Claude Haiku 5.5 1.64×
Harness: Claude Code · switches: R3OPT_CPU_STEP=1 R3OPT_DECODE_FUSED=1 R3OPT_DECODE_GRAPH=1 R3OPT_DECODE_SYNCFREE=1 R3OPT_DENOISE_PREPLAN=1 R3OPT_DENOISE_SYNCFREE=1 R3OPT_GEN_BLOCK=1 R3OPT_GEN_FUSED=1 R3OPT_LATE_REWARD=1 R3OPT_MERGE_FUSED=1
- Judged
- 1.64×
- Tier
- N0
- Self-best
- 1.62×
- Rounds
- 16
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $12.6
- Input tokens · 99.3% cached
- 185 M
- Output tokens
- 1.0 M
- Requests
- 383
§ 02Key levers
- Text-decode CUDA graph
- ✓
R3OPT_DECODE_GRAPH, 1.10× → 1.31× (single-run timing) - Reward wait hidden behind forward
- ✓
R3OPT_LATE_REWARD, 1.31× → 1.42× - Rollout-side bitwise fused kernels
- ✓ Triton decode / denoise elementwise fusion, full check 1.45× → 1.50×; rows of the two experts laid out as contiguous blocks + merged kernels → 1.61×
- Train-side bitwise kernels / freeing memory
- ✗ listed under "remaining directions", noted as high effort, not done (peak 130.8 GiB)
- Other main levers
- AdamW step counter moved back to CPU; one-step decode lookahead, expandable segments (1.48×, slower) tried, reverted
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log21 sections
0.0 hRound 1 (started 2026-11-06 05:57 UTC, GPU lock taken 05:58:27)
- Start: profile of the unchanged reference (bench/bench.py profile --tree targets/reference, output/tmp/prof-ref-1, log/tmp/prof-ref-1.log, detached). Ends after optimizer steps 11-12. - Reference timing (task/timing_ref.json): 22.97 / 23.47 / 23.12 s per step in windows 10-11, 12-13, 14-15. - Code reading so far (train/online_rl.py, train/rollout_controller.py, modeling/bagel/bagel.py): - Step loop: rollout (text decode with sampling viagenerate_text_batch, then CFG image denoising viagenerate_image_mix),.result()wait on reward futures,prepack,pack_iterator(one batch), ref forward (inference_mode), policy forward, loss, backward, clip, AdamW step. - Host syncs in decode:generate_text_batchcalls.item()per sequence per token; the static-cache attention path inmodeling/bagel/qwen2_navit.py(_static_kv_cache_attention) calls.item()per layer per token. -context()callstorch.cuda.empty_cache()on entry and exit of each rollout, androllout_buffer.all_gather()calls it too. - Reward futures are submitted at the end ofrolloutand awaited right after it (serial with the step).
0.0 hRound 1 profile (reference, optimizer steps 11 edit + 12 gen; /tmp/prof-ref-1)
- Step times on the profiled run: edit (refine) steps 30-35 s, generate steps 14-16 s. GPU busy 27.0 s of a 53 s span.
- Timeline (1 s bins, rank 0):
- text decode (reflection ~305 tokens, then generation ~160 tokens): 0-11 s and 34-41 s, GPU only ~20% busy,
~46k kernels/s; 244k _local_scalar_dense (.item()) syncs in the 2 steps.
- image denoising with CFG (21 / 16 steps, read-only static-cache attention): 12-24 s and 42-49 s, GPU ~65% busy.
- training (ref forward, policy forward/backward, flex attention, FSDP): 27-33 s and 51-52 s, GPU ~100% busy.
- idle gaps with no GPU work: 1.2 s (edit) and 1.6 s (gen), i.e. the reward wait after the rollout.
- Operators by self CUDA time: aten::mm 42.5% (nvjet GEMMs), aten::mul 10.1% (226k calls), _index_put_impl_ 6.2%,
index kernels 5.1%, aten::copy_ 4.9%, flash-attn 6.6%, NCCL 5.4%, Memcpy DtoH 2.2% (263k, from the .item()s).
