GPT-6 Astrasuspected nerf 2.04×
Harness: Codex · switches: GS_OPT_FUSED_ADAM=1 GS_OPT_SKIP_UNUSED_DEPTH_GRAD=1 GS_OPT_DEFER_PROGRESS=1 GS_OPT_COMPILED_STATS=1 GS_OPT_SHARED_DEPTH=1 GS_OPT_BACKWARD_TILE_BOUNDS=1 GS_OPT_COMPILED_ACTIVATIONS=1 GS_OPT_WARP_BINNING=1 GS_OPT_FAST_EXP=1 GS_OPT_DENSE_ADAM=1 GS_OPT_SKIP_FORWARD_DEPTH=1 GS_OPT_RETAIN_CUDA_CACHE=1 GS_OPT_SHARED_COLOR=1 GS_OPT_BACKWARD_STAGED_STATE=1 GS_OPT_BACKWARD_FOLD_BACKGROUND=1 GS_OPT_TILE_SHAPE=8x8 GS_OPT_COMPACT_SORT=1
- Judged
- 2.04×
- Tier
- N1
- Self-best
- 2.07×
- Rounds
- 22
- Hours
- 10.0
- API cost
- $97.5
- Input tokens · 95.3% cached
- 44 M
- Output tokens
- 0.6 M
- Requests
- 386
§ 02Key levers
- Smaller tiles + rewritten binning
- ✓ only in round 20:
GS_OPT_TILE_SHAPE=8x8(keeps the 16×16 parent-tile coverage test, 166.2 → 161.2 s); round 21 compacted sort inputGS_OPT_COMPACT_SORT=1(161.2 → 150.5 s) - Bypass autograd, activations folded into raster kernel
- ✗ activations via torch.compile
GS_OPT_COMPILED_ACTIVATIONS=1(234.7 → 225.2 s; of the first two versions one errored, one only 1.08×) - Lazy Adam (update only visible Gaussians)
- ✗ dense Adam in Triton (211.9 → 196.4 s)
- Fused loss / SSIM
- ✗ not in the log
- Other main levers
- warp-cooperative binning for large rectangles (225.2 → 216.0 s), cooperative staging of backward pixel state (187.7 → 170.6 s), background term pre-folded, depth skipped, memory cache kept
§ ARaw trace
Raw work log34 sections
0.0 hRound 1 — baseline profiling and optimizer fast path
- Start: 2026-11-05T15:45:00Z (profile launch; actual GPU-lock time recorded in its log). - Unchanged-tree profile:/tmp/r1/profile; detached PID 2513, log/tmp/r1/profile.log. - Profile completed 15:46:25Z, status ok, GPU lock 15:45:23Z. At steps 7000–7019: rasterizer backward 32.78% CUDA self time (per-Gaussian rendering 27.19%), rasterizer forward 26.25% (render 16.62%), Adam about 26.06%, indexing 5.31%. Adam uses many separate foreach kernels, a memory/launch bottleneck with an existing fused fast path. - Experiment/tmp/r1/tree: opt-inGS_OPT_FUSED_ADAM=1selects PyTorch fused dense Adam, preserving all groups, float32 parameters/states, hyperparameters, steps, and hooks. Expected arithmetic tier N1. Default remains upstream foreach selection. No other changes. - Timing followed by quick validation launched 2026-11-05T15:48:14Z, detached PID 2780, log/tmp/r1/measure.log; outputs/tmp/r1/timeand/tmp/r1/quick. Submission still unchanged. - Timing:/tmp/r1/time/time.json, status ok, 263.921 seconds,speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.1789. Windows (steps 1–10000, 10000–20000, 20000–29999): 74.554 / 96.487 / 92.879 s. Peak allocated/reserved: 5.32 / 7.75 GiB. This exceeds the local benefit threshold. Windows cover different training phases and are not interchangeable steady-state replicates. - Quick check:/tmp/r1/quick/check.json, PASS, exact items identical for all 3000 steps. - End: 2026-11-05T15:55:05Z. Promoting fused Adam based on timing and exact-item evidence; full N1 check follows outside the round.
0.0 hFull validation after round 1
- Started 2026-11-05T15:56:02Z, detached PID 3616, log/tmp/r1/check.log, output/tmp/r1/check. - Completed 2026-11-05T16:07:57Z: PASS, tier N1. Benefit: 268.972 s, speedup 1.1568x; windows 78.035 / 97.008 / 93.929 s. All quick and full exact items and all four statistical endpoints passed. - Commit:25a0479. Full validation is outside round time.
