Claude Sonnet 5.5 1.76×

Harness: Claude Code · switches: OPD_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF=1 OPD_FUSE_LOGPROB=1 OPD_NO_RECOMPUTE=1 OPD_CPU_THREADS=24 OPD_PIN_MASTER=1 OPD_GDN_SHARD=1 OPD_FAST_COMM_CHECK=1 OPD_GC_FREEZE=1 OPD_SLEEP_GRADS_ONLY=1 OPD_WARM_FLA=1 OPD_PIPELINE_WEIGHT_SYNC=1 OPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS=--chunked-prefill-size 16384 --max-prefill-tokens 32768 --disable-radix-cache

Judged
1.76×
Tier
N1
Self-best
1.68×
Rounds
6
Hours
10.0
API cost
$75.2
Input tokens · 99.5% cached
507 M
Output tokens
1.5 M
Requests
996
Candidate, three windows (s)
85.8 / 86.9 / 89.8
Rollout side
~1.21×
Teacher side
~1.09×
Train side
~1.99×
Per-step sampler sync
✓
Train-side main levers
✓ skip zero-coefficient reference forward (−10.9 s), fused old-policy logprob, no recompute, 24 CPU threads, pinned master weights; GDN split by head with forward bitwise identical; only fp32 grad buffers released during sleep; pipelined weight sync; FLA warmup
Teacher-side changes
chunking only: teacher chunk 16384 + single-batch prefill 32768 + radix cache off
Raw work log7 sections
0.1 hRound 1 — profile the unchanged reference (2026-11-14 20:59 -> 22:20 UTC)
Profiles: /tmp/r1/profile_train (killed: slime's torch profiler with with_stack/record_shapes/profile_memory exports
>1.3 GB/rank for >40 min), /tmp/r1/profile_train2 (scratch copy /tmp/ptree with a light profiler, 18 min).
Train step (slime perf metrics, one warm 73.6 s step): ref_log_probs forward 10.9 s (WASTE: kl_loss_coef = 0),
log_probs forward 9.8 s, actor_train 46 s (fwd 9.8 + recompute 9.8 + bwd ~19.6 + CPU optimizer ~4.8 + grad sync 0.7),
sleep 4.3-4.9 s + wake_up 1.4 s.
Kernel time of one profiled step (rank 0, 59.4 s): GEMM 46%, aten elementwise/copy/reduce 18% (eager GDN glue + fp32
logits ops), NCCL 18% (AllGather RING_LL 29.5k calls, 7 s: TP/CP gathers of the replicated GDN layers), FLA/GDN 14%,
flash-attn 1.6%; GPU busy 77% (forward-only passes 75-80% busy: launch bound; optimizer phase ~5-9 s mostly idle).
GDN layers run REPLICATED (hf_attention.py): hidden states all-gathered over TP and CP, full weights, full sequence on every
rank = 4x redundant GDN GEMM/kernel work (target for a later round).
CPU optimizer: HybridDeviceOptimizer.step 4.8 s/step, aten::_fused_adamw_ ~15 GB/s per param (4 ranks x 96 OMP threads on
the same 96 logical CPUs -> oversubscribed), fp32->bf16 param copy-back is a pageable H2D copy per param.
cudaMemGetInfo 11.7k calls/2.8 s inside _AllGather/_VocabParallelLogProbEntropy; cudaMallocHost 1.8 s per step.
Student decode (reference rollout log): 32 running req/engine, ~5000 tok/s/engine = ~6.5 ms per decode step.
FlashQLA 0.1.3 (QwenLM TileLang GDN kernels, supported by slime as --qwen-gdn-backend flashqla) installed in
/opt/candidate-env (pip --no-deps); not yet evaluated.
2.2 hRound 2 — train side: dead-work removal + numerics probes (2026-11-14 22:00 -> 23:15 UTC)
Changes (all behind env switches, default off, in /submission/slime_opd/slime + Megatron-LM):
- OPD_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF: skip the reference-model log-prob forward when kl_coef == kl_loss_coef == 0 (its result only feeds a KL term
  multiplied by exactly 0). Saves ~10.9 s/step. loss.py guards the KL term; train/kl_loss metric disappears.
- OPD_FUSE_LOGPROB: single optimizer step per rollout => the "old" log-probs are the training forward's own; skip the separate
  no-grad log-prob forward (9.8 s) and apply the OPD advantage adv - opd_kl_coef*(logp - teacher_logp) inside policy_loss_function
  on the detached training log-probs. Probe V1 (this switch alone) reproduced the unchanged tree's step-0 loss/mismatch bitwise.
