Claude Haiku 5.5 1.85×

Harness: Claude Code · switches: SLIME_OPT_BINARY_TOPK_ONLY=1 SLIME_OPT_SKIP_ZERO_KL=1 SLIME_OPT_NO_RECOMPUTE=1 SLIME_OPT_ROUTER_POLICY=round_robin SLIME_OPT_TRAIN_THREADS=24 SLIME_OPT_GC_FREEZE=1 SLIME_OPT_LIVE_PARAMS=1

Judged
1.85×
Tier
N1
Self-best
1.90×
Rounds
23
Hours
10.1
API cost
$16.8
Input tokens · 99.5% cached
276 M
Output tokens
0.8 M
Requests
572
Candidate, three windows (s)
98.3 / 100.2 / 99.6
Rollout side
2.15×
Train side
1.50×
Rollout host-side fixes
✓ sampler desync, engine sends binary top-k only, round-robin
Skip zero-coefficient reference forward
✓
Train-side main levers
partial: no recompute, 24 training CPU threads, GC freeze + param buffers resident (1.40 → 1.50×)
RoundChangeMeasuredStepSide, cumulativeStatus
Rollout side
2sampler top-p flag on host, per-step sync removedrollout-side speedup: — → 1.33×1.331.33×kept
3reward moved out of the event loop (process pool)rollout window s: 84.3 → 84.8——reverted
5engine side no longer builds verbose top-logprob listsrollout-side speedup: 1.33 → 1.93×1.451.93×kept
7per-request top-k D2H copies batchedrollout window s: 52.7 → 112——reverted
10router switched to round_robinrollout-side speedup: 1.93 → 2.15×1.112.15×kept
12whole underlying [batch,k] tensor in one D2H, then slicedrollout window s: 52.3 → 52.9——reverted
14custom Triton GEMM replacing cuBLASgate_up GEMM µs (dev microbenchmark): 29.8 → 28.6——reverted
16leaner CPU reduction on the decode siderollout-side speedup: 2.1 → 2.11——reverted
19AllReduce fusion backend switched to mnnvlrollout-side speedup: 2.15 → 2.13×0.99—reverted
Train side
6skip zero-coefficient KL forward + recompute off + restore removedtrain-side speedup: — → 1.4×1.401.40×kept
8optimizer offload fraction 0.5train-side speedup: 1.4 → 1.13×0.80—reverted
92 samples per micro-batchtrain-side speedup: 1.4 → 1.5×1.07—reverted
11routine memory logging off (6 mem_get_info/step)train-side speedup: 1.4 → 1.41×1.00—reverted
13fused attention backendnone (grad norm NaN): — → ———reverted
15gc.freeze + larger gen-0 thresholdtrain window s: 47 → 47.3——reverted
15training actor CPU threads capped at 24 (CPU Adam)train-side speedup: 1.4 → 1.42×1.011.42×kept
17NCCL_PROTO=Simpletrain window s: 45.4 → 45.9——reverted
21TE TP comm overlap (userbuffer)none (init assertion / UB buffer shape): — → ———reverted
22offload fraction 0.5 rechecktrain-side speedup: 1.42 → 1.08×0.76—reverted
23gc.freeze after init to cut gc.collectwake_up s (full loop): 1.5 → 0.8——kept
23param buffers resident in GPU memory, per-step backup/restore skippedtrain-side speedup (counted together with GC_FREEZE): 1.42 → 1.5×1.051.50×kept
Raw work log27 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — profile the unchanged reference (started 08:20 UTC)
- Profiles launched detached: rollout → /tmp/r1/profile_rollout, train → /tmp/r1/profile_train (driver /tmp/r1/run_profiles.sh).

#### Round 1 profile findings (unchanged reference; judge profile, 08:20–08:55 UTC)
- Clarification of the frozen timing: each *window* is one rollout (~114 s) or one train step (~67 s); a full RL step ≈ 182 s = 114 + 67.
- Rollout (f = 0.63), decode is host-bound. Trace window (200 decode steps, device 0): GPU busy 32 % of the window (kernel time 1116 ms / 3150 ms).
  - Scheduler main thread: Sampler.forward → bool(sampling_info.return_top_p_log_probs.any().item()) is a device sync on every decode step: 200 calls, 823 ms (≈4 ms/step). cudaStreamSynchronize total 818 ms / 261 calls, i.e. essentially all syncs are this one. This kills the overlap scheduler (disable_overlap_schedule is False in the server args).
  - Per-request top-k device→host copies: async_d2h 14 330 calls (≈72 per step), each allocating a pinned host tensor (torch.empty(pin_memory=True)): 407 ms (≈2 ms/step).
  - Reward: async_rm calls the synchronous get_deepscaler_rule_based_reward (sympy grading) inside the event loop, so the 64 rewards serialize after generation. Progress bar: last generation done ≈ 90 s, rollout ends ≈ 120 s (profile run, not timed) → ≈ 25–30 s serial tail.
- Train (f = 0.37). slime's own timers (profile run, step 0–5): ref_log_probs (reference forward, 64 micro-batches) 12–38 s; actor_train (fwd + recompute + bwd over 64 micro-batches of 1 sample, ≈1.07 s each, plus CPU Adam ≈ 7 s) 45–78 s; sleep/wake (offload) ≈ 6 s outside the timers.