- Classification: decode = host-bound (missed syncs and per-op dispatch); denoise = sync-bound at ~35% idle;
training = compute-bound; reward wait = serial latency.0.0 hRound 1 change (commit 33ba26e): sync-free static-cache text decode (switch R3OPT_DECODE_SYNCFREE)
-Bagel._generate_text_batch_static_syncfree: same kernel calls, batch composition and RNG draws; host keeps the active set and cache lengths; one device-to-host transfer per step; the attention reads decode facts fromStaticKVCache.decode_host_meta. - Numerics N0 by construction; tiny-model bitwise test over 24 configurations (identical, 96 EOS, RNG state included). - Time: /tmp/time-r1-a,speedup_vs_frozen_reference= 1.0223 (22.68 s/step; windows 22.19 / 23.53 / 22.32). Within noise. Finding: decode is bound by op dispatch (about 1.8k eager ops per token), not by the syncs. - Full check: not run yet.
1.2 hRound 2 (commit 9655800): host-planned read-only static-cache attention in denoising (switch R3OPT_DENOISE_SYNCFREE)
- Target: the CFG denoising forwards (update_past_key_values=False) ran the masked merge with ~8 host syncs per layer per forward. - Change:build_static_readonly_plan(host index plan, one H2D copy per forward),_merge_static_kv_planned(same gathers and scatters), flash call with host max lengths. N0 by construction. - Unit test (8 cases, random caches): bitwise identical. - Time: /tmp/time-r2-a with R3OPT_DECODE_SYNCFREE=1 + R3OPT_DENOISE_SYNCFREE=1: speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0995 (21.09 s/step; windows 20.59 / 21.16 / 21.52 vs frozen 22.97 / 23.47 / 23.12). Rounds 1 and 2 were timed together here. - check --quick (gates 0 and 2, record run) on the same config: PASS, bitwise, N0 (3200 tensors, 235 reward requests), output /tmp/check-r2q/check.json. The full check (gate 1 with reference A/B) has not been run yet. - /submission/switches.json set to {R3OPT_DECODE_SYNCFREE: 1, R3OPT_DENOISE_SYNCFREE: 1} after this check.
1.2 hRound 3 (commit pending amend): CUDA-graph replay of the text-decode step (switch R3OPT_DECODE_GRAPH)
- Profile basis: decode ~19 s of the 53 s profiled span at ~20% GPU busy, dispatch-bound; round 1 showed syncs are not the limit. - Change:_decode_step_body(one step, shared by eager and graph paths),_capture_decode_graph(one graph per active batch size per generate call, generator registered), replay with host-side decisions unchanged. - Tiny-model bitwise test: 48 runs, default and deterministic algorithms, 70 captures each: identical (tokens, probs, generator state, KV cache, lengths, positions). Test script: /tmp/analysis/unit/test_decode_graph.py. - Time: pending (/tmp/time-r3-a, switches R3OPT_DECODE_SYNCFREE=1, R3OPT_DENOISE_SYNCFREE=1, R3OPT_DECODE_GRAPH=1). - Round 3 check (check --quick, record run, /tmp/check-r3q, config = switch-r3): PASS, bitwise, N0 (3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). Enabled in /submission/switches.json (with DECODE_SYNCFREE and DENOISE_SYNCFREE). - Current best: switches {R3OPT_DECODE_SYNCFREE, R3OPT_DENOISE_SYNCFREE, R3OPT_DECODE_GRAPH} = 1.3087 (time-r3-a).
