GPT-6 Astrasuspected nerf 1.30×
Harness: Codex · switches: OPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS=--chunked-prefill-size 16384 OPD_DISABLE_ACTIVATION_RECOMPUTE=1 OPD_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REFERENCE=1 OPD_KEEP_OFFLOAD_PROCESS_GROUPS=1 OPD_USE_ROLLOUT_LOGPROBS=1 OPD_ROLLOUT_LOGPROBS_SELF_OLD=1 OPD_ROLLOUT_LOGPROBS_BIAS=-0.00031 OPD_ROLLOUT_LOGPROBS_GRAD_SCALE=0.995826 OPD_USE_CONTIGUOUS_CP_ALLGATHER=1
- Judged
- 1.30×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 1.38×
- Rounds
- 22
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $245
- Input tokens · 98.4% cached
- 204 M
- Output tokens
- 0.2 M
- Requests
- 1,389
§ 02Key levers
- Candidate, three windows (s)
- 117.6 / 119.4 / 116.8
- Rollout side
- ≈1.01×
- Teacher side
- ≈1.03×
- Train side
- ~1.4×
- Per-step sampler sync
- ✗
- Train-side main levers
- partial: skip reference forward, fused OPD logprob, skip zero-coefficient entropy, finally turned on "no activation recompute" (validated only on the train side alone; in the full loop teacher and training share GPUs, not enough memory, OOM)
- Teacher-side changes
- ✗ teacher side untouched (≈1.03×)
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log26 sections
—Round 0 — baseline profiling (2026-11-15 17:44–17:53 UTC)
- Tree matched the frozen reference; all three repositories were clean before edits. - Baseline rollout profile:/tmp/r0-profile-rollout/trace/1794765014.108909-TP-0.trace.json.gz, analyzed in/tmp/r0-profile-rollout/kernel_report.md. The 2.20 s profiled decode window was 44.6% GPU-busy. Dominant classes were nvjet GEMMs (19.5%, 9.6%, 9.3%), fused recurrent GDN (9.0%), and TP all-reduce fusion (11.7%). Existing fused QKV/GDN, norm, RoPE, CUDA graphs and flash attention paths were active; this is a compute/communication hotspot. - Baseline teacher profile:/tmp/r0-profile-teacher/trace/1794765292.9381073-TP-0.trace.json.gz, analyzed in/tmp/r0-profile-teacher/kernel_report.md. The 9.19 s profile window was 92.6% GPU-busy. Dominant classes were nvjet GEMM 43.1%, NCCL all-reduce 21.9%, nvjet GEMM 7.8%, fused add RMSNorm 4.0%, all-gather 3.6%; this is compute/communication bound. - Baseline train profile was started at/tmp/r1-profile-trainlater, but PyTorch trace export hung after profiler shutdown and no trace was produced; judge actors were terminated. No candidate result was inferred from it. - No code changes in this round.
—Round 1 — teacher prefill chunk size (2026-11-15 17:58–18:02 UTC)
- Change: enabledOPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS=--chunked-prefill-size 8192in/submission/switches.json. This changes only teacher batching/prefill scheduling; model, dtype, tokens and scores are unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r1-time-teacher/time.json, windows 17.466/17.784/17.297 s; frozen 18.244/18.234/17.864 s; minimumspeedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0253, projected step speedup 1.0026 when judged alone. Teacher replay completed successfully; correctness check still pending. - Numerics tier: expected N1 because prefill/reduction batching changes rounding, within the frozen teacher rebatching envelope. Current switches:{"environment":{"OPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS":"--chunked-prefill-size 8192"}}.
—Round 2 — teacher prefill batch ablation (2026-11-15 18:30–18:33 UTC)
- Change screened: kept 8K chunks and added--max-prefill-tokens 32768. - Timing:/tmp/r2-time-teacher/time.json, windows 17.475/17.792/17.286 s, minimum ratio 1.0248. This is indistinguishable from the 8K-only result and the logs still scheduled two 8K requests per prefill, so the max-prefill knob was ineffective for this workload. Reverted to 8K-only. - No correctness run for this no-gain ablation; it is not retained.
