Kimi k3.1-pro 1.42×

Harness: Claude Code · switches: BAGEL_OPT_EMPTY_SCATTER=1 BAGEL_OPT_EXPERT_INPUT_NORM=1 BAGEL_OPT_GQA_ATTENTION_VIEWS=1 BAGEL_OPT_PRENORM_QK_SCATTER=1 BAGEL_OPT_SHARED_BF16_MASKS=1 BAGEL_OPT_STATIC_FLEX=1 BAGEL_OPT_UNCHECKPOINT_LAYERS=17 BAGEL_OPT_UNCHECKPOINT_VIT=1 PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True

Judged
1.42×
Tier
N0
Self-best
1.43×
Rounds
20
Hours
10.0
API cost
$18.8
Input tokens · 99.2% cached
78 M
Output tokens
0.2 M
Requests
570
Attention kernel swap (split by mask structure)
✓ BAGEL_OPT_STATIC_FLEX: production mode uses FlexAttention fixed at 11520, 1.18 → 1.38×; deterministic mode falls back to the original SDPA, so the record stays bitwise
Drop activation recompute (28 decoder layers)
partial: 17 layers + ViT. 18–20 layers hit the 135 GiB reservation cap (20 layers left only 1.008×)
Intra-layer MoT fusion (routing / RMSNorm / RoPE / SwiGLU)
bitwise reorderings only: Q/K normalized before scatter (1.376 → 1.399×), input normalization kept expert-local (→ 1.426×). Compiled SwiGLU no end-to-end gain, reverted
Optimizer, EMA, step start / end
✗ fused AdamW measured 1.168×, window spread 4.76%, reverted; direct mixed-precision EMA no gain
Other main levers
skip zero fill that gets overwritten, GQA via views instead of copies (+0.55%, saves 2.1 GiB)
Raw work log22 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — baseline profile
- Started: 2026-11-10T05:29:08+00:00 (4 GPUs; Hopper in this container).
- Frozen reference: 2.6080 s/step, run spread 0.13%; windows 2.6119 and 2.60407 s; peak 82.14 GiB.
- Pre-run GPU check: all four GPUs idle, 0 MiB used; /tmp has ample free space.
- Action: profile the unchanged submission/reference before editing, steps 8–9 on rank 0.
- Command: /opt/bagel-env/bin/python bench/bench.py profile --tree /submission/bagel_sft --config /submission/switches.json --out /tmp/r1/profile from /opt/researchboost/ws.
- Detached PID 8788; log /tmp/r1/profile.log; finished successfully at 05:33:57. GPU hold 218.9 s (0.249 GPU-hour), then all GPUs returned to 0 MiB.
- Profile findings (two profiled steps; CUDA sums overlap and are not wall-time attribution): FSDP collectives dominate the trace: reduce-scatter 1.593 s (22.55%, 116 calls), all-gather 1.076 s (15.23%, 234 calls). aten::mm is 1.487 s (21.05%, 3116 calls). Memory-efficient attention forward/backward is 0.487/0.640 s (338/168 calls); FlashAttention is not on this path. aten::copy_ 0.310 s, mul 0.252 s, indexing/index-put 0.282 s. AdamW is 0.146 s over two steps. Peak allocated 82.13 GiB, reserved 109.02 GiB.
- Classification: exposed FSDP communication is the first configuration/communication hotspot; attention backend/layout and elementwise/index traffic are the next candidates. Profile step times are instrumented and not used as timing results.
- Next: obtain the required uninstrumented baseline time for this unchanged tree, then target one hotspot in round 2.

- Baseline time: /tmp/r1/time/time.json, 2.6081 s/step, speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.0000; windows 2.6107/2.6056 s (range 0.20%), peak allocated 82.14 GiB. Valid run, all ranks exited normally.
- Round 1 ended: 2026-11-10T05:42:47+00:00. No source change, hence no source commit.
0.2 hRound 2 — FSDP forward prefetch
- Started: 2026-11-10T05:43:00+00:00.
- Hotspot from round 1: FSDP all-gathers/reduce-scatters are the largest communication class. Target only forward all-gather exposure this round.
- Change: optional BAGEL_OPT_FSDP_FORWARD_PREFETCH=1 passes FSDP forward_prefetch=True; default remains upstream False. Expected tier N0 because this only changes communication scheduling.
- time (/tmp/r2/time/time.json): 2.6046 s/step, speedup 1.0013, window range 0.19%; not beyond reference noise. Reverted the source change; no commit.
- Same communication-class sweep: test NCCL_PROTO=Simple instead of the observed LL protocol, with no source change. This can change collective reduction order, so prospective tier N1 until measured.
- NCCL_PROTO=Simple time (/tmp/r2/nccl-simple/time.json): 2.6133 s/step, speedup 0.9980, window range 0.29%. No gain; removed.
- Final option in this communication-class sweep: NCCL_ALGO=TREE versus the observed RING algorithm.
- NCCL_ALGO=TREE time (/tmp/r2/nccl-tree/time.json): 2.6066 s/step, speedup 1.0005, window range 0.62%. No gain; removed.
