Claude Opus 5.5 2.35×
Harness: Claude Code · switches: OPT_SAMPLER_NOSYNC=1 OPT_TOPK_B64_ONLY=1 OPT_TOPK_FAST=1 OPT_SKIP_DEAD_REF=1 OPT_SKIP_REDUNDANT_RESTORE=1 OPT_NO_RECOMPUTE=1 OPT_TRAIN_CPU_THREADS=16 OPT_FAST_COMM_CHECK=1 OPT_PIN_FP32_MASTER=1 OPT_KEEP_TRAIN_RESIDENT=1 OPT_SGLANG_MEM_FRACTION=0.25 OPT_KEEP_ROLLOUT_RESIDENT=1 OPT_GDN_BWD_SPLIT=2
- Judged
- 2.35×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 2.48×
- Rounds
- 7
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $87.7
- Input tokens · 99.5% cached
- 288 M
- Output tokens
- 0.9 M
- Requests
- 648
§ 02Key levers
- Candidate, three windows (s)
- 79.2 / 78.0 / 77.7
- Rollout side
- 2.42×
- Train side
- 2.15×
- Rollout host-side fixes
- ✓ sampler desync, only compact base64 top-k returned (post-rollout tail 28 → 2 s), top-k copied back once per step
- Skip zero-coefficient reference forward
- ✓
- Train-side main levers
- ✓ no recompute, 16 CPU threads, free memory queried once before comm, pinned fp32 master weights, training process and rollout engine both resident (no more per-step sleep / wake), GDN backward split by token across 4 GPUs (forward unchanged); train window 66.2 → 30.9 s (2.15×), highest train side overall
Round 7 also measured a fused sampling kernel + round-robin routing (rollout 2.51×) and weight sync directly from on-GPU params (train 2.17×); its own full loop ~74 s/step; quick check didn't finish before time ran out, not committed
§ 03Step by step
| Round | Change | Measured | Step | Side, cumulative | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rollout side | |||||
| 1 | sampler device sync removed + only compact base64 top-k returned + top-k copied back once per step (measured together with three train-side items) | rollout-side speedup: — → 2.42 | ×2.42 | 2.42× | kept |
| 4 | Triton small-matrix decode GEMM | — | — | — | reverted |
| 7 | fused sampling kernel (single-pass Gumbel-max + top-k) | rollout-side speedup: 2.42 → 2.38 | ×0.98 | 2.38× | measured; quick check didn't finish before time ran out, not committed |
| 7 | routing switched to round-robin (32 requests on each of two engines) | rollout-side speedup: 2.38 → 2.5 | ×1.05 | 2.50× | measured; quick check didn't finish before time ran out, not committed |
| Train side | |||||
| 1 | skip zero-coefficient reference forward + skip redundant weight restore + no recompute (measured together with rollout side) | train-side speedup: — → 1.33 | ×1.33 | 1.33× | kept |
| 2 | GDN forward split by head | train-side speedup: 1.33 → 1.55 | ×1.16 | — | reverted |
| 2 | 16 CPU threads + free memory queried once before comm + pinned fp32 master weights | train-side speedup: 1.33 → 1.53 | ×1.15 | 1.53× | kept |
| 2 | GDN forward split by token | train-side speedup: 1.53 → 1.64 | ×1.07 | — | reverted |
| 3 | training process resident in GPU memory (no more per-step sleep / wake) + engine memory fraction 0.55 | train-side speedup: 1.53 → 1.84 | ×1.20 | 1.84× | kept |
| 5 | rollout engine also resident + memory fraction 0.25 | train-side speedup: 1.84 → 1.89 | ×1.02 | 1.89× | kept |
| 6 | GDN backward split by token across 4 GPUs (forward unchanged) | train-side speedup: 1.89 → 2.15 | ×1.14 | 2.15× | kept |
| 7 | weight sync directly from on-GPU params (saves the per-step backup) | train-side speedup: 2.15 → 2.17 | ×1.01 | 2.17× | measured; quick check didn't finish before time ran out, not committed |
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log7 sections
0.2 hRound 1 — 2026-11-16 18:39 → 2026-11-16 20:28
