GPT-6 Astrasuspected nerf 1.15×

Harness: Codex · switches: SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF=1 SLIME_PERSIST_TRAIN_PROCESS_GROUPS=1 SLIME_RECOMPUTE_GRANULARITY=selective

Judged
1.15×
Tier
N1
Self-best
1.13×
Rounds
20
Hours
10.0
API cost
$217
Input tokens · 97.9% cached
174 M
Output tokens
0.2 M
Requests
1,224
Candidate, three windows (s)
162.1 / 156.1 / 161.5
Rollout side
≈0.98×
Train side
1.48×
Rollout host-side fixes
✗ rollout untouched (measured 0.98–0.99× all three times)
Skip zero-coefficient reference forward
✓
Train-side main levers
partial: training process group kept, selective recompute committed only in round 19 (1.20 → 1.48×)
RoundChangeMeasuredStepSide, cumulativeStatus
Rollout side
1decode CUDA graph exact buckets 24-40rollout-side speedup: — → 0.962——reverted
4FlashInfer trtllm all-reducerollout-side speedup: — → 0.985——reverted
7Hopper BF16 GEMV backendrollout-side speedup: — → 0.981——reverted
16consecutive decode steps set to 2rollout-side speedup: — → 0.984——reverted
Train side
2dynamic micro-batch cap raised to 9000 tokens (64→32 micro-batches)train-side speedup: — → 1.06——reverted
3log-prob chunk raised to 8192train-side speedup: — → 0.999——reverted
5CPU AdamW merges every 16 params into one optimizertrain-side speedup: — → 0.964——reverted
6TE user-buffer TP comm overlapfailed at launch: — → ———reverted
8skip reference forward when KL coefficient is zerotrain-side speedup: — → 1.18×1.181.18×kept
10skip entropy metric computation when entropy coefficient is zerotrain-side speedup: — → 0.911——reverted
11fp32 master weights and Adam momentum all resident on GPUtrain-side speedup: — → 0.902——reverted
12SGLang fused residual/RMSNorm pathtrain-side speedup: — → 0.856——reverted
13training process group kept alive across offload, not destroyedtrain-side speedup: 1.18 → 1.27×1.081.27×kept
14half of optimizer state resident on GPU (fraction 0.5)train-side speedup: — → 1.06——reverted
15skip clear_memory before/after offloadtrain-side speedup: — → 1.08——reverted
17tqdm progress output for the 64 micro-batches turned offtrain-side speedup: — → 1.18——reverted
18skip actor log-prob pre-forward when KL is zerotrain-side speedup: — → 1.2——reverted
19activation recompute switched to selectivetrain-side speedup: 1.27 → 1.48×1.161.48×kept
Raw work log31 sections
—Round 0 (baseline)
- Start: 2026-11-14 08:37 UTC.
- Reference rollout profile: /tmp/r0/profile_rollout/profile.json (ok; 0.528 GPU-hours). Dominant kernels: nvjet GEMMs 52.1% combined, fused recurrent gated delta rule 9.2%, FlashInfer all-reduce 11.5%; CUDA graphs and existing GDN/RoPE/norm fusions active.
- Reference train profile: /tmp/r0/profile_train; reached traced step but PyTorch profiler export stalled with GPUs idle and no trace; terminated and cleaned GPU workers.
- Baseline candidate timing: running as /tmp/r0/time0.
—Round 1 (rollout decode graph buckets; rejected)
- Start: 2026-11-14 09:39 UTC; end: 2026-11-14 09:51 UTC.
- Profile basis: rollout kernel profile /tmp/r0/profile_rollout/profile.json; decode GEMMs were ~52% of GPU time, and engine logs showed live decode batches 27–36 being padded to the 32/40 buckets.
- Change tested: opt-in SGLang parser override plus SGLANG_DISABLE_CUDA_GRAPH_PADDING=1 to capture exact buckets 24–40 while preserving coarse buckets elsewhere. It captured 50 decode graphs successfully and preserved layout.
