GPT-6 Astrasuspected nerf 1.13×

Harness: Codex · switches: NANOCHAT_MICROBATCH_MULTIPLIER=2 NANOCHAT_FP8_HOIST_SCALES=all NANOCHAT_FP8_DUAL_LAYOUTS=all NANOCHAT_FUSE_QK_ROPE=1 NANOCHAT_FUSE_FP8_MLP=all NANOCHAT_PERSISTENT_REDUCTION_LIMIT=2048 NANOCHAT_REUSE_MUON_BUFFERS=1 NANOCHAT_PERSISTENT_NORM_TILE=1x4 NANOCHAT_FUSE_FP8_QK=1

Judged
1.13×
Tier
N1
Self-best
1.21×
Rounds
27
Hours
10.0
API cost
$143
Input tokens · 95.7% cached
72 M
Output tokens
0.7 M
Requests
592
Micro-batch regrouping 4×16 → 2×32
✓ NANOCHAT_MICROBATCH_MULTIPLIER=2, step 1.016 → 0.991 s
Scope of hand-written kernels replacing Inductor glue
partial: one kernel each for dual-layout quantization, QK + RoPE, MLP relu²; rest left to Inductor
Per-shape cuBLASLt algorithm selection
tried, reverted (all shapes switched uniformly to candidate 1 / candidate 3, both slower)
FP8 weights quantized once per step
✗ (considered, not done)
Fast accum on backward GEMMs
no attempt in the log
Other main levers
1536-wide RMSNorm reduction made single-pass (NANOCHAT_PERSISTENT_REDUCTION_LIMIT=2048) with fixed 4 warps, scalar scale hoisted out of the kernel, two fewer copies in Muon
Raw work log50 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — baseline profiling
- Start / GPU lock: 2026-11-05T15:46:30Z.
- Baseline: clean upstream 92d63d4, empty environment switches.
- Profile PID: 41714; log: /tmp/nano-r1-profile-base.log; output: /tmp/nano-r1-profile-base.
- Early baseline timing PID: 52639; log: /tmp/nano-r1-time-base.log; output: /tmp/nano-r1-time-base, queued behind the profile on the judge lock.
- Startup reference timing: 1.2116 / 1.0172 / 1.0193 seconds per update; frozen spread 0.0607.
- Profile completed 15:49:11Z, 0.089 GPU-hours. Profile has 2,019.7 ms of rank-0 kernel time across two updates; 23,674 GPU events. Forward 29.86%, backward 64.85%; optimizer and communications occupy the remainder. FP8 scaled GEMMs 42.59%; attention backward 8.24%, forward 2.48%; largest quantize/transpose/ReLU-backward kernel 6.37%; NCCL collectives about 2.3%. Thus compute/GEMM backend configuration is the first hotspot class.
- Fast-path inventory: whole-model Inductor compilation and FA3 are active; upstream uses cuBLAS FP8 (nvjet_*) rather than tuned Triton GEMMs, and has compiled fused optimizer updates. No skipped graph or recompilation warning in the profile.
- Experiment: enable the existing TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_GEMM=1 switch only. No math, dtype or recipe changes. Config is runs/optimization/gemm-autotune.json in isolated worktree /submission/nanochat-lab.
- Candidate timing, precision check and end time: pending.
- GEMM autotuning timing PID: 69196; log /tmp/nano-r1-time-gemm.log; output /tmp/nano-r1-time-gemm (queued behind baseline timing).
- Early unchanged-tree time completed 15:52:07Z: status=ok, windows 1.0107 / 1.0173 / 1.0204 s/update, mean 1.0161, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0655, 0.097 GPU-hours. This is a reference-control measurement, not an optimization gain; the frozen first window is slower than this run.
- GEMM autotuning quick check queued: PID 76042, log /tmp/nano-r1-quick-gemm.log, output /tmp/nano-r1-quick-gemm.
0.0 hRound 1 conclusion
- End: 2026-11-05T16:05:14Z (under 30 minutes).
- time /tmp/nano-r1-time-gemm: status ok; windows 1.0119 / 1.0195 / 1.0227 s/update; mean 1.0180; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0636; 0.229 GPU-hours. This does not improve on the unchanged-tree control (1.0161 s/update). cuBLAS remained fastest for the large FP8 GEMMs; compiling/searching the alternatives increased startup to 372.6 s.
- check --quick /tmp/nano-r1-quick-gemm: NOT_BITWISE; exact items pass, N1 candidate only (no trajectory run because there is no performance benefit); 0.204 GPU-hours.
- Decision: reject GEMM autotuning; keep it as an isolated documented preset, disabled in the submission. No full check justified.
0.3 hRound 2 — memory/layout compiler configuration
- Start: 2026-11-05T16:05:30Z; profile the unchanged current best again, with compiler output logging for kernel attribution.
- Profile output: /tmp/nano-r2-profile-base; log /tmp/nano-r2-profile-base.log; profile-only switch TORCH_LOGS=output_code (no training behavior change).
- Profile PID 113955, GPU lock taken 16:05:56Z. Round-1 preset committed in the isolated worktree as af47a1c; not promoted.
- Findings, experiment, timing and validation: pending.
- Profile completed 16:08:39Z, 0.090 GPU-hours. The same compiled graph names and FP8 kernel call counts remain active: scaled GEMMs 42.61%, FA3 backward 8.30%; the largest memory kernel is 6.42%, operating on 32768 x 6144 BF16 activation/gradient arrays and producing one transposed E4M3 plus row-major and transposed E5M2 arrays. Optimizer is only 4.06%. This is the memory/layout class, not exposed communication or a host gap.
- First configuration experiment: TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1, broadening only the existing reduction/pointwise kernel configuration search, not GEMM search. All arithmetic and dtypes remain unchanged at source level.
- Pointwise timing PID 129986; log /tmp/nano-r2-time-pointwise.log; output /tmp/nano-r2-time-pointwise.
- Second preset in the same memory-configuration class adds TORCHINDUCTOR_COORDINATE_DESCENT_TUNING=1 to search tile sizes and warp counts further; no source math changes. It is queued after the first timing run.
- Pointwise timing completed 16:12:52Z: /tmp/nano-r2-time-pointwise, status ok, windows 1.0052 / 1.0108 / 1.0159 s/update, mean 1.0106, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0713, cost 0.111 GPU-hours. Only about 0.5% below the unchanged-tree control; not sufficient to promote alone.
- Coordinate timing PID 138551, log /tmp/nano-r2-time-coordinate.log, output /tmp/nano-r2-time-coordinate.
- Coordinate quick check queued: PID 168290, log /tmp/nano-r2-quick-coordinate.log, output /tmp/nano-r2-quick-coordinate.
- Coordinate timing completed 16:20:45Z: status ok; windows 0.9978 / 1.0031 / 1.0069 s/update; mean 1.0026; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0799; 0.261 GPU-hours. About 1.3% below the unchanged-tree control, still below the benefit gate.
- Important negative finding at 16:29Z: PyTorch 2.9.1 coordinate descent calls its own timed bench() outside benchmark_all_configs, so it does not obey the judge first-configuration hook. Its quick check is spending over eight minutes tuning, rather than taking deterministic first configurations. Reject this raw environment preset; do not promote or rely on its precision result. Stopping that experiment and checking the pointwise-only preset instead. No judge code was changed.
- The deliberately stopped coordinate quick check reports ERROR at 16:30:12Z (0.312 GPU-hours); it is not a numerical verdict. Pointwise-only quick check PID 256000, log /tmp/nano-r2-quick-pointwise.log, output /tmp/nano-r2-quick-pointwise.
0.3 hRound 2 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T16:32:32Z, within 30 minutes of lock acquisition.
- Pointwise-only check --quick: /tmp/nano-r2-quick-pointwise, NOT_BITWISE, exact items pass; N1 candidate only, 0.075 GPU-hours. The performance gain is too small to justify a trajectory or promotion.
- Decision: reject both presets for the submitted configuration. Pointwise-only gives an unresolved sub-percent benefit; raw coordinate tuning adds long compilation and bypasses deterministic first-choice selection. Both are recorded as negative results, not accepted optimizations.
0.8 hRound 3 — FP8 backward matrix layouts
- Start 2026-11-05T16:33:00Z. Profile the unchanged current best before a new kernel experiment; output /tmp/nano-r3-profile-base, log /tmp/nano-r3-profile-base.log.
- Direction to investigate from the new profile: weight-gradient GEMMs plus the global FP8 activation/gradient transposes they require. Standard GEMM backend search and memory tile tuning have already been screened without sufficient gain.
- Implementation, measurements and precision validation: pending.
- Profile PID 266847. Candidate kernel contract: preserve the E5M2/E4M3 tensorwise quantized operands and their scales; FP32 dot accumulation, BF16 gradient output; fixed-order split-K partial reduction with no atomics. Only global operand layout copies are to be removed. Parameter and optimizer-state dtypes are untouched. Intended tier N1, not a bitwise claim.
- Profile completed 16:35:39Z (0.089 GPU-hours): FP8 GEMMs 42.50%, largest transpose/quantization/ReLU-backward kernel 6.40%, attention backward 8.28%; backward graph 65.04%, forward 29.57%. Same hotspots and kernel counts as the earlier baseline profiles.
- Implemented an opt-in Triton weight-gradient kernel in the isolated tree. It reads both FP8 operands in their existing row-major layouts, uses FP32 accumulation and deterministic FP32 partial reductions, and returns BF16. The existing library path remains for disabled switches, non-BF16 results and matrices with a feature dimension above 8192. Configuration is runs/optimization/fp8-wgrad.json.
- Unit-correctness then judge-time job PID 282488, unit log /tmp/nano-r3-unit-wgrad.log, driver log /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad.log, timing output /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad. Unit tests use the required GPU lock; the timing stage runs only if they pass.
- First unit invocation could not start because pytest was absent; no timing run occurred. Installed pytest into /opt/candidate-env only (no training library changed). Retried with PID 282554 at 16:39:28Z: unit log /tmp/nano-r3-unit-wgrad-v1.log, driver log /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad-v1.log, output /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad-v1.
- Initial direct cuBLAS closeness tests failed around cancellation (up to 0.7% of outputs outside a one-BF16-ULP-style bound). Investigated against FP64 before proceeding: for the 512x128x256 case the candidate exactly equals correctly rounded FP64 at all 32,768 outputs, while cuBLAS differs at 1,650; relative L2 errors to FP64 are 0.0016492 candidate and 0.0016524 reference. Example truth -1.27997275, candidate -1.28125, cuBLAS -1.265625. This is an arithmetic-order/kernel difference, not an operand/scale bug. Tests now arbitrate against FP64 and require candidate error no worse than reference plus 1%, deterministic replay, BF16 output, and closeness to correctly rounded FP64. The judge gates remain untouched and are still required.
- FP64-arbitrated unit tests then timing retry: PID 282903, unit log /tmp/nano-r3-unit-wgrad-v2.log, driver log /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad-v2.log, output /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad-v2.
- Five FP64-arbitrated tests passed, but time /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad-v2 was much slower: status ok, windows 1.6232 / 1.6314 / 1.6317 s/update, mean 1.6288, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=0.6647, 0.094 GPU-hours. Not promoted.
- Root-cause inspection of generated PTX found that max_num_imprecise_acc=0 forces Triton MMA-v2 with exact FP8-to-FP16 promotion. This is not the intended native FP8 implementation. PyTorch 2.9.1 itself implements scaled-mm USE_FAST_ACCUM=False as acc += tl.dot(a, b) per K tile, rather than passing a running accumulator into dot. Updated the kernel to that same native-FP8/FP32-promotion pattern, preserving the non-fast accumulation recipe. Added an exact signed-integer FP8 test and retained FP64 relative-error arbitration against cuBLAS. No judge gate or threshold changed.
- Native-FP8 retry PID 292079, unit log /tmp/nano-r3-unit-wgrad-v3.log, driver log /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad-v3.log, output /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad-v3.
- Native retry passed all six unit tests, including exact integer operands and deterministic replay. Generated PTX confirms wgmma.mma_async...f32.e5m2.e4m3, with FP32 promotion between 128-token dot products.
- time /tmp/nano-r3-time-wgrad-v3 completed 16:52:03Z: status ok; windows 2.9041 / 2.9032 / 2.9065 s/update; mean 2.9046; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=0.3728; peak 63.25 GiB; 0.118 GPU-hours. The native row-major GEMM is even slower than the promoted fallback. This approach is rejected; avoiding the global transposes does not compensate for the poor inner-kernel layout/pipeline. Do not promote it.
- Final quick correctness screen for the rejected native kernel: PID 301948, log /tmp/nano-r3-quick-wgrad.log, output /tmp/nano-r3-quick-wgrad.
0.8 hRound 3 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T16:57:55Z, within 30 minutes. check --quick /tmp/nano-r3-quick-wgrad: NOT_BITWISE; exact items pass, N1 candidate only; 0.077 GPU-hours.
- Reject the entire custom weight-gradient path for performance. Both variants were slower. Keep its source and numerical tests only in the isolated experiment worktree, disabled by default. No trajectory/full check justified and nothing promoted.
1.2 hRound 4 — overlapping independent microbatches
- Start 2026-11-05T16:58:00Z. Profile the unchanged best tree again: /tmp/nano-r4-profile-base, log /tmp/nano-r4-profile-base.log.
- Investigate overlapping the alternating compute-heavy and memory-heavy parts of independent microbatches on two CUDA streams. Keep original 16-row microbatches, FP8 scale domains and summation order; collect gradients privately, then add them in original order before one optimizer step. This uses the baseline 55.94 GiB peak versus 141 GiB capacity, without changing the global batch.
- Implementation, measurements and validation: pending.
- Profile PID 307613. New isolated worktree /submission/nanochat-overlap starts directly at opt (upstream), so no rejected FP8 kernel code is present in this experiment.
- Profile completed 17:01:01Z: GEMMs 42.51%, attention backward 8.29%, largest FP8 layout kernel 6.42%; forward 29.49%, backward 65.14%. Experiment targets overlap between these compute and memory phases rather than trying to replace cuBLAS.
- Added opt-in NANOCHAT_MICROBATCH_STREAMS=2. Each microbatch keeps its original inputs, scale domains and loss normalization. It computes private gradients on a stream; input copies are protected against the loader persistent-buffer overwrite, and all gradients are joined and added in original microbatch order before the unchanged optimizer step. A mixed-FP32/BF16 unit test compares exact gradients using a persistent-buffer loader.
- Unit tests then timing PID 322618; unit log /tmp/nano-r4-unit-streams.log, driver log /tmp/nano-r4-time-streams.log, output /tmp/nano-r4-time-streams.
- The two eager mixed-dtype unit tests passed, but the first full-model timing run ended with SIGSEGV during compilation before any update (17:03:54Z, 0.034 GPU-hours). No timing score. Testing a default-stream first-backward bootstrap to avoid compiling on a side stream; this still trains the same first microbatch and changes only execution-stream scheduling. Added compiled-model unit coverage and enabled Python faulthandler for the diagnostic retry.
- Bootstrap retry PID 325326; unit log /tmp/nano-r4-unit-streams-v2.log, driver log /tmp/nano-r4-time-streams-v2.log, output /tmp/nano-r4-time-streams-v2.
1.2 hRound 4 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T17:10:00Z, under 30 minutes. Four eager/compiled mixed-dtype accumulation tests passed exactly, but the full-model retry /tmp/nano-r4-time-streams-v2 again reports ERROR, no timing result (17:08:42Z, 0.074 GPU-hours).
- Faulthandler locates the segmentation fault inside the pinned FA3 forward C++ operation on the non-default stream, after the initial default-stream bootstrap. This is not a valid training candidate. Reject overlap with this backend rather than alter attention or weaken a gate; no quick/full precision check is meaningful while the workload crashes.
- No promotion; submission still uses unchanged upstream.
1.4 hRound 5 — microbatch execution granularity
- Start 2026-11-05T17:10:00Z. Profile the current best tree: /tmp/nano-r5-profile-base, log /tmp/nano-r5-profile-base.log.
- Investigate the ta<key> regrouping of identical per-rank token rows into larger microbatches, keeping total tokens/update, optimizer hyperparameters and model precision unchanged. Unlike side-stream overlap this uses the proven default-stream FA3 path.
- Profile PID 339816; actual GPU lock start 17:11:29Z. Isolated worktree /submission/nanochat-granularity is based on unchanged opt.
- Profile completed 17:14:12Z (0.090 GPU-hours): FP8 GEMMs 42.55%, FA3 backward 8.29%, largest memory/layout kernel 6.42%; forward 29.59%, backward 65.30%. Peak memory remains about 56 GiB, leaving room for larger execution granularity.
- Added one opt-in microbatch multiplier, default 1. Multiplier 2 makes 32 rows per microbatch and two accumulation steps per update; total tokens and all optimizer/schedule inputs remain unchanged. The BOS loader fills rows identically across batch boundaries. Tensorwise FP8 remains tensorwise FP8, but its scale domains and reduction order grow with the microbatch, so this is an N1 candidate requiring trajectory validation if useful.
- Batch-32 timing PID 354683, log /tmp/nano-r5-time-batch32.log, output /tmp/nano-r5-time-batch32.
- time completed 17:18:09Z: status ok; windows 0.9870 / 0.9903 / 0.9956 s/update; mean 0.9910; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0925; peak 94.04 GiB; 0.100 GPU-hours. This is a modest improvement over the unchanged-tree control, not yet a gate-1 verdict (the frozen-reference spread sets a higher local benefit bar).
- Quick check PID 368753; log /tmp/nano-r5-quick-batch32.log, output /tmp/nano-r5-quick-batch32.
- Implementation, measurements and validation: pending.
1.4 hRound 5 conclusion
- End of screening 2026-11-05T17:24:20Z. check --quick /tmp/nano-r5-quick-batch32: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass, 0.072 GPU-hours. Batch regrouping preserved rows, update counts, all parameter and optimizer-state dtypes, and hyperparameters.
- Batch 32 is the best measured performance candidate, but is not accepted yet. Queue its official N1 trajectory, using the quick check as the exact-item screen; no full benefit verdict has been obtained.
1.7 hRound 6 — hoisting FP8 scalar scale work
- Profile the best measured batch-32 candidate before modifying it, at /tmp/nano-r6-profile-batch32, log /tmp/nano-r6-profile-and-n1.log. After that profile, the same detached job runs the batch-32 statistical gate at /tmp/nano-r5-n1-batch32.
- Hypothesis to inspect in emitted code: tensorwise FP8 scalar FP64 division is duplicated inside large broadcast/transpose kernels. Materializing the two FP32 scale scalars once may remove that repeated work without changing the quantization recipe or precision.
- The submitted tree stays at the previous version while this candidate is validated; future edits use an independent worktree.
- Profile/statistical queue PID 375059, log /tmp/nano-r6-profile-and-n1.log; GPU lock for the profile began 17:25:29Z. Scalar-scale edits use /submission/nanochat-scales, based on the batch-regrouping commit da5d3db.
- Batch-32 profile completed 17:28:12Z, 0.090 GPU-hours: GEMMs 43.63%, attention backward 8.49%, largest backward quantize/transpose kernel 6.41%, optimizer 4.43%; 94.04 GiB peak. Emitted code confirms that this 65536x6144 kernel computes FP64 reciprocal, clamp and scale conversion from a broadcast scalar in every tile.
- Added opt-in scalar materialization: a deterministic one-block kernel computes the same FP64 scale arithmetic, FP32 rounding and FP32 reciprocal once. The remaining tensor quantization stays in upstream Torch code. Start with gradient E5M2 scales only (grad); all also covers E4M3 scales. Defaults remain off. Unit tests require bitwise scale pairs and FP8 bytes versus compiled upstream expressions.
- Scalar unit tests then timing queued behind the trajectory: PID 398103, unit log /tmp/nano-r6-unit-scales.log, driver log /tmp/nano-r6-time-hoist-grad.log, timing output /tmp/nano-r6-time-hoist-grad.
- Batch-32 statistical gate completed 17:33:23Z: /tmp/nano-r5-n1-batch32/check.json, PASS / N1 (official stdout), 0.172 GPU-hours. Together with the prior exact-item quick check this validates its training semantics. Promoted batch regrouping to the submitted tree and set /submission/switches.json to multiplier 2. Its modest timing benefit is still subject to the final benefit gate; this is not a full-check PASS.

