GPT-6.2 Sol 2.59×
Harness: Codex · switches: none
- Judged
- 2.59×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 2.58×
- Rounds
- 54
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $22.5
- Input tokens · 97.7% cached
- 109 M
- Output tokens
- 0.7 M
- Requests
- 796
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log54 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — baseline profile
- Start: 2026-11-18 06:17:57 UTC. - Unchanged upstream atc121f04, empty switches. Detached profile PID 21432;/tmp/r1/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r1/profile. - Frozen reference: 2,772.4 ms/step, spread 0.19%, windows 28.013 s and 27.435 s. - Rank 0 detail profile: 2,739 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 1,355 ms (49.4%); AllGather: 298.5 ms (10.9%); ReduceScatter: 61.2 ms (2.2%); largest elementwise kernel: 133.6 ms (4.9%). CPU-inclusiveaten::nonzero: 777.3 ms, including waits for previously queued GPU work. - Hypothesis: ZeRO-2 can eliminate per-layer parameter gathers, while retaining BF16 computation and sharded FP32 AdamW. Tested in detached worktree/tmp/r1/tree; the submitted tree is still untouched. Detached timing PID 21941;/tmp/r1/time.log, outputs/tmp/r1/time. Result: ERROR, first loss 1.3758 vs 1.3839 (0.585% vs 0.5% limit). The rejected screen measured 1.0378× with windows 26.997 s and 26.430 s; not a valid gain. - Follow-up within the same communication hotspot: retain ZeRO-3 and increase parameter reuse distance (15B), live budget (8B) and prefetch (150M). Detached timing PID 22597;/tmp/r1/time-reuse.log, outputs/tmp/r1/time-reuse. - End: 2026-11-18 06:25:54 UTC. ZeRO-3 reuse preserved first loss, but measured only 1.0134× (2,735.8 ms/step, windows 27.681 s and 27.034 s; 83.96 GiB peak) against the 1.02× benefit bar. Neither configuration was adopted. No check was run for the rejected screens.
0.2 hRound 2 — decoder padding
- Start: 2026-11-18 06:26:22 UTC. Detached two-step upstream profile PID 23268;/tmp/r2/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r2/profile. - Profile: 2,817 ms/step aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 1,476 ms (52.4%); AllGather: 218.8 ms (7.8%); largest elementwise kernel: 144.5 ms (5.1%). Inclusive checkpoint backward: 1,800 ms; inclusivenonzero: 858 ms (includes stream waits). The decoder runs its projections/MLP on padded positions and repeats mask compaction at every FlashAttention layer, including during recomputation. - Implemented optionalLLAVA_PACK_SEQUENCES=1in detached/tmp/r2/tree. Mask offsets and RoPE positions are computed once; causal FlashAttention retains separate boundaries, and the original shape is restored before the unchanged LM head and loss. Detached timing PID 23783;/tmp/r2/time.log, outputs/tmp/r2/time. - Timing: 1.4054×, 1,972.7 ms/step, windows 20.076 s and 19.378 s, 68.06 GiB peak, first loss 1.3839 (identical when logged). - Detached quick PID 24413;/tmp/r2/quick.log, verdict/tmp/r2/quick/check.json: PASS, no exact failures, measured N1. End: 2026-11-18 06:35:11 UTC. Promoted commit8cd30c7after quick. Full check queued after the next profile, same detached PID 25892;/tmp/r2/check.log, outputs/tmp/r2/check. - Full check: PASS (N1), 1.4123× at 06:44:38 UTC,/tmp/r2/check/check.json. This is a check against the frozen reference timing, not the final paired score.
0.3 hRound 3 — activation recomputation
- Start: 2026-11-18 06:35:51 UTC. Profile of packed baseline, detached PID 25892;/tmp/r3/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r3/profile. - Profile: 2,124 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 1,087.8 ms (51.2%); AllGather: 223.3 ms (10.5%); largest elementwise kernel: 100.1 ms (4.7%); ReduceScatter: 45.0 ms (2.1%).CheckpointFunctionBackwardremains the largest inclusive CPU range (1,264.3 ms, enclosing recompute and backward). - Trial: preserve checkpointing for the first 16 decoder layers and keep ordinary autograd activations for the remaining 16 (LLAVA_UNCHECKPOINTED_LAYERS=16). This keeps identical layer schedules across ranks and leaves the original default intact. In/tmp/r3/tree; timing PID 27245 waits for the packed baseline full check, then logs to/tmp/r3/time.logwith outputs/tmp/r3/time. - Timing: 1.5630× vs reference, 1,773.7 ms/step (10.1% less latency than packing alone), windows 18.097 s and 17.378 s, 115.12 GiB peak. First logged loss remains 1.3839. Exact check in progress, PID 29452,/tmp/r3/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r3/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 06:50:21 UTC. Quick PASS (N1 stack), no exact failures,/tmp/r3/quick/check.json. Committed as229d0f0in the staged worktree. Full check follows the next profile (detached PID 30798;/tmp/r3/check.log). Submission keeps the full-checked packed baseline pending that result. - Full check: PASS (N1), 1.5447× at 06:58:47 UTC,/tmp/r3/check/check.json. Promoted229d0f0and the 16-layer switch after the full pass.
0.6 hRound 4 — RMS normalization
- Start: 2026-11-18 06:50:41 UTC. Detached PID 30798;/tmp/r4/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r4/profile, using the quick-passing Round 3 stack. - Profile: 1,836 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 955.4 ms (52.0%); AllGather: 143.4 ms (7.8%); ReduceScatter: 46.7 ms (2.5%); largest BF16 elementwise kernel: 83.2 ms (4.5%). Separate FP32 multiply, square and mean kernels are 30.1, 10.6 and 6.5 ms; prior trace correlation associated many additional casts and pointwise passes with norm shapes. Checkpoint backward's inclusive range fell from 1,264 ms to 645 ms. - Enabled pinned FlashAttention's fused RMSNorm only for BF16 CUDA LLaMA norms (LLAVA_FUSED_RMS_NORM=1), with unmodified trainable parameters and fallback. The fused function keeps normalization and scaling in FP32 until the BF16 output, so this is a local N2 change. Detached time PID 32366 waits on the prior verdict;/tmp/r4/time.log, outputs/tmp/r4/time. - Timing: 1.7063×, 1,624.8 ms/step (8.4% less latency than prior screen), windows 16.480 s and 16.015 s; peak 100.09 GiB (15.03 GiB less); first logged loss 1.3833. Quick PID 34697,/tmp/r4/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r4/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 07:03:59 UTC. Quick PASS, exact items unchanged; the judge reports N1 for the recorded tensors. The local rounding change is treated as N2. Committed9e644f1in the staged worktree. Full check follows the next profile, detached PID 35639,/tmp/r4/check.log. - Full check: PASS, 1.7104× (judge N1; local N2) at 07:12:41 UTC,/tmp/r4/check/check.json. Promoted9e644f1and enabled the fused norm after the full pass.
0.8 hRound 5 — spend the recovered activation memory
- Start: 2026-11-18 07:04:15 UTC. Profile of the quick-passing fused-norm stack, detached PID 35639;/tmp/r5/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r5/profile. - Profile: 1,807 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 990.5 ms (54.8%); AllGather: 229.3 ms (12.7%); ReduceScatter: 60.1 ms (3.3%); largest BF16 elementwise: 58.8 ms (3.3%). Checkpoint backward inclusive: 579 ms. The norm fusion lowered the measured peak by 15 GiB, so the compute/recompute trade-off can be retuned. - Screen fixed cross-rank retention of all 32 layers, falling back to screening 28 if timing fails or peak exceeds 133 GiB. Detached PID 38151 waits on the prior full check; launcher log/tmp/r5/time-launch.log. Switches/tmp/r5/switches-32.jsonand/tmp/r5/switches-28.json, outputs/tmp/r5/time-32and/tmp/r5/time-28, individual logs/tmp/r5/time-32.logand/tmp/r5/time-28.log. - Detached quick PID 39543 waits for the timing screen and checks its selected configuration;/tmp/r5/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r5/quick. - All 32 layers: ERROR (CUDA OOM) in/tmp/r5/time-32, allocating a further 3.37 GiB with 3.00 GiB free (124.89 GiB allocated; 9.70 GiB allocator reserve unused). No speedup reported by the judge. - Retain 28 layers: 1.8210×, 1,522.5 ms/step (6.3% less latency than the fused-norm screen), windows 15.585 s and 14.864 s, 124.47 GiB peak; first loss 1.3833. Quick and full checks are pending; the 16-layer full-checked configuration remains submitted. Full check queued after a profile, detached PID 42321,/tmp/r5/check.log. - End: 2026-11-18 07:19:10 UTC. Quick PASS,/tmp/r5/quick/check.json. The tuned count is in the switch file; accompanying opt-in documentation committed ase1bb377in scratch. Full check is pending before promotion. - Full check: PASS, 1.8128× (judge N1; local N2 stack) at 07:27:22 UTC,/tmp/r5/check/check.json. Promotede1bb377with 28 as the new selected layer count after the full pass.
1.1 hRound 6 — SwiGLU intermediates
- Start: 2026-11-18 07:19:27 UTC. Detached PID 42321 profiled the 28-layer stack,/tmp/r6/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r6/profile. - Profile: 1,733 ms aggregate GPU kernel time, top five BF16 GEMMs 900.2 ms (51.9%), AllGather 291.5 ms (16.8%), ReduceScatter 49.2 ms (2.8%), largest BF16 elementwise 50.1 ms (2.9%), separate SiLU forward/backward 17.2 ms (1.0%) plus gate multiply/casts. Prior trace showed most collectives overlap compute; SwiGLU fusion also removes the SiLU activation retained by the 28 ordinary autograd layers. - Trial:LLAVA_FUSED_SWIGLU=1selects pinned FlashAttention's fused gate for CUDA BF16 LLaMA MLPs, preserving the three trainable projections and shifting the intermediate rounding (local N2). Detached time PID 45208 waits for the prior full check;/tmp/r6/time.log, outputs/tmp/r6/time. - If the 28-layer fusion measures at most 120 GiB peak, detached PID 46503 screens all 32 layers again to test the recovered memory. Logs/tmp/r6/time-32.log; outputs/tmp/r6/time-32. - Fused SwiGLU at 28 layers: 1.8797×, 1,474.9 ms/step (3.1% less latency), windows 15.008 s and 14.490 s, 115.90 GiB peak (8.57 GiB saved), first loss 1.3834. At 32 layers: 1.8852×, 1,470.6 ms/step, windows 15.080 s and 14.332 s, 122.80 GiB peak. The extra 0.29% latency gain is unresolved, so retain 28 with greater memory and window margin. - Quick PID 48878,/tmp/r6/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r6/quick. Full check queued behind the next profile, PID 48879;/tmp/r6/check.log, outputs/tmp/r6/check. - End: 2026-11-18 07:35:05 UTC. Quick PASS,/tmp/r6/quick/check.json, no exact failures. Committedd1f8a0din the staged worktree. The submitted configuration remains the prior full pass while the fused gate is validated. - Full check: PASS, 1.8799× (judge N1; local N2 stack) at 07:43:08 UTC,/tmp/r6/check/check.json. Promotedd1f8a0dwith 28 retained layers; the submitted config also disables disk persistence of the NVRTC kernels to guarantee fresh compilation.
