward wait 1.26 s + pack + train 16.5–19 s (~100% busy);
  step 11 = ViT/VAE + text-gen 19–31 s (19% busy) + denoise 31.5–45 s (65%) + reward wait 1.22 s + pack (20 k syncs)
  + train 47–54 s.
* Text generation is 37.3 it/s in the *unprofiled* reference log (Thinking...: 385/385 [00:10, 37.35it/s]), i.e.
  26.8 ms per token for a 196/385-token loop whose GPU work is only ~19% → ~15.6 s of the 45 s per 2 steps is
  launch-bound autoregressive decoding (28 layers × ~60 ATen ops per token).
* Reward service: ~1.25 s per step exposed (16 requests/step over 4 workers, ~1 s each), not overlapped.
* Kernel time top list: nvjet GEMMs 8.0 s, elementwise/index/copy ~7 s, flash-attn 1.5 s, NCCL 1.35 s.

Conclusion for round 2: attack the scalar-read stream drains (one .item()/mask-nonzero per layer per forward,
and the per-element torch.tensor(list_of_cuda_scalars) in packing) — pure host-side work, invisible to numerics.
Later rounds: CUDA-graph replay of the fixed-shape per-token / per-denoise-step forward (same kernels, bitwise) is the
only lever left for the remaining ~19 s/step of launch+dispatch overhead.
0.7 hRound 2 — remove scalar-read stream drains in rollout/packing (18:25–18:58)
Change (commit d0b3992, N0 by construction):
* _StaticLensHint in modeling/bagel/qwen2_navit.py: the StaticKVCache sequence lengths are constant across the
  layers of one forward, so they are read once per forward (one .tolist()) and the derived
  cu_seqlens/max_seqlen/gather-index tensors are built on the host; the varlen key/value assembly uses
  index_select/index_copy_ with those precomputed indices instead of mask-based index_put_ (same bytes to the
  same positions). Removes ~7 .item() + ~6 mask-nonzero per layer per forward.
* generate_text_batch: 3 .tolist() per token instead of ~4 .item() per sequence per token.
* rollout_controller.add_latent: dt/timestep were 0-dim CUDA tensors expanded to [t]*1024 and then fed to
  torch.tensor(list) -> 1024 D2H drains per latent; now read once per latent.

Evidence: bench.py time --tree /submission/r3 --out /tmp/t2 -> status ok,
speedup_vs_frozen_reference = 1.1257, windows 20.437 / 20.868 / 21.064 s per step vs frozen 23.237 / 23.479 /
23.495 -> per-window ratios 1.1371 / 1.1251 / 1.1154, min 1.1154 (> bar 1.051). Peak allocated 130.72 GiB
(reference 131). Step times now gen ~12.7-13.2 s, refine ~27.8-28.5 s (was ~14.5 / ~30.5).
check --quick (bitwise, 14 steps) started at 18:59 -> /tmp/c2.

Round 2 verdict: check --quick --tree /submission/r3 -> PASS (bitwise identical to the frozen reference record,
/tmp/c2). Kept.
1.0 hRound 3 — the per-element `torch.tensor([t]*n)` in the denoise loop (19:05–19:16)
Profile follow-up: the denoise phase showed ~9 000 aten::item/s that I could not attribute to the attention. They
are modeling/bagel/bagel.py lines 825/918/1022: timestep = torch.tensor([t] * x_t.shape[0], device=...) with t a
0-dim CUDA tensor -> one D2H drain per element, x_t.shape[0] = 4104 per denoising step = 66k (generate) / 86k
(refine) drains per step, ~5 s of the 9.1 s of cudaStreamSynchronize in the profile. Fixed with t.repeat(n)
(same float32 values, one kernel). Commit (N0).
1.7 hRound 4 — CUDA-graph replay of the text-decoding token step (19:16–20:00)
_TokenStepGraph (modeling/bagel/bagel.py): the per-token forward of generate_text_batch has fixed shapes (one
token per active sequence), so it is captured once per (StaticKVCache, #active sequences) and replayed. Same
kernels, same arguments, same order -> same bits; only token ids, positions, the active cache rows and the cache
lengths change, and those are copied into static buffers before the replay (eff is refreshed from the live
seq_lens). Sampling/RNG stays outside the graph. _StaticLensHint is threaded through forward_inference so the
captured region contains no device->host read.

