Kimi k3.1-pro 1.03×

Harness: Claude Code · switches: NANOCHAT_OPT_COMPILED_WEIGHT_CACHE=1 TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1

Judged
1.03×
Tier
N1
Self-best
1.03×
Rounds
41
Hours
10.0
API cost
$24.4
Input tokens · 99.1% cached
100 M
Output tokens
0.3 M
Requests
714
Micro-batch regrouping 4×16 → 2×32
✗ not in the log
Scope of hand-written kernels replacing Inductor glue
✗ native transpose op 0.688, custom cross-entropy backward 1.013 (slower when stacked on 1.025), both reverted
Per-shape cuBLASLt algorithm selection
✗ (only tried workspace and computing backward GEMMs transposed, the latter 0.838)
FP8 weights quantized once per step
✓ NANOCHAT_OPT_COMPILED_WEIGHT_CACHE, 1.008
Fast accum on backward GEMMs
tried, reverted (all on −4 to −16σ; weight grads only −3.08σ)
Other main levers
Inductor coordinate-descent tuning (alone 1.015, both combined 1.025)
Raw work log41 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — reference profile and FP8 weight-cache experiment
- Start: 2026-11-07 02:05 UTC; end: 02:24 UTC. GPU work was split into a reference profile (02:05:54–02:08:36), a failed first candidate run (02:14:15–02:17:54), and the corrected candidate run (02:19:18–02:23:59).
- GPU preflight/postflight: both Hopper GPUs returned to 0 MiB and 0%; /tmp has ample free space.
- Frozen reference timing: [1.0117, 1.0151, 1.0142] s/update, spread 0.0034.
- Reference profile: /tmp/r1-profile-ref/profile.json (updates 12–13, rank 0, instrumented; not used as a timing result). Startup 137.6 s; peak allocation 55.94 GiB; FA3 active; no other optimizer steps. Top CUDA shares over two profiled updates: FP8 _scaled_mm 865.8 ms / 42.65%; compiled forward graph 1.317 s / 64.87% (overlapping accounting); FlashAttention backward 168.1 ms / 8.28%; largest FP8 quantization/layout kernel 129.5 ms / 6.38%; optimizer 83.6 ms / 4.12%; NCCL reduce-scatter and all-gather each about 23 ms / 1.14–1.16%. The target class was FP8 quantization/layout traffic around the dominant GEMMs.
- Change tried behind NANOCHAT_OPT_FP8_WEIGHT_CACHE: cache each FP8 weight, inverse scale, and column-major backward copy across four accumulation micro-batches; invalidate after each optimizer step. This was intended as N0 data reuse, but the measured result was N1 because the custom op's eager quantization did not reproduce all Inductor quantization bits.
- First attempt (/tmp/r1-quick, /tmp/r1-time): ERROR from WeakKeyDictionary invoking elementwise tensor equality. Fixed with identity-keyed weak references and reran in fresh directories.
- Corrected result: check --quick at /tmp/r1b-quick/check.json = NOT_BITWISE; all exact items passed, first differing update 0. time at /tmp/r1b-time/time.json = ok; windows [1.0081, 1.0162, 1.0136] s/update, mean 1.0126 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0011. Peak allocation 57.32 GiB. No invalid-run signatures.
- Conclusion: no resolved gain and no N0 benefit; revert the experiment and close this formulation of weight caching. The change and its revert are committed separately.
0.4 hRound 2 — NCCL protocol screening
- Start: 2026-11-07 02:27 UTC.
- Profile basis: Round 1 shows optimizer collectives using ncclDevKernel_{AllGather,ReduceScatter}_RING_LL; optimizer CUDA time is 4.12%, with communication also appearing outside that rollup. Low-latency protocol on large tensors is a configuration/backend hotspot.
- Candidate: unchanged upstream tree with /tmp/nccl-simple.json = {"environment":{"NCCL_PROTO":"Simple"}}. Submission switches remain empty while screening.
- Planned measurements: fresh check --quick and time output directories /tmp/r2-simple-quick and /tmp/r2-simple-time; detached log /tmp/r2-simple.log.
- End: 02:35 UTC. check --quick = PASS, tier N0 (/tmp/r2-simple-quick/check.json). time = ok, windows [1.0122, 1.0154, 1.0140] s/update, mean 1.0139 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9998 (/tmp/r2-simple-time/time.json). No tree change or commit was needed. Conclusion: no gain; do not enable the setting.
0.6 hRound 3 — Inductor coordinate-descent tuning
- Start: 2026-11-07 02:36 UTC.
- Profile basis: the largest non-GEMM kernel is triton_poi_fused__scaled_mm__to_copy_clamp_clone_mul_pow_reciprocal_relu_t_threshold_backward_view_12, 129.535 ms over two updates (6.38%, 192 calls). Its launch grid is [96, 512, 1], with 8 KiB shared memory, matching the tiled MLP-backward activation/FP8/transpose region. Other RMS/QK/FP8 Triton kernels add substantial memory/layout time.
- Candidate: unchanged tree with TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1 in /tmp/inductor-cdt.json; this screens existing compiler configurations before any custom kernel work.
- Planned outputs: /tmp/r3-cdt-quick, /tmp/r3-cdt-time, log /tmp/r3-cdt.log.
- End: 02:56 UTC. Quick check NOT_BITWISE (exact items pass; first difference update 0). Timing ok: windows [0.9964, 0.9997, 1.0005] s/update, mean 0.9989 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0148; worst-window ratio about 1.0137, below the 1.02 benefit gate. Cold startup rose to 423.3 s; run wall 460.0 s. No invalid-run signatures. Keep disabled as a standalone candidate; it may be revisited only as part of a faster stack.
0.9 hRound 4 — full Inductor max-autotune screen
- Start: 2026-11-07 02:58 UTC.
- Profile/hotspot: same compiler-configuration class as Round 3; test the remaining standard backend setting once rather than writing a custom kernel prematurely.
- Candidate: unchanged tree with TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE=1 in /tmp/inductor-maxauto.json. Run time first at /tmp/r4-maxauto-time; run quick correctness only if the screening gain justifies a candidate.
- Detached log: /tmp/r4-maxauto.log.
- End: 03:06 UTC. time ok at /tmp/r4-maxauto-time/time.json: windows [1.0070, 1.0124, 1.0123] s/update, mean 1.0106 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0031. Cold startup 408.8 s. No quick check was run because the candidate is rejected on benefit. Full max-autotune is closed.
1.0 hRound 5 — stock PyTorch library backend
- Start: 2026-11-07 03:07 UTC.
