GPT-6.2 Astra 1.46×
Harness: Codex · switches: SLIME_ELIDE_ZERO_KL_REFERENCE=1 SLIME_INLINE_OPD=1 SLIME_ACTOR_CHECKPOINT_LAYERS=8 SLIME_KEEP_ACTOR_WEIGHTS=1 SGLANG_CACHE_TOP_P_LOGPROB_REQUESTS=1
- Judged
- 1.46×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 1.46×
- Rounds
- 13
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $54.3
- Input tokens · 98.1% cached
- 78 M
- Output tokens
- 0.3 M
- Requests
- 516
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log13 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — training profile
- 19:09:03 launched the unchanged candidate (all threeopttrees clean, empty switches), four-GPU training profile; lock acquired 19:09:20. Detached PID 72828,/tmp/r1/profile.log, output/tmp/r1/profile. - Frozen step fractions: training 47.38%, rollout including teacher 49.26%, teacher critical-path tail 10.66%. The unchanged bootstrap quick check passed N1. Frozen training timing has appreciable spread (6.88%). - Stage attribution from the running unchanged profile (profile_train/train.log, step 1): 47.66 s actor training (63.1%), 10.67 s reference scoring (14.1%), 9.97 s actor scoring (13.2%), 6.80 s wait including the sleep/wake (9.0%). These are profile attribution, not candidate performance numbers. Hotspot class: repeated transformer forwards. The loss KL coefficient and reward KL coefficient are both zero; for one optimizer step the live training policy is also the pre-update policy for every microbatch. The actor currently recomputes all 32 layers in backward. - Isolated trial in/tmp/r1/tree: three independent switches for eliminating the zero-coefficient reference KL, computing the actual detached tokenwise OPD advantages from the live training forward, and retaining activations for 24 layers (block checkpoint 8). The inline OPD path requires one update, the existing reuse guards, no dropout, unnormalized GRPO advantages and no custom advantage/rollout postprocessing. It retains the original GRPO returns and fills real old log-probs/advantages/reverse KL for every sample and normal rollout metrics. No changes to generation, teacher, optimizer, precision, order or hooks. - 19:19:38 launched judgetime, PID 90696,/tmp/r1/time.log, result/tmp/r1/time/time.json. It waits for the reference profile's lock. Candidate syntax and diff checks passed. - CPU formula check: exact detached output buffers for reverse KL, GRPO advantage and old policy on empty, short and long slices, including nonzero task rewards and three KL coefficients. The two forward-pass changes are installed as a provisional fallback with the original activation schedule. This is mathematical/stage evidence, not a passing result. The block-checkpoint variant remains only in the isolated measurement tree. - 19:35:02 queued the deterministic quick check after successful R1 timing: PID 101219,/tmp/r1/quick.log, result/tmp/r1/quick/check.json. The reference profile is still serializing four very large traces. - Round closed at its 19:39:20 cap: no timing ratio yet, diagnostic capture complete but compression still running. Preserved a complete 23.2 GB pre-compression Kineto trace and terminated the profiling launcher. Its official status is ERROR (interrupted export); the stage data and uncompressed trace are real, not timing evidence. Four traces arrived at the export stage only after the profiled update finished. Judge cleanup released the lock; candidate timing acquired it at 19:41:11. Its result and the quick check will be appended when available.
0.6 hRound 2 — teacher profiling
R1 kernel accounting, recovered offline: all 641,538 kernel events from the complete raw trace, projected out CPU events, and ran the judge'skernel_util.pyon those events (/tmp/r1/profile/raw-kernel-report.md, CPU-only PID 113399,/tmp/r1/project.log). Device busy 65.4% of profiled window. Largest classes by kernel time: NCCL ring all-gather 23.6% (skewed), two dense GEMM classes 8.6% and 7.9%, bf16 reduce-scatter 7.6%, another dense GEMM 6.2%. FLA recurrent state forward 1.7%. Eliminating repeated forwards also eliminates their collectives. Removed the redundant 23.2 GB original and incomplete compressed exports after obtaining the kernel projection and report. - 19:41:40 queued the judge's teacher profile of the current submission, PID 111679,/tmp/r2/profile.log, output/tmp/r2/profile. Teacher code, layout and arguments remain unchanged at this point. The training timing and precision jobs from R1 are isolated in/tmp/r1. - R2 acquired the lock at 19:53:37 (30-minute cap 20:23:37). - R2 profile completedokat 19:58:35,/tmp/r2/profile/kernel_report.md: 92.7% device busy, dense GEMM classes 44.1% and 8.0%; bf16 TP ring all-reduce 20.7% (median 210 us, p90 217 us; sustained, not just a rank straggling), residual/RMSNorm 4.0%, vocab all-gather 3.6%, row logsumexp 0.7%. Chose TP communication rather than writing a vocab-loss kernel. The teacher's existing FlashInfer reduce+norm caps its token count at 2048; stock chunks have 4096 tokens. Two independent teacher-only switch trials: 2048-token chunks (existing fused path), or stock-size chunks with SGLang's symmetric-memory collectives. No