  - The reference forward runs because use_kl_loss=True, although kl_loss_coef=0.00: the KL term is multiplied by 0 but its ref forward is paid every step.
  - The actor log-prob forward is already skipped (can_reuse_log_probs_in_loss), so there is no separate old-logprob pass.
- Judge artifacts: /tmp/r1/profile_rollout (trace + kernel_report.md), /tmp/r1/profile_train (traces, 2 GB; kernel report pending).

#### Planned rounds (ordered by expected gain)
1. Rollout: remove the per-step device sync in the sampler (host flag). Exact (no numerics change).
2. Rollout: run the reward off the event loop (process pool). Exact (same function, same inputs).
3. Train: skip the reference forward when kl_loss_coef == 0 (its KL term contributes 0 × kl). Expected bitwise (N0); needs the record check.
4. Train: drop the activation recompute if memory allows (memory strategy only).
5. Rollout: batch the per-request top-k copies into one pinned transfer.
1.0 hRound 2 — sampler device sync removed (rollout) — commit d6ed4cc (sglang)
- Change: SamplingBatchInfo.need_return_top_p_log_probs host mirror; Sampler.forward skips .any().item() when the mirror is False. Unconditional (no switch). Numerics N0 (same values).
- time --side rollout (/tmp/r2/time_rollout_sampler/time.json): windows 84.26 / 86.01 / 84.21 s vs reference 113.84 / 114.63 / 113.50 s → side speedup 1.333, projected step speedup 1.185.
- Quick check not run yet (no numerics change expected; will run with the next exactness-relevant change).
1.0 hRound 3 — reward off the event loop (rollout) — switch `SLIME_OPT_RM_POOL=1` (uncommitted)
- Change: slime/rollout/rm_hub/__init__.py: deepscaler reward runs in a forkserver ProcessPoolExecutor (32 workers) instead of inline in async_rm.
- time --side rollout with switch (/tmp/r3/time_rollout_rmpool/time.json): windows 84.81 / 87.47 / 84.38 s → no gain over round 2 (the tail is not the reward function, or the pool is not active; investigating).
- Finding: per-request latencies end by ≈51 s (median 49 s), but the rollout closes at ≈85 s. Groups complete one by one between 53 s and 85 s, so ≈30 s of serialized per-group work follows generation. Diagnosis in progress with py-spy on the rollout manager (round 4 notes).
1.3 hRound 4 — diagnosis of the rollout tail (py-spy on the RolloutManager, no code change)
- Diagnostic time --side rollout with the reward pool on, py-spy (--subprocesses --nonblocking, 50 Hz) attached to the RolloutManager (/tmp/r4/rm_stacks.raw, 7 787 samples over 4 rollouts).
- 80 % of the sampled stacks are json.loads inside decode_score_centering_response (worker threads, GIL-bound). The RM reward (deepscaler) is under 1 % of the samples, so the reward pool was useless. Reverted.
- Cause: each response carries meta_info["output_top_logprobs"], the verbose per-token top-128 lists, built on the engine's tokenizer manager by detokenizing every entry (detokenize_top_logprobs_tokens), then JSON-encoded and parsed on the client (≈ 30 MB per response). Slime reads only the binary top-k fields. The verbose build serializes on each engine's event loop, and the decode of 64 responses serializes on the RM side: together the ≈ 30 s tail.
- Verified environment propagation: the RolloutManager and the SGLangEngine processes both carry the SLIME_OPT_* switch variables from switches.json (an earlier check was wrong; it inspected my own shell).
1.3 hRound 5 — skip the verbose top-logprob lists (rollout) — commit 5fa1282 (sglang), switch `SLIME_OPT_BINARY_TOPK_ONLY=1`
- time --side rollout (/tmp/r5/time_rollout_topk/time.json): windows 52.65 / 52.67 / 58.82 s vs reference 113.84 / 114.63 / 113.50 s → side speedup 1.930, projected step speedup 1.432.
- Per-rollout e2e median 48–55 s, so the rollout now ends right after the last generation; the decode is close to the GPU floor (≈ 5 ms per step × 8 192 steps ≈ 41 s).
- /submission/switches.json now = {"environment": {"SLIME_OPT_BINARY_TOPK_ONLY": "1"}}.
1.5 hRound 6 — train side: skip zero-coefficient KL reference forward, drop activation recompute, skip redundant restore — commits 06ed0293 (slime, restore skip; unconditional) and f7c45f38 (slime, switches SLIME_OPT_SKIP_ZERO_KL and SLIME_OPT_NO_RECOMPUTE)
- time --side train with switches {BINARY_TOPK, SKIP_ZERO_KL, NO_RECOMPUTE} (/tmp/r6/time_train_both/time.json): windows 47.47 / 47.85 / 47.03 s vs reference 66.92 / 67.19 / 66.67 s → side speedup 1.404; first_use 0 s in the windows; layout ok; mismatch values 0.0075–0.0104 (per step).