- Profile basis: FP8 _scaled_mm is 42.65% of reference CUDA time and Inductor memory/layout kernels are the next large class. A stock library upgrade is the remaining L1 backend lever before custom kernels.
- Action: install PyPI torch==2.14.1 and its required dependencies into writable /opt/candidate-env; leave /opt/nanochat-env and the source tree untouched. Verify FA3 loading and judge execution, then time with empty switches at /tmp/r5-torch214-time.
- The submission remains upstream with empty switches unless measured evidence supports a change.
- End: 03:20 UTC. Installation aborted: after about 11 minutes only 31 MB of the 554.6 MB wheel had downloaded. The process was terminated; /opt/candidate-env still resolves torch 2.9.1+cu128 and triton 3.5.1. No GPU run, source change, or commit resulted. Library-upgrade direction closed for this connection.
1.4 hRound 6 — grouped value-embedding AdamW communication
- Start: 2026-11-07 03:22 UTC.
- Profile basis: 18 reduce-scatters and 18 all-gathers per update; the 12 equal-shaped value embeddings are separate collectives despite sharing one AdamW group. Their individual records show 50,331,648 input / 25,165,824 output bf16 elements per reduce. This is a communication batching opportunity.
- Change behind NANOCHAT_OPT_GROUP_ADAMW_COMM: pack the reference row shards into one reduce-scatter and one all-gather for same-shaped multi-parameter AdamW groups. Per-parameter row ownership, state shapes/dtypes, hyperparameters, and adamw_step_fused calls are unchanged; added operations are copies only. Expected tier N1 because collective shapes may change reduction bits.
- Screening config /tmp/group-adamw.json; outputs /tmp/r6-group-quick, /tmp/r6-group-time, log /tmp/r6-group.log.
- End: 03:31 UTC. Quick check PASS, tier N0 (all exact items and all parameter hashes match). Timing ok: windows [1.0115, 1.0188, 1.0142] s/update, mean 1.0148 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9989. Peak allocation 56.50 GiB. Packing copies cost more than the saved collective launches; revert and close this formulation. The change and revert are committed separately.
1.5 hRound 7 — Muon polar-update GEMM epilogues
- Start: 2026-11-07 03:33 UTC.
- Profile basis: Optimizer.step is 83.626 ms over two profiled updates (4.12%); aten::bmm is 41.904 ms (2.06%), with additional scalar/mul/add kernels around the batched polar iteration.
- Candidate: in muon_step_fused, express b * A + c * (A @ A) and a * X + ... @ X as torch.baddbmm epilogues. Keep the same coefficients, five iterations, shapes, dtypes, and update formula. Intended N1 (library epilogue rounding/order may differ), behind NANOCHAT_OPT_MUON_BADDBMM.
- End: 03:39 UTC. Quick check NOT_BITWISE (exact items pass, first difference update 0). Timing ok at /tmp/r7-muon-time/time.json: windows [1.0133, 1.0185, 1.0144] s/update, mean 1.0154 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9983. Revert; no statistical gate is justified.
1.6 hRound 8 — shared Q/K/V FP8 input quantization and layout
- Start: 2026-11-07 03:40 UTC.
- Profile basis: FP8 _scaled_mm dominates, but the surrounding quantization/transposition kernels are the addressable overhead. Each attention layer currently quantizes the identical input three times for Q/K/V and transposes the identical saved FP8 input three times in their backward passes. The same weights and their separate tensorwise scales remain unchanged.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_SHARED_QKV_FP8: one custom autograd call computes input FP8/scale once and its column-major backward layout once, reuses them for the three existing _scaled_mm operations, and returns separate Q/K/V weight gradients. Model parameter names/shapes and optimizer groups remain unchanged. Expected N1 from backward accumulation/kernel scheduling; quick check determines the tier.
- Unit check on CUDA: all three forward outputs and weight gradients were bitwise equal to separate reference calls; accumulated input gradient differed as expected from BF16 addition ordering.
- End: 03:49 UTC. Quick check NOT_BITWISE (exact items pass; first differing update 1). Timing ok at /tmp/r8-qkv-time/time.json: windows [1.0115, 1.0171, 1.0115] s/update, mean 1.0134 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0003. No gain: compiler CSE already obtains the useful sharing. Revert and close.
1.8 hRound 9 — profile the best measured compiler variant
- Start: 2026-11-07 03:50 UTC.
- Action: after reverting Round 8, profile the unchanged tree with TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1 at updates 12–13. Compare its kernel accounting to the Round 1 reference before choosing another rewrite.
- Output: /tmp/r9-cdt-profile; detached log /tmp/r9-cdt-profile.log.
- End: 03:59 UTC. Profile ok; total self CUDA 1.993 s versus 2.030 s reference over two updates. Tuned forward 1.301 s versus 1.317 s; tuned backward 581.6 ms versus 606.6 ms. Largest MLP FP8/transpose kernel 124.748 ms versus 129.535 ms; its tuned launch is grid [192,512,1], block 128, 4 KiB shared memory, 50% occupancy. FP8 GEMMs and FA3 are unchanged within noise. This profile is diagnostic only, not a new timing score.
1.9 hRound 10 — native FP8 transpose/copy path
- Start: 2026-11-07 04:00 UTC.
- Hotspot: the remaining 124.748 ms/two-update MLP-backward FP8/transpose kernel and related layout kernels.
- Change behind NANOCHAT_OPT_NATIVE_FP8_TRANSPOSE: route FP8 row/column-major copies through an opaque custom op calling PyTorch's native .t().contiguous() implementation, rather than letting Inductor fuse all transposes into its current tiled kernels. Same values and layout, expected N0; possible fusion loss is what the judge timing will measure.
- Outputs: /tmp/r10-transpose-quick, /tmp/r10-transpose-time, log /tmp/r10-transpose.log.
- End: 04:07 UTC. Quick check NOT_BITWISE (exact items pass). Timing ok: windows [1.4708, 1.4753, 1.4753] s/update, mean 1.4738 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.6878. Peak allocation rose to 63.01 GiB. Native copies break essential Inductor fusion; revert and close.
2.1 hRound 11 — pointwise-only Inductor autotuning
- Start: 2026-11-07 04:09 UTC.
- Configuration inspection: full max-autotune also tunes GEMMs and was slower, while coordinate descent improved pointwise/reduction/layout kernels. TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1 isolates the useful autotuning class; related controls include coordinate search radius, all-direction search, loop ordering, and permute fusion if this screen fails.
- Candidate: unchanged upstream with /tmp/inductor-pointwise.json. Run time at /tmp/r11-pointwise-time; quick correctness only if benefit justifies it. Log /tmp/r11-pointwise.log.