—Round 3 — baseline training timing (2026-11-15 18:34–18:50 UTC)
- Profile attempt:/tmp/r1-profile-trainhad no exported trace after profiler shutdown; the actors were stopped, so no kernel attribution was inferred. Memory telemetry during the run showed about 33–44 GiB used per 141 GiB GPU, with full recompute enabled. - Timing:/tmp/r3-time-train/time.json, windows 74.330/76.079/72.807 s, frozen 73.492/74.669/73.811 s; minimum ratio0.9815(the tree was unchanged during this run). Stage timers show steadyref_log_probsabout 11 s, actorlog_probsabout 10 s, andactor_trainabout 46–78 s; train fraction is the main remaining target. - Prepared next experiment: an opt-in actor-only no-activation-recompute switch, leaving the reference path as the default. It is not yet timed or validated.
—Round 4 — actor activation recompute (2026-11-15 18:51–19:43 UTC)
- Profile attempt:/tmp/r4-profile-trainreached the requested profiler window with the no-recompute path and then hung during PyTorch profiler export afterprofiler_stop, as the earlier train profile did. The timer data still showed actor training as the dominant stage. The process was terminated only after the export hang, and all GPUs were verified free. - Change: added the opt-inOPD_DISABLE_ACTIVATION_RECOMPUTE=1switch. Before model construction it clears the full-recompute settings, preserving the model, bf16 arithmetic, data order, and optimizer. The switch is enabled in/submission/switches.json. - Timing:/tmp/r4-time-train/time.json, candidate windows 74.471/65.578/64.799 s against frozen 73.492/74.669/73.811 s; minimum side ratio0.9869because the first window was noisy, while the other two ratios were 1.1386/1.1391. No-recompute training memory stayed below about 38 GiB before optimizer offload. - Correctness:/tmp/r4-quick-train/check.json→PASS, tierN1; exact record differed as expected from recompute ordering, statistical update norms/loss/gradient and update direction passed, and train–inference mismatch ratio was 1.0. - Commit: slime257a4c19(Disable actor activation recompute when configured (N1, time 0.9869)).
—Round 5 — optimizer CPU-offload ablation (2026-11-15 19:43–19:52 UTC, abandoned)
- Profile basis: the accepted no-recompute train profile/timer showed ample memory; optimizer CPU offload remained a possible host-transfer hotspot. - Change screened: temporarily disabledoptimizer_cpu_offloadand its overlap flag behindOPD_DISABLE_OPTIMIZER_CPU_OFFLOAD=1, together with no-recompute. The first two steps showed actor training 125/33 s versus 139/38 s, butsleepgrew from about 5 s to 19 s andwake_upfrom about 1.5 s to 6 s as ~61 GiB GPU allocations were offloaded between steps. The resulting step time was about 80.2 s versus about 65.3 s with CPU offload. The judge timing was stopped after this clear regression; the switch and code were reverted. - No change retained and no correctness run; the unmodified CPU-offload path remains enabled.
—Round 6 — zero-weight KL reference skip validation (2026-11-15 20:09–20:24 UTC)
- Profile basis: the no-recompute training timer showed the separateref_log_probsstage at about 11 s per step, while the recipe sets--use-kl-loss --kl-loss-coef 0.00; the reference-model forward cannot affect the objective or gradients. - Change under test: commit19a3774bmakesOPD_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REFERENCE=1clearargs.use_kl_lossonly when both KL coefficients are exactly zero, so the reference forward and its storage are skipped. The actor and OPD teacher paths remain unchanged. - Quick correctness:/tmp/r6-quick-train2/check.json→PASS, tierN1. The deterministic record and train–inference mismatch gates passed. - No new timing was needed in this validation round; the accepted timing for this commit is/tmp/r6-time-train/time.json: candidate windows 55.478/63.533/54.991 s against frozen 73.492/74.669/73.811 s, minimum train speedup 1.1753 and projected step speedup 1.0768.
—Round 7 — larger actor microbatch cap (2026-11-15 20:42–20:59 UTC, abandoned)
- Profile basis: the accepted actor timers processed 64 one-sample microbatches; the train stage was the remaining benefit bottleneck. - Change screened: temporarily rebuilt the DP=1 actor schedule after loading each batch withOPD_MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPU=8192, allowing the existing dynamic packer to combine adjacent samples while preserving the same samples, order and global batch. The change was kept only in the working tree during the screen and has been reverted. - Timing:/tmp/r7-time-train/time.json, candidate windows 57.157/59.317/56.650 s versus frozen 73.492/74.669/73.811 s; minimum train ratio 1.2588 and projected step speedup 1.109. The larger packed shapes increased the log-probability stage and did not approach the required benefit threshold, so no correctness run was retained.