2.0 hRound 4 (commit f07de6b): reward wait after the policy forward (switch R3OPT_LATE_REWARD)
- Profile basis (round 1 profile): reward wait = 1.2-1.6 s per step with no GPU work in flight, serial with packing and training. - Change:_finish_rewards(the reward block, unchanged code) runs after the policy forward; advantages reach the loss throughLateValueplaceholders (pack lists kept unconverted), materialized just before the loss. Same values, same tensors. - check --quick (record run, /tmp/check-r4q): PASS, bitwise, N0 (3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). - Time: /tmp/time-r4-a, all four switches: speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.4176 (16.36 s/step; windows 15.94 / 16.59 / 16.54). - /submission/switches.json now: DECODE_SYNCFREE, DENOISE_SYNCFREE, DECODE_GRAPH, LATE_REWARD (all = 1). ### Cumulative (time runs against the frozen reference, same host) | step | switches | speedup_vs_frozen_reference | s/step | |---|---|---|---| | r1 | DECODE_SYNCFREE | 1.0223 | 22.68 | | r1+r2 | + DENOISE_SYNCFREE | 1.0995 | 21.09 | | r1+r2+r3 | + DECODE_GRAPH | 1.3087 | 17.72 | | r1-r4 | + LATE_REWARD | 1.4176 | 16.36 | (reference: 23.19 s/step; windows 22.97 / 23.47 / 23.12)
2.6 hRound 5 (commit 30190d2): proactive empty_cache skipped on the rollout path (switch R3OPT_NO_EMPTY_CACHE, off)
- Trace estimate (reference profile): cudaFree 1.17 s and cudaMalloc 0.36 s over 2 steps (mostly from empty_cache). - Time: /tmp/time-r5-b (round 4 switches + NO_EMPTY_CACHE=1): 1.433 (16.18 s/step) vs 1.4176 for round 4: within noise. Peak memory unchanged (130.78 / 133.72 GiB). Left off in switches.json. - First attempt /tmp/time-r5-a failed: helper inserted between @contextmanager and fsdp2_rollout_context (AttributeError: __enter__). Fixed and re-timed.
2.6 hRound 6 (in progress): batched device-scalar transfer in packing (switch R3OPT_BATCH_SCALARS, default off)
- Profile basis (round 4 profile, transition after the denoising): ~33katen::itemcalls in 2 s. Cause:torch.tensor(list)of 0-dim CUDA tensors (dts,packed_timesteps_for_loss, one entry per latent token, repeated) syncs once per element. - Change:_float32_tensor_from_scalarsgathers the distinct tensors in one transfer (same float32 values). Unit test (/tmp/analysis/unit/test_scalars.py): identical for repeated and distinct device scalars. - Time: /tmp/time-r6-a (round 4 switches + R3OPT_BATCH_SCALARS=1): pending. ### FULL CHECK of the submitted configuration (commit c37c742, switches = DECODE_SYNCFREE, DENOISE_SYNCFREE, DECODE_GRAPH, LATE_REWARD) -bench.py check --config /submission/switches.json --out /tmp/check-full-1: status PASS, verdict bitwise (N0; 3200 tensors, 235 reward requests), speedup 1.3733 (window ratios 1.4797 / 1.3733 / 1.4024; candidate 15.53 / 17.09 / 16.48 s/step vs frozen reference 22.97 / 23.47 / 23.12; reference spread 0.0205, bar 1.041). Peak 130.76 GiB allocated, 133.72 reserved. - The check's own timing gave 1.3733 while the earliertimeruns gave 1.42; the difference is run-to-run variation.
2.6 hRound 6 result
- Time /tmp/time-r6-a: 1.419 vs 1.4176 (no measurable gain). Switch left off.
3.1 hRound 7 (dev worktree /tmp/r3-dev, branch dev-round7; in progress): denoising plans once per call, no per-forward device reads
- Gap analysis of the round 4 profile (denoising windows): ~60 ms GPU-idle gaps once per denoising step (about 1 s per edit round). Cause:torch.tensor([t] * B)with B = number of image tokens (about 4096) and 0-dim CUDAtreads the device once per element (4096 syncs per step), and the plan building runs after theunique()sync, with the GPU idle. - Change (switch R3OPT_DENOISE_PREPLAN, requires R3OPT_DENOISE_SYNCFREE): plans built once per generate_image_mix call; timestep built as t.reshape(1).expand(B).clone() (same float32 values); the tautologicalunique()assert skipped. - Round 7 check --quick (/tmp/check-r7q): PASS, bitwise, N0 (3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). - Round 7 time (/tmp/time-r7-a): 1.4754 (15.72 s/step; windows 15.10 / 16.12 / 15.93) vs round 4 1.4176. - Committed as e01e369 (fast-forward of opt). /submission/switches.json now enables R3OPT_DENOISE_PREPLAN too.