- OPD_NO_RECOMPUTE: drop --recompute-granularity full (args overridden in initialize.init). Peak memory 64.3 GB allocated /
  68 GB reserved per GPU in train-only mode (teacher not resident there; full loop leaves ~140-45(teacher) GB).
- OPD_CPU_THREADS / OPD_PIN_MASTER (new, untested): torch.set_num_threads for the host Adam (4 ranks x 96 OMP threads oversubscribe 96 logical
  CPUs; Adam ran at ~15 GB/s) and pinned fp32 master params (async H2D copy-back).
- OPD_SGLANG_EXTRA_ARGS: JSON overrides of the student engines' sglang ServerArgs (screening tool).
- sleep/wake sub-timers (perf/sleep_*_time, perf/wake_*_time, perf/backup_actor_weights_time).
time --side train with SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF+FUSE_LOGPROB+NO_RECOMPUTE: windows 47.0/46.8/44.6 s vs frozen 73.5/74.7/73.8 -> side speedup
1.563, projected step speedup 1.208 (/tmp/r2/time_train1). BUT check --quick --side train of that run: INCORRECT (grad_norm_first
d=1.75e-3 > tol 1.65e-3; update cos 0.9477 < 0.9566; loss_mean/update_norm/exp_avg_sq within).
ROOT CAUSE of most of the deviation: I had pip install flash-qla into /opt/candidate-env at ~21:45; FLA 0.5.2 auto-dispatches its GDN kernels to
FlashQLA when importable (FLA_FLASH_QLA=0 disables), so the UNCHANGED tree in the candidate env produced step-0 loss 0.0534509 / gnorm 0.99815
instead of 0.0534137 / 0.99645 (bootstrap). FlashQLA also gave ~no speedup (step 73.3 vs 73.6 s). Uninstalled at 23:07; the time-run above was
made with FlashQLA active (its GDN kernels differ slightly; effect on time is small).
Sleep/wake breakdown (steady state, per step): sleep 4.9 s = clear_memory 0.7 + destroy_process_groups 2.4 + torch_memory_saver.pause 1.8;
wake 1.4 s = tms resume 0.54 + clear 0.5 + reload pgs 0.19 + restore weights 0.2; backup_actor_weights 0.27 s.
Rollout profile (/tmp/r1/profile_rollout): decode step kernel time ~5.4 ms (GEMMs 52% ~79% of HBM roofline, fused allreduce+rmsnorm 13.6%,
GDN packed decode 9%, lm_head 4.5%, FA3 2.3%); real step 6.4 ms -> ~1 ms/step GPU idle (CPU scheduler overhead).
Teacher profile (/tmp/r1/profile_teacher): per 4096-token chunk 143 ms: GEMM 52% (~70% of peak), NCCL allreduce 21.5% (217 us x 128),
logits all-gather+fp32 passes ~8%, norms 4%, GDN prefill (FlashInfer) 5%, attn 2.3%.
NCCL micro-benchmark (/tmp/r3): default == Simple; LL128/NVLS no better (42MB 4-rank allreduce 210 us = 300 GB/s busbw): protocol tuning is a dead end.
2.9 hRound 3 — GDN head-sharded layer (OPD_GDN_SHARD), teacher/rollout flag screening (2026-11-14 23:15 -> ...)
- Implemented ShardedAttention + Qwen3_5GatedDeltaNet.forward_shard (slime_plugins/models/qwen3_5.py, env OPD_GDN_SHARD=1): instead of the
  reference's 4x redundant replicated GDN layer (all heads x all tokens x full weights on every tp x cp rank), each rank of the tp x cp group
  runs 1/4 of the heads on the gathered full sequence (in_proj slices, conv, chunk_gated_delta_rule, gated norm), then one all-to-all
  (heads -> own tokens) feeds out_proj on the rank's own tokens only. Parameters keep their full replicated names/shapes; they are flagged
  sequence_parallel so Megatron's finalize_model_grads sums their grads over TP after the DDP dp-cp reduction (scaling checked analytically).
- Single-GPU unit test (/tmp/r3/test_gdn_shard.py, real shapes, 4 shards emulated sequentially): forward BITWISE equal to the reference module
  (full rows, row-sliced out_proj, every shard's core output); weight grads equal (rel 0) except in_proj_a 2.9e-4 / norm 4e-3 (summation order);
  input grad rel err 5.6e-3 (bf16 summation of 16 partial dX instead of 4: an fp32 partial-sum path is the fallback if the cos gate complains).
- Pitfall found: ShortConvolution/FLA kernels all produce identical values for head subsets (autotuned configs do not change arithmetic here).
- Full-loop robustness probe of the committed switch set (judge's own prime + full procedure via /tmp/r2/full_probe.py, NOT a timing report): /tmp/r2/full1.
- Teacher variants queued (/tmp/r3/sw_t_*.json): torch-symm-mem allreduce, chunk 3072/8192, radix cache off, flashinfer allreduce fusion,
  SGLANG_CUSTOM_ALL_REDUCE_V2_MAX_SIZE_KB=65536 (teacher messages are 42 MB > the 16 MB default of custom AR v2).