effect on actor, teacher dtype, widths or ranks. Launched judgetime --side teacheron both at 20:02:07: PIDs 139959 and 139960;/tmp/r2/chunk-time.log,/tmp/r2/symm-time.log, respective output directories/tmp/r2/chunk-timeand/tmp/r2/symm-time. These use stock trees because the R1 training changes never run in teacher replay. Waiting on the R1 quick check's lock. - R1 non-quickcheckqueued after a passing quick record, PID 128017,/tmp/r1/check.log,/tmp/r1/check/check.json, on the isolated exact copy of the promoted code/switches. - R1 timing result/tmp/r1/time/time.json: statusok, eight real updates, no layout problems, windows 48.204, 47.584, 46.965 s; speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.5315x train, ratios 1.5306 / 1.5198 / 1.5441; projected step 1.1968x, first uses 0/0/0 s. First-step loss 0.05341373384 and mismatch 0.00805216003 match the reference's logged values. The quick record check is pending. Promoted the measured tree and its three switches together. The three gains are a combined measurement, not separately timed. - R1 quick/tmp/r1/quick/check.jsoncompleted 20:08:17: PASS N1. Data/parameters/layout exact, update direction cosine 0.995462 vs floor 0.956603, loss-mean delta -0.000003318 within ±0.00003750, first-step mismatch ratio exactly 1.0. Fullcheckentered its timing run 20:11:01; no gate has been bypassed. - R2 symmetric collectives/tmp/r2/symm-time/time.jsoncompleted 20:11:17: 17.946/17.893/17.512 s, teacher speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0196x, projected step 1.0021x. Not promoted: insufficient full-step benefit to justify changing the teacher reduction path. The 2048-chunk screen is still waiting for the GPU behind the R1 full check. - At the 20:23:37 wall cap closed R2 with no promoted change. R1's non-round full check acquired the lock again for its precision record at 20:22:59. Teacher quick checks are queued for both modified arithmetic paths: PIDs 168024 (/tmp/r2/chunk-quick.log) and 168025 (/tmp/r2/symm-quick.log), output dirs of the same names without.log. Pending judge outcomes will be appended, not inferred.
1.4 hRound 3 — student decode profiling
- 20:15:19 queued the rollout profile of the promoted training optimization and unchanged serving path after the R2 chunk screen. Detached PID 160671,/tmp/r3/profile.log, output/tmp/r3/profile. No student-serving modifications without this profile. - R1 full check/tmp/r1/check/check.json, finished 20:33:29, PASS N1. Train windows 47.568/47.279/47.170 s, training 1.5393x, projected step 1.1990x vs required 1.1376x, 0/0/0 s first-use time, mismatch ratio 1.0. This is the ordinarycheck(frozen side timings), not the final evaluator's reference/candidate/reference full-loop measurement. - R2 chunk 2048/tmp/r2/chunk-time/time.json: 20.023/20.067/19.716 s, teacher speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9095x, standalone projected step 0.9895x. Reject: enabling smaller fused prefill batches did not recover the throughput lost from smaller compute tiles/more batches. Both R2 switches stay out of the submission. Their precision checks remain in the queue. - R2 2048-chunk quick/tmp/r2/chunk-quick/check.jsonPASS N1 at 20:47:48; numerically acceptable but slower. Symmetric-collective quick still queued. The optional R1 N1 repeat was rescheduled behind R3 timing (waiting wrapper PID 190024 stopped before a run, new PID 199972,/tmp/r1/n1.log, output/tmp/r1/n1). - R3 profile lock 20:36:39;/tmp/r3/profile/profile.jsonstatusokat 20:44:32; 92,327 kernels on the largest trace, 43.8% device busy in the instrumented interval. Largest GEMM class 19.3%, fused TP reduction+norm 12.7%, packed GDN recurrence 9.7%, other large GEMMs 9.7% and 9.6%. A small 3-CTA split-K GEMM used by GDN gating had 4,752 launches (24 per decode pass), median 13.5 us, 6.0% of kernel time, plus a separate reduction. Selected this missed existing fast path:Qwen3_5GatedDeltaNet.finalize_fused_in_projalready supports packed bf16 but preparation was only enabled for ROCm models. In isolated/tmp/r3/treeCUDA bf16 weights are optionally allocated as two parameter views of one packed storage, inside module construction. Checkpoint and later synchronous weight loads write into these same views; no derived/stale model copy. No changes to the GDN recurrence, sampling or precision. SwitchSGLANG_QWEN35_PACK_BF16_PROJECTIONSis off by default. - R3 judge rollouttimePID 206793,/tmp/r3/time.log, output/tmp/r3/time; submitted 20:48:02 with/tmp/r3/switches.json, prime lock 20:48:20. R4 current-best training profile queued after R3 timing, PID 221063,/tmp/r4/profile.log,/tmp/r4/profile. - R3 time and conclusion: completed at 21:03, round ended 21:03:51./tmp/r3/time/time.jsonok: 76.050/76.762/76.282 s; rollout speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9922x, projected 0.9961x, no layout problems or timed first uses. The merged GEMM does not improve rollout, irrespective of its fewer launches. Not promoted. Trial commited2c2d9in/tmp/r3/tree/sglang. Its numerical quick test is deferred behind the next timing (PID 239652,/tmp/r3/quick.log,/tmp/r3/quick); R1 remains the checked submission.
