Claude Opus 5.5 2.41×
Harness: Claude Code · switches: BAGEL_FAST_DECODE=1 BAGEL_FAST_HOST=1 BAGEL_FAST_FLOW=1 BAGEL_NO_EMPTY_CACHE=1 BAGEL_KEEP_UNSHARD=1 PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True BAGEL_FUSED_FLOW=1 BAGEL_FUSED_DECODE=1 BAGEL_OVERLAP_REWARD=1 BAGEL_SPLIT_TRAIN=1 BAGEL_DEDUP_PREFILL=1 BAGEL_FUSED_TRAIN=1 BAGEL_DECODE_PARALLEL=1 BAGEL_SHARE_MASK=1 BAGEL_CPU_STEP=1 BAGEL_GC_FREEZE=1 BAGEL_FUSED_PREFILL=1 BAGEL_SPLIT_DENOISE=1 BAGEL_LIGHT_BUFFER=1 BAGEL_FREE_REF_SHARDS=1 BAGEL_AG_WINDOW=2 BAGEL_FUSED_ADAMW=1 BAGEL_DEDUP_ROWS=1 BAGEL_FAST_BLOCK_MASK=1 BAGEL_DEDUP_REF=1 BAGEL_DEDUP_POLICY=1 BAGEL_MERGE_CFG=1 BAGEL_SPLIT_PARTS=1,1,1,1 BAGEL_EARLY_ZERO_GRAD=1 BAGEL_SMALL_GEMM=1 BAGEL_SHARE_FIRST_STEP=1 BAGEL_VAE_PREFETCH=1 BAGEL_SPLIT_PARTS_EDIT=2,1,1 BAGEL_JOINT_ATTENTION=1 BAGEL_VARLEN_PREFILL=1 BAGEL_FAST_ATTENTION=1
- Judged
- 2.41×
- Tier
- N0
- Self-best
- 2.47×
- Rounds
- 8
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $129
- Input tokens · 99.4% cached
- 408 M
- Output tokens
- 1.5 M
- Requests
- 756
- Text-decode CUDA graph
- ✓
BAGEL_FAST_DECODE(together with denoise desync and no cache clearing, single-run timing 1.42×) - Reward wait hidden behind forward
- ✓
BAGEL_OVERLAP_REWARD; also splits denoising into parts sent for scoring one after another (BAGEL_SPLIT_PARTS), exposed wait in the generation step 1.2–1.5 s → 0.17–0.37 s - Rollout-side bitwise fused kernels
- ✓ custom CUDA extension: RMSNorm, q/k norm + RoPE + scatter, silu·mul
- Train-side bitwise kernels / freeing memory
- ✓
BAGEL_FUSED_TRAIN(hand-derived backward),BAGEL_SPLIT_TRAIN, fused AdamW;BAGEL_FREE_REF_SHARDSpeak down to 113.5 GiB, backward 3.7 → 3.0 s - Other main levers
- dedup of repeated rows (17664 of 38912 rows in the refine batch shared), CFG branch merging (single-run timing 2.25× → 2.40×), small-batch GEMM, merged multi-branch attention, custom bitwise attention kernel, GC freeze
Raw work log8 sections
0.1 hRound 1 — profile of the unchanged reference
- start 06:13 UTC. Profile run PID in /tmp/work/prof-r1.log, output /tmp/prof-r1.
- Profile (bench profile, /tmp/prof-r1; profile.json status ERROR only because I stopped rank 0's text-table build after
the Chrome trace was on disk; the trace itself is complete). Steps profiled: 11 (refine) and 12 (gen).
Stage accounting (profiler-inflated wall clock; GPU busy in brackets):
refine: decode 12 s (19 %), denoise 14 s (65-70 %), reward wait 1.2 s (0 %), train 7.5 s (95 %), optimizer 0.15 s
gen: decode 8 s (19 %), denoise 7.5 s (60 %), reward wait 1.5 s (0 %), train 2.5 s
GPU kernel sum 27.2 s of 54 s. Top: GEMM (nvjet), index_put 1.4 s, flash fwd 0.9 s, elementwise chains.
Decode: 35 tok/s, host bound (~1000 launches/token and several syncs/layer). Denoise: syncs in
_merge_static_kv_prefix_and_query (~20/layer), torch.tensor([t]*4096) = 4096 device reads per timestep.
Optimizer is NOT a hotspot (0.15 s/step); the 4 s event in the trace is the profiler shutting down.