- py-spy (installed in /tmp/pyspy_pkg, not in the candidate env) on a student sglang scheduler during decode (/tmp/r3/pyspy_sched0.raw):
  63.6% of the scheduler thread sits at Sampler.forward (sampler.py:321) = bool(sampling_info.return_top_p_log_probs.any().item()),
  a GPU->CPU sync EVERY decode step (slime always requests logprobs) which serializes CPU launch prep after the GPU forward: the ~1 ms/step
  (15%) GPU idle gap seen in the decode profile. Fix (sglang, N0): CPU mirror list return_top_p_log_probs_cpu / need_return_top_p_log_probs
  in SamplingBatchInfo (built from the request list, kept through filter_batch/merge_batch), sampler uses the CPU flag. time --side rollout
  of the fix queued (/tmp/r3/time_roll1).
- Full-loop robustness probe /tmp/r2/full1 (judge's own prime + 5-step full procedure, committed switch set, teacher resident): status ok,
  no OOM/hang, layout fine; windows 122.9/124.6/124.8 s (frozen reference full windows 153.4/156.0/154.9) -> sanity only (official
  number = final evaluation). 2.2 s of Triton autotune (causal_conv1d bwd, T-bucket key) fell inside one timed window.
  Plumbing per step seen in its log: sleep 4.8 s (clear_memory 0.9 + destroy_pgs 1.6 + tms pause 2.2), update_weights 2.4 s.
2.9 hRound 3 results (2026-11-15 00:00 -> 00:50 UTC)
- Sampler sync fix (sglang): time --side rollout windows 59.4/63.1/59.5 s vs frozen 75.9/76.4/76.3 -> 1.210 (min), decode 5.0k -> 6.9k tok/s/engine.
  Window 2 is slower because decode is now GPU-bound and engine load imbalance (round robin arrival order) shows; commit 6444bf5 (sglang).
- Head-sharded GDN (OPD_GDN_SHARD=1): step-0 loss bitwise = reference, mini probe /tmp/r2/mini_t4: fwd+bwd 28.2 s, optimizer 2.3 s (was ~32/4.8).
  check --quick --side train (/tmp/r2/quick3, switches sw_train3 = T1-3 + CPU + GDN_SHARD + FAST_COMM_CHECK, input norm hoisted before
  the gathers, qkv slices via index_select): PASS N1: update_norm d=-1.1e-4, exp_avg_sq d=-1.2e-4, loss_mean d=-4.6e-6 (tol 3.75e-5),
  grad_norm_first d=-3.4e-4 (tol 1.65e-3), cos 0.9940 (min 0.9566).
- Sharded step profile (/tmp/r3/profile_train_t4): GEMM 36%, NCCL 31% (AG 2.5 s, RS 2.6 s, SendRecv 2.4 s), eager elementwise 22%, FLA only 7%
  (h-scan kernel is latency bound: 16 CTAs for 8 heads, no gain from fewer heads); GPU 68% busy; aten::item inside TE's CP-attention backward:
  1536 syncs/step (1.1 s); cudaMemGetInfo/psutil before every slime-patched collective (-> OPD_FAST_COMM_CHECK); python gc 0.4-0.7 s x2/step
  (-> OPD_GC_FREEZE); host Adam now 1.6 s/step (~38 GB/s/rank, host-bandwidth bound).
- Teacher flag screens (time --side teacher, frozen 18.24/18.23/17.86): SGLANG_CUSTOM_ALL_REDUCE_V2_MAX_SIZE_KB=65536: 18.08/18.13/17.70 (+0.9%);
  --enable-torch-symm-mem: 18.42/18.38/18.02 (-0.9%). Allreduce implementation is not the bottleneck (NVLink ~300 GB/s busbw).
- NCCL channel/buffer tuning micro-benchmark: <=12% on 2-rank AG/RS at 64 channels (steals SMs) -> not used.

- Teacher flags (time --side teacher, frozen 18.24/18.23/17.86): --chunked-prefill-size 8192 --disable-radix-cache -> 16.99/17.12/16.75 (1.065x);
  teacher-only check --quick (/tmp/r4check_td, tree = untouched reference + this switch) PASS: mean|d| ratio 1.0165 of the reference spread, event p=0.77.
  ADOPTED in /submission/switches.json via OPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS.
- Larger micro-batches (OPD_MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPU=9216, /tmp/r2/time_train5): windows 36.95/33.43/32.89 (mean 34.4 vs 34.7 without), peak reserved 88 GB
  -> no gain, memory risk: NOT used.
- Rollout in the all-sides check run: reported rollout times 58.2/58.2/58.2 s (warm-up 63.6) with the sampler fix.