0.4 hRound 2 — profile the accepted version
- Start: 2026-11-05T16:08:38Z. Submission remains the N1-passing fused-Adam version throughout experimentation. - Profiles at densification steps 7000–7019 and steady-state steps 20000–20019:/tmp/r2/profile,/tmp/r2/profile-late. Detached PID 4590, log/tmp/r2/profile.log. - Both profiles completed 16:12:39Z. GPU projection per 20 steps: 167.429 ms during densification and 175.595 ms late. Backward rasterization is 31.2% / 33.5%; forward rendering 19.1% / 20.2%; fused Adam 13.8% / 15.8%; backward preprocessing 5.8% / 6.7%; bin duplication 5.8% / 6.2%. Fused Adam kernels are present. No source changes before profiling. - Selected hotspot: backward per-Gaussian rendering, an existing configurable warp-parallel kernel currently launched at one warp/block. Classification: L2 launch configuration, not a new rendering algorithm. Each warp is independent; there are no block barriers in its loop. - Experiment/tmp/r2/tree:GS_OPT_BACKWARD_THREADSsupports 32 (original/default), 64, 128, 256. Only the block grouping changes. Input/output dtypes and within-warp arithmetic are unchanged; atomics can reorder (N1). Profile metadata reports 64 registers/thread, no shared memory, 50% estimated occupancy for the original 32-thread launch. Screening 128 and 64 threads first; a clear failure of both closes the direction. - Measurements launched 2026-11-05T16:14:10Z, detached PID 4926, log/tmp/r2/measure.log. Outputs:/tmp/r2/time128,/tmp/r2/quick128,/tmp/r2/time64,/tmp/r2/quick64. Submission remains the round-1 full-check winner. - Results: 128 threads/tmp/r2/time128/time.json: 265.462 s, speedup 1.1721x, windows 73.821 / 96.829 / 94.812 s;/tmp/r2/quick128/check.json: PASS exact items. 64 threads/tmp/r2/time64/time.json: 265.099 s, speedup 1.1737x, windows 74.938 / 96.723 / 93.438 s;/tmp/r2/quick64/check.json: PASS exact items. - End: 2026-11-05T16:27:59Z. Neither configuration improves on the 263.921-s round-1 screening, and both are within noise of its 268.972-s full-check timing. No clear gain; do not promote or spend a full check. Close the block-size direction without trying 256. Negative experiment committed in its detached worktree; submitted code and switches remain unchanged.
0.7 hRound 3 — accepted-version reprofile
- Start 2026-11-05T16:28:41Z; detached profile PID 6461, log/tmp/r3/profile.log, output/tmp/r3/profile. The accepted version is unchanged from the round-2 early/late profiles. - Profile completed 16:29:37Z: rasterizer backward 37.70% CUDA self time (per-Gaussian kernel 31.24%), forward 30.19% (render 19.09%), fused Adam 13.85%, indexing 6.09%. The unchanged-version late profile from round 2 gives the same ranking. The prior configuration experiment did not reveal an existing faster launch option. - Hotspot: per-Gaussian backward, specifically zero depth-gradient work. The recipe has no depth loss but autograd materializes an all-zero depth gradient, and the kernel still loads depth snapshots, shuffles depth values, performs depth-gradient arithmetic, and atomically adds zeros. - Isolated experiment/tmp/r3/tree,GS_OPT_SKIP_UNUSED_DEPTH_GRAD=1: disable unused-output gradient materialization and select a compile-time color-only backward specialization when the depth gradient is absent. Forward outputs are unchanged. Nonempty depth gradients use the original full kernel; depth-only losses explicitly materialize a zero color gradient. No dtype, schedule, optimizer, loss, visibility, or image formation changes. Expected N1 from reordered kernel arithmetic/atomics; judge decides acceptance. - Extension build started 2026-11-05T16:30:53Z, detached PID 6634, log/tmp/r3/build.log. Preparing correctness-only operator probes while it builds; no custom timing harness. - Extension build succeeded 16:33:01Z, cache/tmp/gs-ext/2b099444928b2f5c51a96ff8. - Probe/measurement queue started 2026-11-05T16:33:25Z, detached PID 7085, log/tmp/r3/measure.log. Correctness-only operator probe (with GPU lock):/tmp/r3/probe.py, log/tmp/r3/probe.log, results/tmp/r3/probe.json; compares forward outputs and all six parameter gradients plus viewspace gradients for color-only, depth-only, and combined losses on two real truck views, against a repeat-run atomic envelope. Then judge/tmp/r3/time,/tmp/r3/quick, and a candidate trace to confirm the specialized kernel is actually used. - Initial T1 probe stopped before any timing: forward color/depth were bitwise identical, but one color-only xyz comparison had relative L2 7.26e-6 versus 6.19e-7 for its single baseline repeat. Initial isotropic Gaussians also have essentially zero rotation gradients (relative errors about 1 in both baseline repeats and candidate). This is diagnostic, not a judge rejection; no judge gate or threshold has changed. Source review confirms the specialization only deletes operations multiplied by an absent, zero depth gradient. - Repeating the same probe with eight baseline repeats per case, frozen before the candidate run, to measure the atomic-accumulation envelope more reliably. The 3x envelope rule and 1e-6 floor remain unchanged; the original fixture and all tested losses remain unchanged. Initial failure retained in/tmp/r3/probe.log. - Revised diagnostic/measurement queue started 2026-11-05T16:35:08Z, detached PID 7195, log/tmp/r3/measure-2.log; diagnostic log/tmp/r3/probe-2.log, result/tmp/r3/probe-2.json. The failed queue started no judge timing or checks. - Repeated T1 probe:/tmp/r3/probe-2.json, all 6 cases pass the unchanged diagnostic rule; color and depth forward outputs bitwise identical. This covers all six parameter gradients and densification viewspace gradients, with unused-depth, active-depth, and depth-only losses. - Timing/tmp/r3/time/time.json: status ok, 255.909 s,speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.2158; windows 71.946 / 93.546 / 90.417 s. All three windows improve on round 1, total about 3.1% lower than its 263.921-s screen./tmp/r3/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. - End 2026-11-05T16:40:56Z. Candidate profile: 162.513 ms GPU projection/20 steps; color-only kernel 47.250 ms, 29.07%, exactly 20 calls (PerGaussianRenderCUDA<3u, false>), 62 registers/thread. Forward render 19.84%, fused Adam 14.05%. The specialization is actually used, and total kernel projection drops from 168.072 ms in the current-version profile. Commitc0c664f. Full check follows outside the round; submission remains the existing N1-passing fused-Adam tree until this candidate passes.