Profiled the unchanged reference. - Rollout profile/tmp/r1/profile_rollout(200 decode steps, TP0 of one engine): - GPU busy (union of kernels) = 30.6 % of the window; ≈5 ms of GPU work per decode step (bs≈32–35) vs ≈8.5–10 ms per step wall clock without the profiler (from sglang'sgen throughputlog lines). Decode is host-bound. - Top kernels: nvjet GEMMs ≈57 % of kernel time, trtllm allreduce fusion 10 %, GDN decode kernel 9.4 %. - Host side (python trace):Sampler.forward≈5.6 ms/step under the profiler, dominated byaten::item→cudaStreamSynchronize(sampler.py:return_top_p_log_probs.any().item()every step, although top-p replay is off) → the overlap scheduler cannot overlap result processing with the GPU.copy_result_to_cpudoes ≈70 per-request D2H copies per step for the top-128 log-probs, then.tolist()per request. - Rollout log timeline (bootstrap run, rollout 1): decode of all 64 samples ends ≈80 s after the start, but slime's rollout manager only completes the batch ≈28 s later: every /generate response carries, besides the compact base64 top-k that slime uses, the nestedoutput_top_logprobslist (8192×128[logprob, id, null]≈ 30 MB JSON per response, ≈2.4 GB per rollout) which slime parses withjson.loadsunder the GIL. - Train side (record-run log, steady state):ref_log_probsforward ≈11 s per step (KL coefficient is 0 → dead work by configuration), sleep (offload) ≈4.9 s, wake ≈1.3 s, actor_train ≈82 s in deterministic mode. - Train profile/tmp/r1/profile_trainstopped by me after ~35 min: the judge's train profile exports a >1.1 GB (gzip) trace per rank single-threaded and would then parse it; the per-step timers were enough. Steady-state train step (steps 2 and 4 of the profile run): ref forward 10.8–11.7 s, actor_train 45.7–47.8 s, sleep 4.5 s, wake 1.25 s, ≈3 s other. Observations from code reading: - GDN layers (24 of 32) use slime's "replicated" HF wrapper: every rank all-gathers the full sequence over TP and CP and runs the whole GDN layer with unsharded weights (4× redundant compute). Megatron's native TP/CP GDN changes parameter names/shapes (record gate requires them exact) → not usable as is. - Full activation recompute is on; memory allows keeping activations (≈35 GB estimated per GPU). - Changes (each behind its own env switch, off by default): -OPT_SAMPLER_NOSYNC(sglang sampler.py, sampling_batch_info.py): host-side flag replacesreturn_top_p_log_probs.any().item()→ no device sync per decode step. -OPT_TOPK_B64_ONLY(sglang tokenizer_manager.py): non-streaming requests without text return only the compact base64 top-k (no nestedoutput_top_logprobs). -OPT_TOPK_FAST(sglang logprob_processor.py, managers/utils.py, batch_result_processor.py, tokenizer_manager.py): one [bs,128] top-k tensor per step, one D2H copy, numpy rows instead of 70 D2H copies + per-rowtolist(). -OPT_SKIP_DEAD_REF(slime actor.py, loss.py): no reference model / ref forward when kl_coef = kl_loss_coef = 0. -OPT_SKIP_REDUNDANT_RESTORE(slime actor.py): skip the second CPU→GPU actor-weight restore per step. -OPT_NO_RECOMPUTE(slime megatron_utils/arguments.py): no full activation recompute. - Functional test of the 3 sglang switches (standalone server, 12 requests × 300 tokens,/tmp/r1/sgltest): base64 top-k sorted, distinct, sampled-token log-probs equal their top-k entries; response 422 KB per 300 tokens. -timewith all six switches (/tmp/r1/sw_r1.json): PID 116264, log/tmp/r1/time.log, out/tmp/r1/time. -timeresult (/tmp/r1/time/time.json, config/tmp/r1/sw_r1.json): rollout windows 45.57 / 45.96 / 45.84 s (ref 110.1 / 112.0 / 110.0) → 2.418×; train windows 48.99 / 53.50 / 47.18 s (ref 67.3 / 65.9 / 65.5) → 1.332×;projected_step_speedup1.795. first_use ≈0 in all windows. Train mismatch per step 0.0075–0.0105 (reference 0.0079, limit 2×). - Rollout log: decode ≈6000 tok/s per engine at 32 requests (was ≈3800), response tail ≈2 s (was ≈28 s). - Train log: steady actor_train 38–45 s (was ≈46 s + 11 s ref forward); sleep ≈4.2 s, wake ≈1.3 s unchanged. Window 2 (53.5 s) is noisy: actor_train 45.2 s for dump 2 whose first use took 38.3 s — to investigate. - Committed: sglang 70b0e6b (NOSYNC), 35f4e7d (B64_ONLY + TOPK_FAST); slime 075531bd (SKIP_DEAD_REF + SKIP_REDUNDANT_RESTORE), 7d136601 (NO_RECOMPUTE). - Prepared next (uncommitted, inert when off):OPT_GDN_SHARD(slime_plugins/models/qwen3_5.py): each of the 4 TP×CP ranks computes only its 8 of 32 GDN value heads (same replicated parameters, sliced rows/columns), partial out_proj outputs summed over TP×CP (backward: sum over CP), input gradient reduce-scattered over TP, GDN params flaggedsequence_parallelso Megatron sums their slice gradients over TP. 4-GPU unit test vs the replicated layer (/tmp/gdntest): rel. error out 3.5e-3, dx 5.1e-3, param grads 2.0–4.4e-3 (bf16 level). -check --quickon sw_r1.json: PID 162481, log/tmp/r1/quick.log, out/tmp/r1/quick. - Findings while the quick check runs (for the next rounds): - Ray setsOMP_NUM_THREADS=floor(num_cpus)=1inside the Megatron actors (ray/_private/utils.pyset_omp_num_threads_if_unset), so the CPU-offloaded fused AdamW runs single-threaded: ≈5.5–6 s per step between the last micro-batch and the step log. Fused CPU AdamW is bitwise identical for 1/7/16 threads (tested, 50M odd-sized params) and 16× faster with 16 threads → switchOPT_TRAIN_CPU_THREADS(actor.py) prepared. - Sleep ≈4 s = ≈2 s clear_memory + destroy NCCL WORLD, ≈2 s memory-saver pause; wake ≈1.2 s (recreates 65 groups, 58 NCCL); first micro-batch after wake ≈1.2 s (NCCL lazy init). Keeping NCCL alive across the memory-saver pause is unsafe as is (the saver remaps cudaMalloc'd buffers that NCCL peers may have IPC-mapped). - Rollout window now ≈1 s overhead + ≈44 s generation, GPU decode-bound (≈5.2 ms/step): GEMMs ≈3.1 ms/step at ≈3 TB/s, allreduce ≈0.57 ms, GDN decode ≈0.52 ms, sampler/top-k ≈0.45 ms (from the reference profile's kernels). - Entropy is already computed without grad upstream when entropy_coef = 0. - Diagnostic launcher for profiling only:/tmp/diag/run_diag.sh(snapshot of the tree, judge's launch.sh under the GPU lock);OPT_PROFILE_LIGHT=1(profile_utils.py) drops stacks/shapes/memory from slime's torch profiler. -check --quickon sw_r1: PASS, tier N1 (/tmp/r1/quick/check.json): token forcing mean |d| ratio 0.997 (events p=0.999, sampler t=0.34), top-k overlap-deficit ratio 1.008 / mean-abs ratio 1.004 (bias t=-1.57), rollout mismatch 0.0080 vs 0.0081; training record not bitwise (6396 differing tensors; the reference itself differs in 6388) → statistical gate passed. Quick-check rollout windows 45.96 / 45.70 / 46.01 s. - →/submission/switches.jsonset to sw_r1 (20:28). Round 1 end: 20:28.
1.8 hRound 2 — 2026-11-16 20:28 → 2026-11-17 01:04
Hotspot: train step (49.9 s mean window after round 1): CPU Adam single-threaded (≈5.5 s), GDN layers computed 4× redundantly (≈half of the per-GPU training FLOPs). -time --side trainwith sw_r2 (= sw_r1 +OPT_TRAIN_CPU_THREADS=16+OPT_GDN_SHARD=1): PID 218542, log/tmp/r2/time_train.log, out/tmp/r2/time_train. -time --side trainsw_r2 (/tmp/r2/time_train/time.json): windows 42.64 / 43.08 / 42.81 s → 1.546× (round 1: 1.332×). But not usable yet: step-0 grad_norm 0.0411 vs 0.0472 (reference record, repeat 0.0471) and 0.0471 (round 1), loss/mismatch unchanged → the sharded GDN backward/accounting differs in the real run although the 4-GPU unit test matched; investigating (thesequence_parallelflag does survive on all 240 GDN params). - Rank-0 timeline (sw_r2): fwd/bwd ≈30 s (round 1: 32–39 s), post-backward gap still ≈5 s, sleep 4.2–4.7 s. - py-spy on rank 0 over one train step (/tmp/r2/diag1/pyspy.raw, 2991 samples, 40 Hz): - 14% of samples inavailable_memory()called from slime's collective wrapper (reloadable_process_group.py_wrap_low_level_call) for every all_reduce/all_gather: twomemory_stats()dicts +mem_get_info+psutil.virtual_memory(), of which onlyfree_GBis used →OPT_FAST_COMM_CHECK(same decision, onlymem_get_info). - Optimizer:param_copy_back_gpu_hook→copy_≈130 samples vs_fused_adamw_≈54: the fp32 CPU masters are made by.float()after pinning → pageable → blocking staged H2D per parameter →OPT_PIN_FP32_MASTER(Megatron hybrid_optimizer.py: pin them; same tensors/values). - CPU threads (OPT_TRAIN_CPU_THREADS=16) only cut Adam itself (≈1.35 s left). - Diagnostic runs (replicated vs sharded GDN, aggregated grad-norm debugOPT_DEBUG_GRADNORM=1, + the two new switches):/tmp/r2/diag2,/tmp/r2/diag3(driver/tmp/r2/run_diag23.sh). - GDN-shard gradient investigation (diagnostic runs, 1–2 train steps,OPT_DEBUG_GRADNORM/OPT_DEBUG_GDN_GRAD): - Thesequence_parallelflag survives on all 240 GDN params; post-finalize GDN grads are identical on TP pairs (Megatron does sum them over TP). - Per-layer complete-gradient sums before finalize (/tmp/r2/diag4replicated vs/tmp/r2/diag5sharded): non-GDN grads of layers 24–31 match (sum of squares within 0.1–0.3%), but deviate toward the input (L16 −1%, L8 −9%, L4 −40%, L0 −49%); the last GDN layer's own param-grad sum differs by −15%. - flachunk_gated_delta_ruleis bitwise identical for 8 heads vs the same 8 heads inside 32 (T up to 16K). - In the real run the output gradient reaching the sharded layer's sum-over-ranks node is as designed (disjoint per-sequence zigzag chunks per CP rank before the CP all-reduce, identical full gradient after). - Next: inline replicated-vs-sharded comparison on real inputs/weights (/tmp/r2/diag8). - In-situ comparison inside the real run (/tmp/r2/diag8,/tmp/r2/diag9): replicated vs head-sharded layer on the same real inputs/weights, every micro-batch of step 0, layers 1 and 31: output rel. err ≈3.5e-3, dx ≈5–6e-3, every reduced param grad 2–7e-3 (bf16 level). Yet the trained step-0 grad norm is 0.0411 vs 0.0471, while steps 1–7 of the sw_r2 run are within run-to-run spread (e.g. 0.0628 vs 0.0630/0.0651). Dump 0 has only 2 non-zero-advantage groups and its score-centering correction differed by 14% → plausibly a noise-sensitive step amplifying the sharded layer's larger rounding noise (4 bf16-rounded partial out_proj outputs summed across ranks). Judge N1 tolerances (task/train_ref.json): update_norm ±0.54%, loss_mean ±1%, grad_norm_mean ±0.034, cos ≥ 0.955. → Head-shard parked (risky); wroteOPT_GDN_TOKEN_SHARDinstead: per-token work (input norm, 4 input projections, gated norm, out_proj) on own tokens only, recurrence on the full sequence exactly as the reference; no cross-rank partial sums in the forward. -time --side trainsw_r2b (= sw_r1 +OPT_TRAIN_CPU_THREADS=16+OPT_FAST_COMM_CHECK=1+OPT_PIN_FP32_MASTER=1,/tmp/r2/time_train_b/time.json): windows 43.75 / 43.24 / 43.05 s → 1.528× (round 1: 1.332×). Step-0 loss bitwise equal to round 1, grad_norm 0.04709 (ref 0.0472/0.0471): neutral as designed. Projected step speedup with round-1 rollout (2.418×): ≈1.915×. - None of my checks run the colocated full RL loop (only the final evaluation does) → diagnostic full-loop run with the sw_r2b switches:/tmp/r2/full1(3 RL steps, forced lengths). - Token-shard 4-GPU unit test (/tmp/gdntest/test_gdn_token_shard.py, LENS 1024,2560 and 8320,384): output vs replicated 1.2–1.6e-4 (head-shard 3.5e-3), dx 3.4–4.7e-4, recurrence params ≤3.4e-4 (dt_bias bitwise), projection-weight grads 2.35e-3 (bf16 rounding of per-rank partial sums); per-token max errors 2e-3 / 4.8e-3. - Full-loop diagnostic/tmp/r2/full1(sw_r2b switches, 3 RL steps): runs cleanly; mismatch 0.0080/0.0081/0.0073 (ref 0.0079); steady RL step ≈94 s from slime's timers (rollout 45.6, actor_train 38.0, extras ≈11: sleep 3.9, weight sync 2.0, wake 1.3, preprocess 0.4, sglang offload/onload + orchestration ≈3). →/submission/switches.jsonset to sw_r2b (22:25), commits Megatron 'hybrid optimizer: pin…', slime 'collective wrapper…', 'megatron actor: set the CPU thread count…'. -time --side trainsw_r2c (sw_r2b +OPT_GDN_TOKEN_SHARD=1,/tmp/r2/time_train_c): windows 39.49 / 41.53 / 40.14 s → 1.641×. But step-0 grad_norm 0.0410 again (as the head-shard), and later steps drift (step 2: 0.046 vs 0.034). Common to both