1.4 hRound 7 — packed rotary embedding
- Start: 2026-11-18 07:35:22 UTC. Detached PID 48879 profiled the quick-passing fused SwiGLU stack;/tmp/r7/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r7/profile. - Profile: 1,698 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 908.5 ms (53.5%); AllGather: 258.5 ms (15.2%); ReduceScatter: 58.1 ms (3.4%); largest BF16 pointwise kernel: 50.2 ms (3.0%), with separate concatenation at 20.7 ms and negation at 11.0 ms. Packed Q/K still use separate gather, multiply, rotate and add ops. - Trial:LLAVA_FUSED_ROTARY=1selects the pinned FlashAttention rotary kernel for compatible packed BF16 sequences with default positions, preserving HF tables, per-sequence boundaries, and fallback. FP32 fused rotation changes the local rounding (N2). Detached time PID 52832 waits on the prior full check;/tmp/r7/time.log, outputs/tmp/r7/time. - Correlating kernel launch timestamps to CPU ops identified 91.3 ms (5.4% aggregate) of Q/K-shaped multiply, add and negation, excluding concatenations. SetUSE_PYTORCH_KERNEL_CACHE=0for subsequent fused-SwiGLU runs, to keep PyTorch's separate NVRTC disk cache cold as well as the judge-managed caches. The first SwiGLU timing run was already cold. - Timing: 2.0060×, 1,382.1 ms/step (6.3% less latency), windows 14.062 s and 13.579 s; peak 115.74 GiB; first loss 1.3838. The NVRTC disk-cache switch was added after this launch began, so the full check will independently verify the configuration with it disabled. - Quick PID 55165,/tmp/r7/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r7/quick. Full check queued after the next profile, PID 55166;/tmp/r7/check.log, outputs/tmp/r7/check. - End: 2026-11-18 07:49:15 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures (/tmp/r7/quick/check.json); rotary committed as7059934. Full check pending before promotion. - Full check with the NVRTC disk cache disabled: PASS, 1.9884× (judge N1; local N2 stack) at 07:57:28 UTC,/tmp/r7/check/check.json. Promoted the rotary configuration and commit7059934.
1.7 hRound 8 — ZeRO-3 collectives
- Start: 2026-11-18 07:49:32 UTC. Detached PID 55166 profiled the rotary stack;/tmp/r8/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r8/profile. - Profile: 1,571 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 932.1 ms (59.3%); AllGather: 239.1 ms (15.2%); ReduceScatter: 54.0 ms (3.4%); fused rotary: 15.2 ms (1.0%). Revisit communication now that the shorter compute path leaves a different overlap budget. - Screen NCCL Simple protocol independently of retaining ZeRO-3 parameters up to 17M elements (including the attention projections but not the larger MLP matrices). Neither changes precision or optimizer state. Detached PID 60718 waits for the rotary full pass;/tmp/r8/time-launch.logand/tmp/r8/time-{simple,persist}.log, outputs/tmp/r8/time-{simple,persist}. - NCCL interval union: only 43.4 / 22.3 ms exposed on ranks 0 / 1, versus 236.0 / 499.0 ms overlapping other GPU kernels. Treat reductions in aggregate NCCL duration as potential overlap/SM effects; judge windows decide whether time is actually recovered. - NCCL Simple: 2.0053×, 1,382.5 ms/step, windows 14.043 s and 13.607 s, 115.74 GiB peak; essentially no incremental benefit. Stock NCCL selection kept. - ZeRO-3 persistence: 2.0352×, 1,362.2 ms/step, windows 13.853 s and 13.391 s, 122.13 GiB peak; first loss unchanged at 1.3838. 1.4% less latency versus the preceding screen. Quick PID 62420 (/tmp/r8/quick.log,/tmp/r8/quick); full check queued after the next profile, PID 62421 (/tmp/r8/check.log,/tmp/r8/check). - End: 2026-11-18 08:09:52 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures,/tmp/r8/quick/check.json. Committed persistence in scratch as1b589c0; the prior full pass stays submitted until the full check completes. - Full check: PASS, 2.0375× (judge N1; local N2 stack) at 08:18:14 UTC,/tmp/r8/check/check.json. Promoted1b589c0; active environment switches are unchanged.
1.9 hRound 9 — supervised-token projection and cross entropy
- Start: 2026-11-18 08:10:09 UTC. Detached PID 62421 profiled the persistence variant,/tmp/r9/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r9/profile. - Profile: 1,512 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 924.3 ms (61.1%); AllGather: 190.8 ms (12.6%); ReduceScatter: 51.6 ms (3.4%); FlashAttention backward main kernel: 45.6 ms (3.0%). Vocabulary GEMMs/casts/cross entropy processing ignored positions accounted for 40.1 ms (2.7%), including 19.3 ms of GEMMs and 8.2 ms of copies. - TrialLLAVA_COMPACT_TOKEN_LOSS=1: use the same shifted-label mean cross entropy on non-ignored labels; Trainer requests loss without materializing full logits during its loss-only calls. Model forwards that request logits still return the complete tensor and use the same supervised-token objective. No change to the training step input dictionary or normalization. Detached time PID 66005 waits for the previous verdict,/tmp/r9/time.log, outputs/tmp/r9/time. - Quick PID 66795 waits on a valid timing gain,/tmp/r9/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r9/quick. - Timing: 2.0742×, 1,336.6 ms/step (1.9% less latency), windows 13.625 s and 13.108 s, 116.26 GiB peak (5.87 GiB saved), first loss 1.3838. Full check queued behind the next profile, PID 69969;/tmp/r9/check.log, outputs/tmp/r9/check. - End: 2026-11-18 08:23:24 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures (/tmp/r9/quick/check.json), and staged9dac2f1. The prior full pass remains submitted until the full check completes. - Full check: PASS, 2.0742× (judge N1; local N2 stack) at 08:31:22 UTC,/tmp/r9/check/check.json. Promoted9dac2f1and enabled compact loss.
2.2 hRound 10 — packed GEMM dimension alignment
- Start: 2026-11-18 08:23:41 UTC. Detached PID 69969 profiled the quick-passing compact-loss stack,/tmp/r10/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r10/profile. - Profile: 1,576 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 906.4 ms (57.5%); AllGather: 290.4 ms (18.4%, mostly overlapping); ReduceScatter: 50.7 ms (3.2%); FlashAttention backward main kernel: 45.1 ms (2.9%). The changing packed token dimension remains the outer or reduction dimension of the expensive GEMMs. - TrialLLAVA_PACK_TOKEN_ALIGNMENT=128appends an independent, zero, unsupervised segment solely to align the internal token dimension. No padding can attend to real sequences or reach the output, and the path requires zero attention dropout. Detached time PID 72537 waits for the compact-loss verdict,/tmp/r10/time.log, outputs/tmp/r10/time. - End: 2026-11-18 08:33:00 UTC. Timing: 2.0757×, 1,335.7 ms/step, 116.45 GiB peak. The 0.07% incremental improvement over Round 9 is below the measured 0.38% noise band; discarded without quick check or commit.
2.3 hRound 11 — BF16 GEMM library
- Start: 2026-11-18 08:34:58 UTC. Detached PID 75558 profiles the full-passing compact-loss stack,/tmp/r11/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r11/profile. - Profile: 1,362 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top five BF16 GEMMs: 895.6 ms (65.8%); AllGather: 78.4 ms (5.8%); ReduceScatter: 61.0 ms (4.5%); FlashAttention backward main kernel: 45.7 ms (3.4%). Newer cuBLAS is a low-complexity way to try improved Hopper GEMM algorithms without changing PyTorch, trainable parameters, or tensor dtypes. - Cancelled a slow PyPI download (PIDs 76203 and 76285), then installed NVIDIA's hash-verified <ip> runtime in an isolated directory in/opt/candidate-env. Detached PID 76481,/tmp/r11/redist-time.log; candidate-onlyLD_PRELOADin/tmp/r11/switches.json. Timing/tmp/r11/time/time_tree.json: 2.1403×, 1,295.3 ms/step, windows 13.246 s and 12.660 s, 116.26 GiB peak, unchanged logged first loss (1.3838). This saves 3.1% versus Round 9. - Exact check for 12.8: detached PID 77310,/tmp/r11/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r11/quick. - The exact check PASS at 08:48:09 UTC (/tmp/r11/quick/check.json); tensor numerics are not bitwise. A CPU loader inspection confirmed both <ip> libraries were actually mapped in the candidate process. - Independent <ip> screen (detached PID 78285,/tmp/r11/redist-time-12.9.log, result/tmp/r11/time-12.9/time_tree.json): 2.1426×, 1,293.9 ms/step, 116.26 GiB peak. The 0.11% incremental gain is below the noise band, so keep the exact-checked 12.8 runtime. - End: 2026-11-18 08:51:47 UTC. Staged4c5aa57documenting the N1 library change (N2 stack). Full check is queued after the next profile, same detached PID 80047,/tmp/r11/check.log, outputs/tmp/r11/check. Submission retains the prior full pass pending the verdict. - Full check: PASS, 2.1433× (judge N1; local N2 stack),/tmp/r11/check/check.json, at 08:59:43 UTC. Promoted4c5aa57and enabled the <ip> preload in the submitted switches.
2.6 hRound 12 — frozen vision attention
- Launched 2026-11-18 08:51:47 UTC. Detached PID 80047 profiles the quick-passing cuBLAS 12.8 stack,/tmp/r12/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r12/profile. - Profile: 1,444 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. The top six cuBLAS kernels account for 845.3 ms (58.5%); AllGather 143.7 ms (9.9%); ReduceScatter 117.0 ms (8.1%); decoder FlashAttention main backward 45.2 ms (3.1%). Frozen vision forward accounts for 67.1 ms (4.6%), including 17.5 ms (1.2%) in the two attention BMMs and softmax, plus layout and scaling kernels. - TrialLLAVA_FLASH_VISION=1replaces the eager attention of frozen CLIP with pinned FlashAttention 2 for unmasked CUDA BF16 forwards with no dropout. Preserves the original projections and feature selection. FP32 attention intermediates change rounding (local N2). Detached timing PID 82305 waits for the cuBLAS verdict,/tmp/r12/time.log, outputs/tmp/r12/time. - End: 2026-11-18 09:01:26 UTC. CPU fallback matched the original outputs and attention weights. Timing/tmp/r12/time/time_tree.json: 2.1488×, 1,290.2 ms/step, 116.26 GiB peak. The 0.26% gain versus the current full check is below the 0.38% frozen noise band; discarded without quick check or commit.
2.8 hRound 13 — packed decoder residual additions
- Launched 2026-11-18 09:05:33 UTC. Detached PID 84886 profiles the full-passing cuBLAS stack,/tmp/r13/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r13/profile. - Profile: 1,431 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. The top six cuBLAS kernels account for 842.2 ms (58.9%); AllGather 142.3 ms (9.9%); ReduceScatter 104.2 ms (7.3%); FlashAttention main backward 45.0 ms (3.1%). The top remaining pointwise kernel is BF16 add (24.2 ms, 1.7%), including decoder residual additions and gradient merges. - TrialLLAVA_FUSED_RESIDUAL_NORM=1carries the residual stream between packed layers and uses pinned FlashAttention's prenorm RMSNorm with residual additions. Exposed residual state remains BF16; local N2 from FP32 addition used immediately by the normalization and its backward. Detached timing PID 85567,/tmp/r13/time.log, outputs/tmp/r13/time. - End: 2026-11-18 09:10:20 UTC. Timing/tmp/r13/time/time_tree.json: 2.1008×, 1,319.7 ms/step, 116.60 GiB peak. Fusion was 2.0% slower than the current full-passing stack; discarded without quick check or commit.