- End: 04:13 UTC. Timing ok: windows [1.0077, 1.0150, 1.0103] s/update, mean 1.0110 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0027. Rejected on benefit; no quick check or source commit.
2.1 hRound 12 — deeper coordinate-descent search
- Start: 2026-11-07 04:14 UTC.
- Candidate: TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1, TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_SEARCH_RADIUS=2, and TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_CHECK_ALL_DIRECTIONS=1 in /tmp/inductor-cdt-deep.json. This expands only the tuning method that produced the best Round 3 result.
- Run time at /tmp/r12-cdt-deep-time; quick correctness if the measured benefit justifies it. Detached log /tmp/r12-cdt-deep.log.
- End: 04:46 UTC. After 31 minutes the run was still in cold compilation and had not reached update 0. Stopped the bench and all orphaned torchrun/worker process groups; both GPUs returned to 0 MiB. No timing record, quick check, or source change. The deep radius/all-direction configuration is abandoned as too expensive.
2.7 hRound 13 — generated-code inspection for MLP backward
- Start: 2026-11-07 04:47 UTC.
- Action: run the judge profiler on upstream with TORCH_LOGS=output_code, then inspect the actual generated Triton for ...threshold_backward_view_12 (the 6.26–6.38% MLP FP8/transpose hotspot). This is diagnostic only, not a timing comparison.
- Outputs: /tmp/r13-output-code, log /tmp/r13-output-code.log.
- End: 04:56 UTC. Profile ok (04:47:04–04:49:42); both GPUs idle afterward. Generated source at log lines 29979–30047 shows a 32768×6144 tile per MLP/micro-batch: two BF16 loads (the c_fc preactivation and incoming gradient), two scalar loads, and three FP8 stores. It recomputes ReLU² for the transposed saved activation and ReLU² backward for row- and transposed-gradient layouts. Thus the kernel moves 11 bytes/element, in addition to its separate abs-max reduction (another two BF16 reads). The transposed stores are real layout requirements of the two backward FP8 GEMMs; Round 10 already showed that splitting them into native copies is much slower.
- Decision: preserve the fusion. First screen the larger 42.65% FP8 GEMM class through cuBLASLt workspace configuration; return to a custom tiled/layout kernel only if the library path does not yield a benefit.
2.9 hRound 14 — larger cuBLASLt workspace for FP8 GEMMs
- Start: 2026-11-07 05:00 UTC.
- Profile basis: FP8 _scaled_mm remains 42.65% of reference CUDA time; its nvjet kernels are the three largest entries in the tuned profile. The generated-code inspection confirms the adjacent pointwise/layout work is already fused and memory-bound, so the GEMM backend is the larger target.
- Candidate: unchanged tree with CUBLASLT_WORKSPACE_SIZE=32768 (KiB) in /tmp/cublaslt-32m.json, expanding algorithm workspace without changing the model, precision, or source. Time at /tmp/r14-cublaslt-time; quick exactness check if the timing gain justifies it. Detached log /tmp/r14-cublaslt.log.
- End: 05:04 UTC. Timing ok: windows [1.0102, 1.0185, 1.0176] s/update, mean 1.0154 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9983. Startup 138.1 s, peak allocation 56.00 GiB, no invalid-run signatures; both GPUs idle afterward. No quick check was needed because the candidate is rejected on benefit. Larger workspace did not improve nvjet algorithm selection/performance; do not enable it.
3.0 hRound 15 — Inductor post-fusion loop ordering
- Start: 2026-11-07 05:05 UTC.
- Profile basis: the MLP quantization/layout chain and other fused Triton kernels account for over 10% of CUDA time. The generated dominant kernel has separate row/transposed stores and is memory-layout bound; the 32 MiB GEMM workspace gave no gain.
- Candidate: unchanged tree with TORCHINDUCTOR_LOOP_ORDERING_AFTER_FUSION=1 in /tmp/inductor-loop-order.json. This changes Inductor's loop/layout selection after fusion, leaving the operations and precision unchanged. Time at /tmp/r15-loop-order-time; run quick exactness if the result is beneficial. Detached log /tmp/r15-loop-order.log.
- End: 05:08 UTC. Timing ok: windows [1.0155, 1.0246, 1.0196] s/update, mean 1.0199 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9939. No quick check; rejected on benefit. Do not enable post-fusion loop ordering.
3.1 hRound 16 — save FP8 input column layout in forward
- Start: 2026-11-07 05:09 UTC.
- Profile/generated-code basis: backward currently recreates each saved FP8 input's column-major copy. For most linears this rereads the BF16 input solely to produce the layout needed by grad-weight. The MLP backward kernel explicitly shows this recomputation; Q/K/V, attention output, c_fc, and head have analogous layout work. Forward already computes the identical row-major FP8 values.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_FORWARD_INPUT_COL: create and save the input's column-major FP8 copy in _Float8Matmul.forward, replacing (not adding to) the live saved row-major buffer, and consume it directly in backward. Same FP8 bytes, scalar scales, GEMM layouts, and saved-buffer size; intended N0. Expected benefit is removing a backward BF16 read where no other backward computation needs that input, while balancing the copy work between forward and backward.
- Outputs: /tmp/r16-input-col-quick and /tmp/r16-input-col-time; config /tmp/forward-input-col.json; detached log /tmp/r16-input-col.log.
- End: 05:19 UTC. Quick check PASS, tier N0: all exact items and all parameter hashes matched. Timing ok: windows [1.0124, 1.0175, 1.0147] s/update, mean 1.0149 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9988. Both GPUs idle afterward. The forward copies cost as much as the backward savings; revert and close this placement. Experiment/revert commits d88ac3a/03a066f.
3.2 hRound 17 — Inductor CUDA graphs for model execution
- Start: 2026-11-07 05:20 UTC.
- Profile basis: each update launches thousands of GEMM, quantization, attention, and optimizer kernels; measured update time is close to summed rank-0 CUDA time, leaving host/launch gaps as a bounded but independent target. Layout/backend changes in Rounds 14–16 did not help.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_CUDAGRAPHS: compile the same model with mode="reduce-overhead", leaving the loop, optimizer, schedules, data, and default compilation path unchanged. Intended N0 if all graphs capture. A log showing requested-but-skipped CUDA graphs is an invalid timing run and will reject the candidate.
- Config /tmp/model-cudagraphs.json; timing output /tmp/r17-cudagraphs-time, log /tmp/r17-cudagraphs.log; quick record only if timing is valid and beneficial.