Measurements: text decoding 127 tok/s (was 37.3): the 385-token think phase is 3.0 s instead of 10.3 s.
check --config {OPT_GRAPH_GEN=1, PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True} -> PASS, bitwise identical
(3200 tensors, 235 reward requests), speedup 1.085 (only the full-batch graph was enabled, n==batch_size, which
turned out to lose most of the win because refine-round sequences finish early -> removed again). The run is at the
memory limit (reference peak 130.6/139.8 GiB reserved, plus ~5 GiB of reward service on GPU 0), so the first
graph attempt OOM'ed in loss.backward at step 7 from allocator fragmentation; expandable_segments:True fixes it
and the 14-step record run then peaked at 131.26 GiB allocated with no OOM. /tmp/c3 (a code bug, UnboundLocal)
and /tmp/t3 (OOM) are the failed attempts.
2.6 hRound 5 — what the graph is worth, and two N1 traps (20:00–20:55)
* time with the graph for all sequence counts but without expandable_segments (/tmp/t3): step times gen
  10.0–12.7 s / refine 23.1–24.0 s (vs 12.7 / 28.2 without the graph) — the refine step is the win, because its
  385-token think phase goes 10.3 s -> 3.0 s. That run OOM'ed at step 7 in loss.backward (allocator
  fragmentation; the reference peak is 130.6 of 139.8 GiB reserved and the reward service holds ~5 GiB on GPU 0).
* check with graph + expandable_segments (/tmp/c4, graph only when #active == batch): PASS, bitwise
  identical, speedup 1.085. So expandable_segments is safe with graph capture but costs ~10 % (it also makes the
  later all-n run only 1.14).
* check with the graph for all n + expandable (/tmp/c5): INCORRECT, speedup 1.144.
* check with no graph at all (empty switch file, /tmp/c6): also INCORRECT, speedup 1.144 — same signature
  (172/235 reward requests differ). So the graph was not the culprit.
* Root cause found by comparing the per-step logs with the reference record: the first difference is
  Total norm: 0.9476192593574524 vs 0.9476318359375 at step 2 while that step's losses are bitwise identical.
  The cause is my per_token_logps = raw_per_token_logps reuse: the same *forward* expression, but one shared
  log_softmax node sums the two outgoing gradients inside the node (dy1+dy2 then -p*sum) instead of adding
  two separate gradients, which rounds differently -> N1. The early output_dict.pop("logits") before the backward
  also perturbs the allocator layout. Both reverted (commit f3010e6). Lesson: any change to the autograd topology,
  even a provably identical forward, is N1.
3.0 hRound 6 — final state (20:55–21:20)
* Reverted the two N1 traps (commit f3010e6): train/online_rl.py is back to the reference expression for
  per_token_logps and keeps the ref/policy logits alive.
* check --quick on the final tree with the empty switch file (/tmp/c8): PASS, bitwise identical
  (3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). Together with /tmp/c6's timing run (windows 19.926 / 20.519 / 20.391 s per
  step vs frozen 23.237 / 23.479 / 23.495 -> per-window ratios 1.166 / 1.144 / 1.152, speedup 1.1442) this is the
  submitted configuration. /tmp/c2 also PASSed an earlier, smaller subset.

# FINAL SUMMARY

Submission: /submission/r3 @ commit f3010e6, /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {}} (no switches).
Evidence: /tmp/c8 check --quick PASS (bitwise, tier N0) and /tmp/c6 check speedup 1.1442 (gate 1 passed;
that run's bitwise failure came from changes that f3010e6 reverts, and the same tree without them is /tmp/c8 PASS).

Gains by change (all N0, all in the tree):
1. _StaticLensHint + index_select/index_copy_ varlen assembly: one device->host read of the StaticKVCache
   lengths per forward instead of ~7 .item() + ~6 mask-nonzero per layer. (commit d0b3992)
2. 3 .tolist() per text-decoding token instead of ~4 .item() per sequence per token; add_latent reads the
   0-dim dt/timestep CUDA tensors once per latent instead of once per latent token. (d0b3992)
3. timestep = t.repeat(n) instead of torch.tensor([t]*n) (4104 stream drains per denoising step). (7fef84f)
Combined measured: 23.40 -> 20.28 s/step mean (frozen reference -> /tmp/c6), speedup 1.1442, peak 130.7 GiB (same as
the reference).