3.1 hCURRENT SUMMARY (updated after round 7)
- Submission: /submission/r3 branch opt at e01e369. Switch file /submission/switches.json:
{R3OPT_DECODE_SYNCFREE: 1, R3OPT_DENOISE_SYNCFREE: 1, R3OPT_DECODE_GRAPH: 1, R3OPT_LATE_REWARD: 1, R3OPT_DENOISE_PREPLAN: 1}.
- Latest full check of the previous configuration (c37c742, four switches): PASS, bitwise, speedup 1.3733.
The full check of e01e369 with the current switch file: running, output /tmp/check-full-2 (see below).
- Gains by change (time runs vs the frozen reference, same host):
- R1 sync-free text decode: ~0 on its own (decode is dispatch bound, not sync bound).
- R2 read-only plan in denoising (with R1 timed together): 1.0223 -> 1.0995 (R1+R2).
- R3 CUDA-graph decode step: 1.0995 -> 1.3087 (R1-R3).
- R4 reward wait after the policy forward: 1.3087 -> 1.4176.
- R5 no proactive empty_cache: 1.4176 -> 1.433 (within noise; left off).
- R6 batched device-scalar transfer: 1.4176 -> 1.419 (no gain; left off).
- R7 denoise plans once per call / no per-forward device reads: 1.4176 -> 1.4754.
- Did not work or not worth it: sync removal alone in decode (R1); empty_cache removal (R5); batched scalar transfer (R6).
- Remaining cost (r4 profile, 2 steps, 33 s span): decode ~6.5 s (GPU replay ~8.4 ms/token plus ~2.4 ms per
cudaGraphLaunch, GPU idle during the launch), denoising ~15 s (after R7 the gaps are gone; GPU-bound), training ~9 s
(GPU-bound: ref + policy forward/backward with activation checkpointing), transitions ~2 s (packing, CPU).
- Next candidates: (a) decode K-step graph or speculative replay with rollback (removes the per-token graph launch gap,
est. 4-5%, high complexity); (b) denoise forwards are GPU-bound, no bitwise lever found; (c) training GPU-bound.
### FULL CHECK of the current submission (commit e01e369; switches DECODE_SYNCFREE, DENOISE_SYNCFREE, DECODE_GRAPH, LATE_REWARD, DENOISE_PREPLAN)
- bench.py check --config /submission/switches.json --out /tmp/check-full-2: status PASS, verdict bitwise (N0; 3200 tensors,
235 reward requests), speedup 1.4538 (window ratios 1.4991 / 1.4758 / 1.4538; candidate 15.33 / 15.90 / 15.90 s per step vs
frozen reference 22.97 / 23.47 / 23.12; bar 1.041). Peak 130.76 GiB allocated.3.9 hRound 8 (dev worktree /tmp/r3-dev2, branch dev-round8; in progress): decode replay with one step of lookahead (switch R3OPT_DECODE_PIPELINE, needs R3OPT_DECODE_GRAPH)
- Finding (r4 profile, decode window): each token costs one cudaGraphLaunch of ~2.4 ms CPU time during which the GPU is idle, then a ~8.4 ms replay: ~11.2 ms per token, the replay is ~75% of it. - Design: the replay of the next step (same active set, device-side state: current tokens and positions updated before the launch) is queued before the host reads this step's tokens. If no sequence finishes, it is the next step. If one does, the lookahead is rolled back (cache lengths, positions, current tokens of finished sequences, generator state restored to the state after this step's replay) and the step is replayed for the new active set. - Tiny-model test (/tmp/analysis/unit/test_decode_pipe.py): 128 runs default and 128 deterministic, all identical (tokens, probabilities, generator state, live cache entries, lengths, positions, current tokens); overflow raises the same error (/tmp/analysis/unit/overflow_pipe.py). - Time: /tmp/time-r8-a (round 7 switches plus R3OPT_DECODE_PIPELINE=1): pending. - Round 8 result: the first time run failed (pinned CPU buffer allocated on the default CUDA device; fixed, and the tiny test now sets the default device as main() does). Time /tmp/time-r8-b: 1.4794 (15.67 s/step; windows 15.24 / 16.01 / 15.78) vs round 7 1.4754. No measurable gain, so not merged (branch dev-round8, commit recorded there, worktree removed).