- Round 2 ended: 2026-11-10T06:06:53+00:00. No accepted change and no commit; source diff is empty and switches are empty.
0.7 hRound 3 — sparse FlexAttention for dense training masks
- Started: 2026-11-10T06:07:00+00:00.
- Hotspot from round 1: memory-efficient SDPA forward/backward took 0.487/0.640 s over two profiled steps and computes every masked block. Existing upstream FlexAttention support is not active under the frozen recipe.
- Plan: behind BAGEL_OPT_FLEX_ATTENTION=1, convert each existing dense per-sample mask once in Bagel.forward to a 128-token block mask, then use upstream's compiled flex_attention with native GQA in both attention classes. The batch fields, masks, model parameters and loss arithmetic remain unchanged. Expected tier N1 due to a different attention kernel/reduction order; gate 2b is essential for the interleaved layouts.
- First attempt (/tmp/r3/time/time.json): ERROR before step 65, no timing result. create_block_mask rounds Q/KV lengths up to 128 but the dense masks are unpadded, causing a compiled-kernel index assertion. Fixed the converter with in-bounds tests and clamped reads; padded positions are masked. Rerunning the same round.
- Guarded attempt (/tmp/r3/time-guarded/time.json): ERROR, no timing result. Mask creation succeeded, but Torch 2.5.1 FlexAttention code generation failed on a captured 2-D mask stride (NameError: s6 is not defined). Changed the captured dense mask to a contiguous flat view with equivalent q * KV_LEN + kv indexing for the next attempt.
- Flat-index attempt (/tmp/r3/time-flat/): ran numerically through warmup but compiled for each new mask/shape; steps 1–5 took about 49–89 s each versus the 2.6 s baseline. Stopped deliberately at 06:32, all child processes and GPU memory released. No valid time result. Archived the attempt as /tmp/r3/flex-attempt.patch and reverted both source files; no commit.
- Round 3 ended: 2026-11-10T06:32:30+00:00. FlexAttention is not viable in this form because per-shape mask/attention compilation dominates; its now-inactive switch was removed when round 4 was configured.
1.1 hRound 4 — eliminate overwritten MoT zero-fills
- Started: 2026-11-10T06:33:00+00:00.
- Hotspot from round 1: aten::fill_ 74.97 ms, aten::copy_ 309.6 ms, indexing/index-put 282 ms and aten::mul 251.8 ms over two profiled steps. This round targets only the fills immediately followed by complete indexed overwrites in the MoT forward path.
- Plan: behind BAGEL_OPT_EMPTY_SCATTER=1, use new_empty instead of new_zeros for MoT expert scatter destinations where the understanding and generation indices partition the full sequence. Default remains upstream. Expected tier N0; verify with check --quick.
- check --quick (/tmp/r4/quick/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed.
- time (/tmp/r4/time/time.json): 2.5889 s/step, speedup 1.0074, window range 0.52%; beyond frozen reference noise.
- Paired confirmation (/tmp/r4/time-paired/time.json): candidate 2.5952 s/step, paired reference 2.6074; speedup 1.0047 versus paired reference, 1.0049 versus frozen. Candidate window range 0.59%, reference 0.06%. Two runs agree on a small positive gain; kept as a stacked N0 optimization, not a standalone gate-clearing result.
- Commit: df1fa58 Avoid overwritten MoT scatter zero fills (N0).
- Round 4 ended: 2026-11-10T07:04:00+00:00.
1.6 hRound 5 — profile current best and reduce host/logging collectives
- Started: 2026-11-10T07:04:30+00:00.
- First action: profile commit df1fa58 with BAGEL_OPT_EMPTY_SCATTER=1 before selecting this round's change. Round-1 candidates for this class are ten small collectives per step and repeated loss/metric host synchronizations.
- Profile /tmp/r5/profile/profile.json completed at 07:09:41. Small nccl:all_reduce operations total 67.15 ms over two profiled steps (20 calls). Fill calls dropped from 3004 to 2108 and fill CUDA time from 74.97 to 47.07 ms, confirming round 4. Other leaders remain FSDP reduce-scatter 1.577 s/all-gather 1.030 s, GEMMs 1.524 s, and memory-efficient attention 0.483/0.640 s.
- Change: behind BAGEL_OPT_PACKED_LOGGING=1, combine the two fp32 MFU metrics, three int64 token/sample counts, two fp32 loss metrics, and two fp32 MAX memory metrics into four collectives rather than nine. Loss values are transferred once after the reduction; training normalization keeps the original dtypes and operation order. Expected tier N0.
- check --quick launched as PID 28090, log /tmp/r5/quick.log; result /tmp/r5/quick/check.json: PASS, bitwise N0.
- time (/tmp/r5/time/time.json): 2.5924 s/step, speedup 1.0060 versus frozen, window range 0.39%. This is not an incremental improvement over the fill-only results (1.0074 unpaired and 1.0049/1.0047 paired), so packed logging is classified as no measurable gain. Archived /tmp/r5/packed-logging-attempt.patch, reverted the source, and removed its switch; no commit.
- Round 5 ended: 2026-11-10T07:26:30+00:00.
2.0 hRound 6 — compile SwiGLU elementwise forward/backward
- Started: 2026-11-10T07:27:00+00:00.