- End: 05:22 UTC. Timing ERROR after 61.1 s: rank 1 received SIGSEGV before update 0 and torchrun terminated rank 0. No valid timing or quick check. Both GPUs returned to 0 MiB. Revert and close stock CUDA-graph mode. Experiment/revert commits 929ae59/a27fafa.
3.3 hRound 18 — horizontal combo-kernel fusion
- Start: 2026-11-07 05:23 UTC.
- Profile basis: many independent FP8 quantization/layout kernels run for Q/K/V and same-shaped layer operations. The target is horizontal launch/tail overhead without CUDA graph capture, which crashed in Round 17.
- Candidate: unchanged upstream with TORCHINDUCTOR_COMBO_KERNELS=1 in /tmp/inductor-combo.json; Inductor's mixed-size combo support remains at its default. Time at /tmp/r18-combo-time, log /tmp/r18-combo.log; quick record if beneficial.
- End: 05:27 UTC. Timing ok: windows [1.0117, 1.0167, 1.0123] s/update, mean 1.0136 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0001. No quick check; horizontal fusion is neutral and remains disabled.
3.4 hRound 19 — backward FP8 fast accumulation screen
- Start: 2026-11-07 05:27 UTC.
- Profile basis: backward FP8 GEMMs are the largest single kernel class after forward GEMMs. The reference explicitly sets use_fast_accum=False for grad-input and grad-weight, while forward uses True. This is a real accumulation-rounding change, not a layout-only optimization: it is screened behind an opt-in switch and requires NOT_BITWISE exact-item validation plus the full N1 trajectory before any submission use.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_FP8_FAST_BACKWARD: set use_fast_accum=True on only the two existing backward _scaled_mm calls. Inputs remain the same tensorwise FP8 values/scales, outputs remain BF16, and parameters/optimizer state are unchanged.
- Config /tmp/fp8-fast-backward.json; time at /tmp/r19-fast-backward-time, quick record at /tmp/r19-fast-backward-quick, log /tmp/r19-fast-backward.log. Reject on weak timing, any exact-item failure, or a failed statistical gate.
- Timing result at 05:31 UTC: ok; windows [0.9861, 0.9894, 0.9879] s/update, mean 0.9878 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0262. Every per-window ratio is about 1.026x, above the 1.02 benefit threshold. Quick record is running; no other change is stacked before the N1 verdict.
- Quick record at 05:33:55 UTC: NOT_BITWISE, with exact_items_ok=true, 10 updates, 175 parameters, and 640 rows/rank compared; first hash difference at update 0. Experiment commit 6e60a0d.
- Full check started at 05:34 UTC: /tmp/r19-fast-backward-full/check.json, detached log /tmp/r19-fast-backward-full.log. It includes fresh timing, the deterministic record, and the 150-update seed-1 trajectory. Production switches remain empty until the verdict.
- End: 05:45 UTC. Full check INCORRECT, reported speedup 1.0264. Benefit passed and exact items passed, but every statistical endpoint exceeded 3σ: biases in σ units were [-4.335, -4.982, -7.839, -15.657, -10.029, -6.582] in endpoint order. This is a systematic trajectory difference, not a marginal miss. The candidate is rejected and reverted; no production switch was enabled. Experiment/revert commits d49e4fd/8cf10cd.
3.7 hRound 20 — grad-weight-only FP8 fast accumulation isolation
- Start: 2026-11-07 05:46 UTC.
- Profile/gate basis: Round 19 proves the backward GEMM option has useful speed but the combined grad-input/grad-weight change is statistically different. Grad-weight-only accumulation leaves gradient propagation through earlier layers on the reference path and is a distinct, smaller change against the same FP8 GEMM hotspot.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_FP8_FAST_WGRAD: use_fast_accum=True only for grad-weight; grad-input remains False. Run time and check --quick. If the statistical question remains relevant, use check --n1 to isolate it without repeating timing; no full submission use without a passing complete check.
- Outputs /tmp/r20-fast-wgrad-time, /tmp/r20-fast-wgrad-quick, /tmp/r20-fast-wgrad-n1; config /tmp/fp8-fast-wgrad.json; log /tmp/r20-fast-wgrad.log.
- End: 05:58 UTC. Timing ok: windows [0.9951, 1.0010, 0.9985] s/update, mean 0.9982 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0155 (worst-window ratio about 1.0141, below benefit). Quick record NOT_BITWISE with exact items passing. Isolated check --n1 at /tmp/r20-fast-wgrad-n1/check.json = INCORRECT: five endpoints passed, but probe 50–80 had bias -0.0420787 = -3.0837σ, just beyond the 3σ bound. Reverted; no endpoint-specific tuning or masking stack will be attempted. Experiment/revert commits 7def93b/c6c71f0. The fast-backward direction is closed.
3.9 hRound 21 — Inductor permute/GEMM vertical fusion
- Start: 2026-11-07 05:59 UTC.
- Profile basis: transposes and layout copies surround the dominant FP8 GEMMs, and Round 13 confirmed their real layouts. Round 10's opaque native transpose split was harmful; Round 16's forward placement was neutral-negative. TORCHINDUCTOR_PERMUTE_FUSION=1 is the remaining stock Fx-level matmul/permute vertical-fusion path.
- Candidate: unchanged upstream with /tmp/inductor-permute.json; time at /tmp/r21-permute-time, log /tmp/r21-permute.log, quick record if beneficial.
- End: 06:00 UTC. Timing ERROR after 13.9 s: both ranks failed during Inductor compilation with RuntimeError: tensor does not have a device from functional tensor conversion. No update, timing, or quick record. This stock pass is unusable here and is closed.
3.9 hRound 22 — allow pointwise fusion across tiled layouts
- Start: 2026-11-07 06:01 UTC.
- Profile basis: tiled FP8 transpose/layout kernels and adjacent pointwise work dominate the non-GEMM budget. Inductor defaults triton.tiling_prevents_pointwise_fusion=True; disabling that guard may fuse more surrounding work without the failed Fx permute pass or opaque native copies.
- Candidate: unchanged upstream with TORCHINDUCTOR_TILING_PREVENTS_POINTWISE_FUSION=0 in /tmp/inductor-tiled-pointwise.json. Time at /tmp/r22-tiled-pointwise-time, log /tmp/r22-tiled-pointwise.log; quick record if beneficial.
- End: 06:04 UTC. Timing ok: windows [1.0129, 1.0169, 1.0148] s/update, mean 1.0148 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9989. No quick check; rejected on benefit.
4.0 hRound 23 — allow reduction fusion across tiled layouts
- Start: 2026-11-07 06:05 UTC.
