DeepSeek V4.1 Flash-1017 1.06×
Harness: DeepSeek's own harness · switches: NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2 NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET=1 TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1 NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED=1 NANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM=1 TORCHINDUCTOR_PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS=0 NANOCHAT_OPT_FUSEDMLP=1
- Judged
- 1.06×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 1.06×
- Rounds
- 87
- Hours
- 9.0
- API cost
- $2.74
- Input tokens · 99.5% cached
- 241 M
- Output tokens
- 0.8 M
- Requests
- 653
§ 02Key levers
- Micro-batch regrouping 4×16 → 2×32
- ✓
NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2, alone 1.025 - Scope of hand-written kernels replacing Inductor glue
- MLP only:
NANOCHAT_OPT_FUSEDMLP, full check 1.036 → 1.047, later 1.059; rewrites of norm, RoPE, attention grads all measured slower - Per-shape cuBLASLt algorithm selection
- ✗ (log says "no interface to pick another algorithm")
- FP8 weights quantized once per step
- tried, reverted (1.043, slower than 1.050 without cache)
- Fast accum on backward GEMMs
- not tried (treated as a disallowed precision change)
- Other main levers
- Inductor pointwise kernel autotuning, persistent reduction off, Newton-Schulz via baddbmm, small grads merged into one all-reduce, optimizer issues the Muon group first
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log103 sections
0.1 hRound 0 — baseline profile (2026-11-06 17:03–17:07)
Command:bench.py profile --tree targets/reference --from 12 --iters 3->/tmp/prof-ref-1(3 updates, instrumented, 1.026 s/update during profiling; the clean frozen timing is 1.018). Findings (sum of CUDA kernel time = 3.037 s over 3 updates = 1.012 s/update, GPU busy 97.3% of the span => compute-bound, CPU/launch/data are not the bottleneck; CUDA graphs cannot help): | category | ms/update | share | |---|---|---| | FP8 GEMMs (nvjet = cuBLASLt_scaled_mm) | 454 | 45% | | Inductor Triton fusions (quantize/amax ~180, norms/rope/relu/residual ~200, CE ~25) | 412 | 41% | | FlashAttention-3 fwd+bwd (cutlass sm90 kernels) | 109 | 11% | | optimizerMuonAdamW.step(incl. NCCL reduce-scatter/all-gather) | 41 + 23 | 6% | | misc (bmm, adds, memsets) | ~14 | 1% | Other observations: 10,423 kernels/update; 5,868/3 = 1,956 GEMM launches/update (4 accumulation steps x 145 FP8 linears x 3 GEMMs each). Activation paths: each FP8 Linear quantizes its own input and grad_output each micro-step (the qkv projections quantize the *same* attention input three times). Peak memory 55.9 GiB of 141. No invalid-run signatures (fa3 True, no recompile/graph messages).
0.1 hRound 1 — micro-batch regrouping (accum 4x16 -> 2x32) (started 17:09)
Switch:NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2-> device_batch_size 32, grad_accum_steps 2, same rows/order/tokens per update. Tier: N1 (gradient accumulation order changes; rows and math unchanged; gate 2 explicitly allows regouping). Change:scripts/base_train.py(envNANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM, default 0 = upstream). Result round 1:time0.9931 s/update,speedup_vs_frozen_reference1.0251 (windows 1.0223/1.0275/1.0254), peak 94.0 GiB. Committed 4b0b57f.
0.1 hRound 1b — full check of accum=2 (17:21–17:32)
check --tree /submission/nanochat --config /submission/switches.json --out /tmp/check-A:
status PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0256. Gate 2 exact items all ok (175 parameters, 640 rows/rank, 10 updates);
parameters not bitwise from update 0 (expected: accumulation order). Gate 3: all 6 endpoints within
|bias| <= 0.42 sigma (bounds 3 sigma) -> equivalent with a wide margin.
Submission state: /submission/switches.json = {"NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM": "2"}.0.6 hRound 2 — shared QKV input quantization (17:12–17:16)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_QKV=1:_Float8Matmul3(nanochat/fp8.py) quantizes the attention input once for c_q/c_k/c_v and runs the same three_scaled_mm; backward sums grad_input in the autograd order (g_v+g_k)+g_q, so it is bitwise identical to the per-layer path.timeresult: 0.9936 s/update, speedup 1.0246 (windows 1.0264/1.0253/1.0221) — no gain over accum=2 alone (Inductor already fuses the three quantizations or the saving is below noise). Switch left off by default; code kept (unused).
0.6 hRound 3 — cuBLASLt workspace (17:32–17:35)
Switch CUBLASLT_WORKSPACE_SIZE=33554432 (32 MiB; default is 1 MiB): OOM (131 GiB allocated) — a larger
workspace is allocated per in-flight FP8 GEMM, and the compiled step has thousands. ERROR, no timing. Direction
closed (do not enlarge the cuBLASLt workspace).0.6 hRound 4 — bucket the small AdamW gradient all-reduces (17:34–)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET=1(nanochat/optim.py): oneall_reduceof all 74 small fp32 AdamW gradients concatenated instead of one per parameter (same per-element AVG; 2 ranks), launched before phase 1 and waited before phase 2. Expected ~3–5 ms of removed GPU idle in the optimizer region. Result round 4:time0.9921 s/update, speedup 1.0261 (windows 1.0258/1.0267/1.0257); committed 85f6c56. Full check with accum=2 + bucket:/tmp/check-BPASS, N1, speedup 1.0242 (window ratios 1.0243/1.0242/1.0260; gate 2 exact items ok; gate 3 all endpoints <= 0.42 sigma). Run-to-run variance of the candidate between check-A (1.0256) and check-B (1.0242) is ~0.15%.
0.9 hRound 5 — NCCL protocol (17:38–17:41)
Switch NCCL_PROTO=Simple with accum+bucket: 0.9920 s/update, speedup 1.0262 (windows
1.0269/1.0258/1.0258) — no gain over 1.0261. Direction closed, not used.0.9 hRound 6 — fresh profile at the current best (17:41–17:44, /tmp/prof-opt2)
998 ms/update of kernel time: GEMM 460 (46%), Inductor Triton 396 (40%), FA3 110 (11%), NCCL 24 (2.4%), other 8. GPU idle 1.4% (was 2.7% at accum=4). Biggest single kernel is still the fused relu^2-backward+fp8-quantize+transposed-write kernel (64 ms/update, 2.1 TB/s, partly uncoalesced because it writes both the row-major and the transposed fp8 layouts); everything else is at 80-85% of the memory roofline. GEMMs run at ~1.25 PFLOPS/GPU (~65-75% of the machine's FP8 peak).
0.9 hRound 7 — pointwise autotuning (17:55–)
SwitchTORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1(library switch, no code): lets Inductor time pointwise/fused kernel tile configs instead of using its static heuristic; the hope is a better tile for the fused kernel above. Compile time is the risk (cold compile in every run). Result round 7:time0.9867 s/update, speedup 1.0317 (windows 1.0298/1.0334/1.0318), startup 168.5 s (+28 s cold compile vs 140 s). Real, window-consistent gain (+0.55% over 1.0261). switches.json now has it.
0.9 hRound 8 — full Inductor max-autotune (17:58–)
AddsTORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE=1(Triton templates for the aten matmuls/bmm, i.e. the Muon NS iterations, plus epilogue-fusion benchmarking). Compile time is the risk. Numerics tier N1. Result round 8:time0.9860 s/update, speedup 1.0325 (windows 1.0313/1.0332/1.0330), but startup 465 s (7.8 min cold compile vs 168 s). Gain over pointwise-only is +0.08% (noise) for a large compile-time cost, soTORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNEis not used; onlyTORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE.
1.5 hRound 9 — CUDA graphs (18:29–18:31)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_CUDAGRAPH=1->torch.compile(model, dynamic=False, mode="reduce-overhead")(Round-9 hotspot class: launch/host gaps; the current profile shows 1.4% GPU idle). Result: **SIGSEGV during graph capture** (exitcode -11, right after the training loop starts; no "skipping cudagraphs" message, the capture itself crashes — the FP8_scaled_mmautograd path is not graph-capturable). Direction closed; the switch stays off by default (it is not in switches.json).
1.7 hRound 10 — optimizer phase scheduling (18:32–18:36)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED=1(nanochat/optim.py). Round-10 hotspot: the optimizer region was 46 ms/update and its NCCL stream was serialized behind the 9 small bf16 AdamW reduce-scatters, so the compute stream waited. Changes, all order/copy only (every parameter's update is independent -> bitwise identical output): - run phase 1 + phase 2 in an order with the Muon groups first (longest compute, largest collectives) and the AdamW groups last (short compute, small gathers); - fillstacked_gradswith_foreach_copy_instead oftorch.stack+ copy; - all-gather straight fromstacked_ownedwhen the group needs no padding (skips theupdated_paramscopy). Result: 0.9834 s/update, speedup 1.0352 (windows 1.0332/1.0385/1.0336). Gain +0.16% over 1.0336. Re-profile (/tmp/prof-sched): optimizer region 44.8 ms with 42.9 ms of compute-stream kernels and only 1.5 ms of gaps, NCCL 24.5 ms fully overlapped -> the optimizer is now compute-bound, scheduling is done.
1.7 hRound 11 — force Inductor to materialize multi-consumer buffers (18:40–18:44)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_REALIZE=1(torch._inductor.config.realize_reads_threshold = 1). Hypothesis: the fused FP8 quantize kernels that also write a transposed copy (biggest kernel 64 ms/update, 2.1 TB/s) would get faster if the transpose became its own coalesced kernel. Result: much slower — 1.0254 s/update, speedup 0.9928 (the extra materializations cost far more than the bad fusion). Closed; switch stays off by default.
1.7 hRound 12 — FA3 forward split-K (18:44–18:48)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_FASPLIT=2(passnum_splits=2to the FA3 forward). Hypothesis: more CTAs for the attention forward on short sliding windows. Result: much slower — 1.0202 s/update, speedup 0.9978 (the split-K combine costs more than the extra parallelism buys; 384 CTAs already fill the 132 SMs). Closed, switch off by default.
2.0 hRound 13 — Newton-Schulz affine combination via baddbmm (18:59–19:03)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM=1(nanochat/optim.py). Round-13 hotspot: after the scheduling round the optimizer region is compute-bound (43 ms of compute kernels); the NS loop'sB = b*A + c*(A@A)andX = a*X + X@Bwere two separate elementwise passes over the 113 M-element A/X tensors between the bmms. Expressing them astorch.baddbmm(A, A, A, beta=b, alpha=c)/torch.baddbmm(X, X, B, beta=a, alpha=1)lets cuBLAS apply beta*C in the GEMM epilogue. Same real-valued function, different rounding (tier N1). Result: 0.9811 s/update, speedup 1.0376 (windows 1.0330/1.0418/1.0378). Gain +0.24% over 1.0352.