- Changes (dev branch, all behind switches, off by default): BAGEL_FAST_DECODE (whole decode step as a CUDA graph per active-row
count, host-side token bookkeeping, ATen's single-sample multinomial without its sync checks), BAGEL_FAST_HOST (no per-token
device scalar reads in torch.tensor(list), memoized image transforms), BAGEL_FAST_FLOW (read-only varlen K/V laid out once per
denoising loop, no syncs per layer), BAGEL_NO_EMPTY_CACHE + expandable_segments, BAGEL_KEEP_UNSHARD (no second all-gather).
- Exactness evidence so far: single-GPU A/B harness (/tmp/work/harness, gen + edit rollouts, deterministic mode): 442 hashes, 0 differ.
- time: /tmp/time-r1 (first attempt failed: private pool assert after all graphs died without empty_cache; fixed by an anchor graph).
speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.4187, windows 15.86 / 17.02 / 16.75 s/step, peak 130.7 GiB allocated.
- end 06:55 UTC. check --quick pending.0.9 hRound 2 — fused rollout kernels, reward overlap, split training forward (started 06:45 UTC)
- Findings from the time-r1 step log: gen ~9 s, refine ~22.5 s. Denoise: GEMMs run at ~730 TFLOPS (near the practical limit), so what is left there is elementwise/index work (30 % of the kernel time) and idle gaps. - New: modeling/bagel/fused/fused_ops.cu (built at startup with cpp_extension, eager fallback): RMSNorm (+ residual add), q/k head norm + RoPE + scatter into the packed/merged buffers, silu*mul, rows<->heads permutes. Lesson: ATen's mean over a 3584-row vectorizes the input (float4 groups, 4 accumulators per position), a scalar-order emulation passes bf16 output tests on small row counts and only fails at thousands of rows. Tests must compare the fp32 statistics. Verified with /tmp/work/harness/red_probe.py (exact tree for 3584 and for head dim 128) and test_fused.py. - BAGEL_OVERLAP_REWARD: pack, ref forward and policy forward run before the rewards are read; advantages are filled in afterwards. - BAGEL_DEDUP_PREFILL: the text-free CFG context is a copy of the image prefill instead of a second prefill. - BAGEL_SPLIT_TRAIN: forward_train with each expert's rows in their own contiguous tensors: same GEMMs and row order, no zero fills, gathers or index_puts between them; q, k, v created in the same order, so autograd sums input gradients in the same order. - Exactness so far: harness rollouts 442 hashes 0 differ with fused flow + fused decode; training A/B (ref forward, policy forward, every parameter gradient, gen and edit packs): 1827 hashes, 0 differ with BAGEL_SPLIT_TRAIN. - check --quick on dev commit eb756aa with switch set sw3 (/tmp/chk-q1): PASS, N0, 3200 tensors + 235 reward requests bitwise identical. /submission/r3 fast-forwarded to eb756aa, /submission/switches.json = sw3. Gate 1 for this exact set not timed yet (time run next). - Fallback path note: profile.json of round 1 says ERROR only because I stopped the table build after the trace was on disk. - Fused training kernels (BAGEL_FUSED_TRAIN): RMSNorm, q/k head norm + RoPE, silu*mul with hand-derived backward that follows autograd's op order and rounding (rsqrt: (-0.5*g)*((r*r)*r); mean: * (1/C) via ATen's reciprocal path; pow: g*(2h); silu_backward with nvcc's FMA contraction). test_fused.py: forward, input and weight gradients bitwise equal to eager autograd at rows 2..11000, scales 0.1..20 (rms/qk/silu bwd all True). - time (dev e42219a + phase log, /tmp/time-r2): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.9345, windows 11.18 / 13.19 / 12.03 s/step, peak 127.8 GiB allocated. Stage table of a quiet pair (rank 0, synchronized attribution): gen: prefill .23 decode 1.05 denoise 2.83 ref+policy fwd .53 rewards(exposed) 1.35 backward .72 optimizer .11 = 7.0 s; refine: prefill .35 decode 1.1-2.1 prefill_edit .51 denoise 5.78 pack .18 ref+policy fwd 2.5 rewards(exposed) 0-1.3 backward 3.7 optimizer .12 = 15.4 s. Reward service time is prompt dependent (1.3 s up to 5.8 s per step; color prompts go through a DataLoader with 4 forked workers per image), so overlap hides it on refine steps and only partly on gen steps (just .55 s of forward to hide behind). Random stall at step 13 (pack 1.65 s vs .18, backward 5.5 vs 3.7): suspect automatic Python GC gen-2 passes on a huge heap. - BAGEL_FUSED_PREFILL harness A/B (rollouts + ref forward + all gradients): 1827 hashes, 0 differ. - cuBLASLt probe (/tmp/work/ltbench, microbenchmark only to choose a direction): all 8 heuristic algorithms of gate/down/q shapes are bit-identical to the default (non-split-K: tile and cluster shape do not change the bits). Default already within 1-4 % of the best on the big shapes (q shape 9 %): replacing cuBLAS calls is not worth it, direction closed.