sharded variants: replicated weights with per-rank partial grads summed over TP through Megatron's sequence-parallel all-reduce; the numbers fit "averaged instead of summed". Test:OPT_GDN_OWN_TPSUM=1(slime finalize wrapper sums flaggedtp_partial_gradmain grads over TP before Megatron's finalize) →/tmp/r2/diag11. - Grad-norm investigation, continued (1-step diagnostics on dump 0, token-shard unless noted): - own TP sum (OPT_GDN_OWN_TPSUM) 0.04102 = Megatron's mechanism; no TP sum 0.0391 → the sum takes effect. - 6.5 GiB fp32 NCCL all-reduce exact under default and Ring (/tmp/nccltest). - Record-style run (/tmp/r2/rec_c, judge's hook +NCCL_ALGO=Ring+CUBLAS_WORKSPACE_CONFIG): step-0 grad 0.04714, and the mirror of the judge's N1 gate (/tmp/diag/eval_record.py) passes everything with wide margins (update_norm Δ −4.2e-5 / tol 6.6e-4, loss_mean Δ −1.3e-6 / tol 2.5e-5, cos 0.9929 ≥ 0.955). - Isolation:NCCL_ALGO=Ringalone → 0.04102;CUBLAS_WORKSPACE_CONFIGalone → 0.04104; judge's record hook alone (SLIME_GRPO_BENCH_RECORD=1) → loss and mismatch bitwise identical to the replicated model (−0.0007013520690397197, 0.008164666641911946), grad 0.04712. Default-mode token-shard forward is reproducible but different (loss −0.00069341) → result depends on what ran before the step (allocation state / timing): suspect a stream race. - fla's tensor_cache (identity-keyed, strong refs) and its strided conv forward are not the cause. - Test: device sync at the token-shard layer input (OPT_DEBUG_SYNC=1,/tmp/r2/diag16). - Root cause of the step-0 grad-norm deviation (/tmp/r2/diag16–diag20): not a race. Repeating the same configuration flips between two bitwise-reproducible outcomes (e.g. "sync at every layer" gave the reference's bits in one run and the other outcome in the next): Triton autotuning picks between configs from noisy timings. In the token-shard path the fla gated RMSNorm ran on per-rank rows (autotune key NB=1/2 instead of the reference's ~5), and different (BT, num_warps) give different per-row reduction rounding. Dump 0's step-0 gradient is hypersensitive to such rounding (score-centeringrho=(1-q_mass)/(1-p_mass)with 1-p_mass ≈ 1e-4…1e-7): the reference's own 5 record repeats show grad_norm_mean noise 0.0068 (tolerance 0.034). Even the perturbed outcome passes loss_mean (Δ 7.7e-6 / 2.5e-5) and grad_norm_mean (Δ 0.0016 / 0.034) on dumps 0–2. - Fix: token-shard now gathers z with q/k/v/b/a and applies the gated norm on the whole sequence exactly like the reference (norm.weight back to the reference's reduction); only the four input projections, the input norm and out_proj run on own tokens. Unit test: out 1.2e-4, norm.weight 2.3e-4. Determinism check:/tmp/r2/diag21,diag22. - Full-sequence gated norm (fix attempt above) did not remove the alternative outcome → reverted to the local-norm token-shard for the judge. -check --quicksw_r2c (/tmp/r2/quick_c/check.json, 00:28 → 00:58): INCORRECT (train statistical gate). Rollout side PASS (token forcing 1.0051×, top-k 1.0074/1.0023, mismatch 1.0058). Train: update_norm 0.120554 vs 0.121669 (Δ −1.1e-3, tol 6.6e-4), update_direction_cos 0.908 < 0.955; loss_mean, grad_norm_mean, exp_avg_sq pass. The judge's record run landed on the perturbed forward (step-0 loss −0.00069341 vs reference −0.00070135). Lesson: the reference's 5 repeats differ only through the backward (update_norm noise 1.3e-4); any change of the forward's rounding moves dump 0's score-centering terms and fails update_norm/cos → training-side changes must keep the forward bitwise identical to the reference. - Token-shard parked on branchexp/gdn-shard(slime, commit 5cec24f3, not in the submission); the diagnostics (OPT_DEBUG_TIMERS,OPT_PROFILE_LIGHT,OPT_UPDATE_WEIGHT_BUFFER_MB, all off) committed onopt(ca58c358). - Round 2 end: 2026-11-17 01:04. Submission stays sw_r2b (train 1.528×, rollout 2.418×, projected ≈1.915×).