0.7 hFull validation after round 3
- Started 2026-11-05T16:42:30Z, detached PID 7807, log/tmp/r3/check.log, output/tmp/r3/check. Accepted submission was unchanged while validation ran. - Completed 2026-11-05T16:52:08Z: PASS N1, 256.263 s, speedup 1.2142x. Windows 72.098 / 93.673 / 90.493 s. Exact items passed in quick and full trajectories. Endpoint biases in frozen sigma units: PSNR -1.573, SSIM -1.388, LPIPS +0.192, log count +0.720, all within 3 sigma. Promoted to main commit59dbe1dwith both switches enabled.
1.1 hRound 4 — steady-step profile and host synchronization
- Start 2026-11-05T16:53:21Z, detached profile PID 8321, log/tmp/r4/profile.log, output/tmp/r4/profile. - Profiling the exact round-3 N1-passing source/config copy (same accepted source, cached extensions) at steps 7101–7120, away from densification events. Prior 7000-based windows included a scheduled densification; their large gather cost should be amortized at its actual 1/100 cadence, not 1/20. - Profile completed 16:54:15Z. Away from densification, backward/color-only kernel is 32.00% GPU time, forward render 20.41%, fused Adam 15.61%, backward preprocessing 6.50%, bin duplication 6.44%. CPU synchronization and event accounting identify the per-iteration loss.item()and unused timing events as removable scheduling barriers; their CPU wait times are not claimed as directly recoverable GPU time. - Isolated change/tmp/r4/tree, switchGS_OPT_DEFER_PROGRESS=1: batch detached loss scalars at the existing ten-step progress updates, then apply every EMA update on the CPU in the original order; omit unused CUDA timing events only on this no-TensorBoard path. TensorBoard explicitly falls back. All model operations, optimizer hooks/steps, camera order, loss arithmetic, and logging values are retained. Main submission stays at the full N1-passing round-3 version. - Baseline CPU attribution over 20 steady steps:aten::item20 calls / 58.330 ms inclusive;aten::nonzero20 calls / 30.477 ms;cudaStreamSynchronize40 calls / 87.156 ms;cudaEventElapsedTime20 calls. These overlap parent ranges and are not summed as independent costs. A CPU-only probe of 137 float32 loss scalars confirms exact EMA equality at every reporting point and the final partial batch. - Timing/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T16:56:06Z, detached PID 8557, log/tmp/r4/measure.log, outputs/tmp/r4/time,/tmp/r4/quick,/tmp/r4/profile-candidate. - Results:/tmp/r4/time/time.json, status ok, 249.291 s,speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.2481; windows 69.522 / 91.251 / 88.518 s. Each window improves on round 3 (255.909 s total)./tmp/r4/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. - End 2026-11-05T17:03:38Z. Candidate profiling confirms the synchronization changes. The optimization changes no model arithmetic. Full validation follows; the submission remains the round-3 N1-passing source until the new verdict.
1.1 hFull validation after round 4
- Started 2026-11-05T17:04:49Z, detached PID 9466, log/tmp/r4/check-and-profile.log, check output/tmp/r4/check. - Only if its JSON verdict is PASS, the queue profiles this new best version into/tmp/r5/profileat steps 7101–7120. That profile starts round 5; no round-5 source edits have been made. Full checks are outside round time, and the main submission remains at the prior passing version until the verdict. - Round-4 full check completed 2026-11-05T17:14:11Z: PASS N1, 249.161 s, speedup 1.2488x; windows 69.126 / 91.688 / 88.347 s. All exact items pass. Biases in sigma units: PSNR -0.597, SSIM +0.804, LPIPS -1.463, log count +0.755. Promoting deferred logging. - Its diagnostic profile removed all 20aten::itemand all 20cudaEventElapsedTimecalls. Stream synchronizations fall from 40 to 22 over 20 iterations; the remaining 20 visibilitynonzerocalls are the next scheduling target.