1.4 hRound 3 — stragglers and small overheads (started 07:24 UTC)
- BAGEL_GC_FREEZE: gc.collect + gc.freeze after each of the first 4 steps. First timing run with it (/tmp/chk-f1): no more 3 s spikes, steps 6.9-7.5 s (gen) and 15.0-16.5 s (refine). - BAGEL_LIGHT_BUFFER (dev, not tested yet): exchange only rollout-buffer metadata at gen steps, broadcast the one sampled image at refine steps. - FULL CHECK (dev a844d03, switches sw5, /tmp/chk-f1): PASS, N0, speedup 1.7785, window ratios 1.97 / 2.03 / 1.78, candidate 11.78 / 11.82 / 13.09 s/step, frozen reference spread 0.019. /submission/r3 = a844d03, /submission/switches.json = sw5. - Worst window of that check = steps 14-15: step 15 took 18.9 s vs 16.1-16.5 s for the other refine steps, equal on all ranks. Reward service time is the variable: color prompts run a 4-process DataLoader per color check in the worker. Next: hide more of it (first images to the service earlier). - Probes (/tmp/work/harness/split_probe.py, default and deterministic mode): rows of every denoise GEMM are bit-identical at half the row count, padded M=8 text GEMMs keep their rows, VAE decode N=2 equals N=4 (VAE encode N=1 does NOT equal N=8). Small-M cuBLASLt alternatives gain only ~5 %: closed. - BAGEL_SPLIT_DENOISE: gen_image denoises the batch in two parts; first part's images go to the reward service while the second part denoises. Global CFG renorm keeps the batch shape via padding (torch.norm's tree depends on the number of outputs), the SDE noise is drawn once for all rows. - BAGEL_SPLIT_DENOISE harness A/B: 1827 hashes, 0 differ. Stage effect (time-r3, in progress): denoise +0.4 s (gen) / +0.6 s (refine), exposed rewards -0.3..-1.0 s. Under GPU contention the reward workers crawl (their small kernels wait for time slices), so only their CPU-bound part hides. - Clocks during real steps: 1400-1980 MHz, power up to 704 W: the GEMM phases are power limited, which is why sustained GEMMs stay near 730 TFLOPS. - The stalls are not GC (they survive gc.freeze: chk-f1 step 15 = 18.9 s). New suspect: allocator release/remap when my reserved memory (133.7 GiB) and the reward worker peak together. BAGEL_FREE_REF_SHARDS frees the frozen model's fp32 shards (14 GB/GPU) once unsharded; the phase log now prints alloc retries and free memory. - time (dev b405672, sw6 + phase log, /tmp/time-r3): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.0631, windows 11.25 / 11.44 / 11.45 s/step (no stall in this run). Worst window ratio about 2.03. - Reward bursts of the reference record, mapped to prompts: spans are not only a color effect. Refine steps show 2.4-4.4 s spans with all four workers released at the same instant even for color-free prompts: requests of ranks that finish early crawl while other ranks still run denoise kernels on the same GPUs (no MPS: time slicing, and a small reward kernel waits for its slice). Reward work is effectively serialized with GPU-saturating work; only its CPU part overlaps. - BAGEL_FREE_REF_SHARDS (dev, sw7 + phase log, /tmp/time-r4): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.127, windows 10.81 / 11.12 / 11.17 s/step, peak 113.5 GiB allocated, no stall in the run. backward 3.7 -> 3.0 s, policy forward 1.2 -> 1.05 s, gen prefill .24 -> .11 s: running close to the memory limit next to the reward workers was costing far more than any retry counter shows (retries=0). - Full check of dev df56a04 with sw7 started 08:08 UTC (/tmp/chk-f2). Queued profile stopped before it produced anything: the verdict comes first. - Estimated what is left: the reward service's GPU time cannot be hidden (no MPS, exclusive time slices), so a gen step has a floor near decode + denoise + forward + backward + ~0.6 s; we are ~0.25 s above it. GPU timeslice policy is left at Default on purpose (machine setting, not part of the submission). - Prepared (dev a960481, not timed yet): empty_cache once after releasing the shards, BAGEL_AG_WINDOW=2 (bounded all-gathers) to leave the reward workers more memory. - FULL CHECK (dev df56a04, sw7, /tmp/chk-f2): PASS, N0, speedup 2.0941, window ratios 2.155 / 2.176 / 2.094, candidate 10.75 / 11.01 / 11.12 s/step, peak 113.5 GiB. /submission/r3 = df56a04 + summary commit, /submission/switches.json = sw7. (first bitwise check of BAGEL_LIGHT_BUFFER, BAGEL_FREE_REF_SHARDS, BAGEL_SPLIT_DENOISE in FSDP: passed)