6.8 hRound 3 — 2026-11-17 01:04 → 2026-11-17 02:11
Profile first (light torch-profiler trace of a warm train step, sw_r2b,/tmp/r3/trainprof, driver/tmp/r3/run_trainprof.sh; report/tmp/r3/trainprof/kernel_report_rank0.md; gap analysis/tmp/r3/ana/gapcat.py): - Rank 0, profiled step window 43.7 s: GPU busy 71.4%. Kernel time: cuBLAS GEMMs ≈13 s, NCCL all-gather 3.06 s + reduce-scatter 1.19 s + send/recv 0.78 s, GDN kernels ≈4 s (replicated), elementwise ≈4 s. - GPU idle gaps (>0.2 ms) total 16.4 s: 5.3 s in 852 gaps dominated bycudaMemGetInfo(6079 calls, 7.5 s CPU, up to ≈75 ms each, from slime's reloadable-process-group wrapper that checks free memory before every collective), 1.3 scudaMallocHost+ 0.4 scudaFreeHost(wake-up), first collectives after every process-group reload (≈0.1–0.2 s each), 9.1 s other host-bound gaps. - Sleep/wake laps (OPT_DEBUG_TIMERS): sleep ≈4 s = clear_memory 0.7 + destroy_process_groups 1.9–2.3 + TMS pause 1.3–1.5; wake ≈1.3 s = TMS resume 0.4 + clear_memory 0.5 + reload groups 0.15 + restore weights 0.2. Every weight sync also reloads and destroys the process groups. - NCCL micro-benchmark (/tmp/r3/nccl, 2 GPUs): default protocol = Simple for large messages (16 MB/rank all-gather 90 µs, same as in training); theRING_LLkernel name is not the protocol → no protocol switch. Change:OPT_KEEP_TRAIN_RESIDENT=1(colocated without train offload, upstream's--no-offload-trainpath: no sleep/wake, no TMS preload in the Megatron actors, plain process groups → no memory check per collective, no group teardown per weight sync) +OPT_SGLANG_MEM_FRACTION=0.55(engines' static pool; the rollout uses <10% of the pools at 0.7; at 0.55 the GPUs keep ≈22 GB free during the rollout with Megatron resident at 41 GB). Memory strategy only. - Full-loop diagnostic (/tmp/r3/full_res, 3 RL steps, driver/tmp/r3/run_full_resident.sh): runs; steady step 2: actor_train 32.5 s (sw_r2b 38.0), weight sync 0.7 s (2.0), no sleep (3.9) / wake (1.3); mismatch 0.0081/0.0082/0.0074. -time --side trainsw_r3a (= sw_r2b +OPT_KEEP_TRAIN_RESIDENT=1+OPT_SGLANG_MEM_FRACTION=0.55,/tmp/r3/time_train_a/time.json): windows 36.08 / 36.11 / 35.78 s → 1.841× (sw_r2b 1.528×); step-0 mismatch 0.008164666641911946 = the reference's value bit for bit (forward unchanged). Projected step speedup with rollout 2.418×: ≈2.07× (the full loop gains more: no sleep/wake, weight sync 0.7 s instead of 2.0 s). - Commit slime 56466bc7.check --quicksw_r3a: PID 735213, log/tmp/r3/quick_a.log, out/tmp/r3/quick_a. -check --quicksw_r3a (/tmp/r3/quick_a/check.json, 01:40 → 02:10): PASS, N1. Rollout: token forcing 0.997×, top-k 1.0049/1.0026 (bias t −1.82), mismatch 1.0049, windows 49.2/46.2/48.2 s (rollout code unchanged; quick-check runs are not timing). Train: update_norm Δ −9.0e-5 (tol 6.6e-4), loss_mean Δ 2.9e-6 (tol 2.5e-5), grad_norm_mean Δ −2.4e-4, cos 0.9912 (min 0.955), mismatch ratio 1.0 (bitwise the reference's value). →/submission/switches.json= sw_r3a (02:11). - Round 3 end: 2026-11-17 02:11.
7.6 hRound 4 — 2026-11-17 02:10 → 2026-11-17 02:21
Hotspot (round-1 reference rollout profile, unchanged GEMM path): decode GEMMs ≈3.1 of ≈5.2 ms per decode step (cuBLAS nvjet kernels at 1.9–3.1 TB/s in the engine; LM head 4.1 TB/s). - Wrote a Triton skinny GEMM for decode-sized M (sglang/srt/layers/opt_skinny_gemm.py, deterministic two-kernel split-K, hook inUnquantizedLinearMethod.applybehindOPT_SKINNY_GEMM) and tuned it per shape against cuBLAS with HBM-resident rotated weights under CUDA graphs (/tmp/gemmbench/tune.py, logs/tmp/gemmbench/tune_*.log): | shape (N×K) | cuBLAS M=32 | best Triton M=32 | |---|---|---| | gate_up 12288×4096 | 28.4 µs (3.55 TB/s) | 27.2 µs (3.71) | | down 4096×6144 | 17.2 µs (2.92) | 15.8 µs (3.19) | | GDN qkvz 6144×4096 | 16.0 µs (3.15) | 16.9 µs | | attn qkv 5120×4096 | 13.4 µs (3.14) | 15.0 µs | | o/out_proj 4096×2048 | 6.8 µs (2.46) | 6.9 µs | | GDN ba 32×4096 | 6.1 µs | 4.0 µs | → cuBLAS is already near what a per-GEMM kernel can reach (the gap to ≈4.1 TB/s is per-kernel ramp/tail); wins only on gate_up/down/ba ≈0.1 ms/step (≈2%, ba partly hidden on the alt stream). Not adopted (kept off). - Re-profiling the current rollout (profile --side rollout, sw_r3a): PID 791005, out/tmp/r4/profile_rollout. - Current rollout profile (/tmp/r4/profile_rollout/kernel_report.md, TP0, bs 32, 198 decode steps): ≈4.8 ms of kernel time per step: decode GEMMs ≈3.0 ms (gate_up 34 µs ×32, down 16.8 ×32, qkvz/qkv 15.6 ×32, ba 12.7 ×24 on the alt stream with 3 CTAs, o/out_proj 8.4 ×32, lm_head 246, split-K reduces 2.1 ×56), GDN decode 20.2 µs ×24 (0.49 ms), fused all-reduce+norm 6.7 µs ×63 (0.43 ms), sampling/log-prob path ≈0.48 ms in ≈30 kernels after the LM head (logits all-gather 56 µs on 4 CTAs, softmax 75 µs on 32 CTAs, exponential-race sampling 17+11+22+19 µs, log 15, clamp 14, radix top-128 ≈125 µs). - Conclusion: no GEMM change (gain ≈2% of the decode step, below the noise of a rollout timing); the sampling path (≈9% of the step, ≈30 launches over 32 MB rows) is the next decode target. Round 4 end: 02:21 (no commit on opt; the Triton GEMM module is parked on sglang branchexp/skinny-gemm).