Direction that works but is not in the submission: CUDA-graph replay of the text-decoding token step
(commit 90bd1cd, switch OPT_GRAPH_GEN, default off). It is bitwise identical (/tmp/c4 PASS) and takes text decoding
from 37.3 to 110-127 tok/s, but every attempt to use it for *all* sequence counts OOM'ed in loss.backward
(/tmp/t3, /tmp/c7: "Tried to allocate 740 MiB", 130.0-130.5 GiB allocated, 0.5-0.6 GiB free — the reference itself
sits at 130.6 GiB allocated / 133.7 GiB reserved of 139.8 with the reward service on the same GPU). With
expandable_segments:True it is memory-safe but the allocator option costs ~10 %, which cancels the gain
(/tmp/c4 speedup 1.085, /tmp/c5 1.144). With more memory headroom this is the direction to take: the graph removes
~1900 kernel launches per token (the step is ~50 % host-bound: 1.32 M cudaLaunchKernel + 264 k
cudaStreamSynchronize per two steps).

Other directions measured and rejected: expandable_segments:True (~10 % slower here); sharing one log_softmax node
between the policy loss and the KL term (N1: changes backward rounding, Total norm 0.9476192 vs 0.9476318);
dropping the full-vocabulary logits early (N1 by allocator-layout perturbation of the backward); per-denoising-step
CUDA graph (OPT_GRAPH_FLOW, implemented but never enabled: its capture cost is 1-3 forwards against only ~3.6 s of
host time per refine step).
3.5 hRound 7 — the graph OOM is allocator fragmentation, not the graph's own memory (21:20–21:50)
Three more attempts to run the CUDA-graph token step at all sequence counts without expandable_segments
(/tmp/c9: + ~0.9 GiB freed by dropping the dead ref/policy logits; /tmp/c10: + capture without
torch.cuda.graph's gc.collect()/torch.cuda.empty_cache() churn, via a hand-rolled
_capture_graph() side-stream capture) all OOM'ed in loss.backward on the same 740 MiB allocation with
129.8–130.0 GiB allocated and 1.7–2.0 GiB "reserved by PyTorch but unallocated" — i.e. the graph pools come
back to the allocator as unusable fragments, while the same tree without the graph runs at 130.6 GiB. Both
mitigations are kept in the tree (they are N0 and give ~0.9 GiB of headroom and cheaper captures: gen steps
9.9–10.2 s / refine 21.4–22.7 s in /tmp/c10, i.e. windows ≈16 s ⇒ ≈1.46 if it ran).
4.4 hRound 8 — the graph is bitwise correct, but it cannot be afforded on this memory budget (22:00–22:45)
* check --config {OPT_GRAPH_GEN=1, expandable_segments:True} (/tmp/c11): PASS, bitwise identical — so the
  CUDA-graph token step is N0 for every sequence count (the earlier INCORRECT was entirely the log_softmax reuse).
  Speedup only 1.0765 (windows 18.26 / 19.00 / 21.82): expandable_segments:True costs ~15 % here (refine steps
  25.3–26.0 s vs 21.4–22.7 s without it), which cancels the graph's gain.
* Without expandable_segments, with the dead ref/policy logits dropped and torch.cuda.empty_cache() before
  the backward (/tmp/c12): still OOM, but it got to step 13 with **windows ≈15.6 s per step (gen 9.6–10.6 s,
  refine 21.7–22.2 s)** — i.e. ≈1.45–1.49 of the frozen reference. The OOM is a ~1 GiB allocator-fragmentation
  shortfall: 129.8 GiB allocated, 1.7 GiB "reserved but unallocated" split into blocks that cannot serve the
  backward's 740 MiB activation allocation, 0.6 GiB free (the reference itself runs at 130.6 GiB allocated with the
  judge's reward service holding ~5 GiB on GPU 0).
* max_split_size_mb:640 to stop block splitting (/tmp/c13): worse — 6.2 GiB stranded, OOM at step 0.
* Conclusion: on this 4-GPU budget the graph cannot run without expandable_segments, and with it the tree is
  slower than the plain one (1.08 vs 1.14). All of it stays in the tree behind OPT_GRAPH_GEN (default off) with
  the reasoning recorded above; the submitted configuration is the plain one.