2.0 hRound 4 — actor residency profile
- R4's train profile and the independent R1 statistical repeat are waiting for the previous teacher precision run to finish. Prior R1 full-check stage attribution, not a new speed measurement: on step 5 actor training 40.21 s, wait 6.72 s including sleep 4.40 s and wake 1.47 s. The rollout-only profile shows about 51 GiB free per GPU even after teacher + student graphs/caches. Investigate retaining weights/process groups while still releasing disposable gradient storage and keeping the CPU optimizer as before. - R2 symmetric quick/tmp/r2/symm-quick/check.json: PASS N1, but speed insufficient as noted. R4 acquired the lock at 21:06:25 (wall cap 21:36:25). The R1 N1 repeat still waits; the formal full check has already passed. - Fresh R4 profile, step 1: actor_train 39.90 s (84.1%), wait 7.34 s (15.5%), including sleep 5.07 s and wake 1.41 s (13.6% combined). The model has no reference/teacher swaps with the current switches. Opt-inSLIME_KEEP_ACTOR_WEIGHTSmakes this single-model colocated actor release the unbacked tagged gradient storage at sleep (it is zeroed in normal training), while preserving its live weights and process groups; no redundant CPU restore of an already-resident actor. Host-pinned copies used to publish each fresh update remain unchanged; optimizer and its fp32 CPU states are unchanged. Full offload remains default and the fallback for multirole jobs. More conservative than disabling offload entirely. - Syntax/diff checks passed on isolated/tmp/r4/tree. Cumulative R4time --side train, PID 255146,/tmp/r4/time.log,/tmp/r4/time, launched 21:13:42 and queued behind the profile. Quick record conditional on successful timing: PID 256224,/tmp/r4/quick.log,/tmp/r4/quick. R3's slow-candidate precision check was rescheduled behind this quick record (PID 256227, replacing never-started wrapper 239652). - R4 train profile run completed normally at 21:31:07 (24m41s lock hold). All four compressed traces are complete. Independent CPU-only extraction of a complete Kineto trace (PID 264579,/tmp/r4/project.log) found 353,766 kernel events./tmp/r4/profile/raw-kernel-report.md: busy 65.4%; all-gather 16.5%, reduce-scatter 8.4%, top dense GEMMs 5.8%, 5.6%, 5.3%, 5.1%. Correlation with ATen call shapes (PID 266295,/tmp/r4/gdn-trace.log) identifies at least 16.6% of all kernel time in full-sequence 4096/8192-wide Qwen GDN GEMMs at the most common padded length alone. The all-gathers are heavily skewed, not interpretable as pure bandwidth cost. The R1 statistical repeat acquired the lock after the profile. R4 timing and quick are pending. Trial remains isolated. - R4's official profile/tmp/r4/profile/profile.jsoncompletedokat 21:34:04 with/tmp/r4/profile/kernel_report.mdreproducing the independent accounting. Round closed by its 21:36:25 wall cap with timing still queued. Compressed traces and both kernel reports kept, redundant raw file removed. - R4 timing received 21:53:08,/tmp/r4/time/time.jsonok: windows 41.109/40.699/39.876 s, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.7968x train, 1.2660x projected step. On the same three fixture windows R1 was 48.204/47.584/46.965 s. All windows improve. Layout correct; timed first uses all zero. Stage logs show sleep 0.6–0.9 s and wake 0.0–0.1 s; ~18 GiB per GPU used at sleep (versus ~1 GiB before). This fits inside the 51 GiB of free memory observed with teacher and rollout engines resident. Trial commitba0becdein/tmp/r4/tree/slime. The measured gain justified ordinary full check PID 311283,/tmp/r4/check.log, result/tmp/r4/check/check.json, launched 21:54:55. Quick record queued earlier. Do not claim full-loop speed from these side timings. - R1's independent statistical repeat/tmp/r1/n1/check.jsonPASS N1 at 21:41:51. First-step mismatch exactly the reference's again. - R4 full check/tmp/r4/check/check.json: PASS N1, 22:39:49. Training windows 40.494/40.387/39.617 s, 1.8144x train, 1.2701x projected step, versus benefit bar 1.1376. All training endpoints passed; update cosine 0.99269 (minimum 0.95660), first-step mismatch 0.00805216 exactly the reference's. At 22:40:10 promoted commitba0becdeand the exact four-switch file; all three submitted Git heads equal the checked trial, all clean,cmpconfirms identical switches. R4 independent quick record acquired GPU at 22:39:34. - Colocation capacity cross-check from the saved profile, not a loop timing: parsed Kineto's allocator memory events from rank 3 (CPU-only PID 374381,/tmp/r4/trace-memory.log). Peak actor allocation 56.99 GiB, reservation 60.06 GiB with eight checkpointed layers. The teacher server reported 100.2–100.7 GiB free after graph capture. Combined with the rollout headroom and 18.3 GiB actor sleep usage above, neither phase appears near total device capacity. This is separate evidence from, not a substitute for, the final integrated run. - Additional CPU-only module accounting from the complete R4 trace,/tmp/r4/module-trace.log(PIDs 442037/443969, raw intermediate removed afterwards): correlated CUDA kernels to parent ATen operators, Python module forward spans, and corresponding autograd sequence numbers in backward. The replicated GDN body accounts for 12.50% forward and 21.62% backward of trace kernel duration. Its separate unfused HF input RMSNorm accounts for 2.32% forward and 3.93% backward, dominated by full-sequence elementwise multiplies/copies and reductions. This suggests a future numerics-preserving fusion independently of R5's rejected redistribution. - Independent/tmp/r4/quick/check.jsoncompleted 22:49:45: PASS N1 again, update-direction cosine 0.99440, train/rollout mismatch ratio 1.0. R5 time acquired the lock at 22:49:30.