2.9 hRound 14 — AdamW memory traffic
- Launched 2026-11-18 09:13:39 UTC. Detached PID 86542 profiles the full-passing cuBLAS stack,/tmp/r14/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r14/profile. - Profile: 1,358 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 838.7 ms (61.8%), ReduceScatter 107.4 ms (7.9%), AllGather 76.6 ms (5.6%), FlashAttention main backward 45.0 ms (3.3%). Five large multi-tensor kernels account for 50.2 ms (3.7%). - Correlation to theOptimizer.step#AdamW.stepCPU scopes attributes 65.2 ms of GPU work (4.8% of the profile's aggregate kernel time) to the five AdamW subgroups. - TrialLLAVA_FUSED_ADAMW=1keeps PyTorch AdamW with identical hyperparameters and FP32 states, but selects its fused CUDA kernel. Initial timing attempt (PID 87232,/tmp/r14/time.log, outputs/tmp/r14/time) returned ERROR: PyTorch's constructor checks device eligibility before ZeRO-3 installs CUDA master partitions and sees CPU placeholders. - Revised trial enables the fused option on the optimizer groups after construction only for BF16, CUDA, non-offloaded ZeRO-3. Detached PID 87747,/tmp/r14/time-groups.log, outputs/tmp/r14/time-groups; quick check is queued only if timing meets the screen. Submission remains the full-checked cuBLAS stack. - Revised timing at 09:19:33 UTC: 2.1591×, 1,284.1 ms/step, windows 13.071 s and 12.611 s, 116.27 GiB peak. This saves 0.73% relative to the current full check. Quick check uses the same detached PID,/tmp/r14/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r14/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 09:23:47 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures,/tmp/r14/quick/check.json. Staged12a0aa3(N1 change, local N2 stack). Full check queued behind the next profile, detached PID 90354,/tmp/r14/check.log, outputs/tmp/r14/check. - Full check: PASS, 2.1504× at 09:31:43 UTC,/tmp/r14/check/check.json. Promoted12a0aa3and enabled the fused optimizer. The full-check incremental improvement is smaller than the timing screen's, consistent with a small gain.
3.1 hRound 15 — ZeRO-3 MLP weight residency
- Launched 2026-11-18 09:23:47 UTC. Detached PID 90354 profiles the quick-passing fused AdamW stack,/tmp/r15/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r15/profile. - Profile: 1,461 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 846.3 ms (57.9%); AllGather 161.7 ms (11.1%); ReduceScatter 121.9 ms (8.3%); fused AdamW 56.3 ms (3.9%, down from 65.2 ms of unfused AdamW work). - NCCL interval union was 275.4 / 374.9 ms on ranks 0 / 1, with only 52.8 / 71.2 ms without overlapping compute. The new candidate tests whether more residency saves any of the exposed time rather than just rearranging overlap. - Trial raises ZeRO-3 per-parameter residency to 46M elements to include the decoder MLP. Two candidate trees cap total residency at 5.0B and 6.6B elements; both preserve the ZeRO stage, hyperparameters, and precision. Detached PID 92096 queues the two timing screens after the fused AdamW verdict,/tmp/r15/time-launch.log, outputs/tmp/r15/time-partialand/tmp/r15/time-full. - End: 2026-11-18 09:35:17 UTC. The 5.0B cap measured 2.1357×, 1,298.1 ms/step and 119.15 GiB peak; 6.6B measured 2.1479×, 1,290.8 ms/step and 120.55 GiB peak. Both timings were valid, but neither improved on the fused AdamW stack. Discarded both without quick check or commit.
3.3 hRound 16 — packed QKV projection and layout
- Launched 2026-11-18 09:36:45 UTC. Detached PID 95985 profiles the full-passing fused AdamW stack,/tmp/r16/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r16/profile. - Profile: 1,523 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 846.2 ms (55.6%), AllGather 219.8 ms (14.4%), ReduceScatter 121.8 ms (8.0%), FlashAttention main backward 45.2 ms (3.0%), rotary kernels 14.8 ms (1.0%). The QKV projections remain separate GEMMs, rotary launches, and input-gradient merges. - TrialLLAVA_PACK_QKV=1concatenates the weights only for each projection call, registers their unchanged parameters with ZeRO-3, and feeds jointly rotated Q/K into the packed FlashAttention API. Shared projection gradients change the reduction order (local N2). Detached timing PID 96663,/tmp/r16/time.log, outputs/tmp/r16/time. - First timing ERROR at 09:39:49 UTC: installed DeepSpeed exposeszeroas an attribute, not an importabledeepspeed.zeromodule. Corrected the import to the publicfrom deepspeed import zeroentry point before re-measuring. - Detached retry PID 97111,/tmp/r16/time-fixed.log, outputs/tmp/r16/time-fixed. The submitted tree remains the fused AdamW full pass. - End: 2026-11-18 09:43:12 UTC. Valid retry: 2.1374×, 1,297.1 ms/step, 121.80 GiB peak,/tmp/r16/time-fixed/time_tree.json. It is 0.6% slower than the current full check and uses 5.5 GiB more; discarded without quick check or commit.
3.5 hRound 17 — within-step token balance
- Launched 2026-11-18 09:43:40 UTC. Detached PID 97941 profiles the full-passing fused AdamW stack,/tmp/r17/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r17/profile. - CPU workload sizing with the original conversation/tokenization pipeline found that only 0.12% of expanded fixture tokens trail the final supervised target, so causal-tail pruning is not attractive. Estimated rank imbalance over the 80 existing megabatches was 1.56% with word lengths versus 0.13% using expanded token counts (counts only, not a timing result). - Profile: 1,461 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 844.7 ms (57.8%), AllGather 171.3 ms (11.7%), ReduceScatter 112.6 ms (7.7%), fused AdamW 56.5 ms (3.9%). The dense decoder GEMMs scale with the number of packed tokens; the profiled image step had 13,600 versus 13,254 across ranks. - TrialLLAVA_BALANCE_PACKED_TOKENS=1lazily tokenizes prompt lengths, includes vision patch counts, and balances only within existing full, single-modality megabatches. Image and label preprocessing and the per-micro-batch token mean are preserved. Detached PID 98617,/tmp/r17/time.log, outputs/tmp/r17/time; quick check is queued only if the gain is resolved. - End: 2026-11-18 09:47:48 UTC. Timing 2.0533×, 1,350.2 ms/step and 111.91 GiB peak,/tmp/r17/time/time_tree.json. The data probe passed, but the online sampler added 4.7% latency compared with the current full check. Lower imbalance did not pay for the extra input pipeline work; discarded without quick check or commit.
3.6 hRound 18 — FP32 AdamW bandwidth kernel
- Launched 2026-11-18 09:49:39 UTC. Detached PID 99387 profiles the full-passing fused AdamW stack,/tmp/r18/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r18/profile. - Profile: 1,495 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 840.7 ms (56.2%), AllGather 195.7 ms (13.1%), ReduceScatter 125.9 ms (8.4%), fused AdamW 56.2 ms (3.8%). The master weights and moments are contiguous and the fused optimizer remains an exposed bandwidth cost. - TrialLLAVA_TRITON_ADAMW=1uses a single streaming Triton update on the existing contiguous FP32 ZeRO-3 partitions with zero weight decay, and preserves PyTorch's state initialization and the original AdamW groups. Uses a generic AdamW fallback for unsupported layouts/settings. Detached PID 100081,/tmp/r18/time.log, outputs/tmp/r18/time; quick check queued only on a resolved timing gain. - Initial timing ERROR at 09:53:36 UTC: pinned Triton 2.1 exposes explicit rounded FMA, division, and square root undertl.math. Corrected the kernel intrinsics and retried. - Detached corrected timing PID 100594,/tmp/r18/time-fixed.log, outputs/tmp/r18/time-fixed. - Second timing ERROR at 09:55:23 UTC: the kernel compiled and launched, but PyTorch 2.1's autograd version API requires one tensor per call. Changed the post-update version bumps to individual tensors and retried. - Third timing (PID 101102,/tmp/r18/time-stream.log, outputs/tmp/r18/time-stream) returned ERROR at 09:57:54 UTC: DataLoader worker segfault. Suspect Triton JIT running during ZeRO's state initialization before DataLoader fork. The next variant uses PyTorch's own AdamW for state creation, enabling Triton only once the corresponding FP32 state exists. - Detached lazy-JIT timing PID 101788,/tmp/r18/time-lazy.log, outputs/tmp/r18/time-lazy. - Lazy-JIT timing at 10:01:06 UTC: 2.2227×, 1,247.3 ms/step, windows 12.722 s and 12.224 s, 116.26 GiB peak, first loss 1.3838. This saves 3.26% compared with the current full check. Quick check now runs under the same detached PID in/tmp/r18/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r18/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 10:05:02 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures (/tmp/r18/quick/check.json). Stagedcbda53c(N1 change, local N2 stack). Full check queued after the next profile, detached PID 104494,/tmp/r18/check.log, outputs/tmp/r18/check. - Full check: PASS, 2.2163× at 10:12:53 UTC,/tmp/r18/check/check.json. Promotedcbda53cand enabled streaming AdamW; FP32 master and moment dtypes, exact items, and both trajectory endpoints pass.
3.8 hRound 19 — ZeRO-3 gradient staging
- Launched 2026-11-18 10:05:02 UTC. Detached PID 104494 profiles the quick-passing streaming AdamW stack,/tmp/r19/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r19/profile. - Profile: 1,385 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 842.1 ms (60.8%); AllGather 138.6 ms (10.0%); ReduceScatter 107.7 ms (7.8%); the newadamw_updatekernel 23.4 ms (1.7%, down from 56.2 ms of native fused AdamW). The installed ZeRO-3 implementation stages gradients in a contiguous buffer before coalescing them again for reduce-scatter. - Trialcontiguous_gradients: falseeliminates that preliminary copy, leaving bucket sizes, communication dtype, and reduce-scatter unchanged. Detached PID 105661 waits for the streaming AdamW verdict and uses its switches;/tmp/r19/time.log, outputs/tmp/r19/time. - The trace attributes 197 D2D copies (4.34 GB, 3.0 ms aggregate) directly to__add_grad_to_ipg_bucket. A second gradient-reduction screen keeps staging off and grows the reduce-scatter bucket from 16.8M to 67.1M elements, testing whether fewer collectives save more than the copy removal alone. - Larger-bucket variant is queued if the first variant has no resolved gain, detached PID 107726,/tmp/r19/time-larger.log, outputs/tmp/r19/time-larger. - End: 2026-11-18 10:16:18 UTC. Without staging: 2.2284×, 1,244.1 ms/step and 116.23 GiB peak (/tmp/r19/time/time_tree.json), just 0.26% better than the matched Round 18 screen. Larger bucket: 2.2197×, 1,249.0 ms/step, 116.23 GiB (/tmp/r19/time-larger/time_tree.json). Both timing runs were valid; neither shows a resolved gain. Discarded without quick check or commit.
