GPT-6.2 Astra 1.84×
Harness: Codex · switches: BAGEL_SELECTIVE_CHECKPOINT=1 BAGEL_PACKED_FLASH=1 BAGEL_EXPERT_LAYOUT=1 BAGEL_FUSED_RMS=1 BAGEL_CHECKPOINT_GATE=1 BAGEL_REMAT_DOWN_INPUT=1 BAGEL_FUSED_ADAMW=1 BAGEL_FUSE_GATE_REMAT=1 BAGEL_FSDP_AVG_SCATTER=1 BAGEL_FUSED_ROPE=1 BAGEL_GATHER_ROPE=1 (BAGEL_VAE_GROUP_SWISH: its fused VAE GroupNorm failed the interleaved-layout gate (2b, ratio 3.44 > 3); scored without it, 1.84×)BAGEL_VAE_GROUP_SWISH=1
- Judged
- 1.84×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 1.93×
- Rounds
- 18
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $45.2
- Input tokens · 96.3% cached
- 51 M
- Output tokens
- 0.3 M
- Requests
- 356
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log18 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — selective activation checkpointing (19:14:57–19:32:30)
- Profile submitted 19:14:33; GPU lock acquired 19:14:57. Unchangeda2fa77d, empty switches. PID 9310;/tmp/r1/profile.log; output/tmp/r1/profile. - Frozen baseline: 2.63397 s/step; 2.64% spread. The localcheckrequires more than 1.0528x. Peak allocated: 82.14 GiB. - Baseline profile completed at 19:19:08. Two-step rank-0 kernel totals (overlap included): 68.5% backward, 25.7% model forward. NCCL 38.8% (reduce-scatter 22.7%, gather 15.2%);mm20.9%,addmm1.4%, efficient attention 9.1% backward / 6.9% forward, copies 4.4%, mul 3.6%. Of 2.65 s in the two main collectives, 1.60 s overlaps compute. The ranks do not necessarily process equally expensive packs. The reference repeats forward GEMMs and SDPA in non-reentrant checkpoint recomputation. - Experiment in detached worktree/tmp/bagel-exp: keep upstream FSDP layout and checkpoint boundaries; cache ATen GEMM and efficient SDPA outputs per checkpoint rather than evaluating them again. Switch/tmp/r1/switches.json. Expected exact (to verify). JudgetimePID 10609,/tmp/r1/time.log, submitted 19:21:32. - Quick check queued after a successful timing run (PID 11394,/tmp/r1/quick.log). -timefinished 19:27:41,/tmp/r1/time/time.json: 1.1347x, 2.3212 s/step, window range 0.85%, peak 99.54 GiB allocated. Beyond reference noise. No extra libraries. -/tmp/r1/quick/check.json: PASS N0 at 19:32:30, all record hashes identical. Promoted and committed96128ad, including the optimization only when enabled. Fullcheckqueued after the next profile, PID 13174,/tmp/r1/check.log, output/tmp/r1/check. - Full check finished 20:05:59: INCORRECT (/tmp/r1/check/check.json). Gate 1: 1.1418x. Gate 2 bitwise; gate 2b deterministic distances all zero, production (N,J,B) = (0.00399,0.00478,0.00426), conforming. Gate 3: 13/14 endpoints within 3σ, but ViT displacement over steps 50–100 was −4.516σ (−0.0012082; bound 0.0008027). Not an accepted version. Do not retry this unchanged configuration. Disable it as a standalone configuration while checking the distinct packed-attention path.
0.3 hRound 2 — packed GQA (19:33:20–20:16:48; R1 full check excluded)
- 19:32:56: started profile of96128adwith the submitted switches. PID 13173;/tmp/r2/profile.log; output/tmp/r2/profile. - GPU lock 19:33:20, profile completed 19:37:29. Rank 0: backward 64.8%, model forward 28.4%. Collectives 39.2% including overlap, GEMM (mm) 18.7%. Efficient attention (SM80 CUTLASS) 10.4% backward, 3.9% forward, despite using a Hopper GPU; the nested mask path repeats KV heads and invokes SDPA per sample. Selected the attention backend/layout for this round. - In the experiment worktree only: plan two variable-length FlashAttention groups from the real nested additive masks once per batch, gathering exactly the keys each span can see. Grouped-query attention without repeating heads. Verify the entire mask representation and fall back to SDPA on arbitrary nonrepresentable masks. No changes to data, noise, parameter layout or optimizer. Uses flash-attn's deterministic backward in strict mode. SwitchBAGEL_PACKED_FLASH=1on top of round 1; expected N1. - CPU proof check/tmp/test_bagel_mask_plan.py: all 1,089 synthetic sample masks reconstructed entry-for-entry, covering adjacent full spans, interleaved noise and length-one spans; three unsupported mask cases fell back. Locked GPU forward/backward probe followed bytimequeued after the full R1 check. PID 16452,/tmp/r2/probe.logand/tmp/r2/time.log, timing output/tmp/r2/time. - Round 2 quick check queued after successful timing: PID 16480,/tmp/r2/quick.log, output/tmp/r2/quick. The round 1 full check holds the GPUs in the meantime (not counted toward the round). - Locked GPU probe passed after the R1 full check: relative L2 from dense SDPA (output, dQ, dK, dV) = (0.00168,0.00369,0.00491,0.00357) in production, similar in strict mode with bitwise equality on a repeated strict backward. No performance timing in this probe. -timefinished 20:11:57:/tmp/r2/time/time.json, 1.2950x vs frozen baseline, 2.0339 s/step (2.0242, 2.0437), peak allocated 97.13 GiB, no notes. Relative to round 1: 1.141x. Strongest tested candidate, promoted for validation; the previous config has no full pass. - Commit924e314.checkqueued after quick and the next profile, PID 23431,/tmp/r2/check.log, output/tmp/r2/check. Round 3 profile queued on the same measured candidate, PID 23430,/tmp/r3/profile.log, output/tmp/r3/profile. - Quick finished 20:16:48:/tmp/r2/quick/check.jsonNOT_BITWISE, all exact items passed as expected; conformance and statistical gates pending. - Full check finished 20:48:35: PASS N1, 1.2896x (/tmp/r2/check/check.json). Exact items, deterministic and production conformance, and all 14 trajectory endpoints passed; largest absolute endpoint difference 1.36σ. This is the submitted, full-checked fallback while later experiments run.