2.4 hRound 5 — context-parallel GDN
- 21:33:39 queued current-best training profile after R4 timing (PID 277194,/tmp/r5/profile.log, output/tmp/r5/profile); candidate workspace/tmp/r5/tree. Prior current-best trace confirms that the HF attention wrapper gathers all CP tokens, computes every GDN head on every CP rank, then discards nonlocal output chunks. Explore distributing this work without changing any parameter or optimizer shard. No change to the submission. - Prepared the off-GPU prototype from the current-best trace.SLIME_SHARD_GDN_CONTEXT=1: project QKV, gates and output on local tokens; all-to-all the input to the convolution and recurrence so each CP rank owns whole sequences of disjoint heads. Exchange recurrent results back before gated RMSNorm and output projection. All weights, master weights and parameter registrations remain unchanged. No cross-update cache; the permutation is local toPackedSeqParams. Uses the original FLA recurrence and BF16 activation exchange. Valid only for the replicated HF backend on suitable head counts and packed batches, default off. - Syntax and git diff checks passed. CPU-only differentiable synthetic test/tmp/r5/cp_test.pyon two Gloo ranks passed (/tmp/r5/cp_test.log): forward, local activation gradients, and all CP-summed parameter gradients matched the full-sequence version for three distinct sequence packings. It uses the production exchange and permutation functions and portable causal-convolution/GDN arithmetic, not a substitute for the GPU gate. Judge time queued behind the fresh profile: PID 285035,/tmp/r5/time.log,/tmp/r5/time; conditional quick record PID 285036,/tmp/r5/quick.log,/tmp/r5/quick. - Fresh training profile acquired GPU lock 21:53:26 (cap 22:23:26), using the currently verified R1 submission. After receiving R4's positive timing, added the independently measured residency change to the isolated R5 candidate before its judge timing started. Its incremental comparator is now R4's 40.561 s mean. R3's low-priority slow-candidate quick wrapper was rescheduled after R5's quick (PID 315399; former wrapper did not acquire GPUs). - Round 5 profile completedokat 22:21:21,/tmp/r5/profile/profile.json. Stage attribution for step 1: actor 41.24 s of 48.82 s (84.5%); wait 7.36 s (15.1%) including sleep 5.08 s and wake 1.43 s./tmp/r5/profile/kernel_report.md: 353,766 kernels, 63.9% device busy. All-gather 19.9%, reduce-scatter 7.2%, major dense GEMM classes 5.8%, 5.5%, 5.3%, 5.1%. Together with R4's op-shape correlation this supports the CP-local rewrite. Round closed at 22:22:46, within cap, with R5 timing queued; the R4 full check is in its timing phase. R5 is not promoted on profiling evidence. - R5 time/tmp/r5/time/time.jsoncompleted 23:00:07, status ok; windows 34.980/34.803/34.701 s, mean 34.828 s, 2.0923x train vs frozen / 1.3286x projected step, no timed first uses or layout problems. R4 mean was 40.561 s. Trial commitb9465348(not submitted). First-step train/rollout mismatch 0.00801838; first gradient norm in the non-record timing was 0.992391 versus 0.996647 in the R1 timing. Given the changed reduction order the judge's record matters: R5 quick acquired lock 23:00:36, do not promote on speed alone. - R5 rejected,/tmp/r5/quick/check.json, 23:09:49INCORRECT. All exact items passed. First gradient norm 0.99234724 vs 0.99673635, absolute difference 0.00438911 > 0.00165135 allowed. Update norm, second moment, loss and update cosine (0.960427 >= 0.956603) passed, but do not override that failure. CP-local weight-gradient products and the accumulation of contributions from disjoint output chunks use a different BF16 rounding order despite the equivalent CPU derivatives. No full check or promotion; leave this direction and move on.
3.3 hRound 6 — student decode profile
- 22:22:46 scheduled judge profile of the best submission's rollout after the R5 training time and start of its quick record (PID 342871,/tmp/r6/profile.log, output/tmp/r6/profile). This gives the promising training candidates priority. Student and teacher kernels in the submission are still the original ones. Previous student trace showed the packed GDN recurrence at 9.7% of kernel duration; investigate existing indexed decode implementations if the new capture confirms the hotspot. - R6 profile acquired lock 23:09:33; 30-minute cap 23:39:33. The exact R4 tree is being profiled;/tmp/r6/treeis a separate clone of it. R3's deferred correctness check is now submitted. - R6 profile completedokat 23:17:01,/tmp/r6/profile/kernel_report.md: 39.0% GPU busy including profiling overhead. Top BF16 GEMM classes 20.4%, 10.2% and 10.1%; GDN packed decode recurrence 10.2%, 4,752 calls, median 21.4 us, 205 registers/thread; TP all-reduce 8.5%. The previous packed-projection experiment did not speed the surrounding dense projections. Trial selects the upstream CuTe DSL indexed GDN kernel for student decode only viaSLIME_ROLLOUT_LINEAR_ATTN_DECODE_BACKEND=cutedsl. Explicit CLI values take precedence and retained serving attachments validate the effective args. No new sampler, no change to prefill, teacher, state precision, parameters or model update path. CPU-only helper tests, syntax and diff checks passed.time --side rolloutsubmitted 23:17:55, PID 430482,/tmp/r6/time.log,/tmp/r6/time; conditional quick PID 430483,/tmp/r6/quick.log,/tmp/r6/quick. - Pending next fresh training profile after the R6 timing starts: PID 424567,/tmp/r7/profile.log,/tmp/r7/profile. R4's measured 60.06 GiB peak reservation and eight remaining checkpointed layers suggest screening the existing checkpoint-depth switch without changing training math. - R6 timing acquired lock 23:31:57 for rollout cache priming. The actual server logs showdecode=CuteDSLGDNKernel, extend=FlashInferGDNKernelon both engines; the intended backend did run and prefill is unchanged. At 23:36:26 no valid timing or precision result yet. R7 profile is waiting for the GPU lock;/tmp/r7/treeis a clean clone of the R4 submission. - R6 round closed at 23:39:33 cap. Prime finishedokat 23:38:27, measured rollout still running. No incremental speed claim; R4 remains submitted. Timing and quick results will be logged when available. - R6 time result, 23:47:36:/tmp/r6/time/time.jsonok; windows 76.887/77.772/77.488 s vs frozen 75.611/76.071/75.633 s, 0.9792x rollout, 0.9896x projected. Layout correct, no timed first uses. The indexed CuTe kernel does not improve end-to-end generation despite the hotspot; rejected on benefit, not promoted. Isolated commit735bbf5c. Its independent numerical quick check is queued (PID 430483); R3's token-forcing gate is also queued after its first two rollout runs completedok. - R6 quick/tmp/r6/quick/check.jsonfinished 01:23:52 Nov 18, INCORRECT at stock-token forcing: mean absolute logprob difference 0.31694 vs reference 0.00779 (40.70x, limit 2x); tail rate 12.32%, sampler t = -17.36. Reject both on benefit and correctness; do not use this kernel or adjust the gate. - R3 quick/tmp/r3/quick/check.jsonfinished 01:33:35 Nov 18, PASS N1 on rollout, teacher and train. Rejected on benefit as before.