- Gradient-only scalar hoisting passed four unit tests (6.21 s). time /tmp/nano-r6-time-hoist-grad completed 17:36:28Z: status ok; windows 0.9831 / 0.9917 / 0.9903 s/update; mean 0.9884; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0954; 94.04 GiB peak; 0.098 GPU-hours. The sub-percent difference from batch 32 is not a confirmed gain. Next screen materializes both forward and gradient scales, followed by a quick exact-item check.

- All-scale timing and quick-check queue PID 416508; driver log /tmp/nano-r6-time-quick-hoist-all.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r6-time-hoist-all and /tmp/nano-r6-quick-hoist-all. The submission remains the validated batch-32 candidate while this runs.

- All-scale time /tmp/nano-r6-time-hoist-all completed 17:42:21Z: status ok; windows 0.9803 / 0.9865 / 0.9858 s/update; mean 0.9842; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1001; peak 108.76 GiB; 0.084 GPU-hours. This is 0.7% below batch-32 timing, too small to resolve without a paired screen.
- All-scale check --quick /tmp/nano-r6-quick-hoist-all completed 17:44:18Z: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass, 0.064 GPU-hours. Parameter digests also differ from batch-32-only, so the scalar optimization needs its own N1 validation; unit-level bitwise scale tests do not establish full-model N0.

- Paired timing PID 433902; log /tmp/nano-r6-time-paired-hoist-all.log; output /tmp/nano-r6-time-paired-hoist-all. This is a reference-then-candidate screening run, not a full benefit verdict.
1.7 hRound 6 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T17:51:00Z, within 30 minutes. Paired time /tmp/nano-r6-time-paired-hoist-all completed 17:50:48Z: status ok; candidate windows 0.9827 / 0.9863 / 0.9886 s/update, mean 0.9858; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0983; speedup_vs_paired_reference=1.0279 (minimum window ratio). Reference windows 1.0101 / 1.0181 / 1.0219. Cost 0.180 GPU-hours. The combined candidate has a modest screening benefit, not a full-check verdict; the scalar increment alone remains sub-percent.
- Keep the validated batch-32 submission unchanged pending the official N1 trajectory for all-scale hoisting. Commit the isolated implementation and tests as N1 candidate, then run the trajectory outside this screening round. No numerics tier has yet been awarded to the scalar change.

- Scalar N1 / next-profile queue PID 458307, log /tmp/nano-r6-n1-r7-profile.log. Validation output /tmp/nano-r6-n1-hoist-all; on PASS, profile that candidate for round 7 at /tmp/nano-r7-profile-best; otherwise profile the unchanged batch-32 submission there. Isolated scalar commit: 9433561.

- Scalar N1 validation /tmp/nano-r6-n1-hoist-all completed 17:56:57Z: PASS / N1, equivalent at all six endpoints (largest absolute bias 0.432 sigma), 0.164 GPU-hours. Promoted as 37084de; submission now enables batch 32 and all-scale hoisting. This is correctness validation plus paired timing evidence, not a full-check PASS.
2.3 hRound 7 — persistent TMA GEMM backend
- GPU lock start 2026-11-05T17:56:58Z. Profile of the validated best candidate /tmp/nano-r7-profile-best finished 17:59:14Z, status ok, 0.075 GPU-hours. FP8 GEMMs remain 44.35% of CUDA time; FA3 backward 8.57%; optimizer 4.61%; largest quantize/transpose kernel now 3.25% (down from 6.41%, partly offset by forward materialization work). Forward 33.59%, backward 60.35%.
- Hotspot classification: compute/backend configuration. PyTorch 2.9.1 contains an existing Hopper persistent-TMA scaled-mm template, but its enabling flag defaults off. Test that backend with GEMM autotuning on the now-larger microbatch, retaining cuBLAS as a candidate and preserving forward/backward accumulation settings.
- Isolated worktree /submission/nanochat-tma, preset runs/optimization/microbatch-32-hoist-tma.json. No production code changes; TMA is disabled in the submission until measured and validated.

- TMA timing / quick queue PID 478051; driver log /tmp/nano-r7-time-quick-tma.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r7-time-tma and /tmp/nano-r7-quick-tma.

- Profile-only interval accounting on /tmp/nano-r7-profile-best/timing_profile.trace.json: rank-0 GPU kernel union covers 98.565% of its profiled span (12,374 kernels across two updates). This argues against host launch gaps as a large opportunity; it is hotspot evidence, not an alternate training timing measurement.
2.3 hRound 7 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T18:15:30Z, within 30 minutes. time /tmp/nano-r7-time-tma: status ok; windows 0.9826 / 0.9878 / 0.9894 s/update; mean 0.9866; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0974; peak 108.80 GiB; startup 421.1 s; 0.254 GPU-hours. No improvement over the accepted-code-path screening (0.9858 s/update), with much longer compilation.
- check --quick /tmp/nano-r7-quick-tma: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass, 0.231 GPU-hours. No N1 trajectory justified because the backend gives no gain. Reject the preset; submission remains batch 32 plus scalar-scale hoisting.
2.5 hRound 8 — overlap FP8 layout conversion with matrix multiplication
- Profile the current best before any implementation change, adding compiler output logging only. Output /tmp/nano-r8-profile-best; log /tmp/nano-r8-profile-best.log. Isolated worktree /submission/nanochat-layout-overlap starts at submitted commit 37084de.
- Candidate direction to inspect: matrix-input transposes are memory-heavy, while gradient-input GEMMs are compute-heavy. Overlap only pure FP8 transposes with GEMM, not whole microbatches or FA3. Preserve quantization, matmuls, reduction order, and optimizer behavior. Proceed only if the new profile confirms those conversions remain exposed.

- Round-8 profile PID 521812; log /tmp/nano-r8-profile-best.log.

- Profile lock start 18:16:04Z; complete 18:18:20Z, status ok. GEMMs 44.48%, FA3 backward 8.61%, optimizer 4.47%, largest backward quantize/dual-layout kernel 3.27%; forward activation quantize/transpose 1.96%. Emitted code confirms two exposed costs: the backward gradient kernel writes row and column layouts together, and forward recomputes quantized ReLU-squared activations into the layout needed only by backward.
- Implemented opt-in NANOCHAT_FP8_LAYOUT_OVERLAP=1: retain the already-quantized row-major input, use an exact tiled FP8 transpose on a dedicated copy stream, and overlap those copies with the original non-fast-accumulation input-gradient cuBLAS GEMM. Explicit stream dependencies and allocator lifetime records protect all cross-stream buffers. FA3 and the rest of training remain on their original stream. Added eager/compiled bitwise GEMM checks and raw-byte/strided transpose checks, including all FP8 encodings.