- Profile basis: FP8 abs-max reductions are substantial (39.4 ms and 22.1 ms for the two largest MLP instances over two profiled updates), with many smaller norm/amax reductions. The pointwise guard did not help; the independent triton.tiling_prevents_reduction_fusion guard controls whether these reductions can join tiled producers/consumers.
- Candidate: unchanged upstream with TORCHINDUCTOR_TILING_PREVENTS_REDUCTION_FUSION=0 in /tmp/inductor-tiled-reduction.json. Time at /tmp/r23-tiled-reduction-time, log /tmp/r23-tiled-reduction.log; quick record if beneficial.
- End: 06:08 UTC. Timing ok: windows [1.0128, 1.0180, 1.0157] s/update, mean 1.0155 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9982. No quick check; rejected on benefit. Both tiling-fusion guards are closed.
4.1 hRound 24 — selective deep tile tuning for the dominant MLP kernel
- Start: 2026-11-07 06:09 UTC.
- Profile basis: the named ...threshold_backward_view_12 kernel is 124.748–129.535 ms over two updates. Radius-1 global coordinate tuning chose a better launch and saved 4.787 ms there, but global radius-2/all-direction tuning did not reach update 0 after 31 minutes. The stock autotuner supports per-kernel metadata at cached_autotune.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_MLP_TILE_TUNING: wrap Inductor's cached_autotune so only the exact dominant MLP-backward kernel name receives coordinate descent with radius 2 and all directions. No graph, arithmetic, dtype, or other kernel changes. This is a fixed-shape launch-configuration search, intended N0/N1 depending on generated reduction paths (this kernel is pointwise).
- Outputs /tmp/r24-mlp-tiles-time and, if useful, /tmp/r24-mlp-tiles-quick; config /tmp/mlp-tile-tuning.json; log /tmp/r24-mlp-tiles.log.
- End: 07:00 UTC. Initial timing was ok with windows [1.0120, 1.0166, 1.0152] s/update, mean 1.0146 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9991, but this was not a valid test of deep tuning: judge profiles /tmp/r24-mlp-tiles-profile and /tmp/r24b-mlp-tiles-profile showed the reference grid [96,512,1], block 256, and 129.55 ms for the target kernel. The parent-process hook was absent from subprocess compile workers; neither a candidate-environment startup hook nor fork worker mode activated it.
- A decisive diagnostic with TORCHINDUCTOR_COMPILE_THREADS=1 (/tmp/r24d-mlp-tiles-profile) logged activation on both dominant MLP kernel instances, but reached no update 0 after 21 minutes. The complete bench, torchrun, and rank process groups were terminated and both GPUs returned to 0 MiB. Thus the neutral timing was a missed-hook result and the activated radius-2/all-direction search is impractical even for this narrow kernel class. No quick check was needed; the experiment was reverted and production remains upstream with empty switches.
5.0 hRound 25 — transposed FP8 backward GEMM formulation
- Start: 2026-11-07 07:02 UTC.
- Profile basis: the fresh upstream profile /tmp/r24c-mlp-tiles-profile shows the two largest FP8 GEMM kernel families at 322.042 ms and 172.863 ms over two updates. Backward currently computes grad-input and grad-weight in their logical orientation. The transposed forms can reuse the identical physical FP8 transpose buffers without extra copies.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_FP8_TRANSPOSE_BACKWARD: compute (weight.T @ grad_output.T).T for grad-input and (input.T @ grad_output).T for grad-weight, returning transposed views. Keep all FP8 values/scales, use_fast_accum=False, output dtypes, shapes, and one optimizer step unchanged. This is an N1 kernel/layout selection change; run timing and quick exact-item validation.
- Outputs /tmp/r25-transpose-backward-time and, if warranted, /tmp/r25-transpose-backward-quick; config /tmp/fp8-transpose-backward.json; detached log /tmp/r25-transpose-backward.log.
- End: 07:09 UTC. Timing ok: speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.8383, mean 1.2093 s/update. The transposed GEMM/gradient-layout formulation is a severe regression, so no quick check was run. Reverted; production remains upstream with empty switches. Both GPUs idle afterward.
5.2 hRound 26 — SDPA attention backend screen
- Start: 2026-11-07 07:12 UTC.
- Profile basis: upstream FA3 forward/backward accounts for 218.0 ms over two updates (10.74% of CUDA time) in /tmp/r24c-mlp-tiles-profile. Upstream already includes an SDPA fallback with full-context causal support and explicit sliding-window masks.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_SDPA: select the existing SDPA implementation in normal execution. When deterministic algorithms are enabled, use the same loaded FA3 module and call as the reference because not every SDPA mask/backend combination has a deterministic implementation. No Q/K/V values, masking semantics, dtypes, or model parameters change. Intended timing-path N1 and deterministic-record N0; timing and quick record will verify.
- Outputs /tmp/r26-sdpa-time and /tmp/r26-sdpa-quick if timing is useful; config /tmp/sdpa-attention.json; detached log /tmp/r26-sdpa.log.
- End: 07:18 UTC. Timing ok: speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.5755, mean 1.7615 s/update. Explicit-mask sliding-window SDPA is decisively slower; no quick check was run. Reverted. A full-context-only substitution is separable, but sliding-window SDPA is closed. Both GPUs idle afterward.
5.2 hRound 27 — full-context-only attention backend substitutions
- Start: 2026-11-07 07:19 UTC.
- Profile basis: Round 26 showed explicit sliding-window masks make whole-model SDPA unusable. Full-context layers are only one quarter of the attention calls but can use causal SDPA without a materialized mask; the reference attention class is 10.74% of CUDA time.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_FULL_SDPA=flash|cudnn: substitute only full-context causal calls, retain FA3 for every sliding-window call, and retain FA3 for all deterministic execution. Screen Flash SDPA and cuDNN SDPA independently with /tmp/full-sdpa-flash.json and /tmp/full-sdpa-cudnn.json.
- Outputs /tmp/r27-full-flash-time and /tmp/r27-full-cudnn-time; detached logs /tmp/r27-full-flash.log and /tmp/r27-full-cudnn.log. Quick record only for a beneficial variant.
- End: 07:27 UTC. Flash SDPA timing 0.9726x (1.0423 s/update); cuDNN SDPA 0.7984x (1.2697 s/update). Both regress despite restricting substitution to full context, so no quick checks were run. Reverted; SDPA backend substitutions are closed. Both GPUs idle afterward.
5.4 hRound 28 — radius-one all-direction coordinate descent
- Start: 2026-11-07 07:28 UTC.