1.1 hRound 3 — decoder expert layout (20:17:16–20:59:07; R2 full check excluded)
- Profile of924e314with both submitted switches: PID 23430,/tmp/r3/profile.log, output/tmp/r3/profile. - GPU lock 20:17:16; profile completed 20:21:22. Kernel-duration stage shares: 63.6% backward, 28.7% model forward. NCCL 40.1% with substantial overlap/wait (one gather 221 ms, median 0.185 ms), GEMM 21.1% (mm), copies 5.5%, mul 4.9%, FA varlen backward 3.5% and forward 2.7%.index+index_putalone 5.4%, 5,144 calls over two steps; device idle 10%. Chose repeated expert routing/layout traffic, also a source of zero-fills, cats, and backward accumulation. - ExperimentalBAGEL_EXPERT_LAYOUT=1: for a verified partition, keep hidden states and rotary tables in[understanding; generation]order across the decoder, composing the attention plan with that permutation once per forward. The expert-local operations consume contiguous rows, not repeated scatter-then-gather buffers. Restore normal output order before losses. Original paths for other layouts, frozen understanding, or other layer types. The two-layer synthetic CPU decoder probe (mixed nested masks, permuted expert IDs) reproduced the output and all 59 gradient tensors exactly. - Queue after the R2 full check: locked real-GPU probe thentime(PID 27736;/tmp/r3/probe.log,/tmp/r3/time.log, output/tmp/r3/time);check --quick(PID 27737;/tmp/r3/quick.log, output/tmp/r3/quick). No R3 performance claim yet; submitted tree unchanged in this round. - GPU probe: two-layer decoder outputs and all 59 gradients bitwise identical to R2.timefinished 20:54:19: 1.4334x (/tmp/r3/time/time.json), 1.8376 s/step (1.8305,1.8447), allocated peak 97.10 GiB; 1.107x vs R2. Experiment committed2546ff8; full check queued on a clean worktree/tmp/bagel-r3-eval(PID 34360,/tmp/r3/check.log, output/tmp/r3/check). R4 profile queued immediately before that full check (PID 34359,/tmp/r4/profile.log, output/tmp/r4/profile). - Quick finished 20:59:07: NOT_BITWISE vs upstream (all exact items pass). Relative to the full-passed R2 version, all 4,224 rank/step digest entries matched bitwise (/tmp/r3/quickvs/tmp/r2/quick). R3 still requires the full judge independently. - Full check finished 21:29:53: PASS N1, 1.4437x (/tmp/r3/check/check.json). Both conformance runs and all 14 endpoints passed (largest absolute endpoint bias 2.33σ). Promoted this exact source tree and its three overrides to the submission.
1.8 hRound 4 — fused RMSNorm (20:59:34–21:40:13; R3 full check excluded)
- Profile of the strongest screened experiment2546ff8, with/tmp/r3/switches.json; PID 34359,/tmp/r4/profile.log. - GPU lock 20:59:34, finished 21:03:31. Stages (kernel sums, overlap included): backward 66.2%, model forward 25.2%. NCCL 37.0%,mm25.1%, copies 6.3%, mul about 5.6%; 13.4% of the device interval idle. Correlated trace over 2 steps: 62.1 ms of copies under ToCopyBackward, 25.1 ms of multiplies under PowBackward, 104.7 ms MulBackward mul, plus forward and replayed pow/mean/mul/cast chains. Selected the many-pass Qwen RMS normalizations of hidden vectors and Q/K heads. - Experiment only: use genericliger-kernel==0.6.2RMSNorm kernels (installed with--no-depsonly in/opt/candidate-env), fp32 reduction, Llama/Qwen cast-before-scale convention. The backward launch uses fixed row tiles rather than specializing compilation on every varying expert length; disjoint gradient writes and fp32 weight partials followed by reduction, no atomics or in-place overwrite of incoming gradients.BAGEL_FUSED_RMS=1on top of R3; unchanged paths for incompatible dtype/layout. CPU import/fallback and syntax checks passed. - Queued after R3 full check: locked GPU forward/backward precision and deterministic repeat probe, thentime(PID 39367,/tmp/r4/probe.log,/tmp/r4/time.log, output/tmp/r4/time); quick (PID 39368,/tmp/r4/quick.log, output/tmp/r4/quick). - GPU probe passed: 6 shapes/scales, including 128-wide heads and 3584-wide hidden states. Maximum relative L2 (output, input grad, weight grad) = (1.17e-5, 0.00287, 0.00114); each repeated strict-mode output and gradient bitwise identical.timefinished 21:35:28: 1.6029x, 1.6433 s/step (1.6320, 1.6546), peak allocated 96.54 GiB and no notes,/tmp/r4/time/time.json. Incremental 1.118x vs R3. Experiment commit3811638includes optional dependency and switch documentation. - Full check queued in stable/tmp/bagel-r4-evalafter the next profile, PID 47014,/tmp/r4/check.log, output/tmp/r4/check; R5 profile PID 47013,/tmp/r5/profile.log, output/tmp/r5/profile. - Quick finished 21:40:13:/tmp/r4/quick/check.jsonNOT_BITWISE, all exact items passed. Cumulative timing 1.6029x; submitted fallback remains R3 pending full check. - Full check finished 22:10:02: PASS N1, 1.6019x,/tmp/r4/check/check.json. Both conformance modes passed. Every endpoint was within one reference σ (largest absolute 0.96σ). Promoted the identical tree, its four switches and the installed generic Liger dependency.