- The judge's steady-state windows are flat. The step-to-step stalls seen in the log belong to the warm-up steps 0–3, which compile and autotune the flash-linear-attention Triton kernels for each dump's sequence lengths (judge's warm-up design).
- Projected full-loop speedup with both sides (from the two side results and the frozen fractions): ≈ 1.69.
- Train phase breakdown (slime timers, this run): sleep ≈ 4.3 s, wake ≈ 1.3 s, data preprocess ≈ 0.4 s, train_wait ≈ 8.5 s (includes the sleep wake overlap), actor_train ≈ 38 s for 64 micro-batches.

### Full check 1 (in progress, started 09:50 UTC): bench.py check --tree /submission/slime_grpo --config /submission/switches.json --out /tmp/r7/check (log /tmp/r7/check.log)
- Switches: SLIME_OPT_BINARY_TOPK_ONLY=1, SLIME_OPT_SKIP_ZERO_KL=1, SLIME_OPT_NO_RECOMPUTE=1.
- Result: pending.

### Full check 1 — stopped by a judge-side crash (10:10 UTC)
- bench.py check (non-quick) ran the candidate's rollout timing run (rollout_cand, 380 s wall), the train timing run (train_cand, 761 s wall), then crashed in judge_rollout: score() writes to <out>/rollout/score.log, and that directory is only created when the gate itself launches a run. When the check reuses a timing run (the non-quick path), nothing creates <out>/rollout, so FileNotFoundError is raised before token forcing. This is in the judge's bench.py (read-only), not in the candidate tree. The bootstrap full check never reached this gate (it stopped at no_benefit).
- No verdict from check 1. Plan instead: check --quick (the correctness gates, run before timing) plus separate time runs for each side (the benefit gate uses the same timing).
1.9 hRound 7 (in progress) — batch the per-request top-k device-to-host copies (rollout, sglang `managers/utils.py`)
- _async_d2h_rows: one stacked pinned copy for same-shape CUDA rows (previously ≈ 64 pinned copies and stream lookups per decode step). Values unchanged. Uncommitted until validated.
- Validation: check --quick (/tmp/r8/quick1, started 10:11 UTC, includes this change), then time --side rollout (not yet run).
- Also staged (default off, uncommitted): SLIME_OPT_OFFLOAD_FRACTION sets optimizer_offload_fraction (CPU share of the optimizer step). Changes rounding (N1 at most); to be timed.

### Quick check 1 (/tmp/r8/quick1/check.json): PASS, tier N1 (10:11–10:42 UTC)
- Tree: commits d6ed4cc, 5fa1282 (sglang), 06ed0293, f7c45f38 (slime) + uncommitted _async_d2h_rows (sglang managers/utils.py); switches {BINARY_TOPK, SKIP_ZERO_KL, NO_RECOMPUTE}.
- Rollout: exact items ok; token forcing mean |d| ratio 1.008 (limit 2); tail-event test p = 0.999; sampler shift t = −0.75; top-k overlap 0.988; layout ok.
- Train record: exact items ok; bitwise False (6 388 tensors differ). The judge's own bootstrap recorded the reference as not repeatable bitwise either (6 388 differing tensors, repeatable: False), so the statistical gate decides: update norm, second-moment norm, loss, and grad-norm endpoints within tolerance. The reference cannot reach N0 under this judge, so N1 is the realistic tier.
- Mismatch and layout gates passed.
- Consequence: train-side numerics changes that are statistically equivalent are acceptable (N1), so the optimizer offload fraction is in scope.

### Time results (all judge time)
- rollout with batched top-k copies: pending (/tmp/r8/time_rollout_batch, started 10:43 UTC).
1.9 hRound 7 result — REVERTED: batched top-k copies corrupt the sampled top-k arrays
- time --side rollout with _async_d2h_rows (/tmp/r8/time_rollout_batch): windows 112.1 / 105.4 / 108.7 s (vs 52.7 s before). The RolloutManager log shows Sampler top-k token ids must be distinct and Sampler top-k logprobs must be finite nonpositive values validation errors, retried 28 times in the quick check, so requests were resubmitted and the tail returned.
- The quick check had passed with this change only because the retries regenerate valid samples. Its timing was not inspected at the time. Lesson: a time run must show zero retrying lines (grep -c retrying train.log) before its number is trusted.
- Cause (not fully diagnosed): the pinned host copy of the stacked rows is read before the stream has finished writing it, or the stacked device temporary is recycled too early. Reverted with git checkout (sglang managers/utils.py back to 5fa1282). Not retried.
- Earlier runs: retrying count 0 in the sampler run (/tmp/r2) and the binary top-k run (/tmp/r5).

### Queued (10:55 UTC, /tmp/r9/chain.sh, sequential)
- Rollout time on the reverted tree (expect ≈ 52 s; verify 0 retries).
- Train time with SLIME_OPT_OFFLOAD_FRACTION=0.5 (/tmp/r9/train_offload).
- Train time with SLIME_OPT_MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPU=9216 (two samples per micro-batch; /tmp/r9/train_mb2).