2.3 hRound 14 — reduction block scaling knob (19:15–19:18)
Switch TORCHINDUCTOR_DYNAMIC_SCALE_RBLOCK=0: 0.9851 s/update, speedup 1.0334 (windows 1.0336/1.0340/1.0325)
— slightly worse than 1.0376. Closed, not used.2.3 hRound 15 — persistent reductions off (19:19–19:22)
SwitchTORCHINDUCTOR_PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS=0: 0.9787 s/update, speedup 1.0402 (windows 1.0374/1.0431/1.0398). Gain +0.26% over 1.0376 — the non-persistent reduction kernels are better for the RMSNorm/log-softmax/amax shapes here. Kept in switches.json. (For the record,TORCHINDUCTOR_DYNAMIC_SCALE_RBLOCK=0in round 14 was worse, 1.0334, and is not used.)
2.3 hRound 16 — precise accumulation in the forward FP8 GEMMs (19:23–)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_FWDACC=1: forward_scaled_mmwithuse_fast_accum=False(the backward already uses False). This is a kernel/accumulation choice that *raises* precision, allowed by the precision rule and judged by gates 2/3. Hypothesis: the forward GEMM kernels run at 1.18 PFLOPS vs 1.32 for the identical-shape backward; cuBLASLt picks a different (faster) algorithm without fast accum. Result round 16:use_fast_accum=Falsein the forward is much slower — 0.9910 s/update, speedup 1.0272 (windows 1.0278/1.0278/1.0263). fast accumulation is genuinely faster; the forward/backward GEMM efficiency gap has another cause. Closed, switch stays off.
2.6 hRound 17 — online softmax off (19:37–19:40)
Switch TORCHINDUCTOR_ONLINE_SOFTMAX=0: 0.9810 s/update, speedup 1.0377 — slightly worse than 1.0402.
Closed, not used.2.7 hRound 18 — cooperative reductions (19:40–19:45)
SwitchTORCHINDUCTOR_COOPERATIVE_REDUCTIONS=1: catastrophic — 1.2998 s/update, speedup 0.7832. Closed. --- # FINAL SUMMARY (current best; updated at the end of every round) Tree:/submission/nanochat@d89613b, working tree clean. Only these source changes vs upstream 92d63d4: 1.scripts/base_train.py:NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM(micro-batch regrouping),NANOCHAT_OPT_REALIZE,NANOCHAT_OPT_CUDAGRAPH(both off/unused experiments). 2.nanochat/optim.py:NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET(bucketed small AdamW all-reduce),NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED(Muon-first scheduling + copy elisions),NANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM(baddbmm Newton-Schulz). 3.nanochat/fp8.py:NANOCHAT_OPT_QKV(unused),NANOCHAT_OPT_FWDACC(off). 4.nanochat/flash_attention.py:NANOCHAT_OPT_FASPLIT(off). All experiment switches default off;/submission/switches.jsonenables exactly the winner set. Switches (/submission/switches.json):NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2,NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM=1,TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1,TORCHINDUCTOR_PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS=0. Verdict evidence:/tmp/check-F(exactly this configuration): status PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0358 (gate 1 windows 1.0358/1.0392/1.0385; gate 2 exact items all identical; gate 3 all six endpoints within 0.27 sigma of the reference seed trajectory).timesample of the same configuration: 1.0402. Earlier full checks: A 1.0256 (accum), B 1.0242 (+bucket), C 1.0296 (+pointwise autotune), D 1.0336 (+scheduling), E 1.0346 (+baddbmm), F 1.0358 (+persistent reductions off). Gains by change (measured, vs the frozen reference; per-window consistent): | change | s/update | speedup | tier | |---|---|---|---| | upstream reference (frozen) | 1.018 | 1.000 | - | | micro-batches 4x16 -> 2x32 | 0.9931 | 1.0251 | N1 | | + bucketed small AdamW all-reduce | 0.9921 | 1.0261 | N0 | | + Inductor pointwise/reduction autotune | 0.9867 | 1.0317 | N1 | | + optimizer scheduling / copy elisions | 0.9834 | 1.0352 | N0 | | + baddbmm Newton-Schulz | 0.9811 | 1.0376 | N1 | | + persistent reductions off | 0.9787 | 1.0402 | N1 | Why the remaining time is bounded: the step is compute/bandwidth bound with ~1.4% GPU idle. Final profile breakdown per update: FP8 GEMMs 460 ms (46%, ~1.25 PFLOPS = 65-75% of the machine's FP8 peak), Inductor Triton fusions 387 ms (40%, mostly 80-85% of the memory roofline; the single biggest is the fused relu^2-backward + fp8 dual-layout quantize at 64 ms, 2.1 TB/s, its transposed store is uncoalesced), FA3 fwd+bwd 110 ms (11%, ~57% of bf16 peak, backward-limited), NCCL 26 ms (2.6%, at NVLink bandwidth, fully overlapped with the now compute-bound optimizer's 43 ms). No GPU idle worth CUDA graphs (and they crash on this FP8 path). Directions tried and rejected (all logged above with numbers): shared QKV quantization (no gain); larger cuBLASLt workspace (OOM); NCCL_PROTO=Simple (no change); full max-autotune (+0.08% for +300 s compile); CUDA graphs (SIGSEGV); forcing Inductor to materialize multi-consumer buffers (much slower); FA3 num_splits=2 (slower); dynamic_scale_rblock=0 (worse); forward precise FP8 accumulation (much slower); online softmax off (worse); cooperative reductions (much slower).
3.4 hRound 19 — custom fused MLP gradient-quantization kernel (19:57–20:27)
Profile of the current best (/tmp/prof-final, 2 of 3 profiled updates captured -> scale x1.5): 980 ms/update of kernel time: GEMM 462 ms (47%), Inductor Triton 377 ms (38.5%), FA3 110 ms (11%), NCCL 23 ms (2.4%). Hotspot: the fused relu^2-backward + FP8 dual-layout quantize kernel (63.6 ms/update, 2.1 TB/s) plus the amax reduction that recomputes the same gradient (19.1 ms/update) — together 83 ms, 8.5% of the step. Microbenchmark (same shapes/dtypes, standalone under flock): the reference kernel moves 2.8 GB in 1329 us (2.1 TB/s); a hand-written Triton kernel with the same expression but writing the transposed fp8 layouts through a tiled layout conversion (join/permute/split of the two int8 tiles) moves the same 2.8 GB in 728 us (3.83 TB/s), and an equivalent abs-max pass takes 353 us (the reference's takes 397 us). Found and worked around two Triton 9.5/3.5 codegen bugs while validating: twotl.transcalls on fp8 tiles in one kernel miscompile (the second store is garbage), and sharing one SSA value between a row-major store and the join/permute/split corrupts the transposed tile (fixed by recomputing the row-major value with a+0.0CSE barrier). Production config validated bitwise against a torch reference on the real [65536,6144] shapes. Implementation:nanochat/mlp_fused.py(new) +MLP.forwardbranch innanochat/gpt.py, switchNANOCHAT_OPT_FUSEDMLP=1. The forward is the same_scaled_mmcalls with the same scales (bitwise identical to upstream); only the gradient-quantization region is replaced (tier N1). Result:time0.9685 s/update, speedup 1.0511 (windows 1.0488/1.0554/1.0493). Full check/tmp/check-H: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0471 (windows 1.0471/1.0538/1.0480; gate 2 exact items ok; gate 3 all endpoints within 0.28 sigma). ~+1.2% over the previous best 1.0358.
3.5 hRound 20 — custom abs-max kernel inside the fused MLP path (20:31–20:35)
Replacedto_fp8_scale'sx.float().abs().max()with a hand-written Triton abs-max custom op (tensor_amax) for the MLP path. Result: slower — 0.9963 s/update, speedup 1.0218 (vs 0.9685/1.0511). Making the amax an opaque op breaks Inductor's fusion of the relu^2 producer into the amax reduction (the reference fusespow_reluintoabs_max), so a2 has to be materialized and read. Reverted.
3.6 hRound 21 — allow_in_graph on the fused MLP Function (20:35–20:39)
DecoratingFusedMLPwith@torch._dynamo.allow_in_graph(the pattern_Float8Matmuluses): 0.9708 s/update, speedup 1.0486 — slightly worse than 0.9685/1.0511. Reverted.
3.8 hRound 22 — fused forward quantization op (20:35–20:53, experiment copy)
Prepared (in/tmp/nanochat-exponly) a custom op replacing the MLP forward'sto_fp8_scale(relu(h)^2)with two Triton kernels (amax-of-a^2 and quantize) so both passes readainstead of Inductor's amax+quantize pair. Result: slower — 0.9752 s/update, speedup 1.0439 (vs 0.9685/1.0511). Inductor's fused amax (which fuses the relu^2 producer) plus its quantize kernel is cheaper than a 2-pass custom region here. Not moved into the submission (submission unchanged and validated). --- # UPDATE — best validated state after the expensive-lever rounds (20:53) Tree:/submission/nanochat@993a7e7, working tree clean. Switches (/submission/switches.json):NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2,NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_FUSEDMLP=1,TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1,TORCHINDUCTOR_PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS=0. Verdict evidence for exactly this configuration: -/tmp/check-H: PASS, N1, speedup 1.0471 (windows 1.0471/1.0538/1.0480) -/tmp/check-I: PASS, N1, speedup 1.0466 (windows 1.0467/1.0475/1.0466) -/tmp/t-fusedmlp3(time): speedup 1.0511 (windows 1.0488/1.0554/1.0493) Gate 2 exact items identical in both checks; gate 3 all six endpoints within 0.28 sigma (bound 3 sigma). Cumulative progression of the validated speedup: reference 1.000 -> accum 1.0256 -> +bucket 1.0242 -> +pointwise autotune 1.0296 -> +scheduling 1.0336 -> +baddbmm 1.0346 -> +persistent reductions off 1.0358/1.0371 -> +custom fused MLP gradient kernels 1.0466/1.0471 (time samples 1.0402 -> 1.0511). Expensive-lever outcome: the one custom kernel that paid off isnanochat/mlp_fused.py(MLP block relu^2-backward + FP8 dual-layout quantize, 0.73 ms vs Inductor's 1.33 ms for the same 2.8 GB, plus a 0.42 ms abs-max pass vs 0.40 ms). Two attempted extensions of it (custom abs-max via an opaque op; a fused forward quantize op) were measurably slower because they break Inductor's producer fusion, and are not used. Everything else in the step is at the library's limit for these shapes (FP8 GEMMs ~1.25 PFLOPS = 65-75% of the machine peak, FA3 ~57% of bf16 peak in the backward, elementwise fusions 80-85% of the memory roofline). No processes left running; both GPUs idle.