2.5 hRound 5 — MoT gate-only checkpointing (21:40:37–22:35:23; R4 full check excluded)
- Profiling R4 with its four switches using/tmp/r5/profile.log(PID 47013), before the R4 full check. - Lock 21:40:37; profile completed 21:44:27. Backward 62.0%, forward 27.4%, NCCL 38.0% incl overlap,mm27.6%, cat 3.0%, mul 2.4%; device idle 11.7%. Trace correlation showed about 76 ms of forward FlashAttention kernels inside backward functions over two steps, plus 34.6 msindex_select, 28.5 msmul, 21.7 mscat, 13.4 mssiluunderMmBackward0. GEMMs are cached, but the checkpoint still replays the rest of the entire MoT decoder body. R4's model already has compact expert states and fused norms, with 96.54 GiB peak, so checkpoint placement is worth revisiting. - ExperimentalBAGEL_CHECKPOINT_GATE=1: move the MoT decoder rematerialization boundary down to just SiLU(gate) × up using PyTorch non-reentrant checkpointing, with no RNG state manipulation for this random-free expression. Projection, attention, layout, and norm states are otherwise retained. ViT and connector policies unchanged. CPU probe exactly matched forward, input grad and all three FFN parameter grads at three token counts; the two-layer layout probe also remained exact. -timequeued after the R4 full check (PID 52097,/tmp/r5/time.log, output/tmp/r5/time); quick after a successful timing run (PID 52098,/tmp/r5/quick.log, output/tmp/r5/quick). - Initialtimefinished 22:15:39: 1.5494x vs frozen, 1.7000 s/step (1.7175,1.6825), slower than R4's 1.6433 s/step. Peak allocated 117.37 vs 96.54 GiB; reserved 134.96 GiB. Experimental commit0a69866, not promoted. Queued a diagnostic profile of this memory-heavier path (PID 60267,/tmp/r5/diagnose.log, output/tmp/r5/diagnose) to distinguish memory allocation stalls from compute before spending the rest of the round. - Native-allocator quick: all exact items pass, NOT_BITWISE vs upstream; all 4,224 shard/step digests identical to R4. Diagnostic profile finished 22:24:43: R5 made 449cudaMalloccalls (324 ms host time) and 446cudaFreecalls (77 ms) in two steps; R4 made zero of both in its corresponding trace. This exposes allocation churn from the larger live activation set, not an increase in model arithmetic. Testing the allocator's variable-shape expandable-segment option, separately switched byPYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True. Timing PID 62414,/tmp/r5/time-expandable.log, output/tmp/r5/time-expandable; quick queued if faster than R4 (PID 62415,/tmp/r5/quick-expandable.log, output/tmp/r5/quick-expandable). - Allocator screen finished 22:30:31:/tmp/r5/time-expandable/time.json= 1.6493x, 1.5970 s/step (1.5780,1.6160), peak allocated 117.33 GiB. Not a demonstrated gain from that switch: all four ranks explicitly warned that expandable segments are not supported on this platform. The two ordinary-allocator runs therefore bracket R4 and do not establish a reliable benefit. Do not promote or use the unsupported knob. R4 is still the strongest accepted version. - Its quick check finished 22:35:23: NOT_BITWISE, exact items pass,/tmp/r5/quick-expandable/check.json. Round ended after 29m35s excluding the full check. No new full check or promotion for this noisy/no-gain configuration.
3.4 hRound 6 — reduce retained FFN data (22:35:50–23:02:22)
- Re-profile the full-passed R4 submission across four packs (steps 5–8),/tmp/r6/profile, PID 64852,/tmp/r6/profile.log. - Lock 22:35:50, profile finished 22:39:58. 61.3% backward, 28.3% forward;mm30.0%, NCCL reduce-scatter 17.8% and all-gather 17.8% incl overlap. Device-interval union idle 13.0%, all-gather alone 8.2%. Zero CUDA alloc/free calls in this R4 sample. Contrasting R5's 449 allocs/446 frees and 29.4% all-gather-only time on the straggler-heavy profile, target the wide dynamic FFN buffers which prevented profitable finer checkpointing. Keep the submitted R4 intact. - Two independent remedies screened: (1) Native allocatorroundup_power2_divisions:8on R5, PID 67073,/tmp/r6/time-rounded.log,/tmp/r6/time-rounded, config/tmp/r6/rounded.json; (2) R5 withBAGEL_REMAT_DOWN_INPUT=1, native unmodified allocator, PID 68098,/tmp/r6/time-remat.log,/tmp/r6/time-remat, config/tmp/r6/remat.json. The second brings the down projection inside the gated checkpoint and caches its much narrower GEMM output (3584 vs 18944 columns), so its backward regenerates the large input, not the GEMM. Four synthetic CPU sizes matched native forward and every input/parameter gradient bitwise, with either checkpoint boundary. - Size-binningtimefinished 22:46:11:/tmp/r6/time-rounded/time.json= 1.4764x, 1.7841 s/step (1.7620,1.8061), 121.08 GiB allocated, 134.96 GiB reserved. Worse than R4 and R5; discard the allocator override. It did not change the mathematical path. - Down-input remat finished 22:51:36:/tmp/r6/time-remat/time.json= 1.6821x, 1.5659 s/step (1.5617,1.5701), 108.40 GiB allocated (down 8.97 GiB vs R5), no notes. Native allocator, no rounding override. Commitc1e1f28. Given the preceding round's volatility, repeat timing on the identical tree (PID 70292,/tmp/r6/time-repeat.log, output/tmp/r6/time-repeat) then quick (PID 70293,/tmp/r6/quick.log, output/tmp/r6/quick). Not promoted over full-passed R4 yet. - Repeat finished 22:57:33:/tmp/r6/time-repeat/time.json= 1.6790x, 1.5688 s/step (1.5620,1.5756), same peak 108.40 GiB, no notes. The ~4.9% improvement over R4 reproduced. Queue R7 profile on this screened stack after quick (PID 71928,/tmp/r7/profile.log,/tmp/r7/profile); accumulate the next change before another long full check, keeping R4 in the submission. - Quick finished 23:02:22:/tmp/r6/quick/check.jsonNOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass. All 4,224 shard/step digest entries matched the full-passed R4 tree. Round duration 26m32s.