8.2 hRound 5 — 2026-11-17 02:21 → 02:53
Hotspot (full-loop timeline of/tmp/r3/full_res, sw_r3a): ≈5–6 s per RL step outside rollout and train: engines' memory-saver release after the rollout (rollout end → train start 3 s),clear_memory(sync + gc + empty_cache, ≈1 s) after training, engine resume of weights and of KV/state pools + graphs before the next rollout. The engines' pools at 0.55 hold 35.2 GB KV (2.31 M tokens) + 31.7 GB mamba state (1320 slots); the rollout needs ≈270 K tokens and 32 requests per engine. Change:OPT_KEEP_ROLLOUT_RESIDENT=1(withOPT_KEEP_TRAIN_RESIDENT):offload_rollout=False(no memory saver on the engines, no release/resume per step) and the train actors skipclear_memorybetween steps; `OPT_SGLANG_MEM_FRACTION =0.25` (pools ≈25.7 GB). Memory strategy only. - Full-loop diagnostic (/tmp/r5/full_rr, 5 RL steps, driver/tmp/r5/run_full_rr.sh, nvidia-smi sampled every 0.5 s): all steps run; peak 120.3–120.9 GB of 143.7 GB per GPU; mismatch 0.0073–0.0083; steady RL step ≈80 s (rollout end → train start 2 s, actor_train 32.7–34.3 s, weight sync 1.0 s, rollout ≈44.5 s) vs ≈82.5 s with sw_r3a. (Steps 1 and 3 took 84 s: Triton autotuning on first-seen shapes, as no cache warm-up precedes my diagnostic; the judge's full loop warms the caches on the fixture's dumps, whose shapes the forced lengths reproduce.) -time --side trainsw_r5a (= sw_r3a +OPT_KEEP_ROLLOUT_RESIDENT=1,OPT_SGLANG_MEM_FRACTION=0.25,/tmp/r5/time_train_a/time.json): 35.23 / 35.22 / 34.99 s → 1.885× (sw_r3a 1.841×); step-0 mismatch bitwise the reference's. - Commit slime 0cf4330d./submission/switches.json= sw_r5a (02:53); judge correctness check folded into the nextcheck --quick(the train computation is bitwise unchanged; the rollout side only sizes the pools).
8.6 hRound 6 — 2026-11-17 02:53 → 03:47
Hotspot (round-3 train profile + per-layer timing): the replicated GDN layers (24 of 32) run their whole forward and backward on the full sequence on every one of the 4 ranks; per layer and micro-batch (T = 8192): forward 3.4 ms, backward 7.1 ms (backward GEMMs ≈3.2 ms, recurrence/conv backward ≈2–2.5 ms, rest elementwise). Their forward must stay bitwise (round 2), so only the backward is split. -OPT_GDN_BWD_SPLIT(slimeslime_plugins/models/qwen3_5.py): forward = the reference ops on the whole sequence; backward via a custom autograd function. - mode 1 (heads): each rank recomputes and backpropagates a quarter of the heads. 4-GPU unit test (/tmp/gdntest/test_bwd_split.py, T = 8192): forward bitwise, dX rel 5e-3, param grads 2–4e-3; backward 7.10 → 5.99 ms (fla's state-passing kernels are latency-bound: 8 heads take as long as 32). Record-mode mirror of the judge's N1 gate (/tmp/r6/rec_split, judge hook + Ring + fixed cuBLAS workspace): update_norm Δ −1.2e-4 (tol 6.6e-4), loss_mean Δ 4e-7, grad_norm_mean Δ −1.7e-4, cos 0.9919 (min 0.955); step-0 loss bitwise the reference's → backward-only changes of this size pass. - mode 2 (tokens): out_proj, gated norm, input projections and input norm backpropagated on the own tokens; the recurrence + conv keep their forward graph and are backpropagated on the whole sequence with the gradient assembled from all ranks; own-token input gradient then complete (no reduce-scatter). Unit test: forward bitwise, dX rel 0–3.4e-4, param grads ≈2.3e-3; backward 7.10 → 4.57 ms (multi-sequence 7.55 → 4.51 ms). -time --side trainsw_r6a (= sw_r5a +OPT_GDN_BWD_SPLIT=2,/tmp/r6/time_train_a/time.json): 30.98 / 30.95 / 30.70 s → 2.145× (sw_r5a 1.885×); step-0 loss bitwise the reference's, grad norm 0.04715. Projected step speedup with rollout 2.418×: ≈2.20×. - Commit slime bf0f7b45.check --quicksw_r6a: PID 878215, log/tmp/r6/quick_a.log, out/tmp/r6/quick_a. -check --quicksw_r6a (/tmp/r6/quick_a/check.json, 03:16 → 03:46): PASS, N1. Train: update_norm Δ −3.9e-5 (tol 6.6e-4), loss_mean Δ 7.4e-7, grad_norm_mean Δ −8.3e-4, cos 0.9931 (min 0.955; the reference's own repeats 0.991–0.994), mismatch ratio 1.0 (bitwise). Rollout (validates sw_r5a's pool size): token forcing 1.0007×, top-k 1.0069/1.003 (bias t −1.53), sampler t 0.31, mismatch 0.9998. →/submission/switches.json= sw_r6a (03:47). - Round 6 end: 2026-11-17 03:47.
