Claude Haiku 5.5 1.60×
Harness: Claude Code · switches: BAGEL_OPT_KEEP_UNSHARDED=1 BAGEL_OPT_FORWARD_PREFETCH=1 BAGEL_OPT_LIMIT_ALL_GATHERS=0 BAGEL_OPT_MOT_PERMUTE=1 BAGEL_OPT_ATTN_FLASH=1 BAGEL_OPT_FUSED_ADAMW=1 NCCL_PROTO=Simple BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_RMSNORM=1 BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_MLP_ACT=1 BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_ROPE=1 PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True BAGEL_OPT_NO_GRAD_DIVIDE=1 BAGEL_OPT_FLASH_BATCHED=1 BAGEL_OPT_PAIR_CARRY=1 BAGEL_OPT_VIT_NO_AC=1
- Judged
- 1.60×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 1.60×
- Rounds
- 14
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $20.0
- Input tokens · 99.6% cached
- 336 M
- Output tokens
- 0.9 M
- Requests
- 710
§ 02Key levers
- Attention kernel swap (split by mask structure)
- ✓
BAGEL_OPT_ATTN_FLASH(FA2): 1.09 → 1.26×; batched calls a further +4.5%. Wanted FA3, source couldn't be downloaded, dropped - Drop activation recompute (28 decoder layers)
- only ViT removed (+2.9%). Decoder minus 4 layers 1.280× vs 1.289×, minus 2 layers −0.9%, both reverted; all 28 layers still recomputed
- Intra-layer MoT fusion (routing / RMSNorm / RoPE / SwiGLU)
- ✓
torch.compileon RMSNorm, SiLU·up, RoPE (1.29 → 1.44×); MoT permuted layout (bitwise, +6.5%), two token types carried separately (+2.1%) - Optimizer, EMA, step start / end
- fused AdamW; FSDP grad division removed (bitwise, +1.4%). EMA via lerp blocked by gate 3; EMA side stream −1.0%, reverted
- Other main levers
- unsharded weights kept for backward, all-gather rate limiter off, forward prefetch (combined 1.025×)
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log16 sections
0.1 hSetup facts (round 0)
- Start of session: 2026-11-10 ~01:35 UTC. Working time is not told; treat as limited.
- GPUs: 4 x Hopper-class (nvidia-smi names them "Hopper", 143771 MiB, 700 W limit, NV18 NVLink,
max SM clock 1980 MHz). Peak BF16 used by the run's MFU: 119.5 (L20 entry); true Hopper-class dense
peak is ~989 TFLOPS. Judge reference timing: 2.5966 s/step (spread 0.07%), peak alloc 82.14 GiB.
- Gate 1 needs speedup > max(1.02, 1 + 2 x reference spread) -> >= 1.02.
- candidate runs use /opt/candidate-env/bin/python (torch 2.5.1+cu124, triton 3.1.0, transformers 4.49.0).
- Current switches file: /submission/switches.json = {"environment": {}} (upstream behaviour).
- Tier ceiling: agent_max_tier N1 (N2 dtype changes are rejected).0.1 hRound 0: profile of the unchanged reference (01:36-01:43 UTC)
- Judge profile: bench.py profile on the unchanged tree, steps 8-9 of a 10-step run, rank 0.
Output: /tmp/r0/profile/timing_profile.profile.txt and .trace.json (kernel aggregation in /tmp/r0/ana/).
- Kernel time per step (trace, summed over streams; 2 profiled steps halved):
NCCL 1.34 s (ReduceScatter bf16 0.78 s, AllGather 0.53 s; RING_LL kernels, on a side stream);
cuBLAS GEMM 0.79 s; mem-efficient SDPA with explicit bias 0.55 s (fwd+recompute 0.24, bwd 0.32; dense L^2, no causal skip);
elementwise 0.55 s (RMSNorm fp32 pieces, SiLU/mul, adds, bf16 casts); index/copy/fill ~0.30 s (MoT index_put/gather, cat, zeros);
AdamW/EMA/clip foreach 0.09 s; flash (ViT) 0.015 s; reduce/norm 0.035 s.
- Timeline (2 steps, span 5.6 s): compute stream busy 2.07 s/step, idle 0.73 s/step. NCCL not overlapped with compute
~0.56 s/step. Forward shows ~17-18 ms compute gaps per FSDP unit: forward all-gathers are issued only when the unit starts
(FSDP forward_prefetch is off by default upstream), so they are exposed.
- Hotspot classes: (1) communication exposed in forward = configuration problem (existing overlap option not enabled);
(2) attention = existing backend (mem-efficient) on dense masks with no causal skipping = candidate for a rewrite;
(3) elementwise/index traffic = fusion candidate.
- No NCCL environment is set in the container (NCCL 2.21.5 defaults).0.1 hRound 1 (started 01:43 UTC): FSDP forward prefetch
- Hotspot: exposed forward all-gathers (class: communication, configuration).
- Change: train/fsdp_utils.py fsdp_wrapper passes forward_prefetch=True when BAGEL_OPT_FORWARD_PREFETCH=1 (default 0 = upstream).