3.8 hRound 7 — fused AdamW (23:02:47–23:17:22)
- Profile of R6c1e1f28,/tmp/r6/remat.json(no allocator override), PID 71928,/tmp/r7/profile.log, output/tmp/r7/profile. - Lock 23:02:47, finished 23:06:33. Backward 57.2%, model forward 33.4%;mm27.2%, NCCL gathers 23.5%, reduce-scatter 17.9% including waits. AdamW step 146.47 ms across two steps (73.23 ms/step), 3.56% of summed kernel durations; optimizer uses multiple foreach passes on large fp32 shards. Selected this serial step-end bandwidth cost and its transient storage. -BAGEL_FUSED_ADAMW=1selects native torch AdamW's fused kernel without changing the optimizer class, group, lr schedule, clipping, moments, or EMA.timePID 74988,/tmp/r7/time.log, output/tmp/r7/time;check --quickqueued PID 74989,/tmp/r7/quick.log, output/tmp/r7/quick. - Time finished 23:12:36: 1.7247x, 1.5272 s/step (1.5271,1.5274), 108.40 GiB allocated, no notes,/tmp/r7/time/time.json. Commit27204a6; relative to the repeat of R6 the optimizer saves 0.0416 s/step (1.027x). With R6 accumulated this justifies full validation; queued PID 77414,/tmp/r7/check.log,/tmp/r7/checkon/tmp/bagel-r7-eval. R8 profile just before it, PID 77413,/tmp/r8/profile.log, output/tmp/r8/profile. - Quick finished 23:17:22:/tmp/r7/quick/check.jsonNOT_BITWISE, all exact items passed, including group hyperparameters and optimizer-state dtype checks. - Full check finished 23:47:04: PASS N1, 1.7203x (1.5311 s/step),/tmp/r7/check/check.json. Interleaved N/J ratios: 1.33/1.04 deterministic, 1.35/1.06 production; largest absolute trajectory bias 1.023σ over 14 endpoints. Promoted all three R5–7 commits together; submitted7b76d3chas identical tree to27204a6and identical switch file to/tmp/r7/switches.json.
4.1 hRound 8 — overlap the frozen encoder (23:17:47–23:56:33; R7 full check excluded)
- Profile R7, steps 12–14, PID 77413,/tmp/r8/profile.log,/tmp/r8/profile. - GPU lock 23:17:47; profile finished 23:21:48. Rank 0: 60.7% backward, 29.4% model forward;mm38.2%, NCCL gather 14.5%, reduce-scatter 8.7% including overlap. Exclusive communication only ~3% of wall, idle 13.3%. Three VAE convolution-bracketed spans of 120.87, 86.62 and 46.25 ms immediately precede root all-gathers; there is no model dependency on those activations until after SigLIP. R7's different profiled packs corroborate the serialized VAE/gather boundary.BAGEL_OVERLAP_VAE=1enqueues the same frozen encode and FSDP input cast on a dedicated stream, waits at the first latent use, and records tensor lifetimes on their consumer streams. No change to VAE noise draw, layout or dtype. -timequeued behind R7 full check, PID 81348,/tmp/r8/time.log, output/tmp/r8/time; follow-upcheck --quickPID 81349,/tmp/r8/quick.log, output/tmp/r8/quick.py_compileandgit diff --checkpassed. - Overlaptimefinished 23:51:45: 1.6150x, 1.6309 s/step (1.6604,1.6015) and 108.38 GiB allocated,/tmp/r8/time/time.json. This is 6.8% slower than R7; adding a second stream did not improve end-to-end throughput. Commit58f1524experimental only. No full check warranted. Queue next profile on the accepted R7 without overlap (PID 88109,/tmp/r9/profile.log,/tmp/r9/profile). - Quick finished 23:56:33: NOT_BITWISE vs upstream but all exact items passed,/tmp/r8/quick/check.json. Reject for throughput; submission unchanged.