4.3 hRound 9 (started 10:20 UTC): profile of the current best (e01e369 + switches), output /tmp/prof-r9, log /tmp/prof-r9.log
- Purpose: re-profile before choosing the next hotspot (the earlier profile was of the r4 configuration; its trace was deleted). - Profile of the current best (e01e369 + switches): /tmp/prof-r9 (profile.txt). Decode per token: many small element-wise kernels (RMSNorm chains of ~8 kernels, rotary ~10, SiLU*up 2) on top of the GEMMs. - Round 9 change (dev worktree /tmp/r3-dev3, branch dev-round9): modeling/bagel/fused_decode.py: Triton kernels for the decode step's element-wise work, reproducing PyTorch's CUDA ops bit for bit: add+square (residual add fused), final RMSNorm (rsqrt via libdevice, bf16 roundings), rotary for q and k in one launch, SiLU*up. The reductions (torch.mean) and all GEMMs and attention calls stay PyTorch's. Switch R3OPT_DECODE_FUSED (decode steps only). - Numerics finding: Triton's .to(bf16).to(f32) pairs were folded in one kernel (wrong rounding); every bf16 rounding is now an explicit PTX cvt.rn.bf16.f32 (inline_asm_elementwise). Unit test (168 cases, RMSNorm/rotary/SiLU): bitwise identical. - Tiny-model equivalence (/tmp/analysis/unit/test_decode_fused.py, 81 runs x 3 modes, default and deterministic, 382 fused calls): identical. - Time: /tmp/time-r9-a (current switches plus R3OPT_DECODE_FUSED=1): pending. - Round 9 time (/tmp/time-r9-a): 1.4504 (15.99 s/step; windows 14.82 / 17.54 / 15.60) vs round 7 1.4754 (15.72). The per-step times show the gain that is expected: refine (edit) steps about 1 s faster in 5 of 6 steps, generate steps about 0.2 s faster; the window average is hit by one slow step (13: 25.0 s). A check --quick of this configuration is running (/tmp/check-r9q). - Round 9 check --quick (/tmp/check-r9q, config = switch-r9): PASS, bitwise, N0 (3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). - Committed as 660be19 (fast-forward of opt); /submission/switches.json now also enables R3OPT_DECODE_FUSED.
5.2 hRound 10 (dev worktree /tmp/r3-dev4, branch dev-round10): fused element-wise work in the generation (denoising) path (switch R3OPT_GEN_FUSED)
- Profile basis (round 9 profile, denoising window 5.5-12.5 s): GEMM 60% of busy time, element-wise 23%, index (gather/scatter) 13%. - Change: subset RMSNorm (bf16) with the fused kernel for the input, post-attention and final norms of the two MoT experts; the MLPs with the fused SiLU*up; the float32 q/k norms written straight into the full layout (gen_qk_norm_rope) and the float32 rotary with explicit PTX mul/add (no contraction) writing bfloat16. Gathers, scatters, GEMMs and attention unchanged. - Unit tests: /tmp/analysis/unit/test_gen_kernels.py (48 cases, head dim 128): identical. /tmp/analysis/unit/test_gen_fused.py (Qwen2Model gen-mode forward, 4 trials, fused calls 8): identical. - check --quick (/tmp/check-r10q, config /tmp/switch-r10.json): PASS, bitwise, N0 (3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). - Time: /tmp/time-r10-a: pending. - Round 10 time (/tmp/time-r10-a, round 9 switches + R3OPT_GEN_FUSED=1): 1.6159 (14.35 s/step; windows 13.89 / 15.07 / 14.09) vs round 9 1.4504 (per-step: generate steps about 8.8-9.7 s, refine steps 18.7-20.5 s). - Committed as the fast-forward to dev-round10 (see git log); /submission/switches.json enables R3OPT_GEN_FUSED too. - Full check of this configuration started (/tmp/check-full-3). - FULL CHECK of the current submission (commit f212eb7, switches = DECODE_SYNCFREE, DENOISE_SYNCFREE, DECODE_GRAPH, LATE_REWARD, DENOISE_PREPLAN, DECODE_FUSED, GEN_FUSED): PASS, bitwise (N0), speedup 1.5035 (window ratios 1.6612 / 1.5035 / 1.5892; candidate 13.83 / 15.61 / 14.55 s per step vs frozen reference 22.97 / 23.47 / 23.12). Output /tmp/check-full-3/check.json. - Round 10 result: adopted (see the round 10 time above).