Scheduling only; same collectives and math. Expected N0.
- Experiment config: /tmp/r1/switches_fp.json. time output: /tmp/r1/time_fp.
- Round 1 result: time run /tmp/r1/time_fp/time.json: 2.5943 s/step, speedup_vs_frozen_reference 1.0009 (no gain beyond
noise; reference spread 0.0007). Forward prefetch alone does not help: the CPU rate limiter (limit_all_gathers=True)
still blocks the issuing thread on events (trace: 234 cudaEventSynchronize calls over 2 steps), and NCCL LL kernels spin
on SMs. Forward prefetch kept only as a switch (default off).
- Tooling note: time takes ~6-7 min per run (model build ~3 min, 65 steps ~3 min); the judge copies the tree at start.0.3 hRound 2 (started 01:50 UTC): FSDP rate limiter off (+ forward prefetch)
- Switch BAGEL_OPT_LIMIT_ALL_GATHERS=0 with BAGEL_OPT_FORWARD_PREFETCH=1. Config /tmp/r2/switches_fp_nolimit.json. - Also written, not yet timed: MoT permuted layout (BAGEL_OPT_MOT_PERMUTE=1; modeling/bagel/qwen2_navit.py) and _HYBRID_SHARD_ZERO2 for the trained model (BAGEL_OPT_KEEP_UNSHARDED=1; train/fsdp_utils.py), AC skip (BAGEL_OPT_AC_SKIP_FIRST=K). - Round 2 result (fp + limit off): /tmp/r2/time_fp_nolimit/time.json: 2.5681 s/step, speedup 1.0111 (windows 2.5749, 2.5613), beyond reference noise but below the 1.02 bar on its own. Reserved memory 122 GiB. - Round 3 result (ZERO2 keep-unsharded + fp + limit off + expandable segments): /tmp/r3/time_zero2/time.json: 2.5323 s/step, speedup 1.0254 (windows 2.5361, 2.5285), beyond reference noise. Peak allocated 90.39 GiB, reserved 119.32 GiB. Config /tmp/r3/switches_zero2_nolimit.json. - Production-mode losses are not bitwise reproducible across runs (steps 0-1 agree, step 2 onward differs in the 3rd digit, including the profiled reference run). Bitwise verdict comes only from deterministic record/check --quick. - MoT permuted layout: CPU equivalence on a tiny bf16 model (tests in /tmp/r2/unit/test_perm_count.py): forward output, input gradient, all 58 parameter gradients bitwise equal; the permuted path was called once (verified by counter).
0.6 hRound 4 (02:03-02:20 UTC): bitwise check of the combined candidate
- First attempt of the permuted layout called the layer's inner method directly, bypassing the FSDP unit and checkpoint
wrapper: record run failed in backward (ViewBackward0 modified in place). Fixed by calling the layers as modules with the
permuted layout as one keyword argument (commit 7f28ce1). CPU equivalence test still bitwise equal.
- check --quick on /tmp/r4/switches_all_perm.json (ZERO2 + forward prefetch + limit off + MoT permute + expandable
segments): PASS, tier N0 (/tmp/r4/quick_all_perm2/check.json). This config is now /submission/switches.json.
- Time run of this config: /tmp/r4/time_all_perm (result below when finished).
- Round 4 time result (ZERO2 + fp + limit off + MoT permute + expandable segments): /tmp/r4/time_all_perm/time.json:
2.3782 s/step, speedup 1.0918 (windows 2.3774, 2.3790), beyond reference noise. Peak allocated 90.32 GiB, reserved 119.38 GiB.
The MoT permutation alone added ~6.5% on top of round 3 (1.0254 -> 1.0918).
- Full check of this config started 02:18:57 on a copy of commit 7f28ce1: /tmp/r4/check_full_1 (log /tmp/r4/check_full_1.log).
- After the copy: uncommitted change in qwen2_navit.py converting the per-sample masks to bf16 once per forward (N0 by
construction; CPU equivalence test bitwise equal). Not yet judged; needs its own check --quick before commit.