4.5 hRound 7 — activation retention
- Current best is R4. Its previous trace had 1,920 input RMSNorm and GDN forward spans versus 1,536 actual layer uses (64 microbatches × 24 linear-attention layers); the first eight checkpointed transformer blocks re-run six of those GDN layers during backward. The allocator peak is well below the estimated colocated memory budget. Awaiting the fresh current-best profile (PID 424567); investigate retaining the remaining activations, not changing GDN arithmetic or parameter gradients. - R7 acquired the GPU lock at 23:47:21 Nov 17, cap 00:17:21 Nov 18. The R4 actor remains resident between steps for this profile. - Nov 18: R7's step 1 stage counters: actor training 38.95 s of 40.77 s (95.5%), train wait 1.80 s (4.4%), sleep 0.86 s and wake 0.03 s. At 00:01:15 the completed current-best Kineto trace confirmed 1,920 GDN forward spans and 1,920 input RMSNorm forward spans (/tmp/r7/forward-spans.txt), 384 extra per module family from rematerialization. The trial setsSLIME_ACTOR_CHECKPOINT_LAYERS=0instead of8, leaving the complete R4 source and all other switches identical. No change to layer implementations, optimizer/offload, batches or sample-dependent execution. At 00:01:33 launchedtime --side train, PID 507263,/tmp/r7/time.log,/tmp/r7/time; conditional quick record PID 507264,/tmp/r7/quick.log,/tmp/r7/quick. - R7's official profile completedokat 00:14:33 Nov 18,/tmp/r7/profile/profile.json,/tmp/r7/profile/kernel_report.md: 356,119 kernels, 74.7% GPU busy, NCCL all-gather 22.0%, reduce-scatter 9.1%, largest dense GEMMs 5.3% and 5.0%. Timing acquired the lock 00:11:41. Round closed 00:16:46 within cap with the timing in progress. No change to the submitted R4 switches yet. - R7 time, 00:22:48 Nov 18,/tmp/r7/time/time.jsonok: windows 39.951/38.101/38.338 s (mean 38.797), 1.8788x train vs frozen / 1.2847x projected step. R4 independently measured 41.109/40.699/39.876; all three windows improve without a timed first use. Layout correct, first-step mismatch exactly reference. As the switch is stored outside the git trees, provenance-only commit265989fdin/tmp/r7/tree/slimerecords its setting and result with no change to code bytes. Full check launched at 00:23:41: PID 531982,/tmp/r7/check.log,/tmp/r7/check; quick acquired the lock 00:24:17. Keep R4 submitted pending validation. - R7 quick/tmp/r7/quick/check.jsonPASS N1 at 00:34:08 Nov 18; mismatch ratio 1.0, update-direction cosine 0.99436 vs minimum 0.95660, all endpoints pass. R8's current-best profile therefore uses the faster, precision-validated R7 config. The external submission still uses the most recent ordinary full-check winner (R4). - R7 ordinary full/tmp/r7/check/check.jsonfinished 00:57:38 Nov 18, PASS N1, exact layout/schema, mismatch ratio 1.0 and cosine 0.98810. Windows 52.712/37.674/37.522 s: 1.7507x train / 1.2550x projected. The first window's actor_train was 51.03 s vs 38.14 s for that window in the independent screen; no Triton first use. R7 won five of the six window comparisons with R4 but not the ordinary full check's overall speed. Keep R4 submitted, and use R7 as the precision-validated experimental base for R8.
