Kimi k3.1-pro 1.38×
Harness: Claude Code · switches: none
- Judged
- 1.38×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 1.39×
- Rounds
- 35
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $28.9
- Input tokens · 99.1% cached
- 119 M
- Output tokens
- 0.3 M
- Requests
- 895
§ 02Key levers
- Sequence packing
- ✗ not done
- Recompute / activations
- ✓ activations kept for 22 layers (OOM with any more)
- Optimizer
- ✓ fused AdamW (1.329 → 1.333×)
- Communication & libraries
- ZeRO-2 off by 0.585%, dropped; NCCL protocol and bucketing no gain
- Other main levers
- torch.compile on RoPE / MLP / RMSNorm; flash-attn's Triton cross-entropy (in-place backward); bf16 logits returned, freed memory keeps one more layer
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log35 sections
0.1 hRound 1 — ZeRO parameter/gradient communication
- Start: 2026-11-12 19:07:33 UTC. - Baseline: unchanged upstreamc121f04; switches{"environment": {}}; frozen reference 2756.1 ms/step, spread 0.0018, peak 73.5 GiB. - Profile:/tmp/r1/profile(detached launcher PID 20731, actual bench PID 20732, log/tmp/r1/profile.log), 19:07:57–19:09:04 UTC, status ok. Data probe 13/13 matched before and after. One detailed steady-state step: 2662 ms wall, 2651 ms GPU kernel time, peak 71.44 GiB. - Hotspots: bf16 GEMM kernels 19.7% + 13.2% + 7.0% + 5.3% + 5.2% (about 50% total); ZeRO-3AllGather237.1 ms (8.9%) and bf16ReduceScatter75.3 ms (2.8%); generic bf16 binary elementwise 132.1 ms (5.0%); flash attention forward/backward visible (29.7 + 41.3 ms for top kernels). CPUaten::nonzeroinclusive time 770.5 ms, but total GPU kernel time nearly equals step wall time. - Classification: parameter communication is a configuration/backend hotspot. Hopper memory headroom makes upstream ZeRO-2 a candidate to remove per-layer parameter gathers while retaining the recipe's batch, optimizer and precision. - Change: replace the zero-optimization block in the judge-usedscripts/zero3.jsonwith upstream'sscripts/zero2.jsonblock (stage 2; all other recipe settings unchanged). Expected tier N1 until measured; switches remain empty. - Timing:/tmp/r1/time/time_tree.json(launcher PID 21244, log/tmp/r1/time.log), ended 19:13:08 UTC. ERROR despite speedup 1.0356× (2661.3 ms/step; windows 26.906/26.320 s; spread 0.0011; peak 82.58 GiB). Data probe matched andrepartitioned=false; no invalid-run signature. Rejection: first logged loss differed by 0.00585, above the 0.005 band. This is not a valid candidate; no precision gate was reached. - End: 2026-11-12 19:14 UTC. Reverted the ZeRO-2 edit after recording the rejected attempt; the submission returns to reference ZeRO-3.
0.2 hRound 2 — repeated flash-attention unpadding synchronization
- Start: 2026-11-12 19:15 UTC (GPU profiling began about 19:15; result at 19:16). - Profile of restored best tree:/tmp/r2/profile, launcher PID 21932, log/tmp/r2/profile.log, status ok. The kernel ranking is unchanged from round 1. Detailed rank-0 trace attribution found 112aten::nonzerocalls totaling 770.875 ms of inclusive CPU time; 64 are explicittorch.nonzerocalls totaling 768.574 ms. There are 165aten::itemcalls totaling 43.561 ms. Llama_get_unpad_dataaccounts for 64 nonzero calls and 64 max-length scalar reads: one of each in every decoder layer, repeated by gradient-checkpoint recomputation. All operate on the same mask within a model forward. - Hotspot classification: missed reuse / host synchronization in the existing flash-attention fast path, not an attention-kernel change. - Change: behindLLAVA_CACHE_ATTENTION_UNPAD=1, wrap Transformers_get_unpad_dataand cache its exact(indices, cu_seqlens, max_seqlen)result on the mask tensor, keyed by the tensor mutation version. No values cross optimizer steps; recomputation reuses the same mask object. Tier target N0. Updated/submission/switches.jsonaccordingly. - CPU unit probe: cached object identity, exact tensor/scalar equality against the original function, and invalidation after an in-place mask mutation passed. - Timing:/tmp/r2/time/time_tree.json(launcher PID 22730, log/tmp/r2/time.log), ended 19:24:09 UTC. Status ok, 1.0013× (2752.4 ms/step; windows 27.832/27.216 s; spread 0.0007; peak 73.5 GiB), below the frozen-reference noise band; first loss exactly matched and later logged-loss max difference was 0.16%. No resolved benefit, so the change was reverted without spending a quick/full check. - End: 2026-11-12 19:25 UTC. The no-gain attempt and its revert are committed separately; submission is back to reference behavior with empty switches.
0.4 hRound 3 — selective decoder activation retention
- Start: 2026-11-12 19:26 UTC; detailed profile ended 19:28 UTC. - Profile:/tmp/r3/profile, launcher PID 23469, log/tmp/r3/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time 2656 ms/step.CheckpointFunction667.7 ms andCheckpointFunctionBackward1644.5 ms inclusive CPU time show all 32 decoder layers using checkpoint/recompute. GEMMs remain about half of device time; reference allocated/reserved peaks are 73.5/88.92 GiB on 140 GiB Hopper. - Hotspot classification: memory-saving configuration is over-conservative for this hardware; selectively retaining activations can remove a bounded fraction of the extra forward without changing operators or their precision. - Change: opt-inLLAVA_UNCHECKPOINT_LAYERS=N, implemented inLlavaLlamaForCausalLM.gradient_checkpointing_enable, directly executes the final N bound decoder layers while all others use the original checkpoint function. Default zero preserves the reference. Screening configs for N=8/16/24 are/tmp/r3/uncheckpoint{8,16,24}.json; submitted switches remain empty during screening. Target tier N0. - Local test: a four-layer CPU model with N=2 produced bitwise-equal loss and every trainable-parameter gradient versus full checkpointing. - Sweep:/tmp/r3/sweep/sweep.json(launcher PID 24103, log/tmp/r3/sweep.log), 19:32:00–19:39:06 UTC. Paired references were 2749.3/2751.1 ms (spread 0.0007). N=8: status ok, 2604.7 ms/step, 1.0581× vs frozen and 1.0559× vs paired reference, window spread 0.0002, peak allocated 119.9 GiB (per-rank reserved peaks 136.26/137.10 GiB). N=16 and N=24 both OOM, so they are rejected. Promoted N=8 to/submission/switches.json. - Full check:/tmp/r3/check/check.json(launcher PID 27024, log/tmp/r3/check.log), 19:41:47–19:50:17 UTC. PASS, N0, speedup 1.0574× (2606.4 ms/step; windows 26.375/25.754 s; spread 0.0007; peak 119.9 GiB allocated, 137.29 GiB reserved). Gate 2: 4724/4724 tensors bitwise identical, no exact/dtype/math-mode failures. Gate 3: train endpoint bias -0.0068σ, probe endpoint bias -0.0270σ; equivalent. This is the best fully validated submission. - End: 2026-11-12 19:50:37 UTC.
0.8 hRound 4 — RoPE elementwise/layout chain
- Start: 2026-11-12 19:51 UTC; profile ended 19:52 UTC. - Profile of fully validated N=8 tree:/tmp/r4/profile, launcher PID 29492, log/tmp/r4/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time 2530 ms/step (reference 2656 ms in round 3), checkpoint backward inclusive CPU time fell from 1644.5 to 1237.0 ms. Detailed kernel counts: 530 non-vectorized bf16 multiplies totaling 121.512 ms, 323 non-vectorized bf16 adds totaling 53.505 ms, 112 bf16 batched cats totaling 36.523 ms, and 176 bf16 negations totaling 16.937 ms. These correspond to the two RoPE applications per decoder execution, including checkpoint recomputation and backward activity. Flash forward is 56 calls / 25.967 ms and flash backward's top kernel is 32 calls / 40.611 ms. - Hotspot classification: memory/layout work between GEMMs and flash attention; existing eager operations do not fuse the RoPE chain. - Change to test:LLAVA_COMPILE_ROPE=1wraps only Transformersapply_rotary_pos_embwithtorch.compile(dynamic=True), retainingLLAVA_UNCHECKPOINT_LAYERS=8. Dynamic shapes are required to prevent new padded sequence lengths from compiling inside timed windows. Expected tier N1 because fusion may remove bf16 intermediate rounding; no GEMM/attention backend or precision setting changes. Experiment config/tmp/r4/rope.json; submitted switches stay at the fully validated N=8 setting during measurement. - Timing:/tmp/r4/time/time_tree.json(launcher PID 30076): status ok, 2592.1 ms / 1.0633×, but windows 26.976/24.865 s had 0.0583 spread (near final-invalid threshold), with zero compiles in both. Repeated as/tmp/r4/time2/time_tree.json(launcher PID 31686): status ok, 2530.5 ms / 1.0892×, windows 25.781/24.829 s, spread 0.0145, peak 119.9 GiB, first-loss difference 0.00029, no timed compiles. The repeat resolves a real gain over N=8 alone. - Full check:/tmp/r4/check/check.json(launcher PID 33294, log/tmp/r4/check.log), 20:04:39–20:13:20 UTC. PASS, measured N1, speedup 1.0911× (2526.0 ms/step; windows 25.682/24.839 s; peak 119.9 GiB; zero timed compiles). Exact failures 0, dtype/math-mode changes 0. Gate 2 was NOT_BITWISE as expected (7 diagnostic unresolved tensors; gate 3 decides). Gate 3 biases: train -0.0277σ, probe +0.0220σ; equivalent. Promoted both switches to/submission/switches.json. - End: 2026-11-12 20:13:31 UTC.