- FULL CHECK PASS (02:36 UTC): /tmp/r4/check_full_1/check.json: status PASS, tier N0, speedup 1.0921, for
/submission/switches.json (all-perm switches) on commit 7f28ce1. Gates: timing (gate 1) 02:19-02:24, record (gate 2)
bitwise, conformance deterministic + production (gate 2b) 02:28-02:36. Gate 3 not needed (bitwise).1.1 hRound 5 (02:36-): fused AdamW (dropped), attention via flash-attention runs (N1 candidate)
- Fused AdamW (BAGEL_OPT_FUSED_ADAMW=1) with the rest of the verified config: check --quick NOT_BITWISE (exact items pass, numbers differ): N1 at best. Not used (small expected gain, would need gate 3). Switch left in code, default 0. - Flash-attention path (BAGEL_OPT_ATTN_FLASH=1): per sample, the mask rows must be prefixes [0, E(r)] (checked on GPU once per forward; two host transfers). Causal runs -> one causal flash call over keys [0, end) (bottom-right alignment gives row r keys <= r); full runs -> one non-causal call over keys [0, end). Any sample not prefix-shaped (noise span followed by another split, the N pool of gate 2b) -> dense path for the whole forward. GQA handled by flash (no K/V repeat). CPU test (/tmp/r5/unit/test_flash_plans.py, float64, reference flash with bottom-right causal): exact (1e-15) on causal/full/alternating/multi-sample layouts; holes -> fallback. GPU sanity (/tmp/r5/unit/gpu_flash_check.py): relative L2 2.1e-3 vs fp32 dense reference (bf16 output level). - Expected tier N1 (numerics change in the attention kernel): needs gate 3 (check --n1 or full check). - Time run: /tmp/r5/time_flash (started 02:42:22). - Also uncommitted: per-forward bf16 conversion of masks (N0 by construction); to be verified with its own check --quick. - Flash path v1 (prefix-only masks): time 1.1267 (2.3045 s/step) but only ~12% of attention kernel time went to flash: the judge's timing data (interleave config, editing mandatory) has noise spans followed by more tokens in ~40% of samples (holes; checked on real batches with /tmp/r5/unit/data_masks.py on CPU), and any such sample forced the dense path for the whole pack. - Flash path v2 (current working tree): per sample, query runs (causal/full, from the per-row last allowed key), key set of a run = allowed set of its last row (holes excluded), verified on the device against the mask; a failing sample falls back to the dense path, per sample. CPU end-to-end test with a hole sample (/tmp/r5/unit/test_flash_e2e.py): 12 flash calls, output identical at bf16, grads 0.4% relative. Time run: /tmp/r5/time_flash2 (started 02:57:34). - Flash v2 time run /tmp/r5/time_flash2/time.json: 2.0529 s/step, speedup 1.2648 (windows 2.0615, 2.0444); peak allocated 90.13 GiB, reserved 118.59 GiB. - Full check of the flash config started 03:03:38 (/tmp/r5/check_flash_full): gate 1 timing done, gate 2 not bitwise (expected, N1 kernel), gate 2b passed (deterministic and production), gate 3 trajectory running at 03:20. - Code edit after the copy (guard in _split_runs against E[r] < r, docstring): CPU tests re-run, identical results. Needs a final verification in the committed state. - FULL CHECK PASS (flash config, tree before the guard edit): /tmp/r5/check_flash_full/check.json: status PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.263. Gates: gate 1 timing, gate 2 not bitwise, gate 2b passed (deterministic + production), gate 3 passed. - Submission now: commit f8c464e + /submission/switches.json = flash config (BAGEL_OPT_KEEP_UNSHARDED=1, BAGEL_OPT_FORWARD_PREFETCH=1, BAGEL_OPT_LIMIT_ALL_GATHERS=0, BAGEL_OPT_MOT_PERMUTE=1, BAGEL_OPT_ATTN_FLASH=1, PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:True). - Round 6 (03:33): time of bundle = flash config + NCCL_PROTO=Simple + BAGEL_OPT_FUSED_ADAMW=1 (/tmp/r6/time_bundle). - Round 6 results: bundle (flash + fused AdamW + NCCL_PROTO=Simple): /tmp/r6/time_bundle: 2.0148 s/step, speedup 1.2887 (+1.9% over flash alone, beyond noise). Bundle + NCCL_MAX_NCHANNELS=4: 1.2664 (worse; channel cap slows the collectives). - Full check of the bundle started 03:44 (/tmp/r6/check_bundle_full). If PASS it becomes the submission switch file.
2.6 hRound 7 (04:11): verified bundle is the submission
- /tmp/r6/check_bundle_full/check.json: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.2905. /submission/switches.json = /tmp/r6/switches_bundle.json.