4.0 hRound 23 — hotspot identification from Inductor's generated code (20:53–20:58)
Dumped Inductor's code for the current best (1-step run,/tmp/ind2) and read the two unidentified kernels: -view_15-type (10.2 ms/up, 98 calls): a standalone re-quantize+transpose of an attention linear's [M,1536] gradient (reads bf16, writes fp8 transposed) at 2.8 TB/s — small traffic, already efficient. -view_27-type (14.8 ms/up, 96 calls): the RoPE backward already fused with the dual-layout FP8 quantize of its result in one kernel (reads the two rope halves, writes both layouts) at 2.6 TB/s — nothing to split. - Cross-entropy: forward kernel is the online softmax withlibdevice.tanh(accurate tanh on 2.1 B logits per pass, measured ~5.4e11 tanh/s); the backward kernels recompute the same tanh. A custom CE cannot be faster without changing the model function (an approximate tanh would be N3), so this direction is closed. Conclusion: no tractable single hotspot remains; the remaining time is spread over fused kernels at 2.6-3.9 TB/s and the FP8 GEMMs/FA3 at the libraries' limits.
4.0 hRound 24 — abs-max of a^2 from max(a) with the fast custom kernel (20:58–21:01)
Sincemax(bf16(a^2)) = bf16(max(a)^2)exactly, the MLP forward's a2 abs-max (20.2 ms/up at 1.9 TB/s under Inductor) was replaced by the fast custom abs-max overa(3.85 TB/s) while keeping Inductor's quantize fusion. Result: still slower — 0.9770 s/update, speedup 1.0420 (vs 0.9685/1.0511). Even a purely additive custom reduction breaks Inductor'smul_relufusion into the abs-max, costing more than the faster reduction saves. Reverted; submission unchanged and validated.
4.1 hRound 25 — paired verification against a live reference (21:02–21:09)
bench.py time --paired on the final configuration (timing pattern of the final evaluation: reference run
immediately followed by the candidate): candidate windows 0.9684/0.9718/0.9713 s/update,
speedup_vs_paired_reference 1.0485, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0489. The live reference and the frozen
reference agree, so the ~1.049 speedup is not an artifact of the frozen timing.4.2 hRound 26 — unlimited-window FA3 path for the long layers (21:09–21:13)
SwitchNANOCHAT_OPT_NOWIN=1: the SSSL long layers passwindow_size=(-1,0)instead of(seq_len,0)(identical attention math; the short window stays derived from the sequence length). Result: 0.9705 s/update, speedup 1.0471 vs 1.0511 — neutral/slightly worse (FA3 already treats window >= seqlen as plain causal). Discarded. (A first attempt was aborted because derivingshort_windowfrom the overridden long window collapsed it to 0; caught before any result was used.)
4.3 hRound 27 — Inductor C++ launcher (21:13–21:19)
The inter-update gap (4.7 ms/update) is the compiled graph's Python launcher, soTORCHINDUCTOR_CPP_WRAPPER=1was tested. Result: 0.9775 s/update, speedup 1.0456 vs 1.0511; startup 297 s (vs 166 s) for the C++ build. Slightly worse, discarded. --- # FINAL STATE (21:19) Tree:/submission/nanochat@993a7e7, working tree clean. Switches (/submission/switches.json):NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2,NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_FUSEDMLP=1,TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1,TORCHINDUCTOR_PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS=0. Best evidence for exactly this configuration: - full check/tmp/check-H: PASS, N1, 1.0471 - full check/tmp/check-I: PASS, N1, 1.0466 - paired run (live reference immediately before the candidate): 1.0485; frozen-reference ratio 1.0489 -timesamples: 1.0489, 1.0511 Gate 2 exact items identical, gate 3 all six endpoints within 0.28 sigma, all timing windows within 0.4%. Gains (each measured with the judge's own commands): | change | speedup | tier | |---|---|---| | micro-batches 4x16 -> 2x32 (NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2) | 1.0251 | N1 | | bucketed small AdamW all-reduce (NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET=1) | +0.1% | N0 | | Inductor pointwise/reduction autotune | +0.55% | N1 | | optimizer scheduling + copy elisions (NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED=1) | +0.16% | N0 | | baddbmm Newton-Schulz (NANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM=1) | +0.24% | N1 | | persistent reductions off | +0.26% | N1 | | custom fused MLP gradient kernels (NANOCHAT_OPT_FUSEDMLP=1) | +1.2% | N1 | Rejected directions (with numbers in the rounds above): shared QKV quantize (no gain), cuBLASLt workspace (OOM), NCCL proto (no change), full max-autotune (+0.08% for +300 s), CUDA graphs (SIGSEGV), realize-everything (0.993), FA3 num_splits=2 (0.998), dynamic_scale_rblock=0 (1.0334), forward precise accum (1.0272), online softmax off (1.0377), cooperative reductions (0.783), custom abs-max inside the MLP path (1.042), custom forward quantize op (1.0439), allow_in_graph (1.0486), unlimited-window FA3 (1.0471), C++ launcher (1.0456).
4.3 hRound 28 — re-read the MLP forward amax kernel (21:19–21:22, analysis)
From the dumped code,triton_red_fused__to_copy_abs_max_mul_relu_18(20.2 ms/update) is an in-place fused kernel: it computesrelu(h)intoa's buffer and the max ofrelu(h)^2in the same pass (1.6 GB, 3.8 TB/s = roofline). This explains why both custom replacements of it were slower; the forward is already optimally fused. No change (analysis round).
4.3 hRound 29 — third full check of the final configuration (21:22–)
Running bench.py check again on the unchanged final tree/switches to add a third independent PASS sample.4.3 hRound 30 — value-embedding / small-GEMM accounting (21:22, analysis)
Checked the remaining "suspicious" kernels in the current profile: the value-embedding chain (gather + gate +v + gate*ve+ sigmoid) is 6.0 ms/update across 24 fused kernels (3.7 TB/s, roofline); theve_gatebf16 linears are 0.76 ms/update of tiny cutlass kernels;embedding_dense_backwardscatter-adds are 2.0 ms/update. The "cutlass" total of 111 ms is the FA3 attention (110.7 ms), not GEMM leftovers. No tractable hotspot remains.
4.3 hRound 29 result — third full check (21:20–21:31)
/tmp/check-J(unchanged final tree/switches): PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0438 (windows 1.0484/1.0488/1.0438; gate 2 exact items ok; gate 3 biases identical to check-H/I, all within 0.28 sigma). Three independent full checks of the final configuration now pass: check-H 1.0471, check-I 1.0466, check-J 1.0438; paired-vs-live-reference 1.0485;timesamples 1.0489 and 1.0511. Mean ~1.047, run-to-run window noise ~0.5%.
4.6 hRound 31 — full Inductor max-autotune retest in the new graph (21:31–21:41)
Re-testedTORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE=1on top of the final configuration (it would Triton-template the 20 ms/update Muon bmm set). Windows [0.9653, 0.9687, 0.9701] s/update, speedup 1.0517 (min-window ratio 1.0492) vs the current config's [0.9679, 0.9675, 0.9700], 1.0511 (min-window 1.0488) — within run-to-run noise, with startup 486 s instead of 166 s. Not enabled; the current configuration stays. --- # FINAL STATE (21:41) — unchanged and best-validated Tree/submission/nanochat@993a7e7(clean). Switches:NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2,NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM=1,NANOCHAT_OPT_FUSEDMLP=1,TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE=1,TORCHINDUCTOR_PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS=0. Evidence: three full checks PASS, N1 (1.0471 / 1.0466 / 1.0438), paired vs a live reference 1.0485,timesamples 1.0489 / 1.0511 / 1.0517(max-autotune variant). Every remaining component of the step sits at the memory roofline, the accurate-tanh cost, or the FP8-GEMM/FA3 libraries' limits; the only sub-roofline region (the MLP dual-layout FP8 store) is the custom kernel innanochat/mlp_fused.py.
4.7 hRound 32 — Inductor cudagraph trees (21:42–21:46)
TORCHINDUCTOR_CUDAGRAPHS=1(Inductor's cudagraph-tree implementation, a different code path frommode="reduce-overhead", which crashed in round 9). Result: SIGSEGV again (exitcode -11 during graph capture of the FP8_scaled_mmpath). CUDA graphs are definitively not usable with this FP8 autograd path; closed. The switch is not in switches.json.
4.7 hRound 33 — value-embedding gradient scatter analysis (21:46–21:50, analysis)
Read the fused kernel that carries the value-embedding backward (...embedding_dense_backward_mul_nll_loss_forward..., 6.88 ms/update, 24 calls): it reducesv*veover the head dim for the gate, quantizes the v gradient, and scatters the value-embedding gradient withtl.atomic_addover 65536x1536 = 100 M elements per layer per micro-step (2.4 B atomics/update, ~1.4 TB/s effective because of atomic contention). A sorted/segmented non-atomic scatter could reach ~2-4 TB/s (est. 3-4 ms/update, 0.4%) but would require taking over the whole fused region (gate backward + v quantize + scatter) and a 65536-element sort per layer; the expected gain is below the run-to-run noise of the gate and the effort/risk is high, so it is left as the one documented remaining micro-opportunity. # END OF LOG
4.8 hRound 34 — ablation: pointwise/reduction autotuning (21:48–21:51)
Removed TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE from the final configuration (everything else unchanged):
1.0487 s/update, speedup 0.9707 — i.e. the autotuner is now worth ~8 % (it was +0.55 % before the
persistent-reduction and fused-MLP changes). Single-kernel config selection dominates the step in the current
graph, so this switch is essential and stays. This also explains part of the run-to-run variance (the choice is
made by timing during compile).4.9 hRound 35 — retest dynamic reduction block scaling in the new regime (21:51–21:54)
TORCHINDUCTOR_DYNAMIC_SCALE_RBLOCK=0 with everything else at the final configuration: 0.9736 s/update,
speedup 1.0456 (windows 1.0467/1.0489/1.0413) vs 1.0511. Worse; default (=1) stays. Together with round 34 this
confirms the current autotune configuration is the right one: the pointwise/reduction autotuner is essential
(+8 %), and its default dynamic block scaling is better than the fixed alternative.4.9 hRound 36 — widened autotune search space (21:55–21:59)
Since per-kernel config choice is worth ~8 %, NANOCHAT_OPT_ATPLUS=1 appends extra tile/warp candidates to
Inductor's own autotune lists for 1-D pointwise and reduction kernels (the autotuner still picks the fastest,
so extra candidates only cost compile time; they are appended so deterministic mode's first-config choice is
unchanged). Result: 0.9706 s/update, speedup 1.0488 vs 1.0511 — no gain (slightly worse, within noise): the
built-in search space is already adequate, and more noisy candidates do not improve the pick. Switch stays off.4.9 hRound 37 — autotuner measurement robustness (21:59–22:02, analysis)
Read Inductor's per-config benchmark: it usesbenchmark_gpuwithbenchmark_iters=100,max_benchmark_duration=25 msandreturn_mode="min", i.e. the minimum over up to 100 repetitions. The measurement is already robust, so the round-36 result is "no better candidates exist", not selection noise. Direction closed. (TheNANOCHAT_OPT_ATPLUScode is inert with the switch off.)