- Timing: /tmp/r1/time_rollout/time.json; windows 111.587, 117.870, 112.985 s; speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9619 (worse than baseline, no benefit). Reverted source and reset switches to {"environment": {}}.
- Correctness check was not run because the timing gate rejected the change.
—Round 2 (larger dynamic training microbatches; timing accepted, correctness pending)
- Start: 2026-11-14 09:51 UTC; end: 2026-11-14 10:11 UTC.
- Profile basis: /tmp/r0/profile_train/profile_train/train.log and /tmp/r0/time0/train_tree/train.log; actor training repeatedly ran 64 microbatches per step with the 4096-token-per-GPU cap, while samples were about 8.2–8.4K tokens and CP=2.
- Change: slime/slime/utils/arguments.py accepts generic SLIME_MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPU and overrides the dynamic cap after parsing. Switch uses SLIME_MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPU=9000, yielding 32 packed microbatches while preserving sample order and batch contents.
- Timing: /tmp/r2/time_train/time.json; train windows 62.824, 62.339, 63.011 s; speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0618. Projected train-only step speedup 1.0618 (projected whole-step 1.0217 when combined with the unchanged rollout fraction). Mismatch metrics stayed within the baseline range.
- Correctness check pending; this changes microbatch grouping and is expected to be tier N1 if accepted.
—Round 2 conclusion (failed correctness)
- Quick check: /tmp/r2/quick/check.json, status INCORRECT at training statistical gate. Rollout exact/token-forcing/top-k/mismatch all passed.
- Training with 32 microbatches differed in update norm (0.12045 vs reference 0.12167, outside paired tolerance) and update direction cosine (0.9266 below 0.9554), so the larger-cap change was reverted.
- Revert commit: 4f5c41c4; switches reset to {"environment": {}}.
—Round 3 (larger log-probability chunks; no benefit)
- Start: 2026-11-14 10:46 UTC; end: 2026-11-14 11:06 UTC.
- Profile basis: repeated ref_log_probs work in the train log; tried SLIME_LOG_PROBS_CHUNK_SIZE=8192 in backends/megatron_utils/loss.py while keeping batch grouping and arithmetic unchanged.
- Timing: /tmp/r3/time_train/time.json; windows 67.012, 65.726, 65.551 s; train speedup 0.9987, projected step speedup 0.9995. Reverted with commit ffec7766 (see log for preceding implementation commit).
- No correctness run because the timing gate showed no benefit.
—Round 4 (FlashInfer rollout all-reduce; no benefit)
- Start: 2026-11-14 11:07 UTC; end: 2026-11-14 11:19 UTC.
- Profile basis: rollout trace all-reduce fusion chain (~9.5% kernel time); enabled SGLang TRTLLM FlashInfer fusion through SLIME_FLASHINFER_ALLREDUCE_BACKEND=trtllm.
- Timing: /tmp/r4/time_rollout/time.json; windows 110.248, 115.094, 111.965 s; rollout speedup 0.9851, projected step speedup 0.9908. Reverted source and switch.
—Round 5 (group CPU AdamW tensors; no benefit)
- Start: 2026-11-14 11:21 UTC; end: 2026-11-14 11:38 UTC.
- Profile basis: CPU offload creates one optimizer object per parameter; grouped 16 parameters per CPU optimizer behind SLIME_CPU_OPTIMIZER_GROUP_SIZE=16.
- Timing: /tmp/r5/time_train/time.json; windows 66.584, 68.953, 66.231 s; train speedup 0.9640, projected step speedup 0.9865. Reverted source and switch.
—Round 6 (TP communication overlap; initialization failure)
- Start: 2026-11-14 11:39 UTC; end: 2026-11-14 11:44 UTC.
- Profile basis: training log shows TP communication enabled in neither baseline nor candidate; enabled Megatron TE user-buffer overlap via SLIME_TP_COMM_OVERLAP=1.
- Timing: /tmp/r6/time_train/time.json; initialization failed before timing because TE required the intra-node TP group backend to match the world NCCL backend. Reverted source and switch.
—Round 7 (Hopper BF16 GEMV backend; rejected)
- Start: 2026-11-14 11:49 UTC; end: 2026-11-14 12:00 UTC.