9.2 hRound 7 — 2026-11-17 03:47 → (in progress)
Hotspots: decode-step sampling path (round-4 rollout profile: ≈0.48 ms of the 5.2 ms step in ≈30 kernels after the LM head, the radix top-128 ≈125 µs of it) and, train side, the per-step CPU weight backup (device-to-host copy of every parameter, only consumed by the weight sync once Megatron stays resident). -OPT_FUSED_SAMPLER(sglanglayers/opt_fused_sampler.py+ hook inSampler.forward, plain temperature sampling only, needsOPT_TOPK_FAST): Triton chunk kernel (per-lane online max / sum-exp / Gumbel-max with Philoxrand4x) + combine kernel +torch.topkon the logits. Tests (/tmp/r6/test_fused_sampler.py,/tmp/r6/chi_fs.py): identical top-128 ids, log-probs within 2e-6, chi-square over 6 seeds z ∈ [−1.97, +1.31] (mean −0.25), cross-row joint frequencies as independent. Microbenchmark (B 32, V 248320): 385 → 201 µs per call; the chunk kernel is compute-bound at ≈35 µs (Philox + exp/log per token; block/chunk/warp sweep), torch.topk ≈140 µs is the rest. Seed passed withdo_not_specialize(a value-specialized seed recompiled the kernel). -OPT_LIVE_WEIGHT_SYNC(slime actor): weight sync from the live GPU params, no per-step CPU backup (resident actor, no ref/teacher sharing the params). -timesw_r7a (= sw_r6a +OPT_FUSED_SAMPLER=1+OPT_LIVE_WEIGHT_SYNC=1): PID 933552, out/tmp/r7/time_a. Commits sglang d73fec3, slime e012b852. -timesw_r7a (/tmp/r7/time_a/time.json): rollout 44.39 / 48.09 / 47.56 s → 2.375×; train 30.66 / 30.66 / 30.49 s → 2.165× (sw_r6a 2.145×: the skipped per-step backup); projected 2.186×. Decode throughput at 30–33 running requests (sglang log): 5900 tok/s (sw_r3a), 5988 (sw_r6a, pool 0.25), 6380 (sw_r7a, fused sampler, +6.5%), yet windows 2–3 were slower: the router (cache_aware) split the 64 requests 28–32 / 32–36 between the engines, and the busier engine sets the rollout's end (window-to-window variance ≈±2 s). -OPT_ROUTER_POLICY(slimebackends/sglang_utils/deployment.py, scheduling only): router policy override;round_robingives 32/32.time --side rolloutsw_r7b (= sw_r7a +OPT_ROUTER_POLICY=round_robin): PID 974276, out/tmp/r7/time_b. -time --side rolloutsw_r7b (/tmp/r7/time_b/time.json): 44.25 / 44.12 / 44.27 s → 2.505× (cache_aware sw_r7a 2.375×, round 1 2.418×); both engines ≤32 running requests; decode 6182 tok/s at 30–33 running. With train 2.165× (sw_r7a) → projected ≈2.25×. Commit slime 8a5e267b. - Full-loop diagnostic sw_r7b (live weight sync, fused sampler and round-robin in the colocated loop, 5 RL steps): PID 997311,/tmp/r7/full. - Full-loop diagnostic sw_r7b (/tmp/r7/full, 5 RL steps): all steps run; peak 116.9–117.4 GB per GPU; mismatch 0.0073–0.0082; warm actor_train 28.3–28.4 s, weight sync 0.7 s; steady RL step (rollout end → rollout end) ≈74 s (sw_r5a ≈80 s; reference ≈184 s).check --quicksw_r7b: out/tmp/r7/quick_b.