- Hotspot from /tmp/r5/profile: aten::mul remains 250.8 ms over two profiled steps, with additional activation/copy traffic. The MoT MLP applies SiLU and multiplication on large [expert_tokens, 18944] intermediates, including activation-checkpoint recomputation and backward.
- Plan: behind BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_SWIGLU=1, compile only F.silu(gate) * up with dynamic=True; keep all GEMMs, dtypes, parameters and checkpointing unchanged. This targets forward and backward fusion without whole-model graph breaks or varying attention compilation. Expected tier N1; use the quick exact-items gate, then full N1 validation only if the accumulated timing gain justifies it.
- check --quick (/tmp/r6/quick/check.json): NOT_BITWISE, exact_items_ok=true; a valid N1 candidate on exactness.
- time (/tmp/r6/time/time.json): 2.5937 s/step, speedup 1.0055 versus frozen, window range 0.60%; no improvement over fill-only timing.
- Diagnostic profile (/tmp/r6/profile): compiled kernels were active, not poisoned by checkpointing: 224 triton_poi_fused_mul_silu_0 and 112 fused backward calls over two steps. Profile CUDA total fell from 7.017 to 6.630 s, but this did not reduce end-to-end wall time; exposed communication/scheduling, rather than this compute chain, limits the step. Archived /tmp/r6/compile-swiglu-attempt.patch, reverted and removed the switch; no commit.
- Round 6 ended: 2026-11-10T07:47:50+00:00.
2.4 hRound 7 — selective decoder activation retention
- Started: 2026-11-10T07:48:00+00:00.
- Hotspot: 234 all-gathers over two profiled steps = 58 wrapped units in the initial forward plus 58 again under checkpoint recomputation. Baseline peak allocation is 82.14 GiB on 140.4 GiB GPUs, leaving memory to avoid some recomputation.
- Plan: BAGEL_OPT_UNCHECKPOINT_LAYERS=K skips activation checkpointing for K decoder layers (selected from the end), leaving all other checkpointing and arithmetic unchanged. Sweep K=4, 8, 12, 16 as memory permits. Expected tier N0 because the same deterministic forward is evaluated once and retained instead of evaluated twice; validate the selected K with quick check.
- K=4 time (/tmp/r7/time-k4/time.json): 2.5149 s/step, speedup 1.0370, window range 0.25%, peak allocated 82.14 GiB, reserved 123.56 GiB. First substantial valid gain; proceeding to K=8.
- K=8 time (/tmp/r7/time-k8/time.json): 2.4517 s/step, speedup 1.0638, window range 0.10%, peak allocated 86.54 GiB, reserved 133.78 GiB. Stronger and stable.
- K=12 is next with PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True, targeting the reservation fragmentation that would otherwise leave too little headroom.
- K=12 + expandable segments time (/tmp/r7/time-k12-expandable/time.json): 2.3733 s/step, speedup 1.0989, window range 0.08%, peak allocated 98.17 GiB, reserved 116.74 GiB. Allocator change lowered reserved memory substantially. K=16 is next with the same allocator.
- K=16 + expandable segments time (/tmp/r7/time-k16-expandable/time.json): 2.3003 s/step, speedup 1.1338, window range 0.45%, peak allocated 109.83 GiB, reserved 128.47 GiB.
- K=16 check --quick (/tmp/r7/quick-k16/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed.
- Commit: b3383a5 Make decoder checkpoint retention configurable (N0). Active switches: empty scatter, 16 retained layers, expandable segments.
- Round 7 sweep ended: 2026-11-10T08:27:09+00:00.
- Full check launched as PID 40512, log /tmp/r7/check-k16.log, output /tmp/r7/check-k16/check.json; no source/config edits while it ran.
- Full check result: PASS, N0, speedup 1.1381; candidate 2.2916 s/step, gate-1 window range 0.46%, record bitwise identical, deterministic and production interleaved-data conformance both PASS. Finished 08:44:59.
3.3 hRound 8 — extend activation retention toward K=20
- Started: 2026-11-10T08:46:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the fully validated b3383a5 / K=16 tree before changing the checkpoint count. The full check establishes the current safe fallback at 1.1381× N0.
- Profile /tmp/r8/profile/profile.json: memory-efficient attention forward calls fell from 338 (round 1) to 242 over two steps; GEMM calls 3116→2860 and CUDA total 7.065→6.028 s. Reduce-scatter/all-gather remain 1.302/0.842 s over two steps. Peak allocated 108.36 GiB, reserved 126.93 GiB in this profile; timing K=16 used 109.83/128.47 GiB.
- Change this round: K=20 with the same committed code and expandable segments, using the remaining memory headroom. No source edit required.
- K=20 time (/tmp/r8/time-k20/time.json): 2.5874 s/step, speedup only 1.0080, window range 2.69%, peak allocated 121.50 GiB, reserved 134.96 GiB. Memory pressure causes a sharp slowdown; rejected. Testing K=18 to bracket the cliff.
- K=18 time (/tmp/r8/time-k18/time.json): 2.2674 s/step, speedup 1.1502, window range 0.31%, peak allocated 115.67 GiB, reserved 134.30 GiB. Stable improvement over K=16. Testing K=19 as the final point before the observed K=20 cliff.