1.9 hRound 7b — reverted tree, rollout re-timed (/tmp/r9/rollout_reverted): windows 63.82 / 51.21 / 52.42 s, speedup 1.784 (min window), retries 0
- Window 1 was slow: one request finished at 60.7 s while the median was 47.9 s (straggler). Rollout time = last request.
- Finding: the sglang router defaults to cache_aware (sglang_router RouterArgs.policy). Slime never sets router_policy, so the four samples of each prompt share one engine and the 16 prompts split unevenly (engine loads of 35 and 29 running requests were seen earlier). The engine with more requests is the straggler.
- Switch added (default off): SLIME_OPT_ROUTER_POLICY=round_robin sets args.router_policy, which RouterArgs.from_cli_args(use_router_prefix=True) reads. Queued for timing in /tmp/r9/chain2.sh (after the train runs).
3.0 hRound 8 — optimizer offload fraction 0.5 (train, `SLIME_OPT_OFFLOAD_FRACTION`): **rejected (slower)**
- time --side train (/tmp/r9/train_offload/time.json, switches {BINARY_TOPK, SKIP_ZERO_KL, NO_RECOMPUTE, OFFLOAD_FRACTION=0.5}): windows 58.96 / 56.99 / 58.28 s vs 47.4 s with the default fraction 1.0 (CPU optimizer step). Speedup 1.13 against the reference; first_use 0.
- The GPU share of the Adam step costs more than the CPU share it removes. Default (1.0) kept; the switch stays default-off.
3.2 hRound 9 — two samples per micro-batch (train, `SLIME_OPT_MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPU=9216`): faster but **not adopted (memory)**
- time --side train (/tmp/r9/train_mb2/time.json; switches {BINARY_TOPK, SKIP_ZERO_KL, NO_RECOMPUTE, MAX_TOKENS_PER_GPU=9216}): windows 43.81 / 44.70 / 43.56 s vs 47.4 s with one sample per micro-batch → speedup 1.50 vs 1.40.
- Six CUDA caching-allocator warnings (memory allocation failed with OOM ... free: 2.0–3.2 GB, needing 4.3–4.5 GB; the retry succeeded). The one-sample run had none. The margin is too thin for the full loop, where the rollout engines share the process group, so the switch stays default-off and is not in the submission.
- Math: per-token loss is summed over all tokens and normalized by the step total, so two-sample micro-batches differ only in summation order (N1).
3.3 hRound 10 — routing (rollout) adopted; final-config quick check started (11:36 UTC, /tmp/r10/quick_final)
- Commit 14d2b4b6 (slime): SLIME_OPT_ROUTER_POLICY=round_robin. Rollout windows 52.33 / 53.16 / 52.75 s, speedup 2.152, 0 retries (/tmp/r9/rollout_rr).
- /submission/switches.json = {BINARY_TOPK=1, SKIP_ZERO_KL=1, NO_RECOMPUTE=1, ROUTER_POLICY=round_robin}.
4.1 hRound 11 — steady-state train profile (py-spy on rank 0, /tmp/r11/train_steady.raw) and routine memory logs
- Run: time --side train with the final switches; py-spy attached after 4 completed steps (about 150 s, 11 395 samples). The recorder costs something: that run's first window was 53.5 s (the judge's windows for the same tree are 47–48 s).
- Main-thread shares (approximate): TE context-parallel attention backward 18 % (line 2869 is a host-side fill of the padded tail, cu_seqlens[-1] → Python int, which syncs with the device; inside TE, not editable here); CPU fused Adam (_fused_adam) 9 %; available_memory() → mem_get_info 5.5 % (routine print_memory calls around sleep, wake and update_weights, six per step); pause (torch_memory_saver) 3 %; gc.collect in clear_memory 3 %; param_copy_back_gpu_hook 3 %; collectives (all-gather, reduce-scatter, all-reduce) ~5 %.
- Change under test: routine_memory_log gates the six routine calls behind SLIME_OPT_ROUTINE_MEMORY_LOGS=0 (logging only; default 1 keeps the reference behaviour; the OOM and error paths call print_memory directly). Timing run: /tmp/r11/train_nomemlog (started 12:21 UTC). Not yet validated.
4.1 hRound 11 result — routine memory logs skipped: **no gain, reverted**
- time --side train with SLIME_OPT_ROUTINE_MEMORY_LOGS=0 (/tmp/r11/train_nomemlog/time.json): windows 47.41 / 47.48 / 46.67 s (speedup 1.411), versus 47.0–47.9 s without the switch. The mem_get_info samples were waiting on device work that the next synchronize() in clear_memory absorbs, so removing the query moves the wait rather than removing it. Reverted (git checkout).
- Remaining steady-state costs are the attention backward (TE, host sync inside TE), CPU Adam at its memory-bandwidth floor, and the sleep/wake machinery. None has a cheap, safe fix in this tree.

### Full-loop integration test (judge's bench/launch.sh, MODE=full, NUM_ROLLOUT=3, with the final switches, under flock)
- Run 1 (/tmp/r12/full_test): invalid setup on my side. I passed SGLANG=/submission/slime_grpo/sglang/python, but launch.sh builds PYTHONPATH=$SGLANG/python, so the engines imported the image's reference sglang (/sgl-workspace/sglang). Its rollouts took 111–119 s, the reference speed. That run does not measure the candidate; it only shows the loop runs end to end (rc 0; train, sleep, weight update, wake, and the step metrics all present). The freeze_gc connection errors come from the reference engines in that setup.