1.2 hRound 5 — MLP SiLU/gating fusion
- Start: 2026-11-12 20:14 UTC; profile ended 20:16 UTC. - Profile of validated 1.0911× tree:/tmp/r5/profile, launcher PID 39184, log/tmp/r5/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time 2361 ms/step. Inductor kernels are present (triton__...43.6 + 43.0 + 17.3 + 8.8 ms among the top entries), proving compiled RoPE did not fall back to eager. Remaining MLP chain: 209 vectorized bf16 multiplies / 44.4 ms, 56 SiLU / 18.8 ms, and SiLU backward / 11.1 ms. ZeRO all-gather 194.4 ms and reduce-scatter 55.8 ms; GEMMs still dominate. - Hotspot classification: memory-bound activation/gating chain between library GEMMs; an isolated compiler fusion is available without compiling modules or changing their ZeRO hooks. - Change to test:LLAVA_COMPILE_MLP=1compiles a helper containing onlyF.silu(gate) * upwith dynamic shapes and substitutes it into the ordinarypretraining_tp=1,hidden_act=siluLlamaMLP path. Gate/up/down projections stay in their original modules. Expected N1, stacked on the validated switches. Experiment/tmp/r5/mlp.json; submitted switches remain unchanged until a full pass. - Timing:/tmp/r5/time/time_tree.json(launcher PID 40564, log/tmp/r5/time.log), ended 20:19:58 UTC. Status ok, 2489.8 ms/step, 1.1070×, windows 25.156/24.639 s, spread 0.0023, peak allocated/reserved 114.73/136.37 GiB. First-loss difference 0.00051, later max 0.0012; no compile/recompile error signatures. - Full check:/tmp/r5/check/check.json(launcher PID 42245, log/tmp/r5/check.log), 20:21:39–20:30:46 UTC. PASS N1, speedup 1.1077× (2488.1 ms/step; windows 25.177/24.585 s; peak 114.73 GiB). Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0; three diagnostic unresolved tensors only. Gate 3 train/probe biases +0.0806σ/-0.0019σ, equivalent. Promoted all three switches. - End: 2026-11-12 20:31:30 UTC.
1.5 hRound 6 — RMSNorm fusion
- Start: 2026-11-12 20:32 UTC; profile ended 20:33 UTC. - Profile of validated 1.1077× tree:/tmp/r6/profile, launcher PID 48370, log/tmp/r6/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time 2347 ms/step. MLP Inductor kernels are active (including 24.5 and 18.1 ms entries), and the previous 44.4 ms vectorized bf16 multiply and separate SiLU entries are gone. Remaining norm-related work includes fp32 non-vectorized multiply 41.9 ms, fp32 vectorized multiplies 26.5 + 15.3 ms,pow16.6 ms, bf16 weight multiply 16.9 ms, fp32 add 13.1 ms, mean reduction 10.3 ms, plus backward/layout traffic. - Hotspot classification: RMSNorm reduction and surrounding elementwise work between GEMMs; the exact library formula can be regionally compiled without touching decoder modules or projection hooks. - Change to test:LLAVA_COMPILE_RMSNORM=1compiles a helper reproducingLlamaRMSNorm.forwardexactly (float32square/mean/rsqrt normalization, cast back, bf16 weight multiply) and calls it from the original module withself.weightand epsilon. Expected N1. Experiment/tmp/r6/rmsnorm.json; submitted switches remain at the 1.1077× full-pass configuration. - Timing:/tmp/r6/time/time_tree.json(launcher PID 49835, log/tmp/r6/time.log), ended 20:37:39 UTC. Status ok, 2256.6 ms/step, 1.2213×, windows 22.826/22.306 s, spread 0.0001, peak allocated/reserved 98.41/119.14 GiB. First-loss difference 0.00029, later max 0.0011; no compile/recompile error signatures. - Full check:/tmp/r6/check/check.json(launcher PID 51625, log/tmp/r6/check.log), 20:39:11–20:47:46 UTC. PASS N1, speedup 1.2214× (2256.5 ms/step; windows 22.823/22.306 s; peak 98.41 GiB). Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0; ten diagnostic unresolved tensors only. Gate 3 train/probe biases +0.0219σ/+0.1357σ, equivalent. Promoted all four switches. - End: 2026-11-12 20:48:03 UTC.
1.8 hRound 7 — re-screen retained layers after fusion
- Start: 2026-11-12 20:49 UTC; profile ended 20:50 UTC. - Profile of validated 1.2214× tree:/tmp/r7/profile, launcher PID 58154, log/tmp/r7/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time 2175 ms/step; bf16 GEMMs now account for about 60% of listed device time. ZeRO all-gather/reduce-scatter are 181.1/86.3 ms.CheckpointFunctionBackwardremains 1040.6 ms inclusive for the 24 checkpointed layers. Full-check peak allocated/reserved memory is only 98.41/118.53 GiB after fusion, leaving roughly 21 GiB reserved headroom. - Hotspot classification: the same N0 activation-recompute configuration can now be retuned because compiled norms/MLP lowered per-layer live activation storage; no new code is needed. - Change to screen:LLAVA_UNCHECKPOINT_LAYERS=12, 14 and 16 with all three compile switches, using/tmp/r7/retain{12,14,16}.json. Tier remains N1 from the existing compiled functions; changing the retained count alone was N0 in round 3. Submitted switches stay at the validated N=8 setting. - Sweep:/tmp/r7/sweep/sweep.json(launcher PID 59711, log/tmp/r7/sweep.log), 20:52:26–21:00:40 UTC. Paired references 2751.2/2751.3 ms. N=12: 2195.9 ms / 1.2551× frozen; N=14: 2156.6 ms / 1.2780×; N=16: 2126.1 ms / 1.2963× frozen and 1.2940× paired, spread 0.0017, peak allocated 124.27 GiB, reserved about 136.2 GiB, zero timed compiles. All statuses ok. - Full check:/tmp/r7/check/check.json(launcher PID 65990, log/tmp/r7/check.log), 21:02:17–21:10:47 UTC. PASS N1, speedup 1.2922× (2132.9 ms/step; windows 21.546/21.111 s; peak 124.27 GiB allocated, 137.77 GiB reserved). Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0. Gate 3 train/probe biases +0.0126σ/-0.0310σ, equivalent. Promoted N=16. - End: 2026-11-12 21:11:09 UTC.
2.2 hRound 8 — ZeRO bucket sizing; sampler headroom check
- Start: 2026-11-12 21:12 UTC; profile ended 21:14 UTC. - Profile of validated 1.2922× tree:/tmp/r8/profile, launcher PID 72528, log/tmp/r8/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time 2101 ms/step. Main bf16 GEMMs 399.0 + 362.2 + 191.5 + 148.7 + 105.9 ms; ZeRO all-gather 186.1 ms (8.9%) and reduce-scatter 116.3 ms (5.5%). Checkpoint backward is now 686.0 ms inclusive for 16 layers. Transformers resolves theautoreduce bucket to hidden_size² = 16,777,216 elements and prefetch to 0.9× that, rather than DeepSpeed's much larger defaults. - CPU-only data ablation:/tmp/r8/length_analysis.logtokenized the exact samples of the first 25 steps and compared reference partitions with the allowed exact-token-length greedy partition. Aggregate padded-work ratio token/current was 1.000445 and a mixed max/sum cost proxy ratio was 1.000033. There is no useful headroom in that direction; it was rejected without a GPU candidate. - Hotspot classification: many small per-projection collectives and limited communication/computation overlap due to hidden-sized auto buckets. - Changes to screen in isolated copies (submission untouched):/tmp/r8/tree-reduce100setsreduce_bucket_size=100000000;/tmp/r8/tree-prefetch100setsstage3_prefetch_bucket_size=100000000;/tmp/r8/tree-both100sets both. All use the validated 16-layer + three-compile config/tmp/r7/retain16.json. Bucket scheduling is expected N1 but all dtype/precision settings are unchanged. - Additional size screen:/tmp/r8/tree-both500sets both buckets to 500,000,000 elements. - Timing (sequential launcher PID 74522, log/tmp/r8/bucket-times.log): all data probes matched and all runs were valid with zero reported problems. Reduction-only 100M:/tmp/r8/time-reduce100/time_tree.json, 2120.7 ms, 1.2996×, windows 21.424/20.991 s, spread 0.0027. Prefetch-only 100M:/tmp/r8/time-prefetch100/time_tree.json, 2119.5 ms, 1.3004×, windows 21.416/20.974 s, spread 0.0023. Both 100M:/tmp/r8/time-both100/time_tree.json, 2110.4 ms, 1.3060×, windows 21.334/20.874 s, spread 0.0013, peak allocated/reserved 124.43/137.48 GiB, first-loss difference 0.00029. Both 500M:/tmp/r8/time-both500/time_tree.json(PID 79811), 2120.9 ms, 1.2995×, spread 0.0161, peak allocated 125.18 GiB; worse than 100M and not promoted. - Quick check:/tmp/r8/quick-both100/check.json(PID 81585, log/tmp/r8/quick-both100.log), PASS, measured N1; 4724 tensors checked, no exact failures, dtype changes or precision-mode changes. Ten unresolved diagnostic tensors are the established compiled-fusion differences; gate 3 decides. The 100M-both variant was promoted toscripts/zero3.jsonand committed as5d72e7d. - End of GPU screening round: 2026-11-12 21:40 UTC. Full verdict:/tmp/r8/check/check.json(PID 84956, log/tmp/r8/check.log), ERROR, not promoted. Timing itself passed at 2118.4 ms / 1.3010×, windows 21.505/20.863 s, spread 0.0072; gate 2 again had zero exact/dtype/math-mode failures. The 60-step trajectory completed all displayed optimizer steps but rank 0 then exited with SIGSEGV (/tmp/r8/check/traj_s0.log, exitcode -11 at 21:49:13), so gate 3 returned error and awarded no speedup. Reverted both bucket values toautoin commitb5261f5; the submission is restored to the/tmp/r7/checkfully passing tree. Per the gate-rejection rule, bucket tuning is abandoned rather than retried around the failure.