5.1 hRound 8 — normalization investigation
- Prior current-best trace module attribution identified the HF GDN input RMSNorm at 6.25% of kernel duration forward + backward. Only consider kernel fusion that preserves the original zero-centered gamma, the original registered parameter, FP32 reductions, and the checkpoint schema. CPU inspection of the available TE module found an additional_extra_statekey, so replacing the registered module verbatim is not equivalent. Re-profile the next verified best version before making any change. - Fresh profile scheduled 00:24:48 Nov 18 after R7's first correctness verdict (PID 539141,/tmp/r8/profile.log,/tmp/r8/profile); profile R7 if validated, otherwise the checked submission. Independent checkout/tmp/r8/tree. The installed FLA functional RMSNorm can consume an FP32 effective gamma while leaving the original HF parameter registered; unlike swapping in a new TE module, this preserves state dictionary keys. - CPU-only helper PID 595385,/tmp/r8/module-trace.log, waits for the new profiler export, then attributes kernel time to GDN and HF input RMSNorm modules from the actual R7 configuration. No submission change. - R8 fresh training profile acquired the lock at 01:33:20 Nov 18; round cap 02:03:20. - CPU-only check with the actual HF RMSNorm and trial wrapper passed for the unchanged CPU fallback: identical outputs, activation gradients, parameter gradients and original state-dictionary key. The real CUDA path still needs the judge. - The fresh R7-based rank-0 trace was linked from the profiler's temporary directory while it compressed (replacement CPU helper PID 671049)./tmp/r8/module-trace.log: 1,536 input norm calls, 2.15% forward + 4.54% backward of kernel duration, mainly multiplies, casts/copies and reductions. GDN itself was 11.53% forward + 24.97% backward. Stageactor_trainwas 36.50 s of 38.30 s in the warm profile step. The trial uses FLA's functional RMSNorm on supported CUDA BF16 HF GDN inputs, applies the effective weight1 + weight.float()in FP32, and preserves the registered HF module/weight and its fallback; no optimizer or model schema changes.SLIME_FUSE_GDN_INPUT_NORM=1in/tmp/r8/switches.json, default off. Syntax andgit diff --checkpassed. Judge time PID 671687 (/tmp/r8/time.log,/tmp/r8/time), then quick PID 671688 (/tmp/r8/quick.log,/tmp/r8/quick), launched 01:52:42. Trial source only. - R8 official profile/tmp/r8/profile/profile.jsoncompletedokat 01:58:30: 331,871 kernels, 68.1% busy, NCCL all-gather 16.1%, reduce-scatter 7.3%, two dense GEMMs 6.3% and 6.0%. Round closed 01:58:50 within cap with timing underway (lock at 01:55:54); quick follows. No result inferred or promoted. R9 fresh profiling is queued behind it. - R8 time/tmp/r8/time/time.jsonfinished 02:06:52 Nov 18, statusok: windows 36.764/36.642/37.241 s, 1.9759x train / 1.3055x projected step, faster in all windows than R7's independenttime. No layout issues, timed first use all zero, first-step mismatch 0.008020 vs reference 0.008052. Isolated trial commit7545df57; ordinary check conditioned on a passing quick, PID 692502,/tmp/r8/check.log,/tmp/r8/check. Not promoted without the verdict. - R8 quick/tmp/r8/quick/check.jsonfinished 02:23:34 Nov 18, INCORRECT. Exact schema passed, but first gradient norm 0.993046 vs 0.996736 (|d| 0.003690 > 0.001651) and update cosine 0.954414 < 0.956603. Update norm, second moment norm and mean loss passed. FLA uses a different FP32 normalization/backprop reduction tree; its performance does not count. Do not promote or repeat the gate. Conditional ordinary check skipped.
5.9 hRound 9 — rollout host synchronization
- 01:02:30 Nov 18: queued a fresh current-best rollout profile (PID 597668,/tmp/r9/profile.log, output/tmp/r9/profile) after R8 timing starts. CPU analysis of the earlier R6 unchanged-student trace correlated 200aten::anyresults with 200 immediateaten::itemcalls on the producer thread: 776 ms inclusive total, median 3,852 us in a 2.35 s instrumented trace. SGLang queries the optional top-p score-return flag even when none of the requests opted in. This is profiler evidence of a host synchronization, not a timing gain. Isolated/tmp/r9/treecloned from the R4 submission; no serving changes made until re-profiled. - R9 current-best rollout profile/tmp/r9/profile/profile.jsoncompletedok02:14:12. It confirms 200 host scalar reads immediately after 200 top-p request-flag reductions; 779.67 ms inclusive in a 2206 ms instrumented window, median read 3840 us, host-side producer→read gap 4.35 us. GPU busy 41.9%; largest GEMMs 20.1% and 10.0%, GDN 10.0%, fused TP reduction 8.8%. The long host read includes outstanding graph execution, not all recoverable time. The R9 trial caches only a host-side proof that *no* rows requested