5.0 hRound 38 — final clean timing sample on the submitted tree (22:00–22:03)
timeon/submission/nanochat@6f7d8abwith/submission/switches.json(the ATPLUS code is inert): windows [0.9679, 0.9718, 0.9702] s/update, speedup 1.0495 (ratios 1.0488/1.0507/1.0491), startup 166 s, peak 94.0 GiB. Consistent with the three full checks (1.0471/1.0466/1.0438) and the paired run (1.0485).
5.1 hRound 39 — retest shared QKV quantization in the final graph (22:04–22:07)
Inductor's code shows the per-block kernel that does the residual blend + RMSNorm + FP8 quantize for the attention input writing three identical transposed fp8 tensors (one per c_q/c_k/c_v_Float8Matmulsaved input) and recomputing that forward path inside the backward (~1.6 GB/call of avoidable traffic — the biggest single redundancy found in the whole profile, ~10-16 ms/update if removable). Re-enabled the shared-QKV path (NANOCHAT_OPT_QKV=1,_Float8Matmul3, one quantization shared by the three projections): 0.9710 s/update, speedup 1.0484 vs 1.0495/1.0511 — neutral (the fused Function does not shrink the saved-input buffers in the partitioner and loses other fusions). Closed a second time; switch stays off.
5.1 hRound 40 — explicit shared QKV quantization tensor (22:08–22:12, experiment copy)
Third attempt at the triple-saved QKV input (after rounds 2 and 39): a new_Float8MatmulPreautograd Function takes the already-quantized attention input as an *explicit* tensor, so all three projections reference the same saved value (ctx.save_for_backward(x8)) instead of each saving a private copy. Arithmetic identical to_Float8Matmul. Implemented in/tmp/nanochat-exponly and measured with the current switches: 0.9711 s/update, speedup 1.0488 vs 1.0495/1.0511 — neutral again. So the three identical transposed fp8 stores are not on the critical path (the per-block kernel is read/latency bound, not store bound). Not moved into the submission; the submission is unchanged.
5.2 hRound 41 — fourth full check of the exact submitted tree (22:12–)
Contents are byte-identical to993a7e7; runningbench.py checkonce more to add a fourth independent PASS/timing sample for the final configuration (the score is decided by this command, so repeated confirmation is the highest-value remaining use of the budget).
5.2 hRound 41 result — fourth full check (22:12–22:24)
/tmp/check-Kon the exact submitted tree: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0484 (candidate windows 0.9682/0.9676/0.9705 s -> ratios 1.0484/1.0553/1.0487; gate 2 exact items ok; gate 3 biases identical again). Four independent full checks of the final configuration now pass: check-H 1.0471, check-I 1.0466, check-J 1.0438, check-K 1.0484 (mean 1.0465, min 1.0438) paired-vs-live-reference 1.0485;timesamples 1.0489 / 1.0495 / 1.0511.
5.4 hRound 42 — power/clock diagnostic + expandable segments (22:26–22:30)
Samplednvidia-smievery 5 s across a fulltimerun: - during the measured steps both GPUs draw ~693 W of the 700 W cap at 100 % utilisation; - SM clock 1980 MHz at the start -> 1620 -> 1500 -> 1440 MHz by the end of the 34-step run, temperature 62 C (well below the thermal limit), i.e. the GPUs are software-power-capped, not thermally throttled. This is the fundamental limit of the last few percent: at a fixed power cap the time per update is energy-per-update / cap, which is why every remaining improvement had to remove *work* (bytes, passes, kernels) rather than just run the same work faster, and why the later windows of a run are systematically a few tenths of a percent slower than the first (the score uses the slowest window).PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:Truewas tested in the same run (it cannot change the arithmetic): windows 0.9683/0.9723/0.9687 s, speedup 1.0497 (min-window ratio 1.0483), reserved peak 94.8 GiB vs 96 GiB. Neutral on time, so it is not added toswitches.json(no unproven knobs in the submitted configuration).
5.5 hRound 43 — second paired measurement (22:30–)
The final evaluation times the reference and the candidate in the same session; a second time --paired sample
gives the expected final ratio and its spread directly (first sample: 1.0485).5.5 hRound 43 result — second paired measurement (22:30–22:36)
time --paired (reference run immediately followed by the candidate, i.e. the final evaluation's pattern):
candidate windows 0.9703/0.9738/0.9715 s -> speedup_vs_paired_reference 1.0479 (vs_frozen 1.0474).
Two paired samples now: 1.0485 and 1.0479 (mean 1.0482), consistent with the four full checks
(1.0471 / 1.0466 / 1.0438 / 1.0484). Expected final score ~1.046-1.048, i.e. 2.6-2.8 % above the 1.02 bar.5.6 hRound 44 — cross-entropy / lm_head gradient path closure (22:37-22:45, analysis)
Checked whether a fully fused cross-entropy could beat Inductor's two kernels by reading the generated code: - the lm_head gradient kernel (..._tanh_tanh_backward_view_2, 65536x32768) **already writes both FP8 layouts in the same kernel** (out_ptr0row-major,out_ptr1transposed) — nothing to save there; - the CE backward is[log_softmax bwd + dlogits + dlogits amax](9.05 ms) followed by[tanh bwd + dual-layout quantize](9.03 ms), i.e. dlogits is materialised once (4.3 GB) and then read once. A fused version would have to re-read the logits and the upstream gradient in the quantize pass (8.6 GB instead of 4.3 GB), so it would be *slower*, not faster. Both kernels run at ~2.9 TB/s. The cross-entropy path is therefore optimal given the exact-tanh requirement; the last expensive rewrite candidate is closed on evidence (round 23 had closed it on the tanh throughput alone).
5.6 hRound 45 — full code audit of the submitted tree vs the reference (22:45-)
Diffed every file against/opt/researchboost/ws/targets/referenceto confirm that the submitted tree contains exactly the intended changes and nothing accidentally active: -nanochat/optim.py89 changed lines — bucketed small-param all-reduce (OPTBUCKET), phase ordering + stack/copy elisions (OPTSCHED), baddbmm Newton-Schulz (NSBMM): all three *active*. -nanochat/mlp_fused.pynew, 163 lines — custom fused MLP gradient quantization (FUSEDMLP): *active*. -scripts/base_train.py24 — micro-batch regrouping (ACCUM) *active*; the REALIZE/CUDAGRAPH/ATPLUS blocks are inert (switch off). -nanochat/fp8.py48 —_Float8Matmul3(QKV) +_OPT_FWDACC: inert, off. -nanochat/gpt.py23 — QKV branch (off) + the FUSEDMLP dispatch (on). -nanochat/flash_attention.py7 — FASPLIT switch: inert, off. No unintended activation, no debug left enabled, no changed default in the reference paths used by the checks.
5.7 hRound 46 — Inductor codegen options (numerics-neutral), four tested (22:38-22:47)
Added temporary switches for the remaining numerics-neutral Inductor codegen options and measured each on top of the final configuration (the switches were then removed; the tree is back to the validated content): -triton.tile_reductions-> InductorError ("failed to set ranges [1536, 1]") on these kernels, crash. -triton.use_block_ptr-> 0.9763 s/update, speedup 1.0427 (windows 1.0410/1.0465/1.0406) — worse. -triton.use_tensor_descriptor(TMA, sm90) -> 0.9694 s/update, speedup 1.0501 (windows 1.0476/1.0515/1.0512, min-window 1.0476) — neutral vs 1.0495/1.0511 (min-window 1.0488). -triton.dense_indexing-> Triton CompilationError ("r0_mask is not defined"), crash. All four are rejected; none is inswitches.jsonand the code was reverted (git diff 993a7e7 HEADempty).
5.8 hRound 47 — fifth full check of the exact submitted tree (22:48-)
The check CLI has no separate "final" mode; check is the protocol (gates 0-3) and the final evaluation runs it
with the reference timed twice. Running it once more on the unchanged tree for a fifth independent sample of the
score and to confirm nothing has drifted on the machine over the session.5.8 hRound 47 result — fifth full check (22:48-22:59)
/tmp/check-L: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0461 (candidate windows 0.9704/0.9735/0.9709 ->
ratios 1.0461/1.0489/1.0483). Five checks now: 1.0471 / 1.0466 / 1.0438 / 1.0484 / 1.0461 (mean 1.0464,
min 1.0438). No drift on the machine over the session.6.0 hRound 48 — activation-checkpointing policy: save-all vs min-cut (23:00-23:03, experiment copy)
torch._functorch.config.min_cut_rematerialization_partitionno longer exists in torch 2.9, so the alternative partitioner was installed throughtorch._inductor.config.custom_partitioner_fnusingtorch._functorch.partitioners.default_partition(save every stashed activation instead of recomputing any). Result: 0.9684 s/update, speedup 1.0512 (windows 1.0524/1.0529/1.0484), i.e. identical to the min-cut configuration (0.9685/1.0511) but with peak memory 113.7 GiB instead of 94.0 GiB. Neutral on time, materially less safe on memory -> rejected; the submission keeps the default partitioner.
6.1 hRound 49 — hoisting the weight quantization out of the compiled graph (23:04-23:07, experiment copy)
The last identified redundancy was that each FP8 layer re-quantizes its weight in both micro-steps (~4.4 ms/update at ~3 TB/s). ImplementedNANOCHAT_OPT_WQ=1: per-module fp8 weight buffers refreshed once per optimizer step byrefresh_fp8_weights()(outside the compiled region) and a_Float8MatmulWFunction that consumes them (arithmetic identical to_Float8Matmul). Result: 0.9765 s/update, speedup 1.0425 (windows 1.0381/1.0473/1.0420) — clearly worse than 1.0495/1.0511: outside the compiled graph the 145 per-layer_to_fp8calls become individually launched eager kernels instead of Inductor's fused ones, costing more than the saved duplicate pass. Rejected; submission unchanged (the experiment stayed in /tmp/nanochat-exp2). --- # CLOSING SUMMARY (23:08)
6.1 hRound 50 — re-ablation of the earliest optimizer switch in the final graph (23:08-23:11)
NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET was measured at +0.1% early in the session (before the fused-MLP and phase-ordering
changes), so it was re-ablated now: without it, 0.9707 s/update, speedup 1.0487 (windows
1.0482/1.0500/1.0482) vs 0.9685-0.9700 / 1.0495-1.0511 with it. It still pays (small but consistent) -> kept.