- Train-step idle analysis (rank 0, sharded profile): ~1.8 s/step of cudaMallocHost/FreeHost + ~2 s destroy_pg: NCCL communicators destroyed and lazily
  re-created every step; OPD_SLEEP_GRADS_ONLY (keep groups + params resident, pause only the fp32 grad buffer) is the fix, test pending (/tmp/r2/full3).
5.7 hRound 4 — validation of the plumbing switches, teacher chunk 16384, and two new train-side kernels (2026-11-15 01:50 -> ...)
- All-sides check --quick of the previous switch set (/tmp/r4check1, sw_train4, sampler fix in sglang, 8192-chunk teacher not included): PASS on all three
  sides. Rollout: token-forcing mean|d| ratio 0.99, mismatch ratio 1.0005; train N1: update_norm d=-7e-5 (tol 1.2e-3), loss_mean d=-1.3e-5 (tol 3.75e-5),
  grad_norm_first d=-7e-5 (tol 1.65e-3); teacher PASS.
- Full-loop robustness probe /tmp/r2/full3 (train set + GRADS_ONLY + WARM_FLA + PIPELINE, default 4096 teacher): windows 89.3/89.8/91.6 s, first_use 0.0 s,
  mismatch 0.0073-0.0081 (reference 0.0081), no OOM. Probe /tmp/r5/full4 (the same + teacher `--chunked-prefill-size 16384 --max-prefill-tokens 32768
  --disable-radix-cache`, = /tmp/r5/sw_cand1.json): windows 86.4/86.3/87.8 s (frozen reference step 153-156 s), no OOM. Teacher-only check with the 16384
  variant /tmp/r4check_tg PASS (replay 16.74/16.78/16.56 s; mean|d| ratio 1.014; events p=0.38).
- Step anatomy at ~90 s (probe full3 log): rollout 58-62 s = decode 41.8 s (5.1 ms/step) + teacher tail 16.5 s; train fwd+bwd 26 s + optimizer 2.2 s;
  plumbing ~2.5 s. Decode is HBM-bound (GEMMs ~72% of peak bandwidth, GDN state update at roofline, 63 allreduce/step): <10% left without custom GEMMs.
- Train profile reading (old sharded profile /tmp/r3/profile_train_t4, analysis scripts /tmp/r5/module_acct2.py, main_ops.py, rank_compare.py): ranks are balanced
  (busy 24.6-25.3 s of 37 s span), NCCL kernels 7.4-8.1 s are almost not overlapped with compute (sum 26.0 s vs union 25.2 s), the forward is CPU-launch-bound
  (main thread 15.8 s of CPU in the profiled step vs ~8 s of forward GPU time), micro-batches are 1 sample (64 per step, max-tokens-per-gpu 4096).
  Biggest single waste found: SliceBackward0 of the zigzag reorder slices in my sharded GDN layer (74K tiny kernels, 0.78 s + 0.45 s gaps) and
  slime's chunked vocab-parallel log-prob/entropy (11K kernels, ~1.2 s, 2187 tiny fp32 all-reduces).
- NEW (off by default, committed, not yet timed/validated by the judge):
  * OPD_FUSED_LOGPROB_LOSS (slime commit ddd0fdb4): Triton online-softmax stats kernel + one all-gather of the 4 row statistics (instead of 4 all-reduces per 1024-row
    chunk, twice), single-pass backward. Unit test /tmp/r5/test_fused_logprob.py: logp diff 2e-6 (rel 1.2e-7), bf16-rounded grads equal in 99.998%, 2.7 ms vs 18.2 ms per
    micro-batch fwd+bwd.
  * OPD_GDN_FUSED_GATHER (uncommitted at this edit): one all-gather over the tp x cp group straight into global token order + one row gather (backward: row gather +
    reduce-scatter) instead of TP gather + CP gather + per-sequence slices/cat (removes the SliceBackward0 storm). Distributed test /tmp/r5/test_gather_dist.py queued.

- Full check (with timing) of cand1 on snapshot /tmp/chk_tree5 (/tmp/r5/check_full1): status UNAVAILABLE at gate 1 (benefit): side windows rollout 59.5/58.1/58.4 s (1.276x),
  teacher 16.74/16.79/16.53 s (1.081x), train 26.8/27.2/44.0 s (1.676x min) -> projected 1.427x < bar 1.4688, because the bar is max(1.02, 1 + 2 x the frozen reference
  spread) and the frozen TRAIN reference spread is 0.2344 (the two startup reference runs differed by 23% in a window). Cause of the 44 s window: one 18 s stall at
  micro-batch 8 of step 6 on a cold-cache timing run (no compile/autotune event recorded, first_use 0.0; logs show nothing; unexplained one-off). Consequence: the correctness gates
  were NOT evaluated by this run (gate 1 stops first); use check --quick for correctness and time for speed; a check with timing only passes gate 1 if every train window is
  clean. The final evaluation's bar uses the full-loop reference spread (<= 5%), not this one.