5.8 hRound 11 (started 11:44 UTC): profile of the current submission, output /tmp/prof-r11
- Round 11 profile (/tmp/prof-r11, current submission): per 2 steps ~29 s span: decode ~5 s (GEMM 72% of decode busy), denoising ~13 s (GEMM 72%, index gather/scatter 16%, element-wise 2% after round 10), training ~9 s, other ~2 s (straggler wait 1.6 s). - Next candidate (round 11): block-ordered generation forward (permute the packed stream once per forward so the two experts' rows are contiguous blocks; GEMM inputs become views; attention stays in sample order via fused gathers). Expected ~3-4%. - Round 11 check --quick of the block-ordered generation forward (/tmp/check-r11q, switches = r10 + R3OPT_GEN_BLOCK=1): PASS, bitwise, N0 (3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). Unit: test_gen_block.py (4 trials) identical. - Round 12 (same worktree, uncommitted until verified): R3OPT_MERGE_FUSED: the read-only cache merge as one copy kernel per k/v driven by a source table (test_merge_fused.py, 6 cases identical). Time run with both switches: /tmp/time-r12-a (pending). - Round 12 time (/tmp/time-r12-a; block + merge): 1.5753 (14.72 s/step; windows 13.80 / 14.44 / 15.91). Excluding one outlier step (step 14: 12.6 s), generate steps average about 8.6 s (round 10: 9.0 s) and refine steps about 18.9 s (round 10: 19.3 s). Check --quick of this combination started (/tmp/check-r12q). - FULL CHECK (commit c19bf57; switches DECODE_SYNCFREE, DENOISE_SYNCFREE, DECODE_GRAPH, LATE_REWARD, DENOISE_PREPLAN, DECODE_FUSED, GEN_FUSED, GEN_BLOCK, MERGE_FUSED): PASS, bitwise (N0), speedup 1.6117 (window ratios 1.6998 / 1.6117 / 1.6569; candidate 13.52 / 14.56 / 13.95 s per step vs frozen reference 22.97 / 23.47 / 23.12). Peak 130.76 GiB allocated, 133.72 reserved. Output /tmp/check-full-4/check.json. Adopted (previous full check of f212eb7: 1.5035).
6.9 hCURRENT SUMMARY (after round 12; updated 12:52 UTC)
- Submission: /submission/r3, branch opt, commit c19bf57 (clean). /submission/switches.json enables nine switches (list above). - Latest full check on exactly this state: PASS, bitwise N0, speedup 1.6117 (/tmp/check-full-4). - Gains by change (time runs; the rounds are cumulative): R1 sync-free decode ~0; R2 denoise read-only plan (with R1) 1.02 -> 1.10; R3 CUDA-graph decode 1.10 -> 1.31; R4 late reward wait 1.31 -> 1.42; R5 empty_cache (off, noise); R6 batched scalars (off, noise); R7 denoise plans once per call 1.42 -> 1.48; R9 fused decode element-wise 1.48 -> 1.45 (time run; per-step gain about 1 s per refine step; full checks of f212eb7 1.50); R10 fused gen-mode element-wise 1.45 -> 1.62 (time) / 1.50 (full check); R11-12 block-ordered gen forward and merge kernel: full check 1.61. - Did not work or not adopted: decode lookahead (dev-round8; no gain), empty_cache removal, batched scalar transfer. - Remaining cost per 2 steps (round 11 profile): decode ~5 s (GEMM bound), denoising ~11 s (GEMM bound, index work reduced by R11-12), training ~9 s (autograd; its element-wise and index work is about 30% of busy time, not fused), straggler wait ~1.6 s (rank imbalance in decode lengths). - Directions left: fused training element-wise with exact custom autograd (large effort); decode cache-index hoisting (<1%).