- Profile basis: Round 3 radius-one coordinate tuning remains the best measured variant at 1.0148x mean and approximately 1.0137x worst-window, about 0.63 percentage points below benefit. Its matched Triton savings span many memory/layout kernels. Round 12 showed radius 2 plus all directions is impractical, but all directions at radius 1 is a smaller, untested search.
- Candidate: unchanged upstream with TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1 and TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_CHECK_ALL_DIRECTIONS=1 in /tmp/inductor-cdt-all.json. No source change. Time at /tmp/r28-cdt-all-time, log /tmp/r28-cdt-all.log; quick record if the result justifies it.
- End: 07:50 UTC. No update 0 after 21 minutes; no valid timing or quick record. Terminated the bench, torchrun, and rank process groups and verified both GPUs at 0 MiB. Radius-one all-direction search is impractical and closed; ordinary radius-one coordinate descent remains the only usable compiler-tuning variant.
5.8 hRound 29 — pointwise autotune plus coordinate descent
- Start: 2026-11-07 07:51 UTC.
- Profile basis: ordinary radius-one coordinate descent is the best variant (1.0148x mean, 1.0137x worst-window), while pointwise autotune alone gives 1.0027x with only 163.1 s startup. They target the same memory/layout kernel class but are compatible: autotune selects a starting point and coordinate descent refines it.
- Candidate: unchanged upstream with TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1 and TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1 in /tmp/inductor-pointwise-cdt.json. No deeper radius or all-direction search. Time at /tmp/r29-pointwise-cdt-time, log /tmp/r29-pointwise-cdt.log; quick record if beneficial enough.
- End: 07:59 UTC. Timing ok: windows [0.9968, 1.0017, 1.0011] s/update, mean 0.9999 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0138; worst-window ratio about 1.0131, slightly below ordinary coordinate descent and still below benefit. Startup 440.7 s. No quick check or source change; do not add pointwise autotune to the coordinate-descent base.
6.0 hRound 30 — MLP-only forward-saved FP8 input columns
- Start: 2026-11-07 08:00 UTC.
- Profile/generated-code basis: the dominant MLP backward layout kernel rereads the BF16 c_fc preactivation, recomputes ReLU², quantizes it, and writes the transposed FP8 c_proj input while also handling gradient layouts. Round 16's global forward-column placement was N0 but 0.9988x; applying it to every linear pays forward copies where backward only transposes an existing FP8 tensor. Restricting the placement to mlp.c_proj targets the unique recompute case.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_MLP_INPUT_COL: pass a per-module flag only for mlp.c_proj; forward saves the identical FP8 input in column-major layout and backward consumes it directly. Other linears use the reference path. Same FP8 bytes/scales and GEMMs, intended N0. Run timing and quick record.
- Outputs /tmp/r30-mlp-input-col-time and /tmp/r30-mlp-input-col-quick; config /tmp/mlp-input-col.json; log /tmp/r30-mlp-input-col.log.
- End: 08:07 UTC. Timing ok: speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0003, mean 1.0134 s/update. The selective placement is neutral and cannot contribute a reliable benefit, so no quick check was run. Reverted; both GPUs idle afterward.
6.1 hRound 31 — fixed 16×128 tile for the dominant MLP layout kernel
- Start: 2026-11-07 08:08 UTC.
- Profile/generated-code basis: the dominant _view_12 MLP kernel writes two transposed FP8 outputs and one row-major FP8 output. Reference autotuning chooses X=64/Y=32 (grid [96,512]); radius-one coordinate descent prefers X=32/Y=64 (grid [192,512]) and saves 4.787 ms over two updates. This trend favors longer contiguous transposed stores. Deep search is impractical, but a fixed X=16/Y=128 tile tests the next point directly.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_MLP_TILE_16X128: wrap AsyncCompile.triton in the parent so the source sent to compile workers replaces only this kernel's pointwise decorator with one fixed Triton config (16×128, 8 warps). Remove only unsupported decorator arguments; the generated arithmetic/body is byte-for-byte otherwise unchanged. Intended N0, with quick record and launch-grid verification.
- Outputs /tmp/r31-mlp-tile-16x128-time and, if useful, /tmp/r31-mlp-tile-16x128-quick; config /tmp/mlp-tile-16x128.json; log /tmp/r31-mlp-tile-16x128.log.
- End: 08:16 UTC. Timing ok: speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9923, mean 1.0216 s/update. The aggressive tile is slower; no quick check was run. Reverted. A source-inspection follow-up found TunableOp's CUDA build registers only Default for scaled GEMM and ordinary GEMM (alternative implementations are ROCm-only), so TunableOp offers no useful algorithm search here and no GPU round was started for it.
6.3 hRound 32 — compiled FP8 weight cache across accumulation
- Start: 2026-11-07 08:18 UTC.
- Profile basis: four accumulation micro-batches repeatedly quantize unchanged FP8 weights and recreate their column-major layout. Round 1's cache saved this work but used eager cache-miss arithmetic, was NOT_BITWISE, and timed only 1.0011x. The cache remains one of the few ways to remove whole-model memory traffic without changing the math.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_COMPILED_WEIGHT_CACHE: a custom caching op keyed by weight identity/version calls a standalone torch.compiled quantization+column-layout function only on cache misses. Hits reuse identical FP8 tensors/scales for the remaining micro-batches; optimizer in-place version changes invalidate entries. All GEMMs and parameter dtypes remain unchanged. Quick record first, then timing if valid.
- Outputs /tmp/r32-compiled-weight-cache-quick and /tmp/r32-compiled-weight-cache-time; config /tmp/compiled-weight-cache.json; logs /tmp/r32-compiled-weight-cache-quick.log and /tmp/r32-compiled-weight-cache.log.
- End: 08:29 UTC. Quick record PASS, tier N0: all exact items and every parameter hash matched over 10 updates. Timing ok: windows [0.9997, 1.0082, 1.0083] s/update, mean 1.0054 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0083; worst-window ratio about 1.0059. Peak allocation 57.33 GiB; startup 127.6 s. This is a genuine independently verified N0 gain, kept behind its opt-in switch for stack testing. Both GPUs idle afterward.
6.4 hRound 33 — compiled weight cache plus coordinate descent
- Start: 2026-11-07 08:29 UTC.
- Profile basis: the N0 compiled cache removes repeated weight quantization/layout work and gives 1.0083x mean; ordinary coordinate descent gives 1.0148x mean and 1.0137x worst-window. Their simple window-wise subtraction puts the stack near the 1.02 gate, so measure their actual interaction rather than assuming additivity.