- K=19 time (/tmp/r8/time-k19/time.json): 2.3567 s/step, speedup 1.1066, window range 3.48%, peak allocated 118.58 GiB, reserved 134.97 GiB. Also degraded; rejected. K=18 is the sweep optimum and has been restored.
- check --quick for K=18 launched next, output /tmp/r8/quick-k18/check.json. No source change this round, so no new source commit; the switch file selects K=18 on b3383a5.
- K=18 quick result: PASS, bitwise N0. Round 8 sweep ended 09:19:38; K=20 and K=19 rejected for memory-pressure slowdowns.
- Full K=18 check launched as PID 50723, log /tmp/r8/check-k18.log, output /tmp/r8/check-k18/check.json; no edits while it ran.
- Full K=18 result: PASS, N0, speedup 1.1529; candidate 2.2621 s/step, gate-1 window range 0.21%, record bitwise identical, both interleaved-data modes conforming. Finished 09:36:54. K=18 is the new validated submission.
4.2 hRound 9 — ViT/connector activation retention
- Started: 2026-11-10T09:38:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the fully validated K=18 tree before changing checkpoint policy. Target the remaining smaller checkpointed ViT/connector regions rather than crossing the K=19 decoder memory cliff.
- Profile /tmp/r9/profile/profile.json: 230 memory-efficient SDPA forward calls and 168 backward calls over two steps; FSDP reduce-scatter/all-gather 1.254/0.827 s; total CUDA 5.921 s. Peak allocated 114.02 GiB, reserved 132.62 GiB, leaving about 7.8 GiB reserved headroom.
- Change: BAGEL_OPT_UNCHECKPOINT_VIT=1 retains all SigLIP encoder-layer and connector activations while keeping K=18 decoder retention. Default off. Expected N0; time first because memory pressure is the main failure mode.
- K=18 + ViT time (/tmp/r9/time-vit/time.json): 2.4632 s/step, speedup 1.0588, window range 2.11%, peak allocated 121.05 GiB, reserved 134.96 GiB. Rejected: substantially slower than K=18 alone and unstable at the same reservation ceiling as the K=19/20 failures. Restored the validated K=18 submission switches; no commit.
- Same checkpoint-policy sweep: test K=16 + ViT using /tmp/r9/switches-k16-vit.json. This exchanges two retained decoder layers for the ViT/connector footprint while keeping the validated K=18 configuration active in /submission/switches.json during the experiment.
- K=16 + ViT time (/tmp/r9/time-k16-vit/time.json): 2.2413 s/step, speedup 1.1636, window range 0.03%, peak allocated 115.22 GiB, reserved 133.84 GiB. This improves on K=18 alone without memory-pressure variability.
- K=16 + ViT check --quick (/tmp/r9/quick-k16-vit/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed.
- Promoted K=16 + ViT to /submission/switches.json. Commit: ecffa05 Make ViT checkpoint retention configurable (N0). Round 9 ended 2026-11-10T10:10:00+00:00.
4.2 hFull validation after round 9
- Full check launched as PID 59898, log /tmp/r9/check-k16-vit.log, output /tmp/r9/check-k16-vit/check.json; no source/config edits while it ran.
- Full K=16 + ViT result: PASS, N0, speedup 1.1629; candidate 2.2426 s/step, gate-1 window range 0.44%, record bitwise identical, deterministic and production interleaved-data conformance both PASS. Finished 2026-11-10T10:28:40+00:00. This is the current validated submission.
5.0 hRound 10 — share bf16 packed-attention masks
- Started: 2026-11-10T10:29:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the fully validated ecffa05 / K=16 + ViT tree before changing mask handling. Candidate hotspot for the next change: every decoder layer casts the same fp32 per-sample attention masks to bf16, creating repeated large copies and distinct saved tensors.
- Profile /tmp/r10/profile/profile.json: aten::copy_ 282.95 ms over two steps (5803 calls), 242 memory-efficient SDPA forwards and 168 backwards, aten::cat 91.80 ms. Peak allocated 112.58 GiB, reserved 131.49 GiB. The mask conversion is performed at every SDPA call even though the same input masks are reused by all decoder layers.
- Change: behind BAGEL_OPT_SHARED_BF16_MASKS=1, cast each nested mask once at the start of Bagel.forward; existing per-layer .to(torch.bfloat16) calls then become no-ops on the shared tensors. This is a layout/allocation change with identical mask values and the same SDPA kernel, expected N0. Keep the validated submission switches unchanged and screen with /tmp/r10/switches-mask.json.
- Shared-mask time (/tmp/r10/time-mask/time.json): 2.2379 s/step, speedup 1.1654, window range 0.36%, peak allocated 115.22 GiB, reserved 133.84 GiB. This is only 0.15% faster than the same policy without mask sharing (1.1636), below the measurement resolution, and does not reduce peak memory; classify as a marginal stackable change, not a standalone proven gain.