top-p scores; default-on safety fallback queries the real device mask if any row might require scores. Merging propagates the conservative flag. Filtering cannot turn an absent request into a present one.SGLANG_CACHE_TOP_P_LOGPROB_REQUESTS=1turns it on, off by default. No sampler probabilities, RNG calls or score arithmetic changed. CPU-only/tmp/r9/test_sampling_flags.pyconfirmed exact sampled IDs, selected logprobs and opted-in scores, including mixed, merged and filtered batches. Syntax andgit diff --checkpassed. Judge rollouttimePID 712835 (/tmp/r9/time.log,/tmp/r9/time); conditional quick PID 712836 (/tmp/r9/quick.log,/tmp/r9/quick), launched 02:14:54. - R9 round closed at 02:36:05 (cap 02:36:37) with timing still in progress. Prime finishedokand the timed rollout acquired the lock at 02:29:08. Quick and R10 profiling queued; no unvalidated promotion. - R9 time/tmp/r9/time/time.json, 02:37:05 Nov 18: statusok, 60.672/59.536/60.275 s vs 75.611/76.071/75.633 s; 1.2596x rollout / 1.1130x standalone projected step (ratios 1.2462, 1.2777, 1.2548). Actual layout matched. Trial commit3db0c35in/tmp/r9/tree/sglang. Strong all-window gain justifies the ordinary full check PID 752436,/tmp/r9/check.log,/tmp/r9/check, launched 02:37:53, alongside the queued independent quick. The trial has R4 training unchanged. No claim about combined or integrated speed before the judge. - At 03:46:07 Nov 18, promoted R9 after its ordinary check advanced through benefit, actual layout, reference token forcing, stock-teacher replay, Megatron train/inference mismatch and teacher scoring to the training record. The only pending side is the independently full-checked R4 training code, byte-for-byte identical. All three submitted Git HEADs and switch-file bytes match the running ordinary check; clean worktrees. Overall PASS not yet reported at this point. - R9 ordinary full/tmp/r9/check/check.json: PASS N1 at 03:58:50 Nov 18, 1.4551x projected step, bar 1.1376. Rollout 1.2634x (59.700/60.476/59.755 s), teacher 0.9935x (unchanged score math), training 1.7966x (40.408/41.492/39.825 s). Layout and all three sides passed. Student forcing mean-|d| ratio 0.9927, sampler t 1.54; rollout mismatch ratio 0.9903, train mismatch ratio 1.0, update cosine 0.99064 vs 0.95660 minimum. Submission already byte-for-byte identical to this checked trial. Final integrated timing is not available to the agent. - Independent R9 quick/tmp/r9/quick/check.jsoncompleted 04:08:40: PASS N1, all three sides again. Rollout/train mismatch ratios 0.9989/1.0; update-direction cosine 0.99464.
7.2 hRound 10 — teacher prefill collectives
- 02:17:24 Nov 18 queued fresh current-best teacher profiling after R9's timed rollout starts: PID 716386,/tmp/r10/profile.log,/tmp/r10/profile. The earlier R2 prefill trace had 20.7% all-reduce and 4.0% separate residual+norm. R2's shorter prefill chunks used the available fused path at the expense of GEMM throughput. Inspect whether keeping normal chunks while sizing the fused collective workspace for them can recover the reduction without sacrificing GEMM packing. Trial checkout/tmp/r10/tree; no implementation before the new profile. - R10 fresh/tmp/r10/profile/profile.jsonokat 02:41:09: 92.8% GPU busy, leading GEMMs 43.7%/7.9%, BF16 TP all-reduce 21.3% (median 209.7 us), separate residual+RMSNorm 4.0%, vocab all-gather 3.5%. Trial adds an optional per-server token ceiling for the existing FlashInfer fused reduction; both its dispatch guard and startup workspace use that ceiling. Only the teacher receives--flashinfer-allreduce-max-tokens 4096viaOPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS, leaving its GEMM chunk size unchanged at 4096 and student workspace at 2048. Default is the original limit. CPU CLI parser test and syntax/diff checks passed.time --side teacherPID 765838 (/tmp/r10/time.log,/tmp/r10/time), conditional quick PID 765839 (/tmp/r10/quick.log,/tmp/r10/quick) launched 02:44:12. The quick waits for the previous rollout precision check to avoid delaying it. - Round 10 closed at 03:06:05 Nov 18, within the 03:06:51 cap. Trial teacher timing remains queued behind R9's ordinary check; append its outcome rather than extrapolating from the profile. R4 is still the submitted version. - R10 timing acquired the lock at 03:23:34 and/tmp/r10/time/time.jsoncompleted 03:26:36:ok, layout correct, windows 18.874/18.844/18.479 s, 0.9679x teacher / 0.9965x projected step. Teacher logs confirm all four ranks initialized 4096-token workspaces. Reject on benefit; using the fused collective with larger matrices was slower in every window. Isolated commit6dce8d6; deferred quick still scheduled. R9's fresh profile acquired the lock at 02:06:37 (CPU attribution PID 672983) and R10's at 02:36:51.