4.7 hRound 9 — fuse the gated FFN activation (Nov 17 23:57:01–Nov 18 00:22:26)
- Profile PID 88109,/tmp/r9/profile.log, output/tmp/r9/profile; steps 8–10. Worktree/tmp/bagel-nextcreated at the submitted R7 commit. No R8 async code in this base. - Lock 23:57:01, profile finished 00:00:56 on Nov 18. Backward 58.7%, model forward 33.1%; GEMMmm31.0%, all-gather 21.4%, reduce-scatter 14.3% inclusive. Exclusive gather/scatter 12.2%/5.2% on these packs, idle 10.8%. CUDA SiLU kernels 54.93 ms,mul127.23 ms in model forward/backward; the wide gated FFN repeats the SiLU/mul in remat and materializes intermediate gradients in backward. Testing the installed FlashAttention library's standalone two-input SwiGLU pointwise forward and backward (BAGEL_FUSED_SWIGLU=1), no new package. Same formula, rounding can differ. - Timing PID 90904,/tmp/r9/time.log,/tmp/r9/time; quick PID 90905,/tmp/r9/quick.log,/tmp/r9/quickqueued behind it. The gated activation switch is off in the submitted tree. - Library SwiGLUtimefinished 00:07:51: 1.7360x, 1.5173 s/step (1.5150,1.5195), 108.20 GiB allocated. Only ~10 ms faster than R7; not enough by itself for full validation. Commit557da35experimental. In a separate copy of R7, try fusing reconstruction of the down-projection input with the two SwiGLU gradients in a single pointwise pass; all three GEMMs remain native torch linear/mm. SwitchBAGEL_FUSE_GATE_REMAT, no dependency on the standalone library-switch patch. - Locked correctness probe of all 3 gradients (no timings) and subsequent judgetimePID 93145,/tmp/r9/probe-remat.log,/tmp/r9/time-remat.log, output/tmp/r9/time-remat; quick PID 93150,/tmp/r9/quick-remat.log,/tmp/r9/quick-rematif probe/time complete. Submission remains the full-passed R7. - Library quick finished 00:12:37: NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass. Fused reconstruction probe matched standalone library SwiGLU bitwise on forward, both gate inputs' gradients and down-weight gradient at three shapes (including the real FFN widths). Integratedtimefinished 00:17:35: 1.7639x, 1.4933 s/step (1.5025,1.4842), peak 106.25 GiB,/tmp/r9/time-remat/time.json. This saves 33.9 ms/step and 2.15 GiB vs accepted R7. Commit56fd929. Full check on stable/tmp/bagel-r9-evalqueued PID 95490,/tmp/r9/check.log,/tmp/r9/check; R10 profile before it, PID 95489,/tmp/r10/profile.log,/tmp/r10/profile. - Fused remat quick finished 00:22:26,/tmp/r9/quick-remat/check.json: NOT_BITWISE vs upstream, exact items pass, and every digest on all ranks and steps is identical to the standalone library SwiGLU variant. Round lasted 25m25s. - Full check finished 00:52:03: PASS N1, 1.7564x, 1.4996 s/step,/tmp/r9/check/check.json. N/J conformance ratios 1.36/1.05 deterministic and 1.33/1.07 production; maximum trajectory bias 0.961σ. Fast-forwarded the submission to exactly the evaluated commit56fd929,/submission/switches.jsonidentical to/tmp/r9/remat.json.
5.2 hRound 10 — gradient reduction normalization (00:22:52–01:11:06; R9 full check excluded)
- Profile the screened R9 fused-remat stack across steps 10–12: PID 95489,/tmp/r10/profile.log, output/tmp/r10/profile. - Lock 00:22:52, finished 00:26:50. Rank 0: 52.8% backward and 36.2% model forward;mm34.5%, all-gather 23.3% and reduce-scatter 5.4% including overlap. Disjoint gather 12.8%, exclusive reduce-scatter 0.8%, idle 12.5%. 152.1 ms ofaten::div_, all under FSDP's post-backward hook (2.7% of summed kernel durations); also 130.7 ms there casting the shards to fp32. FSDP ordinarily divides the full bf16 gradient by 2 then its 1/4-size reduced shard by 2.BAGEL_FSDP_POSTDIVIDE=1replaces the two factors by 1 and 4, leaving the world-size divisor, reduction dtype, optimizer input dtype, sharding and collectives intact. The option uses FSDP's initialized factors, not a hard-wired world size. - Postdivide timing queued after R9 full, PID 99213,/tmp/r10/time.log, output/tmp/r10/time; quick PID 99214,/tmp/r10/quick.log,/tmp/r10/quick. No change to submitted switches pending validation. - Postdividetimefinished 00:56:34: 1.7900x, 1.4715 s/step (1.4806,1.4625), 106.25 GiB allocated,/tmp/r10/time/time.json; 21.8 ms/step below R9 screening. Commit94fb334, not yet promoted. Alternate on the same gradient scaling hotspot:BAGEL_FSDP_AVG_SCATTER=1uses the equivalent one-level FULL_SHARD group *only on a one-replica hybrid mesh*, with FSDP's public comm hook and NCCL bf16 AVG reduce-scatter. Retains the original path for real multi-replica meshes. Direct four-rank mean/shard correctness probe and judgetimePID 107298,/tmp/r10/probe-avg.log,/tmp/r10/time-avg.log,/tmp/r10/time-avg; quick PID 107305,/tmp/r10/quick-avg.log,/tmp/r10/quick-avgwhen probe/time complete. - Postdivide quick finished 01:01:23: all exact items pass, every digest bitwise identical to R9. Native AVG probe matched the expected exact bf16 mean and shard assignment on all four ranks. Native AVGtimefinished 01:06:22: 1.8143x, 1.4518 s/step (1.4672,1.4364), peak allocated 106.25 GiB,/tmp/r10/time-avg/time.json. Saves 41.5 ms/step vs R9, ~19.7 ms vs postdivide. Commit1f8219a; full validation queued PID 109581,/tmp/r10/check.log,/tmp/r10/checkon a stable worktree. R11 profile first (steps 14–17), PID 109580,/tmp/r11/profile.log,/tmp/r11/profile. - AVG quick finished 01:11:06: NOT_BITWISE vs upstream, all exact items pass, every shard digest bitwise identical to R9 on the deterministic record. No submitted change until the full verdict. Round used ~24 minutes excluding R9 full. - Full check finished 01:40:33: PASS N1, 1.8043x, 1.4598 s/step,/tmp/r10/check/check.json. N/J conformance ratios 1.36/1.05 deterministic, 1.37/1.13 production; largest absolute trajectory bias 1.396σ. Fast-forwarded/submission/bagel_sftto the evaluated1f8219a,/submission/switches.jsonbyte-identical to/tmp/r10/avg.json.