1.5 hRound 5 — compiled densification statistics and visibility synchronization
- Start/GPU lock: 2026-11-05T17:14:12Z; profile/tmp/r5/profilecompleted 17:15:04Z on the newly N1-passing round-4 source. No edits before this profile. Launch PID/log recorded in the prior queue. - Profile: backward kernel 31.87% GPU time, forward render 20.13%, fused Adam 16.18%, preprocessing 6.46%, bin duplication 6.41%. CPU visibilitynonzero: 20 calls / 29.962 ms; indexing 100 calls / 1.593 ms; index writes 60 calls / 0.809 ms; 22 stream synchronizations / 28.664 ms. Inclusive CPU waits are not independent GPU costs. - Isolated/tmp/r5/tree:GS_OPT_COMPILED_STATS=1uses a dynamic-shape, fullgraph Torch compiler fusion for the sameradii > 0max-radius, norm accumulation, and denominator updates. The renderer can omit its unused index list; the default public return is unchanged. Training schedules, norm dimensions, and all optimizer/parameter dtypes remain unchanged. Expected N1 reduction reordering. Compilation counters report unique graphs at exit; fallback is not silently permitted. - Build and correctness-only probe launched 2026-11-05T17:18:44Z: detached build PID 10196, log/tmp/r5/build.log; GPU-locked probe PID 10197, log/tmp/r5/probe.log, result/tmp/r5/probe.json. Probe covers float32 max radii/norm accumulation/counts at 1, 31, 128, 136029, and 2000003 Gaussians, including invisible radii. No local timing harness. - Build succeeded (cache/tmp/gs-ext/3b2334a0ef942473a63e5fa0). Probe/tmp/r5/probe.jsonpasses: radius maxima and observation counts exactly equal; norm-accumulation maximum absolute difference at production sizes 9.537e-7, within the fixed probe tolerances. Two compiled graphs across the probe shapes; full-training compilation counters will be checked independently. - Judge timing/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-05T17:21:45Z, detached PID 10810, log/tmp/r5/measure.log; outputs/tmp/r5/time,/tmp/r5/quick, and/tmp/r5/profile-candidate. Submitted source remains the round-4 full-check winner. - Initial screen/tmp/r5/time/time.json: 241.913 s, speedup 1.2862x; windows 67.027 / 89.467 / 85.419 s./tmp/r5/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. Startup to first step 8.3 s (including initial compilation), outside timed windows. - The candidate trace verifies the fused statistics kernel, but the run exit did not emit the registeredatexitdiagnostics. Replacing the exit-only logger with an immediate report when the compiler graph count changes; model/statistics arithmetic is unchanged. Repeatingtimeon this final diagnostic implementation instead of claiming evidence for untimed code. - Confirmation launched 2026-11-05T17:28:46Z, detached PID 11622, log/tmp/r5/confirm.log; outputs/tmp/r5/time-confirmand/tmp/r5/quick-confirm. - Confirmed final implementation:/tmp/r5/time-confirm/time.json, 239.017 s,speedup_vs_frozen_reference=1.3018; windows 65.967 / 88.268 / 84.782 s./tmp/r5/quick-confirm/check.json: PASS exact items. This confirms the initial 241.913-s screen rather than relying on a single timing. - Compiler diagnostics in both the complete timing and quick record report exactly one graph, captured on the first iteration before timed step 1 ends; no further graph reports occur over the changing Gaussian counts. No recompilations or silent fallback. Candidate profile: 20 fused statistics kernel calls (0.314 ms total); nononzero,index, orindex_put_calls in steady steps; only two stream synchronizations per 20 steps instead of 22. GPU projection 149.014 ms/20 steps. - End 2026-11-05T17:33:19Z. Current submission remains the round-4 full N1 winner while the new full validation runs.
1.5 hFull validation after round 5
- Started 2026-11-05T17:34:45Z, detached PID 12216, log/tmp/r5/check.log, output/tmp/r5/check. This validation is outside round time; the main submission remains the prior passing version until the verdict. - Full check completed 2026-11-05T17:43:51Z: PASS N1, 238.264 s, speedup 1.3059x. Windows 65.649 / 87.678 / 84.937 s. All quick and full exact items pass. Endpoint biases in sigma units: PSNR -0.494, SSIM +0.669, LPIPS -2.243, log count +0.723, all within 3 sigma. Promoted compiled statistics to the submitted tree.
2.0 hRound 6 — remaining rasterizer work
- Started 2026-11-05T17:44:45Z, profile detached PID 13167, log/tmp/r6/profile.log, output/tmp/r6/profile. Profiling the identical just-promoted N1-passing source/config copy to reuse its extension cache. - Profile completed 17:45:41Z: backward kernel 32.09% GPU time, forward render 20.49%, fused Adam 16.39%, preprocessing 6.52%, bin duplication 6.50%. Forward rendering uses 32 registers/thread, 7212 bytes shared memory, and 100% estimated occupancy. - Selected hotspot: the forward per-pixel depth reciprocal, invariant for a Gaussian within its tile. L3 common-subexpression hoisting in the existing accelerated rasterizer, not a new image-formation model. There is no existing switch for this reuse. - Isolated/tmp/r6/tree,GS_OPT_SHARED_DEPTH=1: compute the same float321.f / depthonce per Gaussian batch entry, synchronize using the existing block barrier, and reuse it from shared memory. Color and depth remain computed