4.0 hRound 20 — checkpoint recomputation follow-up
- Launched 2026-11-18 10:17:07 UTC. Detached PID 110210 profiles the submitted, full-passing streaming AdamW stack,/tmp/r20/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r20/profile. - Profile: 1,400 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 839.9 ms (60.0%), AllGather 147.4 ms (10.5%), ReduceScatter 115.8 ms (8.3%), AdamW streaming update 23.4 ms (1.7%).CheckpointFunctionBackwardis a 138.1 ms inclusive CPU range, including backward work as well as recomputation. Retest retaining all 32 after compact loss recovered memory and the compute/overlap mix changed. - TrialLLAVA_UNCHECKPOINTED_LAYERS=32over the submitted tree, detached PID 110884,/tmp/r20/time.log, outputs/tmp/r20/time. The submission remains on 28 until a resolved gain and full pass. - Timing at 10:20:43 UTC: 2.2636×, 1,224.8 ms/step, 123.14 GiB peak, a 1.8% latency reduction compared with the matched 28-layer screen. Quick check under the same PID,/tmp/r20/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r20/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 10:25:56 UTC. Quick PASS (/tmp/r20/quick/check.json), no exact failures. Staged56b19b0documenting 32-layer retention. Full check queued behind the next profile: detached PID 113570,/tmp/r20/check.log, outputs/tmp/r20/check. The full check will test the longer trajectory's memory headroom. - Full check: PASS, 2.2616×,/tmp/r20/check/check.json. Both statistical endpoints are within 0.15σ. Promoted56b19b0and enabled 32-layer retention.
4.2 hRound 21 — duplicate dummy-image forward
- Launched 2026-11-18 10:25:56 UTC. Detached PID 113570 profiles the quick-passing 32-layer stack,/tmp/r21/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r21/profile. - Profile: 1,377 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 807.6 ms (58.7%), AllGather 157.9 ms (11.5%), ReduceScatter 117.8 ms (8.6%), FlashAttention main backward 45.2 ms (3.3%). The frozen vision forward takes 75.7 ms on rank 0 on the profiled image batch. - TrialLLAVA_DEDUP_DUMMY_IMAGES=1encodes one all-zero image for text-only batches, retaining the projector's zero-gradient path. Detached PID 114977 queues timing behind the Round 20 full check;/tmp/r21/time.log, outputs/tmp/r21/time. - End: 2026-11-18 10:35:27 UTC. Timing/tmp/r21/time/time_tree.json: 2.2376×, 1,239.0 ms/step, 122.99 GiB peak, valid. This is 1.15% slower than the matched 32-layer timing screen. The device-to-host predicate sync costs in image-heavy windows outweigh sparse dummy-image savings. No quick check or commit.
4.3 hRound 22 — unused frozen vision layers
- Launched 2026-11-18 10:36:27 UTC. Detached PID 118462 profiles two steps of the submitted 32-layer stack,/tmp/r22/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r22/profile. - Profile: 1,353 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 685.6 ms (50.7%), AllGather 125.4 ms (9.3%), ReduceScatter 122.0 ms (9.0%), attention backward 47.5 ms (3.5%). The frozen CLIP vision tower runs all 24 blocks but LLaVA uses its penultimate hidden state. - TrialLLAVA_CLIP_EARLY_EXIT=1keeps embeddings and the selected encoder prefix, leaving all parameter registration intact and skipping only unused tail outputs. Detached PID 119225,/tmp/r22/time.log, outputs/tmp/r22/time; quick check queued for a resolved timing gain. - End: 2026-11-18 10:40:31 UTC. Timing/tmp/r22/time/time_tree.json: 2.2619×, 1,225.7 ms/step, 123.14 GiB peak, valid. No resolved gain over the matched 32-layer screen; discarded without quick check or commit.
4.4 hRound 23 — ZeRO-3 gradient norm reductions
- Launched 2026-11-18 10:41:13 UTC. Detached PID 120095 profiles two steps of the submitted 32-layer stack,/tmp/r23/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r23/profile. - Profile: 1,374 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 691.9 ms (50.4%), AllGather 131.0 ms (9.5%), ReduceScatter 125.5 ms (9.1%), FlashAttention backward 47.9 ms (3.5%). Gradient norms use 8.6 ms of FP64 reduction kernels (0.6%) plus conversions, launches, and scalar reads. - TrialLLAVA_FUSED_ZERO3_GRAD_NORM=1validates that the gradient views cover the contiguous ZeRO-3 partition, squares and reduces them in FP64 without writing a FP64 input copy, and combines group sums in one DP all-reduce. Offloaded, noncontiguous, and model-parallel gradients keep DeepSpeed's original path. Detached PID 120863,/tmp/r23/time.log, outputs/tmp/r23/time. - Timing at 10:45:20 UTC: 2.3199×, 1,195.1 ms/step, 123.14 GiB peak, 0.75% window spread, valid. This is 2.4% lower latency than the matched 32-layer screen. Quick check runs under the same PID,/tmp/r23/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r23/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 10:49:58 UTC. Quick PASS (no exact failures),/tmp/r23/quick/check.json. Stagede82da02; the norm regrouping changes FP64 summation order without changing the gradients or Adam update. - Full check queued after quick pass and the next profile. Detached PID 122689,/tmp/r23/check.log, outputs/tmp/r23/check. The submitted tree stays at the Round 20 pass until the verdict. - Full check: PASS, 2.3059× at 10:57:00 UTC,/tmp/r23/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack). Both endpoints are within 0.09σ. Promotede82da02and enabled the fused FP64 norm.
4.5 hRound 24 — explicit BF16 GEMM plans
- Detached PID 122689 queues a two-step profile of the quick-passing gradient-norm stack,/tmp/r24/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r24/profile. - Launched 2026-11-18 10:49:11 UTC. Profile: 1,369 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 696.9 ms (50.9%), AllGather 146.8 ms (10.7%), ReduceScatter 125.3 ms (9.2%), FlashAttention backward 47.7 ms (3.5%). Fused norm now takes 1.5 ms of GPU kernels (0.1%), down from 8.6 ms of reductions plus casts. - TrialLLAVA_CUBLASLT_LINEAR=1dispatches matching bias-free BF16 linear projections, input gradients, and weight gradients via cached cuBLASLt plans with 32 MiB per stream. It preserves parameter names, FP32 accumulation and the existing reduced-precision-reduction setting; other shapes keep the PyTorch path. The native wrapper builds and loads on CPU. Detached PID 126413 waits for the full norm verdict,/tmp/r24/time.log, outputs/tmp/r24/time. - End: 2026-11-18 10:58:44 UTC. Timing/tmp/r24/time/time_tree.json: 2.2360×, 1,239.9 ms/step, 123.18 GiB peak. Windows 13.160 s and 11.638 s; 10.2% relative window spread was marked interference. The mean is 3.75% slower than the matched norm screen; no robust incremental gain and not suitable for final pairing. Discarded without quick check or commit.
4.7 hRound 25 — optimizer gradient staging
- Launched 2026-11-18 10:59:56 UTC. Detached PID 128939 profiles two steps of the submitted fused-gradient-norm stack,/tmp/r25/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r25/profile. - Profile: 1,446 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 692.3 ms (47.9%), AllGather 217.4 ms (15.0%), ReduceScatter 136.5 ms (9.4%), FlashAttention backward 47.3 ms (3.3%). Optimizer gradient staging runs a BF16 flatten (6.4 ms), FP32 cast (10.0 ms), and identity unscale (6.3 ms), roughly 1.6% of GPU kernel time. - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_DIRECT_GRAD_CAST=1reuses the exact contiguous views verified by the norm path, casts into FP32 master gradients in one streaming pass, and skips unity multiplication only when clipping is disabled. Preserves DeepSpeed gradient release and falls back for unsupported layouts. Detached PID 129690,/tmp/r25/time.log, outputs/tmp/r25/time. - Timing at 11:04:10 UTC: 2.3380×, 1,185.8 ms/step, 123.14 GiB peak, 1.62% window spread, valid. The matched screen is 0.78% faster than norm alone. Quick check under the same PID,/tmp/r25/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r25/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 11:07:44 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures,/tmp/r25/quick/check.json. Staged6db79bc: the direct cast and skipped unity scaling preserve finite FP32 gradients bitwise. - Full check queued after quick pass and next profile: detached PID 131134,/tmp/r25/check.log, outputs/tmp/r25/check. Submission stays at the Round 23 full pass until this verdict. - Full check: PASS, 2.3464× at 11:15:58 UTC,/tmp/r25/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack). Both endpoints are within 0.09σ. Promoted6db79bcand enabled direct FP32 gradient staging.
4.8 hRound 26 — BF16 optimizer writeback
- Detached PID 131134 queues a two-step profile of the quick-passing direct-cast stack,/tmp/r26/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r26/profile. - Profile completed 2026-11-18 11:09:23 UTC: 1,537 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 697.4 ms (45.4%), AllGather 320.6 ms (20.9%, overlapped), ReduceScatter 134.8 ms (8.8%), FlashAttention backward 47.5 ms (3.1%). Direct gradient casting is 5.1 ms, with flatten and unity multiply gone. The sequential FP32-to-BF16 weight writeback still takes 10.0 ms (0.7%). - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_BF16_WRITEBACK=1adds the BF16 shard store to the streaming AdamW kernel. It retains FP32 master and moment stores and DeepSpeed's unflattening, falling back to the original copy if the fused kernel did not write the shard. Detached PID 134630 queues behind the direct-cast full check,/tmp/r26/time.log, outputs/tmp/r26/time. - End: 2026-11-18 11:17:39 UTC. Timing/tmp/r26/time/time_tree.json: 2.3243×, 1,192.8 ms/step, 123.14 GiB peak, 1.44% window spread, valid. This is 0.59% slower than the matched direct-cast screen; discarded without quick check or commit.
5.0 hRound 27 — identical causal prefixes
- Launched 2026-11-18 11:18:23 UTC. Detached PID 138017 profiles two steps of the submitted direct-cast stack,/tmp/r27/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r27/profile. - Profile: 1,435 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 689.9 ms (48.1%), AllGather 227.9 ms (15.9%), ReduceScatter 136.8 ms (9.5%), FlashAttention backward 47.0 ms (3.3%). Many of the dense decoder rows have the same causal Vicuna conversation prefix, so a shared prefix can reduce the GEMM token dimension without removing any training sample or supervised position. - TrialLLAVA_SHARE_CAUSAL_PREFIX=1: verify a common unmasked text prefix with standard positions and dropout disabled, compute its decoder states once, restore the K/V boundary for each sequence, and expand the final hidden output. Backward sums gradients for each original occurrence; accumulation order changes (local N1/N2). CPU layout and shared-gradient identity tests passed. Detached PID 138834,/tmp/r27/time.log, outputs/tmp/r27/time. - First screen at 11:23:23 UTC: 2.3436×, 1,183.0 ms/step, 121.34 GiB peak, 4.98% window spread, valid. This saves 1.8 GiB, but the 0.24% latency reduction is below the measured noise band. Detached PID 139751 profiles the prefix trial to price its K/V expansion overhead before deciding whether to fuse it;/tmp/r27/profile-prefix.log, outputs/tmp/r27/profile-prefix. - Prefix profile: 1,409 ms aggregate GPU kernel time; top six BF16 GEMMs 767.2 ms (54.5%), ReduceScatter 179.7 ms (12.8%), AllGather 144.4 ms (10.2%). New BF16 row gathers occupy 60.0 ms (4.3%), with additional prefix gradient reduction/copy work. - Follow-upLLAVA_FUSED_PREFIX_EXPAND=1uses vectorized Triton row copies and a fused gather/sum in backward. Keeps all contributions and FP32 prefix summation, with a layout fallback. Detached PID 140514;/tmp/r27/time-fused.log, outputs/tmp/r27/time-fused. - End: 2026-11-18 11:28:43 UTC. Fused screen/tmp/r27/time-fused/time_tree.json: 2.3430×, 1,183.3 ms/step, 121.34 GiB peak, 5.73% window spread, valid. Neither variant resolved a gain over the direct-cast stack or beat its full-check timing. Both discarded without quick check or commit.