2.8 hRound 8 (04:11-04:30): bundle profile and host stalls
- Profile of the verified bundle (/tmp/r7/profile): step 2.04 s; NCCL RS 0.66 s/step (RING_LL), AG 0.24 s/step, GEMM 0.73 s, flash attention 0.17 s, elementwise 0.41 s; compute stream idle ~0.54 s/step, of which ~0.34 s NCCL not overlapped. - Backward shows ~45 ms compute gaps once per FSDP unit: the CPU autograd thread sits ~400 ms in FullyShardedDataParallel._post_backward_hook with no GPU work queued (/tmp/r0/ana/gapcpu.py). - NCCL_PROTO=Simple had no effect: the kernels stay RING_LL. NCCL's parser is probably case-sensitive (SIMPLE). - expandable_segments off: 1.2900 vs 1.2887 with it (no difference). - Hypothesis under test: the DataLoader pin-memory thread pins the fp32 nested masks (hundreds of MB per pack) during backward. Switch BAGEL_OPT_NO_PIN_MASKS=1 (data/dataset_base.py); time run with NCCL_PROTO=SIMPLE too (/tmp/r7/time_nopin). - Round 8 result: no-pin + NCCL_PROTO=SIMPLE (uppercase not guaranteed effective): 1.2691 (worse than bundle 1.2887). Re-testing no-pin alone (/tmp/r7/time_nopin_only). - No-pin masks alone: /tmp/r7/time_nopin_only: 1.2676 (worse than bundle 1.2887) -> hypothesis refuted; code reverted (data/dataset_base.py restored to the committed version). - NCCL transport check (/tmp/r8/nccl_probe.log): P2P/CUMEM on all pairs; a 256 MB reduce-scatter takes 0.82 ms alone. So the ~45 ms ReduceScatter kernels in training are waiting for the slowest rank (packs differ per rank: 9-10.6k tokens and different sum of L^2), not slow NCCL. Structural to the recipe's data; not changeable without changing packing. - AC skip for 4 layers (BAGEL_OPT_AC_SKIP_FIRST=4) on the bundle: time run /tmp/r8/time_ac4 (started 04:36:30). - AC skip 4 layers on the bundle: 1.2798 (worse than 1.2887). Rejected. - Compiled RMSNorm (BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_RMSNORM=1; torch.compile dynamic=True on the same formula): time run /tmp/r8/time_rms. - Compiled RMSNorm (BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_RMSNORM=1, torch.compile dynamic=True of the same formula): /tmp/r8/time_rms: 1.8566 s/step, speedup 1.3986 (windows 1.8584, 1.8548); peak alloc 89.57, reserved 112.03 GiB; no recompile-limit or cudagraph signature in the log. - + compiled silu(gate)*up in the Qwen2 MLP (BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_MLP_ACT=1): /tmp/r8/time_rms_mlp: 1.8307 s/step, speedup 1.4183 (windows 1.8285, 1.8329); peak alloc 89.17, reserved 112.69 GiB; no invalid signature. - Full check of this config (switches /tmp/r8/switches_rms_mlp.json, tree = working tree incl. the two compile switches, default off) started 04:55:05: /tmp/r8/check_rms_mlp. - NOTE: the two compile switches are uncommitted edits in modeling/qwen2/modeling_qwen2.py (defaults off = upstream math).
3.8 hRound 9 (05:22-): compiled elementwise pieces
- Full check of commit 58b982f config: PASS, N1, speedup 1.4251. Submission switch file updated. - Next candidate: compile the rotary embedding (apply_rotary_pos_emb in the permuted attention). - Compiled RoPE (BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_ROPE=1, apply_rotary_pos_emb_switchable in the permuted attention): time run /tmp/r9/time_rope: 1.8011 s/step, speedup 1.4417 (+1.65% over 1.4183), reserved 113.1 GiB, no invalid signature. Full check started 05:28:55: /tmp/r9/check_rope. - Remaining small candidates: EMA as one _foreach_lerp_ (N1, ~1%); coarser FSDP units (2 layers per unit: fewer collectives, structural, uncertain). Exposed NCCL is mostly waiting for the slowest rank (packs differ per rank). - FULL CHECK PASS (05:56): /tmp/r9/check_rope/check.json: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.4356 (time run 1.4417). - SUBMISSION NOW (05:57): commit (see git log, "Compile the rotary embedding") + /tmp/r9/switches_rope.json as /submission/switches.json (bundle + BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_RMSNORM=1 + BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_MLP_ACT=1 + BAGEL_OPT_COMPILE_ROPE=1).
4.4 hRound 10 (06:00): profile of the submission config and the stall analysis
- Profile /tmp/r10/profile (2 steps, rank 0): GEMM 0.73 s/step (40% of compute), flash attention 0.18 s, elementwise incl. compiled 0.20 s, RS 0.58 s/step and AG 0.19 s/step on the NCCL stream (exposed part ~0.27 s/step), compute idle ~0.48 s/step. - The per-unit compute gaps equal the ReduceScatter duration on rank 0 (~45 ms). The judge's step is set by the SLOWEST rank (packs differ per rank), and rank 0 waits for it at each collective, so the idle time on rank 0 is largely imbalance wait, not lost time on the critical rank. Possible remaining cause to test later: allocator reuse of freed reduce-scatter buffers across streams (FSDP records the unsharded grad on the post-backward stream). - No further change verified after 6d2fac4. Submission stays at 6d2fac4 + switches (verified PASS, N1, 1.4356).
4.6 hRound 11 (06:03-): profile of the submission config; backward stalls
- Profile /tmp/r11/profile (2 steps, rank 0): data loader __next__ 0.10 ms (not data-bound); start-of-step gaps 4-7 ms
(the 80 ms start gap of earlier profiles is gone); optimizer step 34 ms.
- Backward gaps: 8-9 gaps of ~38 ms, one per FSDP unit, during each ReduceScatter. Inside one gap the CPU thread is blocked
in a single cudaLaunchKernel call (inside aten::add_ / ToCopyBackward0) for 39.5 ms, while the RS kernel runs for 38.7 ms
(/tmp/r11/window.py). Hypothesis: the spinning LL-protocol RS kernel blocks compute-stream launches/dispatch until it ends.