- Run 2 (/tmp/r12/full_test2, started 12:52 UTC): SGLANG=/submission/slime_grpo/sglang. Expected: rollouts ≈ 52 s, train ≈ 47 s, sleep ≈ 4.5 s, update_weights ≈ 2 s per step.
- Run 2 result (/tmp/r12/full_test2, rc 0, 3 RL steps, final switches): rollouts 53.51 / 50.44 / 48.55 s (perf 0–2; the engines import /submission/slime_grpo/sglang, as the bench does). Train steps 52.5 / 58.0 / 38.7 s (steps 0–1 are cold: compile and autotune of new shapes; the judge's priming run covers this). Per step: sleep ≈ 4.3 s, update_weights ≈ 2.1 s, wake ≈ 1.3 s. The freeze_gc failed startup message also appears in the reference runs' logs (a race at engine start), so it is not from this change set.
- Projected steady RL step ≈ 50 (rollout) + 39–47 (train) + 8 (sleep, update, wake) ≈ 97–105 s, against 182 s for the reference: full-loop speedup ≈ 1.75–1.85.
4.9 hRound 12 — base-tensor batched top-k copy (sglang managers/utils.py): no measurable gain, reverted
- Variant: rows that are slices of one [batch, k] device tensor are copied as that tensor (one transfer) and re-sliced on the host; no torch.stack. Self-test against per-row copies: PASS (values equal; mixed k and non-view fallbacks). Under the GPU lock.
- time --side rollout (/tmp/r13/time_rollout_base): windows 52.86 / 52.35 / 60.76 s; retries 0. Windows 1–2 are about 2 % faster than the round-robin run (52.3–53.2 s), within noise. Window 3 was slow across all requests (decode throughput 146 vs 170 tok/s per request), not a straggler, so the host or GPU state, not the copy path.
- Conclusion: the per-step CPU copy work is not the limit; the decode is near the GPU-bound step time (kernel gaps inside the CUDA graph). Reverted; the committed tree stays at 5fa1282 / 14d2b4b6.
5.0 hRound 13 — attention backend (train): rejected
- NVTE_FLASH_ATTN=0 directly: Megatron refuses it (--attention-backend flash requires NVTE_FLASH_ATTN=1).
- Attention backend fused through args.attention_backend (switch added and reverted): train step 0 fails with found NaN in local grad norm for bucket #0 (/tmp/r13/train_fusedattn). The fused kernels do not handle this model's attention (head_dim 256, output gate, CP). Not usable.
5.1 hRound 14 — expensive lever: custom skinny bf16 GEMM for decode (rollout). Negative result, no code shipped.
- sglang already has a Hopper bf16 GEMV (--bf16-gemm-backend gemv), but it only handles m == 1 (bs=1) and some N ranges. Decode runs m = 32 per engine, so it does not apply. A CUDA-core GEMV cannot serve m = 32 (about 32 FLOP per weight byte, compute-bound on CUDA cores), so tensor cores are required.
- Development microbenchmark (not a score; kernel selection only), M = 32, Triton tl.dot with fp32 accumulation, bf16 output, skinny tiles, 2 032-config sweep on the two MLP shapes:
  - gate_up (N = 12 288, K = 4 096, 101 MB): cuBLAS 29.8 µs (3.4 TB/s); best Triton 28.6 µs (4 % better).
  - down (N = 4 096, K = 6 144, 50 MB): cuBLAS 17.1 µs (2.8 TB/s); best Triton 19.7 µs (slower).
  - qkv-like (N = 5 120, K = 4 096): cuBLAS 11.0 µs already at 3.8 TB/s.
- Conclusion: cuBLAS is already within about 70–80 % of DRAM bandwidth on these shapes; a Triton replacement gains at most a few percent on the GEMMs (about 0.1 ms per step, roughly 1 s per rollout), so it is not worth shipping. Correctness of the kernel was fine (relative error ≈ 1e-4 on M ≤ 32).
- Other checks: Megatron pinned CPU grads/params are already the default (no gain); NVTE_FLASH_ATTN=0 and the fused attention backend were rejected earlier; a global is_graph_capturing patch in TE would change six other kernel flags (rejected).
- Started the judge's profile --side train on the current submission (/tmp/r15/profile_train) for the GPU kernel mix of a steady train step.
5.9 hRound 15 — train-side GPU profile (judge `profile --side train`, /tmp/r15/profile_train; gap analysis of rank 2 with /tmp/r15/gaps.py)
- Kernel mix in the traced step (window 55.7 s with profiler overhead): GPU busy 58 %, idle 42 %. NCCL ≈ 21 % of kernel time (AllGather 12 %, ReduceScatter 5 %; ~12.5 K tensor-parallel all-gathers per step, median 92 µs, p90 735 µs). GEMMs (nvjet) ≈ 40 %; GDN (FLA chunk kernels, causal conv1d) ≈ 12 %; elementwise add/copy/fill ≈ 12 %; flash attention ≈ 2 %.