5.2 hRound 28 — direct packed multimodal inputs
- Launched 2026-11-18 11:29:58 UTC. Detached PID 141440 profiles two steps of the submitted direct-cast stack,/tmp/r28/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r28/profile. - Profile: 1,334 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 694.1 ms (52.0%), ReduceScatter 132.2 ms (9.9%), AllGather 125.1 ms (9.4%), FlashAttention backward 47.8 ms (3.6%). In the two profiled stepsIndexFirstAxisgathers 13,600 and 14,724 rows from freshly padded 17,808- and 21,648-row activation tensors; its backward constructs corresponding padded gradients. - TrialLLAVA_DIRECT_PACKED_INPUTS=1directly concatenates the already processed unpadded embeddings, builds the identical sequence offsets from their lengths, and retains dense labels and outputs. CPU packing and gradient identity passed. Detached PID 142304,/tmp/r28/time.log, outputs/tmp/r28/time. - Timing at 11:34:47 UTC: 2.3609×, 1,174.3 ms/step, 123.15 GiB peak, 3.41% window spread, valid. The matched timing gain is 0.97% lower latency. Quick check runs under the same PID,/tmp/r28/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r28/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 11:38:20 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures,/tmp/r28/quick/check.json. Staged425ee4cwith the packed-input layout change. - Full check queued after quick pass and next profile: detached PID 143892,/tmp/r28/check.log, outputs/tmp/r28/check. The submitted tree stays at the Round 25 pass pending the verdict. - Full check: PASS, 2.3636× at 11:46:49 UTC,/tmp/r28/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack). Both endpoints are within 0.23σ. Promoted425ee4cand enabled direct packed inputs.
5.3 hRound 29 — ZeRO-3 collective channel pressure
- Detached PID 143892 queues a two-step profile of the quick-passing direct-packed-input stack,/tmp/r29/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r29/profile. - Profile launched 11:38:38 UTC: 1,355 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 696.4 ms (51.4%), AllGather 153.6 ms (11.3%), ReduceScatter 124.3 ms (9.2%), FlashAttention backward 47.6 ms (3.5%). The trace ranks collective channel pressure ahead of splice metadata: collective launches use up to 24 blocks and overlap BF16 GEMMs, while the preceding stage trace attributes only 3.85 ms inclusive to multimodalnonzeroand scalar reads combined. - NCCL interval union is 265.1 / 433.0 ms/step on ranks 0 / 1; 48.4 / 144.0 ms lacks overlapping compute, including peer waiting. The 24-block kernels account for 262.5 / 403.9 ms aggregate. Try less SM pressure without changing the payload, precision, or collective order. - Detached PID 147160 queuesNCCL_MAX_NCHANNELS=12and=8screens behind the direct-pack full check. Switches/tmp/r29/switches-{12,8}.json, logs/tmp/r29/time-{12,8}.log, outputs/tmp/r29/time-{12,8}. Quick check only for a resolved winner with valid windows. - End: 2026-11-18 11:50:03 UTC. 12-channel screen: 2.3702×, 1,169.7 ms/step, 3.39% window spread (/tmp/r29/time-12/time_tree.json). 8-channel screen: 2.3638×, 1,172.9 ms/step, 2.68% spread (/tmp/r29/time-8/time_tree.json). Both valid, 123.14 GiB peak; 12 channels improves the full-pass timing by only 0.28%, below the noise band. Neither promoted; no quick check or commit.
5.5 hRound 30 — batched token embedding
- Launched 2026-11-18 11:50:39 UTC. Detached PID 151484 profiles two steps of the submitted direct-packed-input stack,/tmp/r30/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r30/profile. - Profile: 1,326 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 689.7 ms (52.0%), ReduceScatter 129.2 ms (9.7%), AllGather 127.1 ms (9.6%), FlashAttention backward 47.4 ms (3.6%). The decoder token table does 16 full-shape backward calls (2.95 ms total) plus 15 BF16 gradient adds (2.92 ms), excluding the embedding module's ZeRO scheduling. - TrialLLAVA_BATCH_TOKEN_EMBEDDINGS=1gathers unmasked text tokens once and splits the resulting embeddings back to their original rows and image-boundary segments. Uses the same embedding parameter; the sum order changes (local N1). Detached PID 152260,/tmp/r30/time.log, outputs/tmp/r30/time. - Timing at 11:54:43 UTC: 2.3789×, 1,165.4 ms/step, 123.15 GiB peak, 2.93% window spread, valid. This is 0.76% lower latency than the matched direct-packed-input screen. Quick check under the same PID,/tmp/r30/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r30/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 11:58:17 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures,/tmp/r30/quick/check.json. Stagedd41b102. - Full check queued after quick pass and the next profile: detached PID 153448,/tmp/r30/check.log, outputs/tmp/r30/check. Submission stays at the Round 28 full pass pending this verdict. - Full check: PASS, 2.3771× at 12:06:25 UTC,/tmp/r30/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack). Both endpoints are within 0.15σ. Promotedd41b102and enabled batched token embedding.
5.6 hRound 31 — unused vision computation on text-only batches
- Detached PID 153448 queues a two-step profile of the quick-passing batched-embedding stack,/tmp/r31/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r31/profile. - Profile finished 11:59:52 UTC: 1,337 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 690.7 ms (51.7%), AllGather 146.7 ms (11.0%), ReduceScatter 124.0 ms (9.3%), FlashAttention backward 47.5 ms (3.6%). The frozen CLIP module still runs before determining whether any image token is present. Unlike Round 21, bypass the whole unused tower in text-only batches and do not scan image tensors. - TrialLLAVA_SKIP_UNUSED_VISION=1selects this path only when there are no unmasked image placeholders and the module is dropout-free frozen CLIP with a linear/GELU projector. The projector runs on empty features so the optimizer still receives its full zero gradients. CPU ZeRO-3 projector gradient and RNG identity passed. Detached PID 157195 waits for the batched-embedding full check,/tmp/r31/time.log, outputs/tmp/r31/time. - Timing at 12:08:01 UTC: 2.3956×, 1,157.3 ms/step, 118.26 GiB peak, 1.68% window spread, valid. Latency improves 0.70% compared with the matched batched-embedding screen. Quick check under the same PID,/tmp/r31/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r31/quick. - Full check queued directly after quick pass. Detached PID 161599,/tmp/r31/check.log, outputs/tmp/r31/check. Submission remains the Round 30 full pass until the verdict. - Quick PASS at 12:11 UTC,/tmp/r31/quick/check.json; no exact failures. The verdict run has completed its timing phase and moved on to recording. - End: 2026-11-18 12:18:19 UTC. Full check PASS, 2.3822×, 1,163.8 ms/step, 118.26 GiB peak,/tmp/r31/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack). Both trajectory endpoints are within 0.20σ. Both full-check windows improved; across the screen and full check, the mean latency fell 0.45% versus Round 30 and peak allocation fell 4.9 GiB. Promoted9dcaafdwithLLAVA_SKIP_UNUSED_VISION=1.
5.9 hRound 32 — packed decoder attention backend
- Queued 2026-11-18 12:12 UTC. Detached PID 163613 profiles the best full-passing stack after the Round 31 check,/tmp/r32/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r32/profile. - The profile started 12:18:26 UTC, after the Round 31 full pass. Prepared pinned FA3/CUDA build prerequisites without touching the submitted tree (detached PID 165491,/tmp/r32/deps.log). - Profile: 1,403 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 702 ms (50.0%), AllGather 174.5 ms (12.4%), ReduceScatter 147.1 ms (10.5%); FlashAttention forward and three backward kernels account for 73.4 ms (5.2%). TrialLLAVA_HOPPER_ATTENTION=1selects FlashAttention 3 for packed BF16, 128-wide, zero-dropout MHA on Hopper (local N2 backend). It retains offsets, causality, and deterministic backward support. - Built the Hopper backend from FlashAttentionv2.7.4.post1with CUDA 12.8.93 and the pinned PyTorch (detached PID 167359,/tmp/r32/build-fixed.log); the wheel installed under a separate name in/opt/candidate-env. Import required CUDA runtime 12.8.90 for a new driver symbol, resolved with a candidate-only preload. FA2 remains installed and used when the switch is off. - Detached PID 167672,/tmp/r32/verify.logand/tmp/r32/time.log. Packed 16-sequence attention output and dQ/dK/dV have ≤0.12% relative L2 versus FA2 in both math modes, with unchanged CUDA RNG. Timing/tmp/r32/time, quick check/tmp/r32/quickqueued for an incremental gain. The submission remains the Round 31 full pass. - Timing at 12:26:11 UTC: 2.4291×, 1,141.3 ms/step, 118.24 GiB peak, windows 11.658 s and 11.169 s, valid. This is 1.38% lower latency than the matched Round 31 screen. - Quick PASS at 12:29:45 UTC,/tmp/r32/quick/check.json, no exact failures. Detached PID 169439 runs the full check,/tmp/r32/check.log, outputs/tmp/r32/check. - End: 2026-11-18 12:36:22 UTC. Full check PASS, 2.4307×, 1,140.6 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, windows 11.616 s and 11.196 s,/tmp/r32/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack). Both trajectory endpoints are within 0.14σ. Promoted20d2193withLLAVA_HOPPER_ATTENTION=1and the CUDA runtime dependency.
6.3 hRound 33 — ZeRO-3 gradient reduce-scatter predivision
- Queued 2026-11-18 12:29:46 UTC. Detached PID 170616 profiles the best stack after the Round 32 verdict,/tmp/r33/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r33/profile. - Profile completed 12:37:55 UTC (GPU start 12:36:41). 1,377 ms aggregate GPU kernel time; top six BF16 GEMMs 708.4 ms (51.4%), AllGather 178.5 ms (13.0%), ReduceScatter 141.8 ms (10.3%); FA3 main backward 25.1 ms (1.8%). The trace contains 293 in-place BF16 scalar divides per step (mostly the 16.8M/45.1M-element decoder gradients); the largest BF16 scalar multiply kernel accounts for 14.7 ms (1.1%). - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_REDUCE_SCATTER_AVG=1uses NCCL's native pre-scaled BF16 average for equally split single-gradient buckets on two ranks. It retains the output rank/partition and falls back for other buckets. Standalone two-rank tests including BF16 subnormals and production-size buffers were bitwise identical. Detached PID 175004,/tmp/r33/verify.log,/tmp/r33/time.log, outputs/tmp/r33/time; quick check queued for a measured gain. - Timing at 12:42:29 UTC: 2.4482×, 1,132.4 ms/step, 118.24 GiB peak, windows 11.508 s and 11.141 s, valid. This is 0.78% lower than the matched Round 32 latency. Quick check under PID 175004 (/tmp/r33/quick.log,/tmp/r33/quick); detached PID 177006 queues the full check on quick pass (/tmp/r33/check.log,/tmp/r33/check). The submission remains the Round 32 full pass. - Quick PASS at 12:46:02 UTC, no exact failures. End: 2026-11-18 12:52:37 UTC. Full check PASS, 2.4469×, 1,133.0 ms/step,/tmp/r33/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack). Both trajectory endpoints are within 0.18σ. Promoted01f3eacand enabled native BF16 reduce-scatter averaging.