- Tests queued: profile with NCCL_PROTO=SIMPLE (uppercase; /tmp/r11/profile_simple), then time with
CUDA_DEVICE_MAX_CONNECTIONS=32 (/tmp/r11/switches_conn32.json).
- NCCL_PROTO=SIMPLE: the profile kernel names stay ...RING_LL, and so do the names of a probe with the default setting;
the probe's NCCL_DEBUG tuning line did pick proto 2 (Simple) under the variable. Reduce-scatter time is unchanged
(1177 vs 1166 ms per 2 steps). Conclusion: the protocol is not the limit here.
- Time run with CUDA_DEVICE_MAX_CONNECTIONS=32 (/tmp/r11/time_conn32) started 06:15.
- CUDA_DEVICE_MAX_CONNECTIONS=32 on the submission config: /tmp/r11/time_conn32 = 1.4383 (1.8053 s/step) vs 1.4417 for the
submission: no gain (rejected).
- Key correction to earlier analysis: the judge's step time is set by the SLOWEST rank. Rank 0 is a fast rank here (it waits
in every ReduceScatter), so its idle time is not on the critical path. Compute-kernel composition on rank 0 is still the
right guide for kernel work. Per-rank pack statistics (CPU, judge timing data, seed 42): /tmp/r11/rank{0..3}.json (running).
- Per-rank pack statistics (CPU, judge timing data): tokens per rank 0.83-1.15 x mean, sum of L^2 0.72-1.36 x mean; the
slowest rank changes from step to step. Rank 0 is an average rank.
- Non-GEMM kernel time on rank 0 (per step, round 11 trace): ~438 ms in total: triton (compiled) 74, cat 59 (539 calls),
bf16 copies 46 (FSDP casts / grad casts), fused AdamW 34, bf16 adds 30, gathers 30, fills 28 (1666 calls), bf16 unary 24.
- Found: slicing x[:n] / x[n:] in the permuted path creates one full-size zero-fill and add per slice in backward (about 16
slices per layer per pass); permutation gathers zero-fill and sort in backward. Fix (switch BAGEL_OPT_PERM_AUTOGRAD=1):
one split per stage (split backward = cat) and a permutation autograd function whose backward is the inverse gather.
CPU: forward, input and parameter gradients identical to the default path (test_perm_autograd.py; helpers counted).
Flash e2e CPU test unchanged. Time run /tmp/r11/time_permauto started 06:26.
- Permutation autograd (BAGEL_OPT_PERM_AUTOGRAD=1; split once per stage + inverse-gather autograd): /tmp/r11/time_permauto =
1.4389 (1.8045 s/step) vs 1.4417 for the submission: no gain. Code reverted from the tree (patch kept at
/tmp/r11/perm_autograd_attempt.patch). CPU equivalence held (forward, input and parameter grads identical).
- cuBLASLt preference (BAGEL_OPT_BLAS_LT=1, torch.backends.cuda.preferred_blas_library('cublaslt'), in
train/pretrain_unified_navit.py main()): time run /tmp/r11/time_blaslt started 06:32:50. Default off.
- cuBLASLt preference on the submission config: /tmp/r11/time_blaslt = 1.4493 (1.7916 s/step), +0.5% vs 1.4417 (small;
within ~2x of run-to-run variation seen on this machine, not adopted alone).
- EMA as one _foreach_lerp_ (BAGEL_OPT_EMA_LERP=1, train/fsdp_utils.py): time run with cuBLASLt on:
/tmp/r11/time_blaslt_lerp, started 06:39:16.
- cuBLASLt + EMA lerp (switches /tmp/r11/switches_blaslt_lerp.json): time run /tmp/r11/time_blaslt_lerp = 1.4537
(1.7862 s/step), +0.8% vs the submission. Full check started 06:45 (/tmp/r11/check_blaslt_lerp). If PASS: commit the two
default-off switches and set /submission/switches.json to this file. If not: revert the two code switches.
- FULL CHECK INCORRECT (07:12): /tmp/r11/check_blaslt_lerp/check.json (speedup 1.4517 measured). Gate 3 failed on the two EMA
displacement endpoints (disp_ema_s050_100: -53 sigma; disp_ema_s100_140: -40 sigma; sigma ~4e-5). Cause: the single-pass
_foreach_lerp_ EMA rounds differently from upstream's mul-then-add; the EMA displacement endpoint is very sensitive to the
EMA arithmetic. Lesson: keep the EMA update exactly as upstream. Other endpoints passed (grad-norm endpoints at 1.0-1.6 sigma,
which says cuBLASLt-type changes move the trajectory noticeably). Conformance passed (n 1.60 ratio, j 1.12).
- Reverted both uncommitted switches (EMA lerp, cuBLASLt preference); the tree is back at commit 6d2fac4 and the submission
switches are unchanged (verified PASS, N1, 1.4356).
- Selective activation checkpointing (BAGEL_OPT_SAC_MM_FIRST=K; train/pretrain_unified_navit.py): save the outputs of the
matmuls (mm/addmm/bmm) for the first K decoder layers instead of recomputing them in backward (same values). First attempt
failed (context_fn must be functools.partial of create_selective_checkpoint_contexts); fixed; time run /tmp/r11/time_sac12b (K=12).