- Profile basis: rollout profile showed nvjet GEMMs at ~52% of GPU time; exposed SGLang's BF16 GEMM backend and tested Hopper gemv through SLIME_BF16_GEMM_BACKEND=gemv.
- Timing: /tmp/r7/time_rollout/time.json; windows 113.010, 113.751, 113.419 s; speedup_vs_frozen_reference 0.9814 (worse). Reverted with slime commit 3095d932; switches reset to {"environment": {}}.
—Round 8 (skip zero-weight KL reference forward; accepted N1)
- Start: 2026-11-14 12:06 UTC; end: 2026-11-14 12:22 UTC for timing, 12:34 UTC for quick check.
- Profile basis: baseline train logs/profile show steady ref_log_probs at about 10.9 s per step, while the recipe has kl_coef=0, use_kl_loss=true, and kl_loss_coef=0.0; the KL term is identically zero.
- Change: slime commit 6a22f055 adds opt-in SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF=1. Actor skips the frozen-reference log-probability forward only when both KL coefficients are zero; loss retains the kl_loss=0 metric without reading reference log-probs. Switch is /submission/switches.json.
- Timing: /tmp/r8/time_train/time.json; windows 55.578, 57.130, 56.029 s; speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.1635; projected full-step speedup 1.0541. Mismatch metrics remained within the reference range.
- Quick check: /tmp/r8/quick/check.json, PASS tier N1. Update-direction cosine 0.99423 >= 0.95541, update norm/loss/Adam moment/gradient norm within tolerance, mismatch ratio 1.0.
—Full check after Round 8
- /tmp/r8/check/check.json: PASS, tier N1; benefit passed with train windows 55.824, 56.353, 55.384 s, side speedup 1.1796, projected speedup 1.0589. Statistical update-direction cosine 0.99524 and mismatch ratio 1.0.
- Current best remains slime 6a22f055 with SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF=1.
—Round 9 profile (training profiler export failure; no change)
- Start: 2026-11-14 13:02 UTC; profile /tmp/r9/profile_train reached the traced actor step and stopped the profiler, but PyTorch profiler export hung for more than 15 minutes with no trace or kernel report. The four workers were terminated after GPU kernels were idle; no timing or correctness result was used.
- The existing trace/log evidence still identifies metric-only full-vocabulary entropy as the next zero-weight candidate (entropy_coef=0.0), but it remains untested.
—Round 10 (zero-weight entropy metric skip; reverted)
- Start: 2026-11-14 13:25 UTC; end: 13:39 UTC for timing, 13:51 UTC for quick check.
- Profile basis: the prior train profile/log showed a metric-only full-vocabulary entropy computation even though entropy_coef=0.0; tested the opt-in skip behind SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_ENTROPY=1.
- Change: slime commit 1bc8fa98 added the skip in backends/megatron_utils/loss.py; it was reverted as bb15202e after measurement.
- Timing: /tmp/r10/time_train/time.json; windows 58.540, 55.520, 73.404 s versus frozen reference 66.927, 66.472, 66.904 s. The minimum window ratio was 0.9114 and projected speedup 0.9657, so this was a regression/no benefit (the third window was also outside the stable reference pattern).
- Quick correctness: /tmp/r10/quick/check.json, PASS N1; update direction cosine 0.99268 >= 0.95541 and mismatch ratio 1.0. Correctness passed, but the change remains reverted because it did not benefit timing.
—Current best (updated after Round 10)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1"}}.
- Latest full check: /tmp/r8/check/check.json, PASS tier N1; latest quick check for current best before Round 10: /tmp/r8/quick/check.json, PASS N1. Round 10 quick check also passed but its change was reverted.
- Accepted gain: zero-weight KL reference skip (slime commit 6a22f055; revert of the later experiment is bb15202e), full-check train speedup 1.1796 and projected full-loop speedup 1.0589.