Together with rounds 34/35 this means every switch in the submitted configuration has been ablated *in the final
graph*, not only at the time it was introduced.6.2 hRound 51 — re-ablation of persistent reductions in the final graph (23:12-23:15)
TORCHINDUCTOR_PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS was turned off early (round 15) because it cost 0.3%; the mechanism it
would help (the norm backward's split reduction+elementwise, 23 ms/update) is now a bigger share of the step, so
it was retested: 0.9748 s/update, speedup 1.0443 (windows 1.0435/1.0446/1.0450) vs 0.9685-0.9700 /
1.0495-1.0511. Still clearly worse; it must be hurting other reductions more than it helps the norms. Off stays.
With rounds 34/35/50 this completes a full re-ablation of the submitted configuration in the final graph:
MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE essential (~8%), DYNAMIC_SCALE_RBLOCK=0 negative, OPTBUCKET still positive,
PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS=1 negative -> the seven switches are each individually justified *now*.6.3 hRound 52 — re-ablation of OPTSCHED, completing the switch audit (23:16-23:19)
NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED off (everything else final): 0.9740 s/update, speedup 1.0452
(windows 1.0465/1.0470/1.0420) vs 0.9685-0.9700 / 1.0495-1.0511 with it. It is worth ~+0.4% in the final graph
(more than the +0.16% measured when introduced) -> kept.
### Final switch audit (all measured in the final graph)
| switch | without it | with it | verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| NANOCHAT_OPT_ACCUM=2 | 4x16 micro-batches | 1.0251 when introduced | kept |
| NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTBUCKET | 1.0487 | 1.0495-1.0511 | kept |
| NANOCHAT_OPT_OPTSCHED | 1.0452 | 1.0495-1.0511 | kept |
| NANOCHAT_OPT_NSBMM | (elementwise form) | +0.24% when introduced | kept |
| NANOCHAT_OPT_FUSEDMLP | 1.0358 | 1.0466 (+1.2%) | kept |
| TORCHINDUCTOR_MAX_AUTOTUNE_POINTWISE | 0.9707 (1.0487 s/up) | 1.0495-1.0511 | essential |
| TORCHINDUCTOR_PERSISTENT_REDUCTIONS=0 | 1.0443 (=1) | 1.0495-1.0511 | kept |6.3 hRound 53 — sixth full check (23:20-)
No further implementation change is justified by the measurements, so the remaining budget is spent on the one
thing that directly de-risks the score: repeating the judge's own check on the unchanged tree.6.3 hRound 53 result — sixth full check and final score statistics (23:20-23:31)
/tmp/check-M: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0478 (windows 0.9688/0.9674/0.9707 -> 1.0478/1.0555/1.0485;
gate 2 exact items ok; gate 3 identical biases).
All score samples on the submitted configuration (n=8: 6 full checks + 2 paired runs):
1.0471 1.0466 1.0438 1.0484 1.0461 1.0478 1.0485 1.0479
mean 1.0470, std 0.0016, min 1.0438
Margin over the 1.02 bar: worst case +2.33%, mean +2.65%. The bar is cleared by a wide margin in every
measurement, and the spread (0.16%) is measurement/thermal noise, not implementation variance.
# END OF WORK LOG6.5 hRound 54 — final integrity verification (23:31)
-/submission/switches.json: valid JSON, exactly the seven audited keys. -/submission/nanochat: working tree clean, HEAD8aa07ca,git diff 993a7e7 HEADempty (content identical to the commit that passed six full checks). -nanochat/mlp_fused.pyis imported bynanochat/gpt.pyat the MLP dispatch; every changed file compiles. - No processes running; both GPUs idle (0 MiB). Remaining identified-but-unimplemented opportunity, quantified for the record: the RMSNorm region is ~91 ms/update and its backward runs as two passes (a reduction + an elementwise kernel, ~23 ms/update for the backward alone). Fusing it into one pass needs anautograd.Function, which makes the region opaque and therefore breaks the forward's fusion with the residual add (and loses the add-only backward fusion), i.e. the same failure mode that measured negative in five of six custom-op attempts this session (custom abs-max 1.0420, forward quantize 1.0439, hoisted weight quantize 1.0425, allow_in_graph 1.0486, block-ptr/TMA codegen). Expected value is not positive, so the validated submission is left untouched.
6.5 hRound 55 — quantifying the last expensive lever before committing to it (23:32-23:36)
Fresh profile (3 updates) with all kernels whose name containsrms_norm_backwardsummed: - norm-backward kernels total 120.8 ms/up (8.3% of the profiled step); - of that, only 34.6 ms is the separable two-kernel backward (poi_..._add_mul_neg_slice20.5 +red_..._mul14.1); - the remaining ~86 ms is already fused with neighbouring ops: the adjacent FP8 quantize (..._scaled_mm_..._abs_add_clamp_clone_max_mul_reciprocal_..., ~30 kernels of ~2.8/1.1 ms), the value-embeddingmm(..._abs_add_max_mm_mul_select...), andslice_backward. Replacingnorm()with an opaque autograd Function would break exactly those fusions (they carry the majority of the time), to fuse a 34.6 ms two-kernel sequence down to roughly 20 ms — i.e. about +9 ms (1%) of upside against more than that in fusion losses. The same reasoning that made five of six earlier opaque-op attempts measure negative applies here with a *measured* breakdown, so this lever is declined on evidence rather than attempted blind, and the six-times-validated submission is left untouched. (Note: profile mode inflates absolute times by ~1.5x due to the profiler; the proportions are what matter, and scaled to the real 968 ms step the separable norm-backward gain is ~8-11 ms, 0.8-1.1%, before any fusion loss.)
6.6 hRound 56 — definitive kernel accounting from a full profile (23:32-23:40)
Fresh 3-update profile: total 971 ms/up of kernel time (the profiler does not inflate this workload; the un-profiled wall is 968 ms). Complete accounting of every component: | component | ms/up | share | limit | |---|---|---|---| | FP8 GEMMs (6 nvjet kernels: fwd 162.7+44.4, bwd 139.7+83.8+10.2, Muon bmm 16.9) | 458 | 47% | cuBLASLt, ~1.25 PFLOPS | | FA3 attention (bwd 44.0+25.1, fwd 17.2, pre/post 15.9) | 102 | 10.5% | library | | my MLP kernels (_quant_dual35.6 +_amax_gh19.9) | 55.5 | 5.7% | 3.8-3.9 TB/s = roofline | | MLP forward (Inductor amax 20.3 + quantize 17.4) | 37.7 | 3.9% | 3.4-3.8 TB/s = roofline | | RMSNorm backward (separable 13.6+9.4, plus fused ~40) | ~63 | 6.5% | fused with quantize/ve_gate | | RoPE (fwd 19.1 + bwd 14.7) | 33.8 | 3.5% | 2.6-4.0 TB/s = roofline | | cross-entropy (fwd 7.9, bwd 9.1+9.1) | ~27 | 2.8% | exact-tanhbound | | value embeddings / gathers / scatters | ~20 | 2.1% | atomic scatter | | quantize+transpose kernels (~98 calls) | ~20 | 2.1% | 2.8-2.9 TB/s | | NCCL (overlapped) | 12 | 1.2% | NVLink | | everything else (smear, backout, lambdas, residuals, CE-adjacent) | ~140 | 14% | fused pointwise, roofline | Every line is at a measured external limit; there is no remaining kernel with an unexplained gap to its roofline. Combined with the 0.16% measurement spread and a 2.33% worst-case margin over the 1.02 bar, further work has no positive expected value, and the submitted tree (validated six times) is final.
6.6 hRound 57 — the "everything else" bucket itemized (23:40)
Grouped the whole profile by component: GEMM 468.4, FA3 111.0, norm backward 80.5, my MLP kernels 55.4, norm/rope-fused 44.0, MLP forward 37.7, CE 34.8, NCCL 24.3, embeddings 5.7, and a remaining 109.6 ms/up across 120 distinct kernels. That remainder is, in full: - quantize / transpose / slice kernels for the linear layers (view_29 14.7, view_15 10.2, view_13 6.9, view_16 4.8+4.6, clamp_mul_t_13 4.3, view_28 3.4, t_28 3.65, view_23 2.9, view_78 2.4, to_copy_12 1.4, ...) ~55 ms, all measured at 2.8-3.3 TB/s; - abs-max reductions (view_20 3.5, view_11 3.4, view_27 5.5) ~12 ms, fused with producers; - optimizer copies and elementwise (multi_tensor_apply 3.7, vectorized_add<float> 2.6, Muon/AdamW elementwise ~3.4) ~10 ms, at 1.4-2.2 TB/s on 2.4 MB per-tensor copies (multi_tensor_apply granularity); - the remainder is <2 ms each. Nothing in the bucket has an unexplained gap: it is quantize/transpose traffic at the roofline, fused reductions, and the optimizer's small-tensor copies. The accounting is now closed end to end, which is the quantitative basis for stopping: the submitted tree has been validated six times and every one of its 971 ms/update is attributable to a measured hardware or library limit.
6.6 hRound 58 — final quick gate (gates 0+2) on the submitted tree (23:37-)
Running check --quick (formulation checks + the bitwise/exact-item gate, no timing, no trajectories) as a last
integrity gate on the unchanged tree.6.6 hRound 58 result — quick gate (23:37-23:39)
check --quick(gates 0+2 only) on the submitted tree: statusNOT_BITWISE, withexact_items_ok: true,problems: [], 175 parameters compared, 52 differing at update 0 and 175 from update 1. This is the expected and documented outcome for this submission: the N1 changes (micro-batch regrouping, optimizer ordering, baddbmm rounding, and the fused MLP kernels) reorder reductions, so gate 2 is not bitwise — which is exactly why every fullcheckreportstier: N1after passing gate 3 (the statistical gate) with all six endpoints within 0.28 sigma. Gate 0 (formulation) and the exact-item check pass, i.e. same parameter names, shapes and dtypes, one model init, same fp8 flags.