6.9 hRound 13 (dev worktree /tmp/r3-dev6, branch dev-round13): per-forward index work hoisted out of the layer loop
- Change: decode attention computes the cache-index triple (batch index, cache indices, sequence lengths) once per forward (_static_kv_index_prep, passed as pre=); the read-only plan carries the cumulative query and key lengths as device tensors (cu_q, cu_k) instead of pad/cumsum per layer. Same integers, N0 by construction. - Tests: t13_decode (tiny decode, fused, 81 runs x 3 modes, both modes) identical; t13_gen (block gen forward, 4 trials) identical; t13_merge (planned merge, 6 cases) identical. - check --quick (/tmp/check-r13q, config = current submission switches): started. - Round 13 check --quick (/tmp/check-r13q, current switches): PASS, bitwise, N0. Committed as the fast-forward to dev-round13 (see git log). Time run of the submitted tree: /tmp/time-r13-a (pending). - Round 13 time (/tmp/time-r13-a, the submitted tree 329c0f0): 1.6579 (13.99 s/step; windows 13.38 / 13.85 / 14.72). Refine steps average about 18.3 s (round 12: 18.9 s); generate steps about 8.6 s (unchanged). - FULL CHECK (commit 329c0f0, the current submission; switches as in /submission/switches.json): PASS, bitwise (N0), speedup 1.6239 (window ratios 1.7710 / 1.6315 / 1.6239; candidate 12.97 / 14.39 / 14.23 s per step vs frozen reference 22.97 / 23.47 / 23.12). Peak 130.76 GiB allocated. Output /tmp/check-full-5/check.json. Adopted (previous full check c19bf57: 1.6117).
8.2 hRound 14 (13:36-14:10 UTC; dev worktree /tmp/r3-dev7, branch dev-round14): profile of the submitted state, host-stall analysis, allocator switch rejected
- Profile (/tmp/prof-r14, submission 329c0f0 with the switches of /submission/switches.json; optimizer steps 11-12 under torch.profiler, instrumented, so not comparable with time): the pair spans 27.5 s on the GPU stream (refine step about 18.5 s, generate step about 9.2 s). GPU busy 21.7 s (79%). - Kernel mix (22.9 s of GPU busy time over the two steps): GEMMs (aten::mm/addmm and cuBLAS nvjet kernels) about half; flash attention about 1.3 s (6%); NCCL all-gather and reduce-scatter about 0.9 s (4%); our fused Triton kernels about 1.3 s (6%); remaining element-wise, index, copy, cat and reduce about 5 s (22%); AdamW 0.22 s (1%). - GPU idle: 4.6 s in gaps of at least 0.3 ms (957 gaps); about 1.2 s more in about 591k gaps of about 2 us (kernel-to-kernel). - Largest gap, 1.51 s in the generate step: it sits between the last GEMMs of the policy forward and the first loss kernels (log-softmax, gather). No traced CPU operation covers it, so it is the late-reward wait (_finish_rewards()runs afterfsdp_model(...)in late mode). The reward requests are fixed by gate 2 (content and count), and the loss needs the advantages before backward, so this wait is structural: the reward latency is not covered by the forward and reference forward. - Other gap time, by overlapping main-thread operations: aten::item 0.61 s (nested with _local_scalar_dense), cudaGraphLaunch 0.46 s, cudaStreamSynchronize 0.33 s, cudaMalloc 0.23 s and cudaFree 0.19 s (device-synchronizing allocator calls), cudaMemcpyAsync 0.15 s, aten::linear/index/copy/empty about 0.5 s together, Optimizer.step 0.12 s; unattributed Python time 0.44 s. - Rejected before any measurement: moving the barrier at train/online_rl.py:1168 after prepack and pack_batch. Packing is not a GPU gap on rank 0 in this profile, and for the slowest rank (which sets the step time) packing follows its own rollout in both orders, so the reordering cannot shorten the critical path. - Allocator switch PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True (time run /tmp/time-r14-alloc, switch file /tmp/switches-r14-alloc.json): speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.4801 (15.67 s per step; generate steps 9.3-10.1 s, refine steps 21.5-23.7 s), against 1.6579 for the submitted state in round 13. Slower by more than the noise: not adopted, not in /submission/switches.json. - Round 14 result: no change adopted; the submission stays at 329c0f0.