2.4 hRound 4 — memory headroom and small overheads (started 08:27 UTC)
- empty_cache once after the shard release + BAGEL_AG_WINDOW=2 (sw8 + phase log, /tmp/time-r5): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.1382, windows 10.77 / 11.02 / 11.14, reserved 127 GiB, 6.6 GiB free next to the reward worker. - BAGEL_FUSED_ADAMW kernel: params, exp_avg, exp_avg_sq bitwise equal to torch's foreach AdamW over 6 steps in test_fused.py. Probe: llm2vae rows are NOT invariant at M=1024/3072 (fine at 2048), so three-part splits would need padding. - Gen-only split + fused AdamW (/tmp/time-r6): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.1143, windows 10.58 / 11.26 / 11.47. Refine without split: denoise -0.6 s but exposed rewards +0.5..+1.3 s: rejected, split stays on for both step types. Fused AdamW: optimizer stage 0.111 -> 0.073 s, kept. - Probe /tmp/work/mmatest: a K-sequential chain of mma.sync m16n8k16 reproduces cuBLAS small-M GEMMs bit for bit at M=1,2,3,4,8: gate and lm_head without split, q and o with split-K 2, down with split-K 4 (fp32 partial sums added in order, then bf16). A custom bandwidth-bound decode GEMV can therefore be exact. Sustained large-GEMM probe (/tmp/work/ltbench/out3.txt): all bit-identical algorithms within ~1-2 % of the default under the power limit: closed. - Custom GEMV estimate after the mma probe: decode is already ~4.8 ms/token (5.3 with captures); a fully custom bit-exact GEMV path would reach ~4.5: about 1 %. Parked behind cheaper items. Full check of sw10 (/tmp/chk-f3) running. - Idea under test: in refine steps the 4 samples of a rank share image and prompt, so prefill rows are duplicated 4x, and the reference forward repeats long shared prefixes (image prefix of 8 sequences, prompt prefix of 4): about 52 % of its rows at 128-row block granularity. Needs row-invariant GEMMs at the reduced sizes: /tmp/work/harness/dedup_probe.py. - FULL CHECK (dev ca2fcfc, sw10, /tmp/chk-f3): PASS, N0, speedup 2.1127, window ratios 2.191 / 2.205 / 2.113, candidate 10.57 / 10.87 / 11.02 s/step, peak 113.3 GiB (record run). Merged into /submission/r3, /submission/switches.json = sw10.
2.9 hRound 5 — duplicated rows, fresh profile (started 09:07 UTC)
- Probes running (dedup_probe default and deterministic, test_mask, flex_probe, A/B with BAGEL_DEDUP_ROWS and BAGEL_FAST_BLOCK_MASK), log /tmp/work/probes1.log. - Probes: dedup_probe (default and deterministic): all GEMM rows same at 1024+ rows, 1298 vs 5192, 1430 vs 5720, 18432 vs 39168, ViT 1296 vs 15552; only M=55/67 differ (k, o), so only prefills >= 256 rows are de-duplicated. test_mask: fast_block_mask equals create_block_mask (4 layouts). flex_probe: defaults are the fastest of all options (fwd 3.4 ms, bwd 8.6 ms per layer at N=39424, attention is <10 % of a forward): direction closed, no option helps. A/B with BAGEL_DEDUP_ROWS=1 BAGEL_FAST_BLOCK_MASK=1: 1827 keys, 0 differ. Timing: sw11p, /tmp/time-r7, PID in /tmp/work/time-r7.log. - BAGEL_DEDUP_ROWS + BAGEL_FAST_BLOCK_MASK (dev db313c0 base, sw11p, /tmp/time-r7): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.1909, 10.71 s/step. prefill .28 -> .18 s, prefill_edit .43 -> .255 s, reference forward -.05 s. Decode graph capture is only 4 x .013 s per step. - New: BAGEL_DEDUP_REF (frozen model: GEMMs on distinct rows only, attention on all rows with the same block mask) and BAGEL_DEDUP_POLICY (policy forward and its recompute: RowSharedLinear computes distinct rows, backward on all rows). Whole 128-row blocks of a common