6.6 hRound 59 — closing declaration (23:39)
The two remaining candidates were both re-examined analytically this round and are not positive expected value: 1. RMSNorm backward rewrite (measured above): 34.6 ms separable, of which ~9 ms is recoverable by fusing the two passes, against ~57 ms of fused kernels that an opaque replacement would split. Not attempted. 2. Dual-layout quantize for the attention linears' gradients: 600 MB per linear today (row-major quantize + re-quantize/transpose from bf16) vs 400 MB for a single dual-layout kernel, i.e. ~4-5 ms (0.5%) — but only for the linears whose backward is *not* already fused (view_15/view_13), and the op cannot be applied selectively; for the already-fused ones (view_27/view_29, rope backward) it would add a bf16 round-trip and lose. Measured outcome of the analogous blanket attempt (rounds 2/39/40 on the QKV input, round 49 on the weights): neutral to negative every time. To go faster from here would require either an approximate tanh, FP8 attention, oruse_fast_accumin the GEMM backward — all precision changes (N2/N3), which the task forbids and which the agent tier (N1) excludes. The submission is therefore final: content ==993a7e7, seven audited switches, six full PASS checks at tier N1, mean speedup 1.0470 with a worst case of 1.0438 (2.33% above the 1.02 bar).
6.6 hRound 60 — stability sample (23:40-)
No change is justified (see rounds 55-59). Taking one more time sample of the unchanged configuration to add to
the stability statistics.6.6 hRound 60 result — stability sample (23:40-23:43)
time on the unchanged configuration: windows 0.9679/0.9696/0.9694 s -> ratios 1.0488/1.0531/1.0499,
speedup 1.0506.
All nine score samples of the submitted configuration:
1.0471 1.0466 1.0438 1.0484 1.0461 1.0478 1.0485 1.0479 1.0506
mean 1.0474, std 0.0019, min 1.0438, max 1.0506
Worst-case margin over the 1.02 bar: +2.33%. No drift over ~4 hours of session.6.7 hRound 61 — per-update timing pattern inside the measured windows (23:43)
Extracted the individual update times from the timing logs of the submitted configuration (updates 10-32 of
/tmp/t-final3):
963 961 964 970 976 968 970 970 969 970 970 973 970 965 971 968 969 969 967 967 972 970 968 ms
mean 968.7, min 961.4, max 975.5, spread 1.47%
Findings: (a) the first three measured updates are the fastest (963/961/964 ms) and everything after settles at
~969-970 ms — the GPU warming into its power cap, exactly the clock drift measured in round 42; (b) there is **no
periodic pattern** (the slowest updates, 14/21/30, are not spaced), so the data loader, allocator and parquet row
groups are not causing stalls; (c) run-to-run and within-run variation is now the only source of spread, and it is
clock/thermal, not implementation.
Since the reported score is the *minimum* window ratio, the score is set by the coldest part of the run, which is
measured identically for the frozen reference - the comparison is fair and there is nothing further to tune.6.7 hRound 62 — submission tree cleanup (23:44)
The submitted tree contained untrackednanochat/__pycache__/andscripts/__pycache__/directories (bytecode from my experimental runs, gitignored but copied along with the tree). Removed them so the judged tree is pristine:git status --ignoredis now empty,git statusclean, andgit diff 993a7e7 HEADis still empty (content unchanged). All changed files re-verified to parse (without writing new bytecode, using -B).
6.9 hRound 63 — removing the relu(h) materialisation in the fused MLP (23:44-23:59) — REAL WIN
Found a genuine inefficiency inside my *own* kernel region:FusedMLP.forwardmaterialiseda = relu(h)(805 MB write per call, 48 calls/update) only so that Inductor's FP8 quantize and my two custom backward kernels could read it. But all three can recompute the rectifier from the pre-activationhinline (exact), and my kernels already did (ar = max(av, 0)); onlya8in_quant_dual_kernelhad to switch fromav*avtoar*ar(same value). So the change is bitwise identical. Measured: -time(experiment copy): windows 0.9639/0.9682/0.9652 s -> ratios 1.0531/1.0546/1.0545, speedup 1.0540 (best of the session), losses on the reference trajectory. - fullcheck(/tmp/check-N): PASS, tier N1, 1.0472 (windows 0.9649/0.9684/0.9719), exact items ok, gate-3 biases bit-identical to all previous checks. Signal: the first (least thermally affected) window improves from 0.9674-0.9704 s in every earlier run to 0.9639/0.9649 s now, i.e. ~0.3-0.4% real; the mean per-update time moves 0.9695 -> 0.9671 s. Committed to the submission as the new best version.
6.9 hRound 63 — second confirmation sample
timeon the submitted (updated) tree: windows 0.9647/0.9648/0.9661 s -> ratios 1.0522/1.0584/1.0535, speedup 1.0547, mean 0.9652 s/update. New best version (commit8afe4f1): mean per-update time 0.9652-0.9658 s vs 0.9685-0.9716 s before the change (-0.4%), with score samples 1.0472 (check-N), 1.0540, 1.0547.
6.9 hRound 63 — second full check on the new best
/tmp/check-O: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0531 (candidate windows 0.9639/0.9677/0.9657 s -> ratios 1.0531/1.0552/1.0540), exact items ok, gate-3 biases identical. New best version (commit8afe4f1, "stop materialising relu(h) in the fused MLP"): - checks: 1.0531 (check-O), 1.0472 (check-N, whose third window was thermally unlucky) -time: 1.0540, 1.0547 - mean per-update time 0.9652-0.9658 s vs 0.9685-0.9716 s before = -0.4% - mean score of the four samples: 1.0523 (vs 1.0474 for the nine samples of the previous best) This is the new submitted configuration.
7.5 hRound 64 — custom kernels for the MLP forward FP8 quantize (00:17-00:32) — REAL WIN
The round-63 profile showed the MLP forward's a2 quantization as two Inductor kernels at 3.0-3.1 TB/s (abs_max_pow_relu12.69 +clamp_mul_pow_relu_t19.06 = 31.75 ms/update) while my own kernels reach 3.8 TB/s. Since this region is *inside* my MLP block (its producer is the c_fc GEMM, its consumer the c_proj GEMM), taking it over cannot break any Inductor fusion. Added tomlp_fused.py:_amax_a2_kernel(single-load fp32 max of relu(h)^2, BLOCK 2048 x ITERS 2, partials + max) and_quant_a2_kernel(single-load, fp32 relu(h)^2 * scale, clamp, single fp8 store, BLOCK 4096, 8 warps), wrapped in the custom opnanochat::mlp_fwd_quant_a2(h) -> (a8, a_inv, a_scale). Both recompute the rectifier fromh, so noa2buffer is materialised; the arithmetic (fp32 relu(h)^2, tensorwise scale, clamp) is the same expression Inductor fused, so the result is bitwise identical to the round-63 version. Measured: -time: windows 0.9588/0.9592/0.9605 s -> ratios 1.0587/1.0645/1.0597, speedup 1.0610, mean 0.9595 s/up (vs 0.9652-0.9658 for the round-63 version, 0.9685 for the one before); - fullcheck(/tmp/check-P): PASS, tier N1, 1.0593 (windows 0.9583/0.9609/0.9603 -> 1.0593/1.0626/1.0599), exact items ok, gate-3 biases -0.243/-0.153/+0.004/-0.177/-0.096/-0.139 sigma. Committed as the new best version.
7.6 hRound 65 — dual-layout quantize of the c_proj gradient (00:32-00:36)
Same pattern applied to the last Inductor piece in the MLP block: mlp_bwd_quant_dy(x) computes the e5m2
quantization of the c_proj gradient in both layouts in one tiled kernel (plus the abs-max pass), replacing
Inductor's separate quantize + transposed requantize. Result: 0.9602 s/update mean, speedup 1.0602 vs
1.0610 (0.9595) for the committed version — neutral/slightly worse, so not adopted (the two layouts were
apparently already produced efficiently there). Experiment stayed in /tmp/nanochat-exp2.
---
# UPDATED FINAL STATE (00:36)7.6 hRound 66 — stability of the new best (00:36-00:40)
timeon2bc0b62: windows 0.9578/0.9605/0.9601 s -> ratios 1.0598/1.0631/1.0601, speedup 1.0610, mean 0.9595 s/update. All samples of the submitted version (excluding the rejected dy2 variant): 1.0593 (full check-P) 1.0610 (time) 1.0610 (time) mean 1.0604, min 1.0593 -> +3.9% over the 1.02 bar (was +2.3% before rounds 63-64) Mean per-update time 0.9595 s vs 0.9695 s at the start of this round of work (-1.0%).
7.6 hRound 67 — qk-norm audit + second full check (00:40-)
Checked the per-head qk-norm (2 per layer, 96 calls/update, 128-element reduction): it is **fused into the RoPE kernel** (view_10, 18.95 ms/update for 96 calls = 800 MB at 4.1 TB/s = roofline), so there is nothing to gain there. All the short-reduction norms are fused and at roofline; the only sub-roofline norm work is the block norm *backward* (2.1-2.8 TB/s), which is fused with the adjacent FP8 grad quantization. Since the tree changed twice today, running a second fullcheckon2bc0b62to have two independent PASSes on the exact submitted version.
7.6 hRound 67 result — second full check on the final tree (00:40-00:51)
/tmp/check-Q: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0534 (candidate windows 0.9603/0.9641/0.9662 s -> ratios 1.0571/1.0591/1.0534), exact items ok, gate-3 biases identical to check-P. Final tree (2bc0b62) has two independent full PASS checks: 1.0593 and 1.0534, plus twotimesamples 1.0610 / 1.0610. Mean 1.0587, min 1.0534 -> worst case +3.3% over the 1.02 bar (before today's last two changes the same statistic was 1.0474 / +2.33%). # FINAL Tree2bc0b62(clean), switches unchanged (7 keys), 2x PASS N1, mean score 1.0587.
7.8 hRound 68 — final opportunity scan of the remaining sub-roofline kernels (00:52)
Checked the last candidates with measured traffic accounting: - MLP backward kernels (_amax_gh19.9 +_quant_dual36.7 ms): 1.6 GB + 2.8 GB per call at 3.8-3.85 TB/s = exactly roofline; the alternative of materialising the c_fc gradient as bf16 to save a re-read is 4.4 GB either way, so no gain. -_Float8Matmul.backward's dual-layout quantize: blanket takeover would help the ~50 unfused calls by ~1.7 ms and hurt the ~96 rope/tanh-fused calls by ~4.8 ms (they already write both layouts in one pass) -> negative and not selective. - optimizer copies (multi_tensor_apply3.7 ms at 1.45 TB/s): per-tensor 2.4 MB granularity, destinations are separate parameter allocations;_foreach_copy_is already the batched form. - merging both micro-steps into one compiled graph would CSE the weight quantizations and remove one accumulation pass (~5-7 ms) but doubles graph size/compile time and risks the 94 GiB peak; not attempted given the measured spread of the score and the risk to a twice-validated submission. Conclusion: the submitted version (2bc0b62, 2x PASS N1, mean score 1.0587) is final.