- Main-stream gaps: 40 683 gaps of 0.1–1 ms (11.3 s), 2 952 of 1–10 ms (4.0 s), and 5 gaps over 100 ms (6.2 s). The largest single gap (4.7 s) sits between the last grad-norm/param op and the next AllGather, i.e. the CPU optimizer step (Adam ≈ 4.2 s) with the GPU idle. Most 1–10 ms gaps are before collectives: rank skew (the collective waits for a peer), not PCIe (GPUs are NV18 all-to-all).
- Tried and rejected:
  - Automatic-GC tuning (gc.freeze() + gen-0 threshold 100 000): windows 47.29 / 48.18 / 47.24 s, no gain (reverted).
  - Gradient-accumulation fusion is already on by default in Megatron (--no-… is the opt-out), so the fp32 accumulate adds are not from wgrad.
- CPU Adam microbenchmark (CPU only, no GPU lock; dev only): fused AdamW on 128 M fp32 elements peaks at ≈ 7 G elem/s at 32–48 threads and falls to 5 G at 96 threads. Four ranks share one host, so per-rank thread count may matter. Testing OMP_NUM_THREADS=24 (time run /tmp/r15/train_omp24).
- OMP_NUM_THREADS=24 (all processes, time run /tmp/r15/train_omp24): windows 45.41 / 46.45 / 46.91 s → speedup 1.421 (baseline windows ≈ 47.0–47.9 s). Gain ≈ 1.3 s per train step (≈ 3 %) on the CPU Adam and copy-back. Candidate: set torch.set_num_threads(24) in the train actor only (not the rollout processes). Not yet adopted.
- Rollout profile for the decode gap analysis started (/tmp/r16/profile_rollout) with the current submission.
6.7 hRound 16 — decode critical path (rollout): CPU reductions and pinned-buffer sync check. No gain; reverted.
- Rollout profile with the current submission (/tmp/r16/profile_rollout) and gap attribution (/tmp/r17/gap_owner.py): gaps ≥ 1 ms are launched by aten::index (197 per window). Source: a per-step aten::index, but the CPU was simply late to launch the next kernel, not a host transfer (req_pool_indices is a device tensor).
- py-spy on the scheduler (/tmp/r16/sched_stacks.raw, timing run /tmp/r16/sched_rollout: windows 52.85 / 52.46 / 54.03 s, speedup 2.10): main thread active ≈ 82 % of samples, of which ≈ 20 % is copy_done.synchronize() (the designed overlap wait). Sampler CPU, top-k slicing, per-row pinned copies and metadata are each 2–8 % of samples.
- Two exact CPU reductions implemented and self-tested (unbind for full-width top-k rows; base-tensor D2H copy): time --side rollout (/tmp/r16/time_rollout_cpu): windows 52.88 / 51.85 / 53.72 s, speedup 2.11 vs 2.10–2.15 baseline, 0 retries. No measurable gain → reverted.
- Pinned host tensor creation does not synchronize with a busy GPU once the cache is warm (test: 0.02–0.06 ms per create, 2.3 ms on the first allocation only). So the per-step pinned allocations are not the stall.
- Conclusion: the decode step is GPU-bound at ≈ 5.3 ms of kernel time plus ≈ 1 ms of intra-graph and intra-step latency. Remaining gains would need decode kernel fusion (≈ 2 µs per removed kernel per layer), estimated at a few percent of the rollout for substantial work.
- Final-config quick check (/tmp/r17/quick_final2, switches incl. SLIME_OPT_TRAIN_THREADS=24) in progress at 15:02 UTC.
7.2 hRound 17 — final-configuration validation and a protocol check
- Quick check on the final configuration (/tmp/r17/quick_final2/check.json, 14:49–15:16 UTC): PASS, tier N1. Rollout exact; token-forcing ratio 1.00; tail p = 0.9995; 0 retries. Train record exact; statistical gates within for update norm, second-moment norm, loss, grad norm and update direction; bitwise false (6 418 tensors, as for the reference).
- Committed d37779ef (slime): SLIME_OPT_TRAIN_THREADS (train actor only). Switch file now = {BINARY_TOPK, SKIP_ZERO_KL, NO_RECOMPUTE, ROUTER_POLICY=round_robin, TRAIN_THREADS=24}.
- NCCL protocol test NCCL_PROTO=Simple on top of the final config (/tmp/r17/train_simple): windows 45.94 / 45.41 / 46.40 s vs 45.41 / 46.45 / 46.91 s without it. Difference within noise → not adopted.
- NUMA: the container is bound to node 1 (where the GPUs sit), so memory and CPUs are already local. No affinity change.
- Integration (judge's launch.sh MODE=full, 3 RL steps, final switches, /tmp/r17/full_final) started 15:30 UTC.
7.3 hRound 18 — integration check of the final configuration and remaining-lever assessment
- Full-loop integration with the final switches (/tmp/r17/full_final, judge's launch.sh MODE=full, 3 RL steps): rc 0. Rollouts 53.80 / 50.19 / 48.30 s; sleep ≈ 4.1–4.6 s, update ≈ 1.9–2.0 s, wake ≈ 0.7–1.3 s; no allocator OOM warnings. Judge train clocks give steady full-loop steps of ≈ 96 s (the first step, ≈ 110 s, is cold: autotune of new shapes, which the judge's priming run removes). Traceback lines are the known freeze_gc startup messages.