6.0 hRound 11 — FSDP gather scheduling (01:11:32–01:59:54; R10 full excluded)
- PID 109580,/tmp/r11/profile.log,/tmp/r11/profileon the exact R10 AVG snapshot used for the upcoming full check. - GPU lock 01:11:32, profile finished 01:15:39. Backward 61.4%, model forward 29.4%,mm27.7%, all-gather 19.7%, reduce-scatter 27.0% including overlap. GPU disjoint gather-only time 9.9%, reduce-scatter alone 6.5%, idle 12.0%. FSDP's host rate limiter synchronized 468 times (3.02 s total, overlapped with GPU work); no CUDA malloc/free on these four packs. Target posting parameter gathers earlier rather than the allocator for this sample.BAGEL_FSDP_FORWARD_PREFETCH=1selects native FSDP forward lookahead for the static module sequence, leaving the default rate limiter unchanged initially. - Two separate candidates on the same R10 base, not combined: (A) forward prefetch, timing PID 113111,/tmp/r11/time-prefetch.log, output/tmp/r11/time-prefetch; (B) finite rate-limiter depth 4 rather than 2,BAGEL_FSDP_GATHER_DEPTH=4, leave explicit prefetch off, timing PID 113142,/tmp/r11/time-depth4.log,/tmp/r11/time-depth4. Quick checks queued after both timings: PIDs 113161/113162,/tmp/r11/quick-prefetch.log,/tmp/r11/quick-depth4.log, outputs/tmp/r11/quick-prefetchand/tmp/r11/quick-depth4respectively. R10 full holds the lock first. - Forward prefetchtimefinished 01:45:01: 1.8175x, 1.4492 s/step (1.4572,1.4413), peak 106.48 GiB,/tmp/r11/time-prefetch/time.json. Only 2.6 ms/step (0.18%) below R10; not a demonstrated benefit by itself. - Depth 4timefinished 01:50:17: 1.8128x, 1.4530 s/step (1.4602,1.4457), 106.25 GiB,/tmp/r11/time-depth4/time.json. Essentially unchanged from R10's 1.4518. Prefetch commit299f59f, limiter commitcf233c7; neither promoted or worth a new full check. After both queued quick checks, re-profile accepted R10 on other packs (steps 6–9), PID 125034,/tmp/r12/profile.log,/tmp/r12/profile. - Both quick checks NOT_BITWISE vs upstream, exact items pass, all shard/step digests identical to R10 for both:/tmp/r11/quick-prefetch/check.jsonat 01:55:06,/tmp/r11/quick-depth4/check.jsonat 01:59:54. Round used ~24m18s outside R10 full. No change to submission.
6.8 hRound 12 — fuse packed rotary transforms (02:00:21–02:21:33)
- Profile of the full-passed R10, PID 125034,/tmp/r12/profile.log,/tmp/r12/profile. - Lock 02:00:21, profile finished 02:04:17. Backward 60.0%, forward 28.9%;mm33.6%, all-gather 17.6%, reduce-scatter 15.2% inclusive. Four packs contained 224 Q/K rotary transforms of five consecutive CUDA operations each (two multiplies, negation, concatenate, addition), 64.56 ms summed GPU time just for the forward, plus their backwards. Repeated independently in every decoder layer. Forward index selections took another 73.01 ms and backwardindex_add_86.19 ms. Test the installed FlashAttention fused rotary kernel on compact half-width frequency tables already gathered in expert order; standard unmodified layout remains available. -BAGEL_FUSED_ROPE=1,/tmp/r12/rotary.json. Timing PID 128727,/tmp/r12/time-rotary.log, output/tmp/r12/time-rotary; quick PID 128728,/tmp/r12/quick-rotary.log,/tmp/r12/quick-rotary. Experiments isolated in/tmp/bagel-rotary; the submitted tree remains at full-passed R10. - Timing finished 02:16:46: 1.8444x, 1.4281 s/step (1.4414,1.4147), peak 106.25 GiB,/tmp/r12/time-rotary/time.json; 23.7 ms/step below R10 and both windows improved. Commite0faf70. Full check on that snapshot queued, PID 130875,/tmp/r12/check.log,/tmp/r12/check; next profile just before it (PID 130874,/tmp/r13/profile.log,/tmp/r13/profile). - Quick finished 02:21:33: NOT_BITWISE vs upstream, all exact items pass,/tmp/r12/quick-rotary/check.json. Round lasted 21m12s. - Full check finished 02:50:46: PASS N1, 1.8421x, 1.4299 s/step,/tmp/r12/check/check.json. Interleaved N/J ratios 1.41/0.98 deterministic, 1.53/1.09 production. Largest absolute trajectory bias 2.246σ (ViT displacement in the first window). Fast-forwarded the submission to exactly the testede0faf70; switch file identical to/tmp/r12/rotary.json.
7.2 hRound 13 — packed attention layout transforms (02:22:00–03:10:01, R12 full excluded)
- Profile of R12 on steps 8–11, PID 130874,/tmp/r13/profile.log,/tmp/r13/profile. - Lock 02:22:00, finished 02:25:56. Backward 57.9%, model forward 31.1%;mm33.3%, gather 19.4%, reduce-scatter 14.9% inclusive. Fused rotation is now only 18.0 ms across 448 kernels. But there are 484 index-select kernels (77.5 ms) and 456 index-add kernels (90.7 ms), including the packed Q/K/V layout gathers and their backwards. First optionBAGEL_INVERT_PERMUTATIONS=1: Q and output are inverse permutations by construction; their gradients can use the inverse gather, without a zero-fill and atomic scatter-add. Keys may repeat and retain the normal accumulation. - First timing PID 133866,/tmp/r13/time-inverse.log,/tmp/r13/time-inverse. Independent second option on R12 (BAGEL_GATHER_ROPE=1, no standalone inverse option) combines rotary with the packed query/key gather in one rowwise Triton kernel. Inverse query gather + conjugate rotation is one backward kernel; explicitly sums all gradients for repeated keys before the conjugate. Normal causal/dense span grouping and visible keys are unchanged. Locked synthetic probe (identity, permutation, repeated keys, two head widths and non-contiguous incoming gradients) then timing PID 134309,/tmp/r13/probe-rope.log,/tmp/r13/time-gather-rope.log,/tmp/r13/time-gather-rope; quick PIDs 134355/134356,/tmp/r13/quick-inverse.log,/tmp/r13/quick-gather-rope.log, outputs/tmp/r13/quick-inverse,/tmp/r13/quick-gather-rope. R12 full check runs first. All experiments isolated from the submission. - Standalone inverse gathertimefinished 02:55:11: 1.8431x, 1.4291 s/step (1.4400,1.4182), 106.25 GiB,/tmp/r13/time-inverse/time.json. No gain over R12 (1.4281 s); do not submit this by itself. - Indexed rotary probe matched R12 forward and gradients bitwise on all six cases.timefinished 03:00:30: 1.8562x, 1.4190 s/step (1.4308,1.4072), peak 106.25 GiB,/tmp/r13/time-gather-rope/time.json. A modest 9.1 ms/step (0.64%) below R12, both windows improved; not sufficient by itself for another long full check. Commit20f8066, experimental. Profile this screened stack after both quick checks before considering accumulation, PID 146101,/tmp/r14/profile.log,/tmp/r14/profile. - Both examples passed exact items and were NOT_BITWISE vs upstream; all digests of both are bitwise identical to R12 on the deterministic record:/tmp/r13/quick-inverse/check.jsonat 03:05:16 and/tmp/r13/quick-gather-rope/check.jsonat 03:10:01. Round used ~24m outside R12 full. Keep full-passed R12 submitted.