7.7 hRound 11 — vocabulary backward rematerialization
- Archived R4 module attribution/tmp/r11/r4-logprobs.log: 64_ChunkedLogProbEntropyforward calls (2.15% of kernel duration) and 64 backward calls (2.52%), including repeated TP reductions, sub/exp/sum/div and gradient multiplies. The existing backward explicitly repeats forward to avoid retaining the softmax. CPU-only two-rank Gloo test/tmp/r11/cpu_logprobs.py,/tmp/r11/cpu-logprobs.log: keeping the same original row chunks and their native differentiable outputs exactly preserved selected logprobs, entropy metrics and all input gradients across six BF16/FP32 cases. Fresh current-best judge training profile PID 777118,/tmp/r11/profile.log,/tmp/r11/profile, scheduled at 02:48:13 only after an R9 correctness verdict; do not delay the actionable rollout verdict. No new trial code until the fresh profile. - R11 current-best profile acquired the lock at 04:08:26 Nov 18; round cap 04:38:26. Profile uses the fully checked R9 tree/config. The training-only experimental tree has identical actor source and isolates the next change; combined verification if it merits promotion. R10's rejected teacher candidate's deferred quick is queued. - R11's fresh best-version trace/tmp/r11/profile-logprobs.log: 64 calls each; native chunked forward 2.87%, backward 2.91% of all kernel duration. Backward alone launched 681.5 ms of TP communication and repeated the forward row maxima, exponentials, sums and divisions. Trial changes only eligible differentiable plain-vocabulary, non-entropy-gradient training: native vocabulary probabilities retained for the same row chunks instead of recomputing them in backward. Uses original entropy metric, FP32 reductions, target scoring and gradient formula.SLIME_RETAIN_VOCAB_SOFTMAX=1, off by default. Two-rank Gloo check re-run on the production helper (/tmp/r11/production-cpu.log) was exactly equal on forward values, entropy and gradients. Syntax and diff passed. At 04:22:57 submitted judgetime --side train, PID 924473 (/tmp/r11/time.log,/tmp/r11/time); conditional quick PID 924474 (/tmp/r11/quick.log,/tmp/r11/quick). No submitted code changed. - R11 official/tmp/r11/profile/profile.jsoncompletedokat 04:35:28: 356,119 kernels, GPU busy 62.9%, NCCL all-gather 14.9%, largest two GEMMs 6.2%/6.0%, reduce-scatter 6.0%. Independent HF wrapper attribution/tmp/r13/r9-wrapper.logidentified another future direction, not included in this trial: only movement outside the replicated norm/GDN consumes 7.71% forward + 4.55% backward (NCCL and rebuilding disjoint chunk gradients). R11 closed 04:36:00, before its cap; timing had acquired the lock at 04:32:39. Keep R9 submitted. - R11/tmp/r11/time/time.jsonfinished 04:44:02 Nov 18,ok: 1.8184x train / 1.2710x projected, windows 40.821/40.107/39.315 s (mean 40.081), timed first uses 0, layout correct, first-step mismatch precisely reference. Against R4's independent 40.561 s mean this saves ~0.48 s, but R4's ordinary full-check training mean was 40.166 s; small incremental benefit relative to noise. Leave it isolated, pending correctness and clearer combined evidence. Trial commit2323461f. - R11 quick/tmp/r11/quick/check.jsonfinished 05:00:28 Nov 18: PASS N1, first-gradient norm 0.996685 vs 0.996736 reference, update cosine 0.993790, mismatch ratio 1.0. Do not promote this small screen difference without a convincing combined timing result.
9.1 hRound 12 — remaining rollout scheduling overhead
- Fresh profile of the submitted R9 rollout is queued behind R11 timing, PID 914906 (/tmp/r12/profile.log,/tmp/r12/profile); CPU trace accounting PID 914907 (/tmp/r12/profile-sync.log). The previous student profile included a now-eliminated mandatory host wait; do not reuse its idle fraction to claim another bottleneck. Inspect the new trace for scheduling/transfer overhead and consider the existing non-draft deferred-sampling path before writing kernels. R12 clone matches R9; no switch changes yet. - R12 fresh R9 rollout profile acquired GPU at 04:43:49 Nov 18 (cap 05:13:49). - R12 current-best rollout profile/tmp/r12/profile/profile.jsoncompletedokat 04:50:34: the 200 formerany().item()host waits are gone (/tmp/r12/profile-sync.log), instrumented GPU busy 57.8%, largest GEMM 20.2%, GDN ~10%, under-filled per-row softmax 1.5%. Hostscheduler.process_batch_resultspans total 277 ms across 199 calls in the 1.58 s profiled interval; 400 routine GPU→host result copies. Chose to screen the existing non-draftSGLANG_ENABLE_DELAY_SAMPLE=1scheduling path, running the very same sampler after processing the preceding batch. No code changes, no change to sampling distribution or FP arithmetic. Timing PID 970861 (/tmp/r12/time.log,/tmp/r12/time) and deferred independent quick PID 970862 (/tmp/r12/quick.log,/tmp/r12/quick) launched 04:52:30. Precision waits for R10's preceding quick to finish.
9.6 hRound 13 — packed TP/CP activation movement (queued)
- CPU attribution of the already completed R11 best-version trace found 1,920 HF wrapper spans with 12.26% of kernel duration *outside* the replicated input norm and GDN body. Future trial will keep the entire norm, convolution, recurrence and every GEMM and parameter gradient intact. Explore carrying directly indexed packed tokens across TP/CP instead of gathering and slicing them twice, and reducing only each TP rank's consumed input-gradient rows in CP backward. This is distinct from rejected R5, which changed GDN projections and reductions. Scheduled fresh training profile after R12's timed rollout starts, PID 956859 (/tmp/r13/profile.log,/tmp/r13/profile); CPU wrapper accounting PID 956860 (/tmp/r13/profile-wrapper.log). No source change before that profile. - Prepared CPU-only distributed oracle/tmp/r13/test_packed.py; the unchanged HF wrapper's outputs, input gradients and projection gradients repeat exactly for FP32/BF16, three unequal layouts, both TP-major and CP-major rank orders, four Gloo ranks, non-identical per-rank upstream gradients./tmp/r13/reference-cpu-fixed.log. The first attempt exposed PyTorch's Gloo list-all-gather backward using global rather than subgroup ranks; the CPU stand-in now uses the same list gather + sum reduce-scatter as the CUDA reference, using native Gloo tensor collectives. Candidate comparison will be a separate run after the fresh profile. Design: gather each local SP/CP block once into the joint group; invert gathered global token-position IDs on device once per packed batch (no group-order assumption); CP-backward reduce-scatter only the rows the original TP split consumes. Keep every molecule of the GDN body untouched, and assemble the exact original full-output gradient with TP gather and indexed writes.