- Candidate: Round 32 source with NANOCHAT_OPT_COMPILED_WEIGHT_CACHE=1 and TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1 in /tmp/compiled-weight-cache-cdt.json. No new source change. Time at /tmp/r33-cache-cdt-time, log /tmp/r33-cache-cdt.log; quick record and full check if benefit passes.
- Timing result at 08:38 UTC: ok; windows [0.9843, 0.9918, 0.9901] s/update, mean 0.9887 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0253. Per-window ratios are approximately [1.0278, 1.0235, 1.0243], so the deciding window passes the 1.02 screening threshold. Startup 420.9 s; both GPUs idle afterward.
- Quick record at /tmp/r33-cache-cdt-quick/check.json = NOT_BITWISE, exact_items_ok=true, all 175 parameters and 640 rows/rank compared; coordinate descent requires the statistical gate. The deterministic record took 572.9 s because coordinate tuning remains active there.
- Full check started at 08:50 UTC: /tmp/r33-cache-cdt-full/check.json, detached log /tmp/r33-cache-cdt-full.log. /submission/switches.json now enables the measured cache+CDT stack while its verdict is pending.
- End: 09:20 UTC. Full check PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0223. Benefit passed, exact items passed, and the statistical verdict was equivalent. Endpoint biases in σ units were [0.0283, 0.0569, 0.1546, 0.0575, 0.0282, -0.0175], all far inside 3σ. This is the current passing submission baseline; both GPUs idle afterward.
7.5 hRound 34 — cuBLASLt backend preference on the passing stack
- Start: 2026-11-07 09:24 UTC.
- Current-stack profile /tmp/r34-stack-profile: 1.967 s total CUDA over two updates. FP8 GEMMs 871.8 ms (44.33%); FA3 forward/backward about 219.3 ms; dominant MLP layout kernel 123.975 ms (down from 129.780); optimizer 86.87 ms; Muon BMMs 44.924 ms; collectives 46.8 ms. Cache+CDT is therefore removing work outside the dominant GEMM/attention classes.
- Candidate: add TORCH_BLAS_PREFER_CUBLASLT=1 to the passing configuration, using PyTorch's documented global backend preference. This is distinct from Round 14's workspace-only setting and may change Muon BF16 BMM backend selection. Intended N1, in the separate /tmp/nanochat-exp worktree with /tmp/cache-cdt-cublaslt.json.
- Timing output /tmp/r34-cublaslt-backend-time, detached log /tmp/r34-cublaslt-backend.log. Production tree and passing switches remain unchanged.
- End: 09:42 UTC. Timing ok: windows [0.9836, 0.9910, 0.9939] s/update, mean 0.9895 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0245; deciding-window ratio about 1.0204, worse than the passing stack's 1.0235 screening margin. No quick or full check; do not enable cuBLASLt preference. Production remains the Round 33 PASS configuration.
7.7 hRound 35 — NCCL LL128 protocol on the passing stack
- Start: 2026-11-07 09:43 UTC.
- Profile basis: the passing-stack profile attributes approximately 46.8 ms of collective time to two updates. Round 2's NCCL_PROTO=Simple was neutral (0.9998x); LL128 is the remaining standard protocol option and targets a different latency/bandwidth tradeoff.
- Candidate: add only NCCL_PROTO=LL128 to the verified cache+CDT configuration in /tmp/cache-cdt-ll128.json. No source change; use /tmp/nanochat-exp. Timing output /tmp/r35-ll128-time, detached log /tmp/r35-ll128.log, PID 1249938. Production remains the Round 33 PASS configuration.
- End: 09:51 UTC. Timing ok: windows [0.9878, 0.9918, 0.9902] s/update, mean 0.9899 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0240; deciding-window ratio about 1.0235, essentially tied with the passing stack but with a lower mean. No quick or full check; do not enable LL128. All standard NCCL protocol overrides are now screened. Production remains unchanged and both GPUs are idle.
7.9 hRound 36 — MLP layout-kernel launch-geometry search on the passing stack
- Start: 2026-11-07 09:57 UTC.
- Profile basis: /tmp/r34-stack-profile shows the dominant MLP ReLU-backward/FP8-layout kernel at 123.975 ms over two updates (6.30%). With the cache its generated name ends in view_10; CDT chooses X=32/Y=64, grid [192,512], four warps, 64 registers and 4 KiB shared memory. Round 31's narrower 16×128 tile was slower, but equal- and larger-tile geometries remain untested on the current stack.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_MLP_TILE=XxYxWARPS: source-level replacement of only this kernel's pointwise decorator with one fixed Triton config. The generated arithmetic and addresses are unchanged (intended N0). Screen 64×64×8 and 32×128×8, each with the verified cache+CDT settings. Outputs /tmp/r36-mlp-64x64-time and /tmp/r36-mlp-32x128-time; detached logs /tmp/r36-mlp-64x64.log and /tmp/r36-mlp-32x128.log. Experimental source only in /tmp/nanochat-exp; production remains unchanged.
- End: 10:13 UTC. 64×64×8 timing ok: windows [0.9844, 0.9909, 0.9945] s/update, mean 0.9899 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0240, deciding-window ratio about 1.0197. 32×128×8 timing ok: windows [0.9903, 0.9971, 1.0010], mean 0.9961 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0177. Neither improves the passing stack's 1.0253 screening / 1.0235 deciding-window margin; no quick or full check. Revert the injector and retain CDT's 32×64 choice. Both GPUs idle afterward.
8.3 hRound 37 — asynchronous per-layer FP8 weight-quantization prefetch
- Start: 2026-11-07 10:22 UTC.
- Profile basis: after caching, once-per-update weight quantization/layout still appears as 17.452 ms over two updates for the large head and smaller reductions/layout work elsewhere. The two large MLP abs-max reductions (37.929 + 22.295 ms/two updates) are necessary activation/gradient scaling and already run near memory bandwidth, so they are not the rewrite target. Weight values are constant across an update and later layers' quantization is independent of earlier forward compute.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_FP8_WEIGHT_PREFETCH: before the micro-batch loop, enqueue compiled weight quantization on a side stream, store the same FP8/scalar/column tensors in the existing identity/version cache, and use events plus record_stream for ordering/lifetime safety. First screened one six-weight graph per layer plus the head, then isolated the head-only case with one event and the whole trunk available for overlap. Arithmetic and GEMMs are unchanged; intended N0 for the prefetch itself. Timing uses cache+CDT+prefetch in /tmp/cache-cdt-weight-prefetch.json. Production remains the Round 33 PASS tree.