- SAC K=12 result (/tmp/r11/time_sac12b): 1.2834 (2.0232 s/step), peak alloc 102.9 GiB, reserved 124.4 GiB: 12% SLOWER
than the submission despite less recompute. Hypothesis: allocator behaviour with expandable segments under the larger
footprint. Testing the same SAC config without PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF (/tmp/r11/time_sac12_noexp).
- SAC K=12 without expandable segments (/tmp/r11/time_sac12_noexp): 1.2758 (2.0352 s/step): same slowdown, so the allocator
is not the cause. The selective policy is a Python callback on every op (dispatch mode), a likely host-side cost. Rejected;
code reverted (tree back at 6d2fac4).6.0 hRound 13 (07:32-): attribution of non-GEMM time, FSDP division removal
- Attribution (CPU op that launched each kernel; /tmp/r13/attrib.py, parents2.py; rank 0, per step): slice backward zero-fill
+ add 43 ms (permuted x[:n]/x[n:] slices), cat 59 ms (split backward 32, forward 25), copy 47 ms (FSDP casts 28, VAE and
ViT autocast 15), FSDP post-backward division div_ 24 ms (2 divides per unit, full unsharded gradient), flash K/V gathers
and their index_put backward ~35 ms.
- Change (switch BAGEL_OPT_NO_GRAD_DIVIDE=1): FSDP predivide/postdivide factors set to 1 on every FSDP module, and the loss
normalization uses scale 1 instead of world_size (ce and mse). The loss scale is a power of two (4), so all backward
values and reduce-scatter sums scale exactly and the divisions removed were exact: expected bitwise identical gradients.
Logged loss values change by the factor 4 (logging only).
- Check: check --quick on the N0 config + switch (/tmp/r13/quick_n0_nodiv) to confirm bitwise identity.
- check --quick on the N0 config + BAGEL_OPT_NO_GRAD_DIVIDE=1 (/tmp/r13/quick_n0_nodiv): PASS, tier N0 (bitwise identical
to the reference record). So the change is a pure reorganization of the scale: N0.
- Time run of the submission config + NO_GRAD_DIVIDE=1 (/tmp/r13/time_nodiv) started 07:43.
- Time run submission + NO_GRAD_DIVIDE=1 (/tmp/r13/time_nodiv): 1.4614 (1.7768 s/step), speedup +1.4% vs 1.4417 (beyond
noise). Tier N0 for this switch (bitwise quick check above); the full config stays N1 (flash path).
- Full check of this config started 07:49 (/tmp/r13/check_nodiv). If PASS: commit the switch and set switches.json.
- Batched flash calls (BAGEL_OPT_FLASH_BATCHED=1): all runs of a forward issued from one split of the queries and one
index-select of keys/values (+ one split each). CPU check (/tmp/r13/test_batched.py): forward output exactly equal to the
per-sample calls; gradients differ at bf16 summation-order level (input grad 2e-4, max param grad 3e-3 relative, same order
as flash vs dense). Time run queued behind the running full check: /tmp/r13/time_nodiv_batched.
- Pair carry (BAGEL_OPT_PAIR_CARRY=1): understanding and generation rows carried as two tensors through the permuted layers
(per-part projections, norms, RoPE, attention core; o_proj and MLP per part; residual adds per part). CPU check
(/tmp/r13/test_pair.py): outputs exactly equal and all gradients exactly equal to the default permuted path, with flash
(per-sample and batched) and with the dense fallback; the pair layers are called. Time run queued: /tmp/r13/time_pair.
- FULL CHECK PASS (08:15): /tmp/r13/check_nodiv/check.json: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.4698 for the submission config
+ BAGEL_OPT_NO_GRAD_DIVIDE=1 (was 1.4356). /submission/switches.json = /tmp/r13/switches_nodiv.json.
- Committed (see git log): NO_GRAD_DIVIDE switch + default-off FLASH_BATCHED and PAIR_CARRY code. The default path is the
checked one (the new code only runs under the new switches).
- Time run nodiv + BAGEL_OPT_FLASH_BATCHED=1 (/tmp/r13/time_nodiv_batched): 1.5275 (1.6999 s/step), +4.5% vs the nodiv
configuration (1.4614 in its time run). Pair-carry run next (/tmp/r13/time_pair).
- Time run nodiv + batched + pair carry (/tmp/r13/time_pair): 1.5593 (1.6652 s/step), +2.1% over batched, +6.7% over the
adopted nodiv configuration. Full check of this config started 08:25 (/tmp/r13/check_pair). If PASS: adopt
/tmp/r13/switches_pair.json as the submission switch file and commit the WORK_LOG note.
- FULL CHECK PASS (08:52): /tmp/r13/check_pair/check.json: PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.5582 for nodiv + BAGEL_OPT_FLASH_BATCHED=1
+ BAGEL_OPT_PAIR_CARRY=1 (code committed in aa57b3f). /submission/switches.json = /tmp/r13/switches_pair.json.