8.0 hRound 14 — retain selected gathered weights (03:10:25–03:35:42)
- Profile R13's screened indexed-rotary version on steps 12–15, PID 146101,/tmp/r14/profile.log,/tmp/r14/profile. - Lock 03:10:25, completed 03:14:28. Backward 59.7%, forward 29.0%, GEMMmm34.2%, reduce-scatter 18.6%, all-gather 17.6% including overlap; backward gathers alone total 365.07 ms across four packs. Nonoverlapped gather 7.8% of wall, idle 11.5%. R11's posting-order knobs did not reliably help, so change the communication volume instead: optionally retain bf16 compute weights between the forward and backward of the last N MoT blocks. FSDP still shards the fp32 master parameters/gradients, uses the same reducer and wraps the same module boundaries. Screen N=8 and N=16 separately on R13; untouched submitted R12 while these run. -BAGEL_FSDP_RETAIN_TAIL=8timing PID 149996,/tmp/r14/time-tail8.log,/tmp/r14/time-tail8; N=16 timing PID 149997,/tmp/r14/time-tail16.log,/tmp/r14/time-tail16. Corresponding quick PIDs 150811/150812 if timings run successfully,/tmp/r14/quick-tail8.log,/tmp/r14/quick-tail16.log, outputs/tmp/r14/quick-tail8,/tmp/r14/quick-tail16. - N=8 finished 03:20:47: 1.8067x, 1.4579 s/step (1.5200,1.3957), peak 111.47 GiB,/tmp/r14/time-tail8/time.json. Window range 8.53%, above the final judge's interference threshold. Faster second window but a slower mean than R13; not valid evidence of a gain. - N=16 finished 03:26:10: 1.7512x, 1.5041 s/step (1.5386,1.4696), peak 118.42 GiB,/tmp/r14/time-tail16/time.json. More memory and slower in both windows than R13. Commit87c3870, not promoted. No new full check. Re-profile the leaner R13 (R14 retention disabled) on steps 5–9 after quicks, PID 154388,/tmp/r15/profile.log,/tmp/r15/profile. - N=8 and N=16 quicks completed 03:30:58 and 03:35:42: NOT_BITWISE vs upstream, exact items pass, every digest bitwise identical to R13./tmp/r14/quick-tail8/check.json,/tmp/r14/quick-tail16/check.json. Round used 25m17s.
8.4 hRound 15 — VAE normalization and activation (03:36:11–04:01:26)
- Profile PID 154388,/tmp/r15/profile.log,/tmp/r15/profile, no retained tail weights. - GPU lock 03:36:11, profile finished 03:40:13. Backward 57.3%, model forward 31.2%; GEMMmm32.0%, all-gather 20.3%, reduce-scatter 17.9% including overlap. VAE convolution-bracketed spans on five packs: 37.53, 102.41, 45.93, 22.44, 102.26 ms. These serial intervals include 70.38 ms of native GroupNorm, ~54 ms copies/casts, then standalone fp32 Swish before bf16-autocast convolutions. Optimize this memory traffic, not the VAE noise draw or scheduling. First screen installed native fp32 SiLU instead of materializing sigmoid followed by multiply on the frozen path. - NativeBAGEL_VAE_NATIVE_SILU=1time PID 158352,/tmp/r15/time-silu.log,/tmp/r15/time-silu. IndependentBAGEL_VAE_GROUP_SWISH=1fuses the no-grad contiguous NCHW GroupNorm→Swish→convolution input cast, using fixed-tree fp32 chunk means/centered moments, pooled fp32 group statistics and fp32 affine/activation. Writes bf16 only at the existing bf16 autocast convolution boundary. Unsupported dtype/layout/gradient cases use the original formula. Locked probe on random and constant groups then judge timing PID 159171,/tmp/r15/probe-group.log,/tmp/r15/time-group.log,/tmp/r15/time-group; quick PIDs 159198/159199,/tmp/r15/quick-silu.log,/tmp/r15/quick-group.log, outputs/tmp/r15/quick-silu,/tmp/r15/quick-group. - Native fp32 SiLUtimefinished 03:46:30: 1.8829x, 1.3989 s/step (1.4098,1.3880), 106.26 GiB peak,/tmp/r15/time-silu/time.json. Saves 20.1 ms vs R13 screening. - Fused GroupNorm/Swish probe passed: worst relative L2 vs native post-cast result 1.56e-5 for random inputs, 5.56e-4 for exactly constant groups over four shapes. Group fusiontimefinished 03:51:54: 1.9263x, 1.3674 s/step (1.3715,1.3632), 106.26 GiB,/tmp/r15/time-group/time.json. Saves 51.6 ms vs R13 and 31.5 ms vs native-SiLU alone. Commit3524392. Full check on a frozen worktree queued PID 162907,/tmp/r15/check.log,/tmp/r15/check, after R16 profile PID 162906,/tmp/r16/profile.log,/tmp/r16/profile. - Native SiLU quick finished 03:56:40,/tmp/r15/quick-silu/check.json; fused group quick finished 04:01:26,/tmp/r15/quick-group/check.json. Both NOT_BITWISE, all exact items pass, both change numerical digests vs R13 as expected. Round duration 25m15s. - Full check finished 04:30:41: PASS N1, 1.9311x, 1.3640 s/step,/tmp/r15/check/check.json. Interleaved conformance N/J ratios 2.20/1.98 deterministic, 2.21/1.98 production, both below 3; all trajectory endpoints within 1.281σ. Fast-forward promoted R13 and R15 together to exact evaluated commit3524392, switch file byte-identical to/tmp/r15/group-swish.json.