- Unit tests (single GPU, real shapes, /tmp/r5/test_gdn_variants.py): TE RMSNorm in place of the eager Qwen3NextRMSNorm: forward bitwise equal in 99.9996% of elements, input grad
  rel 1.6e-5, weight grad rel 3e-7, 0.13 vs 0.47 ms fwd+bwd per layer call (-0.5 s/step) -> OPD_FAST_RMSNORM kept. FLA in-kernel gate/beta (OPD_GDN_GATE_IN_KERNEL): only 74% of
  the layer outputs bitwise equal (max abs diff 1.6e-2), no speedup -> REJECTED (kept off).
- HBM microbenchmark (/tmp/r5/bw_test.py): read-only 4.27 TB/s, copy 4.28 TB/s; cuBLAS M=32 skinny GEMMs: K=4096,N=12288 3.39 TB/s (79%), N=24576 3.86 TB/s (90%), K=6144,N=4096
  2.73 TB/s (64%), K=2048,N=4096 1.49 TB/s (35%). In the decode graph gate_up takes 34 us (ideal 24), down 16-18 us (ideal 12), o_proj 8.5 us (ideal 4-5): a bandwidth-optimal
  skinny-GEMM kernel could save ~0.45 ms of the 5.1 ms decode step (~3.7 s per rollout, 4% of the full step) -- biggest remaining decode lever, not started (3+ h of work, uncertain).
- Queue (2026-11-15 03:06): time_cand2 (train-only time, /tmp/r5/time_cand2) -> check --quick train-only of the cand1 train set (/tmp/r5/quick_c1train, snapshot /tmp/chk_tree6) ->
  check --quick train-only of cand3 = cand1 train set + FUSED_LOGPROB_LOSS + GDN_FUSED_GATHER + FAST_RMSNORM (/tmp/r5/quick_c3train, snapshot /tmp/chk_tree7).
6.4 hRound 5 (2026-11-15 02:00 -> ...): train-side kernel-count cuts, decode in_proj fusion, stall hunt
- time --side train of cand2 (= cand1 + OPD_FUSED_LOGPROB_LOSS + OPD_GDN_FUSED_GATHER; /tmp/r5/time_cand2, snapshot /tmp/time_tree6): fwd+bwd 21.2-21.6 s per step vs 23.4 s
  for cand1 (-2.0..2.2 s: the fused loss path replaced ~11K kernels / 2187 tiny all-reduces per step, the fused gather the 74K-kernel SliceBackward storm), windows 24.9 / 38.0 / 24.5 s.
- UNEXPLAINED STALLS: in 3 of ~36 observed train steps one forward_backward took 13-18 s longer (check_full1 step 6 +18 s at micro-batch 8; time_cand2 step 5 +13 s after the last
  micro-batch; full3 prime step 4 +17 s). Not Triton compile (judge first_use 0), no log line, GPUs healthy (ECC/throttle clean), cgroup: 1 TB memory limit with 905 GB max usage ever,
  cpu throttling negligible, host NUMA balancing on (numa_balancing=1, THP always/defer). A stall inside a candidate window of the final evaluation would cost ~15% of the score
  (min over windows). Host monitor /tmp/r5/monitor.sh -> /tmp/r5/monitor.log (1 Hz /proc/vmstat NUMA/THP/compaction counters) running to correlate with the next stall.
- Decode kernel hunt (profile /tmp/r1/profile_rollout, 198 steps): per step the sampler costs ~216 us (softmax 75 on 32 CTAs, copy 20, clamp 2x12, exponential 17, div 22+22, argmax 20,
  log 15), the logits multimem all-gather 63 us (always 4 blocks), the separate GDN in_proj_ba GEMM 13 us x 24 layers. New sglang changes (committed, rollout side):
  OPD_GDN_FUSED_IN_PROJ (sglang's own finalize_fused_in_proj enabled for CUDA, decode only; GEMM microbench: merged N=6176 17.0 us vs 16.5+5.8 separate) and the all-gather block
  count scaling (N0). Not yet judge-timed. Candidate cand4 = cand2 + FAST_RMSNORM + LIVE_WEIGHT_SYNC + GDN_FUSED_IN_PROJ (/tmp/r5/sw_cand4.json).
- Queue at 03:20: quick_c1train (check --quick train-only, cand1 train set) -> quick_c3train (cand3 = cand1 + fused loss/gather/rmsnorm) -> time_c4roll (rollout time cand4) ->
  full8 (full-loop probe cand4) -> quick_c4all (all-sides quick check cand4). Outputs under /tmp/r5/.

- cand1 ADOPTED into /submission/switches.json at 03:27 after check --quick --side train PASS N1 (/tmp/r5/quick_c1train: update_norm d=-2.3e-5 (2% of tol), exp_avg_sq d=-1.2e-4 (27%),
  loss_mean d=+1.1e-5 (30%), grad_norm_first d=-1.3e-4 (8%), update-direction cos 0.9825 = 2.0x the worst reference-repeat noise; limit 5x = 0.9566).
