Claude Sonnet 5.5 1.21×

Harness: Claude Code · switches: OPT_MB_GROUP=2 OPT_BLOCK=1 OPT_OPTIM_V2=1 OPT_LOSS=1 OPT_ASYNC_LOADER=1 OPT_ADAMW_BEFORE_LAST=1 OPT_FP8_CACHE=1 OPT_WGRAD_FP32=1 OPT_LT_GEMM=1 OPT_FREE_GRADS=1 OPT_SUMSTACK=1 OPT_AMAX_CARRIER=1 OPT_LT_WS0=1 OPT_PSTACK=1 OPT_EARLY_REFRESH=1 OPT_MUON_SYRK=1 OPT_EMBED_SEG=1 OPT_DX0_RETAIN=1

Judged
1.21×
Tier
N1
Self-best
1.19×
Rounds
24
Hours
10.0
API cost
$48.4
Input tokens · 99.4% cached
285 M
Output tokens
1.3 M
Requests
547
Micro-batch regrouping 4×16 → 2×32
✓ OPT_MB_GROUP=2, alone 1.026
Scope of hand-written kernels replacing Inductor glue
✓ whole block: OPT_BLOCK 1.066 → 1.129, plus OPT_LOSS to 1.149
Per-shape cuBLASLt algorithm selection
✓ OPT_LT_GEMM, full check 1.164 → 1.185, output bitwise unchanged
FP8 weights quantized once per step
✓ OPT_FP8_CACHE, 1.149 → 1.156
Fast accum on backward GEMMs
no attempt in the log
Other main levers
Muon symmetric matmul computes only the upper triangle (OPT_MUON_SYRK, 1.200 → 1.207), value-embedding grads via sorted segments (OPT_EMBED_SEG, 1.209 → 1.215), params as views into stacked buffers, grads from two accumulations summed in one pass, weight grads emitted directly in fp32, async data fetch
Raw work log24 sections
0.3 hRound 1 — profile of the unchanged reference (13:22 – 13:45, 2026-11-08)
Command: bench.py profile --tree /submission/nanochat --out /tmp/runs/prof-0 --from 12 --iters 3 (updates 12-14, rank 0).
Reference timing (frozen, task/timing_ref.json): 1.0195 / 1.0262 / 1.0264 s per update (window 1/2/3).

GPU time per update (sum of kernel durations of one update = 1021 ms = wall time, i.e. the compute stream is never idle
except ~1.5-2.5 us launch gaps between the ~9000 kernels per update):

| class | ms/update | share |
|---|---|---|
| FP8 GEMMs (cuBLAS nvjet_*, aten::_scaled_mm, 1740/update) | 457 | 44.8 % |
| Inductor (triton) pointwise/reduction kernels (quantisation amax/cast/transposes, rms-norm, rotary, relu^2, residual adds...) 7091 launches | 377 | 36.9 % |
| FlashAttention-3 fwd+bwd (+ bwd pre/post-process) | 110 | 10.7 % |
| NCCL (reduce-scatter / all-gather in the optimizer, mostly overlapped) | 23 | 2.3 % |
| embedding fwd/bwd triton kernels | 19 | 1.9 % |
| lm_head loss (log_softmax / tanh softcap / nll) | 17 | 1.7 % |
| aten misc (grad accumulation adds etc.) | 14 | 1.4 % |
| memcpy / memset | 3.6 | 0.4 % |

Optimizer phase (reduce-scatter -> AdamW/Muon -> all-gather): ~42 ms (4.1 %) from first NCCL kernel to end; Muon NS bmm ~500 us each.

Biggest single kernels (per update): MLP-backward fp8 cast of grad_h with transposed copy
triton_poi_..._relu_t_threshold_backward_view_12 65 ms (96 calls x 680 us, ~1.8 TB/s because of the uncoalesced transposed
store) + its amax pass ..._view_10 19.7 ms; MLP forward relu^2 cast 18.7 ms + amax 13 ms; rotary+rmsnorm fwd 18.7 ms and bwd
13.7 ms; per-layer weight amax/cast/transpose small kernels repeated every micro-batch (~10 ms total).

Classification: hotspot kind = "genuinely new opportunity" (memory-bound fused-kernel work around the FP8 GEMMs) plus a few
"missed fast path" items (weight quantisation recomputed in every micro-batch although weights are constant within an update).

(round 1 produced no code change.)
0.8 hRound 2 — micro-batch grouping (13:30 – 13:46)
Hotspot class: per-micro-batch fixed costs (weight quantisation/transposes, gradient-accumulation adds, kernel launches/gaps,
GEMM tile efficiency) — the GPU is 100 % busy so fewer/larger passes are the lever.
Change: OPT_MB_GROUP=k (scripts/base_train.py): the loader is asked for k x 16 rows per yield (same rows, same order,
the judge only digests rows) and one forward/backward processes k x 16 sequences (k=2 -> 2 accumulation steps of 32 x 2048
tokens instead of 4 of 16 x 2048). Real-valued function unchanged; the FP8 per-tensor amax scope doubles => tier N1.
time (/tmp/runs/t-mb2, switches {"OPT_MB_GROUP": "2"}): windows 0.9943 / 0.9982 / 1.0010 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0263
(per-window ratios 1.0253 / 1.0281 / 1.0254), peak memory 94 GiB (ref 56 GiB; limit 141 GiB). Commit 1f2b0d2 (branch exp).