- SUBMISSION NOW: commit aa57b3f + switches: KEEP_UNSHARDED, FORWARD_PREFETCH, LIMIT_ALL_GATHERS=0, MOT_PERMUTE, ATTN_FLASH,
FLASH_BATCHED, PAIR_CARRY, FUSED_ADAMW, NCCL_PROTO=Simple (no effect), COMPILE_RMSNORM, COMPILE_MLP_ACT, COMPILE_ROPE,
NO_GRAD_DIVIDE, expandable segments.7.3 hRound 14 (08:53-): profile of the pair configuration
- Profile of the submission (aa57b3f + pair switches) started 08:53: /tmp/r14/profile (judge profile, rank 0, steps 8-9). - Flash views (BAGEL_OPT_FLASH_VIEWS=1, with FLASH_BATCHED): profile of aa57b3f+pair showed the split backward of the batched keys/values (35 ms/step, cat of all runs' key rows) as the largest remaining non-GEMM item. Views: queries split once; keys/values split once per sample; prefix runs take views of the sample's key rows (no copy), hole runs gather. CPU check (/tmp/r14/test_views.py): output exact vs gathered batched; gradients 2e-4 (input) / 3e-3 (params) relative. Time run /tmp/r14/time_views started 08:59. - Flash views on the pair configuration (/tmp/r14/time_views): 1.5609 (1.6635 s/step) vs 1.5593 for the pair configuration: no gain (within noise). Although the split-backward cats were 35 ms per step in the profile, removing them did not move the step time: the critical rank's time is not the rank 0 kernel sum. Code reverted (patch kept at /tmp/r14/views_attempt.patch). - Round 14 profile (pair configuration, rank 0, per step): GEMM 666 ms, NCCL 685 ms (overlapped), flash attention 180, compiled Triton 74, fused AdamW 34, EMA foreach 19, clip 10, cat 46, copy 46 (FSDP casts 27, VAE/ViT autocast ~10), index 27, add 20, sum 12. The remaining non-GEMM items are each 1-5% and mostly inherent (FSDP mixed-precision casts, optimizer, autograd sums).
7.3 hRound 14 verdict (09:38 UTC): ViT without activation recomputation adopted
- Full check of pair + BAGEL_OPT_VIT_NO_AC=1 (/tmp/r14/check_vitnoac, 09:11-09:38): PASS, tier N1, speedup 1.5958 (candidate 1.6271 s/step against the frozen reference 2.5966; window range 0.9%; window ratios 1.5928 and 1.5989). Gate 2 NOT_BITWISE with the exact items passing: the first differing shards (step 0) are the gradients and both Adam moments of r0.model0, so the un-recomputed ViT changes gradient bits (the cause was not isolated; the change is N1). Gate 2b conforming: deterministic R_N ratio 1.56, R_J 1.05; production R_N ratio 1.47, R_J 0.97 (bound 3.0). Gate 3 seed 1 equivalent: all 14 endpoints within 3 sigma. Peak allocated 95.66 GiB, reserved 119.84 GiB. - Adopted: /submission/switches.json = /tmp/r14/switches_vitnoac.json (pair configuration + BAGEL_OPT_VIT_NO_AC=1). Code committed as a21d36d (N1; time run 1.6045; full check 1.5958). Working tree clean. - The previous full check (pair configuration, aa57b3f) was 1.5582; this round adds +2.4% on the full check.
8.4 hRound 15 (09:40-): profile of the submission (a21d36d + switches), NCCL and stream switches
- Profile /tmp/r15/profile (judge profile, rank 0, steps 8-9; per step = total / 2): NCCL ReduceScatter 537 ms (116 calls
over 2 steps, 9.3 ms avg, RING_LL), AllGather 383 ms (6.6 ms avg, RING_LL); GEMM (aten::mm + addmm) ~730 ms; flash
attention forward 69 ms + backward 95 ms; compiled Triton 75 ms; cat 47 ms; copy_ 47 ms; index + elementwise gathers
~61 ms; fused AdamW 34 ms; EMA foreach 11 ms; VAE conv + group norm ~32 ms.
- NCCL diagnostics (kernel names only, no timing; /tmp/r15/nccl/names.py): NCCL_NVLS_ENABLE=1 still launches RING_LL
for unit-sized all-gather and reduce-scatter (NVLS is set up but not selected); NCCL_PROTO=SIMPLE: the tuner reports
proto 2 but the launched kernels are still RING_LL (same conclusion as round 11).
- AC_SKIP_FIRST=2 on top of VIT_NO_AC (/tmp/r15/time_ac2): 1.5896 (1.6335 s/step) vs the control run of the submission
(/tmp/r15/time_base): 1.6040 (1.6188 s/step). Rejected: about 0.9% slower; memory headroom is the limit (about 2.8 GB of
activations per LM layer at 10240 tokens, and reserved memory was 119.8 GiB).