with all original thresholds, ordering, and formulas; no approximate reciprocal. The submission remains the complete round-5 full-check winner, main commit52e52a6. - Extension build launched 2026-11-05T17:49:22Z, detached PID 13487, log/tmp/r6/build.log. Correctness probe preparation is CPU-only while the build runs. - Build succeeded, cache/tmp/gs-ext/140685c53076963632fae3f8. Probe/timing/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-05T17:53:42Z, detached PID 13975, log/tmp/r6/measure.log; probe log/tmp/r6/probe.log, result/tmp/r6/probe.json; judge outputs/tmp/r6/time,/tmp/r6/quick,/tmp/r6/profile-candidate. - The correctness probe uses two real truck cameras, anisotropic scales and nontrivial rotations, color-only/depth-only/combined losses, every Gaussian parameter gradient plus viewspace gradients, and eight baseline repeats per case. It compares both forward images and both active/inactive depth-gradient paths. This is diagnostic only, never a speed measurement. - Shared-depth T1:/tmp/r6/probe.json, all six cases pass. Both forward color and depth images are bitwise identical; all seven gradient comparisons are inside the eight-repeat atomic envelope. - Initial judge screen/tmp/r6/time/time.json: 236.918 s, speedup 1.3133x; windows 64.661 / 88.279 / 83.978 s./tmp/r6/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. Incremental gain over the latest 238.264-s full timing is small and not yet established. - Profile verifies exactly 20 shared-depth forward calls: 28.011 ms vs the prior 30.694 ms, with the same 32 registers/thread and 100% estimated occupancy; shared memory increases from 7212 to 8236 bytes. Backward is 48.427 vs 48.081 ms. This local profile supports the hypothesis but is not a speed verdict. - Re-time the actual accepted round-5 source as a control before deciding whether the small incremental gain merits a full check. Keep the submission unchanged. - Accepted-version control started 2026-11-05T18:06:05Z, detached PID 14876, log/tmp/r6/control-time.log, output/tmp/r6/control-time. - Accepted-version control/tmp/r6/control-time/time.json: 239.423 s, speedup 1.2995x; windows 66.290 / 87.798 / 85.335 s. Shared-depth screen is about 1.05% faster overall but has a small middle-window regression, so the incremental benefit remains modest. The full check supplies a second candidate timing and N1 validation; do not promote a regression. - End 2026-11-05T18:10:15Z (under 30 minutes from the profile GPU lock). The current submission remains the full N1-passing round-5 version.
2.0 hFull validation after round 6
- Started 2026-11-05T18:14:11Z, detached PID 15262, log/tmp/r6/check.log, output/tmp/r6/check. Main remains at round 5 while this runs. Full-check time is outside the round. - CPU-only preparation for a possible future backward bound:/tmp/r7/BOUNDS_DESIGN.mdand/tmp/r7/bounds_probe.py. This is not a source change or a selected new round yet. Detached probe PID 15938, log/tmp/r7/bounds_probe.log; it waits for the full check to leave timing before running a million-matrix numerical safety probe, to avoid contaminating performance. Any implementation must first reprofile the current best and pass the judge.
2.0 hRound 6 validation outcome
- Full check completed 2026-11-05T18:23Z:/tmp/r6/check/check.json, PASS N1, 236.836 s, speedup 1.3137x; windows 65.558 / 87.144 / 84.134 s. All exact items pass; endpoint biases are PSNR +0.004 sigma, SSIM -0.113 sigma, LPIPS -1.706 sigma, log count +0.321 sigma. - Both shared-depth timings (236.918 / 236.836 s) beat the accepted-version control (239.423 s). The full-check timing also improves all three control windows. Promoted candidate commit03b745bto the submission, enablingGS_OPT_SHARED_DEPTH=1alongside the prior switches. - CPU-only possible backward-bound safety study completed:/tmp/r7/bounds_probe.json, one million matrices, 364176 eligible, 187745 rejected samples, zero false rejections; minimum alpha margin under the conservative rounding allowance 1.60955e-7. This is not yet evidence for a CUDA implementation.
2.7 hRound 7 — backward work rejection investigation
- Start 2026-11-05T18:24:28Z. Submission is the fully N1-passing round-6 version. First profile launch was cancelled because the preceding cherry-pick ran from the judge directory rather than the repo; no measurement from it is used. Cherry-pick rerun in the correct repo. - Fresh profile of the promoted winner:/tmp/r7/profile-best, detached PID 16377, log/tmp/r7/profile-best.log; no round-7 source changes yet. - Profile completed 2026-11-05T18:27:15Z. Backward per-Gaussian kernel: 48.191 ms/20 calls, 33.13% GPU time; shared-depth forward: 27.844 ms, 19.14%; fused Adam 16.37%; backward preprocessing and bin duplication each 6.67%. All previous fast paths are present. Selected hotspot: unnecessary backward exponent evaluations, a genuinely new L3/L4 kernel opportunity after launch-size tuning failed. - Isolated candidate/tmp/r7/tree,GS_OPT_BACKWARD_BOUNDS=1: padded conic axis bounds exclude only pixels below the original alpha cutoff, after the original float32 coordinate subtraction. Entire warps may exit when all Gaussians miss the tile; individual lanes never exit