0.8 hRound 3 — Inductor autotuning flags (13:45 – 14:07)
Change: only environment variables (no code): TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1 on top of mb2.
time (/tmp/runs/t-mb2cd): windows 0.9768 / 0.9828 / 0.9826, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0442 (per-window min ratio 1.0437);
cold compile 473 s (vs 140 s) — inside the 2700 s timing limit. N1 (block-size / reduction-order choices of Inductor kernels).
TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE=1 was started and aborted: the Triton FP8 GEMM templates it autotunes are 2.3x slower than
cuBLAS (aten._scaled_mm), so no gain, only compile time. Profile with mb2+CD (/tmp/runs/prof-mb2cd): 982 ms/update; GEMM 465,
Inductor pointwise 340, FA3 110, NCCL 25, lm_head loss 17, embedding 14.5.
Also: optimizer window = 45 ms (compute stream busy 40): Muon GEMMs 22.8, Muon pointwise 9.8, copies (stack/copy_/foreach) 5.7, AdamW 1.5, idle 5.
0.8 hRound 4 — fused MLP backward quantisation kernels (14:07 – )
Finding: the largest single Inductor kernel (..relu_t_threshold_backward_view_12, 65 ms/update, ~1.8 TB/s because of its uncoalesced
transposed fp8 stores) quantises grad_h = dr*2*relu(h) to e5m2 (row-major + transposed) and relu(h)^2 to e4m3 (transposed).
A hand-written Triton kernel (tile 32x128, transposed stores through tl.trans) reaches 3.5 TB/s in a micro-benchmark.
Change: nanochat/fp8_fused.py (Float8MLPFunction, custom ops nanochat_opt::mlp_bwd_amax/mlp_bwd_cast), enabled with OPT_FUSED_MLP=1.
Forward = the reference's torch ops (bitwise); backward = same torch._scaled_mm calls with the custom kernels in between.
Op-level check (/tmp/mb/test_mlp.py, compiled vs compiled reference): out, dx, dw_fc, dw_proj bitwise identical.
Triton 3.5.1 bug found on the way: using one fp8 value for a row-major store AND a transposed store corrupts every 4th row of the
transposed copy; worked around by computing the row-major value through a max/min-swapped (equivalent) clamp.

Round 4 result (/tmp/runs/t-mb2cd-mlp, switches mb2 + CD + OPT_FUSED_MLP=1): windows 0.9623 / 0.9665 / 0.9680, speedup_vs_frozen_reference
1.0605 (per-window min ratio 1.0595); +1.6 % over mb2+CD (0.9807). Commit 8f8b5a2.
1.4 hRound 5 — Inductor persistent reductions (14:19 – 14:30): NO GAIN
OPT_PERSISTENT_RED=2048 (monkey-patches InductorChoices.should_use_persistent_reduction so INNER-hinted row reductions of up to
2048 elements — the 1536-wide norm/quantisation rows — become single-pass): windows 0.9616 / 0.9654 / 0.9669, 1.0616 vs 1.0605 without
(noise). Compile dump showed only 2 kernels changed (5 -> 7 persistent, 60 -> 56 looped): 49 of the 63 backward reductions carry
ReductionHint.DEFAULT, which the patch did not cover (extended later with OPT_PERSISTENT_ALL=1, untested). Left off.
1.4 hRound 6 — optimizer data movement + fast loss (14:30 – 14:41)
OPT_OPTIM_V2=1 (nanochat/optim.py): torch.stack(..., out=padded buffer) instead of stack+copy_, owned params stacked straight into the
all-gather input and updated in place, Muon groups issued before the AdamW groups (big Newton-Schulz compute can start while the
embedding collectives are in flight). OPT_FAST_LOSS=1 (nanochat/gpt.py): softcapped logits are bounded by +-15, so
loss = mean(log(sum(exp(t))) - t_target) needs no running-max (online softmax) bookkeeping.
time mb2+CD+MLP+optv2+fastloss (/tmp/runs/t-e6): windows 0.9586 / 0.9619 / 0.9606, speedup 1.0662 (min window 1.0636), peak mem 90 GiB.
check --quick with ONLY {OPT_FUSED_MLP=1, OPT_OPTIM_V2=1} (/tmp/runs/q-n0): PASS, tier N0, bitwise identical (10 updates, 175 params).
=> the fused MLP kernels and the optimizer data-movement change are exact; mb2 / CD / fast loss are the N1 part.
Commits ad5b634, 9b10951 (OPT_ASYNC_LOADER: pinned ring-buffer asynchronous H2D copy, default off; the reference loader compares
device == "cuda" against a torch.device so its copy is a blocking pageable one that stalls the GPU ~0.8 ms at every micro-batch
boundary and ~2 ms before the optimizer; untested).
Full check of the E6 configuration started 14:43 (/tmp/runs/check-1).
2.2 hRound 7 — hand-fused FP8 transformer block (OPT_BLOCK) (15:00 – 15:31)
Profile motivation: after the MLP fix the Inductor elementwise region was still ~330 ms/update (mega-kernels that re-read 6-8 tensors in two
loops and write three identical transposed fp8 copies, ~1.9 TB/s transposed stores, separate amax passes...).