- Layout unit-tests / timing queue PID 532392; unit log /tmp/nano-r8-unit-layout.log; driver log /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-overlap.log; timing output /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-overlap.

- The first layout unit run caught a Triton compile-time type issue: integer other=0 cannot be cast directly to FP8 for masked loads. No timing ran. Use floating other=0.0, keeping every loaded FP8 byte unchanged, and rerun the same exact tests.

- Retry PID 532593; unit log /tmp/nano-r8-unit-layout-v2.log; driver log /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-overlap-v2.log; timing output /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-overlap-v2.

- Six layout tests now pass exactly, including compiled custom-op calls and every FP8 byte encoding (5.09 s). time /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-overlap-v2 completed 18:22:59Z: status ok; windows 0.9823 / 0.9890 / 0.9888 s/update; mean 0.9867; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0973; peak 106.76 GiB; 0.078 GPU-hours. No measured gain yet. Profile this experiment to distinguish failed overlap scheduling from added copy traffic before one targeted scheduling adjustment.

- Layout diagnostic profile PID 539042; log /tmp/nano-r8-profile-overlap.log; output /tmp/nano-r8-profile-overlap.

- Diagnostic profile completed 18:26:27Z. It exposes 1,160 transpose launches across two updates (5.60% of summed kernel time). Trace interval intersections show only 5.1–6.7% of their duration overlaps cuBLAS GEMMs: launching the copies before the higher-overhead cuBLAS dispatch lets most copies finish first. Targeted correction: enqueue the GEMM first, then the copy kernels, while retaining the ready-event dependency recorded before that GEMM. All arithmetic, layouts and stream lifetime protections remain unchanged.

- GEMM-first layout retry PID 545242; unit log /tmp/nano-r8-unit-layout-v3.log; driver log /tmp/nano-r8-time-quick-layout-v3.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-overlap-v3 and /tmp/nano-r8-quick-layout-overlap-v3.

- GEMM-first scheduling passes six exact tests (4.03 s). time /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-overlap-v3 completed 18:30:35Z: status ok; windows 0.9810 / 0.9869 / 0.9863; mean 0.9848; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0994; peak 106.76 GiB; 0.078 GPU-hours. The difference remains unresolved versus the current best (0.9858). check --quick /tmp/nano-r8-quick-layout-overlap-v3 completed 18:32:29Z: NOT_BITWISE, exact items pass, 0.062 GPU-hours.
- One final same-hotspot screen restricts overlap to wide matrices (max input/output features at least 4096), leaving attention projections on their original path. This avoids duplicate input transposes at the shared Q/K/V input and limits custom-op dispatch overhead. Default minimum is zero, reproducing the prior all-layer variant; the submitted path stays disabled.

- Wide-layer timing / quick queue PID 559224; log /tmp/nano-r8-time-quick-layout-wide.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-wide and /tmp/nano-r8-quick-layout-wide.
2.5 hRound 8 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T18:40:00Z, within 30 minutes. Wide-only time /tmp/nano-r8-time-layout-wide completed 18:36:24Z: status ok; windows 0.9805 / 0.9837 / 0.9871 s/update; mean 0.9838; speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1005; 106.76 GiB peak; 0.080 GPU-hours. check --quick /tmp/nano-r8-quick-layout-wide completed 18:38:21Z: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass, 0.064 GPU-hours.
- Decision: reject promotion. The best layout variant differs by only 0.04% from the first all-scale timing (0.9842), and only 0.2% from its paired repeat (0.9858). This does not resolve a gain, and the additional stream/copy machinery is not justified. The exact copy/GEMM tests pass and full-model exact items pass, but there is no N1 trajectory or full verdict for this change. Keep it only in the isolated worktree.
2.9 hRound 9 — batched Q/K/V FP8 projections
- Profile the validated best tree again at /tmp/nano-r9-profile-best, log /tmp/nano-r9-profile-best.log, before changing any computation. Isolated worktree /submission/nanochat-qkv starts at submitted commit 37084de.
- Inspect the repeated Q/K/V forward GEMMs for a grouped/merged launch opportunity. Any experiment must retain three independently computed original tensorwise weight scales and the original tensorwise activation scale; broadcasting those unchanged scalars for a grouped GEMM epilogue is not rowwise requantization. Original E5M2 gradient quantization and optimizer remain unchanged.

- Round-9 profile PID 573051; log /tmp/nano-r9-profile-best.log.

- Profile lock 18:40:37Z to 18:42:52Z: FP8 GEMMs 44.12%, FA3 backward 8.59%, optimizer 4.94%, forward 33.30%, backward 60.37%. Correlating the 145 scaled GEMMs in each forward with the fixed six-per-layer source order attributes 288 Q/K/V calls across four microbatches to 3.729% of CUDA kernel time; other forward GEMMs are 11.139%. This is a bounded existing-backend/graph batching opportunity, not a dominant whole-step bottleneck.
- A small exact-integer capability probe confirms both PyTorch 2.9.1 APIs support these GPUs: 3D _scaled_grouped_mm and merged _scaled_mm with broadcast scale vectors each return the expected [16, 32, 64] per-projection values. No timing was taken outside the judge.
- Implemented two opt-in QKV launch variants. Each still invokes the original _to_fp8 separately for all three weight tensors and once for the shared activation tensor; the API scale vectors contain only repeated copies of these original scalars, never row-derived scales. Backward retains three independent E5M2 tensorwise gradient quantizers, the original non-fast GEMMs and BF16 outputs. Parameter objects, names and shapes are unchanged. Unit tests compare forward errors against quantized FP64 and the reference error envelope, require exact weight gradients, and bound only the reordered input-gradient sum against its own reference rounding envelope.

- QKV unit-tests / timing queue PID 583921; unit log /tmp/nano-r9-unit-qkv.log; driver log /tmp/nano-r9-time-qkv.log; timing outputs /tmp/nano-r9-time-qkv-grouped and /tmp/nano-r9-time-qkv-merged.

- All eight initial QKV tests pass (8.70 s). Grouped time /tmp/nano-r9-time-qkv-grouped completed 18:48:35Z: windows 0.9853 / 0.9901 / 0.9885, mean 0.9879, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0960, peak 113.26 GiB, 0.082 GPU-hours. Merged-vector-scale time /tmp/nano-r9-time-qkv-merged completed 18:51:05Z: windows 0.9821 / 0.9885 / 0.9912, mean 0.9873, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0966, peak 113.26 GiB, 0.083 GPU-hours. Neither resolves a gain.
- Final QKV backend screen uses the ordinary tensorwise cuBLAS GEMM with an FP32 temporary, then applies the three unchanged weight inverse scales and returns BF16 projections. It retains more intermediate precision rather than lowering any precision; the model activation boundaries, FP8 quantization domains, parameters and state remain unchanged. This trades the vector-scale backend for an extra FP32 intermediate and needs the same numerical checks.

- Tensorwise-cuBLAS QKV queue PID 609171; unit log /tmp/nano-r9-unit-qkv-v2.log; driver log /tmp/nano-r9-time-quick-qkv-fp32.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r9-time-qkv-fp32 and /tmp/nano-r9-quick-qkv-fp32.
2.9 hRound 9 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T18:58:00Z, within 30 minutes. All 12 tests pass (6.32 s), including the final FP32-temporary variant. time /tmp/nano-r9-time-qkv-fp32 completed 18:55:36Z: windows 0.9971 / 1.0008 / 1.0015 s/update, mean 0.9998, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0829, peak 113.26 GiB, 0.083 GPU-hours. check --quick /tmp/nano-r9-quick-qkv-fp32 completed 18:57:32Z: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass, 0.063 GPU-hours.
- Reject all QKV variants. Grouped and vector-scale merged backends are slightly slower than the best submission; the FP32-temporary tensorwise cuBLAS path is slower still. The same tensorwise quantizers and weight gradients were verified, but the small forward-only GEMM budget does not pay for the launch/layout/temporary changes. No trajectory or promotion is justified.
3.2 hRound 10 — model-only CUDA graph capture
- Profile the validated best tree at /tmp/nano-r10-profile-best, log /tmp/nano-r10-profile-best.log, before changing code. Isolated worktree /submission/nanochat-graphs starts at 37084de.
- Prior profiles price launch gaps at only about 1.4% of the GPU span, so this is a bounded cheap-lever screen. If still warranted, enable graph capture only for the model, not the optimizer graphs with CPU scalar inputs; require capture to succeed rather than silently skip. No change to the model or optimizer arithmetic is intended.

- Round-10 profile PID 623533; log /tmp/nano-r10-profile-best.log.

- Profile lock 18:58:13Z to 19:00:28Z: GEMMs 44.44%, FA3 backward 8.64%, optimizer 4.53%, largest quantize/transpose kernel 3.27%, forward 33.45%, backward 60.62%. The dominant kernels are unchanged, so graph capture is tested only as a small launch/scheduling opportunity.
- Added opt-in NANOCHAT_MODEL_CUDAGRAPHS=1: only the model compiler receives triton.cudagraphs=True and triton.cudagraph_or_error=True; the optimizer compiler configuration stays unchanged. Mark the beginning of each optimizer-update iteration for the graph memory pool. The strict option makes capture failure an error, not a silent skipped-graph timing candidate. Default code paths remain unchanged.

- Fresh profile interval accounting gives 98.557% kernel union coverage, confirming the small exposed launch-gap budget. Graph timing / quick queue PID 634929; log /tmp/nano-r10-time-quick-model-graphs.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r10-time-model-graphs and /tmp/nano-r10-quick-model-graphs.

- Initial graph time and quick check both fail with SIGSEGV before the first update: /tmp/nano-r10-time-model-graphs (19:02:11Z, 0.032 GPU-hours) and /tmp/nano-r10-quick-model-graphs (19:03:10Z, 0.032 GPU-hours). No performance or numerical verdict.
- Isolated the crash without the model or compiler in /tmp/nano-r10-fa3-stream-probe.log: the pinned FA3 forward/backward succeeds on the default stream, then its forward segfaults on an ordinary pooled CUDA stream. This also explains the round-4 failure.
- A second probe /tmp/nano-r10-fa3-external-probe.log wraps the exact same pooled CUDA handle in torch.cuda.ExternalStream: forward and deterministic backward both succeed and are bitwise equal to the default-stream result. The CUDA handle is unchanged; only the PyTorch stream-id representation changes (pooled id 3 versus the raw external handle).
- Added opt-in NANOCHAT_FA3_EXTERNAL_STREAMS=1: a narrow adapter around the cached module low-level fwd/bwd calls uses an external descriptor for the same physical stream, restoring the original descriptor afterward. Default/external stream calls go directly through. No kernel, arithmetic, stream dependency, judge hook or read-only file changes. Added exact pooled-stream and CUDA-graph forward/backward tests for local and full windows. Retry model graphs with this compatibility adapter.

- Stream-adapter tests / graph retry PID 640257; unit log /tmp/nano-r10-unit-stream-adapter.log; driver log /tmp/nano-r10-time-quick-model-graphs-v2.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r10-time-model-graphs-v2 and /tmp/nano-r10-quick-model-graphs-v2.

- The first adapter unit run passes pooled-stream exact checks but its first direct whole-autograd graph capture fails in the autograd engine: the reference had already attached default-stream leaf metadata, creating an implicit dependency on the legacy stream during capture. The second case passes. Corrected the test setup by cloning equal-valued leaves and the upstream gradient on the capture stream before warmup; expected outputs/gradients remain the default-stream reference. No numerical assertion was relaxed and no training timing ran in this failed test queue.