7.8 hRound 69 — the merged-micro-step idea, closed on a memory argument (00:52)
The last structural lever considered was compiling both micro-steps into one graph (it would CSE the per-weight FP8 quantizations across micro-steps and sum the two branches' gradients inside the graph, saving one accumulation pass and one launcher prologue, ~6-7 ms or 0.7%). Closed analytically: a single joint graph holds the activation of *both* micro-batches simultaneously (the backward of both branches runs after the whole forward), which doubles the ~77 GiB of live activations to ~154 GiB against a 141 GiB limit — an OOM. The current structure (f1, b1, f2, b2) keeps only one micro-batch's activations alive, which is exactly why the 2x32 regrouping fits at 94 GiB. That closes the final candidate. Summary of what remains unimplemented and why: RMSNorm backward rewrite (fusion loss > gain, measured), rope-backward tiling (requires owning the attention-linear+rope backward graph), dual-layout quantize for the attention gradients (hurts the already-fused majority), merged micro-steps (OOM).
7.9 hRound 70 — grad_output dual-layout quantize for the attention linears (00:52-00:55) — abandoned
Attempted the last untested variant of the dual-layout pattern: in_Float8Matmul.backward, replace_to_fp8(grad_output)+go_T = go_fp8.t().contiguous()with one dual-layout kernel for the attention linears (the standalone requantize+transpose kernelview_15runs at 2.9 TB/s, so ~3-5 ms is theoretically available). The experiment copy could not run it: the op it needs (mlp_bwd_quant_dy, written for round 65 and rejected there) is not part of the submission, so the traced graph raised ImportError; reconstructing it would mean re-adding an op that round 65 measured neutral. Combined with the accounting already done — the ~96 rope/tanh-fused calls would each lose a 200 MB bf16 round-trip while only the ~50 unfused ones gain, and the two groups cannot be distinguished at the op level without per-module plumbing — the expected value is not positive, so this is closed rather than pursued further. The submission is untouched (verified clean at2bc0b62).
7.9 hRound 71 — paired measurement of the final tree (00:55-)
The final evaluation times a live reference and the candidate in the same session; I have paired numbers only for the pre-2bc0b62 tree (1.0485/1.0479). Taking a paired measurement of the submitted version.
7.9 hRound 71 result — paired measurement of the final tree (00:55-01:01)
time --pairedon2bc0b62(live reference run immediately before the candidate, the final evaluation's pattern): candidate windows 0.9602/0.9633/0.9589 s -> ratios 1.0572/1.0600/1.0614, speedup_vs_paired_reference 1.0571 (vs_frozen 1.0595). The gain holds against a live reference, confirming it is not an artifact of the frozen timing. All measurements of the submitted version: 1.0593 (check-P) 1.0534 (check-Q) 1.0610 (time) 1.0610 (time) 1.0571 (paired, live reference) mean 1.0584, min 1.0534 -> worst case +3.3%, mean +3.8% over the 1.02 bar --- # FINAL REPORT (01:02)
8.0 hRound 73 — third full check for maximum confidence (01:02-)
The only remaining candidate changes are all <0.5% with medium risk (e.g. fusing the add+norm pair that is fusable *within* a block: 24 of 48 norms, worth ~0.3% after the amax-fusion loss). With the submission already carrying two PASS checks, the highest-value use of the remaining budget is a third independent full check, which directly reduces the risk of an unexpected gate failure in the final evaluation.
8.0 hRound 73 result — third full check (01:02-01:13)
/tmp/check-R: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0591 (windows 0.9585/0.9624/0.9604 -> 1.0591/1.0610/1.0598), exact items ok, gate-3 biases identical to check-P/Q. All six measurements of the submitted version (2bc0b62): 1.0593 (check-P) 1.0534 (check-Q) 1.0591 (check-R) 1.0610 (time) 1.0610 (time) 1.0571 (paired, live ref) mean 1.0585, std 0.0029, min 1.0534 -> worst case +3.27% over the 1.02 bar, mean +3.77% Three independent full checks, all PASS at tier N1.
8.3 hRound 74 — fused add+norm pair for the MLP-side norm (01:13-01:19) — rejected
ImplementedAddNorm(an autograd Function that computesx += branchandxn = norm(x)in the traced/fused forward and returns d/dx of both from a single one-pass Triton backward kernel with an in-register 8x2048 tile): 0.9632 s/update mean, speedup 1.0569 (windows 1.0562/1.0588/1.0556) vs 1.0610 (0.9595) for the submitted version — i.e. ~3.7 ms *worse*. The theoretical saving (~1000 MB/call by fusing the two backward passes and the residual-add gradient) is outweighed by (a) losing the forward's amax fusion with the norm (~2.5 ms) and (b) the backward kernel's 8x2048 fp32 tile, which needs 64 KB of registers per program and spills. Rejected; the experiment stayed in /tmp/nanochat-exp2 and the submission is untouched at2bc0b62.
8.3 hRound 75 — add+norm retested with a spilling-free tile (01:19-01:22) — closed
Re-ran the round-74 experiment with BM=4/BN=2048, 4 warps (12 fp32 registers per element-tensor instead of 32,
so no spilling): 0.9641 s/update mean, speedup 1.0559 (1.0544/1.0576/1.0557) — still ~4.5 ms worse than the
submitted 0.9595/1.0610. So the penalty is not the backward kernel's tiling but the forward: losing Inductor's
amax fusion with the norm and materialising the add+norm outputs costs more than the fused backward saves.
The add+norm idea is closed with two independent tilings measured; the submission is untouched at 2bc0b62.
That completes the search: every lever in the profile is either implemented, measured-negative, or structurally
infeasible (see rounds 55/65/69/74/75). The submitted version carries three PASS checks at tier N1 with a mean
speedup of 1.0585 (min 1.0534).8.3 hRound 76 — fourth full check (01:23-)
All implementation levers are closed (rounds 74-75 measured the last two). The remaining budget is best spent reducing the risk of an unexpected failure in the final evaluation, so running the judge's owncheckonce more on the unchanged tree (2bc0b62).
8.3 hRound 76 result — fourth full check (01:23-01:34)
/tmp/check-S: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.0598 (candidate windows 0.9578/0.9621/0.9604 s -> ratios 1.0598/1.0613/1.0598), exact items ok, gate-3 biases identical to check-P/Q/R. All seven measurements of the submitted version (2bc0b62): 1.0593 1.0534 1.0591 1.0598 (four full checks, all PASS at N1) 1.0610 1.0610 (time) 1.0571 (paired vs a live reference) mean 1.0587, std 0.0027, min 1.0534 -> worst case +3.27%, mean +3.80% over the 1.02 bar Four independent full checks, all PASS at tier N1, with identical trajectory biases and exact items.
8.5 hRound 77 — the last large prize, quantified and declined (01:34)
The largest remaining sub-roofline block is the *attention-side* norm backward: 24 blocks x 2 micro = 48 calls totalling ~57 ms/update (the..._scaled_mm_...abs_add_clamp_max_mul_reciprocal...kernel family, ~1.19 ms each). It fuses the RMSNorm backward (~600 MB) with the dual-layout FP8 quantisation of the q, k and v gradients (~3 x 400 MB), i.e. ~1.8 GB per call at ~1.5 TB/s — the transposed stores are uncoalesced, the same pathology my tiled kernels fix, suggesting up to ~34 ms (3.5%) could be recovered. Taking it over, however, requires a custom autograd Function spanning the *whole attention projection path*: forward = one shared quantisation + 3_scaled_mms; backward = 3 dual-layout quantises + 6 GEMMs + the norm backward + the sum of three grad_inputs. That is a multi-hour rewrite of a core block with a realistic chance of losing more than it gains (the forward's amax fusions would go, as they did in round 74), against a submission that has already passed the full protocol four times at 1.0587 mean with a 3.3% worst-case margin. Declined on risk/reward. The submission stays at2bc0b62; the four PASS checks, the gain attribution and all 36 rejected/closed directions are recorded above.
8.5 hRound 78 — the 57 ms attention-quantize family, explained and closed (01:35)
Traced the composition of the largest remaining sub-roofline family (the ~57 ms/update..._scaled_mm_...abs_add_clamp_clone_max_mul_reciprocal_slice_backward...kernels, ~1.19 ms per block): reading its generated source shows it is **the attention input's residual blend + RMSNorm + FP8 quantize recomputed inside the backward** (AOT's min-cut chose recompute over save, because the three_Float8Matmullayers each need the quantised input for their grad_weight GEMM), and it writes the *same* quantised tensor three times (one private copy per projection). Every alternative for that region has already been measured in this session: - recompute vs save: the save-all partitioner (round 48) was neutral (same traffic either way); - share the quantisation across q/k/v: three implementations (rounds 2, 39, 40) were all neutral; - replace the dual-layout store with my tiled kernel: only reachable by owning the three projections' backward, which is the whole-block rewrite declined in round 77. So the ~57 ms is a measured-invariant rematerialisation artifact of the partitioner, not an unexplored hotspot. This closes the last open item in the kernel accounting.
8.6 hRound 79 — profiling the QKVPRE variant to test the model (01:35-01:38)
To check whether the rematerialised attention-quantise region could be attacked by sharing the quantisation, I profiled the round-40 variant (_Float8MatmulPre, shared quantised input) against the current best: total: current 965.1 qkvpre 970.0 ms/up (the variant is 5 ms worse) the fused family in question: 20.6 ms (66 calls) in BOTH profiles — completely unchanged Two conclusions, both correcting earlier notes: 1. Sharing the quantised input does not touch that fused kernel, so it is not the q/k/v input quantisation as I had assumed; the redundancy I read in its source is not what makes it run at 1.5 TB/s. 2. My earlier attribution of "~57 ms" to this family was an over-count from summing the top-22 list by eye; the family is 20.6 ms/update (66 calls over 3 updates = 22 calls/update), so even a perfect rewrite caps at ~13 ms and every alternative measured neutral. The kernel accounting in the final report should be read with this correction: the honest bound on that direction is ~13 ms (1.3%), not 3.5%. The submission is unchanged at2bc0b62; the four PASS checks and the recorded gain attribution are unaffected (the accounting correction concerns only a rejected direction).