2.8 hRound 9 — allocator headroom for activation retention
- Start: 2026-11-12 21:51 UTC; profile ended 21:52 UTC. The failed first launcher (PID 91494) did not start because/tmp/r9did not yet exist; actual profile launcher PID 91496, log/tmp/r9/profile.log. - Profile of the restored 1.2922× full-pass tree:/tmp/r9/profile, status ok, 2058 ms GPU kernel time in the profiled step. Main GEMMs 401.0 + 360.5 + 192.7 + 150.1 + 106.2 ms; all-gather 184.3 ms and reduce-scatter 73.4 ms.CheckpointFunctionBackwardis 690.1 ms inclusive and eager bf16 residual adds are 31.5 + 5.6 ms. Full-check memory at N=16 remains 124.27 GiB allocated versus 137.77 GiB reserved, making allocator overhead the limiting factor for further N0 recompute removal. - Hotspot classification: memory-configuration bottleneck. Expandable CUDA allocator segments may reduce the roughly 13 GiB reserved-minus-allocated gap and permit retaining additional complete decoder layers. The allocator alone is N0; existing compiled helpers keep the candidate N1 overall. - Changes to screen by judge sweep, all with the existing three compile switches:/tmp/r9/expand16.json,expand18.json, andexpand20.jsonsetPYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:Trueand retain 16, 18, and 20 layers respectively. Submitted switches remain at validated N=16 with the default allocator. - Sweep:/tmp/r9/sweep/sweep.json(launcher PID 93047, log/tmp/r9/sweep.log), 21:54:01–22:02:07 UTC. Paired references 2750.7/2755.0 ms, spread 0.0016. Expandable N=16: 2120.8 ms, 1.2995× frozen / 1.2980× paired, spread 0.0009. Expandable N=18: 2087.1 ms, 1.3205× frozen / 1.3190× paired, windows 21.099/20.640 s, spread 0.0010, zero timed compiles, peak allocated 130.74 GiB, reserved about 135.56 GiB. N=20 OOMed while trying to allocate 3.75 GiB with 3.62 GiB free and was rejected. - N=19 timing:/tmp/r9/time19/time_tree.json(PID 99332, log/tmp/r9/time19.log), status ok, 2080.7 ms / 1.3246×, windows 20.914/20.699 s, spread 0.0128, zero reported problems, peak allocated/reserved 133.97/136.44 GiB, first-loss difference 0.00029. It improves modestly on N=18 while retaining about 3.4 GiB reserved headroom; N=19 is the promotion candidate. - Quick check:/tmp/r9/quick19/check.json(PID 101091, log/tmp/r9/quick19.log), PASS, no exact failures. Promoted N=19 plusPYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=expandable_segments:Trueto/submission/switches.json; no source change was needed, so there is no new source commit. - End of GPU screening round: 2026-11-12 22:11 UTC. Full verdict:/tmp/r9/check/check.json(PID 104445, log/tmp/r9/check.log), 22:11:16–22:19:52 UTC, PASS N1, speedup 1.3293×. Timing: 2073.4 ms/step, windows 20.934/20.534 s, spread 0.0038, peak allocated/reserved 133.97/136.23 GiB. Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0; gate 2 has the established ten diagnostic unresolved tensors. Gate 3 equivalent: train bias +0.0082σ, probe bias -0.0458σ. This is the best fully validated submission.
3.3 hRound 10 — residual-plus-RMSNorm fusion
- Start: 2026-11-12 22:21 UTC; profile ended 22:22 UTC. Profile/tmp/r10/profile, launcher PID 110961, log/tmp/r10/profile.log, status ok. - Profile of the 1.3293× full-pass tree: 2042 ms GPU kernel time. Main GEMMs 372.1 + 364.1 + 191.7 + 150.7 + 100.5 ms; all-gather 193.8 ms, reduce-scatter 89.0 ms. Checkpoint backward fell to 556.3 ms inclusive after retaining 19 layers. Eager bf16 residual adds remain 30.9 + 5.6 ms, alongside the already-compiled norm chains. - Hotspot classification: unfused memory-bound work between the attention projection and MLP. One of the two residual additions in every decoder execution feeds the post-attention RMSNorm and can share its compiled region. - Change in isolated tree/tmp/r10/tree-resnorm: opt-inLLAVA_COMPILE_RESIDUAL_NORM=1adds a dynamic compiled helper returning both the bf16 residual sum and its fp32-normalized/bf16-weighted RMSNorm output. The post-attention norm is still invoked as a module, so DeepSpeed hooks and weight access remain in place; attention, MLP, projections and model-level loss are unchanged. Expected N1. Syntax and diff checks passed. Experiment config/tmp/r10/resnorm.jsonstacks the validated N=19/allocator settings. Submission remains unchanged during screening. - Timing:/tmp/r10/time-resnorm/time_tree.json(PID 112499), status ok, 2076.8 ms / 1.3271×, windows 20.961/20.575 s, spread 0.0045, peak 133.97 GiB. This did not improve on the 2073.4 ms full-pass baseline. Candidate profile/tmp/r10/profile-resnorm(PID 114295) confirmed the fast path: the separate 5.6 ms add disappeared and the main add total fell from 30.9 to 23.0 ms, about 13.5 ms saved. A scalar DeepSpeed all-reduce's rank-0 wait rose from 2.8 to 21.0 ms in this profile; the same five small all-reduces exist in both trees, so this is exposed rank imbalance rather than a new collective. - Repeat timing:/tmp/r10/time-resnorm2/time_tree.json(PID 115903, log/tmp/r10/time-resnorm2.log), 2082.6 ms / 1.3234×, spread 0.0119. Two runs do not resolve a benefit over baseline; the fusion is rejected without spending a quick/full check. No experimental source or switch was promoted. - End: 2026-11-12 22:33 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r9/check1.3293× full-pass tree.
3.5 hRound 11 — fused AdamW optimizer kernels
- Start: 2026-11-12 22:33 UTC; profile/tmp/r11/profile, launcher PID 117722, log/tmp/r11/profile.log, status ok. - Profile of the unchanged 1.3293× tree: 2116 ms GPU kernel time (communication was higher in this sample: all-gather 250.5 ms, reduce-scatter 102.5 ms). Optimizer-related multi-tensor kernels are approximately 65 ms: 14.9 + 13.8 + 10.6 + 10.5 + 7.7 + 7.5 ms, with additional scalar/norm work. This is a launch/memory-bound optimizer hotspot rather than model math. - Change in isolated tree/tmp/r11/tree-fusedadam: behindLLAVA_FUSED_ADAMW=1, make a shallow copy of the training arguments solely while constructing the optimizer and select Transformers' existingadamw_torch_fusedbranch. This sets PyTorchAdamW(fused=True)while leaving the recipe's argument object, betas, epsilon, LR, weight decay, parameter groups, fp32 master weights/state and DeepSpeed engine step unchanged. Expected N1. Experiment/tmp/r11/fusedadam.jsonstacks all validated switches. Syntax and diff checks passed. - Initial timing attempt/tmp/r11/time-fusedadam/time_tree.json(PID 119375): ERROR before training because directfused=Trueconstruction rejects ZeRO-3's CPU-initialized parameters. No optimizer step ran. Revised only the isolated experiment:_LlavaLazyFusedAdamWconstructs withfused=False, then enables fused mode on its first nonempty all-CUDA floating-point subgroup, which is how DeepSpeed_optimizer_stepsupplies fp32 partitions. This is unconditional workload-based behavior, not judge detection. - Lazy candidate timing:/tmp/r11/time-fusedadam-lazy/time_tree.json(PID 120589, log/tmp/r11/time-fusedadam-lazy.log), status ok, 2071.2 ms / 1.3307×, windows and run valid, spread 0.0020, peak 133.97 GiB. Profile/tmp/r11/profile-fusedadam(PID 122365) confirms the fast path: aFusedOptimizerTensorListMetadata<4>kernel takes 55.9 ms and replaces the previous multi-tensor sequence, with no timed compiles or fallback signatures. - Quick check:/tmp/r11/quick-fusedadam/check.json(PID 123911, log/tmp/r11/quick-fusedadam.log), PASS N1. No exact, dtype or precision-mode failures; the same ten unresolved diagnostics as the existing compiled-fusion baseline. Promoted the lazy optimizer patch as commit1288d97and addedLLAVA_FUSED_ADAMW=1to switches. Timing windows were 20.972/20.451 s, reserved peak 136.46 GiB, first-loss difference 0.00029. - End of GPU screening round: 2026-11-12 22:50 UTC. Full verdict:/tmp/r11/check/check.json(PID 127281, log/tmp/r11/check.log), 22:50:31–22:58:52 UTC, PASS N1, speedup 1.3334×. Timing 2067.0 ms/step, windows 20.858/20.481 s, spread 0.0048, peak allocated/reserved 133.97/136.60 GiB. Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0. Gate 3 equivalent: train bias +0.00017σ, probe bias -0.04274σ. Best fully validated submission.