- Decode-kernel mix per step (rollout profile): TP all-reduce fusion ≈ 15 % of kernel time (6.4 µs per call, 63 calls per step), nvjet GEMMs ≈ 40 %, GDN and norm kernels a few percent each. The all-reduce is latency-bound at 256 KB per call; no safe lever found.
- Remaining levers evaluated and not worth shipping now: custom skinny GEMM (no gain over cuBLAS), decode CPU reductions (no gain), NCCL protocol (noise), GC tuning (no gain), offload fraction (slower), two samples per micro-batch (memory), fused attention (NaN), TE sync patch (unsafe: is_graph_capturing gates six other kernel flags).
- Projected full-loop speedup of the committed configuration ≈ 1.8–1.9 (reference 182 s per RL step vs ≈ 96–100 s).
7.5 hRound 19 — all-reduce fusion backend `mnnvl` for the engines (rollout, switch added and reverted)
- The backend initializes on these GPUs (FlashInfer AllReduce Fusion enabled ... backend=mnnvl), no errors, 0 retries. time --side rollout (/tmp/r17/rollout_mnnvl): windows 52.35 / 51.40 / 53.34 s, speedup 2.13 versus 2.10–2.15 for the default trtllm backend. No gain; reverted.
- sglang's SGLANG_USE_1STAGE_ALLREDUCE applies only on AMD, and the custom all-reduce v2 thresholds are not on the fused decode path. Not tested.
7.5 hRound 20 — Megatron tensor-parallel communication overlap (train), switch added and reverted: blocked at initialization
- --tp-comm-overlap (userbuffers through Transformer Engine) with the NCCL bootstrap and with the gloo bootstrap both fail at actor init: comm_gemm_overlap.cpp:42 ... Assertion failed: intra_domain_group ... getBackendType() == backend (/tmp/r17/train_tpov, /tmp/r17/train_tpov_gloo). The intra-node group that TE creates does not report the bootstrap backend. Likely cause: slime's monkey_patch_torch_dist (active with offload_train) wraps new_group, so TE's group is a wrapper. Fixing it needs changes to slime's process-group layer, not a switch. Not pursued; reverted.
- Expected value if it worked: overlap of the 21 % of GPU time spent in tensor-parallel all-gathers and reduce-scatters (about 5–10 % of the train step).
7.6 hRound 21 — Megatron tensor-parallel communication overlap: the bootstrap is fixed; the userbuffer shape is the next blocker
- Root cause of the earlier assertion (intra_domain_group.getBackendType() == backend): slime's patched torch.distributed.new_group returns a ReloadableProcessGroup wrapper for the groups that Transformer Engine's initialize_ub creates (its world group), and the C++ CommOverlapHelper cannot read a wrapper's backend. Fix tested: create TE's groups with the unwrapped new_group (temporarily restore the original function around Megatron's _initialize_tp_communicators call). Initialization then passes.
- New blocker in the first training step: copy_into_buffer: _ubufs[_tp_id].numel() == input_size fails. Transformer Engine sizes the userbuffers once, from seq_length × micro_batch_size / cp, and our packed micro-batches have variable token counts. Overlap therefore needs every micro-batch padded to one fixed length (a data-path change in slime's batching).
- Estimate: overlap could hide about 60–70 % of the 21 % of GPU time in tensor-parallel collectives (≈ 5–8 % of the train step), but padding to a fixed length costs ≈ 2–3 % (samples are 8.2–8.7 K tokens). Net ≈ 2–4 % of the train step. Not pursued now; changes reverted (commit history unchanged).
7.9 hRound 22 — optimizer offload fraction 0.5 re-examined: the regression is the sleep backup of GPU-resident optimizer state
- time --side train with fraction 0.5 (/tmp/r21/off05): windows 57.81 / 62.34 / 59.13 s (speedup 1.08). Steady-state py-spy of rank 0 (/tmp/r21/off05_stacks.raw, 11 380 samples): torch_memory_saver pause 27 % and resume 8 % of samples, against ≈ 3 % and ≈ 1 % in the all-CPU baseline.
- Cause: slime sets TMS_INIT_ENABLE_CPU_BACKUP=1, so every allocation that is not explicitly excluded is backed up to host memory at sleep and restored at wake. The GPU-resident half of the optimizer state (≈ 27 GB) is therefore copied to host and back every RL step, which costs more than the CPU Adam it saves.
- Keeping that state resident would need it outside the memory saver. Training-phase memory is the limit: full resident state (≈ 54 GB) would not fit beside the training peak, and the half-resident version adds OOM risk to the final evaluation for about 2 % of the loop. Not pursued; reverted.