Change (nanochat/fp8_block.py, GPT._forward_trunk_fused, switch OPT_BLOCK=1): every block = Float8PreAttnFunction (mix/residual + rmsnorm + amax,
fp8 cast with transposed copy, q/k/v GEMMs, rotary + qk-norm + value-gate kernel) -> FA3 -> Float8PostAttnFunction (y quantisation, Wo GEMM, add + rmsnorm,
MLP with the relu^2 quantisation kernels). Hand-written backward: one-pass norm-backward kernels (residual, lambda gradients, amax by atomic max), qk-norm+rotary backward,
cast kernels that write the row-major and the transposed fp8 copy in one pass (Triton 3.5.1 byte-corruption workaround kept), same torch._scaled_mm calls
(tensorwise scaling, fp32 scales, fast-accum only in the forward) => same recipe. Block output is the pair (x2, m); the next block's first kernel adds it.
Op-level tests (/tmp/mb/test_ops.py, test_post.py, test_pre.py, test_model.py): outputs and gradients within 3e-3..9e-3 of the compiled reference (the eager-vs-compiled
reference noise is 2e-2..5e-2); compiled == eager for the new functions; loss of a small GPT identical to 4 digits.
time (/tmp/runs/t-b1, {"OPT_MB_GROUP": "2", "OPT_BLOCK": "1", "OPT_OPTIM_V2": "1", "OPT_FAST_LOSS": "1"}, NO coordinate-descent): windows 0.9038 / 0.9081 / 0.9092,
speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.129 (min-window ratio 1.128); cold compile only 70 s (was 506 s). check --quick: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items OK.
Profile (/tmp/runs/prof-b1, 912 ms/update): GEMM 474, FA3 112, my kernels ~220 (all near HBM roofline: cast_pair 3.5 TB/s, mlp_bwd_cast 3.3, nb1 3.9, mlp amax 4.3),
lm_head/loss Inductor kernels ~30 (compute-bound tanh/exp, one-hot scatter), optimizer window 49 ms (4-5 ms exposed tail waiting for the last all-gather), embeddings ~20, gaps ~18.
Full check #2 of this configuration started 15:32 (/tmp/runs/check-2).
2.7 hRound 8 — fused lm_head + softcap + cross-entropy (OPT_LOSS) and optimizer/loader tail (15:39 – 16:03)
Profile of OPT_BLOCK: the lm_head glue still cost ~27 ms (Inductor kernels, tanh/exp compute-bound, one-hot scatter). New Float8LMHeadLossFunction
(fp8_block.py): x quantisation + transposed copy, fp8 GEMM, one Triton pass over the logits (logsumexp without running max, target logit, and the *exact amax of the gradient*
per unit coefficient computed analytically from exp(t)*(1-tanh^2)/S, so the old gradient-amax pass disappears), backward = one cast kernel (recompute, e5m2 row-major + transposed), two fp8 GEMMs.
Test /tmp/mb/test_loss.py: loss identical to 6-7 digits, gradients 5e-4 vs compiled reference. time b2 = b1 + OPT_LOSS: 0.9011 s (1.136); after the amax fusion in the lse pass 0.8909 (1.149).
Tried and dropped: NCCL_PROTO=Simple (no change; standalone 906 MB all-gather is 1.8 ms but 2.4-4.4 ms in the step: contention/skew), OPT_MUON_CHUNK=12 (chunked Muon groups: 0.9035, worse),
FP8 GEMM merging of q/k/v (micro-benchmark: 3 x 228 us vs 667 us merged, rowwise-scaled merged 776 us -> nothing to gain; GEMMs run at 1.2-1.4 PFLOPs in isolation).
NB1 no longer reads the two residual tensors (x_in reconstructed from x1 and x0 for d lam_r; error is rounding noise averaged out in a 100M-element sum); OPT_ASYNC_LOADER=1, OPT_ADAMW_BEFORE_LAST=1.
b5 time (/tmp/runs/t-b5, mb2 + BLOCK + OPTIM_V2 + LOSS + ASYNC_LOADER + ADAMW_BEFORE_LAST): 0.8967 s (1.142); with the loss amax fusion (t-b6): windows 0.8877 / 0.8912 / 0.8938, 1.1494.
Full check #3 (/tmp/runs/check-3): PASS, N1, speedup 1.1469 (windows 0.8889 / 0.8925 / 0.8934; gate 3 d/sigma 0.14, 0.41, 0.52, 0.49, 0.42, 0.32). Merged into /submission (edd845e).
3.0 hRound 9 — per-step FP8 weight cache (OPT_FP8_CACHE) (16:05 – 16:22)
Weight quantisation (amax + cast + the _to_col_major copies) ran in every micro-batch (~8.4 ms/update plus ~1000 small kernels). Now one batched refresh per optimizer
step: pointer-table Triton kernels (_wamax_kernel, _wcast_kernel, one launch pair per weight shape) write fp8 row-major / transposed / inverse scale into per-module buffers;
MuonAdamW.post_step runs the refresh at the end of step() (before the judge's post-step hook, so the probe evaluation sees fresh weights). The Functions take the cached tensors
as extra inputs (_wcache), dgrad GEMMs use w8T.t(). time b8 (...OPT_FP8_CACHE=1): windows 0.8826 / 0.8861 / 0.8884, 1.1561 (b6 was 0.8909). Peak memory 86.6 GiB.
(Inductor schedules all wgrad GEMMs of a backward at its end; harmless.)
Full check #4 (/tmp/runs/check-4): PASS, N1, speedup 1.1543 (gate 3 d/sigma 0.14, 0.41, 0.52, 0.49, 0.42, 0.32). Merged into /submission.
Layer profile at K=2 (per layer-microbatch): forward 5.8 ms (GEMM 3.1, FA 0.5, own kernels 1.9), backward 9.8 ms (GEMM 3.1 dgrad + wgrad later, own kernels ~3.0): all own kernels within
10-20 % of the HBM copy roofline (4.2 TB/s measured), cast_pair tile sweep best 3.8 TB/s (current 3.76).