3.9 hRound 12 — compiled shifted cross entropy and logits backward layout
- Start: 2026-11-12 23:00 UTC; profile/tmp/r12/profile, launcher PID 133804, log/tmp/r12/profile.log, status ok. - Profile of the 1.3334× tree: 2078 ms GPU kernel time. Fused AdamW remains active (56.0 ms). Large layout work includes 32.3 ms direct copy, 15.3 + 11.3 + 11.1 ms other copies and 15.7 ms fills. Trace attribution at the profiled shape [16,1113,32000] confirms the loss path: lm-head bf16 logits are cast to a full fp32 tensor, the [16,1112,32000] shift is cloned contiguously, fp32 cross entropy runs, and backward allocates/fills and copies full shifted and unshifted fp32 gradient tensors. - Hotspot classification: redundant loss/layout work and an unnecessarily long autograd cast/slice chain between the lm-head GEMM and its backward. - Change in isolated tree/tmp/r12/tree-loss: opt-inLLAVA_COMPILE_LOSS=1uses a dynamic compiled shifted cross entropy directly from the existing bf16 lm-head output, casting the shifted logits to fp32 inside that helper and retaining defaultignore_index=-100and mean reduction. The returned logits are still cast to fp32 and remain attached to autograd, so output dtype and external output-gradient semantics are preserved. Since the loss no longer depends on that output-cast branch, ordinary loss-only backward avoids the old cast/slice chain. Unlabeled forwards use the original parent forward. Expected N1, not an output precision change. Experiment/tmp/r12/loss.json; syntax/diff checks passed. - Timing:/tmp/r12/time-loss/time_tree.json(PID 135375, log/tmp/r12/time-loss.log), status ok, 2077.4 ms / 1.3267×, windows 21.032/20.516 s, spread 0.0017, peak allocated/reserved 130.22/133.59 GiB, first-loss difference 0.00029. This is 10.4 ms slower than the current full-pass timing, so the change is not promoted standalone; however it frees 3.75 GiB allocated and about 3 GiB reserved. - Quick check:/tmp/r12/quick-loss/check.json(PID 137499, log/tmp/r12/quick-loss.log), PASS N1, zero exact/dtype/math-mode failures, 11 unresolved diagnostics (the established ten plus the compiled loss). The isolated tree remains available solely to test whether its memory saving enables one more retained layer in the next round. - End: 2026-11-12 23:11 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r11/check1.3334× full-pass tree.
4.1 hRound 13 — use compiled-loss memory for a twentieth retained layer
- Start: 2026-11-12 23:11 UTC; profile/tmp/r13/profile, launcher PID 141194, log/tmp/r13/profile.log, status ok. - Profile of the current 1.3334× best: 2056 ms GPU kernel time, checkpoint backward 554.0 ms inclusive for the 13 remaining checkpointed layers, fused AdamW 56.0 ms. Round 9's N=20 attempt OOMed by roughly 0.13 GiB after allocator caching; round 12's otherwise slower compiled-loss candidate freed 3.75 GiB allocated and passed quick exactness, making N=20 the next bounded recompute experiment. - Hotspot classification: activation-recompute cost that can now be removed by using the new memory headroom; this round changes onlyLLAVA_UNCHECKPOINT_LAYERSfrom 19 to 20 on the already quick-validated isolated loss tree. Tier remains N1. - Timing:/tmp/r13/time-loss20/time_tree.json(PID 142736, log/tmp/r13/time-loss20.log), status ok, 2062.9 ms / 1.3361×, windows 20.772/20.486 s, spread 0.0093, peak allocated/reserved 133.46/136.48 GiB, first-loss difference 0.00029. N=20 now fits with about 3.3 GiB reserved headroom and is modestly faster than the 2067.0 ms baseline. Round 12 already quick-validated the only non-N0 portion (compiled loss); this round's retention increment is the same N0 operation validated previously. - End of GPU screening round: 2026-11-12 23:17 UTC. Full verdict on the isolated tree:/tmp/r13/check-loss20/check.json(PID 144856, log/tmp/r13/check-loss20.log), 23:17:13–23:25:55 UTC, PASS N1, speedup 1.3432×. Timing 2051.9 ms/step, windows 20.557/20.482 s, spread 0.0195, peak allocated/reserved 133.46/136.40 GiB. Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0; 11 diagnostic unresolved tensors. Gate 3 equivalent: train bias +0.05665σ, probe +0.01674σ. Promoted the exact source match as commitabf88de; switches now use compiled loss and N=20. Best fully validated submission.
4.6 hRound 14 — bf16 returned training logits
- Start: 2026-11-12 23:27 UTC; profile/tmp/r14/profile, launcher PID 152571, log/tmp/r14/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2006 ms/step. Main GEMMs took 363.5 + 362.4 + 191.6 + 152.2 + 96.7 ms; all-gather 199.5 ms, reduce-scatter 81.2 ms, fused AdamW 56.0 ms. Checkpoint backward was 505.8 ms inclusive for the 12 remaining checkpointed layers. Loss-adjacent work remains visible among direct/layout copies, although the largest individual bf16 copy is a 65,536,000-element ZeRO bucket rather than the logits cast. - Change in isolated tree/tmp/r14/tree-bf16logits: behindLLAVA_BF16_LOGITS=1, the labeled compiled-loss forward returns the existing bf16 lm-head logits instead of allocating upstream's fp32 output cast. Shifted cross entropy still casts its shifted input to fp32 and retainsignore_index=-100and mean reduction; unlabeled forwards use the original parent path. This was an explicit N2 output-precision experiment. Config/tmp/r14/bf16logits.json; the submission remained unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r14/time-bf16logits/time_tree.json(PID 154535, log/tmp/r14/time-bf16logits.log), status ok, 2069.7 ms / 1.3316×, windows 20.658/20.737 s, spread 0.0269, peak allocated/reserved 133.45/136.40 GiB, first-loss difference 0.00029. This is slower than both the 2062.9 ms screening and 2051.9 ms full-check timings of the current best; reserved memory did not decrease, so it also creates no useful headroom for another retained layer. - Quick check:/tmp/r14/quick-bf16logits/check.json(PID 156692, log/tmp/r14/quick-bf16logits.log), PASS, measured N1 on the recorded tensors: zero exact errors/failures, zero dtype or precision-mode changes, and the same 11 unresolved diagnostics. The source-level output-precision experiment was not promoted, and no full check was justified by its timing. - End: 2026-11-12 23:41 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r13/check-loss201.3432× full-pass tree.
4.9 hRound 15 — retain MLP graphs inside checkpointed decoder layers
- Start: 2026-11-12 23:41 UTC; profile/tmp/r15/profile, launcher PID 160551, log/tmp/r15/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2003 ms/step; the 12 still-checkpointed layers accounted for 506.8 ms inclusive inCheckpointFunctionBackward. Main GEMMs took 367.6 + 365.7 + 194.0 + 149.5 + 97.0 ms, all-gather 199.1 ms, reduce-scatter 68.9 ms, and fused AdamW 56.0 ms. - Hotspot classification: whole-layer recomputation with too little memory for a twenty-first fully retained layer. Change in/tmp/r15/tree-partialmlp: opt-inLLAVA_RETAIN_MLP_LAYERS=Ncheckpoints only the input-norm/attention/residual portion of the N layers immediately before the 20 fully retained layers, while preserving their post-attention norm and MLP autograd graphs in the main forward. Unexpected kwargs, cached decoding and attention-output paths fall back to the original whole-layer checkpoint. A small CPU double-precision decoder test had bitwise-equal forward and input gradients versus whole-layer checkpointing. Syntax and diff checks passed. Configs/tmp/r15/partial1.json,partial2.json,partial3.json; submission unchanged. - Sweep:/tmp/r15/sweep/sweep.json(PID 162602, log/tmp/r15/sweep.log). Bracketing references were stable at 2754.3/2753.2 ms. One partially retained MLP was valid but slower: 2086.5 ms / 1.3209×, spread 0.0148, peak allocated 135.87 GiB. Two and three partial MLPs both OOMed on a 3.75 GiB allocation at step 10; neither produced a timing result. The valid N=1 result is slower than the current 2051.9–2062.9 ms timings, so there is no promotion or full check. - Quick check on N=1:/tmp/r15/quick-partial1/check.json(PID 169994, log/tmp/r15/quick-partial1.log), PASS N1, zero exact errors/failures, zero dtype/math-mode changes and the same 11 unresolved diagnostics. Correctness did not offset the unresolved timing regression. - End: 2026-11-12 23:58 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r13/check-loss201.3432× full-pass tree.