the relay loop early. Double-precision auxiliary construction, guarded condition number, conservative rounding slack, and infinite-bound fallback preserve the original image/gradient function. Main remains the round-6 full-check winner. - Extension build launched 2026-11-05T18:28Z, detached PID 17116, log/tmp/r7/build.log. Preparing operator probes while it builds; no custom timing scripts. Saved full-check parameter payloads are cleaned by the judge, so the operator probe uses the real initial scene plus a separate anisotropy/near-cutoff stress fixture, not a trained-model checkpoint. - Build succeeded: cache/tmp/gs-ext/44f88350df26ed3e15094723. Probe/timing/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-05T18:30:56Z, detached PID 17612, log/tmp/r7/measure.log. Probe results/tmp/r7/probe.jsonand/tmp/r7/probe-stress.json; measurements/tmp/r7/time,/tmp/r7/quick,/tmp/r7/profile-candidate. Main stays at the validated round-6 version. - Pixel-bound results: both operator fixtures pass (12 camera/loss cases; color and depth bitwise identical; all parameter/viewspace gradients within the eight-repeat atomic envelope)./tmp/r7/time/time.json: 236.200 s, speedup 1.3173x, windows 65.087 / 86.695 / 84.418 s./tmp/r7/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. Kernel profile worsens from 48.191 to 49.487 ms/20 steps despite 64 registers, no spills and unchanged occupancy; the 0.27% end-to-end improvement is too small to establish a gain. Do not promote it. - One bounded follow-up in the same hotspot: reject only complete Gaussian/tile intersections and skip their zero atomics, avoiding two bounds comparisons on every pixel. Individual lanes still relay pixel state. Separate switchGS_OPT_BACKWARD_TILE_BOUNDS=1and config/tmp/r7/coarse.json; the pixel-bound variant is preserved in its experimental commit. - Extension-cache discovery: the judge build key includes environment overrides as well as sources; subsequent explicit builds usebuild --configwith the measurement config to avoid compiling identical sources twice. - Tile-only extension build started 2026-11-05T18:40:39Z, detached PID 19009, log/tmp/r7/build-coarse.log. - Tile-only build succeeded at cache/tmp/gs-ext/865202cf54ff6bc6bb23ea80. Probe/timing/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-05T18:43:00Z, detached PID 19473, log/tmp/r7/measure-coarse.log; results use the-coarsesuffix. Main remains unchanged. - Tile-only results: both real-scene operator probes pass (12 camera/loss cases, both outputs bitwise identical, all gradients inside the repeat envelope), and/tmp/r7/quick-coarse/check.jsonpasses exact items./tmp/r7/time-coarse/time.json: 234.663 s, speedup 1.3259x, windows 64.619 / 86.185 / 83.859 s, all faster than the round-6 full check. Kernel uses 62 registers with no spills. Its 7101-step profile is 48.641 ms vs 48.191 ms for the original, so it does not establish a local kernel gain; the full check supplies a second complete timing and N1 verdict before any promotion. - Round end 2026-11-05T18:49:55Z, less than 30 minutes from the 18:26:24 GPU lock. The submitted winner remains at round 6.
2.7 hFull validation after round 7
- Started 2026-11-05T18:49:55Z, detached PID 20426, log/tmp/r7/check.log, output/tmp/r7/check. Main remains unchanged; this validation is outside the round.
2.7 hRound 7 validation outcome
-/tmp/r7/check/check.json: PASS N1, 234.814 s, speedup 1.3251x; windows 64.393 / 86.383 / 84.038 s. Exact items match, and endpoint biases are PSNR -1.206 sigma, SSIM +0.092 sigma, LPIPS -2.256 sigma, log count -0.019 sigma. - Both complete candidate timings (234.663 / 234.814 s) improve on both round-6 timings (236.918 / 236.836 s); the second timing also improves each prior full-check window. Promoted the tile-only variant, enablingGS_OPT_BACKWARD_TILE_BOUNDS=1. Per-pixel bounds are not present in the final code.
3.2 hRound 8 — accepted-version late profile
- Started 2026-11-05T18:59:46Z, detached PID 21253, log/tmp/r8/profile.log, output/tmp/r8/profile. Profile Gaussian steps 20001–20020, after densification ends, to complement the recent early steady-state profile. No source changes yet. - Late profile: backward render 53.284 ms/20 calls (32.00%), forward render 32.170 ms (19.32%), fused Adam 17.19%, backward preprocessing 7.03%, bin duplication 6.62%. A missed compiler fast path remains in Gaussian activation backward: division 2.739 ms, normalization backward 1.750 ms (2.219 ms including surrounding work), broadcast-gradient reduction 1.137 ms, plus 1.180 ms forward norm. These memory-bound chains account for at least 4% of GPU time and execute every step in both phases. - Selected round-8 hotspot: the scale/quaternion/opacity activation region, particularly quaternion normalization backward. L0/L3 dynamictorch.compilereplaces the same PyTorch function chain, with no manual derivative or changed normalization epsilon. SeparateGS_OPT_COMPILED_ACTIVATIONS=1in/tmp/r8/activations.json; experiment/tmp/r8/tree. Nonstandard activation functions and Python covariance retain their original path and report/count fallback. Main remains the full N1-passing round-7 version. - Extension-cache preparation started 