- Reverted directions: entropy metric skip (no benefit/regression), larger microbatch cap (N1 direction failure), rollout graph buckets, log-prob chunk size, FlashInfer all-reduce, grouped CPU AdamW, TP overlap (initialization failure), and Hopper BF16 GEMV (no benefit).
—Round 11 (GPU-resident fp32 optimizer state; reverted)
- Start: 2026-11-14 14:01 UTC; end: 14:25 UTC.
- Profile basis: current-best train timers put actor forward/backward plus optimizer at about 46–48 s per steady step; memory telemetry during training showed about 106 GB free after actor wake. Tested SLIME_OPTIMIZER_OFFLOAD_FRACTION=0 to keep the fp32 master and Adam moments on GPU and avoid CPU optimizer transfers.
- Change: slime commit 08c2e660 added the opt-in fraction override in backends/megatron_utils/actor.py; it was reverted as c44b5ea7.
- Timing: /tmp/r11/time_train/time.json; candidate windows 73.898, 73.711, 73.946 s versus frozen reference 66.927, 66.472, 66.904 s. Side speedup was 0.9018 and projected speedup 0.9617. GPU state residency caused about 20 s extra sleep and 6–7 s extra wake time per cycle, so this direction is closed without a correctness run.
—Current best (updated after Round 11)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1"}}.
- Latest full check: /tmp/r8/check/check.json, PASS tier N1; current-best quick check /tmp/r8/quick/check.json, PASS N1.
- Accepted gain remains zero-weight KL reference skip (6a22f055), full-check train speedup 1.1796 and projected full-loop speedup 1.0589.
- Round 11 GPU optimizer residency was reverted as a clear regression; no other switches changed.
7.2 hRound 12 (SGLang fused residual/RMSNorm path; reverted)
- Start: 2026-11-14 14:26 UTC; end: 14:48 UTC.
- Profile basis: current train arguments showed fused_residual_rmsnorm=False; the source contains an opt-in SGLang batch-invariant residual/RMSNorm path. First timing attempt /tmp/r12/time_train/time.json failed at the first forward because Qwen linear-attention blocks use IdentityOp without a weight attribute. Added temporary IdentityOp handling in Megatron commit 39eef7e and reran.
- Timing: /tmp/r12b/time_train/time.json; windows 60.899, 77.649, 60.308 s, side speedup 0.8561 and projected speedup 0.9421. The warmed actor steps were also slower. The candidate mismatch was about 9.4 versus 0.008 for the current best, so the path is numerically invalid for this recipe. The guard was reverted as 4b9f1e0; the failed first attempt is recorded in /tmp/r12/time_train/time.json.
- No correctness run was needed after the timing/mismatch rejection.
7.2 hCurrent best (updated after Round 12)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1"}}.
- Latest full check: /tmp/r8/check/check.json, PASS tier N1; current-best quick check /tmp/r8/quick/check.json, PASS N1.
- Accepted gain remains zero-weight KL reference skip (6a22f055), full-check train speedup 1.1796 and projected full-loop speedup 1.0589.
- Round 12 fused residual/RMSNorm and its IdentityOp guard were reverted after a clear timing regression and mismatch failure.
7.2 hRound 13 (persistent NCCL/Gloo process groups; full check passed)
- Profile basis: /tmp/r9/profile_train and current timed logs showed repeated process-group teardown/reload around each CPU offload cycle, with steady actor steps around 46–48 s and train-wait overhead around 6–7 s. Keeping groups alive preserves the fixed parallel layout while removing that lifecycle work.
- Change: slime commit 9819891b adds opt-in SLIME_PERSIST_TRAIN_PROCESS_GROUPS=1, skipping destroy/reload across offload and weight-update boundaries. The existing zero-weight KL reference skip remains enabled.
- Timing: /tmp/r13/time_train/time.json; candidate windows 53.950, 52.891, 51.879 s, train speedup 1.2405 and projected speedup 1.0763.
- Full check: /tmp/r13/check/check.json, PASS tier N1. Candidate windows 52.739, 52.196, 51.729 s; train speedup 1.269 and projected full-loop speedup 1.084. Statistical update-direction cosine 0.99481 and mismatch ratio 1.0.