- Corrected graph-unit / timing / quick queue PID 640343; unit log /tmp/nano-r10-unit-stream-adapter-v2.log; driver log /tmp/nano-r10-time-quick-model-graphs-v3.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r10-time-model-graphs-v3 and /tmp/nano-r10-quick-model-graphs-v3.
3.2 hRound 10 conclusion
- Screening ended 2026-11-05T19:23:42Z; diagnostic inspection continued through 19:28:52Z, slightly exceeding the 30-minute round limit. Housekeeping completed 19:32:51Z after handoff. Adapter tests pass (2 cases, 2.55 s), including bitwise forward and all backward outputs on pooled streams and graph replay.
- time /tmp/nano-r10-time-model-graphs-v3: status ok, windows 0.9766 / 0.9818 / 0.9814 s/update, mean 0.9799, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1049, peak allocated 102.79 GiB. This is only a small additional screening gain.
- check --quick /tmp/nano-r10-quick-model-graphs-v3: ERROR, no numerical verdict. Deterministic embedding backward introduces aten.index_put.default, which Inductor marks graph-incompatible; strict graph mode correctly aborts instead of concealing a skipped graph. Graph mode is not promoted. No GPU jobs remain.
- The same-handle FA3 adapter is independently useful for future side-stream experiments. Keep adapter and graph changes isolated and commit them separately; no production precision claim is made for graph mode.
3.8 hRound 11 — retry whole-microbatch overlap
- Profile PID 656990, log /tmp/nano-r11-profile-best.log. GPU lock 19:32:52Z to 19:35:06Z, 0.074 GPU-hours. Profile: FP8 GEMMs 44.27%, FA3 backward 8.58%, optimizer 4.66%, largest quantize/transpose 3.26%; compiled forward 33.57%, backward 60.45%. The graph screen found little launch-gap budget; independent microbatch streams instead test whether memory-bound kernels can overlap tensor-core work.
- Retry in isolated /submission/nanochat-streamed, based on submitted 37084de with the adapter and ordered-sum implementation cherry-picked. Start at original 16-row microbatches and four accumulation steps, scalar hoisting off. The adapter changes descriptors, not CUDA handles or arithmetic. Compare enabling scalar hoisting only if the first result warrants it. No graphs enabled.
- Unit / timing / quick queue PID 666893, driver log /tmp/nano-r11-time-quick-streamed.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r11-unit-streamed.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r11-time-streamed and /tmp/nano-r11-quick-streamed.
- All six unit tests pass (5.01 s). Timing completed 19:39:08Z: status ok, windows 1.0091 / 1.0155 / 1.0151, mean 1.0133 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0685, peak allocated 63.92 GiB, 0.097 GPU-hours. Quick check completed 19:41:15Z: PASS / N0, 0.070 GPU-hours. The fixed stream adapter enables real D24 execution and ordered gradient sums preserve bitwise equality, but this configuration does not beat the submitted batch-32 tree. Next inspect actual concurrency and screen scalar hoisting on the same stream configuration.
- Profile / hoisted timing / quick queue PID 687386, log /tmp/nano-r11-profile-time-quick-hoist.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r11-profile-streamed, /tmp/nano-r11-time-streamed-hoist, /tmp/nano-r11-quick-streamed-hoist.
- Streamed profile completed 19:44:43Z, 0.089 GPU-hours. Both compute streams launch 9,660 kernels across two updates. Trace interval accounting: no kernel 1.75%, one kernel 94.18%, two kernels only 4.06% (including communication overlap). Peak allocated 63.92 GiB but reserved 130.12 GiB. Real concurrency is too limited to justify a larger live microbatch; memory reservations also rule out concurrent batch-32 forwards without further memory work.