document prefix are shared if the block classes up to the end of the prefix are equal; the frozen ViT tower runs once per distinct image. A/B harness (forward, gradients of all parameters): 1827 keys, 0 differ; refine pack: 17664 of 38912 rows shared, gen pack: none. Timing: sw12p, /tmp/time-r8. - BAGEL_DEDUP_REF + BAGEL_DEDUP_POLICY (dev, sw12p, /tmp/time-r8): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.253, 10.42 s/step. Refine: reference forward 1.12 -> .69 s, policy forward 1.02 -> .70 s, backward 2.98 -> 2.81 s; exposed rewards at the slowest rank grew by ~.45 s (they were hidden behind the forwards before). - text_rows_probe (default and deterministic): cuBLAS rows at M=1..4, 12, 16, 20 equal the rows at M=8 for q, k, o, gate, down (down differs from 24 on, q from 48, o from 64). So the text rows of the CFG branches can share one GEMM. BAGEL_MERGE_CFG (forward_flow_merged): CFG branches of a denoising step in lockstep: one read of the text expert's weights instead of one per branch, large GEMMs on the rows of all branches. A/B: 1827 keys, 0 differ. Timing: sw13p, /tmp/time-r9. - /tmp/work/skinny: mma-chain small-M kernel with fragment-major weights reproduces cuBLAS bit for bit (q, k S=2 with bias, o S=2, gate S=1, down S=4, lm_head S=1). Not integrated: the round-1 trace shows cuBLAS at ~3.6 TB/s in these kernels already (gate 37.6 us, down 37.2 us), so the gain would be ~1 %. - BAGEL_MERGE_CFG + RowSharedMLP + no attention for copied blocks (dev 8cb5a59, sw13p, /tmp/time-r9): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.4045, windows 9.62 / 9.91 / 9.76 s/step. denoise 3.25 -> 3.10 s (gen), 6.4 -> 6.0 s (refine); exposed rewards fell too (gen 1.5 -> .7-1.0 s). - Parts 1,1,1,1 with merged branches, A/B: images of samples 0 and 1 differ in the edit rollout (latents up to the SDE step equal, 6 keys differ): some GEMM rows vary at M=3072 (3 branches x 1024): probe /tmp/work/harness/m_probe.py queued. VAE decode N=1,2,3 equals N=4 (default and deterministic), so padding the decoder is not needed. - Accounting (r1 trace kernels): GEMMs at M=4096 run at ~734 TFLOPS (gate 761 us), the power limit; a pass of 28 layers = 73 ms. denoise floor gen 2.4 s, refine 5.2 s, measured 3.1 / 6.0 s: the rest is mostly the reward workers' GPU slices, which land inside the denoise phases. Full check of sw13 (snapshot /tmp/work/snap4 = dev b4ee8d7) running: /tmp/chk-f4. - Full check 4 timing part (sw13): windows 9.59 / 10.68 / 9.77 s/step, ratios 2.416 / 2.243 / 2.383. Step 12 took 7.65 s (6.56 in /tmp/time-r9) and step 13 13.71 s (13.26): step 12 is a color prompt: reward requests fork a DataLoader, their latency varies by a second and it is exposed at the end of the step. Starting the requests earlier (more denoise parts) is the lever for the worst window. - FULL CHECK (snapshot of dev b4ee8d7, sw13, /tmp/chk-f4): INCORRECT, timing 9.59 / 10.68 / 9.77 s/step (2.2429). Steps 0, 1 equal the reference (norms .3777087, 1.5733635), step 2 images equal, but its text loss and norm differ in the 6th-7th digit (.9476162 vs .9476193); step 3 on diverges. /submission stays at the 2.1127 state. Harness (one pack, one GPU) showed 0 differ: bisecting with the judge's record run, stopped after step 3 (/tmp/dbg-*). - m_scan: rows of q, k, o, gate, down at all sampled M >= 1024 equal those at M=8192; k differs below 256, down sporadically up to 896. - Bisect with the judge's record run (norms of steps 0-3 against the reference record): without DEDUP_REF and DEDUP_POLICY: equal (/tmp/dbg-c). With DEDUP_POLICY alone: equal (/tmp/dbg-e). So the frozen model's dedupe (DEDUP_REF) is the culprit: its rows matter only through the KL terms, hence the tiny step-2 difference. Comparing both forwards in a debug tree (/tmp/work/dbgtree, /tmp/dbg-f). - Also found while reading: padded text rows took the head norm's reduction tree from the real row count (2 rows: other tree than the batch's 8); fixed