6.5 hRound 34 — frozen CLIP checkpoint overhead
- Queued 2026-11-18 12:44:19 UTC. Detached PID 177007 profiles the best stack after the Round 33 verdict,/tmp/r34/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r34/profile. - Profile 12:52:58–12:54:12 UTC: 1,279 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 701.6 ms (54.9%), AllGather 156.7 ms (12.3%), ReduceScatter 87.4 ms (6.8%), FA3 main backward 25.1 ms (2.0%). The new reduce-scatter path leaves only one separate BF16 scalar divide per step.CheckpointFunctioncovers 92.5 ms inclusive CPU, with CLIP-shaped inputs[16, 577, 1024]; the previous early-exit variant's guard excluded this checkpoint-enabled encoder. - TrialLLAVA_SELECTED_CLIP_FEATURES=1computes the selected no-grad, dropout-free CLIP hidden state directly, skipping checkpoint wrappers and unused later operations while preserving the child module calls and parameters. CPU BF16 selected features and RNG match with checkpointing enabled, for list/tensor images and several selected layers. Detached PID 182242,/tmp/r34/verify.log,/tmp/r34/time.log, outputs/tmp/r34/time, quick check queued for a measured gain. - Timing at 12:57:45 UTC: 2.4563×, 1,128.7 ms/step, 118.19 GiB peak, windows 11.507 s and 11.067 s, valid. The 0.33% latency reduction is borderline; request a full check independently to confirm, without promoting the trial. Quick check under PID 182242 (/tmp/r34/quick.log,/tmp/r34/quick); detached PID 184187 queues the full check on quick pass (/tmp/r34/check.log,/tmp/r34/check). - Quick PASS at 13:01:19 UTC. End: 2026-11-18 13:07:59 UTC. Full check PASS, 2.4413×, 1,135.6 ms/step,/tmp/r34/check/check.json. The gain did not repeat, and the mean across both runs is within the frozen noise band of Round 33. Discarded without promotion; both statistical endpoints were within 0.10σ.
6.7 hRound 35 — direct ZeRO-3 reduce-scatter destination
- Queued 2026-11-18 12:58:48 UTC. Detached PID 184188 profiles the best stack after the Round 34 verdict,/tmp/r35/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r35/profile. - Profile 13:08:16–13:09:30 UTC: 1,404 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 707.4 ms (50.4%), AllGather 261.5 ms (18.6%), ReduceScatter 99.6 ms (7.1%), FA3 main backward 25.1 ms (1.8%). D2D copies matching large BF16 gradient partition sizes account for 6.76 GB and 7.13 ms per step. - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_DIRECT_REDUCE_SCATTER=1writes each eligible single-gradient average directly into its existing ZeRO-3 partition buffer on the first micro-step. DeepSpeed's bookkeeping is retained, and PyTorch elides the same-storage copy. Standalone two-rank tests verified the destination alias and bitwise values on production-size buffers. Detached PID 189590,/tmp/r35/verify.log,/tmp/r35/time.log, outputs/tmp/r35/time; quick check queued for a measured gain. The submission remains the Round 33 full pass. - Timing at 13:13:42 UTC: 2.4579×, 1,128.0 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, windows 11.500 s and 11.059 s, valid. Latency improves 0.39% versus the matched Round 33 screen. Quick check under PID 189590 (/tmp/r35/quick.log,/tmp/r35/quick); detached PID 191595 queues the full check on quick pass (/tmp/r35/check.log,/tmp/r35/check). - Quick PASS at 13:17:15 UTC. Full check PASS, 2.4557× at 13:23:51 UTC, 1,128.9 ms/step,/tmp/r35/check/check.json, both endpoints within 0.04σ. Both windows improved; the two-run mean improvement of 0.38% is at the frozen noise band. Detached PID 196746 queues a paired switch sweep after the next baseline profile,/tmp/r35/sweep.log, outputs/tmp/r35/sweep. Submission stays at Round 33 pending the paired timing. - The first sweep refused duplicate switch-file stems before taking the GPU. Retried with distinct names at 13:26:22 UTC, detached PID 196795,/tmp/r35/sweep-named.log, outputs/tmp/r35/sweep-named. - End: 2026-11-18 13:32:15 UTC. Paired sweep/tmp/r35/sweep-named/sweep.json: 1,132.8 → 1,129.1 ms/step with the direct destination (0.33% gain); both arms valid. This repeats the modest gain observed in the independent timing and full check. Promoted82005f8with direct BF16 reduce-scatter destinations.
7.0 hRound 36 — paired packed rotary embeddings
- Queued 2026-11-18 13:15:33 UTC. Detached PID 191596 profiles the best stack after the Round 35 verdict,/tmp/r36/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r36/profile. - Profile 13:24:12–13:25:27 UTC: 1,277 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 697.8 ms (54.6%), AllGather 143.7 ms (11.3%), ReduceScatter 103.5 ms (8.1%), FA3 main backward 24.9 ms (1.9%); FlashAttention's rotary kernels 14.8 ms (1.2%). Trial uses each valid token's existing packed position and shares the sine/cosine loads for both Q and K, avoiding two launches and the per-sequence padded grid per layer/pass. Two-shape BF16 output/gradient comparison queued after the paired screen, detached PID 198219,/tmp/r36/verify.log. - Initial isolated verification failed becausekeycollides with a Triton 2.1 launcher variable. Renamed the argument and based the trial on the newly submitted direct-scatter stack. Detached PID 199823 from 13:35:09 UTC profiles the new baseline (/tmp/r36/profile-direct.log,/tmp/r36/profile-direct), retries the isolated check (/tmp/r36/verify-fixed.log), and on success timesLLAVA_PAIRED_ROTARY=1(/tmp/r36/time.log,/tmp/r36/time). Quick check queued for a resolved gain. No changes to the submitted tree or switch file for this trial. - New baseline profile: 1,310 ms aggregate GPU kernel time; top six BF16 GEMMs 702.9 ms (53.7%), AllGather 199.8 ms (15.2%), ReduceScatter 75.9 ms (5.8%), FA3 main backward 25.1 ms (1.9%), rotary 14.8 ms (1.1%). The direct-scatter baseline eliminated all matching large shard D2D copies from this profile. The retried paired rotary test returned bitwise-equal Q, K, dQ and dK at 525 and 14,102 packed tokens. - Timing at 13:38:19 UTC: 2.4719×, 1,121.5 ms/step, 118.20 GiB peak, windows 11.553 s and 10.878 s, valid. This saves 0.58% versus the matched direct-scatter screen. Quick check under PID 199823 (/tmp/r36/quick.log,/tmp/r36/quick); full check queued after exactness, detached PID 201860 (/tmp/r36/check.log,/tmp/r36/check). - Quick PASS at 13:41:53 UTC. End: 2026-11-18 13:48:25 UTC. Full check PASS, 2.4818×, 1,117.1 ms/step, windows 11.419 s and 10.923 s,/tmp/r36/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack), both endpoints within 0.14σ. Promoted7e85602and enabled the paired rotary kernel.
7.4 hRound 37 — parallel projection input gradients
- Queued 2026-11-18 13:38:54 UTC. Detached PID 201861 profiles the best stack after the Round 36 verdict,/tmp/r37/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r37/profile. - Profile 13:48:46–13:50:05 UTC: 1,540 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 698.1 ms (45.3%), AllGather 445.8 ms (28.9%, largely overlapped), ReduceScatter 70.1 ms (4.5%), FA3 main backward 25.0 ms (1.6%), and BF16 adds 20.9 ms (1.4%). The new paired rotary uses 7.3 ms of GPU time, down from 14.8 ms. The trace shows 224 packed-width BF16 additions per step, including the two Q/K/V input-gradient merges per decoder layer. - TrialLLAVA_FUSED_QKV_INPUT_GRAD=1preserves the three projection weights, forward GEMMs and weight-gradient GEMMs, accumulating input gradients through the BF16 GEMM epilogues instead of separate activation-size adds (local N2 rounding). The projections' existing parameters are registered with their attention owner for ZeRO. Detached PID 207845,/tmp/r37/verify.log,/tmp/r37/time.log, outputs/tmp/r37/time; quick check queued for a resolved gain. The submitted tree remains the Round 36 pass. - Isolated BF16 projections and weight gradients were bitwise identical; input gradients were within 0.32% relative L2. Timing at 13:53:41 UTC: 2.4944×, 1,111.4 ms/step, 121.17 GiB peak, windows 11.422 s and 10.807 s, valid. This is 0.90% lower than the matched Round 36 screen. Quick check under PID 207845 (/tmp/r37/quick.log,/tmp/r37/quick); detached PID 209344 queues the full check on quick pass (/tmp/r37/check.log,/tmp/r37/check). - Quick PASS at 13:57:14 UTC. End: 2026-11-18 14:03:49 UTC. Full check PASS, 2.5052×, 1,106.7 ms/step, 121.17 GiB peak, windows 11.326 s and 10.808 s,/tmp/r37/check/check.json(judge N1; local N2 stack); both endpoints within 0.23σ. Promoted7c66b13with GEMM input-gradient accumulation for Q/K/V.
7.6 hRound 38 — MLP gate/up input gradients
- Queued 2026-11-18 13:54:25 UTC. Detached PID 209345 profiles the best stack after the Round 37 verdict,/tmp/r38/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r38/profile. - Profile 14:04:08–14:05:32 UTC: 1,263 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 653.1 ms (51.7%), AllGather 149.5 ms (11.8%), ReduceScatter 99.2 ms (7.9%), FA3 main backward 25.1 ms (2.0%); Q/K/V GEMM epilogues replace the separate additions (remaining BF16 add kernels 15.3 ms, down from 20.9 ms). - TrialLLAVA_FUSED_MLP_INPUT_GRAD=1uses the same epilogue for the two MLP gate/up input-gradient contributions, leaving both trainable weights, weight gradients, swiglu and down projection intact (local N2 rounding). Detached PID 215125,/tmp/r38/verify.log,/tmp/r38/time.log, outputs/tmp/r38/time; quick check queued for a resolved gain. The submission remains the Round 37 pass. - End: 2026-11-18 14:08:43 UTC. The isolated comparison passed, but the valid screen was 2.4808×, 1,117.5 ms/step, versus the Round 37 screen at 1,111.4 ms/step./tmp/r38/time/time_tree.json; discarded without quick check or commit.
7.9 hRound 39 — ZeRO-3 parameter prefetch bucket
- Launched 2026-11-18 14:09:14 UTC. Detached PID 216120 profiles Round 37,/tmp/r39/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r39/profile. - Profile: 1,214 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 645.8 ms (53.2%), AllGather 106.6 ms (8.8%), ReduceScatter 103.4 ms (8.5%), FlashAttention 3 main backward 24.9 ms (2.1%). The automatic bucket is smaller than one MLP weight; test coalescing prefetches with a 120M-element bucket without changing residency, reuse distance, or reduction settings. - Detached PID 216893 was stopped before completing an unchanged-baseline run because the patch executable was missing fromPATH. Patched only the scratch tree and launched PID 217792 at 14:12:55 UTC,/tmp/r39/time-120m.log, outputs/tmp/r39/time-120m. The submitted tree remains the Round 37 pass. - End: 2026-11-18 14:14:31 UTC. 2.4779×, 1,118.8 ms/step, 121.17 GiB peak, 0.14% window spread, valid./tmp/r39/time-120m/time_tree.json. The prefetch-only change is 0.67% slower than the Round 37 screen; discarded without quick check or commit.