8.8 hRound 16 — GEMM dispatch and shape alignment (04:01:51–04:50:09; R15 full excluded)
- Profile R15 group fusion on steps 10–13, PID 162906,/tmp/r16/profile.log,/tmp/r16/profile. - Lock 04:01:51, finished 04:05:52. Backward 57.0%, forward 32.5%,aten::mm38.6%,addmm1.5%, NCCL gather 19.2%, reduce-scatter 9.0% inclusive. GPU was compute/copy-only 54.0%, idle 14.0%. Largest individual GEMM family sm90 BF16 NT 128x128x64, 901 ms. Test existing PyTorch BLAS preference (TORCH_BLAS_PREFER_CUBLASLT=1) versus default dispatch. Independently test alignment (BAGEL_FFN_ROW_ALIGN=16) of the arbitrary per-expert row/K dimension in the FFN forward/weight-gradient GEMMs, on default cuBLAS. This pads only implementation-private zero rows and slices them out before the residual; no attention or extra training tokens. - Native backend timing PID 168259,/tmp/r16/time-lt.log,/tmp/r16/time-lt; FFN alignment timing PID 168260,/tmp/r16/time-align.log,/tmp/r16/time-align. Quicks PIDs 168293/168294,/tmp/r16/quick-lt.log,/tmp/r16/quick-align.log, outputs/tmp/r16/quick-ltand/tmp/r16/quick-align. R15 full runs first, no R16 changes in the submission. - Native cuBLASLttimefinished 04:35:10: 1.7963x, 1.4663 s/step (1.3699,1.5627), peak 106.26 GiB,/tmp/r16/time-lt/time.json. Window range 13.14%, well above final validity threshold, and slower overall. Reject, keep default BLAS dispatch. - FFN align-16timefinished 04:40:23: 1.9292x, 1.3653 s/step (1.3744,1.3562), 106.28 GiB,/tmp/r16/time-align/time.json. Only 2.1 ms below R15 screening, not supported by both windows, and within noise of the 1.3640 s full check. Commit814e320and backend doc/configa294718not promoted. After both quick checks re-profile accepted R15 at steps 5–9, PID 182406,/tmp/r17/profile.log,/tmp/r17/profile. - Both quicks NOT_BITWISE vs upstream, all exact items pass: cuBLASLt 04:45:21,/tmp/r16/quick-lt/check.json, digests differ from R15; row-aligned FFNs 04:50:09,/tmp/r16/quick-align/check.json, digests identical to R15. Round used 24m22s excluding R15 full.
9.6 hRound 17 — pack and overlap scalar count reductions (04:50:35–05:06:08)
- Profile PID 182406,/tmp/r17/profile.log,/tmp/r17/profile, no backend or FFN shape overrides. - Lock 04:50:35, completed 04:54:45. Backward 60.1%, model forward 30.7%,mm34.6%, reduce-scatter 18.1%, gathers 18.6% inclusive. Pairing CPUrecord_param_comms(dtype, ordinal) with 50 corresponding CUDA all-reduces isolates two post-forward int64 target-count barriers: 36.00 + 6.89 ms over five steps, up to 22.45 ms on a pack. R15's profile of the previous stack measured 149.75 + 12.47 ms for the same two counts.BAGEL_ASYNC_BATCH_COUNTS=1reduces CE/MSE target and sample counts in an int64 vector before forward, pack lengths/squares in a separate fp32 vector with the original dot product, and waits at use. Statistics accumulate in original step order at the existing logging sync. All loss formulas/sizes, dtype, weighted CE handling, and logging remain in place. -timePID 187080,/tmp/r17/time.log,/tmp/r17/time;check --quickPID 187081,/tmp/r17/quick.log,/tmp/r17/quick. Experiment in/tmp/bagel-counts, no submission change. - Timing finished 05:01:23: 1.9292x, 1.3653 s/step (1.3676,1.3629), 106.26 GiB,/tmp/r17/time/time.json. Within noise of R15, not worth promoting even though the explicit count barriers move. Commit61fecca. Profile accepted R15 on steps 13–16 next, PID 189596,/tmp/r18/profile.log,/tmp/r18/profile. - Quick finished 05:06:08: NOT_BITWISE vs upstream, all exact items pass, all numerical digests bitwise identical to full-passed R15,/tmp/r17/quick/check.json. Round duration 15m33s.
9.9 hRound 18 — NCCL protocol and occupancy (05:06:33–in progress)
- PID 189596,/tmp/r18/profile.log,/tmp/r18/profile, no async count changes. - Lock 05:06:33, finished 05:10:37. Backward 63.3%, forward 27.7%;mm32.4%, reduce-scatter 24.7%, all-gather 16.9% inclusive. Every all-gather and reduce-scatter kernel in these four packs had 24 CTAs of 544 threads. GPU wall: 25.8% overlapping compute+reduce-scatter, 16.4% compute+gather, and 12.7% gather/scatter alone. Test NCCL's native transport choices without changing reduction math or groups: automatic→Simple protocol, independently 24 observed→12 maximum CTAs to address SM contention. No combined override.