- Start with a fresh profile of the validated submitted tree at /tmp/nano-r11-profile-best, log /tmp/nano-r11-profile-best.log. Revisit the prior side-stream experiment only after reviewing this profile, using the proven FA3 stream-descriptor adapter rather than changing kernels or precision.
3.8 hRound 11 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T19:50:00Z, within 30 minutes. Hoisted time /tmp/nano-r11-time-streamed-hoist completed 19:47:12Z: status ok, mean 1.0090 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0730. Quick check /tmp/nano-r11-quick-streamed-hoist completed 19:49:08Z: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass. No trajectory is justified for this slower configuration.
- Reject both overlap variants for performance: neither beats the submitted batch-32 plus scalar-hoisting tree. Original 16-row tensorwise FP8 scale domains plus ordered accumulation pass N0; the FA3 external-stream adapter solves the crash but cannot force kernels with saturated resources to overlap. No submission changes and no jobs remain.
4.1 hRound 12 — backward memory traffic
- Profile the validated submission again before selecting a specific backward memory kernel. Profile output /tmp/nano-r12-profile-best, driver log /tmp/nano-r12-profile-best.log, PID 717855. GPU lock 19:49:57Z to 19:52:11Z. FP8 GEMMs 44.19%, backward 60.48%, forward 33.12%, optimizer 4.93%, largest quantize/transpose 3.25%. Prior rounds exhausted broad backend and launch substitutions; remaining duplicated activation reads in row/column FP8 layout generation are a bounded memory-fusion opportunity.
- Added isolated /submission/nanochat-dual-layout: one Triton pass produces both row-major and transposed FP8 bytes from the same tensorwise scalar scale. Forward saves the column-major activation for weight gradients, avoiding later layout/recomputation. Optional gradient quantization uses the same dual-output kernel. Defaults off; all parameter, activation and optimizer-state dtypes remain unchanged. Custom-op boundaries may alter fusion rounding, so this is an N1 candidate rather than an assumed N0 path.
- Unit / timing / quick queue PID 729973, driver log /tmp/nano-r12-time-quick-dual-input.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r12-unit-dual.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r12-time-dual-input and /tmp/nano-r12-quick-dual-input.
- Initial 14 byte-exact quantization tests pass (5.82 s). Input-only time completed 19:57:18Z: status ok, windows 0.9628 / 0.9671 / 0.9692, mean 0.9664 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1203, peak allocated 108.76 GiB, startup 110.1 s, 0.081 GPU-hours. Quick check completed 19:59:11Z: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass. This improves the best measured candidate enough to justify the official statistical gate. Added full eager FP8 linear forward/backward exact comparisons for all three dual-layout modes before further screening.
- Linear unit / input N1 / all-layout timing / quick queue PID 748019, log /tmp/nano-r12-n1-time-quick-dual.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r12-unit-dual-linear.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r12-n1-dual-input, /tmp/nano-r12-time-dual-all, /tmp/nano-r12-quick-dual-all.
- All 17 unit tests pass (4.27 s), including bitwise complete eager FP8 linear forward, input gradients and weight gradients. Official input-only statistical gate completed 20:05:12Z: PASS / N1, maximum endpoint bias 0.205 sigma, 0.161 GPU-hours. Combined with its exact-item quick check, this validates the new input-layout configuration. Promoted commit dc94848 and set NANOCHAT_FP8_DUAL_LAYOUTS=input in /submission/switches.json; the all-layout variant remains an isolated screening configuration.
- All-layout time /tmp/nano-r12-time-dual-all completed 20:07:31Z: status ok, windows 0.9518 / 0.9582 / 0.9598, mean 0.9566 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1318, peak allocated 100.76 GiB, 0.077 GPU-hours. Quick check /tmp/nano-r12-quick-dual-all completed 20:09:19Z: NOT_BITWISE, exact items pass. The additional gradient-layout kernel gives another roughly 1% in this screening; queue its N1 gate, then paired timing and a full check only if N1 passes. Full-check time is outside the round budget.
- N1 / paired timing / full-check queue PID 767631, log /tmp/nano-r12-n1-paired-full-dual-all.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r12-n1-dual-all, /tmp/nano-r12-time-paired-dual-all, /tmp/nano-r12-full-dual-all.
- All-layout N1 completed 20:15:14Z: PASS / N1, largest endpoint bias 0.2125 sigma, 0.159 GPU-hours. Promote NANOCHAT_FP8_DUAL_LAYOUTS=all; both layouts now have official exact-item and statistical evidence. Paired timing starts 20:15:15Z and the full check follows it. The submission is not waiting on those jobs to become numerically valid.
4.1 hRound 12 implementation conclusion
- Implementation and precision work ended 2026-11-05T20:15:14Z, within 30 minutes of the profile lock. Promoted both input and gradient dual layouts: mean 0.9566 s/update and 1.1318x frozen mean screening, exact items pass, official N1 passes. Paired confirmation and the full benefit check remain in the detached queue above; do not confuse these mean screening gains with a full-check PASS.
4.1 hRound 12 confirmation
- Paired time /tmp/nano-r12-time-paired-dual-all completed 2026-11-05T20:20:28Z: windows 0.9506 / 0.9573 / 0.9604, mean 0.9561 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1324, speedup_vs_paired_reference=1.0590, 0.173 GPU-hours. This follow-up confirmation ran 31 seconds past the initial 30-minute lock interval; no implementation changes were made after 20:15:14Z.
- Full check /tmp/nano-r12-full-dual-all completed 20:22:48Z: UNAVAILABLE / no_benefit at gate 1. Windows 0.9529 / 0.9599 / 0.9604, minimum per-window speedup 1.0597, below the frozen-reference bar 1.1214 because its spread is 6.07%. The judge correctly stops without record/trajectory work. Separate official exact-item and N1 checks already pass for this same code/configuration. Do not call this a full-check PASS; final evaluation retimes the reference pair.
4.6 hRound 13 — profile the dual-layout best
- New profile /tmp/nano-r13-profile-best, driver log /tmp/nano-r13-profile-best.log, PID 800814. Lock 20:23:37Z to 20:25:43Z. FP8 GEMMs 45.90%, dual-layout quantization 9.48%, FA3 backward 8.89%, optimizer 4.79%; forward 32.17%, backward 61.60%.
- The newly introduced dual-layout kernel is now a concentrated 9.48% memory hotspot, with only its initial 32x128/4-warps configuration tested. Prefer a bounded tile search before rewriting another operator or replacing cuBLAS. It launches 772 narrow, 192 wide and 4 head-sized kernels over two updates; narrow and wide shapes each account for roughly half its GPU time.
- Isolated /submission/nanochat-dual-tune adds NANOCHAT_FP8_DUAL_TILE, defaulting to the current 32x128x4. Screen 64x128x4, 128x64x4, 128x128x8, 64x256x8. Arithmetic, tensorwise scales and all dtypes are unchanged. Parameterize all 17 exact quantizer/linear tests across the five tiles. The judge has no sweep subcommand in this image, so run ordinary time commands sequentially, never a local timer.
- Unit / four timing runs PID 808633, log /tmp/nano-r13-time-tiles.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r13-unit-tiles.log; timing outputs /tmp/nano-r13-time-tile-64x128x4, /tmp/nano-r13-time-tile-128x64x4, /tmp/nano-r13-time-tile-128x128x8, /tmp/nano-r13-time-tile-64x256x8.
- All 85 exact tests pass (16.11 s). All four timings are valid: 64x128x4 mean 0.9538 s/update, frozen speedup 1.1351; 128x64x4 mean 0.9583, speedup 1.1298; 128x128x8 mean 0.9567, speedup 1.1317; 64x256x8 mean 0.9543, speedup 1.1345. Last run ended 20:38:02Z. No resolved improvement over the submitted 0.9561 paired screen; keep the original tile rather than promoting noise. Run a final quick check of the fastest screen to document exactness, then close this direction.
- Quick check PID 840140, log /tmp/nano-r13-quick-tile.log, output /tmp/nano-r13-quick-tile-64x128x4.
4.6 hRound 13 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T20:41:20Z, within 30 minutes. Quick check /tmp/nano-r13-quick-tile-64x128x4: NOT_BITWISE versus frozen upstream, all exact items pass. Comparing its records against the submitted dual-layout candidate shows identical parameter digests after all ten updates on both ranks (N0 increment relative to the N1 best). The four tile screens give no resolved gain; reject the optional tuning interface and leave the submission unchanged. All 85 byte/gradient exact tests pass. Keep this bounded search as evidence, not a new claimed speedup.
4.9 hRound 14 — remaining FP8 GEMM choices
- Profile the submitted best at /tmp/nano-r14-profile-best, log /tmp/nano-r14-profile-best.log, PID 845340. Lock 20:42:08Z to 20:44:12Z: GEMMs 45.70%, quantization/layout 9.50%, FA3 backward 8.84%, optimizer 4.87%. Select the dominant GEMM backend as this round hotspot.
- Added isolated /submission/nanochat-cublaslt: opt-in direct cuBLASLt algorithm screening, using the installed library and its headers (primary sources). Matrix layouts, FP8 input bytes, per-tensor FP32 inverse scales, BF16 outputs and the original forward/backward fast-accum flags are preserved. Algorithms are restricted to no split reduction or a separate FP32 workspace reduction; output-dtype/in-place reductions are excluded in all modes. Cache plans per shape and stream and reserve a per-stream 128 MiB workspace. No deterministic/judging mode detection.
- Screen heuristic ranks 0, 1 and 3 (clamped only when fewer supported algorithms exist, logged per plan). Unit tests compare repeated outputs bitwise and arbitrate against the same quantized inputs in FP64, then use the judge for all timing. Main submission is unchanged.
- Unit / three timing runs PID 853042, driver log /tmp/nano-r14-time-cublaslt.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r14-unit-cublaslt.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r14-time-cublaslt-0, /tmp/nano-r14-time-cublaslt-1, /tmp/nano-r14-time-cublaslt-3.
- All 12 unit cases pass (2.50 s). Valid timings: index 0 mean 0.9570 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1313; index 1 mean 0.9624, speedup 1.1250; index 3 mean 0.9854, speedup 1.0987. Last ends 20:53:00Z. Each production shape exposes 8 supported algorithms. Index 0 is essentially the submitted speed, and alternatives lose. Before closing the backend direction, query whether these FP8 kernels support a separate FP32 split-K reduction for large-inner-dimension weight gradients; this is a capability probe, not a timer.
- Capability probe /tmp/nano-r14-splitk-capabilities.log: all 8 algorithms for the representative 1536x1536x65536 weight-gradient shape support split-K and only reduction-mask 2 (separate FP32 partials). Added an opt-in split-K override for gradient GEMMs whose inner dimension dominates both output dimensions, validated by cublasLtMatmulAlgoCheck; unsupported configurations are explicitly logged and retain the unmodified heuristic. Screen split 2 and 4 with 1 GiB workspace, with no dtype or fast-accum changes. Expand unit tests across both splits before timing.
- Split unit / timings / fastest quick queue PID 875079, log /tmp/nano-r14-time-quick-split.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r14-unit-cublaslt-split.log; time outputs /tmp/nano-r14-time-split-2, /tmp/nano-r14-time-split-4.
4.9 hRound 14 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T21:02:52Z, within 30 minutes. All 36 unit cases pass (2.66 s). Split-2 time /tmp/nano-r14-time-split-2: mean 0.9639 s/update, frozen speedup 1.1232. Split-4 time /tmp/nano-r14-time-split-4: mean 0.9715, speedup 1.1145. Quick check /tmp/nano-r14-quick-split-2: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass. Separate FP32 split-K reductions work but are slower on this workload.
- Reject direct cuBLASLt configuration changes. Heuristic 0 only matches the submitted implementation; alternate heuristic ranks and explicit split-K lose performance. No N1 trajectory is justified, and no submission changes are made. This exhausts the bounded existing-backend GEMM configuration screen.
5.3 hRound 15 — attention backend accounting
- Fresh best-tree profile /tmp/nano-r15-profile-best, log /tmp/nano-r15-profile-best.log, PID 896734. Lock 21:03:53Z to 21:05:57Z: GEMMs 45.64%, dual layouts 9.49%, attention backward 8.80%, optimizer 4.98%. Select attention backend choice, retaining the same BF16 inputs and causal/sliding windows.
- Installed PyTorch exposes native flash forward/backward operators with explicit left/right windows and a deterministic backward implementation. Probe /tmp/nano-r15-native-attention-probe-v2.log confirms strict deterministic mode, bitwise repeated gradients, and small BF16 differences from FA3; dense backward correctly accepts undefined cumulative-sequence tensors (None), not empty tensors. An initial probe merely unpacked five outputs into four variables and was corrected before any training run.
- Isolated /submission/nanochat-native-attention adds an opt-in native attention autograd wrapper, using the same path in production and deterministic mode. Cached FA3 still loads normally and remains the default and KV-cache path. Screen native for all training layers and for only local-window layers. Tests cover eager/compiled full and local attention, all input gradients, strict determinism and FP64 arbitration against FA3.
- Unit / two timings / local quick queue PID 904064, log /tmp/nano-r15-time-quick-native.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r15-unit-native-attention.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r15-time-native, /tmp/nano-r15-time-native-local, /tmp/nano-r15-quick-native-local.
- All six unit tests pass (5.01 s). Native-all time: mean 1.0318 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0493; native-local time: mean 1.0038, speedup 1.0786. Both lose clearly to FA3. Quick local check ends 21:15:35Z: NOT_BITWISE, exact items pass. No trajectory or promotion is justified. Before closing the standard attention-backend screen, test installed cuDNN attention only for full-window layers, leaving local-window semantics in FA3 and avoiding a dense local-mask allocation.
- Added cudnn-full as a separate opt-in choice in the same experiment. It calls the existing native cuDNN SDPA operator with BF16 tensors and the exact causal mask. Local windows remain FA3. Extend strict deterministic/FP64 tests to cuDNN full windows, including 2048-token sequences, before any timing.
- Extended unit / cuDNN timing / quick queue PID 925088, log /tmp/nano-r15-time-quick-cudnn.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r15-unit-cudnn-attention.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r15-time-cudnn-full and /tmp/nano-r15-quick-cudnn-full.
- This queue stops in unit tests: 11 pass, 4 are intentionally out-of-scope local-window skips, and eager cuDNN at 2048 tokens fails exact repeated-gradient equality despite torch deterministic algorithms being enabled. No timing or quick check runs. Test cuDNN with its explicit deterministic backend flag enabled in both production and validation whenever the opt-in cuDNN path is selected; preserve the strict repeat assertion rather than weakening it. The judge already enables this additional flag in deterministic checks.
- Explicit-determinism unit / time / quick retry PID 925300, log /tmp/nano-r15-time-quick-cudnn-det.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r15-unit-cudnn-deterministic.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r15-time-cudnn-full-det and /tmp/nano-r15-quick-cudnn-full-det.
5.3 hRound 15 conclusion
- End 2026-11-05T21:24:37Z, within 30 minutes. Native flash attention is numerically sound in the tested eager/compiled cases and passes the exact-item quick screen, but native-all (1.0318 s/update) and native-local (1.0038) are both much slower than the submission. Reject both.
- The cuDNN full-window option still fails eager repeated-gradient equality at 2048 tokens even with both torch deterministic algorithms and the explicit cuDNN deterministic flag enabled: /tmp/nano-r15-unit-cudnn-deterministic.log, 11 pass, 4 scoped skips, 1 failure. Do not relax this requirement or special-case validation. No cuDNN timing runs; reject this unqualified backend. Submission remains unchanged and all round-15 jobs have exited.
5.7 hRound 16 — QK normalization and rotary fusion
- Profile the submitted best with emitted compiler code at /tmp/nano-r16-profile-best, log /tmp/nano-r16-profile-best.log, PID 925531. Lock 21:24:38Z to 21:26:42Z. Target QK preparation: rotary+norm forward 1.918%, norm backward reduction 1.004%, inverse-rotary/norm elementwise backward 1.421%, plus subsequent half-gradient reassembly traffic.
- Actual source inspection is essential: this model rotates before RMS normalization, then multiplies by 1.2; its compiled normalization epsilon is FP32 epsilon (1.1920928955078125e-7), not BF16 epsilon. Forward normalizes unrounded FP32 rotary intermediates but saves BF16 rotary values for backward. The backward uses those rounded values, the saved FP32 inverse RMS, and unrounded FP32 scaled upstream gradients. Preserve all these boundaries.
- Added isolated fused forward/backward kernels in /submission/nanochat-qk-rope. Save the original BF16 projections and FP32 inverse RMS, recompute rotary values in backward, reproduce the reference saved-BF16 rounding there, and directly write contiguous input gradients instead of four separate half buffers. This removes forward rotary buffer writes and backward reduction/reassembly traffic. Fixed per-row reductions are deterministic; only reduction grouping and fusion rounding may differ (N1 candidate). Default off; 128-dimensional BF16 CUDA heads only; other paths stay upstream.
- Unit / time / quick queue PID 933715, log /tmp/nano-r16-time-quick-qk.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r16-unit-qk.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r16-time-qk and /tmp/nano-r16-quick-qk.
- All 10 initial tests pass (8.19 s). Time completes 21:34:23Z: status ok, windows 0.9295 / 0.9349 / 0.9382, mean 0.9342 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1590, peak 100.76 GiB, startup 88.9 s, 0.069 GPU-hours. Quick completes 21:35:56Z: NOT_BITWISE, exact items pass. This is a resolved improvement worth the statistical gate. Add explicit shape/stride/dtype/constant-trig guards and exact fallback tests before promotion; eligible production and probe shapes take the unchanged new kernel path.
- Guard unit / N1 / paired timing queue PID 945813, log /tmp/nano-r16-n1-paired-qk.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r16-unit-qk-guards.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r16-n1-qk and /tmp/nano-r16-time-paired-qk.
- All 12 tests, including guards, pass (4.90 s). Official N1 gate completes 21:41:47Z: PASS / N1, maximum endpoint bias 0.276 sigma, 0.143 GPU-hours. Promote the guarded QK fusion and enable NANOCHAT_FUSE_QK_ROPE=1. The production/probe shapes all satisfy its guards; exact-item evidence comes from the earlier quick run, and the added guard paths preserve the original expression on unsupported inputs. Paired confirmation is running on this same source.
5.7 hRound 16 confirmation and conclusion
- Paired timing completed 2026-11-05T21:46:45Z at /tmp/nano-r16-time-paired-qk/time.json: status ok, candidate windows 0.9293 / 0.9355 / 0.9346 s/update, mean 0.9332, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1602, speedup_vs_paired_reference=1.0889. Reference windows 1.0119 / 1.0197 / 1.0201; peak candidate allocated 100.76 GiB, startup 87.2 s, total paired cost 0.165 GPU-hours. Numerics N1 PASS already recorded. This confirms the QK-fused best in screening, not a full-check verdict. Round ends 21:46:50Z, within the 30-minute limit.
6.0 hRound 17 — profile the QK-fused best
- Start a fresh best-tree profile with emitted code using /submission/r17-profile.json; next hotspot will be selected from its stage/module/kernel accounting. Preserve the N1-validated submitted tree while experiments run separately. Detached PID 978670, driver log /tmp/nano-r17-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r17-profile-best.
- Profile lock 21:47:45Z to 21:49:34Z, 0.060 GPU-hours. FP8 GEMMs 47.11%, quantize-dual 9.74%, attention backward 9.09%, optimizer 4.85%; compiled forward 32.40%, backward 61.05%. Select MLP activation/FP8 preparation: forward ReLU-square plus amax is 2.20% of kernel time, backward derivative plus amax is 3.17%, followed by dual-layout quantization. Emitted code confirms scales use unrounded FP32 activation/derivative maxima, while quantization reads BF16-rounded values. This is a new fusion opportunity after the backend/tile searches, not a missed fast path.
- Implement in isolated /submission/nanochat-mlp-fusion, behind NANOCHAT_FUSE_FP8_MLP: fuse ReLU-square and its backward derivative into the existing tensorwise FP8 preparation without changing GEMMs, scale precision, or saved-value rounding. Keep all parameter names/dtypes and training semantics unchanged.