7.5 hRound 14 (partial GPU optimizer residency; reverted)
- Profile basis: /tmp/r9/profile_train and Round 13 logs showed CPU optimizer movement as the remaining train-wait candidate; the actor had roughly 100 GB free on each GPU after wake.
- Change: slime commit 28a5f514 exposed SLIME_OPTIMIZER_OFFLOAD_FRACTION; tested 0.5 with the two passing switches. This retains fp32 master and Adam state arithmetic while keeping half the optimizer state resident on GPU.
- Timing: /tmp/r14/time_train/time.json; candidate windows 62.945, 62.199, 60.733 s, train speedup 1.0633 and projected full-loop speedup 1.0222. The partial residency increased the measured windows, so it was reverted as 1e08249f.
- No correctness run was needed after the timing rejection.
7.5 hCurrent best (updated after Round 14)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1", "SLIME_PERSIST_TRAIN_PROCESS_GROUPS": "1"}}.
- Latest full check: /tmp/r13/check/check.json, PASS tier N1, projected speedup 1.084.
- Accepted gains remain zero-weight KL reference skip (6a22f055) and persistent train process groups (9819891b). Round 14 partial optimizer residency was reverted after its 1.0222 projected timing result.
7.7 hRound 15 (skip offload allocator cleanup; reverted)
- Profile basis: current-best timers showed sleep around 2–3 s and wake_up around 1.2 s per cycle; the cleanup calls immediately before and after the memory saver were the remaining housekeeping candidate.
- Change: slime commit efda6dbf added opt-in SLIME_SKIP_OFFLOAD_CLEAR_MEMORY=1 around the sleep/wake clear_memory calls.
- Timing: /tmp/r15/time_train/time.json; candidate windows 60.929, 61.340, 59.971 s, train speedup 1.0837 and projected speedup 1.0290. Logs showed sleep expanding to 8–9 s and wake to about 3 s, so the cleanup is required and the change was reverted as 4e7e8ec5.
- No correctness run was needed after the timing rejection.
7.7 hCurrent best (updated after Round 15)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1", "SLIME_PERSIST_TRAIN_PROCESS_GROUPS": "1"}}.
- Latest full check: /tmp/r13/check/check.json, PASS tier N1, projected speedup 1.084.
- Round 15 offload-cleanup skip was reverted after its 1.0290 projected timing result; the tree is restored to the full-check-passing candidate.
7.9 hRound 16 (multi-step SGLang decode scheduling; reverted)
- Profile basis: /tmp/r0/profile_rollout/kernel_report.md showed only 32.8% GPU busy with large host launch gaps; decode GEMMs and scheduler launches dominated the rollout window. Tested SGLang's existing num_continuous_decode_steps setting as a launch-overhead lever.
- Change: slime commit ee9ee69e added opt-in SLIME_SGLANG_NUM_CONTINUOUS_DECODE_STEPS; tested value 2 while retaining the two passing train switches.
- Timing: /tmp/r16/time_rollout/time.json; candidate windows 114.295, 115.207, 113.134 s versus frozen reference 112.843, 113.384, 111.310 s. Rollout speedup was 0.9839 and projected full-loop speedup 0.9900, so it was reverted as 687d41c7.
- No correctness run was needed after the timing rejection.
7.9 hCurrent best (updated after Round 16)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1", "SLIME_PERSIST_TRAIN_PROCESS_GROUPS": "1"}}.
- Latest full check: /tmp/r13/check/check.json, PASS tier N1, projected speedup 1.084.
- Rollout scheduling and offload housekeeping experiments were reverted; current tree remains the full-check-passing candidate.
8.2 hRound 17 (disable microbatch progress output; reverted)
- Profile basis: /tmp/r9/profile_train/train.log showed a tqdm update for each of the 64 actor microbatches on the main rank; tested this host-side launch/console overhead separately from GPU computation.
- Change: slime commit 0d76d820 added opt-in SLIME_DISABLE_TRAIN_PROGRESS=1 to disable the progress wrapper on all ranks.