2026-11-05T19:06:13Z, detached PID 21962, log/tmp/r8/build.log. CUDA sources are unchanged this round; the new environment switch requires its own judge cache. - Correctness-only activation probe launched 2026-11-05T19:07:32Z, detached PID 22352 with GPU lock, log/tmp/r8/activation_probe.log, results/tmp/r8/activation_probe.json. Covers point counts 31, 257, 136029 and 2030000, all three outputs and gradients, zero/tiny quaternions and the normalization epsilon boundary. Forward tolerance 1e-6 relative/1e-7 absolute; gradient relative-L2 bound 1e-6. No timing is performed. - Activation probe passes all four point counts with one dynamic compiled graph. Worst forward relative-L2 error 6.75e-8, worst gradient error 1.58e-7; zero/tiny quaternions and the epsilon boundary remain finite. Extension cache/tmp/gs-ext/3e9e2a758b409dd23ea2f86cbuilds successfully. - Judge time/quick/late-profile queue started 2026-11-05T19:09:50Z, detached PID 22636, log/tmp/r8/measure.log; outputs/tmp/r8/time,/tmp/r8/quick,/tmp/r8/profile-candidate. Main remains at the round-7 full-check winner. - First time attempt/tmp/r8/time/time.json: ERROR after 1300 steps, not a speed result. Dynamo forcesnn.Parametershapes static despitedynamic=True; the opacity point-count guard recompiles at every densification and hits the unchanged eight-recompile limit. The tensor-only operator fixture did not expose the parameter-class guard. No gate is relaxed and no failed version is promoted. - Root fix: pass zero-copy differentiable views of the three parameters into the compiled region, so dynamic tensor-shape guards apply while autograd still reaches the original parameters. Extended the operator fixture to nine changingnn.Parametersizes, explicitly requiring exactly one compiled graph. The recompile limit is not changed. Retest in new output directories. - Dynamic-parameter probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T19:13:00Z, detached PID 24207, log/tmp/r8/measure-dynamic.log; result files use the-dynamicsuffix. Submission remains unchanged. - Dynamic-view run/tmp/r8/time-dynamic/time.jsoncompletes, 287.745 s / 1.0813x, windows 77.168 / 106.165 / 104.412 s: a major regression, not promoted./tmp/r8/quick-dynamic/check.jsonpasses exact items. The nine-Parameter-size probe passes with one graph, and full training shows only one activation graph plus one statistics graph, with no recompiles. - Candidate profile identifies the regression: generic dynamic-width norm forward/backward reductions each cost about 24.8 ms/20 calls, versus the original short normalization chains. This is now an L2 compiler-specialization problem, not compilation overhead. A final bounded round-8 attempt marks only the fixed quaternion component dimension static; the changing point dimension remains dynamic. No normalization formula or gradient is changed. - Static-width follow-up started 2026-11-05T19:23:34Z, detached PID 25507, log/tmp/r8/measure-static-width.log; outputs use-static-width. Submission remains at the round-7 full N1 winner. - Static-width results: nine-Parameter-size probe passes with one graph (/tmp/r8/activation_probe-static-width.json);/tmp/r8/quick-static-width/check.jsonpasses exact items./tmp/r8/time-static-width/time.json: 225.959 s, speedup 1.3770x; windows 62.437 / 82.937 / 80.584 s, all better than the accepted version. Full training reports one activation graph and one statistics graph, with no recompiles. - Profile confirms the fixed-width specialization replaces the expensive generic reductions: complete compiled activation backward is 1.486 ms/20 calls at step 7101 (the earlier generic late kernel alone was 24.802 ms). The replacement is now pointwise rather than a dynamic-width reduction; exactly 20 compiled forward/backward calls remain. - Round end 2026-11-05T19:30:02Z, under 30 minutes from the 19:01:42 GPU lock. Both the failed shape-static prototype and the generic-width regression are logged and committed only in the experiment. Main stays at round 7 until full validation passes.
3.2 hFull validation after round 8
- Started 2026-11-05T19:30:02Z, detached PID 27010, log/tmp/r8/check.log, output/tmp/r8/check. Full-check time is outside the round; main is unchanged.
3.2 hRound 8 validation outcome
-/tmp/r8/check/check.json: PASS N1. Endpoint biases: PSNR -0.766 sigma, SSIM +0.163 sigma, LPIPS -0.453 sigma, log count +0.056 sigma; all exact items match. - Full-check timing is 234.141 s / 1.3289x, windows 62.266 / 91.651 / 80.224 s. The first and last windows reproduce the 225.959-s screen, but the middle window is 8.714 s slower. Compilation diagnostics still show only the two expected graphs. This isolated performance anomaly needs a clean re-time before claiming the larger gain or promotion; the submitted tree remains at round 7. - Operational cache finding: the main tree contains an ignored.vscodedirectory inside the rasterizer, absent from detached worktrees. The judge includes that directory in its extension digest, explaining redundant post-promotion builds. Do not remove the user editor configuration; use the validated worktree for profiling, and preserve this directory in future experiment copies when practical.