5.1 hRound 16 — bf16 cross-entropy storage
- Start: 2026-11-12 23:59 UTC; profile/tmp/r16/profile, launcher PID 173717, log/tmp/r16/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 1993 ms/step. The two large compiled-loss kernels remained 44.4 + 34.1 ms; main GEMMs were 365.5 + 363.3 + 192.6 + 150.1 + 95.9 ms, all-gather 197.4 ms, reduce-scatter 67.6 ms, and fused AdamW 56.1 ms. - Change in isolated tree/tmp/r16/tree-bf16ce: behindLLAVA_BF16_CROSS_ENTROPY=1, feed the shifted bf16 logits directly to compiledtorch.nn.functional.cross_entropy, then cast the scalar loss back to fp32. The default compiled fp32 shifted-cross-entropy path remains unchanged. This was an explicit N2 internal-precision experiment; labels, shift, ignore index and mean reduction were unchanged. Config/tmp/r16/bf16ce.json; syntax/diff checks passed and submission stayed unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r16/time-bf16ce/time_tree.json(PID 175637, log/tmp/r16/time-bf16ce.log), status ok, 2060.5 ms / 1.3376×, window spread 0.0049, peak allocated 133.46 GiB, first-loss difference within the existing band. This is only 2.4 ms faster than the prior 2062.9 ms screen and slower than the 2051.9 ms full-pass timing; peak memory is identical. There is no resolved speed or memory benefit and no full check was run. - Quick check:/tmp/r16/quick-bf16ce/check.json(PID 177861, log/tmp/r16/quick-bf16ce.log), PASS, measured N1 on recorded tensors despite the source-level N2 experiment; zero exact errors/failures and dtype/math-mode changes, with 9 unresolved diagnostics. No source or switch was promoted. - End: 2026-11-13 00:10 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r13/check-loss201.3432× full-pass tree.
5.5 hRound 17 — flash-attention Triton cross entropy without shifted-logits materialization
- Start: 2026-11-13 00:12 UTC; profile/tmp/r17/profile, launcher PID 181725, log/tmp/r17/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2079 ms/step in this sample; the compiled fp32 loss kernels were 44.3 + 34.2 ms. Main GEMMs took 366.1 + 365.0 + 194.1 + 149.6 + 97.1 ms, all-gather 210.4 ms, reduce-scatter 134.0 ms, and fused AdamW 56.1 ms. - Change in/tmp/r17/tree-flashce: opt-inLLAVA_FLASH_CROSS_ENTROPY=1selects theflash_attn.ops.triton.cross_entropyimplementation already present in pinned flash-attn 2.5.8. The full contiguous lm-head output is used directly; labels are padded with oneIGNORE_INDEXat each row's final position instead of copying all shifted logits. Per-row fp32 losses are summed and divided by the valid-label count, preserving the supervised token pairs and mean semantics.LLAVA_FLASH_CE_INPLACE=1selects the library's in-place bf16 gradient output. The existing compiled-loss path remains the default. This is N1 reordered fp32 log-sum-exp/reduction arithmetic with the same external dtypes. Syntax/diff checks passed. - Sweep:/tmp/r17/sweep/sweep.json(PID 183637, log/tmp/r17/sweep.log), bracketing references 2761.0/2752.1 ms. Out-of-place backward: 2044.6 ms / 1.3480×, peak allocated 131.58 GiB. In-place backward: 2038.4 ms / 1.3521×, spread 0.0058, peak allocated 131.58 GiB. Both runs were valid; the in-place variant was modestly faster and saved 1.88 GiB allocated versus the prior best. - Quick check:/tmp/r17/quick-flashce-inplace/check.json(PID 188289, log/tmp/r17/quick-flashce-inplace.log), PASS N1, zero exact/dtype/math-mode failures and 11 unresolved diagnostics. - Full verdict:/tmp/r17/check-flashce-inplace/check.json(PID 191712, log/tmp/r17/check-flashce-inplace.log), 00:28:39–00:37:03 UTC, PASS N1, speedup 1.3546×. Timing 2034.6 ms/step, windows 20.593/20.100 s, reported spread 0.0012, peak allocated/reserved 131.58/134.51 GiB. Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0; gate 3 equivalent with train bias -0.00480σ and probe bias -0.06390σ. Promoted the exact source/config match as commitc18f79a; switches now enable flash cross entropy and its in-place backward. Best fully validated submission. - End: 2026-11-13 00:39 UTC.
5.8 hRound 18 — use flash-loss memory for a twenty-first retained layer
- Start: 2026-11-13 00:40 UTC; profile/tmp/r18/profile, launcher PID 198430, log/tmp/r18/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2002 ms/step. The trace directly confirmedcross_entropy_fwd_kernel0.519 ms andcross_entropy_bwd_kernel0.595 ms once each; the repeatedtriton__...kernels formerly suspected as loss work belong to other compiled regions. Checkpoint backward remained 508.4 ms inclusive for 12 checkpointed layers. All-gather was 198.0 ms and reduce-scatter 78.6 ms. - Hotspot classification: remaining whole-layer recomputation; round 17 freed 1.88 GiB allocated and 1.89 GiB reserved, while the last retention increment cost about 3.23 GiB. This round changes onlyLLAVA_UNCHECKPOINT_LAYERSfrom 20 to 21 in/tmp/r18/n21.json, on the exact round-17 full-pass source. Tier remains N1; submission source stayed atc18f79a. - First timing:/tmp/r18/time-n21/time_tree.json(PID 200020, log/tmp/r18/time-n21.log), valid but slower at 2052.7 ms / 1.3427× with a high 0.0337 window spread. Peak allocated 134.81 GiB confirmed that N=21 fits. Repeat/tmp/r18/time-n21-repeat/time_tree.json(PID 201816, log/tmp/r18/time-n21-repeat.log) was 2020.4 ms / 1.3641×, spread 0.0013. The repeat supported a full verdict rather than relying on either screen alone. - Full verdict:/tmp/r18/check-n21/check.json(PID 203606, log/tmp/r18/check-n21.log), 00:47:24–00:55:56 UTC, PASS N1, speedup 1.3598×. Timing 2026.8 ms/step, windows 20.534/20.003 s, reported spread 0.0031, peak allocated/reserved 134.81/136.21 GiB. Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0; gate 3 equivalent with train bias +0.05998σ and probe bias +0.06530σ. Promoted the exact N=21 switch file; no source change or new source commit was needed. - End: 2026-11-13 00:57 UTC. Best fully validated submission.
5.9 hRound 19 — twenty-second retained layer memory boundary
- Start: 2026-11-13 00:57 UTC; profile/tmp/r19/profile, launcher PID 210279, log/tmp/r19/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2051 ms/step in a communication-heavy sample: all-gather 254.0 ms and reduce-scatter 87.7 ms. Retaining layer 21 reduced inclusive checkpoint backward to 461.8 ms for the remaining 11 layers (from 508.4 ms for 12). Fused AdamW remained 56.1 ms. - Change:/tmp/r19/n22.jsonincreases onlyLLAVA_UNCHECKPOINT_LAYERSfrom 21 to 22 on the full-pass source. No source edit and no change to the submitted N=21 configuration. - Timing:/tmp/r19/time-n22/time_tree.json(PID 211846, log/tmp/r19/time-n22.log), ERROR before a valid result. At step 10, rank 0 OOMed while allocating 3.75 GiB: 2.88 GiB free, 615.5 MiB reserved but unallocated, and 134.30 GiB allocated by PyTorch. Even counting the cached-unallocated amount leaves a small shortfall. N=22 alone is therefore not viable; no quick/full check was run. - End: 2026-11-13 01:02 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r18/check-n211.3598× full-pass tree and N=21 switches.
6.3 hRound 20 — bf16 returned logits make N=22 fit
- Start: 2026-11-13 01:02 UTC; profile/tmp/r20/profile, launcher PID 213667, log/tmp/r20/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2088 ms/step in another communication-heavy sample: all-gather 274.4 ms and reduce-scatter 95.2 ms. Checkpoint backward was 468.5 ms inclusive for 11 layers. Round 19's N=22 failure was only about 0.3 GiB short after counting cached-unallocated memory, and flash cross entropy had removed the fp32 loss storage that masked the output-cast cost in round 14. - Change in/tmp/r20/tree-bf16logits-n22: behindLLAVA_BF16_LOGITS=1, labeled forwards return the existing bf16 lm-head logits rather than a full fp32 output cast. Flash cross entropy still computes fp32 per-row losses and the same valid-token mean; unlabeled forwards use the original parent implementation. This is explicitly N2 at the model-output boundary, although logits are not among the judge's recorded tensors. Two configs screen N=21 and N=22 with this memory change; submission remained unchanged during testing. - Sweep:/tmp/r20/sweep/sweep.json(PID 215247, log/tmp/r20/sweep.log), references 2754.5/2750.5 ms. N=21+bf16 logits: 2022.9 ms / 1.3624×, peak allocated 131.55 GiB, demonstrating a 3.26 GiB saving over N=21 with fp32 output. N=22+bf16 logits: 2002.7 ms / 1.3762×, spread 0.0063, peak allocated 134.78 GiB. The previously OOMing layer count now fits and is faster. - Quick check on N=22:/tmp/r20/quick-n22-bf16logits/check.json(PID 219906, log/tmp/r20/quick-n22-bf16logits.log), PASS, judge-measured N1 on recorded tensors, zero exact/dtype/math-mode failures and 11 unresolved diagnostics. - Full verdict:/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits/check.json(PID 223334, log/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits.log), 01:17:21–01:26:00 UTC, PASS, speedup 1.3788× (judge-measured N1). Timing 1998.8 ms/step, windows 20.206/19.771 s, reported spread 0.0013, peak allocated/reserved 134.78/137.69 GiB. Exact/dtype/math-mode failures 0; gate 3 equivalent with train bias -0.04566σ and probe bias +0.02630σ. Promoted the exact source/config match; source commita20b55blabels the output change N2, and switches now use N=22 plus bf16 logits. Best fully validated submission. - End: 2026-11-13 01:28 UTC.