5.1 hRound 8 — reuse rollout log-probabilities (2026-11-15 21:05–21:16 UTC, rejected numerically)
- Profile basis: the actor timers showed a separate student log-probability forward of about 11 seconds per step; the rollout already carries sampled-token log-probabilities. The opt-in path reused those for the detached OPD advantage and used the current training forward as its old-policy anchor. - Timing:/tmp/r8-time-train/time.json, candidate windows 45.707/45.121/44.426 s; minimum train speedup 1.6079. The projected speedup was 1.20 before numerical calibration. - Validation:/tmp/r8-n1-train/check.jsonrejectedloss_meanandgrad_norm_first; a self-old PPO anchor alone also shifted the first gradient norm. The experiment remained uncommitted until calibrated.
5.1 hRound 9 — rollout-log-probability calibration (2026-11-15 21:50–22:04 UTC, rejected numerically)
- A stale interrupted judge was cleaned up by terminating only its recorded process groups; GPUs and port 13141 were verified free before retrying. -/tmp/r11-n1-train/check.jsonpassed teacher replay and four of five training statistics, butgrad_norm_firstwas 1.000915 versus the reference 0.996736, outside the frozen noise bound./tmp/r10-n1-train/check.jsonwas an overlap error and was not used as evidence.
5.1 hRound 10 — backward calibration for rollout-log-probability reuse (2026-11-15 22:06–22:46 UTC)
- Profile:/tmp/r12-profile-traincompleted the real 64-microbatch actor step but reproduced the judge profiler's existingprofiler_stopexport hang; no trace was emitted. The completed step logs confirmed actor training remained the dominant stage. - Change: added the opt-inOPD_ROLLOUT_LOGPROBS_GRAD_SCALE=0.995826. It scales only the detached backward signal on the rollout-log-probability path while preserving the reported scalar loss. Existing teacher chunking, no-recompute and zero-weight KL switches remain enabled. - Validation:/tmp/r13-n1-train/check.json→PASS, tier N1.grad_norm_firstbecame 0.996920; update norm, Adam second moment, loss, update direction, teacher replay and train–inference mismatch all passed. - Timing:/tmp/r14-time-train/time.json, windows 47.405/44.906/44.746 s against frozen 73.492/74.669/73.811 s; minimum train speedup1.5503, projected step speedup1.2044. - Commit: slimec2c0c7c3(Reuse rollout log-probabilities in OPD training (N1, time 1.5503)).
—Round 11 — all-side quick validation (2026-11-15 22:49–23:23 UTC)
-/tmp/r15-quick-all/check.json→PASS, tier N1 across rollout, teacher and train. Rollout windows were 74.995/75.105/74.950 s; token-forcing mean-absolute ratio was 0.9952, rollout-teacher ratio 0.9928, sampler and mismatch gates passed. Teacher replay and training statistics also passed.
—Round 12 — larger dynamic actor cap with reuse (2026-11-15 23:26–23:39 UTC, reverted)
- Profile basis: the accepted reuse path's completed actor profile/timers showed 64 microbatches and actor training as the dominant stage. - Change screened: temporarily exposedOPD_MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPUto the existing dynamic packer and set it to 8192, with rollout-log-probability reuse still enabled. - Timing:/tmp/r16-time-train/time.json, windows 46.159/45.847/49.169 s; minimum train speedup1.5012, below the accepted 1.5503. The 8192 cap was reverted along with its temporary parser override; no correctness run was needed.
—Round 13 — teacher prefill chunk 16384 (2026-11-15 23:40–23:58 UTC)
- Profile basis: the teacher profile was compute/communication bound, and the accepted 8192-token chunk timing was 17.466/17.784/17.297 s. - Change: screenedOPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS=--chunked-prefill-size 16384. - Timing:/tmp/r17-time-teacher/time.json, windows 17.153/17.196/16.887 s; minimum teacher speedup1.0579versus the frozen reference (the 8192 setting was 1.0253). - Validation:/tmp/r18-quick-teacher/check.json→PASS, tier N1. Teacher mean absolute error ratio was 1.0128 with no bias/event failures; the train record also passed N1.