with width_rows (dev), this was the 1,1,1,1 parts failure candidate. - Cause found: the frozen forward's modified copy of the BlockMask (kv_num_blocks zeroed for copied blocks, tensors made in inference mode). Its output equals the plain forward in the same step (/tmp/dbg-f: 0 rows differ), but the frozen model's text KL at the next gen step changed (.00138 vs .00162): the compiled flex attention picked up something stale after that call. Without the copy (dev, /tmp/dbg-g): norms and text KL of steps 0-3 equal the reference. The skip only saved ~40 ms. Full check 5 of sw13 started, log /tmp/work/chk-f5.log. - Prepared on dev (not yet timed): BAGEL_SMALL_GEMM (decode GEMMs on packed weights, A/B 0 differ), BAGEL_FLOW_SIDE (text rows of the merged flow on a second stream, A/B 0 differ), BAGEL_AG_IN_STEP (next rollout's all-gathers start inside the optimizer step), BAGEL_SPLIT_PARTS_EDIT. - Full check 5 timing part (dev a0e7fe9, sw13): windows 9.56 / 10.34 / 10.42, ratios 2.424 / 2.316 / 2.235, steps 10-15: 6.07 13.04 7.14 13.55 7.11 13.72 (r9: 6.24 12.99 6.56 13.26 6.41 13.12): run-to-run variance of ~.6 s per step in the last windows, all in reward exposure. - FULL CHECK (dev a0e7fe9, sw13, /tmp/chk-f5): PASS, N0, speedup 2.2348, window ratios 2.424 / 2.316 / 2.235, candidate 9.56 / 10.35 / 10.42 s/step. Merged into /submission/r3, /submission/switches.json = sw13.
4.7 hRound 6 — reward exposure and small overheads (started 10:53 UTC)
- m_scan2 (all multiples of 16 from 256 to 8192, of 128 up to 24576): q, k, o, gate rows equal those at 24576 rows everywhere; down differs at 256-528 and 896, so every row count >= 1024 is safe (guard: 4096 per expert). - Parts 1,1,1,1 with the head norm fix, A/B: 1827 keys, 0 differ. VAE decode at 512x512: N=1, 2 equal N=4, N=3 does not (default and deterministic). In the refine pack, one cfg document of the last sample shares nothing with the others (its VAE rows differ from the first row on: the batched encoder does not give identical rows for all 8 identical images; the runtime comparison handles it). - BAGEL_SMALL_GEMM + BAGEL_FLOW_SIDE + BAGEL_AG_IN_STEP (dev, sw16p, /tmp/time-r10): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.4027, windows 9.37 / 9.99 / 9.94 (r9: 2.4045). Phases: all-gathers moved from prefill (-.04 s) into the optimizer (+.05 s): no overlap gain, both are memory bound: AG_IN_STEP rejected. Side stream: denoise -.03 s gen, 0 refine: text GEMMs do not co-run with the persistent GEMMs: no gain. Small GEMM: decode ~-.05 s per step net of packing, but +14 GB: reserved 132.7 GiB, 1 GB free next to the reward worker: too tight as it is. - Four denoise parts, one image per rank each (dev, sw17p, /tmp/time-r11): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.4319, windows 9.73 / 9.57 / 9.65 s/step: worst-window ratio about 2.38 (best so far, windows now even). denoise +.28 s gen, +.4 s refine, exposed rewards 1.2-1.5 -> .17-.37 s (gen), .3-.7 -> .13-.55 s (refine); the color step 12 is no longer an outlier (6.10 s). - Full check 6 timing part (dev bc2219d, sw18 = sw13 + 4 parts, small GEMM for decode and text rows, first-step reuse, early zero_grad; no side stream, no all-gathers in the step): windows 9.57 / 10.12 / 10.17, ratios 2.421 / 2.368 / 2.290. Steps 12 and 14 took 7.2 and 7.0 s (r11: 6.1 and 6.0), other gen steps 5.9-6.0. Peak reserved 132.8 GiB. - FULL CHECK (dev bc2219d, sw18, /tmp/chk-f6): PASS, N0, speedup 2.2898, window ratios 2.421 / 2.367 / 2.290, candidate 9.57 / 10.12 / 10.17 s/step. Merged into /submission/r3, /submission/switches.json = sw18. - Reward bursts of the record run with four parts: requests now finish in rounds at the pace of the parts (.85 s gen, 1.5 s refine); only the color prompt (step 12) falls behind, by ~.75 s at its end: 4 requests per worker at ~1.1 s each exceed the denoise time. Reward throughput bound there, nothing left to reorder except starting earlier.