8.0 hRound 40 — decoder MLP projection
- Launched 2026-11-18 14:15:04 UTC. Detached PID 218706 profiles the submitted stack,/tmp/r40/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r40/profile. - Profile: 1,286 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 651.4 ms (50.7%), AllGather 167.6 ms (13.0%), ReduceScatter 107.2 ms (8.3%). SwiGLU forward and backward together take 20.9 ms (1.6%). - TrialLLAVA_PACK_MLP_GATE_UP=1combines both gate/up projections and their dense gradient GEMMs without creating new parameters. A strided SwiGLU kernel writes the packed derivative directly, and the two weight gradients are returned separately (local N2 rounding). Detached PID 219486,/tmp/r40/verify.logand/tmp/r40/time.log, outputs/tmp/r40/time. The submitted tree remains the Round 37 pass. - End: 2026-11-18 14:19:26 UTC. Isolated output bitwise identical and gradient errors ≤0.29% relative L2. Timing 2.4734×, 1,120.9 ms/step, 121.38 GiB peak, 2.46% window spread, valid (/tmp/r40/time/time_tree.json). 0.85% slower than the submitted screen; discarded without quick check or commit.
8.1 hRound 41 — stream BF16 gradient shards into AdamW
- Launched 2026-11-18 14:19:52 UTC. Detached PID 220478 profiles the submitted stack,/tmp/r41/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r41/profile. - Profile: 1,336 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 656.2 ms (49.1%), AllGather 222.1 ms (16.6%), ReduceScatter 91.8 ms (6.9%), AdamW 23.5 ms (1.8%) and the separate gradient cast 5.1 ms (0.4%). Materializing a FP32 gradient only to have AdamW load it can be replaced by exactly the same cast in registers. - TrialLLAVA_ADAMW_BF16_SHARDS=1passes the existing contiguous BF16 ZeRO-3 gradient shard to the streaming optimizer, converts each gradient to FP32 before arithmetic, and preserves FP32 master/moment tensors, normalization, and safe full-gradient access. The old path remains for unsupported optimizer/layout/scaling settings. Three isolated AdamW steps agree bitwise on all tensors. Detached PID 221235,/tmp/r41/verify.log,/tmp/r41/time.log, outputs/tmp/r41/time. The submission remains the Round 37 pass. - End: 2026-11-18 14:24:31 UTC. 2.4979×, 1,109.9 ms/step, 121.16 GiB peak, 3.42% window spread, valid (/tmp/r41/time/time_tree.json). The 0.14% improvement over the matched Round 37 screen is inside the 0.38% frozen noise band and slower than the Round 37 full check; no quick check, commit, or promotion.
8.1 hRound 42 — NCCL runtime
- Launched 2026-11-18 14:25:18 UTC. Detached PID 222210 profiles the submitted stack,/tmp/r42/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r42/profile. - Profile: 1,219 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 650.3 ms (53.3%), AllGather 113.7 ms (9.3%), ReduceScatter 93.2 ms (7.6%). The current NCCL library selects LL for both on the bonded NV18 link between the GPUs. - First screen excludes LL viaNCCL_PROTO=^LL(does not force LL128 on an unsupported topology). Detached PID 222975,/tmp/r42/time-no-ll.log, outputs/tmp/r42/time-no-ll. The runtime screen will keep default protocol selection. - The slow PyPI NCCL 2.27.7 download (PID 222197) was stopped. Detached PID 223425 fetches the official NVIDIA CUDA 12 package, verifies the hash against the package index and extracts it into its own directory under/opt/candidate-env;/tmp/r42/download.log. Neither screen changes the submitted switches. - Excluding LL measured 2.5049×, 1,106.8 ms/step, 121.17 GiB peak, 2.44% window spread, valid (/tmp/r42/time-no-ll/time_tree.json). This matches the submitted full check; no resolved gain. - The CUDA 12 NCCL package matched its official SHA-256. Detached PID 223909 verifies BF16 AllGather and average ReduceScatter on both ranks before timing only the new runtime,/tmp/r42/verify.logand/tmp/r42/time-nccl.log, outputs/tmp/r42/time-nccl. - End: 2026-11-18 14:34:36 UTC. Both isolated collectives matched bitwise. NCCL 2.27.7 measured 2.4987×, 1,109.6 ms/step, 121.16 GiB peak, 3.45% window spread, valid (/tmp/r42/time-nccl/time_tree.json). The 0.16% improvement versus the Round 37 screen is inside frozen noise and slower than the full check. Neither collective variant adopted; no quick check or commit.
8.3 hRound 43 — keep the loss-only output packed
- Launched 2026-11-18 14:37:13 UTC. Detached PID 224884 profiles the submitted stack,/tmp/r43/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r43/profile. - Profile: 1,234 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 651.4 ms (52.8%), AllGather 124.0 ms (10.1%), ReduceScatter 98.4 ms (8.0%). The decoder pads 13,600 and 14,724 hidden rows to 17,808 and 21,648 rows in the two profiled steps, then the loss-only head gathers just the supervised positions. - TrialLLAVA_PACKED_LOSS_ROWS=1maps the exact existing shifted-label positions into the packed row layout, selects only those decoder rows before the token-local final RMSNorm, and bypasses output padding for loss-only calls. Full logits and fallback layouts are unchanged. Detached PID 225619 stopped after the CPU test discovered Transformers does not import its FA2 gather/pad helpers with CUDA hidden; supplied the same CPU-capable helpers in the isolated test only. Retry PID 225688,/tmp/r43/verify-fixed.log,/tmp/r43/time.log, outputs/tmp/r43/time. Isolated positions and input gradients matched bitwise, and RMSNorm weight gradients agreed within tolerance. - End: 2026-11-18 14:42:22 UTC. 2.4932×, 1,112.0 ms/step, 121.06 GiB peak, 3.34% window spread, valid (/tmp/r43/time/time_tree.json). No latency gain over the Round 37 screen. Discarded without quick check or commit.
8.4 hRound 44 — decoder residual GEMM epilogues
- Launched 2026-11-18 14:42:36 UTC. Detached PID 226642 profiles the submitted stack,/tmp/r44/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r44/profile. - Profile: 1,247 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 648.6 ms (52.0%), AllGather 138.7 ms (11.1%), ReduceScatter 99.4 ms (8.0%), vectorized BF16 adds 15.4 ms (1.2%). Test the forward residual adds separately from the earlier RMSNorm fusion, using cuBLASLt's distinct source and destination matrices so that no residual copy is needed. - TrialLLAVA_RESIDUAL_EPILOGUE=1writes attention-output and MLP-down residual sums directly from the packed decoder's GEMMs, leaving the original parameters and projection gradients intact. The fused FP32 accumulator rounds one fewer time (local N2); the isolated outputs agree within 0.28% relative L2 and all three gradients are bitwise equal. Detached PID 227424,/tmp/r44/verify.log,/tmp/r44/time.log, outputs/tmp/r44/time. - First screen at 14:48:00 UTC: 2.5108×, 1,104.2 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, 2.24% window spread, valid (/tmp/r44/time/time_tree.json). This is 0.65% faster than the matched Round 37 screen and 2.94 GiB lower peak memory, but only 0.23% faster than its full check. Detached PID 228368 repeats the timing,/tmp/r44/time-repeat.log, outputs/tmp/r44/time-repeat, with an exact quick check queued only for a repeatable gain (/tmp/r44/quick.log,/tmp/r44/quick). Submission remains the Round 37 full pass pending validation. - Repeat at 14:50:17 UTC: 2.5051×, 1,106.7 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, 2.23% window spread, valid (/tmp/r44/time-repeat/time_tree.json). Both screens improve on the matched Round 37 screen by at least 0.42%; the repeat matches the fastest full check. - End: 2026-11-18 14:53:51 UTC. Quick PASS, exact items unchanged (/tmp/r44/quick/check.json), expected non-bitwise tensors. Scratch commitb1fd8c8. Detached PID 230167 runs the next profile and then the full validation (/tmp/r44/check.log,/tmp/r44/check). - Full check at 15:01:54 UTC: PASS, 2.5121×, 1,103.6 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, windows 11.261 s and 10.811 s (/tmp/r44/check/check.json). Trajectory endpoints are within 0.04σ. Promotedb1fd8c8and enabled the residual epilogues.
8.7 hRound 45 — ZeRO-3 prefetch stream dependencies
- Launched 2026-11-18 14:54:10 UTC. Detached PID 230167 profiles the quick-passing Round 44 stack,/tmp/r45/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r45/profile. - Profile: 1,285 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 590.4 ms (45.9%), AllGather 177.8 ms (13.8%), ReduceScatter 92.0 ms (7.2%). The new residual epilogues show up as two 82.4 ms total GEMM groups; remaining vectorized BF16 adds are 10.0 ms, down from 15.4 ms. Inspecting the pinned coordinator shows that it waits on its prefetch stream even if the current module acquires no in-flight parameter. - Rank 0 / 1 AllGather interval unions are 177.8 / 105.1 ms per step, including 61.5 / 30.7 ms without any other active kernel. This includes time spent waiting for the peer, not only data movement. - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_PREFETCH_OVERLAP=1skips that coarse wait only when no parameter was acquired, the fetch consumer stream hasn't changed, and no NVMe prefetch is active. The original DeepSpeed overload still runs all fetch and trace bookkeeping. CPU validation confirmed the opt-in patch installs on DeepSpeed 0.12.6 and targets the intended method. Detached PID 234473 queues timing after the Round 44 full verdict (/tmp/r45/time.log,/tmp/r45/time), then a quick check only for a gain beyond frozen noise. Submission remains the last fully validated stack. - End: 2026-11-18 15:03:33 UTC. 2.5100×, 1,104.6 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, 2.10% window spread, valid (/tmp/r45/time/time_tree.json). Essentially identical to the residual-only timing, so no quick check, commit, or promotion.
8.8 hRound 46 — Hopper attention for frozen CLIP
- Launched 2026-11-18 15:03:51 UTC. Detached PID 236479 profiles the submitted residual-epilogue stack,/tmp/r46/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r46/profile. - Profile: 1,330 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 590.6 ms (44.4%), AllGather 203.4 ms (15.3%), ReduceScatter 110.1 ms (8.3%). Correlating the 577-token CLIP BMM and softmax ops with their launches attributes 17.9 ms/step (1.35%) to materialized vision attention. - TrialLLAVA_HOPPER_CLIP_ATTENTION=1uses the installed FlashAttention 3 backend for unmasked, dropout-free, 64-wide frozen CLIP attention on Hopper BF16. Existing projections, output selection, layer count and fallbacks remain intact (local N2). The isolated test matched within 0.29% relative L2 with unchanged CUDA RNG. Detached PID 237276,/tmp/r46/verify.log,/tmp/r46/time.log, outputs/tmp/r46/time; a quick check is conditional on a resolved gain. Submission stays on the Round 44 full pass. - End: 2026-11-18 15:08:07 UTC. 2.4965×, 1,110.5 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, 0.82% window spread, valid (/tmp/r46/time/time_tree.json). The apparent kernel opportunity did not translate to faster steps (0.63% slower than the submitted full check); no quick check, commit, or promotion.
8.9 hRound 47 — backward parameter reuse
- Launched 2026-11-18 15:08:27 UTC. Detached PID 238282 profiles the submitted stack,/tmp/r47/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r47/profile. - Profile: 1,286 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 586.7 ms (45.6%), AllGather 170.2 ms (13.2%), ReduceScatter 105.9 ms (8.2%). With the residual epilogues recovering 2.94 GiB, test a longer ZeRO-3 reuse horizon so more forward weights are still local when backward reaches them. - Trial uses 3B live elements and a 4B reuse distance, holding persistence, prefetch and reduction buckets unchanged. The first scratch checkout launcher (PID 239010) ended before detaching; it took no GPU. Detached retry PID 239067,/tmp/r47/time.log, outputs/tmp/r47/time; a quick check is conditional on a resolved timing gain. The submitted config remains unchanged. - End: 2026-11-18 15:13:32 UTC. 2.5160×, 1,101.9 ms/step, 120.09 GiB peak, 2.53% window spread, valid (/tmp/r47/time/time_tree.json). 0.15% lower latency than the submitted full check is inside frozen noise and costs 1.86 GiB. No quick check, commit, or promotion.