3.2 hRound 10 — launch-config tuning of the row kernels (16:23 – 16:32)
Micro-benchmark sweeps (/tmp/mb/row_bench.py, cast_bench.py, loss_bench.py) of tile/warp configs: every own kernel is within ~5-15 % of the measured HBM copy roofline (4.2 TB/s);
applied: mix_stats BM=4, add_norm BM=4, qkv_bwd BR=32/nw8, nb1 BM=1/nw4 (-3.5 ms): time 0.8822 s (1.1607). NCCL coalescing micro-benchmark: 14 x 100 MB RS 3.29 -> 2.57 ms, AG 3.08 -> 2.52 ms
in isolation (not applied: ~1 ms per step in the real run).
Full check #5 (/tmp/runs/check-5): PASS, N1, speedup 1.1589 (windows 0.8797 / 0.8840 / 0.8845; gate 3 d/sigma 0.16, 0.39, 0.42, 0.43, 0.42, 0.34). Merged into /submission.
3.6 hRound 11 — fp32 weight-gradient GEMMs (OPT_WGRAD_FP32) and dead ends (16:36 – 17:00)
Observation: during training both GPUs run at the 700 W SW power cap (SM clock 1440-1650 MHz vs 1980 max), which is why FP8 GEMMs average 1.2-1.3 PFLOPs vs 1.4 in
short micro-benchmarks and why larger M or other GEMM tricks do not help (efficiency saturates at M>=32768; q/k/v merging = nothing; side-stream overlap of GEMM with a
memory-bound kernel: 2-8 % of the shorter one, i.e. nothing).
torch._scaled_mm(..., out_dtype=torch.float32) works at the same speed: the weight-gradient GEMMs now write fp32 directly (parameters are fp32): no bf16 rounding of dW,
no convert kernels. time 0.8789 s (1.1651). Full check #6 (/tmp/runs/check-6): PASS, N1, speedup 1.1642 (gate 3 d/sigma 0.13, 0.40, 0.48, 0.41, 0.39, 0.32). Merged into /submission.
Dead ends (all measured with time, no change): OPT_MUON_BADDBMM (NS scale-and-add in baddbmm epilogues, 0.8828), NCCL_MIN_NCHANNELS=32 (0.8829), OPT_MUON_CHUNK=48/24 (0.8835/0.8839),
persistent reductions, NCCL_PROTO. Gap histogram per step: 7.2 ms launch gaps (4358 kernels, 1.65 us avg), 3.8 ms step-boundary gaps (waiting for reduce-scatter at the start of the optimizer,
CPU path after the judge's sync). Remaining small kernels: 162 fp32 grad-accumulation adds (2.5 ms), ~770 cuBLASLt-internal memsets, 442 amax zero-fills.
3.9 hRound 12 — Gram-space Newton-Schulz (OPT_MUON_GRAM): faster but REJECTED by gate 3 (17:05 – 17:17)
Idea: for the non-square Muon groups run the whole Polar-Express iteration on the small n x n Gram matrix (A_{k+1} = A_k Q_k^2, P_{k+1} = P_k Q_k, X_5 = X_0 P_5): same iteration in exact
arithmetic, 37 % fewer big-GEMM FLOPs. time 0.8643 s (1.1848, -14.6 ms, more than the FLOP count predicts), and on random Gaussian matrices the output singular values and the error
against an fp32 ground truth were as good as the reference's bf16 iteration (/tmp/mb/test_gram.py). But check (/tmp/runs/check-8): gate 3 INCORRECT (d/sigma = 1.9, 5.9, 3.8, 5.1, 5.0, 5.4):
in bf16 the Gram matrix squares the condition number, so the small singular directions of the (ill-conditioned) momentum matrices fall below the bf16 noise floor of A and are no longer amplified.
Not merged (kept off in the exp branch); /submission is unchanged (check-6/7: PASS 1.164).
4.4 hRound 13 — hybrid Gram Newton-Schulz, paired timing, library upgrade attempt (17:20 – 17:50)
OPT_MUON_GRAM_FROM=3 (first 3 NS iterations in X-space, the last 2 in Gram space; on ill-conditioned test matrices it is as accurate as the reference iteration:
error vs fp32 8.1e-2 vs the reference's 7.6e-2, singular values [0.084, 1.156] vs [0.085, 1.142]; GRAM_FROM=2 is already bad, full Gram 64 % error): time 0.8771 s (1.1675), only -1.8 ms
vs 0.8789 because the big saving of the full Gram variant came from the first three (ill-conditioned) iterations. Not merged (gain < noise, extra numerics risk).
time --paired of the submission (/tmp/runs/t-paired): 0.8800 s vs a fresh reference 1.0227 s => 1.1612 (frozen reference: 1.1636), i.e. the final evaluation should show ~1.16.
Upgrading cuBLAS 12.8 -> 12.9 in /opt/candidate-env was tried and abandoned: package download ~50 KB/s (a 600 MB wheel = hours); candidate env left unchanged (nvidia-cublas-cu12 <ip>).
Triton micro-benchmark of a triangular (syrk-style, mirrored) bf16 bmm for X X^T: bit-identical to cuBLAS, 369 us vs 455 us on [48,1536,1536] (-19 %); worth ~3-4 ms per step at best, not built.