6.6 hRound 21 — N=23 and allocator split-limit boundary
- Start: 2026-11-13 01:28 UTC; profile/tmp/r21/profile, launcher PID 230049, log/tmp/r21/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2030 ms/step; checkpoint backward fell to 418.7 ms inclusive for the 10 remaining checkpointed layers. All-gather was 208.7 ms, reduce-scatter 118.2 ms, and fused AdamW 55.9 ms. N=22's full-check peak was 134.78/137.69 GiB allocated/reserved, so one more 3.23 GiB retained-layer increment was the memory question. - N=23 timing with the validated allocator:/tmp/r21/time-n23/time_tree.json(PID 231625, log/tmp/r21/time-n23.log), ERROR. A 1.88 GiB allocation had 1.41 GiB free and 725.7 MiB reserved but unallocated. The combined amount was slightly larger than the request, so two same-round allocator configurations screened whether block splitting was preventing its use:/tmp/r21/n23-split128.jsonandn23-split512.json. - Allocator sweep:/tmp/r21/sweep-allocator/sweep.json(PID 233427, log/tmp/r21/sweep-allocator.log), bracketing references valid. Bothmax_split_size_mb:128and:512combined with expandable segments ERRORED on PyTorch's!block->expandable_segment_ INTERNAL ASSERT FAILEDatCUDACachingAllocator.cpp:2814; neither produced a timing result. No further allocator variant was tried, and no quick/full check was warranted. N=23 is not submitted. - End: 2026-11-13 01:40 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass source and N=22 switches.
6.8 hRound 22 — NCCL protocol substitution
- Start: 2026-11-13 01:40 UTC; profile/tmp/r22/profile, launcher PID 238039, log/tmp/r22/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2007 ms/step.AllGather_RING_LLtook 202.0 ms andReduceScatter_RING_LL109.7 ms, 15.6% of kernel time combined; main GEMMs were 366.7 + 346.3 + 192.2 + 153.1 + 92.1 ms. Checkpoint backward was 421.3 ms inclusive. - Change:/tmp/r22/nccl-ll128.jsonandnccl-simple.jsonset onlyNCCL_PROTO=LL128orSimpleon the exact N=22 full-pass tree. No source edit; all other switches remained identical. With two ranks, all-gather is data movement and reduce-scatter retains one bf16 cross-rank addition, but any candidate still required exactness validation before promotion. - Sweep:/tmp/r22/sweep/sweep.json(PID 239614, log/tmp/r22/sweep.log), references 2759.6/2764.3 ms. LL128: 2017.0 ms / 1.3665×, spread 0.0028. Simple: 2002.2 ms / 1.3765×, spread 0.0018. Both were valid and retained 134.78 GiB peak allocated memory, but neither improved on the 1998.8 ms / 1.3788× full-pass baseline. No quick/full check or promotion was justified; this protocol direction is closed. - End: 2026-11-13 01:51 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
7.0 hRound 23 — flash-attention RMSNorm
- Start: 2026-11-13 01:54 UTC; profile/tmp/r23/profile, launcher PID 244343, log/tmp/r23/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 1964 ms/step. Repeated compiled RMSNorm kernels remained 44.4 + 32.7 ms and MLP gating kernels 18.6 + 19.5 ms; all-gather was 204.0 ms and reduce-scatter 64.8 ms. Earlier trace grids mapped the large repeated kernels to hidden-size norm and intermediate-size MLP regions rather than cross entropy. - Change in/tmp/r23/tree-flashrms: opt-inLLAVA_FLASH_RMSNORM=1replaces the compiled helper with flash-attention 2.5.8's existingrms_norm_fn, flattening only the leading dimensions and restoring the original shape. The LlamaRMSNorm module call, named weight, epsilon and DeepSpeed module-hook boundary remain intact. Its Triton kernel keeps fp32 normalization through the weight multiply rather than rounding the normalized value to bf16 first, so this was treated as an N2 internal-precision experiment. Config/tmp/r23/flashrms.json; syntax/diff checks passed. - Timing:/tmp/r23/time-flashrms/time_tree.json(PID 245935, log/tmp/r23/time-flashrms.log), valid, 2004.3 ms / 1.3751×, spread 0.0137. Quick check/tmp/r23/quick-flashrms/check.json(PID 247760), PASS, judge-measured N1 on records, zero exact/dtype/math-mode failures and 10 unresolved diagnostics. - Repeat timing:/tmp/r23/time-flashrms-repeat/time_tree.json(PID 251235, log/tmp/r23/time-flashrms-repeat.log), valid, 2000.2 ms / 1.3779×, spread 0.0149, peak 134.78 GiB. Neither run improves on the 1998.8 ms / 1.3788× full-pass baseline. No full check or promotion; the isolated experiment remains rejected. - End: 2026-11-13 02:07 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
7.2 hRound 24 — zero-bias addmm / cuBLASLt for ZeRO projections
- Start: 2026-11-13 02:07 UTC; profile/tmp/r24/profile, launcher PID 253070, log/tmp/r24/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 1965 ms/step, with the five main cuBLAS GEMM groups taking 366.4 + 349.1 + 191.4 + 151.4 + 92.2 ms (about 59%). All-gather took 191.5 ms and reduce-scatter 77.9 ms. Pinned PyTorch 2.1 exposes no global preferred-cuBLASLt API; DeepSpeed'sLinearFunctionForZeroStage3usesaddmmonly for 2-D biased inputs andmatmulfor the LLM's bias-free projections. - Change in/tmp/r24/tree-addmm: opt-inLLAVA_ZERO_BIAS_ADDMM=1wraps that same DeepSpeed autograd forward, flattening bias-free inputs to 2-D and callingaddmmwith a non-parameter zero vector, then restoring the original shape. The original saved tensors and complete backward implementation are unchanged; fallback calls the original forward./tmp/r24/addmm-workspace.jsonadditionally setsCUBLASLT_WORKSPACE_SIZE=32768. Expected N1 from backend/reduction-order changes. Syntax/diff checks passed and submission stayed unchanged. - Sweep:/tmp/r24/sweep/sweep.json(PID 254787, log/tmp/r24/sweep.log). Zero-bias addmm: 2026.1 ms; addmm plus 32 MiB Lt workspace: 2020.8 ms. Both are slower than the 1998.8 ms full-pass baseline. No quick/full check was justified, no source or switch was promoted, and this backend direction is closed. - End: 2026-11-13 02:21 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
7.4 hRound 25 — re-test shared attention-unpadding metadata
- Start: 2026-11-13 02:21 UTC; profile/tmp/r25/profile, launcher PID 259468, log/tmp/r25/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 1955 ms/step.aten::nonzeroremained 272.4 ms inclusive on the host, with another 26.1 ms inaten::item; these are the repeated flash-attention unpadding size/max-length synchronizations. GPU kernels still showed all-gather 186.6 ms, reduce-scatter 76.6 ms and checkpoint backward 421.3 ms inclusive. - Change in/tmp/r25/tree-unpad: restored the earlierLLAVA_CACHE_ATTENTION_UNPAD=1experiment, which keys metadata on the shared mask object and its_version, including checkpoint replays. This is the same N0 implementation previously tested at the reference, now re-tested after the step time fell from about 2.75 s to 2.0 s. Config/tmp/r25/unpad.json; syntax/diff checks passed. - Timing:/tmp/r25/time-unpad/time_tree.json(PID 261074, log/tmp/r25/time-unpad.log), status ok but 2061.8 ms / 1.3368×, window spread 0.0593, peak 134.78 GiB. This is much slower than the 1998.8 ms full-pass baseline and close to the final evaluator's 6% interference threshold. No quick/full check or promotion was justified. The original reference-context noise result and this optimized-context regression close the unpadding-cache direction. - End: 2026-11-13 02:28 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
7.5 hRound 26 — max-autotune for regional Inductor kernels
- Start: 2026-11-13 02:28 UTC; profile/tmp/r26/profile, launcher PID 262881, log/tmp/r26/profile.log, status ok. This was an all-gather outlier (466.4 ms; total GPU kernel time 2254 ms), while GEMMs and compiled regions stayed near their established costs: RMSNorm 44.4 + 32.6 ms, MLP gating 19.2 + 19.7 ms, fused AdamW 56.1 ms. - Change in/tmp/r26/tree-autotune: opt-inLLAVA_COMPILE_AUTOTUNE=1routes the existing RoPE, MLP-gating and RMSNormtorch.compile(dynamic=True)calls throughmode="max-autotune-no-cudagraphs". There are no GEMMs inside these helpers and no CUDA graphs. Default compilation remains unchanged; flash cross entropy is unaffected. Config/tmp/r26/autotune.json; syntax/diff checks passed. - Timing:/tmp/r26/time-autotune/time_tree.json(PID 264496, log/tmp/r26/time-autotune.log), status ok, 2043.7 ms / 1.3486×, window spread 0.0379, peak 134.78 GiB. This is substantially slower than the 1998.8 ms full-pass baseline. No quick/full check or promotion was justified; default Inductor tuning remains. - End: 2026-11-13 02:35 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
7.6 hRound 27 — non-reentrant checkpoint autograd