- Shared-mask check --quick (/tmp/r10/quick-mask/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed. Promoted because it is bitwise and slightly positive rather than slower, with the timing limitation recorded; no claim of resolved incremental speedup. Commit: 9e36f87 Share bf16 packed-attention masks (N0). Round 10 ended 2026-11-10T10:48:00+00:00.
5.3 hRound 11 — profile shared-mask tree and attack attention preparation
- Started: 2026-11-10T10:49:00+00:00.
- First action: profile 9e36f87 with all active switches. Use the trace to verify the reduced conversion count and reassess attention-adjacent copies, especially manual K/V head expansion before memory-efficient SDPA.
- Profile /tmp/r11/profile/profile.json: aten::copy_ remains 283.35 ms/5803 calls; aten::_to_copy count is exactly unchanged from /tmp/r10/profile (3678), with only six additional no-op aten::to events. Thus round 10 did not eliminate actual copies and its 0.15% delta is noise. SDPA still has 242 forward/168 backward calls (347/627 ms), with 160 aten::repeat calls for K/V head expansion.
- Change this round: behind BAGEL_OPT_GQA_ATTENTION_VIEWS=1, only in the MoT training path, split Q into [kv_heads, groups, tokens, head_dim] and expand K/V across the group dimension with stride zero instead of repeating and reshaping them. The same per-head K/V pairs and masks are presented to the same memory-efficient SDPA backend. Expected N0 if the backend accepts the strides; quick gate is mandatory, and gate 2b will be required before any non-bitwise variant could be accepted.
- GQA-view time (/tmp/r11/time-gqa/time.json): 2.2256 s/step, speedup 1.1718, window range 0.08%, peak allocated 113.12 GiB, reserved 131.88 GiB. This is 0.55% faster than round 10 and frees 2.10 GiB allocated memory.
- GQA-view check --quick (/tmp/r11/quick-gqa/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed. Promoted the switch. Commit: 8ca5f51 Avoid materializing grouped K/V attention heads (N0). Round 11 ended 2026-11-10T11:11:00+00:00.
5.7 hRound 12 — retune decoder retention with GQA memory savings
- Started: 2026-11-10T11:12:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the promoted GQA-view tree before changing retention. The 2.10 GiB memory saving may make K=17 viable without the earlier K=19/20 pressure failure.
- Profile /tmp/r12/profile/profile.json: peak allocated 110.54 GiB, reserved 129.34 GiB (2.04/2.15 GiB below round 11). aten::cat fell from 92.18 to 80.30 ms and DtoD copies from 1246 to 910 calls; SDPA time is unchanged, confirming that the gain is preparation/layout rather than a different attention kernel. FSDP reduce-scatter/all-gather remain 1.301/1.194 s over two profiled steps.
- Change: test K=17 with /tmp/r12/switches-k17.json, leaving the validated K=16 submission config active. No source edit or numerics change; quick gate only if the timing is promising.
- K=17 time (/tmp/r12/time-k17/time.json): 2.2083 s/step, speedup 1.1810, window range 0.10%, peak allocated 115.90 GiB, reserved 134.45 GiB. Stable improvement over K=16 (1.1718).
- K=18 time (/tmp/r12/time-k18/time.json): 2.2564 s/step, speedup 1.1558, window range 1.47%, peak allocated 118.69 GiB, reserved 134.97 GiB. Rejected at the memory-pressure ceiling. K=17 is the sweep optimum.
- K=17 check --quick (/tmp/r12/quick-k17/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed. Promoted K=17 to /submission/switches.json; no source change or source commit this round. Round 12 ended 2026-11-10T11:37:00+00:00.
5.7 hFull validation after round 12
- Full check launched as PID 76196, log /tmp/r12/check-k17-gqa.log, output /tmp/r12/check-k17-gqa/check.json; no source/config edits while it ran.
- Full K=17 + GQA result: PASS, N0, speedup 1.1823; candidate 2.2058 s/step, record bitwise identical, deterministic and production interleaved-data conformance both PASS. Finished 2026-11-10T11:54:22+00:00. This is the current validated submission.
6.4 hRound 13 — direct token-major attention output layout
- Started: 2026-11-10T11:55:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the fully validated K=17 + GQA tree before changing output layout. Target the remaining per-layer sample concatenation and transpose/reshape copy after SDPA.
- Profile /tmp/r13/profile/profile.json: aten::cat 79.93 ms (528 calls), aten::copy_ 282.62 ms (5727 calls), SDPA forward/backward 335.31/619.62 ms over two steps. Peak allocated 113.20 GiB, reserved 131.98 GiB. The GQA path still concatenates head-major sample outputs and then transposes/reshapes to token-major before the output projections.
- Change: behind BAGEL_OPT_DIRECT_ATTENTION_OUTPUT=1, coupled to the active GQA-view path, allocate the final token-major bf16 buffer once and copy_ each SDPA result's permuted view directly into its sample slice. This removes the intermediate cat and transpose/reshape, with identical element order; expected N0. Screen with /tmp/r13/switches-direct.json while leaving the validated submission switches active.
- Direct-output time (/tmp/r13/time-direct/time.json): 2.2102 s/step, speedup 1.1800, window range 0.06%, peak allocated 115.90 GiB, reserved 134.49 GiB. No improvement over K=17 + GQA (1.1810 standalone, 1.1823 full check); slightly slower within noise.