5.2 hRound 14 — cuBLASLt algorithm tuning of the FP8 GEMMs (OPT_LT_GEMM) (17:55 – 18:35)
Profile (b14, 886 ms/update): nvjet FP8 GEMMs 475 ms (53 %), own Triton kernels 234, FA3 114, NCCL 25, other 39. Hotspot class: "missed fast path" inside the GEMMs: torch._scaled_mm takes the FIRST algorithm
of the cuBLASLt heuristic on every call (and queries the heuristic every call).  A ctypes cuBLASLt harness (/tmp/mb/lt.py, lt_bench.py, lt_scan.py, lt_retune.py) showed:
  * algo 0 of the heuristic list is bit-identical to torch._scaled_mm (all 12 shapes of the model); every candidate algorithm without split-K produced bit-identical outputs too
    (same K order / promotion interval), and all are deterministic -> the tuned table costs NO numerics (GEMM outputs are bitwise those of torch._scaled_mm);
  * the fast-accumulation forward GEMMs have much better algorithms (isolated, sustained: c_fc fwd -20 %, lm_head fwd -17..-23 %, c_proj fwd -5 %, 1536x1536 fwd -10..-19 %); the non-fast-accum
    backward GEMMs (dgrad/wgrad, e5m2 x e4m3) are already at the best algorithm (heuristic default wins or is within 1 % when ranked under a mixed GEMM + memory-bound load);
  * sustained-load rankings are misleading (the real step interleaves memory-bound kernels, so clocks are higher): the final ranking (lt_retune.py) times each GEMM with a memory-bound filler in
    between, which reproduces the in-situ kernel durations (fc fwd 899 -> 813 us, 1536 fwd 228 -> 208 us in the layer trace).
Change: nanochat/lt_gemm.py (custom op nanochat_opt::scaled_mm, ctypes cublasLtMatmul with a per-shape cached descriptor/algorithm, shared 32 MiB workspace, same fp32 scales / fast-accum flag; falls back to the heuristic's first
algorithm = torch's choice if a table entry is rejected), table nanochat/lt_algos.json (4 forward entries: 65536x1536x1536, x6144x1536, x1536x6144, x32768x1536), all call sites in fp8_block.py go through lt_mm
(OPT_LT_GEMM=0 -> torch._scaled_mm unchanged).  time (/tmp/runs/t-b20): 0.8637 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.1856 (b14: 0.8789 / 1.1651), kernel-class totals nvjet 475 -> 464 ms in a profile (+ the rest slightly slower: power/clock state).
Dead ends found on the way (all measured): cuBLASLt AMAX_D_POINTER is rejected for bf16 outputs (INVALID_VALUE: FP8 outputs only), so the relu(h) amax cannot come from the c_fc epilogue (RELU epilogue itself works but is slower);
beta=1 residual-add epilogue works (bf16 C -> D) but costs +43 us on the 65536x1536x1536 GEMM (C read not overlapped) = no net gain over the add_norm kernel it would replace; fp32 beta=1 accumulation works (would save the 162 grad-add kernels, ~1 ms,
needs autograd plumbing: not done).
Full check #9 (/tmp/runs/check-9, tree 405b111 + /tmp/sw/b19.json = the new /submission/switches.json): PASS, N1, speedup 1.1853 (windows 0.8601 / 0.8641 / 0.8658 s, ratios 1.1853 / 1.1876 / 1.1855;
gate 3 d/sigma 0.13 0.40 0.48 0.41 0.39 0.32 = exactly the numbers of check-6/7: the tuned GEMMs are bitwise neutral). Merged into /submission (opt @ 405b111), switches.json now has OPT_LT_GEMM=1.
5.7 hRound 15 — step-boundary and gradient-accumulation overheads (18:45 – 19:05)
Profile of the LT config (b19: 885.9 ms kernel time/update; /tmp/runs/prof-b19): the optimizer window is 46 ms, compute stream busy 40 ms; at its start the compute stream waits for the first reduce-scatter
(1.3 ms), at the end the all-gathers / copy-back / FP8 cache refresh (3.7 ms) follow, and at the step boundary the GPU is idle for 2.3 ms (CPU: model.zero_grad 1.05 ms [175 frees], .item/sync/logging 0.2 ms, Dynamo + AOT + Inductor
entry 0.75 ms).  162 autograd grad += g kernels (2.8 ms with launch gaps) + 7 stack copies (2.2 ms) are executed on the critical path.
Changes (both bitwise neutral, each behind a switch):
  * OPT_FREE_GRADS=1 (optim.py): the Muon-group .grad tensors are released right after torch.stack(..., out=) and the big AdamW grads right after their reduce-scatter launch (the allocator keeps them until the collective is done),
    so zero_grad() finds (almost) nothing to free: zero_grad 1050 -> 550 us -> ~100 us of CPU time in the GPU-idle gap.  time /tmp/runs/t-b22: 0.8627 s (1.1870; b20 0.8637).
  * OPT_SUMSTACK=1 (optim.py _sum_stack Triton kernel + base_train.py stash): after the first micro-batch group's backward p.grad of the Muon params is stashed in p._g1; the second group's backward therefore creates fresh grads
    (no autograd accumulation kernels) and the optimizer writes stack[i] = g1[i] + g2[i] in one pass (the same fp32 sum). Only for exactly 2 accumulation steps; falls back to autograd accumulation otherwise.
    time /tmp/runs/t-b23: 0.8600 s (1.1907).  Profile (/tmp/runs/prof-b23): 871 ms kernel time/update; the CUDAFunctor_add<float> kernels are gone, _sum_stack_kernel 2.2 ms.