- Start: 2026-11-13 02:35 UTC; profile/tmp/r27/profile, launcher PID 266614, log/tmp/r27/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2034 ms/step. Main GEMMs took 369.4 + 349.2 + 194.6 + 150.9 + 90.5 ms, all-gather 232.6 ms, reduce-scatter 99.7 ms, and fused AdamW 56.3 ms. The ten remaining checkpointed layers accounted for 422.7 ms inclusive inCheckpointFunctionBackwardand 268.5 ms in forward; this selected the checkpoint implementation as the round's hotspot. - Change in/tmp/r27/tree-nonreentrant: opt-inLLAVA_NONREENTRANT_CHECKPOINT=1replaces only the checkpoint function used by the ten non-retained layers withfunctools.partial(torch.utils.checkpoint.checkpoint, use_reentrant=False). The 22 retained layers still execute directly and all model, data and optimizer settings remain unchanged. Labeled N1 because checkpoint autograd/RNG mechanics can change recorded execution even though the mathematical layer graph is unchanged. Isolated commit905ef03; submission stayed unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r27/time-nonreentrant/time_tree.json(PID 268281, log/tmp/r27/time-nonreentrant.log), ERROR before any completed step, so no speedup was measured. Both ranks failed inBackendCompilerFailedwhile compiling RMSNorm through Inductor/AOT Autograd: non-reentrant checkpoint unpacking causedaten.cloneof a real uint8 tensor under fake-tensor tracing (Please convert all Tensors to FakeTensors first). This is the pinned PyTorch 2.1 compiler/checkpoint interaction, not an OOM or a timing-validity issue. Disabling the established compiled fast paths merely to accommodate this variant would conflate another hotspot, so the variant was rejected. No quick/full check was meaningful after the pre-step compiler failure. - End: 2026-11-13 02:45 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
7.8 hRound 28 — allocator/cache-release variants for N=23
- Start: 2026-11-13 02:46 UTC; profile/tmp/r28/profile, launcher PID 269651, log/tmp/r28/profile.log, status ok. This sample was another all-gather outlier (466.6 ms of 2254 ms total GPU kernel time); main GEMMs remained 366.8 + 356.1 + 191.6 + 150.4 + 92.2 ms, reduce-scatter 80.9 ms and fused AdamW 55.9 ms. Checkpoint backward remained 420.0 ms inclusive. Round 21's N=23 failure was specifically the lm-head's 1.88 GiBinput.matmul(weight.t())allocation, with 1.41 GiB free plus 725.7 MiB reserved-but-unallocated, so this round addressed only the allocator/memory-fragmentation class. - Change in/tmp/r28/tree-emptycache: opt-inLLAVA_EMPTY_CACHE_BEFORE_LM_HEAD=1callstorch.cuda.empty_cache()immediately before the vocabulary projection, releasing no live tensors and changing no arithmetic (N0). Isolated commit58bb5b3; submission stayed unchanged. Two additional configs screenedbackend:cudaMallocAsyncwithout the cache call andbackend:nativewith it. - Expandable-segment cache release:/tmp/r28/time-n23-emptycache/time_tree.json(PID 271264, log/tmp/r28/time-n23-emptycache.log), ERROR at step 10, same lm-head 1.88 GiB OOM. Free memory was 605.9 MiB and reserved-unallocated 1.53 GiB; their sum remained about 2.12 GiB, so the call redistributed the same fragmented headroom rather than making the allocation fit. - Malloc-async:/tmp/r28/time-n23-mallocasync/time_tree.json(PID 273073, log/tmp/r28/time-n23-mallocasync.log), ERROR at step 3 on a 221 MiB compiled-region allocation. Its pool had 127.65 GiB allocated but only 23.94 MiB CUDA-free; peak reserved reached 137.75 GiB. Native allocator plus cache release:/tmp/r28/time-n23-native-emptycache/time_tree.json(PID 274879, log/tmp/r28/time-n23-native-emptycache.log), ERROR at step 3 on a 594 MiB allocation with 8.56 GiB reserved-unallocated. Neither produced a valid timing window. No quick/full check was meaningful, and no source or switch was promoted. - End: 2026-11-13 02:57 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches; N=23 requires actual live-memory reduction.
8.3 hRound 29 — CPU-prepared flash-unpadding metadata and checkpoint-attribute diagnosis
- Start: 2026-11-13 03:00 UTC; profile/tmp/r29/profile, launcher PID 276712, log/tmp/r29/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 1990 ms/step; main GEMMs took 367.6 + 349.4 + 194.4 + 149.8 + 92.3 ms, all-gather 213.0 ms, reduce-scatter 77.2 ms and fused AdamW 56.2 ms. Hostaten::nonzerowas 282.5 ms inclusive andaten::item37.5 ms. This selected flash-attention unpadding metadata as the host/sync hotspot. - Change in/tmp/r29/tree-cpu-unpad: opt-inLLAVA_CPU_ATTENTION_UNPAD=1derives the upstream nonzero indices, int32 cumulative lengths and Python maximum length on CPU, transfers the two metadata tensors, and monkey-patches_get_unpad_datato use them. Text-only masks are prepared inLLaVATrainer._prepare_inputs; multimodal masks are prepared after LLaVA rebuilds them from known per-row lengths. No input keys or arithmetic change (N0). Isolated commit3c60a0e; submission stayed unchanged. - The Trainer-only version timed 1998.4 ms / 1.3792× (/tmp/r29/time-cpu-unpad/time_tree.json, PID 278319), essentially identical to the 1998.8 ms baseline, and its quick check/tmp/r29/quick-cpu-unpad/check.jsonPASSED. However/tmp/r29/profile-cpu-unpad/profile_tree.mdstill showed 273.8 ms of nonzero, revealing that the multimodal path replaced the original mask. - After attaching metadata to the rebuilt multimodal mask,/tmp/r29/time-cpu-unpad-v2/time_tree.json(PID 285146) was valid but slower at 2016.1 ms / 1.3670×, spread 0.0162. Trace analysis of/tmp/r29/profile-cpu-unpad-v2/detail_tree.r0.jsongrouped 272.031 ms into 42 nonzero calls on the flattened[17808]multimodal mask; all small per-sample boolean-index nonzero calls together were only about 1.9 ms. One-time diagnostics in/tmp/r29/profile-cpu-unpad-identity/timing_tree_detail.logthen proved that the attach branch ran but the first flash call received a different tensor object with no attribute. Reentrant checkpoint/custom-autograd boundaries detach tensor objects, so Python attributes are not a reliable metadata channel. Diagnostic prints were removed before the isolated commit. No full check or promotion; the next separate experiment must key metadata by shared storage/version rather than object identity. - End: 2026-11-13 03:28 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
8.7 hRound 30 — storage-keyed unpadding metadata across checkpoint views
- Start: 2026-11-13 03:28 UTC; current-best profile/tmp/r30/profile, launcher PID 291848, log/tmp/r30/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2019 ms/step; all-gather 210.7 ms, reduce-scatter 107.6 ms, fused AdamW 56.3 ms, and checkpoint backward 423.0 ms inclusive.aten::nonzeroremained 268.2 ms andaten::item32.7 ms, continuing round 29's now-attributed flash-unpadding hotspot. - Change in/tmp/r30/tree-storage-unpad: addedllava/unpad_metadata.py, a weak-reference-cleaned registry keyed by device, storage pointer/offset, shape and version. It returns the same CPU-derived metadata for detached checkpoint views, replacing round 29's unreliable tensor attributes. Text-only and rebuilt multimodal masks both register their exact upstream metadata. No arithmetic or input-format change (N0). A local isolated-import test verified detached lookup and weak-reference cleanup; syntax checks passed. Isolated commit53bfb31; submission stayed unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r30/time-storage-unpad/time_tree.json(PID 293621), valid but 2033.0 ms / 1.3557×, spread 0.0394. Quick check/tmp/r30/quick-storage-unpad/check.json(PID 295417) PASSED with no exactness rejection. - Verification profile/tmp/r30/profile-storage-unpad/profile_tree.md(PID 298844) proved the fast path active: the 42 large flash-unpadding nonzero calls disappeared from the op summary. The remaining small multimodal indexing nonzero was below the displayed threshold.aten::itemrose to 201.5 ms because the work shifted to existing synchronization; trace stacks attributed the largest (171.5 ms) to DeepSpeed'sself.losses += loss.mean().item()before backward, with smaller optimizer norm/logging reads. This is exposed waiting, not a fallback. - Repeat/tmp/r30/time-storage-unpad-repeat/time_tree.json(PID 300473) was 2045.0 ms / 1.3477×, spread 0.0488. Both runs were slower than the 1998.8 ms full-pass baseline and had high window spread, so no full check or promotion was justified. Removing these host syncs does not improve end-to-end optimizer-step time and is now closed. - End: 2026-11-13 03:46 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
8.9 hRound 31 — defer DeepSpeed’s pre-backward loss synchronization