# FINAL STATE (updated)

/submission/r3 @ 2e87462 (all graph work behind OPT_GRAPH_GEN, default off; the N0 rollout/packing/denoise
changes are unconditional), /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {}}.
Evidence for exactly this configuration: /tmp/c8 check --quick PASS (bitwise, N0) on this tree, and
/tmp/c6 check speedup 1.1442 (windows 19.93 / 20.52 / 20.39 s per step vs frozen 23.24 / 23.48 / 23.50).
A final check on the submitted configuration (/tmp/c14) — gates 1 and 2 on exactly this tree + switch file:
PASS, bitwise identical (N0, 14 optimizer steps, 3200 tensors, 235 reward requests), speedup 1.1403
(windows 19.73 / 20.59 / 20.55 s per step vs frozen 23.24 / 23.48 / 23.50; gate-1 bar 1.051).

Kept N0 gains: StaticKVCache lengths read once per forward (+ precomputed varlen indices instead of mask gathers);
batched per-token host reads in text decoding; timestep = t.repeat(n) in the denoiser.
Rejected with reasons: CUDA-graph token step (N0 and ~1.46, but needs expandable_segments for memory, which costs
more than it saves here); shared log_softmax node (N1 through the backward); logits dropped early (N1 through
allocator layout); expandable_segments alone (+memory safety, ~15 % slower); max_split_size_mb (strands GiB).
5.7 hRound 9 — hide the reward-service latency under the training forwards (23:00–00:00)
Profile of the current best version (no graph): the rollout submits one GenEval request per sample at its end and
then blocks on the four futures before packing; the service needs ~1.2 s per step (16 requests/step over 4
workers) and the training process idles for all of it. The per-step bars from the profiled trace are the 1.22-1.26 s
gaps right before the advantage all-reduce.

Change (commit dbb9af2, N0): the reward collection + advantage computation move out of the pre-packing block and
into the training loop, right after the reference and policy forwards. pack_batch then packs advantage *slots*
(writes 0.0 and records (offset, length, (sample, round)), _text_adv_slots / _image_adv_slots) which
_resolve_deferred_advantages() fills in place with the same floats once the futures resolve — identical values in
identical positions, only written later. The forward does not depend on the advantages, so nothing else moves.

Measured on a copy of the tree (check --tree /tmp/r3exp, /tmp/c16): PASS, bitwise identical (3200 tensors,
235 reward requests), speedup 1.174 (windows 19.42 / 19.56 / 20.01 s per step vs frozen 23.24 / 23.48 / 23.50)
against 1.1403 (windows 19.73 / 20.59 / 20.55) for the tree before it: the refine step lost the 2 s the reward wait
used to add. Promoted to /submission/r3.

Also this session: tried to unblock the ~1.46 CUDA-graph version with one shared persistent graph pool
(commit 5421108) — it still OOMs (1.77 GiB stranded, /tmp/c15), so the graph stays behind OPT_GRAPH_GEN (off).
6.1 hRound 10 — re-profile the best version; the remaining idle is only the decoding loop (00:00–00:25)
bench.py profile --tree /submission/r3 --out /tmp/p2 --from 10 --iters 2 (raw numbers in
/submission/logs/analysis2.txt), compared with the round-1 profile of the reference:

| | reference (p1) | now (p2) |
|---|---|---|
| span of 2 profiled steps | 54.09 s | 42.25 s |
| GPU busy | 26.65 s (49.3 %) | 26.26 s (62.2 %) |
| GPU idle | 27.45 s | 15.98 s |
| kernels | 1.74 M | 1.21 M |
| aten::item (stream drains) | 244 496 | 4 016 |
| DtoH copies | 263 330 | 6 404 |
| largest idle gap | 1.26 s (reward wait) | 0.23 s |

Phase utilisation now: denoise 93–95 % GPU busy (it was 65 % — the t.repeat fix and the hint work removed the
whole host deficit there, so a per-denoising-step CUDA graph would gain nothing: the OPT_GRAPH_FLOW code stays
disabled), training 100–115 %, and the two text-decoding stretches still at 21 % busy — 79 % of the remaining
16 s of idle per two steps is the 196/385-token autoregressive loop, which launches ~1900 kernels per token.
That is exactly what the CUDA-graph token step fixes (1.46 measured) and what the 1 GiB memory shortfall blocks;
the alternative left is hand-written bitwise-fused norm/RoPE kernels (~35 % of the ops in that loop), which is a
multi-hour job with a bitwise-reduction contract, not a round.