Full check #10 (/tmp/runs/check-10, tree 58a6dd3 + /tmp/sw/b23.json = the new /submission/switches.json): PASS, N1, speedup 1.1881 (windows 0.8577 / 0.8622 / 0.8639 s; gate 3 d/sigma 0.13 0.40 0.48 0.41 0.39 0.32, identical to check-9).
Findings without a change: (i) bf16 Newton-Schulz bmm run at 0.72-0.76 PFLOPs (near the power-capped bf16 peak); the best of the 8 heuristic algorithms is only 2-3 % faster (batched Lt harness /tmp/mb/ltb*.py): no change;
(ii) fp32 tanh variants for the loss kernels (rational / libdevice) are slower than the current exp-based form; (iii) triton_poi_fused_add_view_14 (1.6 ms per group) is the 25-way sum of the 24 per-layer dx0 contributions (x0 skip connections):
inherent to the dataflow (writes in nb1 + reads here ~10 GB per group); (iv) the judge's check takes only ~6 minutes (timing 1.5 + record 1 + trajectory 3.5), not 40.
6.0 hRound 16 — amax hand-over and workspace-free GEMMs (19:05 – 19:25)
Profile of b23 (871 ms kernel time/update, /tmp/runs/prof-b23): per layer-group backward _amax_kernel (57 us) recomputes max|g_m| although the nb1 kernel of the next block's backward
already produced max|dx_in| (the same tensor); 770 Memset (Device) kernels (one before every nvjet GEMM, the 4-byte workspace of the dynamic-scheduler kernels) cost ~2.5 us each with the launch gap.
  * OPT_AMAX_CARRIER=1 (fp8_block.py, gpt.py): Post.forward returns a third dummy scalar (carrier) that is passed to the next Pre.forward; Pre.backward returns nb1's amax as the gradient of the carrier, so
    Post.backward gets it as g_aux (skipped at the backout layer, which has a second consumer of (x2, m); the last block recomputes). Bitwise identical. time (/tmp/runs/t-b24): 0.8583 s (1.1931).
    Full check #11 (/tmp/runs/check-11): PASS N1 1.1917, gate 3 d/sigma unchanged.
  * OPT_LT_WS0=1 (lt_gemm.py): GEMMs without a table entry (the backward ones) ask the heuristic with MAX_WORKSPACE_BYTES=0, which returns the same tile/cluster algorithm as the static-scheduler variant
    ..._v_ssched_bz_... (same outputs bit for bit): no workspace, no memset. time (/tmp/runs/t-b25): 0.8565 s (1.1956). Full check #12 (/tmp/runs/check-12): PASS N1 1.1927 (windows 0.8543 / 0.8584 / 0.8606 s,
    gate 3 d/sigma 0.13 0.40 0.48 0.41 0.39 0.32). Merged (opt @ cherry-pick of b25), switches.json = /tmp/sw/b25.json.
Findings without a change: the tuned forward algorithms need the 4-byte workspace (their ws=0 variants are not among the enumerated configurations), 0.7 ms of memsets remain; relu2/mlp_bwd amax passes cannot come from GEMM epilogues.
6.3 hRound 17 — weight-amax launch config, parameters as views of stacked Muon buffers (19:25 – 19:45)
Profile (b23): _wamax_kernel 2.17 ms/step (1.5 TB/s on the 9.4M-element matrices: only 8 blocks per matrix, 192 CTAs), _wcast_kernel 1.65 ms (3.4 TB/s, already ~80 % of the roofline), the optimizer copies around the Muon stacks
(torch.stack(owned_params) 0.77 ms + foreach copy-back 1.8 ms, the latter partly on the critical tail of the step after the last all-gather).
  * wamax: 128 blocks x (2 x 8 KB loads in flight): 1.85 -> 0.71 ms per refresh in isolation (/tmp/mb/wamax_bench.py), bitwise identical (max); time 0.8561 s (1.1961), within noise of 0.8565.
  * OPT_PSTACK=1 (optim.py make_param_stacks, base_train.py, fp8_block.py rebuild_fp8_cache_tables): after the optimizer is created every evenly shardable fp32 Muon group is moved into one persistent [n, r, c] buffer and
    p.data re-pointed at its rows; the Newton-Schulz update runs in place on this rank's rows and the all-gather is in place (all_gather_into_tensor(stack, my_rows)), so the stack-owned copy and the copy-back are gone;
    parameters are re-synchronised if .data was re-assigned. time /tmp/runs/t-b27: 0.8539 s (1.1992), peak memory 85.3 GiB (-1.3).
    Full check #13 (/tmp/runs/check-13): PASS N1 1.1972 (windows 0.8516 / 0.8555 / 0.8553 s; gate 3 d/sigma 0.13 0.40 0.48 0.41 0.39 0.32, unchanged). Merged; switches.json = /tmp/sw/b27.json.
Dead end: CUDA graphs via torch.compile(mode="reduce-overhead") (dev run, OPT_CUDAGRAPHS in the exp tree): SIGSEGV inside the FA3 forward during cudagraph_trees run_eager/partition_0 (also without OPT_LT_GEMM);
not pursued (~3-4 ms potential, and a skipped-cudagraph log would invalidate the timing).
6.6 hRound 18 — early FP8 cache refresh (19:46 – 19:55)
Profile of the current tree (b27, /tmp/runs/prof-b27, 864.5 ms kernel time/update): the compute stream idles 1.75 ms waiting for the last all-gather (the (6144,1536) Muon group, 906 MB) and then runs the FP8 weight cache refresh (2.4 ms).