7.7 hRound 7 — attention tails (started 13:56 UTC)
- flash attention is .93 s per refine denoise: one call per branch and layer leaves a tail per call. BAGEL_JOINT_ATTENTION: all branches of a part in one varlen call per layer (one K/V buffer, joined offsets, sequences do not interact). A/B running. - r24 crashed: the judge copies the tree a few seconds after the start and got a half-finished edit (UnboundLocalError), no result. Time runs now use a snapshot of dev (/tmp/work/snapT). Joint attention A/B was clean (1827 keys, 0 differ). Also new: text rows stop after the last attention. - r25 (joint attention + last-layer text skip, sw28p, /tmp/time-r25): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.4117, windows 9.35 / 9.82 / 10.03. Both color steps slow in this run (rewards 1.2, 1.5 s). denoise -.03 s against r23 (3.27-3.30 / 6.17-6.19 s): small but real: the non-color window is 9.35. Likely source of the slow color steps: COLOR_CLASSIFIERS are built per worker and class at first use (CLIP text encoder); if a worker first meets a class in a late request, the build lands on the tail of the step. Which worker gets which image is not under the tree's control. - Profile, edit prefill window: .074 s of kernels in .23 s: 849 device-to-host copies: the eager varlen path of the two edit-text prefills (edit texts differ in length) asks the device for lengths in every layer. BAGEL_VARLEN_PREFILL (forward_prefill_varlen): same GEMMs and varlen attention, lengths known on the host once, fused norms. On dev, A/B after check 9. - Full check 9 timing part (sw28): windows 9.34 / 9.37 / 9.51, ratios 2.480 / 2.556 / 2.449, steps 10-15: 5.86 12.82 5.97 12.78 6.11 12.91; bitwise run in progress. - FULL CHECK (dev snapshot, sw28, /tmp/chk-f9): PASS, N0, speedup 2.4487, window ratios 2.480 / 2.556 / 2.449, candidate 9.34 / 9.38 / 9.51 s/step. Merged into /submission/r3, /submission/switches.json = sw28.
8.3 hRound 8 — exact attention on wgmma (started 14:30 UTC)
- Cheap levers are used up. Prototype /tmp/work/fa/fa.cu: forward attention with flash-attn 2's arithmetic (blocks of 64 keys from last to first, per-thread row sums, same rounding points) on Hopper wgmma, 2 warpgroups, 2 CTAs per SM. flash_fwd is 1.15 s per window at ~230 TFLOPS. Test against flash_attn_varlen_func bit by bit first.
- r26 (BAGEL_VARLEN_PREFILL, sw29p, /tmp/time-r26): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.4161, windows 9.29 / 9.83 / 10.02 (both color steps slow, 7.04 and 7.24 s). prefill_edit .215 -> .116 s, refine steps 12.55-12.8 s. A/B 1827 keys, 0 differ. Kept.
- /tmp/work/fa: the wgmma attention is bit-identical to flash_attn_varlen_func on 5 cases (up to 3 sequences, key lengths 64-3380, inputs scaled by 2): 0 of 11 M elements differ. What it took: rcp.approx for 1/sum, per-thread running row sums, and the FFMA nvcc makes of row_sum * scale + first term. Integrated as BAGEL_FAST_ATTENTION in fused_ops.cu (extension now built for sm_90a); A/B and timing r27 running.
- r27 (BAGEL_FAST_ATTENTION, sw30p, /tmp/time-r27): A/B 1827 keys, 0 differ. speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.439, windows 9.28 / 9.60 / 9.99 (step 14 slow, 7.22 s). denoise refine 6.14 s (-.04 s), gen unchanged: this first version, one synchronous block at a time, is only as fast as flash-attn. Next: overlap QK of the next block with the softmax of the current one (wgmma is asynchronous), 1 CTA per SM. Full check 10 of sw30 meanwhile.
- wgmma pipeline, second version (/tmp/work/fa/fa2.cu): ptxas had serialized every wgmma of the first version and of two attempts at double buffering (C7513-C7515: accumulators or A registers touched while a wgmma of the stage runs). Final order per block: issue QK(i) and PV(i-1), wait for QK, softmax in place while PV runs, wait, pack P, rescale O. 4 arrives and 4 waits in the SASS, no warnings, 146 registers, 1 CTA per SM, 4 K/V stages. Bit test after check 10.
- FULL CHECK (dev snapshot, sw30, /tmp/chk-f10): PASS, N0, speedup 2.3036, window ratios 2.505 / 2.573 / 2.304, candidate 9.25 / 9.31 / 10.11 s/step. The third window holds a slow color step (reward workers); the first two are faster than sw28's 9.34 / 9.38. Merged into /submission/r3, /submission/switches.json = sw30: same bits, less work per step; the reported minimum differs only by which color steps came out slow.