- Direct-output check --quick (/tmp/r13/quick-direct/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, but rejected for no timing gain. Archived /tmp/r13/direct-output-attempt.patch and reverted; no commit.
- Same attention-class sweep: try the standard cuDNN SDPA backend behind BAGEL_OPT_CUDNN_ATTENTION=1, retaining the GQA views and all other validated settings. This changes kernels and is prospective N1; it must pass deterministic quick, interleaved conformance and trajectory gates if fast enough.
- cuDNN + GQA time (/tmp/r13/time-cudnn/time.json): ERROR before step 65, RuntimeError: No available kernel; no timing result. Testing one control with the original materialized K/V layout at K=16 to distinguish the stride-zero layout restriction from general cuDNN mask support. Validated submission config remains unchanged.
- cuDNN + materialized K/V control (/tmp/r13/time-cudnn-repeat/time.json): same ERROR, No available kernel; cuDNN does not support this packed masked attention call in the installed build, independent of GQA layout. Archived /tmp/r13/cudnn-attempt.patch, reverted, and closed the backend direction. No commit.
- Round 13 ended 2026-11-10T12:24:00+00:00. Direct output was N0 but no-gain; both cuDNN forms were unavailable.
6.9 hRound 14 — fused AdamW
- Started: 2026-11-10T12:25:00+00:00.
- First action: reprofile the restored validated K=17 + GQA tree. The prior profile charges 146.20 ms over two steps to AdamW, with multi-tensor kernels and substantial host work; verify before testing PyTorch's fused implementation at unchanged fp32 state and hyperparameters.
- Profile /tmp/r14/profile/profile.json: Optimizer.step#AdamW.step 146.54 ms over two steps. Its visible multi-tensor components include _foreach_addcdiv_ 29.93 ms, _foreach_addcmul_ 23.06 ms, _foreach_lerp_ 22.74 ms and associated launches. FSDP collectives and attention remain larger, but AdamW is a self-contained 3.3%-of-wall candidate.
- Change: behind BAGEL_OPT_FUSED_ADAMW=1, pass fused=True to the same single torch.optim.AdamW instance. Learning rate, betas, eps, weight decay, parameter groups, fp32 master weights and fp32 moments remain unchanged. Expected N1 due to kernel arithmetic ordering; screen with /tmp/r14/switches-fused.json, then quick exact items and full N1 gates only if the gain justifies them.
- Fused-AdamW time (/tmp/r14/time-fused/time.json): 2.2331 s/step, speedup 1.1679, window range 4.76%, peak allocated 115.90 GiB, reserved 134.45 GiB. Slower and less stable than the validated 1.1823 tree; rejected without spending an N1 validation run. Archived /tmp/r14/fused-adamw-attempt.patch, reverted, no commit.
- Round 14 ended 2026-11-10T12:38:00+00:00.
7.2 hRound 15 — remove EMA cast temporaries
- Started: 2026-11-10T12:39:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the restored validated tree with attention on EMA casts and foreach updates. fsdp_ema_update explicitly materializes an fp32 copy of every trained bf16 flat parameter before _foreach_mul_ and _foreach_add_; determine whether direct mixed-dtype foreach inputs can eliminate that traffic without changing the fp32 EMA arithmetic.
- Profile /tmp/r15/profile/profile.json: aten::copy_ 284.99 ms over two steps; _foreach_mul_ 32.57 ms and _foreach_add_ 39.07 ms, plus other optimizer/EMA operations. The explicit EMA cast is inside the copy class and also creates a large short-lived fp32 buffer every step.
- Change: behind BAGEL_OPT_DIRECT_EMA_CAST=1, pass each bf16 model flat parameter directly to the existing fp32 _foreach_add_ rather than materializing .to(dtype=ema_dtype) first. The EMA tensors and stored state remain fp32 and the decay/alpha are unchanged. Expected N0 if TensorIterator performs the same bf16-to-fp32 conversion inline; verify bitwise and reject immediately if the foreach API falls back or slows down.
- Direct-EMA time (/tmp/r15/time-ema/time.json): 2.2117 s/step, speedup 1.1792, window range 0.16%, peak allocated 115.90 GiB, reserved 134.45 GiB. No gain and identical memory versus the validated 1.1823 tree.
- Direct-EMA check --quick (/tmp/r15/quick-ema/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, but rejected for no benefit. Archived /tmp/r15/direct-ema-attempt.patch, reverted, no commit. Round 15 ended 2026-11-10T12:57:00+00:00.
7.5 hRound 16 — static-shape packed FlexAttention
- Started: 2026-11-10T12:58:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the restored validated K=17 + GQA tree before replacing its attention kernel. Round 3 established that unpadded FlexAttention recompiled for each shape; this attempt uses a fixed 11520-token packed extent and one block-diagonal mask per batch, rather than repeating that per-sample varying-shape design.
- Profile /tmp/r16/profile/profile.json: memory-efficient SDPA forward/backward 334.92/624.83 ms over two steps (236/168 calls), still the largest attention-compute class. Peak allocated 113.20 GiB, reserved 131.98 GiB.