- Switch tests on a21d36d (judge time; control = /tmp/r15/time_base 1.6040, 1.6188 s/step; run-to-run spread of this
control is about 0.5%, so differences below about 0.6% are not resolved by one run):
NCCL_MAX_NCHANNELS=12: 1.6163 (1.6065 s/step), repeat 1.6067 (1.6161 s/step): no gain. =16: 1.6113 (1.6115), +0.45%, not
repeated. =8: 1.5906 (1.6324), -0.8%. TORCH_NCCL_HIGH_PRIORITY=1: 1.5857 (1.6375), -1.1%. TORCH_NCCL_AVOID_RECORD_STREAMS=1:
1.5938 (1.6292), -0.6%. Rejected all; the submission keeps the default NCCL settings.
- EMA update on a side stream (BAGEL_OPT_EMA_STREAM=1, a copy at /tmp/r15/tree_ema; optimizer waits for the EMA of the
previous step, EMA waits for the optimizer, checkpoints wait for the EMA; the judge's digests are taken in the optimizer
post-hook, which sees the same EMA state): 1.5890 (1.6341 s/step), -1.0%. Rejected (the quick check was stopped, it was
not needed). Not committed.
- Trace analysis of /tmp/r15/profile (rank 0, 2 steps; no GPU): compute stream busy 1.17 s/step, idle 0.59 s/step; 0.45 s/step
of the idle time is inside NCCL kernels. The three largest gaps (337, 201, 157 ms over the 2 steps) are entirely inside NCCL
kernels; the largest one is a CPU thread blocked for 335 ms in cudaLaunchKernel (GeluBackward0, ViT backward) while an NCCL
kernel is in flight. So rank 0 waits for the slower ranks and its compute stream is starved behind the spinning collectives;
the step is set by the slowest rank's compute plus its waits.
- Looked at and dropped: the flash path already keeps K/V in KV heads (the repeat only in the rare dense fallback), so GQA
expansion is not a cost on the main path.
- Results of that queue: NCCL_BUFFSIZE=16 MB 1.6041 (1.6187 s/step, equal to the control); NCCL_NTHREADS=512 1.6003
(1.6226, -0.2%); baseline repeat 1.5992 (1.6237). The control spread over this round is 1.6183-1.6237 s/step, about
0.4%, so all NCCL knobs are at noise level. The NCCL line is closed.
- Step-start stall (rank 0 trace, window start): the first all-gather starts at 52 ms and then waits 82 ms for the other
ranks; the CPU is in an aten::item sync inside FSDP.forward (bagel.py:169/383 take torch.max(vit_token_seqlens).item()).
Before it on rank 0: an 18 ms blocking batch copy (aten::to), the token all-reduce, and the VAE encode (one
AutoEncoder.encode call per step on padded_images; about 20 conv launches at 1.1-1.5 ms CPU each). So the slowest rank
reaches the first collective later, because of per-rank VAE/batch work. Candidate remedies: a one-batch lookahead that
prefetches the VAE encode of the next batch (the judge's noise is keyed by encode ordinal, so this is allowed); it needs
a checkpoint-state correction for the loader, so it is not started. Estimated gain 1-3%, uncertain.
- Other host syncs inside the training forward (bagel.py:169, 383, 753): each costs a few ms, not pursued yet.
- Next option under consideration: FlashAttention-3 (hopper) for the attention runs (attention is ~165 ms of rank-0 time
and the slowest rank carries more of it). Source clone started at 11:01 (/tmp/r16/fa3src); the sdist route failed.9.9 hRound 16 (11:00-11:35): FlashAttention-3 blocked; host-side copies and data depth (no adoption)
- FlashAttention-3: GitHub clone failed (TLS errors, retried over HTTP/1.1); the PyPI sdist of flash-attn 2.8.3 downloads at
about 25 KB/s and CUTLASS is a GitHub submodule. Not feasible in this container now; dropped for this session.
- Mask copy on a side stream (BAGEL_OPT_MASK_COPY_STREAM=1, a copy at /tmp/r16/tree_mask): the dense fp32 attention masks
(18 ms blocking host copy per step) are copied on a side stream; the training loop waits for the copy event before the
forward (after the VAE encode). Record digests of the deterministic quick check equal the verified candidate's digests on
all four ranks (bitwise no-op relative to a21d36d). Timing: 1.6126 (1.6102 s/step) and 1.5919 (1.6311 s/step) for the same
tree: a 1.3% spread between two runs. Mean is not better than the control. Not adopted; code not committed.
- Prefetch depth (BAGEL_OPT_PREFETCH_FACTOR=4, a copy at /tmp/r16/tree_pf; same batches and order): 1.5962 (1.6267 s/step),
no gain. So the data worker is not what makes the slowest rank late at the first collective; the step-start skew comes
from the per-rank VAE/ViT pre-forward work (see the round 15 notes). Not adopted.
- Measurement lesson: one judge time run of the same tree varies by about 1% (1.6102 vs 1.6311). Only effects above about
1.5% can be called from one run; repeat a candidate before adopting anything smaller.