- Pipelined attention: bit test 0 differ on all 5 cases; integrated (dev 0b008c1). A/B and /tmp/time-r28 running.
- r28 (pipelined attention, sw30p, /tmp/time-r28): A/B 0 differ, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.4708, windows 9.47 / 9.34 / 9.69. denoise 6.17-6.18 s (r27 6.14): no visible gain from the pipeline. Profile next to see the kernel's real duration.
- Profile /tmp/prof-r3 (pipelined attention): attention_kernel 1.23 s per generate + refine pair, 360 µs per call, about 1.9 µs per block of 64 keys against 0.56 µs at tensor peak: the two warpgroups run in lockstep (barrier every block), so QK of both runs alone, then softmax + PV, then pack + rescale, and the K/V address arithmetic sits in front of the wgmma issue. 9 of 9 tiles per head are launched for 1026 rows: the ninth holds 2 rows (11 % of the CTAs for nothing).
- Reward requests (phase log, /tmp/time-r29, 2.4653, windows 9.32 / 9.82 / 9.41): request latency at ranks: non-color .9-1 s during denoise, .6 s after it; color 1.2-1.6 s, then .7-.85 s, one 1.86 s: a request that waits behind the third batch. Step 12's exposed 1.35 s is that queue: worker throughput, not one slow request. The logs show no errors or retries.
- Attention v3 (dev): TMA loads by a producer warp, no barrier in the loop, two consumer warpgroups alternate through named barriers, Q in registers, the tail rows of the 7 query heads of a K/V head share one tile (57 tiles per pair instead of 63). Bit test: 0 differ on all 5 cases at the first run. A/B and profile running (/tmp/work/chain5.out).
- Profile /tmp/prof-a3 (attention v3): A/B 1827 keys, 0 differ. attention3_kernel .697 s per pair (r3: 1.231 s), 204 µs per call; GPU busy 17.43 -> 17.13 s, span 19.63 -> 19.38 s. nvjet GEMMs 3.418 -> 3.512 s: part of the gain goes to the power limit.
- Decode, from the profile: 5.0 ms per token, not 4.1 as logged before (tqdm: 199 tokens/s). Per token: 345 µs of graph launch in front of the first kernel, ~90 µs sync and host loop, 235 µs of sampling kernels, 40 µs of softmax for the token's probability, 30 µs of embedding and rotary kernels; weights at 2-3.8 TB/s in the small kernels against 4.4 TB/s in lm_head. New in dev: BAGEL_PIPELINE_DECODE (the sequences of step s+1 are known before step s ends, because a sequence leaves one step after sampling the end token: launch s+1 while s runs, inputs stay on the GPU, results in a pinned ring, no speculation), BAGEL_SAMPLE_PARALLEL (reductions over the logits on a branch next to top-k), BAGEL_DECODE_PDL (programmatic dependent launch: weights load before waiting for the predecessor). A/B and /tmp/time-r30 running (/tmp/work/chain6.out).
- r30 (attention v3 + pipelined decode + parallel sampling + programmatic launch, sw32p, /tmp/time-r30): A/B 1827 keys, 0 differ. speedup_vs_frozen_reference 2.4709, windows 9.19 / 9.97 / 9.34 (step 12 slow, 6.96 s). denoise 5.92 / 3.20 s (r28: 6.17 / 3.30). Decode slower: 194 tokens/s against 199: the 345 µs in the profile are profiler overhead, the host was not the limit, and programmatic launch shows no gain. Those three switches stay off until a profile explains it.
- Rows per rank in training: 9728 (generate), 38912 (refine, 21248 distinct). Next: memory for activations: frozen model as bf16 shards gathered per layer (-22 GB), policy layers reshard after the training forward (-29 GB until the backward gathers them again), last layers without checkpointing. Backward is on the critical path even in reward-bound steps.
- r31 (memory switches, sw34p): crashed at the first rollout after a training step: assigning a Module to forward registers a child; fixed with the bound __call__. No result. r32 running.
- r32 (sw34p: frozen model on demand, policy reshard after forward, kept layers 28 / 8): memory marks show the frozen model did not reshard (the recipe's strategy makes the config value False, 27 GiB more than planned): 2 allocator retries per step, peak 126 GiB, backward 1.18 / 3.53 s, prefill .32-.4 s. Activations: 47 GiB for 28 generate layers, 5.7 GiB per refine layer. Fixed with set_reshard_after_forward on the frozen model.