- Start: 2026-11-13 03:47 UTC; current-best profile/tmp/r31/profile, launcher PID 302310, log/tmp/r31/profile.log, status ok. This was another communication-heavy sample: all-gather 384.8 ms of 2204 ms total GPU kernel time, reduce-scatter 108.1 ms; main GEMMs remained 368.0 + 356.8 + 192.0 + 152.3 + 89.9 ms and checkpoint backward 422.1 ms. Round 30's stack analysis had located a 171.5 ms exposed wait in DeepSpeed'sself.losses += loss.mean().item()before backward, so this round targeted that host/sync boundary. - Change in/tmp/r31/tree-deferred-loss: opt-inLLAVA_DEFER_DS_LOSS_LOG=1wrapsDeepSpeedEngine.backwardwith the upstream bf16/ZeRO path but moves the same loss accumulation to after backward and gradient reduction. The final publicself.lossesvalue is unchanged, HF Trainer's independent logged-loss path is untouched, and monitoring-enabled calls delegate to the original method. Gradient computation, optimizer order and tensor arithmetic are unchanged (N0). Isolated commita75b611; submission stayed unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r31/time-deferred-loss/time_tree.json(PID 303932), valid, 2003.2 ms / 1.3758×, spread 0.0060. Quick check/tmp/r31/quick-deferred-loss/check.json(PID 305725) PASSED. Repeat/tmp/r31/time-deferred-loss-repeat/time_tree.json(PID 309149) was 2011.0 ms / 1.3705×, spread 0.0128. Both are slower than the 1998.8 ms full-pass baseline, so no full check or promotion was justified. Together with round 30, this closes the unpadding/loss-read host-sync direction: removing or moving these waits does not accelerate the GPU-bound step. - End: 2026-11-13 04:00 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
9.0 hRound 32 — ZeRO residency controls for the N=23 memory boundary
- Start: 2026-11-13 04:00 UTC; current-best profile/tmp/r32/profile, launcher PID 310968, log/tmp/r32/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2097 ms/step, including all-gather 215.8 ms and a reduce-scatter outlier of 177.1 ms; main GEMMs were 367.2 + 351.1 + 194.6 + 151.7 + 91.1 ms and checkpoint backward 420.5 ms inclusive. Flash cross entropy was confirmed to save the full contiguous logits for backward, so avoiding that allocation would require recomputing/changing the returned-output contract rather than a local loss optimization. The N=23 OOM arithmetic instead showed roughly 0.25 GiB of true live-memory shortfall after counting free and cached-unallocated memory. - Live-cap experiment/tmp/r32/tree-live500changed onlystage3_max_live_parametersfrom 1e9 to 500M, leaving the abandoned reduce/prefetch bucket sizes atauto; isolated commit9461800. N=23 timing/tmp/r32/time-n23-live500/time_tree.json(PID 312620) ERRORED at step 10, now on a 250 MiB allocation with only 45.94 MiB free and 136.89 GiB allocated by PyTorch. The cap worsened residency by about 1.24 GiB, consistent with DeepSpeed's documented prefetch-skip release behavior. - Reuse-distance experiment/tmp/r32/tree-reuse500independently changed onlystage3_max_reuse_distanceto 500M; isolated commit32be005. N=23 timing/tmp/r32/time-n23-reuse500/time_tree.json(PID 314415) ERRORED at the same lm-head 1.88 GiB allocation, with the same 135.65 GiB allocated and 1.35 GiB free plus 785.7 MiB cached-unallocated. It did not reduce live memory. Neither variant produced a valid timing window, so no quick/full check was meaningful and nothing was promoted. - End: 2026-11-13 04:09 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches; upstream ZeRO residency settings remain unchanged.
9.5 hRound 33 — fine-grained attention retention
- Start: 2026-11-13 04:09 UTC; current-best profile/tmp/r33/profile, launcher PID 315886, log/tmp/r33/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2064 ms/step: the five main GEMM groups took 367.8 + 348.7 + 193.8 + 150.9 + 91.9 ms (55.9%), all-gather 201.7 ms (9.8%), reduce-scatter 161.2 ms (7.8%), and fused AdamW 55.9 ms (2.7%). The ten remaining reentrant checkpoints accounted for 421.6 ms inclusive in backward and 269.0 ms in forward, selecting selective recomputation as the hotspot. - Change in/tmp/r33/tree-partial-attention: opt-inLLAVA_RETAIN_ATTENTION_LAYERSkeeps input norm, attention and its residual outside the checkpoint for the layers immediately before the 22 fully retained layers, while still checkpointing post-attention norm, MLP and its residual. This changes only recomputation boundaries, not the real-valued layer graph (N1). Isolated commit86108d4; submission stayed unchanged. - Timing: one split layer/tmp/r33/time-partial1/time_tree.jsonwas valid at 1989.4 ms / 1.3854×, spread 0.0012, peak allocated 135.84 GiB; two split layers/tmp/r33/time-partial2/time_tree.jsonwere 1992.4 ms / 1.3833×, spread 0.0026, peak 136.89 GiB. The one-layer quick check/tmp/r33/quick-partial1/check.jsonPASSED, with no exact failures and judge-measured N1. - Full verdict:/tmp/r33/check-partial1/check.json, ERROR in gate 3. Its independent timing was 2001.1 ms / 1.3773× and both record cases completed with zero exact failures, but trajectory seed 0 OOMed at optimizer step 10 in DeepSpeed's linear backward while requesting 246 MiB. Rank 0 had 147.94 MiB free, 136.80 GiB allocated by PyTorch and 852.42 MiB reserved but unallocated (/tmp/r33/check-partial1/traj_s0.log). Thus the 25-step timing fixture did not cover this trajectory's peak-memory demand. No promotion; the timing gain is not a validated result. - End: 2026-11-13 04:33 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
9.7 hRound 34 — compiled attention-residual/post-RMSNorm fusion
- Start: 2026-11-13 04:34 UTC; current-best profile/tmp/r34/profile, launcher PID 331559, log/tmp/r34/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2020 ms/step: five main GEMM groups took 368.1 + 348.6 + 195.5 + 149.6 + 91.5 ms (57.2%), all-gather 213.0 ms (10.5%), reduce-scatter 107.7 ms (5.3%), and fused AdamW 56.0 ms (2.8%). Repeated RMSNorm kernels took 44.3 + 32.5 ms and residual-add kernels 30.1 + 5.7 ms; checkpoint backward was 420.4 ms inclusive. - Change in/tmp/r34/tree-add-rmsnorm: opt-inLLAVA_COMPILE_ADD_RMSNORM=1compiles the attention residual add together with the following post-attention RMSNorm. The RMSNorm module call remains outside the helper so ZeRO pre/post-forward hooks still gather and release its named weight. Cache, attention-output and extra-kwargs paths use the original decoder implementation; the MLP, attention and all other norms are unchanged (N1). Isolated commit9e8c8e2; submission stayed unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r34/time-add-rmsnorm/time_tree.json(PID 333203) was valid at 2011.8 ms / 1.3699×, spread 0.0161, peak allocated 134.78 GiB. Quick check/tmp/r34/quick-add-rmsnorm/check.json(PID 335033) PASSED with no exactness rejection. Repeat/tmp/r34/time-add-rmsnorm-repeat/time_tree.json(PID 338537) was 2014.0 ms / 1.3685×, spread 0.0206. Both are slower than the 1998.8 ms full-pass baseline, so no full check or promotion was justified; this fusion boundary is rejected. - End: 2026-11-13 04:50 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.
9.9 hRound 35 — isolate ZeRO prefetch bucket sizing
- Start: 2026-11-13 04:52 UTC; current-best profile/tmp/r35/profile, launcher PID 340420, log/tmp/r35/profile.log, status ok. GPU kernel time was 2009 ms/step. All-gather took 206.9 ms (10.3%) and reduce-scatter 104.1 ms (5.2%); the five main GEMM groups took 366.4 + 350.9 + 190.2 + 153.6 + 89.7 ms and checkpoint backward 421.2 ms inclusive.nvidia-smi topo -mshowed NV18 between the GPUs, making many gather operations/latency a more plausible target than link bandwidth. DeepSpeed's automatic persistence threshold is 100,000 elements and already covers small norm parameters. - Changes:/tmp/r35/tree-prefetch100andtree-prefetch200independently set onlystage3_prefetch_bucket_sizeto 100M or 200M elements. Unlike the abandoned earlier combined experiment,reduce_bucket_sizestaysauto; model/source and switches are unchanged. Both are N1 communication-scheduling experiments. Isolated commitsb3801f0and564dd77; submission stayed unchanged. - Timing: 100M/tmp/r35/time-prefetch100/time_tree.json(PID 342052) was valid at 2001.4 ms / 1.3771×, spread 0.0029; 200M/tmp/r35/time-prefetch200/time_tree.json(PID 343834) was 2002.0 ms / 1.3767×, spread 0.0069. Both retained 134.78 GiB peak allocated memory and neither beat the 1998.8 ms full-pass baseline. No quick/full check or promotion was justified; the automatic prefetch bucket remains. - End: 2026-11-13 04:59 UTC. Submission remains the/tmp/r20/check-n22-bf16logits1.3788× full-pass tree and switches.