- cand3 (cand1 + OPD_FUSED_LOGPROB_LOSS + OPD_GDN_FUSED_GATHER + OPD_FAST_RMSNORM) FAILED the train gate only on the update-direction cosine: 0.9559 < 0.9566 (5.08x the noise; all
  endpoint statistics inside: update_norm 2%, exp_avg_sq 14%, loss_mean 6%, grad_norm_first 10% of tolerance) -> /tmp/r5/quick_c3train. The cosine is a sign-flip measure of the
  Adam update (the reference's own repeats give 0.991-0.995, cos_min = 1 - 5 x (1 - 0.9913)); cand3's fwd+bwd is 21.5 s vs 24-25 s. Bisect queued: A = loss only, B = gather only
  (4-rank RS backward), C = RMSNorm only, D = gather mode 2 (OPD_GDN_FUSED_GATHER=2: two-stage CP-then-TP backward reduction, 4-rank test: backward BITWISE equal to the unfused path,
  0.50 vs 1.03 ms), E = mode 2 + loss (/tmp/r5/quick_bis_{A..E}); summary script /tmp/r5/show_train_gate.py.
- Rollout side cand4 (/tmp/r5/time_c4roll, 03:37): windows 56.35/56.42/56.68 s (cand1: 59.5/58.1/58.4) = sampler + all-gather only: the in_proj fusion did NOT run because the dense
  Qwen3_5ForConditionalGeneration has no prepare_before_cuda_graph_capture hook (fixed in sglang 7701ac3; re-timing queued as /tmp/r5/time_c4broll). Fused sampler unit test: chi2 459/481 dof,
  logprob err <1e-6, graph-safe, 57 vs 262 us. Skinny-GEMM Triton kernel: no gain over cuBLAS (gate_up 28.0 vs 28.6 us, down 16.1 vs 17.9, out_proj 7.8 vs 7.3).
- Merged shard in_proj (OPD_GDN_MERGED_INPROJ) REJECTED: forward only 99.97% bitwise equal (current is bitwise), weight grads lose exactness (3e-4..7e-4 vs 0), dX error 4.5e-3 -> 4.0e-3.
- Teacher variants (time --side teacher on the unchanged reference tree, frozen 18.24/18.23/17.86): g (16384, no radix) 16.74/16.78/16.56; + flashinfer allreduce fusion 16.74/16.78/16.50
  (no effect, chunk > fusion limit); chunk 2048 + fusion 19.4 (worse); g + --enable-symm-mem (NCCL symmetric memory, 4 GB prealloc) 16.41/16.40/16.18 (-0.35 s, 1.104x):
  correctness check and a 1 GB prealloc variant queued (/tmp/r5/quick_tc3, time_tc4).

- BISECT RESULT (train gate, cand1 train set + one switch each): A = fused log-prob loss PASS cos 0.9947 (0.61x noise); B = fused gather (4-rank RS backward) PASS cos 0.9957 (0.49x);
  C = TE RMSNorm for the sharded GDN input norm INCORRECT cos 0.9562 (5.05x; loss_mean at 47% of tol; step-0 loss 0.0534309 vs 0.0534138: the forward really changes) -> OPD_FAST_RMSNORM is
  DROPPED (cand3's failure was C). Gather mode 2 (OPD_GDN_FUSED_GATHER=2, two-stage backward, bitwise like the unfused path) is used in the final candidate cand4b.
- Anomaly found in the record runs: step-1 train/grad_norm is 1.456 (/tmp/r5/quick_c1train) and 1.484 (/tmp/r2/quick1) instead of the usual 1.001-1.011 in 2 of 10 record runs (A/B/C/cand3/quick2/3/r4check1
  are normal); losses equal, only the reported norm (and hence the clip coefficient 1/1.456 instead of ~1) is off, exp_avg_sq lower by 7%; this alone gave cos 0.9825 for cand1. Cause unknown
  (not tied to GRADS_ONLY: quick1 predates it). Diagnostics: OPD_GRAD_DEBUG=1 logs per-rank sum of squares of main_grad and the top contributors (slime 293826e9); two debug train timing runs queued
  (/tmp/r5/time_dbg1, time_dbg2); faulthandler stall watchdog OPD_STALL_DUMP.
- Teacher --enable-symm-mem (NCCL symmetric memory + NVLS): time windows 16.41/16.40/16.18 (4 GB prealloc) and 16.37/16.44/16.14 (SGLANG_SYMM_MEM_PREALLOC_GB_SIZE=1) vs 16.74/16.78/16.56;
  teacher-only check --quick PASS (/tmp/r5/quick_tc3: mean|d| ratio 1.0044, event p 0.26, bias t -0.79). Included in cand4b with the 1 GB prealloc.