- Unit / timing / quick queue PID 986601, driver log /tmp/nano-r17-time-quick-mlp-all.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r17-unit-mlp.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r17-time-mlp-all and /tmp/nano-r17-quick-mlp-all. The new deterministic reduction computes unrounded FP32 maxima, uses the same FP64 scale division, and rounds activation/derivative values to BF16 before FP8 conversion. No precision switch is changed.
- Initial tests: all 16 exact activation quantization/repetition cases pass; one of two compiled complete-MLP cases fails bitwise gradient comparison. No judge timing has run yet. Investigate compiler rounding boundaries before proceeding; debug PID 988034, log /tmp/nano-r17-debug-mlp.log.
- The failing shape passes bitwise in isolation. The sequential test enabled automatic dynamic generalization, unlike the recipe, which explicitly compiles dynamic=False. Set that same option in the unit comparison (no assertions relaxed) and rerun the complete suite before judge timing. The implementation remains the same for all modes and retains its fixed deterministic reduction.
- Static unit / time / quick queue PID 988637, driver log /tmp/nano-r17-time-quick-mlp-static.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r17-unit-mlp-static.log; official output directories unchanged because the aborted queue never ran either judge command.
- All 18 static tests pass (7.73 s), including exact complete-MLP forward/backward comparisons. All-fusion time /tmp/nano-r17-time-mlp-all completes 21:57:45Z: status ok, mean 0.9208 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1758. Quick /tmp/nano-r17-quick-mlp-all completes 21:59:15Z: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass. This is a small gain over the QK-fused 0.9332 paired screening; screen the forward-only variant, then validate the better one statistically and paired before promotion.
- All-fusion windows 0.9163 / 0.9226 / 0.9233; peak allocated 100.76 GiB, startup 84.9 s, cost 0.066 GPU-hours. Forward-only screen PID 1001245, log /tmp/nano-r17-time-mlp-forward.log, output /tmp/nano-r17-time-mlp-forward.
- Forward-only time completes 22:01:51Z: mean 0.9235 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1724, slightly slower than all-fusion (not a resolved sub-percent difference). Keep the all-fusion candidate for confirmation. Both ranks of its quick recording have every parameter digest after all ten updates identical to the prior QK-fused best: the incremental change is N0 in this recording; the combined submission remains N1 relative to upstream. Run the official statistical gate anyway, then paired timing if it passes.
- N1 / paired confirmation queue PID 1007945, log /tmp/nano-r17-n1-paired-mlp-all.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r17-n1-mlp-all and /tmp/nano-r17-time-paired-mlp-all. Submission stays on the previously validated QK-fused best until the new official statistical result is known.
- Official N1 completes 22:06:42Z: PASS / N1, maximum endpoint bias 0.2771 sigma, 0.140 GPU-hours. Promote the all-fusion implementation and enable NANOCHAT_FUSE_FP8_MLP=all; unit tests and the quick exact-item check already pass. Paired timing begins 22:06:43Z on this same tree. The full-check benefit threshold is still not claimed.
6.0 hRound 17 confirmation and conclusion
- Paired confirmation /tmp/nano-r17-time-paired-mlp-all completes 2026-11-05T22:11:36Z: candidate windows 0.9177 / 0.9214 / 0.9247 s/update, mean 0.9213, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1752, speedup_vs_paired_reference=1.1007. Reference windows 1.0110 / 1.0185 / 1.0178; total paired cost 0.162 GPU-hours. Submitted commit d66aebc is the official N1-validated combination. Round ends 22:11:37Z, within 30 minutes. The additional approximately 1.3% versus the prior QK paired result repeats in this screening; no full-check benefit verdict is implied.
6.4 hRound 18 — profile the MLP-fused best
- Start a fresh current-submission profile with compiler output using /submission/r18-profile.json before choosing the next hotspot. Preserve the validated submitted configuration during experiments.
- Profile detached PID 1036645, log /tmp/nano-r18-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r18-profile-best.
- Profile lock 22:12:03Z to 22:13:49Z. FP8 GEMMs 47.93%, attention backward 9.24%, MLP activation quantization 8.34%, optimizer 5.14%. NCCL kernels total 2.712% (reduce-scatter FP32 0.764%, BF16 0.545%, all-gather 1.398%, scalar all-reduce 0.005%); every collective uses Ring/LL. Upstream already disables automatic GC; no data/host straggler hotspot is exposed. Choose this communication/backend class for an inexpensive configuration screen before optimizer rewrites.
- Consulted only NVIDIA NCCL primary documentation: installed NCCL 2.27.5 has NCCL_PROTO and minimum/maximum CTA controls. Do not force LL128 on an unsupported topology. Isolated /submission/nanochat-nccl-tune screens Simple protocol, minimum 32 CTAs, and maximum 8 CTAs separately; all model/optimizer code and arithmetic remain unchanged.
- Detached screen PID 1044792, log /tmp/nano-r18-time-nccl-screen.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r18-time-nccl-simple, /tmp/nano-r18-time-nccl-min32, /tmp/nano-r18-time-nccl-max8.
- Screens finish 22:21:26Z. Simple: windows 0.9174 / 0.9221 / 0.9236, mean 0.9210 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1756. Minimum 32 CTAs: 0.9161 / 0.9229 / 0.9211, mean 0.9201, frozen 1.1767. Maximum 8 CTAs: 0.9277 / 0.9323 / 0.9347, mean 0.9316, frozen 1.1622. Costs 0.067 / 0.066 / 0.067 GPU-hours. Neither Simple nor min-32 resolves a gain over the 0.9213 paired best; max-8 is slower. Reject the configuration class rather than promote noise. Run quick on min-32 to document whether communication changes affect exactness; no statistical or full check is warranted without benefit.
- Min-32 quick PID 1068839, log /tmp/nano-r18-quick-nccl-min32.log, output /tmp/nano-r18-quick-nccl-min32.
6.4 hRound 18 conclusion
- Min-32 quick finishes 2026-11-05T22:24:33Z: NOT_BITWISE versus upstream, all exact items pass. All parameter snapshots after all ten updates match the submitted MLP-fused best on both ranks (N0 increment in the recording). No resolved performance gain, so no changes promoted and no N1 trajectory spent on this class. Round ends 22:24:59Z, within 30 minutes. Experimental configuration files are committed separately; main stays d66aebc with no NCCL overrides.
6.7 hRound 19 — profile before the next fusion
- Profile the unchanged validated best again with compiler output before choosing another kernel boundary. No new hotspot is selected yet.
- Detached profile PID 1074395, log /tmp/nano-r19-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r19-profile-best; config /submission/r18-profile.json still exactly represents the current best plus emitted-code logging.
- Profile lock 22:25:20Z to approximately 22:27:20Z: FP8 GEMMs 47.92%, backward 61.36%, forward 31.97%, optimizer 5.05%. RMS backward-tagged kernels total 5.488%; norm/rsqrt-tagged preparation another 3.583% (partly optimizer). By comparison, softmax/loss plus head gradient quantization total only 2.413%. Select normalization reduction codegen as the larger opportunity.
- Emitted RMS backward kernels loop over 1536 channels twice, reread up to seven full BF16 tensors, and write/read a full FP32 normalized intermediate. Primary PyTorch 2.9.1 InductorChoices source explains the missed fast path: persistent thresholds are 1024 for INNER but only 64 for DEFAULT; these fused RMS kernels have DEFAULT hints. The existing multi-kernel knob only raises DEFAULT to 1024. Use the documented V.set_choices_handler extension to select existing persistent kernels for reductions 1025..limit with at least 4096 outer elements. Fixed-codegen choice in both deterministic and production modes, no kernel autotuning override or dtype changes.
- Implement isolated /submission/nanochat-persistent-norm, switch NANOCHAT_PERSISTENT_REDUCTION_LIMIT (off at 0). Start with limit 2048; retain library heuristics everywhere else and do not touch the optimizer algorithm or model arithmetic.
- Unit / timing / quick queue PID 1081085, driver log /tmp/nano-r19-time-quick-persistent.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r19-unit-persistent.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r19-time-persistent-2048 and /tmp/nano-r19-quick-persistent-2048.
- All 7 policy/FP64/repetition tests pass (4.81 s). Limit-2048 time completes 22:32:53Z: status ok, mean 0.9184 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1789. Quick completes 22:34:22Z: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass. The small difference from the 0.9213 paired best is not yet resolved. Profile this candidate to verify persistent codegen actually replaces the targeted kernels, and screen limit 8192 as the same reduction-policy class.
- Limit-2048 windows 0.9145 / 0.9204 / 0.9205, peak allocated 100.76 GiB, startup 84.1 s, cost 0.066 GPU-hours. Its parameter snapshots differ from the prior best, so any promotion needs N1. Profile / limit-8192 queue PID 1094122, log /tmp/nano-r19-profile-time-persistent.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r19-profile-persistent and /tmp/nano-r19-time-persistent-8192.
- Candidate profile finishes 22:37:00Z: forward rsqrt-tagged kernels fall from 65.61 to 50.94 ms across the two profiled updates, but RMS backward remains non-persistent (100.48 versus 101.12 ms). The current V choices handler is thread-local, so setting it in the training thread did not propagate to lazy backward compilation. Limit-8192 timing 22:39:00Z is similarly 0.9183 s/update, frozen 1.1790, not a resolved gain.
- Correct the missed backward fast path by passing a standard Inductor backend wrapper whose compile_fx_inner call installs the choices context for each forward or backward compilation. This preserves Inductor and all deterministic first-configuration behavior. Revalidate rather than assume the earlier quick check covers this correction.
- Corrected unit / time / quick queue PID 1108817, log /tmp/nano-r19-time-quick-persistent-backend.log, unit output /tmp/nano-r19-unit-persistent-backend.log; official outputs /tmp/nano-r19-time-persistent-backend and /tmp/nano-r19-quick-persistent-backend.
- Corrected backend: all 7 tests pass (4.07 s). time finishes 22:41:57Z at 0.9058 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1953; quick finishes 22:43:21Z, NOT_BITWISE with exact items passing. This resolves a gain over the prior 0.9213 paired best. Queue N1 and paired confirmation before promotion; the ordinary full benefit check is now close enough to its noisy frozen threshold to justify another attempt after confirmation.
- Corrected windows 0.9011 / 0.9061 / 0.9102; startup 71.1 s, peak 100.76 GiB, cost 0.058 GPU-hours. N1 / paired / full-check queue PID 1119178, log /tmp/nano-r19-n1-paired-full-persistent.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r19-n1-persistent-backend, /tmp/nano-r19-time-paired-persistent-backend, /tmp/nano-r19-full-persistent-backend. Full-check duration is outside the round budget. Main remains on the prior N1-validated best while N1 is pending.
- Official N1 completes 22:48:08Z: PASS / N1, maximum endpoint bias 0.2233 sigma, cost 0.135 GPU-hours. Promote the corrected persistent forward/backward policy at limit 2048; all exact items and tests already pass. Paired confirmation starts 22:48:09Z, followed by the ordinary full check. No full benefit verdict is claimed yet.
6.7 hRound 19 confirmation and conclusion
- Paired timing /tmp/nano-r19-time-paired-persistent-backend finishes 2026-11-05T22:52:49Z: candidate windows 0.9022 / 0.9074 / 0.9099 s/update, mean 0.9065, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1944, speedup_vs_paired_reference=1.1196. Reference windows 1.0104 / 1.0177 / 1.0187; cost 0.155 GPU-hours. Submitted commit 1632e1a has official N1 and exact-item evidence. Round ends 22:53:05Z within 30 minutes. The ordinary full check starts 22:52:49Z and is outside the round budget; wait for that verdict before scheduling another GPU job.
6.7 hRound 19 full-check result
- Ordinary full check /tmp/nano-r19-full-persistent-backend finishes 2026-11-05T22:54:35Z: UNAVAILABLE / no_benefit. Candidate windows 0.9024 / 0.9075 / 0.9109 s/update; minimum frozen window ratio 1.1190 versus required 1.1214. Cost 0.058 GPU-hours. It stops at gate 1 and does not repeat precision; the separate exact-item and N1 evidence remains valid. This is a narrow miss against the noisy frozen spread, not a full-check PASS. Final evaluation retimes both reference arms and still decides acceptance.
7.2 hRound 20 — profile the fully persistent best
- Start a fresh profile of submitted 1632e1a, including persistent codegen in both forward and backward, before selecting this round hotspot. Config /submission/r20-profile.json; retain the N1-validated submitted settings during experiments.
- Detached profile PID 1155265, log /tmp/nano-r20-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r20-profile-best.
- Profile completes 22:56:57Z: FP8 GEMMs 49.24%, attention backward 9.56%, MLP activation quantization 8.47%, optimizer 5.01%. Persistent RMS backward is now confirmed active: 75.64 ms / 4.186% across two updates, down from 100.48 ms before the complete policy; rsqrt preparation is 50.79 ms / 2.811%. Representative backward launch has one row per CTA, 8 warps, 60 registers/thread and estimated 50% occupancy.
- Select the remaining normalization launch configuration. Primary PyTorch runtime source lists row tiles 1/8/32/128 under a 4096-element cap, which leaves only row tile 1 for the 2048-wide padded D24 reduction; it omits valid row tile 2. Isolated /submission/nanochat-reduction-tiles screens fixed 2-row/8-warp, 2-row/16-warp, and 1-row/4-warp launches. Only the persistent configuration generator for large outer batches and padded width 2048 is changed. It returns one fixed configuration in both deterministic and production modes; all other kernels retain library choices.
- Unit / timing queue PID 1160378, driver log /tmp/nano-r20-time-tiles.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r20-unit-tiles.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r20-time-tile-2x8, /tmp/nano-r20-time-tile-2x16, /tmp/nano-r20-time-tile-1x4.
- Initial unit run: all 3 compiled GPU precision/repetition cases pass; the 3 direct configuration tests fail because the native helper expects a metadata dictionary, despite its optional default. Normalize absent metadata to an empty dictionary and correct the direct native-helper test call; no numerical assertions are relaxed. The aborted queue never reached judge timing.
- Corrected unit / three-screen queue PID 1160642, log /tmp/nano-r20-time-tiles-fixed.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r20-unit-tiles-fixed.log; uses the previously planned, not-yet-created timing output directories.
- All 6 tests pass (5.58 s; expected cache-disable warnings). Screens: 2x8 mean 0.9053 s/update, windows 0.9007 / 0.9069 / 0.9084, frozen speedup 1.1960; 2x16 mean 0.9059, windows 0.9011 / 0.9061 / 0.9106, frozen 1.1952; 1x4 mean 0.9065, windows 0.9027 / 0.9074 / 0.9093, frozen 1.1944. Each costs 0.058 GPU-hours. None yet resolves a gain from 0.9065 paired best. Profile 2x8 and run quick before concluding: the actual launch must change, not merely the parent-process configuration generator.
- Profile / quick queue PID 1177624, log /tmp/nano-r20-profile-quick-tile.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r20-profile-tile-2x8 and /tmp/nano-r20-quick-tile-2x8.
- Profile 23:10:23Z confirms the requested tiles did not reach production: all RMS launches remain grid 65536 with 256 threads, identical to one-row/eight-warp baseline. Quick 23:11:47Z passes exact items and all ten parameter snapshots match the prior best on both ranks. The nominal tile timings therefore are not evidence about those tiles. Primary AsyncCompile / _worker_compile_triton source confirms kernels are loaded and configured anew in compiler subprocesses. Test TORCHINDUCTOR_COMPILE_THREADS=1 to keep configuration in the process that installs the fixed tile; this changes compilation scheduling, not training precision or arithmetic.
- Serial time / profile / quick queue PID 1185816, log /tmp/nano-r20-serial-tile.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r20-time-tile-2x8-serial, /tmp/nano-r20-profile-tile-2x8-serial, /tmp/nano-r20-quick-tile-2x8-serial.
7.2 hRound 20 conclusion
- Serial 2x8 time completes 2026-11-05T23:16:31Z: windows 0.9034 / 0.9077 / 0.9099 s/update, mean 0.9070, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1937, startup 99.4 s, cost 0.074 GPU-hours. Profile 23:18:32Z confirms the intended grid 32768 / 256 threads; representative backward register counts rise to 96–128, versus 57–64 previously. This is a real two-row test, with no gain over the submitted 0.9065 paired best.
- Quick 23:20:20Z: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass; parameter snapshots now differ from the prior best, confirming a real numerical codegen change. No N1 or full check is spent on the slower variant. No changes promoted. Earlier parallel 1x4 / 2x16 / 2x8 runs used unchanged launch configurations and must not be cited as evidence against those actual tiles. The experimental implementation and configurations are committed separately. Round ends 23:20:22Z within 30 minutes; submission remains 1632e1a.
7.6 hRound 21 — reprofile the validated best
- Fresh profile of the unchanged submitted tree before selecting another remaining kernel/backend opportunity. No new implementation is selected yet.
- Detached profile PID 1201988, log /tmp/nano-r21-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r21-profile-best.
- Profile finishes 23:22:48Z: FP8 GEMMs 49.01%, FA3 backward 9.44%, MLP quantization 8.57%, optimizer 5.10%. Select attention backend as the remaining substantial class. Revisit only the unqualified cuDNN full-window option from round 15; native flash and native-local have already lost decisively.
- Round 15 established that cuDNN backward is not repeat-deterministic at 2048 tokens even with its deterministic flag. The task explicitly requires a deterministic same-precision stand-in for such implementations. Add a general-purpose fallback to deterministic FA3 whenever torch deterministic algorithms or cuDNN determinism is requested; use cuDNN only for eligible full windows otherwise, leaving local-window production attention unchanged. No evaluation/benchmark variables or mode detection are used. Keep strict repeated-gradient assertions on the public deterministic path, and separately compare actual production cuDNN forward/backward to FP64 and FA3.
- Primary PyTorch v2.9.1 aten/src/ATen/native/cudnn/MHA.cpp sets cuDNN intermediate and compute types to FLOAT for these graphs. Inputs/outputs stay BF16; parameter and optimizer-state precision remain untouched. Implement isolated /submission/nanochat-cudnn-safe, default-off switch NANOCHAT_CUDNN_FULL_ATTENTION=1.
- Unit / time / quick queue PID 1207260, log /tmp/nano-r21-time-quick-cudnn-safe.log, unit log /tmp/nano-r21-unit-cudnn-safe.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r21-time-cudnn-safe and /tmp/nano-r21-quick-cudnn-safe.
- All 8 tests pass (7.54 s): actual production cuDNN forward/backward remain within the FP64/FA3 error envelope, while the public deterministic path has bitwise repeated outputs and gradients and cannot call cuDNN. time 23:26:51Z is slower: mean 0.9117 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1876. Quick 23:28:16Z passes exact items (NOT_BITWISE versus upstream); both ranks match all ten parameter snapshots of the prior best. No promotion or N1 trajectory for this slower combination. Profile the candidate to verify actual cuDNN dispatch and separate its forward/backward costs before closing the backend direction.
- cuDNN profile PID 1218056, log /tmp/nano-r21-profile-cudnn-safe.log, output /tmp/nano-r21-profile-cudnn-safe. The timing windows were 0.9074 / 0.9131 / 0.9145; startup 73.0 s, peak allocated 100.76 GiB, cost 0.060 GPU-hours.
7.6 hRound 21 conclusion
- Candidate profile confirms cuDNN dispatch for all 24 profiled full-window calls: forward totals 20.30 ms (0.846 ms/call), backward totals 70.51 ms (2.938 ms/call). Both phases are slower than the corresponding full-window FA3 work; a hybrid backend is not justified. The 72 local-window calls remain FA3. Precision qualification is sound, but performance is worse, so no changes are promoted and no trajectory/full check is spent. Experimental code is committed separately. Round ends 2026-11-05T23:34:15Z, within 30 minutes; main remains 1632e1a.
7.8 hRound 22 — profile remaining optimizer overhead
- Start another profile of the unchanged N1-validated submission before choosing a bounded optimizer/packing change. Keep all experiments isolated from the submitted tree.