OPT_EARLY_REFRESH=1: MuonAdamW._finish_gathers calls group_post_step(shape) after the (stream-level) wait of each Muon group's gather, so the refresh of the early groups (1536x1536, 1536x6144) is enqueued before the wait for the last gather and runs
while it is in flight (refresh_fp8_cache(model, only_shape=...), remaining shapes - last group, lm_head - in post_step). Bitwise identical. Profile: window tail 1.8 ms shorter; time 0.8537 (noise level 0.5 ms);
full check #14 (/tmp/runs/check-14): PASS N1 1.1997 (windows 0.8498 / 0.8542 / 0.8538 vs check-13 0.8516 / 0.8555 / 0.8553; gate 3 unchanged). Merged; switches.json = /tmp/sw/b28.json.
Measurements without a change: (i) the tuned forward GEMMs also run without workspace (ssched variant, no memset, bitwise equal) but are 0-1.7 % slower (kept with workspace); (ii) cuBLASLt FP8 supports only the TN layout on this GPU
(NT/NN: NOT_SUPPORTED), so the transposed fp8 copies for the weight-gradient GEMMs cannot be avoided; (iii) the weight cast kernel is already at ~3.4 TB/s; (iv) time differences below ~1 ms are not resolvable (use check windows).
7.0 hRound 19 — triangular syrk kernels for the Newton-Schulz Gram matrices (OPT_MUON_SYRK) (20:05 – 20:25)
Profile (b28): the Muon bf16 bmm (nvjet_tst_192x192_64x3/4 NNN/TNN/NTN, 23.6 ms/step) run at 0.72-0.76 PFLOPs (near the power-capped bf16 peak); per NS iteration X X^T and A A (A = X X^T, symmetric; B = b A + c A A symmetric) are half redundant,
and the pointwise b*A + c*(A@A) costs another 1.9 ms. nanochat/muon_syrk.py: one Triton kernel (128x128 tiles, BK 64, 8 warps, 4 stages) computes only the 54 % upper-triangular tiles of C = A_op A_op^T and stores
the off-diagonal tiles a second time transposed; EPI 1 evaluates alpha*Ain + beta*acc from the fp32 accumulator, i.e. B = b A + c A A in one kernel. Unit test (/tmp/mb/test_syrk.py): X X^T is bit-identical to cuBLAS bmm for
all three Muon shapes ([48,1536,1536], wide [12,1536,6144], tall [12,6144,1536]), exactly symmetric; 453 -> 340 us; B: rel. error vs fp32 1.7e-3 (reference-style bf16 expression 2.3e-3), 836 -> 373 us.
Integrated in muon_step_fused (OPT_MUON_SYRK=1, only for groups with min dim % 128 == 0, bf16; the 12x12 ve_gate group keeps the old path). Full check #16 (/tmp/runs/check-16): PASS N1 1.2065
(windows 0.8444 / 0.8490 / 0.8507 vs 0.8497 / 0.8541 / 0.8542 without = -4.9 ms; gate 3 d/sigma 0.16 0.48 0.54 0.45 0.38 0.33). Merged; switches.json = /tmp/sw/b29.json.
No gain (check-17, not merged): OPT_MUON_XUPD (X = a X + B X as one baddbmm epilogue instead of GEMM + pointwise): windows 0.8459 / 0.8497 / 0.8498 (same as without).
7.5 hRound 20 — measurements without a change (20:27 – 20:55)
(i) Inductor size_asserts/alignment_asserts/scalar_asserts off (OPT_INDUCTOR_CFG): the profile showed a 0.6-1.2 ms shorter step-boundary gap, but 3 interleaved time runs each gave 0.8480-0.8486 (asserts on) vs 0.8482-0.8488 (off): no gain (profile CPU overheads are inflated).
(ii) NCCL: the Muon bmm run 25-30 % slower while an all-gather overlaps (484 -> 606-640 us; a pure HBM copy on a side stream: 1.85x); NCCL_MAX_NCHANNELS=4/8 interferes less in isolation (528 us) but the real step becomes 0.8793 / 0.8601 s
(exposed communication): the default channel count stays; cublas SM-count targets (128/120 SMs) do not reduce the interference.
(iii) time noise is ~0.3 ms between identical runs (check windows ~1 ms).
7.9 hRound 21 — syrk launch config (21:00 – 21:15)
Sweep (/tmp/mb/syrk_sweep.py): BT=128, BK=64, 8 warps, 3 stages is 4-6 % faster than 4 stages (325 vs 340 us [48,1536,1536]; 297 vs 310 us [12,1536,6144]); outputs unchanged (bitwise equal to cuBLAS, unit test re-run);
interleaved time runs 0.8478 / 0.8477 vs 0.8480 / 0.8487 s. Committed d837aec; check-20 on /submission: PASS N1 1.2061 (same within noise). 400-step soak test (dev run, final config): loss 10.40 -> 3.42, step time 850 -> 839 ms, no warnings.
8.3 hRound 22 — launch-config re-tuning (21:15 – 21:40)
Re-swept in isolation the kernels that were not covered by the round-10 sweeps (mlp_bwd_cast lives in fp8_fused.py) and the single-pass amax kernels (more bytes in flight, as for the weight amax): mlp_bwd_cast (64,128,8 warps) -3.4 %, mlp_bwd_amax (2048x16, 8 warps) -1.7 %,
relu2_amax (2048x8, 8 warps) -4.7 %, amax (2048x8, 8 warps) -7 %, relu2_cast (2048, 4 warps) -3.6 %; cast_pair, weight cast, sum_stack, the row kernels (mix_stats/nb1/add_norm/norm_bwd/qkv_post/qkv_bwd) are already at their best config.