- cand4b = /tmp/r5/sw_cand4b.json (cand1 + FUSED_LOGPROB_LOSS + GDN_FUSED_GATHER=2 + LIVE_WEIGHT_SYNC + GDN_FUSED_IN_PROJ + FUSED_SAMPLER + AG_SCALE_BLOCKS + teacher symm-mem/1 GB): all-sides
  check --quick queued as /tmp/r5/quick_c4b_all (snapshot /tmp/chk_tree10); adopt only on PASS. Full-loop probe of cand4 (with RMSNorm, tracing, stall dump) /tmp/r5/full8 running.
8.9 hRound 6 (2026-11-15 04:55 -> ...): handoff, profiles of the cand4b step, teacher logits path, TE CP-backward syncs
- Full-loop probe of cand4 (/tmp/r5/full8, tree /tmp/full_tree8; with OPD_TRACE_HANDOFF): step windows 82.8 / 83.3 / 84.0 s (frozen reference step ~154 s), rollout 55.7-55.9 s, train 24.1 s
  (fwd+bwd 21.3-22.1 s, optimizer 1.93-2.0 s), update_weights 0.40-0.47 s. Rollout exit -> train start = 1.5 s of which finish_rollout = 1.0 s (the 1-token /health_generate of
  slime's rollout-boundary health check: sglang's handler polls with await asyncio.sleep(1)), offload 0.27-0.34 s, convert/split 0.22 s.
  -> sglang commit 4a35ad6: OPD_HEALTH_POLL_S (default 1.0 = upstream; cand5 sets 0.02). Pure latency, N0. Probe with it: /tmp/r5/full11 (queued).
- OPD_GDN_FUSED_IN_PROJ (decode in_proj fusion) ran (log: "Packed BF16/FP8 GDN input projection enabled for 24 layers") but gave NO rollout gain: time --side rollout of cand4b
  (/tmp/r5/time_c4broll) windows 56.40/57.31/56.54 s (teacher tail 15.2/14.2/14.1) vs cand4 (without it) 56.35/56.42/56.68. Reason: in CUDA-graph capture sglang already runs the tiny
  in_proj_ba GEMM on an alternate stream concurrently with in_proj_qkvz; merging removes the concurrency. Keep off in later candidates (it is inside the quick_c4b_all validation set).
- Rollout profile of cand4b (/tmp/r5/profile_roll_c4b): kernel time/decode step 4.68 ms (was 5.4): gate_up GEMM 34 us x32 (96 blocks of 132 SMs, ideal 24 us), in_proj/qkv 16.9 x32, down 15.6+2.0
  x32, out 8.5 x32, GDN recurrent 20.2 x24, fused AR+norm 6.5 x63, lm_head 245, sampler _stage1 55 us (was ~216), logits AG 47; GEMM inefficiency vs HBM floor ~0.8 ms/step (16%).
  TunableOp / cuBLAS algorithm search for the four M=32 shapes queued (/tmp/r5/tunable_test.log).
- Teacher profile of the 16384-chunk config is impossible with the judge's profiler (it waits for 64 forward steps; a rollout replay has ~21): /tmp/r5/profile_teacher_tc4 = ERROR. Using the
  old 4096-chunk profile (/tmp/r1/profile_teacher): the logits path (TP all-gather 2.4 ms + permute copy 1.5 + buffer copy 1.3 + row gather + row_logsumexp 0.46 per 2048 rows) is ~9% of a forward.
  -> sglang commit f171eb2 OPD_TP_LOGPROB (vocab-parallel input log-probs: per-rank (max, sumexp, target logit), 3 floats/row all-gathered; sampled rows still gathered). Kernel test vs the
  upstream path: |diff| <= 4e-6 (the upstream path's own error vs float64 is 2e-6). Teacher timing queued (/tmp/r5/time_c6bteacher).
- Train profile of cand4b (/tmp/r5/profile_train_c4b, judge profiler -> 456 MB/rank traces; reduced pickles /tmp/r5/prof_c4b_rank*.pkl, scripts reduce_trace.py nccl_skew2.py rank_busy.py gap_hist.py):
  per rank compute kernels 14.8-15.0 s (balanced), NCCL kernels 8-15.6 s of which only ~2.1 s is transfer (sum over collectives of the min duration across ranks); the rest is waiting for
  late peers (rank 0 waits most, rank 1 arrives last): AG 2-rank 17.8 MB 256 us mean (median ~100), RS 2-rank 35.6 MB 403 us mean. The judge's profiler inflates CPU time 2x (42 s window vs 24 s real step) so
  GPU idle gaps (17 s of 42 s, mostly 100-1000 us gaps) are not representative. 1738 cudaStreamSynchronize/step/rank (1.1-1.55 s CPU wait in the profile): 1536 of them are the redundant eager
  zero-fill dq[cu_seqlens_q_padded[-1]:].fill_(0) in TE's CP P2P attention backward (flash-attn THD path; the same function zero-fills again sync-free with arange masks at its end).