- Detached profile PID 1223357, log /tmp/nano-r22-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r22-profile-best.
- Round-22 profile finishes at 23:35 UTC: FP8 GEMMs 49.11%, backward 61.44%, forward 31.88%, FA3 backward 9.47%, MLP activation quantization 8.49%, optimizer 5.15% (92.983 ms over two updates), communication 2.71%. aten::copy_ totals only 4.517 ms / 0.25%; the copy-removal ceiling is small. Choose optimizer packing as a bounded memory-traffic rewrite, not another numerical algorithm.
- At 23:41 UTC create isolated /submission/nanochat-muon-buffers from 1632e1a. NANOCHAT_REUSE_MUON_BUFFERS=1 removes two redundant allocations/copies when gradients need no rank padding and when a rank owns a full parameter chunk. Partial/empty chunks retain the original zero-padding paths. Arithmetic, state, collective order and dtypes do not change. Main and submitted switches remain untouched while screening.
- Detached unit/time/quick queue PID 1228519, log /tmp/nano-r22-muon-buffers.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r22-time-muon-buffers and /tmp/nano-r22-quick-muon-buffers. Unit coverage includes real compiled single-rank optimizer tests and mocked exact multi-rank packing with full, partial, empty and unpadded shards.
- Queue completes 23:45:06Z: 18 unit tests pass. Time windows 0.8999 / 0.9063 / 0.9078 s/update, mean 0.9047, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1968, peak 100.76 GiB, startup 71.4 s, 0.059 GPU-hours. Quick is NOT_BITWISE versus upstream with all exact items passing; all parameter digests after all ten updates are identical to the prior persistent-RMS best on both ranks. This increment is N0 in that recording. The approximately 0.2% screening gain is below noise, so confirm before considering promotion.
- Paired confirmation detached PID 1239710, log /tmp/nano-r22-time-paired-muon-buffers.log, output /tmp/nano-r22-time-paired-muon-buffers.
- Paired confirmation finishes 23:50:43Z: candidate windows 0.9020 / 0.9059 / 0.9086, mean 0.9055 s/update, frozen screening 1.1957, paired screening 1.1202, 0.155 GPU-hours. Versus prior paired best 0.9065 this is a small 0.1% increment, not independently resolved. The combined windows now narrowly screen above the frozen full-check threshold, so run the full judge on the isolated candidate, not promote on screening alone. Round ends 23:51 UTC, within 30 minutes; the following full check is outside the round budget.
- Full check detached PID 1260945, log /tmp/nano-r22-full-muon-buffers.log, output /tmp/nano-r22-full-muon-buffers; isolated commit 08a6d9f. No submission promotion before its verdict.
- Full check finishes 2026-11-05T23:58:33Z: PASS / N1, performance.speedup=1.1226. Candidate windows 0.8995 / 0.9061 / 0.9072 s/update; all exact items pass and maximum trajectory endpoint bias is 0.2233 sigma (bound 3 sigma). Cost 0.239 GPU-hours. This is the first full-check PASS of the optimized combination, against the frozen timing, not a promise about the final retimed result. Promote as a1180f8 and enable NANOCHAT_REUSE_MUON_BUFFERS=1 in the submitted switches. The packing increment is still too small to claim independently resolved speedup.
8.2 hRound 23 — profile the fully validated combination
- Start 2026-11-05T23:59 UTC. Profile submitted a1180f8 with emitted-code logging (/submission/r23-profile.json) before choosing a loss/reduction rewrite. Main now has full-check evidence and remains untouched by experiments.
- Profile detached PID 1278339, log /tmp/nano-r23-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r23-profile-best. Actual lock acquisition after midnight uses November 6 UTC in the following entries.
- Profile actually holds the GPUs 2026-11-05T23:59:28Z to 2026-11-06T00:01:00Z. Stage shares: backward 61.64%, forward 32.09%, optimizer 4.93%; FP8 GEMMs 49.24%, FA3 backward 9.50%, MLP activation quantization 8.57%. Loss forward online softmax costs 17.598 ms / 0.98% over two updates; the combined loss backward and gradient-amax reduction costs 18.026 ms / 1.01%. Generated backward code first loops over every vocabulary item just to sum a one-hot NLL gradient, then loops again to compute the actual derivative and FP8 amax. This zero-filled reduction has a closed-form sum, so select a loss-backward graph rewrite before writing any custom kernel.
- Isolated /submission/nanochat-loss-backward from a1180f8 adds NANOCHAT_EXPLICIT_CE_BACKWARD=1. Forward retains stable FP32 log-softmax algebra, softcap 15, masking and all loss reductions. Explicit backward replaces only the zero-filled NLL-gradient sum by its exact sparse-target value, retains the original FP32 tanh derivative arithmetic and returns the original logits dtype. The ordinary Torch operations remain visible to Inductor, including its existing online-softmax pattern and downstream FP8 amax fusion. No dtypes, model, data, schedule or tensorwise FP8 recipe change.
- Unit/time/quick queue detached PID 1284302 at 00:02:52Z, log /tmp/nano-r23-loss-backward.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r23-time-loss-backward and /tmp/nano-r23-quick-loss-backward. Tests cover ignored targets, none/sum/mean reduction, compiled BF16/FP32 gradients against FP64, and repeatability.
- Explicit-backward screen completes 00:06:13Z: 10 tests pass. Time windows 0.9048 / 0.9109 / 0.9129, mean 0.9095 s/update, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1904, peak 100.76 GiB, startup 68.6 s, 0.057 GPU-hours. Quick exact items pass and all ten parameter snapshots match the current best on both ranks (N0 increment). It is slower than the submitted 0.9055 paired mean; do not promote. Within this same loss-reduction class, next test the existing persistent reduction codegen at vocabulary width 32768: PyTorch source explicitly supports its online-softmax node by replacing online recurrence with in-register max/sum reductions, and the profile showed the native looping kernel using only 32 registers/thread.
- Add independent default-off NANOCHAT_PERSISTENT_LOSS_WIDTH=32768, qualifying only that reduction width with at least 4096 outer elements. Norm policy is unchanged, and each lazy compilation still installs its own thread-local handler. Additional unit tests cover eligibility and actual compiled 4096x32768 BF16 soft-capped CE forward/backward against FP64. Detached queue PID 1295594 at 00:09:14Z, log /tmp/nano-r23-persistent-loss.log: tests, original-CE timing /tmp/nano-r23-time-persistent-loss, explicit-derivative timing /tmp/nano-r23-time-persistent-loss-explicit, original-CE profile /tmp/nano-r23-profile-persistent-loss, and quick /tmp/nano-r23-quick-persistent-loss.
- Queue completes 00:15:41Z: 13 tests pass; persistent original CE mean 0.9110 (windows 0.9060 / 0.9120 / 0.9150), frozen screening 1.1885; with explicit derivative mean 0.9117 (0.9065 / 0.9120 / 0.9165), frozen 1.1876. Both lose. Quick exact items pass. Profile proves the new path is active but the native 8-warp configuration is register-limited: forward 22.127 ms versus prior 17.598, 162 registers/thread; backward 33.367 ms versus 18.026, 255 registers/thread. Test a bounded 16/32-warp configuration screen before closing the loss-reduction class. Unlike the earlier ineffective worker monkeypatch, PyTorch exposes InductorChoices.triton_kernel_kwargs and FixedTritonConfig, embedding the launch configuration directly in generated code, so parallel compiler workers receive the setting without serial compilation.
- Fixed-launch queue detached PID 1318934 at 00:18:35Z, log /tmp/nano-r23-persistent-loss-warps.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r23-time-persistent-loss-16, /tmp/nano-r23-time-persistent-loss-32, /tmp/nano-r23-profile-persistent-loss-32, /tmp/nano-r23-quick-persistent-loss-32. NANOCHAT_PERSISTENT_LOSS_WARPS defaults to zero (native launch); the screen uses 16 and 32 warps for the same 32768-wide reduction. No compiler parallelism or numerics settings change.
- Queue finishes 00:24:58Z: 15 tests pass; 16-warps mean 0.9057, windows 0.9006 / 0.9077 / 0.9088, frozen screening 1.1954; 32-warps mean 0.9064, windows 0.9025 / 0.9074 / 0.9092, frozen 1.1945. No resolved gain over submitted 0.9055. Quick exact items pass. Profile verifies fixed launches reach workers: 32-warps gives 1024-thread blocks, 49 forward / 63 backward registers. Forward improves to about 3.4 ms/call but backward remains around 5.8 ms versus native 4.5 ms. One final bounded combination uses the explicit derivative with the 32-warp launch; then close this class at the 30-minute limit.
- Final combination detached PID 1339976 at 00:26:07Z, log /tmp/nano-r23-persistent-loss-explicit-32.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r23-time-persistent-loss-explicit-32 and /tmp/nano-r23-quick-persistent-loss-explicit-32.
- Final combination finishes 00:29:13Z: mean 0.9079 s/update, frozen screening 1.1925, quick NOT_BITWISE. No gain. Round 23 concludes at 00:29:23Z, within 30 minutes of the 23:59:28Z lock. No loss changes are promoted; commits a233368, f8e3872, and 270b295 retain the experiments. The useful result is a verified compile-worker-safe fixed-launch API for future kernel configuration, not a loss speedup.
8.7 hRound 24 — profile before normalization launch selection
- Profile the unchanged full-check-passing submission a1180f8, using /submission/r23-profile.json. The old round-20 1x4 and 2x16 nominal launches never took effect; the fixed-configuration API identified in round 23 can test them without changing compiler parallelism. Select only after the new profile confirms the remaining reduction budget.
- Detached profile PID 1349896, log /tmp/nano-r24-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r24-profile-best, started 00:29:43Z.
- Profile ends 00:31:16Z: backward 61.46%, forward 32.01%, optimizer 5.02%; FP8 GEMMs 49.16%, FA3 backward 9.50%, MLP activation quantization 8.54%. RMS-backward-tagged kernels total 75.132 ms over two updates (about 4.18% of GPU kernel time), other normalization/rsqrt kernels 48.623 ms (2.71%). Current launch is one row and eight warps, with 65536 CTAs for the training rows. This is a configuration opportunity with a remaining multi-percent budget.
- Isolated /submission/nanochat-norm-fixed-tiles from a1180f8 adds default-off NANOCHAT_PERSISTENT_NORM_TILE. InductorChoices.triton_kernel_kwargs serializes FixedTritonConfig into generated code, so both forward and lazy backward workers receive the tile without serial compilation. Screen 1x4, 2x16 and 4x32; keep every arithmetic expression and dtype unchanged, and retain guards for reduction size, row count and cooperative kernels.
- Detached queue PID 1354294 at 00:33:23Z, log /tmp/nano-r24-norm-tiles.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r24-time-norm-1x4, /tmp/nano-r24-time-norm-2x16, /tmp/nano-r24-time-norm-4x32, /tmp/nano-r24-quick-norm-2x16. Standalone tests will also be repeated with Dynamo reset between tile variants, to prevent a shared Python code object from reusing the first backend configuration.
- Screens finish 00:40:13Z: 1x4 mean 0.9003 s/update, frozen screening 1.2026; 2x16 mean 0.9112, frozen 1.1882; 4x32 mean 0.9181, frozen 1.1793. Extra-row tiles lose, while 1x4 has a small approximately 0.6% screening gain. 2x16 quick exact items pass. Repeat unit tests with explicit Dynamo resets, profile the real 1x4 launch, quick-check it, and obtain paired timing before any promotion.
- Confirmation queue detached PID 1376365 at 00:40:58Z, log /tmp/nano-r24-norm-1x4-confirm.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r24-quick-norm-1x4, /tmp/nano-r24-profile-norm-1x4, /tmp/nano-r24-time-paired-norm-1x4. 2x16 changes parameter hashes on both ranks, so no bitwise claim applies to the launch family.
- The queue ends at quick (00:42:30Z) because its expected NOT_BITWISE exit code trips shell set -e; profile and paired timing have not run yet. Corrected tests pass all 21 cases with Dynamo reset. 1x4 quick exact items pass. Restart only the unexecuted profile and paired stages; do not repeat the completed quick.
- Restarted profile/paired queue PID 1381250 at 00:43:34Z, log /tmp/nano-r24-norm-1x4-profile-paired.log.
- Confirmation finishes 00:49:49Z: paired candidate windows 0.8969 / 0.9018 / 0.9045 s/update, mean 0.9011, frozen screening 1.2015, paired screening 1.1278, startup 70.8 s, 0.154 GPU-hours. The modest gain repeats against prior paired mean 0.9055. Profile proves real 128-thread launches: RMS backward totals 67.556 ms versus 75.132, other rsqrt normalization 47.700 versus 48.623 ms over two updates. Round ends 00:50 UTC, within 30 minutes. Send the combined candidate to full check outside the round budget; do not promote before its statistical verdict.
- Full check detached PID 1405777 at 00:50:37Z, log /tmp/nano-r24-full-norm-1x4.log, output /tmp/nano-r24-full-norm-1x4, isolated commit 31c67df.
- Full check completes 2026-11-06T00:57:49Z: PASS / N1, performance.speedup=1.1265, candidate windows 0.8979 / 0.9030 / 0.9042 s/update, exact items pass, maximum endpoint bias 0.1496 sigma, 0.239 GPU-hours. Promote as 36a0194 and add NANOCHAT_PERSISTENT_NORM_TILE=1x4 to the submitted switches. As always, final evaluation retimes both reference arms.
- Possible next direction, not implemented: fuse the existing QK rotary-normalization backward with per-CTA maxima of its BF16-rounded result, and carry those maxima through an FP8-linear-plus-rotary autograd wrapper. This can remove a full BF16 gradient reread while preserving tensorwise scaling, every existing FP8 GEMM and both precisions. Current standalone BF16 gradient-amax kernel costs 17.482 ms over two updates (240 calls); a new profile must confirm attribution before selecting this hotspot. Weight-FP8 caching between microbatches was also considered but not implemented; its weight-amax budget is smaller, and any such cache would need refreshing before every post-step probe, not reuse across parameter updates.
9.2 hRound 25 — profile before FP8/QK backward fusion
- At 00:58 UTC profile the newly validated 36a0194 before choosing the next memory-traffic fusion. Keep all new code isolated.
- Detached profile PID 1422787, log /tmp/nano-r25-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r25-profile-best, config /submission/r25-profile.json.
- Profile ends 01:00:05Z: FP8 GEMMs 49.72%, backward 61.60%, forward 32.26%, FA3 backward 9.59%, MLP activation preparation 8.56%. QK rotary-normalization backward is 28.517 ms / 192 calls over two updates; standalone BF16 gradient-amax scan is 17.672 ms / 240 calls. Emitted backward code identifies QK outputs as inputs to the latter scan. Choose this duplicate-read boundary for a custom fusion, not a different attention kernel.
- Isolated /submission/nanochat-qk-fp8-fusion from 36a0194 adds NANOCHAT_FUSE_FP8_QK=1: each Q/K FP8 projection and existing rotary-normalization share one autograd wrapper. Backward emits per-head maxima alongside the existing BF16 gradients, then reduces only those small FP32 maxima for the same tensorwise E5M2 scale. Maxima use the BF16-rounded result, preserving the existing custom-op boundary. FP8 operands, FP32 scales, GEMM accumulation flags, parameter/state dtypes and all QK arithmetic are unchanged. No new atomic or nondeterministic path is introduced.
- Detached unit/time/quick queue PID 1427642 at 01:01:59Z, log /tmp/nano-r25-qk-fp8.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r25-time-qk-fp8, /tmp/nano-r25-quick-qk-fp8. Unit coverage compares every per-head maximum and gradient exactly, including ragged row blocks; full compiled FP8 projection forward/backward must also match the previous pipeline exactly for square and grouped-query shapes. Existing QK FP64 and determinism tests are rerun.
- Queue finishes 01:05:22Z: all 24 tests pass. Time windows 0.8911 / 0.8959 / 0.8989 s/update, mean 0.8953, frozen screening 1.2093, peak 100.76 GiB, startup 70.7 s, 0.058 GPU-hours. Quick exact items pass and all ten parameter snapshots on both ranks match the submitted four-warp-RMS best (N0 increment in the recording). The approximately 0.6% screening increment needs paired confirmation and evidence that the large gradient scans disappear.
- Profile/paired confirmation detached PID 1438779 at 01:06:08Z, log /tmp/nano-r25-qk-fp8-confirm.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r25-profile-qk-fp8, /tmp/nano-r25-time-paired-qk-fp8; isolated commit d33ccca.
- Paired confirmation finishes 01:12:20Z: candidate windows 0.8926 / 0.8970 / 0.9002, mean 0.8966 s/update, frozen screening 1.2076, paired screening 1.1311, cost 0.154 GPU-hours. The incremental gain repeats versus prior paired 0.9011. Profile confirms 192 full gradient scans disappear: the large gradient-amax kernel falls from 240 calls / 17.672 ms to 48 calls / 3.524 ms; the small partial-max reduction is only 0.747 ms over 192 calls. QK backward rises slightly from 28.517 to 29.711 ms over two updates. Round ends 01:13 UTC, within 30 minutes. Run the full judge on this N0-increment combination before promotion.
- Full check detached PID 1462850 at 01:13:16Z, log /tmp/nano-r25-full-qk-fp8.log, output /tmp/nano-r25-full-qk-fp8, isolated commit d33ccca.
- Full check finishes 2026-11-06T01:20:24Z: PASS / N1, performance.speedup=1.1331, windows 0.8930 / 0.8972 / 0.8996 s/update, exact items pass, maximum endpoint bias 0.1496 sigma, 0.237 GPU-hours. Every probe loss in the 150-update trajectory is also identical to the prior four-warp RMS full check. Promote as 472613f and enable NANOCHAT_FUSE_FP8_QK=1 in submitted switches.
- Next-round research only, not implemented: the primary NVIDIA CUDA 12.8 cuBLAS manual defines amax_D after the epilogue, and lists FP8 inputs / BF16 outputs with ReLU support. A ReLU+amax MLP expansion could potentially replace the activation maximum scan while retaining BF16 hidden values; the BF16-rounded maximum must be squared before the unchanged tensorwise scale calculation. Documentation saved as /tmp/nano-cublas-12.8-docs.html, fetched only from NVIDIA. API support, accuracy and performance still require testing. Earlier own nanochat-cublaslt/nanochat/fp8_cublaslt.py provides the already-tested ctypes matrix layout adapter; no external optimized training code was consulted.
9.6 hRound 26 — profile before MLP epilogue fusion
- At 01:21 UTC profile the new full-check-passing best 472613f. Inspect MLP activation preparation before testing whether the library ReLU/amax epilogue can remove its forward maximum scan. No new production changes yet.
- Profile detached PID 1480965, log /tmp/nano-r26-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r26-profile-best, config /submission/r26-profile.json.
- Profile ends 01:22:55Z: GEMMs 49.82%, backward 61.06%, forward 32.49%, MLP activation preparation 8.66%; its maximum scan is 52.244 ms / 2.94% over 192 forward/backward calls. Select MLP forward preparation. First qualify the existing cuBLASLt ReLU/amax epilogue with E4M3 operands, BF16 output, unchanged FP32 compute and original fast-accum flag. The isolated /submission/nanochat-mlp-relu-amax is based on 472613f; no model call site is changed until this API passes per-op tests, including the real 65536x6144x1536 expansion shape.
- API qualification detached PID 1485733 at 01:25:26Z, log /tmp/nano-r26-relu-amax-unit.log; tests check FP64 error relative to the original GEMM, exact BF16-rounded amax, nonnegative output and repeated determinism.
- First API test fails before GEMM: cublasLtMatmulAlgoGetHeuristic returns status 7 (INVALID_VALUE) with ReLU plus BF16 amax requested. Real-shape qualification detached PID 1485818, log /tmp/nano-r26-relu-amax-real-shapes.log, checks both 512x6144x1536 and the actual 65536x6144x1536 expansion before attributing this to a small-shape restriction. A descriptor-only feature matrix will isolate ReLU from amax; no training/model code is connected to the unsupported path.
- Descriptor feature-matrix PID 1485888 at 01:28:24Z, log /tmp/nano-r26-relu-amax-features.log. This is correctness/API diagnosis only, not a timing script or a claimed benchmark result.
- Diagnosis completes 01:28 UTC: both real expansion shapes also return INVALID_VALUE. The feature matrix passes plain GEMM and ReLU-only GEMM, but rejects amax both with and without ReLU. Thus BF16 output amax is unavailable through this installed library interface; the documented general formula does not establish support for every dtype combination. Do not change hidden precision to obtain amax. Retain this rejected prototype in its own commit, then screen only the supported ReLU epilogue as a library-backend variant; it will retain the original activation-amax scan and must not be credited with removing it.
- Rejected amax prototype is commit f841591. Supported follow-up uses NANOCHAT_MLP_RELU_EPILOGUE=1 only for the MLP expansion GEMM. BF16 ReLU commutes with BF16 rounding at zero; stored negative hidden values become zeros, which the existing squared-ReLU and derivative already map to zeros. The original tensorwise activation-amax scan remains intact. Tests compare the ReLU GEMM to FP64 and require exact unchanged forward/backward activation preparation after discarding negative hidden values.