- End: 10:41 UTC. Whole-model prefetch /tmp/r37-weight-prefetch-time: windows [0.9880, 0.9920, 0.9914], mean 0.9905 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0234, deciding ratio about 1.0230. Head-only prefetch /tmp/r37b-head-weight-prefetch-time: windows [0.9857, 0.9915, 0.9958], mean 0.9910 s, 1.0229, deciding ratio about 1.0185. Neither improves the passing stack's screening margin, so no quick or full check was run. The large 17.452 ms kernel initially considered here was subsequently identified from its full trace name/grid as softcap/tanh-backward gradient-logit layout work, not head-weight quantization. Revert prefetch and close this formulation. Both GPUs idle afterward.
8.7 hRound 38 — softcap cross-entropy with recomputed backward softmax
- Start: 2026-11-07 10:46 UTC.
- Profile basis: the passing stack spends 15.815 ms on log-softmax/loss forward, 17.169 ms on log-softmax backward, and 17.452 ms on softcap/tanh backward plus gradient-logit FP8 layout over two updates. Standard autograd saves a full FP32 log-probability tensor and then crosses a separate softcap backward boundary. Saving the already-existing BF16 logits and recomputing softmax gives Inductor a direct reduction-to-BF16-gradient path and removes that FP32 intermediate.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_SOFTCAP_CROSS_ENTROPY: custom autograd forward retains the exact FP32 softcap and F.cross_entropy formula; backward computes softmax, target/mean scaling, and the softcap chain explicitly, saving only BF16 logits/targets. Ignore-index and mean semantics are preserved. Expected N1 from reduction/backward arithmetic order. Config /tmp/cache-cdt-softcap-ce.json. Experimental tree only.
- End: 10:57 UTC. First attempt /tmp/r38-softcap-ce-time ERROR before update 0: backward returned [32768,32768] instead of [16,2048,32768]; corrected with view_as(logits). Valid timing /tmp/r38b-softcap-ce-time: windows [0.9982, 1.0040, 1.0004] s/update, mean 1.0009 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0128. Peak allocation fell from 57.33 to 56.33 GiB, confirming the intended intermediate-memory saving, but recomputation/code generation cost more than it saved. No quick or full check; revert and close this formulation. Both GPUs idle afterward.
8.9 hRound 39 — Muon communication-buffer copy elision
- Start: 2026-11-07 10:59 UTC.
- Profile basis: optimizer time is 86.870 ms over two updates, including 44.924 ms of Muon BMM and 46.801 ms of collectives. Source inspection shows two avoidable full-tensor copies around that compute: _reduce_muon stacks gradients and then copies the stack into stacked_grads; _compute_muon copies stacked_owned into updated_params even when every slot is owned and the stack is already the exact all-gather input shape. All three Muon groups have even sizes on two ranks, so the latter guard covers the recipe.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_MUON_COPY_ELISION: use torch.stack(..., out=stacked_grads[:N]) and pass stacked_owned directly to all-gather when num_owned == chunk_size. Same gradient bytes, reduction operations, Muon arithmetic, communication tensors/shapes and parameters; intended N0. Config /tmp/cache-cdt-muon-copy.json, timing /tmp/r39-muon-copy-time; quick record without CDT available to isolate exactness if useful. Production remains unchanged.
- End: 11:08 UTC. Timing ok: windows [0.9833, 0.9905, 0.9938] s/update, mean 0.9892 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0248; deciding-window ratio about 1.0205. This is within noise of the mean but does not improve the passing stack's deciding-window screening margin, so no quick or full check and no promotion. Revert; both GPUs idle afterward.
9.2 hRound 40 — packed Muon parameter storage and direct gathers
- Start: 2026-11-07 11:10 UTC.
- Profile/source basis: Round 39 showed copy elision alone was neutral, but the remaining torch.stack(owned_params) and final _foreach_copy_ still move every Muon parameter through temporary storage each update. Optimizer time remains 86.870 ms/two updates. Persistent same-shaped storage can remove both copies rather than only the intermediate ones.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_PACK_MUON_PARAMETERS: at optimizer setup, copy each already-initialized same-shaped transformer matrix into one packed allocation and replace module parameters with shaped views (names, shapes, dtypes, values and optimizer groups unchanged). Muon updates the owned contiguous view in place and all-gathers directly into the packed parameter allocation when its shape exactly matches the padded group. A one-element multiply-by-one after raw NCCL writes bumps the shared version counter without changing bits, preserving FP8-cache invalidation. Fallback remains upstream for unpaired/padded/single-rank cases. Intended N0. Configs /tmp/cache-pack-muon-no-cdt.json and /tmp/cache-cdt-pack-muon.json. Production unchanged while validating.
- Quick record at 11:17 UTC: /tmp/r40-pack-muon-quick/check.json = PASS, tier N0, all exact items and parameter hashes matched over 10 updates. Timing /tmp/r40-pack-muon-time: windows [0.9826, 0.9891, 0.9919] s/update, mean 0.9879 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0261; per-window ratios approximately [1.0296, 1.0263, 1.0225]. Peak allocation 56.05 GiB (down 1.28 GiB from the passing stack). This is a full-check candidate, with the remaining direct gradient-stack output screened before that long run. Both GPUs idle afterward.
9.4 hRound 41 — direct gradient-stack output on packed Muon storage
- Start: 2026-11-07 11:28 UTC.
- Profile/source basis: Round 40 is N0 and improves mean timing to 1.0261x, but _reduce_muon still creates grad_stack and then copies it into the reduce-scatter allocation. This is the only remaining redundant Muon communication-buffer copy in the packed path.
- Candidate behind NANOCHAT_OPT_MUON_GRAD_STACK_OUT: torch.stack(..., out=stacked_grads[:N]) directly into the existing contiguous output, with no arithmetic or collective change. Intended N0. Quick combined record /tmp/r41-pack-grad-out-quick, then timing /tmp/r41-pack-grad-out-time with cache+CDT+packed storage. Production remains Round 33 while the Round 40/41 candidates are screened.
- Quick record at 11:31 UTC: PASS, N0. Timing at 11:39 UTC: windows [0.9812, 0.9892, 0.9915] s/update, mean 0.9873 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0267; per-window ratios approximately [1.0311, 1.0262, 1.0229]. Peak allocation 56.05 GiB. This slightly improves Round 40's mean and deciding ratio. Commit d4c9c7e contains Round 40; Round 41 is committed separately. Full check started at 11:41 UTC on the exact experimental tree/config: /tmp/r41-pack-grad-out-full/check.json, log /tmp/r41-pack-grad-out-full.log. Production remains the Round 33 PASS pending the verdict.
↑ NanoChat