9.0 hRound 15 (14:30-14:45 UTC; branch dev-round14, commit 2c95746; not merged): defer the loss statistics (no gain)
- Change (switch R3OPT_DEFER_STATS, default off): the per-key statistics and log lines of the loss section (about 15 host reads before backward) are read after total_norm, in the same per-key order; the large-KL test reuses one host read. - check --quick (/tmp/check-r15q): PASS, bitwise N0 (14 optimizer steps, 3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). - Time (/tmp/time-r15-a): 1.6643 (13.93 s per step) against 1.6579 (13.99 s) for the submitted tree. No measurable gain: not merged.
9.0 hRound 15 profile with stage labels (/tmp/prof-r14b; diagnostic tree /tmp/r3-prof on branch dev-prof14, labels only, no
computation changed; analysis scripts /tmp/analysis/r14_stages.py, r14_cpu_in_label.py). Per-step averages over the refine and generate steps of the profiled pair (CPU wall = time the host spends in the stage; GPU busy = kernels launched in it): | stage | CPU wall ms | GPU busy ms | GPU idle before its kernels ms | |---|---|---|---| | rollout own kernels (decode and denoise nested below) | 7695 total | 564 | 436 | | denoise (16/21 steps, CFG) | 4727 | 4558 | 172 | | text decode | 1872 | 1331 | 538 | | backward | 2600 | 2415 | 191 | | policy forward | 1185 | 938 | 217 | | reward wait (after the policy forward) | 858 | 4 | 721 | | reference forward | 762 | 876 | 16 | | optimizer and clip | 595 | 81 | 108 | | pack_batch | 438 | 37 | 442 | | barrier | 86 | 86 | 97 | - Reading: the step runs serially; rollout (about 7.7 s) then training (about 6.2 s). Denoising is GPU-bound. Three stages are host-bound with the GPU idle: the optimizer section (about 800 host reads per step: the AdamW step counters are CUDA tensors because main() sets the default device to CUDA, while torch keeps them on the host for CUDA parameters), pack_batch (about 18k small device copies per call and Python list work), and the text decode (about 0.5 s per step: one host read per token and one graph launch of about 0.9 ms per token, serialized with the GPU; the active batch shape must stay as it is, so the next graph cannot be launched before the read).
9.0 hRound 16 (14:45 UTC-; branch dev-round15, worktree /tmp/r3-dev8): AdamW step counters on the host (switch R3OPT_CPU_STEP)
- Change: after optimizer.step(), state['step'] tensors that live on CUDA are moved to the CPU, which is torch's own placement for CUDA parameters. The counters hold integers in float32, and the bias corrections are Python floats read from them, so the values and arithmetic are unchanged; the judge's optimizer hyper-parameters are not touched. - check --quick (/tmp/check-r15c): PASS, bitwise N0 (14 optimizer steps, 3200 tensors, 235 reward requests). - Time (/tmp/time-r15c): pending. - Time (/tmp/time-r15c): 1.6963 (13.67 s per step; windows 13.23 / 14.10 / 13.67; the submitted round-13 tree measured 1.6579 with 13.38 / 13.85 / 14.72). Window 2 is slower, so the gain is about 2 percent and within the run-to-run noise; the host work removed (about 1600 host syncs and about 0.6 s of optimizer host time per step) is the reason for the change. - Committed as 1bfde6a (fast-forward of opt, branch dev-round15); /submission/switches.json enables R3OPT_CPU_STEP=1. - FULL CHECK of 1bfde6a (switches as in /submission/switches.json): started 15:08 UTC, output /tmp/check-full-6 (pending). - Round 16 result: adopted provisionally until the full check reports. - FULL CHECK of 1bfde6a (commit 1bfde6a, switches as in /submission/switches.json): PASS, bitwise (N0), speedup 1.6242 (window ratios 1.7690 / 1.6242 / 1.6391). The full check of 329c0f0 gave 1.6239: no measurable change at this level of noise. Kept: it is bitwise identical and removes about 1600 host syncs per step. Output /tmp/check-full-6/check.json.