- Design: behind BAGEL_OPT_STATIC_FLEX=1, assemble the existing per-sample dense masks into one boolean block-diagonal mask of fixed 11520×11520 extent, generate a 128-token BlockMask, and pad packed Q/K/V to that same static extent for one FlexAttention call per layer. Padded and masked blocks are false; only the original tokens are returned. All mask content comes from the unchanged batch, including interleaved noise and adjacent-image rules. Static Q/K/V and block-index shapes should eliminate round-3 recompilation. Prospective N1 due to a different kernel/reduction order; deterministic quick and gate 2b are decisive.
- Static-FlexAttention time (/tmp/r16/time-static-flex/time.json): 1.8952 s/step, speedup 1.3761, window range 0.15%, peak allocated/reserved 114.03/132.87 GiB, startup 173.1 s. Valid run with no recompile invalidation; the static shapes resolved round 3's repeated-compilation failure.
- Initial deterministic check --quick (/tmp/r16/quick-static-flex/check.json): ERROR before completing step 0, not a numeric mismatch. Torch compilation left a dead weak proxy tracked by GC; the judge's gc.get_objects() FSDP-root discovery raised ReferenceError: weakly-referenced object no longer exists in the optimizer post-hook. Production timing does not perform that root scan and completed normally.
- Compatibility fix within the same attention hotspot: when deterministic algorithms are enabled, use the already validated shared-bf16-mask/GQA memory-efficient SDPA path at the same precision; static FlexAttention remains the production path. This is the task's permitted deterministic fallback and avoids the compiler weak-proxy failure without changing deterministic numerics. Re-running quick with /tmp/r16/quick-static-fallback as the new output directory.
- Deterministic-fallback check --quick (/tmp/r16/quick-static-fallback/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed. Promoted BAGEL_OPT_STATIC_FLEX=1; this is an N0 candidate pending mandatory production and deterministic interleaved-layout conformance in the full check.
- Commit: 4ff708e Use static packed FlexAttention in production (N0; 1.3761x). Full check ran as detached PID 97392, log /tmp/r16/check-static-flex.log.
- Full check (/tmp/r16/check-static-flex/check.json): PASS, N0, speedup 1.3762, candidate 1.8951 s/step. Record bitwise identical; deterministic interleaved conformance exact; production interleaved conformance PASS with N/J/B distances 0.005489/0.005147/0.004702 and N/J ratios 1.098/1.029 (limit 3.0). Finished 2026-11-10T13:50:15+00:00; all GPUs returned to 0 MiB. This is the new validated submission.
- Round 16 ended: 2026-11-10T13:51:00+00:00.
8.4 hRound 17 — profile static FlexAttention and reduce mask metadata
- Started: 2026-11-10T13:52:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the fully validated 4ff708e static-FlexAttention tree before changing it. Candidate mask hotspot: _dense_to_static_block_mask currently builds H=num_heads identical sparse-mask head planes even though mask_mod ignores h; the installed FlexAttention kernel supports one shared sparse head via modulo indexing.
- Profile /tmp/r17/profile/profile.json: FSDP reduce-scatter/all-gather 1.094 s/783.83 ms over two profiled steps; aten::mm 1.344 s. FlexAttention-associated triton_, triton_tem_fused_zeros_1 and triton_tem_fused_0 kernels total 343.16+220.59+117.46=681.20 ms over two steps (192/56/78 calls). The block-mask reduction itself is only 0.088 ms over two steps, so eliminating duplicate mask head planes is not a promising hotspot. Peak allocated/reserved 112.46/131.51 GiB.
- Revised target within the same attention class: make static block granularity configurable with BAGEL_OPT_STATIC_FLEX_BLOCK_SIZE, default 128, and test 64. Finer blocks can skip more masked causal/interleaved work while retaining exactly the same dense boolean mask and static 11520-token Q/KV extents. Production-only kernel change; deterministic SDPA fallback remains bitwise N0. Screen with /tmp/r17/switches-block64.json; full gate 2b is required before promotion.
- Block-64 time (/tmp/r17/time-block64/time.json): 1.9542 s/step, speedup 1.3346, window range 0.29%. Slower than validated block-128 (1.8951–1.8952 s/step, 1.3761–1.3762); finer sparsity does not compensate for kernel overhead.
- Block-256 time (/tmp/r17/time-block256/time.json): ERROR before step 65, no timing result. The installed FlexAttention path caused an illegal memory access (reported asynchronously as CUBLAS execution failure on rank 0); rejected. Archived /tmp/r17/block-size-attempt.patch, reverted the configurable block size, and restored clean 4ff708e. No quick check or commit because neither option improved timing and the production kernel was not promotable.
- Round 17 ended: 2026-11-10T14:11:00+00:00. Block 128 remains optimal among 64/128/256 in this implementation.
8.7 hRound 18 — retune decoder retention with FlexAttention memory savings
- Started: 2026-11-10T14:12:00+00:00.
- First action: reprofile the restored, fully validated block-128 tree. Round 17 measured 112.46/131.51 GiB allocated/reserved in profile and static timing previously measured 114.03/132.87 GiB, about 1.6 GiB more reserved headroom than the pre-Flex K=17 configuration. Test whether one additional retained decoder layer now fits without the earlier K=18 memory-pressure slowdown.