8.7 hRound 80 — definitive profile of the submitted version (01:39-01:42)
total 962.9 ms/update (un-profiled wall: 0.9595 s, so no profiler inflation) | component | ms/up | share | |---|---|---| | FP8 GEMMs (fwd 163.5, grad_input 140.7, grad_weight 84.2+44.0, lm_head 10.4, Muon bmm 16.7) | 470.1 | 48.8% | | FA3 attention (bwd 44.3+25.3, fwd 17.2, pre/post 15.9) | 111.5 | 11.6% | | RMSNorm backward (separable 13.6 + the rest fused with the adjacent quantizes) | 80.6 | 8.4% | | custom MLP kernels (_quant_dual36.7 +_amax_gh19.9 +_quant_a213.1 +_amax_a29.0) | 78.7 | 8.2% | | cross-entropy | 35.1 | 3.6% | | NCCL (overlapped) | 25.7 | 2.7% | | everything else (RoPE+qk-norm 19.2, quantize/transpose ~55, optimizer ~35, value embeddings ~20, misc) | 161.2 | 16.7% | The custom MLP kernels measure 3.8-4.4 TB/s (at or above the HBM roofline for their access patterns); the GEMMs run at 1.17 PFLOPS forward and 1.39 backward (cuBLASLt's choice for these shapes); FA3 is at 81% of bf16 peak in the forward. The remaining sub-roofline slack is ~20 ms total, spread over quantize/transpose kernels that are fused with the norm and rope backwards - fusing the *tiling* into them requires owning those backward graphs end to end, whose predicted upside (<=1%) is below the risk threshold set by four passing checks. Final:2bc0b62, 4x PASS N1, mean 1.0587 (min 1.0534 = +3.27% over the bar).
8.7 hRound 81 — dual-layout grad_output quantize for the attention linears, measured (01:42-01:46)
The last unmeasured variant from round 70: in_Float8Matmul.backward, produce the gradient's two FP8 layouts with one tiled kernel (mlp_bwd_quant_dy) instead of Inductor's separate quantize + transposed requantize, for the attention linears (N=1536; the lm_head keeps the current path). Windows 0.9646/0.9704/0.9676 s -> ratios 1.0524/1.0522/1.0519, speedup 1.0521, mean 0.9675 s/update — 8 ms worse than the submitted 0.9595/1.0587. Negative as predicted: the ~96 rope/tanh-fused calls lose more from the split than the ~50 unfused calls gain. Not adopted; the experiment stayed in /tmp/nanochat-exp2. With this, every variant of the dual-layout pattern has been measured (MLP gradient 1.0466 keep, MLP c_proj gradient neutral, attention gradient 1.0521 reject, weight hoist 1.0425 reject, QKV input sharing 3x neutral).
8.8 hRound 82 — the attention q/k projection + RoPE rewrite, implemented and measured (01:47-01:52)
Built the full expensive rewrite:_QProjRopeautograd Function (c_q/c_k GEMM -> RoPE -> out) whose backward fuses the inverse rotation, the |dq| abs-max and the dual-layout FP8 quantisation into two hand-written Triton kernels (_rope_amax_kernel,_rope_quant_dual_kernel) writing dq as [M, C] and [C, M] with tiled, coalesced stores, then the two_scaled_mms. Result: windows 0.9653/0.9683/0.9670 s -> ratios 1.0516/1.0545/1.0525, speedup 1.0528, mean 0.9669 s/update -> 7.4 ms worse than the submitted 0.9595/1.0587. The numerics are right (step-32 loss 6.4705 vs the reference's 6.4668, within the trajectory's normal variation), so the implementation is sound and the loss is pure fusion economics: the forward's RoPE -> qk-norm fusion (4.1 TB/s) and Inductor's amax+quantize pairing are worth more than the ~6.7 ms the better-tiled backward predicted. Not adopted; the experiment stayed in /tmp/nanochat-exp2 and the submission is untouched at2bc0b62. That is the last structural candidate in the profile now *built and measured* rather than argued: with it, the five fusion-adjacent rewrites (rounds 74, 75, 81, 82 and the round-70 variant) all measure negative, which is the empirical answer to "can owning these regions beat Inductor here".
8.8 hRound 82 follow-up — the same rewrite with `allow_in_graph` (01:52-01:55)
Suspecting the forward regression came from a missing@torch._dynamo.allow_in_graphon_QProjRope(whichFusedMLPhas), I added it and re-measured: windows 0.9666/0.9707/0.9730 -> ratios 1.0502/1.0519/1.0460, speedup 1.0494, mean 0.9701 s/update — *worse* than without it (1.0528) and still 10 ms behind the submitted 1.0587. So the traceability hypothesis is wrong too: the rewrite is negative for its own fusion economics, now confirmed with two implementations. Closed. The submission is untouched at2bc0b62(4x PASS N1, mean 1.0587).
8.9 hRound 84 — final quick gate on the submitted tree (01:56-)
All implementation levers are built and measured. Runningcheck --quick(formulation + exact-item gates) on2bc0b62for a final consistency confirmation of the exact submitted tree.
8.9 hRound 84 result — final quick gate (01:56-01:58)
/tmp/check-quick2on2bc0b62: statusNOT_BITWISEwithexact_items_ok: true,problems: [], 175 parameters compared over 10 updates, 640 rows per rank. That is the expected result for this submission (the N1 changes reorder reductions, so gate 2 is not bitwise) and confirms gates 0 and 2 on the exact final tree, which the four fullcheckruns already established at tier N1. The submission is final and consistent across every gate: - gate 0 (formulation): 141/141 inputs match, one model init, same parameter names/shapes/dtypes, fp8 flags ok - gate 1 (timing): 1.0593 / 1.0534 / 1.0591 / 1.0598 / 1.0610 / 1.0610 / 1.0571 (paired) - gate 2 (exact items): ok (not bitwise, as documented) - gate 3 (statistics): all six endpoints within 0.28 sigma, four times
8.9 hRound 85 — reproduction record (01:58)
Exact commands and expected outputs for verifying this submission from a clean state (all runs take the GPU lock themselves;bench.pyis the judge's own harness, unmodified): # full protocol: gates 0/1/2/3 (~13 min) /opt/nanochat-env/bin/python bench/bench.py check \ --tree /submission/nanochat --config /submission/switches.json --out /tmp/verify-check # expected: status PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.053-1.060 # gate 2: exact items ok (not bitwise - documented N1) # gate 3: six endpoints within 0.28 sigma # timing only (~5 min) /opt/nanochat-env/bin/python bench/bench.py time \ --tree /submission/nanochat --config /submission/switches.json --out /tmp/verify-time # expected: s/update 0.958-0.971, speedup 1.050-1.061, peak 94.0 GiB # paired against a live reference, i.e. the final evaluation's pattern (~9 min) /opt/nanochat-env/bin/python bench/bench.py time \ --tree /submission/nanochat --config /submission/switches.json --out /tmp/verify-paired --paired # expected: speedup_vs_paired_reference 1.055-1.060 Evidence produced during development (all under /tmp): check-P/Q/R/S (1.0593/1.0534/1.0591/1.0598), t-fwdquant and t-best2 (1.0610 each), t-paired3 (1.0571), prof-final3 (962.9 ms/update kernel accounting), prof-norm, prof-qkvpre; rejected variants in /tmp/nanochat-exp and /tmp/nanochat-exp2. State:/submission/nanochatat2bc0b62, clean;/submission/switches.jsonwith the seven keys; nothing running.
8.9 hRound 86 — the exact final-evaluation score, computed from the judge's own reference data (01:59)
runs/bootstrap/baseline/baseline.jsoncontains the reference's per-update times for both timed runs, which is exactly the denominator the final evaluation uses (min(refA, refB)per window). Extracting them: ref_a windows: [1.0171, 1.0210, 1.0176] ref_b windows: [1.0162, 1.0233, 1.0189] min over the two runs per window: [1.0162, 1.0210, 1.0176] (matches the frozen 1.0151/1.0211/1.0178) Dividing those by this submission's candidate windows from the four checks: | check | candidate windows | exact final ratio (min over 3 windows) | |---|---|---| | check-P | 0.9583 / 0.9609 / 0.9603 | 1.0597 | | check-Q | 0.9603 / 0.9641 / 0.9662 | 1.0532 | | check-R | 0.9585 / 0.9624 / 0.9604 | 1.0596 | | check-S | 0.9578 / 0.9621 / 0.9604 | 1.0596 | So the final score is predicted at 1.053-1.060 (mean 1.058), i.e. +3.3% to +3.9% over the 1.02 bar, with the worst measured case (check-Q, whose third window was thermally slow) still at +3.3%. This is the most direct prediction available: it uses the judge's own reference timings and this submission's measured candidate windows.
8.9 hRound 87 — handoff note: what a future attempt would need (02:00)
For anyone continuing this work, the measured facts that constrain it: 1. The wins are in work removal, not kernel speed. Every kernel in the final step is at its roofline or at a library limit; the eight gains came from *doing less* (fewer micro-steps of overhead, one all-reduce instead of 74, baddbmm instead of a separate elementwise pass, norelu(h)buffer, one fused dual-layout store instead of two kernels). 2. Owning a region only pays when Inductor's own kernel there is pathological (uncoalesced transposed stores, as in the MLP gradient path) *and* the region has no producer fusion worth keeping. Four rewrites that broke a producer fusion (rounds 74, 75, 81, 82) all lost 4-10 ms, with correct numerics. 3. The remaining ~20 ms of sub-roofline time is inside fused norm/rope backward graphs. Capturing it needs a custom Function spanning several autograd nodes with the *forward* left traceable; every attempt so far lost more on the forward than it gained on the backward. A future attempt should first measure the forward's fusion cost in isolation (e.g. profile the Function with its backward stubbed) before writing kernels. 4. The hardware is the binding constraint: 693 W of a 700 W cap, SM clock 1980 -> ~1440 MHz during a run, so time per update ~ energy per update / cap. Faster kernels that draw more power mostly buy clock reduction. 5. Score arithmetic: the harness dividesmin(refA, refB)per window (1.0162/1.0210/1.0176 from runs/bootstrap/baseline) by the candidate's windows and takes the minimum. Improving the *slowest* candidate window is what moves the score; the per-window spread here is thermal (~0.4%). Submission:/submission/nanochat@2bc0b62, four full PASS checks at tier N1, predicted score 1.053-1.060.
9.0 hRound 88 — single-pass RMSNorm backward, forward ops unchanged (02:00-02:03) — rejected
Isolated the confound from rounds 74/75: keep the forward's *exact* ops (so the add and amax fusions stay in the graph) and replace only the backward with one Triton kernel (dx = rstd*dy - (rstd^3/N)*x*sum(x*dy)), used for both the block norms (N=1536) and the per-head qk-norms (N=128) via a constexpr branch. Result: windows 0.9947/1.0006/1.0023 s -> ratios 1.0205/1.0205/1.0155, speedup 1.0188, mean 0.9992 s/update -> 40 ms worse than the submitted 0.9595/1.0587. So even with the forward untouched, taking the norm backward away from Inductor loses badly: its fused[row-reduction + elementwise + adjacent quantize]grouping is a large win over a hand-written single-pass kernel, and my 4x2048 register tile is not the issue (the forward-only change should have been neutral). Closed. The submission is untouched at2bc0b62. Running tally of structural rewrites built and measured this session (all behind the submitted 1.0587): add+norm 1.0569 / 1.0559, attention grad dual-layout 1.0521, q/k+RoPE 1.0528 / 1.0494, single-pass norm backward 1.0188.