- Supported ReLU-only unit/time/quick queue detached PID 1485995 at 2026-11-06T01:31:47Z, log /tmp/nano-r26-relu.log; outputs /tmp/nano-r26-time-relu and /tmp/nano-r26-quick-relu, config /submission/r26-relu.json. All 9 unit tests pass. Time completes 01:33:38Z: mean 0.8974 s/update, frozen screening 1.2065x; quick is still running. This does not yet resolve any gain over the submitted paired 0.8966 s/update.

- Round ends 2026-11-06T01:36Z, within 30 minutes. ReLU-only windows are 0.8935 / 0.8981 / 0.9006 s/update, mean 0.8974, frozen screening 1.2065x, startup 71.0 s, 0.058 GPU-hours. Quick finishes 01:35:02Z: NOT_BITWISE with all exact items passing. All 9 focused tests pass, but there is no resolved end-to-end gain over the submitted 0.8966 paired mean. All ten parameter snapshots on both ranks match the prior best (N0 increment in the record). Reject the ReLU-only backend for performance; do not spend a trajectory/full check or promote it. Supported experiment is commit 5ba2bd2; preserve main at 472613f.
9.9 hRound 27 — profile before activation-preparation launch tuning
- Fresh profile of validated 472613f detached PID 1496903 at 2026-11-06T01:36:36Z, log /tmp/nano-r27-profile-best.log, output /tmp/nano-r27-profile-best, submitted switches. No new implementation chosen or changed before this profile.
- Profile finishes 01:38:08Z: FP8 GEMMs 50.01%, backward 61.15%, forward 32.60%, optimizer 4.83%; MLP activation quantization 8.63%. Its dual-layout kernel alone is 100.705 ms / 5.65% across 192 calls. Unlike the generic quantizer previously tuned in round 13, this fused activation kernel uses 56/64 registers per thread and only 56%/50% estimated occupancy for forward/backward. The amax scan already has 31/32 registers and 100% estimated occupancy, so leave it alone. Select only the MLP dual-layout launch configuration: screen 16x128x4, 32x64x4 and 32x128x8 against current 32x128x4, retaining identical elementwise expressions, FP8 scales and all dtypes. All experiments isolated in /submission/nanochat-mlp-activation-tiles.
- Unit/three-screen queue detached PID 1501983 at 01:39:27Z, log /tmp/nano-r27-time-tiles.log; configs /submission/r27-tile-{16x128x4,32x64x4,32x128x8}.json, outputs /tmp/nano-r27-time-tile-{16x128x4,32x64x4,32x128x8}. Tests parameterize exact activation bytes, scales, repeated results and compiled MLP gradients over all four tiles, plus full 65536x6144 forward/backward quantization comparisons to the existing tile. No timing is attempted if a unit test fails.
↑ NanoChat