Interleaved time runs: 0.8458 / 0.8457 vs 0.8485 / 0.8478 s. Full check #21 (/tmp/runs/check-21): PASS N1 1.2094 (windows 0.8424 / 0.8469 / 0.8487; gate 3 unchanged). Bitwise identical changes; committed 02ab555.
Not adopted: Inductor coordinate_descent_tuning=1 for the remaining Inductor kernels (embedding etc.): 0.8457 / 0.8446 vs 0.8471 / 0.8464 s (-1.6 ms, +45 s startup), but it times kernel configs at compile time, which conflicts with the judge's
"first configuration, no timing" rule in deterministic mode (our base_train would re-enable it after the judge's settings): not worth the risk.
8.7 hRound 23 — sorted-segment gradient of the value-embedding tables (OPT_EMBED_SEG) (21:45 – 22:10)
Profile (b28/b29): the embedding backward kernels cost 7.4 ms per step for the 12 value-embedding tables x 2 groups: Inductor's embedding_dense_backward = fp32 zero-fill [V, D] (45 us) + fp32 atomic scatter of every token row (209 us) +
fp32 -> bf16 convert (70 us) = 324 us per table and group. Real token batches (/tmp/emb/get_idx.py): 65536 tokens, 10285 distinct ids, max count 2332, 89 ids with > 64 rows covering 40 % of the rows.
nanochat/embed_seg.py: embed_meta (once per forward, shared by the 12 tables, 183 us GPU): stable sort of the ids, chunks of <= 64 rows of one token, static-shape metadata (row0 / partial slots / heavy-token lists, unique-target
scatters, no host sync); _seg_k1 (one program per chunk, rows gathered by the sort permutation, fp32 accumulation, bf16 store for single-chunk tokens, fp32 partial otherwise) and _seg_k2 (partials of the heavy tokens in fixed order);
EmbedSegFunction (forward F.embedding, backward = the two kernels), 130 us per table. Unit test (/tmp/emb/test_seg.py): gradient bit-identical to an fp32-accumulated index_add -> bf16 reference, run-to-run deterministic (also compiled);
the stock eager bf16 backward differs from that reference by up to 2e-3 (atomics order). time /tmp/runs/te-new-*: 0.8432 / 0.8435 s vs 0.8460 / 0.8466 s. Full check #22 (/tmp/runs/check-22): PASS N1 1.2151
(windows 0.8390 / 0.8434 / 0.8445; gate 3 d/sigma 0.19 0.49 0.56 0.51 0.40 0.33). Merged (OPT_EMBED_SEG in switches.json = /tmp/sw/b34.json).
Remaining embedding-related cost: zero-fill of the bf16 table (24 x ~30 us), the two groups' bf16 table grads are still added by autograd (13 x 73 us), wte backward is fused with the norm backward by Inductor.
9.9 hRound 24 — retained block-input gradients for the x0 gradient (OPT_DX0_RETAIN) (22:20 – 23:20)
Profile (post-EMBED_SEG, 848.5 ms kernel time/update, /tmp/runs/pf): Inductor's 25-way add triton_poi_fused_add_view (the 24 per-block dx0_i = lam_0_i * dx1_i tensors, 1.58 ms x 2) is the largest Inductor kernel, and nb1 writes
24 x 201 MB of dx0_i per group. Since dx_in_i = lam_r_i * dx1_i is produced and consumed anyway, dx0 = sum_i (lam_0_i / lam_r_i) * dx_in_i. OPT_DX0_RETAIN=1 (fp8_block.py): nb1(write_dx0=False) skips the dx0_i store; Pre.backward
appends (layer, dx_in) to a module-level list (cleared at the last block, so it is filled while the backward is traced last block first), block 0 calls dx0_sum (Triton kernel with a pointer table, BLOCK 1024 / 8 warps / no eviction hint:
1.33 ms, 3.77 TB/s, 2.9 TB/s with my first config) and returns the total as the x0 gradient, the other blocks return None.
Debugging note: the first compiled run "hung" for > 10 min: Inductor's *implicit fallback* path formats the arguments of an unknown custom op eagerly (log.info("Creating implicit fallback for:\n%s", operator_str(...))) and the 24 deep IR
arguments make that string astronomically large; make_fallback(torch.ops.nanochat_opt.dx0_sum.default) registered at import skips it (watchdog faulthandler.dump_traceback_later found it).
Validation: small-GPT model test (/tmp/mb/test_model_dx0.py, eager + compiled): losses identical (10.547201 compiled), gradients of flag-on vs flag-off within the run-to-run noise of the flag-off baseline (layer weights ~1.8e-2,
wte 4e-3, lambdas 2e-3, all of it FA3 dq-atomics noise: flag0 vs flag0 gives the same numbers). time 0.8404 / 0.8416 s vs 0.8430 / 0.8433 s; full check #23 (/tmp/runs/check-23): PASS N1 1.2164 (windows 0.8381 / 0.8424 / 0.8438;
gate 3 d/sigma 0.18 0.49 0.54 0.45 0.40 0.27). nb1 -1.2 ms (less than the 2.7 ms the traffic suggested), sum kernel -0.4 ms vs Inductor's. Merged; switches.json = /tmp/sw/b35.json.
↑ NanoChat