9.0 hRound 48 — RMSNorm residual-gradient fusion
- Launched 2026-11-18 15:13:57 UTC. Detached PID 239954 profiles the submitted stack,/tmp/r48/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r48/profile. - Profile: 1,275 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 587.6 ms (46.1%), AllGather 156.8 ms (12.3%), ReduceScatter 105.1 ms (8.2%), the two RMSNorm backward variants 13.0 ms (1.0%) and vectorized BF16 adds 9.9 ms (0.8%). Fuse the backward residual addition without changing the forward residual path already handled by the projection epilogues. - TrialLLAVA_NORM_RESIDUAL_GRAD=1uses the pinned RMSNorm's prenorm output to expose the unchanged BF16 residual as an alias, letting its backward kernel add the residual gradient before writing the input gradient (local N2 rounding). Detached PID 240715,/tmp/r48/verify.log,/tmp/r48/time.log, outputs/tmp/r48/time; exact check conditional on a resolved gain. Submission stays at the Round 44 full pass. - End: 2026-11-18 15:18:08 UTC. Isolated output and norm weight gradient agree bitwise, input gradient 0.25% relative L2. 2.4749×, 1,120.2 ms/step, 118.24 GiB peak, 2.42% window spread, valid (/tmp/r48/time/time_tree.json). The fused backward is 1.50% slower than the submitted full pass. No quick check, commit, or promotion.
9.1 hRound 49 — copy-engine peer parameter gathers
- Launched 2026-11-18 15:19:24 UTC. Detached PID 241832 profiles the submitted stack,/tmp/r49/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r49/profile. - Profile: 1,234 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 588.3 ms (47.7%), AllGather 127.6 ms (10.3%), ReduceScatter 94.8 ms (7.7%). A direct peer copy for single large weight gathers could free SMs used by overlapped NCCL kernels. - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_PEER_GATHER=1shares the existing contiguous BF16 partition allocations between the two local ranks at optimizer initialization, checks matching layout, and replaces eligible single-parameter gathers with stream-ordered copies into the original parameter shape. Both ranks still synchronize through the original optimizer norm and persistence collectives around each weight update; small, multi-parameter, offloaded and unsupported cases use the original path. Detached PID 242602 verifies the two-rank copy path across writes, then times the scratch tree (/tmp/r49/verify.log,/tmp/r49/time.log,/tmp/r49/time); quick check conditional on a gain. Main remainsb1fd8c8. - Both ranks matched bitwise across two BF16 updates in the isolated copy test. Timing at 15:25:39 UTC: 2.5309×, 1,095.4 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, 1.33% window spread, valid (/tmp/r49/time/time_tree.json). This is 0.74% lower latency than the submitted full check. Quick under PID 242602,/tmp/r49/quick.log, outputs/tmp/r49/quick. - End: 2026-11-18 15:29:13 UTC. Quick PASS, exact items unchanged (/tmp/r49/quick/check.json). Added collective fallback validation and peer mapping cleanup at optimizer destruction, documented the switch, and staged scratch commit6704601. Detached PID 245541 runs the next profile and then the full check on this exact revision (/tmp/r49/check.log,/tmp/r49/check). Submission remains on the Round 44 full pass pending that verdict. - Full check at 15:37:57 UTC: PASS, 2.5274×, 1,097.0 ms/step (/tmp/r49/check/check.json), 0.60% lower latency than the preceding full pass. Exact items passed, both statistical endpoints within 0.10σ. Promoted6704601and enabled peer gathers.
9.2 hRound 50 — persistent parameter refresh
- Queued 2026-11-18 15:29:58 UTC. Detached PID 245541 profiles the quick-passing peer-gather stack,/tmp/r50/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r50/profile. - Profile: 1,128 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 580.8 ms (51.5%), ReduceScatter 116.9 ms (10.4%), AllGather 16.3 ms (1.4%, down from 127.6 ms), FA3 main backward 24.9 ms (2.2%). Test overlapping the per-step persistent-parameter refresh with its remaining small NCCL gathers. - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_PEER_REFRESH=1uses a two-rank readiness collective after BF16 weights are written and a copy-stream wait before their use. Large persistent parameters are copied from their IPC-mapped shards; DeepSpeed gathers the rest normally. Isolated two-rank refresh matched bitwise across updates. Detached PID 247416,/tmp/r50/verify.logand/tmp/r50/time.log, outputs/tmp/r50/time. - Screen at 15:39:46 UTC: 2.5584×, 1,083.6 ms/step, 118.24 GiB peak, 1.77% window spread, valid; 1.22% lower latency than the Round 49 full pass. Quick check under PID 247416 (/tmp/r50/quick.log,/tmp/r50/quick). Scratch commit5a7a596. Detached PID 252611 queues full validation after quick and the next profile (/tmp/r50/check.log,/tmp/r50/check); submission remains the Round 49 pass. - End: 2026-11-18 15:43:19 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures (/tmp/r50/quick/check.json). Full check started at 15:45:12 UTC. - Full check at 15:51:28 UTC: PASS, 2.5493×, 1,087.5 ms/step (/tmp/r50/check/check.json), 0.87% lower latency than the preceding full pass. Both statistical endpoints within 0.08σ. Promoted5a7a596and enabled persistent peer refresh.
9.4 hRound 51 — copy-engine gradient reduce-scatter
- Queued 2026-11-18 15:42 UTC. Detached PID 252611 profiles the best exact-passing screen before the Round 50 full check,/tmp/r51/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r51/profile./tmp/r51/profile-treerecords the selected tree. - Profile 15:43:44–15:44:57 UTC on the quick-passing Round 50 stack: 1,095 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 581.0 ms (53.1%), ReduceScatter 87.3 ms (8.0%, 24 blocks per large launch), FA3 main backward 25.0 ms (2.3%), AllGather 9.3 ms (0.8%). Try moving large two-rank gradient payloads to the copy engine instead of the NCCL SM kernel. - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_PEER_REDUCE_SCATTER=1pushes the remote half of each large single gradient into the matched peer's existing BF16 gradient partition, then uses a scalar rendezvous and applies the same BF16 predivide and sum locally. The first rendezvous protects previous-step consumers. Small/multiple/padded gradients and unsupported layouts retain the original path. Detached PID 255251 verifies both partition sizes and times the scratch tree after the Round 50 full pass (/tmp/r51/verify.log,/tmp/r51/time.log,/tmp/r51/time); quick check queued only for a resolved gain. - Both ranks matched NCCL BF16 averaging bitwise for 8.39M- and 22.54M-element partitions, including signed BF16 subnormals, across three updates. The judge timing is running. - Screen at 15:53:24 UTC: 2.5815×, 1,074.0 ms/step, 118.23 GiB peak, 2.03% window spread, valid (/tmp/r51/time/time_tree.json). This is 1.24% lower latency than the Round 50 full pass. Quick check under PID 255251 (/tmp/r51/quick.log,/tmp/r51/quick), scratch commitf0d55c7. Detached PID 259748 queues full validation after quick and the next profile (/tmp/r51/check.log,/tmp/r51/check); submission stays on the Round 50 pass. - End: 2026-11-18 15:56:58 UTC. Quick PASS, no exact failures (/tmp/r51/quick/check.json). - Full check at 16:05:04 UTC: PASS, 2.5844×, 1,072.7 ms/step (/tmp/r51/check/check.json), 1.36% lower latency than the Round 50 full pass. Both trajectory endpoints within 0.08σ. Promotedf0d55c7and enabled peer gradient partitions.
9.7 hRound 52 — batched peer gradient rendezvous
- Queued 2026-11-18 15:56 UTC. Detached PID 259748 profiles the best exact-passing version,/tmp/r52/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r52/profile./tmp/r52/profile-treerecords the selected tree. - Profile 15:57:19–15:58:33 UTC on the quick-passing Round 51 stack: 1,119 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 571.6 ms (51.1%), scalar readiness AllReduce 94.3 ms (8.4%, including peer waiting), BF16 ReduceScatter 23.4 ms (2.1%, down from 87.3 ms), local averaging 10.6 ms (0.9%). Batch the scalar rendezvous so the peer copies can queue ahead. - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_PEER_REDUCE_BATCH_SIZE=4groups up to four pending peer copies under one rendezvous. It snapshots local halves only when they alias DeepSpeed's reused staging buffer, and flushes before fallback collectives and before the gradient epilogue completes. Detached PID 262417 is queued behind Round 51's full check to verify and time (/tmp/r52/verify.log,/tmp/r52/time.log,/tmp/r52/time), conditional quick check on a resolved gain. - Isolated verification passed on both ranks: the batched averages match NCCL bitwise across staging-buffer overwrites and partial flushes. - End: 2026-11-18 16:06:55 UTC. 2.5829×, 1,073.4 ms/step, 118.24 GiB peak, 1.89% window spread, valid (/tmp/r52/time/time_tree.json). Within 0.07% of the Round 51 full pass and slightly slower; no quick check, commit, or promotion.
9.8 hRound 53 — earlier peer gradient copies
- Queued 2026-11-18 16:06 UTC. Detached PID 265251 profiles the submitted Round 51 stack,/tmp/r53/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r53/profile. - Profile 16:07:18–16:08:32 UTC: 1,099 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 575.1 ms (52.3%), scalar readiness AllReduce 61.5 ms (5.6%), BF16 ReduceScatter 28.3 ms (2.6%), averaging 10.6 ms (1.0%). DeepSpeed waits for the next gradient to queue before flushing an already-full bucket, delaying large peer copies. - TrialLLAVA_ZERO3_EAGER_PEER_REDUCE_SCATTER=1flushes eligible single-gradient buckets as soon as they fill or exceed the bucket capacity. Only scheduling changes; small/mixed buckets, normal reduction bookkeeping, and partition values are unchanged. Detached PID 266057 times the scratch tree (/tmp/r53/time.log,/tmp/r53/time); quick check queued only for a resolved gain. - End: 2026-11-18 16:11:00 UTC. 2.5722×, 1,077.9 ms/step, 118.24 GiB peak, 1.83% window spread, valid (/tmp/r53/time/time_tree.json). This is 0.48% slower than the full pass; no quick check, commit, or promotion.
9.9 hRound 54 — cuBLAS BF16 GEMM runtime
- Launched 2026-11-18 16:11:28 UTC. Detached PID 266948 profiles the submitted Round 51 stack,/tmp/r54/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r54/profile. - Profile 16:11:42–16:12:56 UTC: 1,118 ms aggregate GPU kernel time. Top six BF16 GEMMs 574.3 ms (51.4%), scalar readiness AllReduce 82.5 ms (7.4%), remaining BF16 ReduceScatter 28.9 ms (2.6%). Screen cuBLAS versions against the current Hopper GEMM mix, keeping all other switches fixed. - Trial cuBLAS <ip> and <ip> via candidate-only preloads, with isolated installations verified against publisher hashes and smoke-checked for mapped libraries. Detached worker PID 267766 (/tmp/r54/time-launch.log,/tmp/r54/install-*.log,/tmp/r54/time-*.log); each completed install has its own judge timing and a quick check is conditional on a resolved gain. Submission stays on the Round 51 full pass.