Submission unchanged and validated (tree digest 936a2568… == /tmp/c16's tested tree): PASS, bitwise, 1.174.
6.6 hRound 11 — fused RoPE kernel: bitwise, but the decoder is GEMM-dispatch bound, not elementwise bound (00:25–01:00)
The profile left the text-decoding loop as the only idle stretch (21 % GPU-busy, 79 % of the residual idle) and
CUDA graphs are memory-blocked, so I took the custom-kernel rung: one Triton kernel per tensor replacing
apply_rotary_pos_emb's 12 ATen dispatches (neg, cat, 2 muls, add, casts) in the MoT inference path.

* Numerics contract bitwise, established with a probe (/tmp/probe_rope.py, run under the GPU lock): the
  reference is three separate bf16 elementwise kernels, so each product is rounded to bf16 before the add; the
  kernel reproduces exactly those three rounding points with an explicit round-to-nearest-even (integer trick:
  (u + 0x7FFF + lsb) & ~0xFFFF, verified equal to torch.Tensor.to(bfloat16) on 65 k values). Note
  x.to(tl.bfloat16) was *not* reproducible in the fused kernel (a f32→bf16→f32 round trip inside one kernel gets
  folded away by Triton), which is why the explicit integer rounding is used. Probe: BITWISE for T=1/4/128/4104 at
  the production shapes [T,28,128]/[T,4,128] and cos/sin [T,128].
* End to end (check --tree /tmp/r3exp --config {OPT_FUSED_ROPE=1}, /tmp/c17): PASS, bitwise identical,
  speedup 1.1751 (windows 19.44/19.86/19.99) — i.e. no change against 1.174 (windows 19.42/19.56/20.01).
  The token rate is 43.1 it/s with *and* without the kernel: at [4,28,128] an ATen elementwise dispatch is only
  ~2-3 µs, while a Triton launch costs ~12 µs, so replacing 12 small ops with 2 launches saves ~0.1 ms/token.
  Reverted (the experiment tree is byte-identical to the submission again).

What that means: the 23 ms/token is dominated by the 140 aten::linear calls per token (45 µs each in the
profile: dispatch plus a [4,3584]×[3584,18944]-class GEMM at ~5 % of peak) — 6.3 ms — and by the rest of the
~1900-op layer body. No elementwise fusion moves that; only collapsing the launches (CUDA graphs) or merging the
q/k/v projections into one GEMM (different GEMM shape ⇒ different rounding ⇒ N1) would.

Round 12 then measured what the graph is really worth once the memory trick was found (freeing the two dead
full-vocabulary logits immediately before the backward): gate 1 = 1.4232, windows 15.42/16.50/16.12 s per step.
It still cannot ship: the *record* run (deterministic kernels, which need ~1–2 GiB more) OOMs with 2.32 GiB stranded
and 145 MiB free, empty_cache() before the backward makes it worse, and expandable_segments either costs ~20 %
(1.08) or, combined with the shared graph pool, trips a PyTorch allocator internal assert. So the graph's +21 % is
real, bitwise-correct and available via OPT_GRAPH_GEN=1, but needs ~2 GiB of per-GPU headroom that this machine does
not have. The submitted configuration is the validated optimum under that constraint.
7.3 hRound 12 — the CUDA-graph version reaches 1.4232, then dies on gate 2 (01:00–01:40)
Following the memory analysis, the graph was retried with the two dead full-vocabulary logits freed **immediately
before loss.backward()** (where the backward's two 740 MiB log-softmax gradients need contiguous room) instead of
early:

* /tmp/c18 (OPT_GRAPH_GEN=1, no allocator flags): gate 1 PASS at speedup 1.4232 — windows
  15.42 / 16.50 / 16.12 s per step (generation steps 9.8–10.5 s, refine 20.8–22.5 s) against 19.42 / 19.56 / 20.01
  for the submitted tree. That is the real value of the graph: +21 %. But the *record* run then OOM'ed
  (129.78 GiB allocated, 2.32 GiB stranded, 145 MiB free): the deterministic-mode kernels (flash-attn's forced
  deterministic backward) need ~1–2 GiB more than the timing run, and the allocator cannot hand out the 740 MiB
  block from the stranded pieces.
* /tmp/c19: adding torch.cuda.empty_cache() before the backward (to defragment) makes the *timing* run OOM
  earlier — the allocator's cache serves the backward's big blocks better than fresh cudaMalloc at this footprint.
* /tmp/c20: expandable_segments:True (which does fix the memory, /tmp/c11) combined with the shared graph pool
  hits a PyTorch allocator internal assert (it->second->use_count > 0, CUDACachingAllocator.cpp:2630) — the
  combination is not supported. With one pool per graph instead, expandable_segments costs ~20 % on this workload
  (1.08), i.e. worse than the submitted 1.174.

Conclusion: the graph's +21 % is real and bitwise-correct but needs ~2 GiB of extra headroom in deterministic mode
that these 4 GPUs do not have (the judge's reward service holds ~5 GiB on GPU 0 and the reference itself peaks at
131.3 GiB of 139.8). The switch stays in the tree, default off; /submission/r3 and switches.json are unchanged
from the validated 1.174 state (all of this round ran on the /tmp/r3exp copy, which is byte-identical again).
7.9 hRound 13 — the graph ships: full-batch replay + late logits frees, 1.2768 validated (01:40–02:20)
The memory blocker was fragmentation of the backward's two 740 MiB [n_tokens, vocab] log-softmax gradients, not the
total (the graph version allocated *less* than the reference yet failed). Three experiments isolated it:

* /tmp/c20 shared graph pool + expandable_segments and /tmp/c21 shared pool alone -> both die with PyTorch's
  it->second->use_count > 0 (CUDACachingAllocator.cpp:2630): a shared pool is simply not usable in this version.
  Reverted (commit notes it in bagel.py).
* /tmp/c18: with a per-graph pool and the two dead full-vocabulary logits freed immediately before
  loss.backward(), the timing run passes and gate 1 is 1.4232 (windows 15.42/16.50/16.12) — the graph's full
  value, +21 %. The *record* run still OOMs (deterministic kernels need ~1-2 GiB more; 2.32 GiB stranded).
* /tmp/c22: additionally replaying only the full-batch token step (one graph per rollout instead of up to
  four, so a quarter of the pool churn) fits in deterministic mode: PASS, bitwise identical (N0), speedup 1.2768
  (windows 17.13 / 18.39 / 17.84 vs 19.42 / 19.56 / 20.01 before). Text decoding goes 43 -> 110 tok/s while all
  four sequences are active; the tail of each generation stays eager.

Shipped: /submission/r3 @ 3c4b0b0 with /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"OPT_GRAPH_GEN": "1"}},
tree digest d1e3403b… == /tmp/c22's tested tree.
9.0 hRound 14 — fused RMSNorm epilogue: bitwise, not faster, and it tips the memory balance (03:00–03:20)
With the graph covering the full-batch stretch, the only host-bound remainder is the eager tail of decoding, so I
fused the RMSNorm epilogue (the reference spends 8 dispatches per norm: bf16->fp32 cast, pow, mean, rsqrt, add, mul,
fp32->bf16 cast, weight mul). PyTorch keeps pow(2).mean(-1) — the reduction order that has to match bit for bit —
and one Triton kernel does the rest with two explicit round-to-nearest-even points. Probe (/tmp/probe_norm.py,
production shapes [1,3584] [4,3584] [112,128] [4096,3584] [4104,3584]): bitwise identical (Triton's tl.rsqrt does
match torch.rsqrt), used only when gradients are off and both input and weight are bf16.

End to end it is a no-gain regression: timing steps gen 10.4-11.3 s / refine 25.1-27.7 s against 10.4-11.0 /
24.0-25.8 for the shipped tree, and the *record* run then OOM'ed (the same 740 MiB fragmentation, 2.07 GiB stranded)
because the extra kernel changes the allocator layout at a knife edge that has ~0.5 GiB of slack. Discarded; the
experiment tree is deleted and /submission is untouched.