- Profile /tmp/r18/profile/profile.json: consistent with round 17—FSDP reduce-scatter/all-gather 1.096 s/793.17 ms over two steps, aten::mm 1.306 s, FlexAttention-associated kernels 683.11 ms, peak allocated/reserved 112.46/131.51 GiB. No source edit was needed for this retention-only sweep.
- K=18 + static FlexAttention time (/tmp/r18/time-k18/time.json): 1.9051 s/step, speedup 1.3690, window range 1.97%, peak allocated/reserved 116.71/134.80 GiB. Slower and less stable than validated K=17 (1.8951 s/step, 1.3762); memory pressure again offsets eliminated recomputation. Kept /submission/switches.json at K=17; no quick check or commit because source and numerics did not change and timing regressed.
- Round 18 ended: 2026-11-10T14:24:00+00:00.
8.9 hRound 19 — profile MoT expert data movement
- Started: 2026-11-10T14:25:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the validated K=17/block-128 tree before selecting the next change. The latest trace still charges 283.81 ms to aten::copy_, 123.44 ms to _index_put_impl_, and 110.66 ms to aten::index over two steps. Inspect whether redundant MoT expert gather/scatter operations can be removed without changing token order or arithmetic.
- Profile /tmp/r19/profile/profile.json: aten::copy_ 275.36 ms, _index_put_impl_ 122.98 ms, aten::index 110.64 ms over two steps; FSDP reduce-scatter/all-gather 1.092 s/731.76 ms and aten::mm 1.302 s. Peak allocated/reserved 112.46/131.51 GiB.
- Change: behind BAGEL_OPT_PRENORM_QK_SCATTER=1, keep MoT Q/K projection outputs expert-local through their existing per-expert RMSNorm calls, then scatter each normalized result into the packed buffer once. Upstream scatters unnormalized Q/K, gathers them for RMSNorm, and scatters normalized values into second full buffers. Projection and norm input shapes, token order, dtypes and arithmetic are unchanged; redundant gathers, indexed writes, backward scatter traffic and two full Q/K buffers are removed. Expected N0; time and deterministic quick record are required.
- Expert-local Q/K time (/tmp/r19/time-prenorm/time.json): 1.8638 s/step, speedup 1.3993, window range 1.14%, peak allocated/reserved 114.03/133.10 GiB. Valid run, about 1.7% faster than the prior 1.8951–1.8952 s/step tree.
- check --quick (/tmp/r19/quick-prenorm/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed. Promoted BAGEL_OPT_PRENORM_QK_SCATTER=1; full interleaved conformance is still required.
- Commit: c94ce89 Normalize MoT QK before packed scatter (N0; 1.3993x). Full check ran as detached PID 113637, log /tmp/r19/check-prenorm.log.
- Full check (/tmp/r19/check-prenorm/check.json): PASS, N0, speedup 1.4074, candidate 1.8530 s/step. Record bitwise identical; deterministic interleaved conformance exact; production PASS with N/J/B distances 0.005637/0.005136/0.004592 and N/J ratios 1.127/1.027. Finished 2026-11-10T15:01:06+00:00; all GPUs returned to 0 MiB. This is the new validated submission.
- Round 19 ended: 2026-11-10T15:02:00+00:00.
9.6 hRound 20 — keep decoder input normalization expert-local
- Started: 2026-11-10T15:03:00+00:00.
- First action: profile the fully validated c94ce89 tree. The remaining MoT decoder path scatters input-RMSNorm outputs into a full packed buffer, after which PackedAttentionMoT immediately gathers the same expert tokens for Q/K/V projections. Target that redundant full-buffer round trip separately from round 19's Q/K normalization.
- Profile /tmp/r20/profile/profile.json: round 19 reduced aten::index calls from 1856 to 1320 and _index_put_impl_ calls from 2374 to 1726 over two steps; their CUDA times are now 86.87/96.09 ms. aten::copy_ is 303.77 ms, FSDP reduce-scatter/all-gather 1.070 s/778.81 ms, and peak allocated/reserved 112.46/131.53 GiB.
- Change: behind BAGEL_OPT_EXPERT_INPUT_NORM=1, compute the existing input RMSNorm on the gathered expert tokens, pass those expert-local outputs directly to PackedAttentionMoT, and use the original packed tensor only as the shape/dtype reference for output allocations. Default retains the full normalized buffer and subsequent gathers. Norm/projection shapes, token order, dtypes and arithmetic are unchanged; expected N0, with timing and quick record before promotion.
- Expert-input time (/tmp/r20/time-expert-input/time.json): 1.8288 s/step, speedup 1.4261, window range 0.38%, peak allocated/reserved 114.03/133.13 GiB. Valid run, improving on the prior full-check 1.8530 s/step.
- check --quick (/tmp/r20/quick-expert-input/check.json): PASS, bitwise N0, all exact items passed. Promoted BAGEL_OPT_EXPERT_INPUT_NORM=1; full interleaved validation is required before treating the combined tree as accepted.
↑ BAGEL SFT