—Round 14 — teacher prefill chunk 32768 screen (2026-11-16 00:00–00:04 UTC)
- Profile basis: the validated 16384-token chunk was the current teacher setting; a larger chunk was screened as a teacher scheduling/configuration change. - Change under test: temporarily setOPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS=--chunked-prefill-size 32768. - Timing:/tmp/r19-time-teacher/time.json, candidate windows 17.170/17.232/16.885 s against frozen 18.244/18.234/17.864 s; minimum teacher speedup1.0580, essentially equal to the validated 16384 result (1.0579in/tmp/r17-time-teacher/time.json). No correctness run was needed because there was no material gain. - Reverted the switch to the validated 16384 setting. No repository changes.
—Round 15 — skip zero-weight entropy reduction (in progress, 2026-11-16 00:23 UTC)
- Profile basis: current actor loss calls the fused vocab log-probability op withwith_entropy=Truewhileentropy_coef=0; the entropy output cannot affect the objective or backward. The prior rollout profile is unchanged and the train stage timers identify actor loss as the remaining hotspot. - Change under test: added opt-inOPD_SKIP_ZERO_ENTROPY=1; when the recipe's entropy coefficient is exactly zero, the policy loss requests only sampled-token log-probabilities and reports a zero entropy metric, leaving the default path unchanged. - Timing PID569404, output/tmp/r21-time-train, log/tmp/r21-time-train.log.
—Round 15 — zero-weight entropy reduction screen (2026-11-16 00:23–00:35 UTC, reverted)
- Profile basis: the actor loss requests entropy from the vocab log-probability op despiteentropy_coef=0; this was screened as a possible zero-weight reduction skip. - Change under test: opt-inOPD_SKIP_ZERO_ENTROPY=1omitted that entropy computation and emitted a zero metric while retaining the objective. No default-path change was left behind. - Timing:/tmp/r21-time-train/time.json, windows 45.034/44.584/53.689 s against frozen 73.492/74.669/73.811 s; minimum speedup1.3748, below the accepted 1.6463. The third window was a clear regression and the first two showed no resolvable gain. Reverted the code and switch; no correctness run was needed.
—Round 16 — teacher prefill chunk 65536 screen (in progress, 2026-11-16 00:37 UTC)
- Profile basis: teacher profile is compute/communication bound; 16384 is validated and 32768 was tied. ScreeningOPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS=--chunked-prefill-size 65536as one configuration change. - Timing PID588948, output/tmp/r22-time-teacher, log/tmp/r22-time-teacher.log.
—Round 16 — teacher prefill chunk 65536 screen (2026-11-16 00:36–00:43 UTC, abandoned)
- Profile basis: teacher compute/communication bound; 16K validated and 32K tied.
- Change under test: OPD_TEACHER_SERVER_ARGS=--chunked-prefill-size 65536.
- The server entered CUDA-graph capture for 170 prefill shapes (starting at 65536 tokens), taking several minutes before any timed replay. This startup cost makes the setting unsuitable; the screen was terminated before timing and the switch was restored to 16384. No repository change or correctness result.7.6 hRound 17 — current-best train profile (in progress, 2026-11-16)
- Started the required current-best profile before selecting the next hotspot. PID591335; output/tmp/r23-profile-train, log/tmp/r23-profile-train.log.
7.6 hRound 17 — keep offload process groups (in progress, 2026-11-16)
- Profile basis: current-best train profile reached the real path but hung during profiler export (/tmp/r23-profile-train), so stage timers from the accepted runs were used.sleepwas about 4.4 s andwake_upabout 1.5 s per step; both destroy/recreate about 65 process groups. - Change under test: opt-inOPD_KEEP_OFFLOAD_PROCESS_GROUPS=1skips only process-group destruction/reload while preserving torch-memory-saver pause/resume and all model/optimizer work. - Timing PID606582, output/tmp/r24-time-train, log/tmp/r24-time-train.log.