# STATUS: shipped optimum reached

Every remaining lever is now measured and blocked:
* tail-of-decoding graph coverage: +11 % (1.4232, /tmp/c18) but every variant (4 graphs, 2 graphs, one re-captured
  graph, one re-capture only) OOMs in the deterministic record run — one capture per rollout is this machine's limit;
* expandable_segments (fixes the memory): ~20 % slower, 1.08; shared/reused graph pools: PyTorch allocator assert;
* elementwise fusion (RoPE, RMSNorm epilogue): bitwise but 0 %, because at [4, ...] shapes an ATen dispatch is cheaper
  than a Triton launch and because the graph already covers the bulk;
* the denoise (93-95 % GPU busy, ~300 TFLOPS effective) and the training (100-115 %) are at the hardware limit;
* merging the q/k/v projection GEMMs (the only way to cut the 140 dispatches/token that dominate the eager tail)
  changes GEMM shapes and therefore rounding, i.e. N1 — not allowed in this task.
9.2 hRound 15 — phase attribution: where the remaining 25.8 s of a refine step go (03:20-03:30)
Two things were established:

1. An instrumented torch.profiler run is no longer possible on this machine. Adding record_function ranges
   (OPT_PHASE_TRACE=1) and profiling the shipped (graph-enabled) tree OOMs — the profiler's own CUDA activity
   buffers push the run over the 139.8 GiB limit (/tmp/p3: 129.65 GiB allocated, 2.07 GiB stranded, 467 MiB free).
   The earlier profiles (/tmp/p1, /tmp/p2) were taken without the graph, which is why they fit.
2. Free attribution from the run log's timestamps (they are printed per phase, /tmp/c22 log, step 13):
   a refine step is 25.8 s, of which the *rollout + prepack* block is 18.0 s and the training block
   (ref+policy forward, loss, backward, clip+optimizer) is 7.0 s; inside the rollout the think-phase tqdm shows
   ~5.5 s of text decoding (graph + eager tail), so the 55 denoising forwards are ~11 s.
   * denoise 11 s: compute-bound (93-95 % GPU busy, ~300 TFLOPS effective, 55 forwards x 4104 tokens x 28 layers) —
     irreducible without changing the recipe;
   * training 7 s: compute-bound at ~5 % MFU because activation checkpointing recomputes every layer, which the
     130 GiB memory ceiling forces;
   * text decoding 5.5 s: ~2.3 s graphed (110 tok/s) + ~3.1 s eager tail (23 ms/token) — the tail is the last
     host-bound item and needs a second graph capture that the memory budget does not allow (rounds 13b-13e);
   * ~1.5 s of VAE/ViT encodes, packing and reward submission.

Remaining candidates are each worth ~2-3 % (e.g. avoiding the two full-cache deepcopys in edit_image, which copy
764 MB of *zeros* because they happen before any context is written). Not attempted: every attempt in this territory
in the last rounds either OOM'ed in deterministic mode or perturbed the allocator enough to do so, and the shipped
tree has ~0.5 GiB of slack.
9.5 hRound 16 — the graph configuration is FLAKY; reverted (03:30-03:50)
A second full check on the *identical* shipped tree + switch file (/tmp/c28) OOM'ed in the record run
(129.55 GiB allocated, 231 MiB free, same 740 MiB allocation) where /tmp/c22 had passed. So the graph configuration
sits exactly on the memory knife edge: 1 pass and 1 fail out of 2 runs. With the final evaluation running the
candidate once, an OOM there scores 0, so the expected value of shipping it (0.5 x 1.2768) is far below the robust
configuration (1.174, which has survived every one of its 4+ runs). /submission/switches.json is empty again
(graph off, default path = the /tmp/c16-validated code path: the graph code and the logits frees are both gated by
OPT_GRAPH_GEN, which is now unset).

The graph work stays in the tree as an opt-in (OPT_GRAPH_GEN=1) with its +21 % measured (1.4232 timing mode) and
the exact reason it cannot be used: deterministic mode needs ~1-2 GiB more than this 139.8 GiB GPU has left after the
judge's reward service, and the failure is stochastic (allocator fragmentation), not deterministic.
↑ R3