- Timing: /tmp/r17/time_train/time.json; candidate windows 53.295, 56.327, 51.597 s, train speedup 1.1801 and projected full-loop speedup 1.0591. This was below the current best's 1.269 train-side ratio and showed a noisy slow middle window, so it was reverted as e51913aa.
- No correctness run was needed after the timing rejection.
8.2 hCurrent best (updated after Round 17)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1", "SLIME_PERSIST_TRAIN_PROCESS_GROUPS": "1"}}.
- Latest full check: /tmp/r13/check/check.json, PASS tier N1, projected speedup 1.084.
- Current tree is restored to the full-check-passing candidate after the progress-output experiment.
—Round 18 (zero-KL actor log-prob prepass; no effective path)
- Start: 2026-11-14 16:53 UTC; profile /tmp/r18/profile_train reached the traced actor step but PyTorch profiler export stalled again with no trace or kernel report. Stage timers showed steady actor training around 47–49 s and train_wait around 6.7–6.9 s.
- Change: slime commit a446e2fd added opt-in SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_ACTOR_LOGPROBS=1 to omit a detached actor log-prob prepass when zero-KL GRPO advantages could use rollout log-probs. The recipe already satisfies can_reuse_log_probs_in_loss, so this branch was not active; the timing was therefore a no-op aside from run noise. The change was reverted as 68758104, and the switch was removed.
- Timing: /tmp/r18/time_actor/time.json; windows 52.975, 55.411, 51.255 s; train speedup 1.1996 and projected speedup 1.0648 versus the frozen reference, below the current best full-check train ratio 1.269. The middle window was noisy.
- Quick correctness: /tmp/r18/quick_actor/check.json, PASS tier N1; update-direction cosine 0.99437 and mismatch ratio 1.0. The path was reverted because it is inactive for this recipe and showed no measured improvement.
—Current best (after Round 18)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1", "SLIME_PERSIST_TRAIN_PROCESS_GROUPS": "1"}}.
- Latest full check: /tmp/r13/check/check.json, PASS tier N1, projected speedup 1.084.
- Latest quick check for the attempted Round 18 branch: /tmp/r18/quick_actor/check.json, PASS N1; branch reverted after timing/no-op analysis.
- Accepted gains remain zero-weight KL reference skip (6a22f055) and persistent train process groups (9819891b).
—Round 19 (selective activation recomputation; quick pass)
- Start: 2026-11-14 17:43 UTC; end: 18:33 UTC for the quick check.
- Profile basis: /tmp/r9/profile_train and the current train timers showed full activation recomputation dominating the actor step; switched Megatron validation to expose selective activation recomputation for this recipe. The override is train-side only in slime/backends/megatron_utils/arguments.py and is enabled by SLIME_RECOMPUTE_GRANULARITY=selective.
- Timing: /tmp/r19b/time_train/time.json; windows 44.580, 44.984, 43.780 s; train speedup 1.4777 and projected step speedup 1.134. Layout and first-use checks passed.
- Quick correctness: /tmp/r19b/quick_train/check.json, PASS tier N1. Candidate update norm 0.1217079, Adam second-moment norm 8.188e-7, mean loss -0.0023630, mean gradient norm 0.04785, and update-direction cosine 0.99398 (minimum 0.95541); train–inference mismatch ratio 1.0.
- Commit: slime 02cdad91 (Expose selective activation recomputation switch (N1 candidate)). Full check started after this quick pass.
—Current best (after Round 19 timing and quick check)
- Switch file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {"SLIME_SKIP_ZERO_KL_REF": "1", "SLIME_PERSIST_TRAIN_PROCESS_GROUPS": "1", "SLIME_RECOMPUTE_GRANULARITY": "selective"}}.
- Latest full check before this round: /tmp/r13/check/check.json, PASS tier N1, projected speedup 1.084.
- Latest quick check: /tmp/r19b/quick_train/check.json, PASS tier N1; full validation is in progress.
- Accepted gains currently measured: zero-weight KL reference skip, persistent train process groups, and selective activation recomputation. Earlier reverted directions remain documented above.
↑ Slime GRPO