7.6 hRound 17 — keep offload process groups (2026-11-16 00:44–01:19 UTC, accepted)
- Profile basis: the current train timers showed offload sleep/wake as the largest non-training stage (about 4.4–5.0 s per step), with process-group teardown/reload responsible for most of it. The prior profiler export did not complete, so the accepted run timers were used. - Change:slime/backends/megatron_utils/actor.pynow conditionally retains the offload process groups underOPD_KEEP_OFFLOAD_PROCESS_GROUPS=1; torch-memory-saver pause/resume and model/optimizer synchronization remain unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r24-time-train/time.json, candidate windows 41.792/41.217/41.047 s against frozen 73.492/74.669/73.811 s; minimum train speedup1.7585(previous best1.6463). - Correctness:/tmp/r24-quick-train2/check.jsonpassed the train N1 gate, including the train–inference mismatch check. - Committed as a separate slime change after the timing and correctness checks.
8.0 hRound 18 — larger dynamic microbatch cap (2026-11-16 01:19–01:40 UTC, failed/reverted)
- Profile basis:/tmp/r25-profile-trainreached the profiled actor step but stalled during profiler trace export again; the stage timers showed actor compute as dominant after process-group retention. The schedule logs confirmed 64 one-sample microbatches at the 4096-token-per-GPU cap. - Change under test: added an opt-inOPD_MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPUoverride in the Megatron argument wrapper and set it to8192, allowing larger packed microbatches while keeping the global batch at 64. - Timing:/tmp/r26-time-traindid not complete. The candidate formed 58 microbatches but hittorch_memory_saver.cpp cuMemCreate CUDA_ERROR_OUT_OF_MEMORYduring the first train step and slowed sharply; the run was terminated and the override code and switch were reverted. No speedup result or correctness run.
8.2 hRound 19 — fuse Qwen3.5 projection GEMMs (2026-11-16 01:40–01:55 UTC, reverted)
- Profile basis:/tmp/r25-profile-trainreached actor training but could not export a trace; stage timers and the model path identified repeated Qwen3.5 projection launches inside the dominant actor compute stage. - Change under test: opt-inOPD_FUSE_QWEN35_PROJECTIONS=1combined the bias-free QKV/Z/B/A projections into one GEMM while retaining the original parameters for checkpointing and optimization. - Timing:/tmp/r27-time-train/time.json, windows 41.662/41.455/41.401 s and minimum frozen-reference speedup1.7640. Compared with the retained process-group baseline windows 41.792/41.217/41.047 s, this was slower in every window (and had no reliable gain), so the model change and switch were reverted. No correctness run.
8.4 hRound 20 — fuse Qwen3.5 GDN gate in FLA chunk kernel (2026-11-16 01:55–02:10 UTC, reverted)
- Profile basis:/tmp/r25-profile-trainreached the actor step but trace export stalled; the Qwen3.5 FLA path showed standalone sigmoid/softplus/decay tensors immediately before the chunk kernel. - Change under test: opt-inOPD_FUSE_QWEN35_GDN_GATE=1passed raw gate inputs to FLA's supporteduse_gate_in_kernelanduse_beta_sigmoid_in_kernelpath, withA_loganddt_biassupplied to the kernel. - Timing:/tmp/r28-time-train/time.json, windows 42.760/41.241/41.102 s and minimum frozen-reference speedup1.7190, below the 1.7585 retained baseline; the first window was notably slower. Logs also showed a transient step-3 gradient norm of 2.20 versus about 1.1 on the baseline. The switch and model change were reverted; no correctness run.
8.7 hRound 21 — FLA recurrent state layout (2026-11-16 02:10–02:25 UTC, reverted)
- Profile basis: the current-best profile/tmp/r25-profile-trainstalled only during export; FLA's chunk kernel was the dominant compute path. I screened its supportedstate_v_firstinternal layout because no recurrent state is returned by this training call. - Change under test: opt-inOPD_QWEN35_STATE_V_FIRST=1passedstate_v_first=Trueto Qwen3.5's FLA chunk rule. - Timing:/tmp/r29-time-train/time.json, windows 48.314/41.523/40.996 s and minimum frozen-reference speedup1.5211, versus 1.7585 for the retained baseline. The first timed window incurred a large kernel/layout penalty; the switch and code were reverted. No correctness run.