8.4 hRound 23 (started 16:31 UTC) — host-sync sites in the train step and the sleep/update/wake path
- Diagnostic only (scratch copy /tmp/r23/tree with a warn-only SLIME_OPT_DEBUG_SYNC switch, not in the submission; time --side train /tmp/r23/time_sync, rc 0): torch.cuda.set_sync_debug_mode("warn") lists 27 distinct synchronizing call sites on the train path. Per-micro-batch ones: Transformer Engine context-parallel backward zero-fill dq/dk/dv[cu_seqlens_*_padded[-1]:].fill_(0) (context_parallel.py:2869-2871, eager branch, one host read of a device scalar per call); FLA prepare_chunk_indices repeat_interleave on device counts (fla/ops/utils/index.py:128, avoidable by passing host-side cu_seqlens_cpu); the rerun state machine's DISABLED-mode validation (Megatron rerun_state_machine.py:521). The rest run once per step (metrics, optimizer, data prep).
- Sleep/update/wake per step (full-loop integration /tmp/r17/full_final): sleep 4.1-4.6 s (1.4 s at init), update_weights 1.9-2.0 s, wake_up 0.7-1.3 s. Each sleep destroys 65 process groups (58 NCCL), and update_weights re-creates them. The actor also copies all parameters to pinned host memory at the end of every train step (TensorBackuper.backup("actor"), actor.py:586) and copies them back on wake.
- Next: py-spy on a train actor during a full-loop run (/tmp/r23/prof) to split the sleep/update/wake time between NCCL group churn, the host backup and TMS, before choosing a fix.
- Profile (py-spy on a Megatron actor during a full-loop run, /tmp/r23/prof, 10 min): per RL step, the end-of-step host copy of the actor weights (TensorBackuper.backup) took about 1.7-2.1 s of wall time, most of it in the copy calls. Sleep spent about 1.2 s per step in gc.collect() (the full collector scanning the actor heap), TMS pause about 1 s, and NCCL group destroy about 0.2 s. Update spent about 0.4 s per step in per-parameter all-gathers and 0.2 s in Ray and sync calls. Wake spent about 1 s, mostly gc.collect().
8.4 hRound 23 result: GC freeze and live parameter buffers (both switch-gated, default off in code)
- SLIME_OPT_GC_FREEZE=1 (commit 76d493a9): gc.collect(); gc.freeze() after init. Full-loop integration (/tmp/r23/gc): wake_up 0.3/0.8/0.8 s (was 0.7/1.5/1.6 s), sleep 3.3-4.4 s (was 3.9-4.3 s), update unchanged, train windows unchanged. Net about 0.7 s per step. No change in memory after wake.
- SLIME_OPT_LIVE_PARAMS=1 (commit fb90e4f8): Megatron parameter buffers are allocated under torch_memory_saver.disable() and recorded by address range. They stay on the GPU through sleep. Backup and restore skip them, and the weight update reads them directly. Only enabled without a ref or teacher model. Full-loop integration (/tmp/r23/live): rc 0; the train-end to sleep gap fell from about 1 s to 0 s; update 1.4/1.8/1.8 s (was 1.9-2.4 s); GPU memory after offload 14.3 GB (was 4.5 GB, the parameters kept); the sglang KV pool is unchanged (3 023 676 tokens); the rollouts after updates read as coherent text.
- Full-loop step (exit to exit, steady step after the first): baseline 95.7 s, GC 95.9 s, live 94.6 s; rollouts vary 48-56 s between runs, which hides the 1-2 s gain. The train-side start-to-start interval of the judge includes the backup, so the train side should drop by about 1 s; to be confirmed by time --side train.
- Switch file now: SLIME_OPT_BINARY_TOPK_ONLY, SLIME_OPT_SKIP_ZERO_KL, SLIME_OPT_NO_RECOMPUTE, SLIME_OPT_ROUTER_POLICY=round_robin, SLIME_OPT_TRAIN_THREADS=24, SLIME_OPT_GC_FREEZE=1, SLIME_OPT_LIVE_PARAMS=1.
- Validation in progress: check --quick on the committed tree with this switch file (/tmp/r23/quick, started 17:27 UTC). Full-loop validity of the live path rests on the integration runs above; the quick check exercises the train record and rollout gates only.
- Not pursued: removing the TE context-parallel zero-fill host syncs (1 536 per step, inside an installed package; estimated under 1 s); the FLA chunk-index sync (cached per micro-batch by FLA, small). The remaining sleep cost (about 2 s after the TMS pause, unexplained) and the NCCL group churn are the next candidates.
- check --quick on the committed tree with the new switches (/tmp/r23/quick): PASS, tier N1. Rollout exact; token-forcing mean-|d| ratio and mismatch ratio 0.996 (limit 2.0). Train record exact; bitwise false (6 402 differing tensors, of the same order as the earlier runs); statistical gates PASS; train mismatch ratio 1.00.
- Judge time --side train with the new switches (/tmp/r23/time_train, rc 0): windows 44.63 / 43.85 / 43.43 s, side speedup 1.499 (was 1.42 with windows 45.4-46.9 s). Projected step speedup from the train side alone 1.139; with the rollout side at 2.15 the projection is about 1.85 (was about 1.80).
- Full loop, steady step (judge clocks, exit to exit, minus the reported rollout): about 46 s for train + sleep + update + wake before, and about 2 s less after the change in the sleep, wake and backup phases.
↑ Slime GRPO