  -> slime commit 5618fcdd OPD_CP_BWD_NO_SYNC (source-level patch of TE's backward at actor start-up, default off, N0 identical values); old-trace estimate of GPU idle exposed after these syncs <= 0.25 s/step.
  Timing queued (/tmp/r5/time_c5train vs time_c6atrain).
- Hardware notes: host = 2 sockets x 48 cores (Xeon 8558), we own NUMA node 0 (CPUs 0-47,96-143; GPU0-3 are node-0 GPUs, other 4 GPUs/node 1 belong to another tenant); 8 sglang scheduler processes
  (4 student + 4 teacher TP ranks) spin at 70-100% CPU each even when idle; train actors main thread ~91-200% CPU.

- BUG FOUND (06:10 UTC) in OPD_LIVE_WEIGHT_SYNC (my own change): the probes of cand4 (/tmp/r5/full8) and cand5 (/tmp/r5/full11) showed mismatch_steps (train_rollout_logprob_abs_diff per step)
  rising 0.0080, 0.0090, 0.0095, 0.0115, 0.0151 (full8: ... 0.0163), while the cand1-era probes (full1/full3/full4) stay flat at 0.0072-0.0081 (reference first-step value 0.00805; the final evaluation
  allows 2x). Root cause: with the live sync backup("actor") is skipped, but train() starts with self._switch_model("actor") = weights_backuper.restore("actor"), which copied the INITIAL host
  backup over the trained bf16 parameters at every step: forward/backward ran at the initial weights while the optimizer (fp32 masters on the host) accumulated correctly and the engines received
  the live (correct) weights -> the trainer's log-probs diverge from the engines' as the weights move. check --quick cannot see it (record runs have no rollouts with updated weights); the
  final evaluation's full-loop mismatch gate would have rejected the run (0.0163 > 2 x 0.0081). FIX (slime 9ad807db): _switch_model returns early when the target tag is already active in the grads-only
  mode (without the live sync the restore was a value no-op, so this is N0 there and saves ~0.2 s/step). Verification probe: /tmp/r5/full13 (cand7 = cand4b - in_proj + health poll). The earlier
  all-sides check of cand4b (/tmp/r5/quick_c4b_all) was killed at its train-record stage (it ran the buggy build); cand1 (adopted) never had the live sync and is unaffected.
  LESSON: read mismatch_steps of every full-loop probe; /submission/switches.json must not get a candidate without a flat trend.

- Grad-norm anomaly (step-1 train/grad_norm 1.46-2.47 instead of ~1.0, 2 of 10 record runs; also seen in full-loop probes: full4 step 1 = 2.02, full8 step 3 = 1.556): it ALSO occurs in the
  unmodified reference: /tmp/r1/profile_train (Round 1, reference tree) logged grad norms [0.997, 2.466, 0.893, 0.949, 0.98, 0.719]. So it is inherited reference behaviour (probably a race around the first
  sleep/wake cycle), not caused by my switches; the judge's N1 gate tolerates it (cos 0.9825 in the anomalous cand1 record run).
- Verification probe of the fixed live sync (cand7 = cand4b without in_proj + OPD_HEALTH_POLL_S; /tmp/r5/full13, tree /tmp/full_tree13 = slime 9ad807db): windows 82.01/83.01/82.56 s, mismatch_steps
  0.0081/0.0082/0.0070/0.0078/0.0077 (flat, healthy), first_use 0.0, no layout problems. (full11 before the fix: 82.43/82.67/83.06 with the rising mismatch.)
- FA3 decode attention microbenchmark (/tmp/r5/fa3_bench.py): batch 32, 8 q / 2 kv heads, head_dim 256: ctx 6000 105 us/layer (3.73 TB/s = 89% of the HBM roofline), ctx 8000 135 us (92%); page size 1..128 makes no
  difference -> the attention part of decode (avg ~0.58 ms of the 5.05 ms step: KV reads grow with the context) is at the roofline. TunableOp for the four M=32 decode GEMM shapes: no change (default cuBLAS is the only candidate).
- Decode GPU utilization (nvidia-smi 1 Hz during full11): decode phase 100%, train phase 91% (the 9% = optimizer CPU Adam wait ~1.9 s), teacher tail 97-98%.
- Queue: check --quick all sides of cand8 (= cand7 + OPD_CP_BWD_NO_SYNC + OPD_TP_LOGPROB; /tmp/r5/sw_cand8.json, snapshot /tmp/chk_tree11) -> /tmp/r5/quick_c8_all (started 06:39). Adopt on PASS.
↑ Slime OPD