3.9 hRound 9 — clean timing audit and densification profile
- Started 2026-11-05T19:41:47Z, detached PID 28376, log/tmp/r9/audit.log; outputs/tmp/r9/profileand/tmp/r9/control-time. - Profile the N1-passing activation candidate at steps 7000–7019, including the actual densification event, then re-time it with no simultaneous local analysis commands. No source changes yet. Main stays unchanged pending the timing confirmation. - Clean activation confirmation/tmp/r9/control-time/time.json: 225.200 s / 1.3816x, windows 62.244 / 82.823 / 80.133 s. This reproduces the 225.959-s screen and confirms the prior middle-window anomaly is not a repeatable regression. The full N1-passing activation change is promoted; its current source includes both dynamic parameter views and the static quaternion-width annotation. - Densification profile/tmp/r9/profile: backward render 31.04% GPU time, forward 19.61%, fused Adam 15.20%; one densification event introduces 60aten::indexcalls (9.328 ms self CUDA, 6.08% of this 20-step window), 60aten::nonzerocalls and 65 stream synchronizations. Runtime-trace CPU totals: index 12.774 ms, nonzero 11.825 ms (nested, not additive), stream sync 9.287 ms. Allocator costs are smaller (five mallocs 1.247 ms, five frees 0.918 ms). - Selected hotspot: repeated Boolean-mask scans and generic gathers during densification/pruning, an existingindex_selectfast path not used by the source (L1/L3). This event occurs every 100 steps, so its true full-run budget is much smaller than the profile-window share./tmp/r9/treeunderGS_OPT_DENSIFY_INDEX_SELECT=1reuses each ordered index list and the known split-sample row count, preserving all selections and random draws. The submission remains the fully N1-passing activation version. - Cache build started 2026-11-05T19:52:22Z, detached PID 29306, log/tmp/r9/build.log; the candidate preserves the ignored rasterizer editor directory, so promotion can reuse this extension digest. - Selection correctness probe started 2026-11-05T19:53:37Z, detached PID 29638 with GPU lock, log/tmp/r9/selection_probe.log, result/tmp/r9/selection_probe.json. Six cases cover empty/partial/full pruning, cloning, splitting and combined densification, requiring bitwise equality for all parameters, Adam state, statistics, radii and the final CUDA RNG state. This probe performs no timing. - All six selection probes pass bitwise equality, including final CUDA RNG state. Extension cache/tmp/gs-ext/e22cefdd3c940c511ddaedbfbuilds successfully. - Judge time/quick/densification-profile queue started 2026-11-05T19:54:53Z, detached PID 29819, log/tmp/r9/measure.log, outputs/tmp/r9/time,/tmp/r9/quick,/tmp/r9/profile-candidate. No simultaneous local analysis commands during the timing. - Selection result/tmp/r9/time/time.json: 224.772 s / 1.3843x, windows 61.963 / 82.625 / 80.184 s;/tmp/r9/quick/check.jsonpasses exact items. The gain over the immediately preceding 225.200-s control is only 0.19%, below a convincing incremental improvement. Profile shows index-selection CUDA cost 8.522 ms versus prior advanced indexing 9.328 ms; the large gathers still dominate this infrequent event. Do not spend a full check or promote this small, uncertain gain. - End 2026-11-05T20:04:50Z, under 30 minutes from the 19:41:48 GPU lock. Experimental selection changes are committed only in/tmp/r9/tree; the submission remains ate807589, the N1-passing activation version.
4.3 hRound 10 — accepted-version steady profile
- Started 2026-11-05T20:04:50Z, detached PID 31152, log/tmp/r10/profile.log, output/tmp/r10/profile. Uses the runtime-identical validated round-8 worktree to reuse its extension cache. No source changes yet. - Profile completes 20:05:43Z: backward render 34.33% GPU time, forward render 19.60%, fused Adam 17.42%, key duplication 6.99% (9.874 ms/20 calls), backward preprocessing 6.89%, radix sorting 3.27%. The duplicate kernel performs a variable serial tile loop per Gaussian; upstream already performs tile culling, so do not replace or weaken that predicate. - Selected hotspot: serial large-rectangle binning, a new L4 work-mapping opportunity./tmp/r10/tree,GS_OPT_WARP_BINNING=1: the original kernel handles rectangles of at most 32 tiles and enqueues larger ones; a warp cooperatively processes each large rectangle using the identical culling helper, row-major ballot compaction, original output offsets and original sentinel keys. The number of sort entries, tile selection and depth ordering remain unchanged. No new host synchronization or changed rendering thresholds. - A patch-anchor typo initially interrupted the isolated edit after adding two internal geometry pointers; repaired before build. The submitted tree was never affected. - Warp-binning build started 2026-11-05T20:09:48Z, detached PID 31648, log/tmp/r10/build.log. Main remains at the complete round-8 N1-passing version. - Build/probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T20:11:53Z, detached PID 32080, log/tmp/r10/measure.log. Probes compare both forward images bitwise and all gradients against eight-repeat atomic envelopes, on two real cameras with ordinary and anisotropic/near-cutoff fixtures, including color-only, depth-only and combined losses. They enable all accepted renderer optimizations. Outputs/tmp/r10/probe.json,/tmp/r10/probe-stress.json,/tmp/r10/time,/tmp/r10/quick,/tmp/r10/profile-candidate. No concurrent local analysis during timing. - Initial build succeeds (/tmp/gs-ext/0e295de1cbc6651385be9f91); light kernels use 53 registers, warp kernel 45, no spills. The ordinary operator probe has bitwise-equal forward color/depth and passes the color-only and depth-only gradient cases, but combined-loss viewspace gradients exceed its sampled atomic envelope: relative L2 2.2153e-5 versus 3 x 4.8041e-6. This diagnostic failure is retained; its threshold is not relaxed, and no timing or judge gate has run yet. - Investigation: add exact intermediate key/value verification under the existing renderer debug flag, comparing every unsorted slot with the original duplicate kernel before sorting. A separate deterministic probe will check both fixtures and all modes. This isolates binning correctness from the unchanged backward atomic accumulation instead of treating the sampled gradient envelope as a verdict; the judge remains the only N1 authority. - Deterministic-debug build started 2026-11-05T20:16:26Z, detached PID 32292, log/tmp/r10/build-verified.log. Main remains unchanged. - Intermediate-verification/probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T20:17:51Z, detached PID 32706, log/tmp/r10/measure-verified.log.keys_probe.pyis a separate exact intermediate/output test, not a replacement or loosening of the failed gradient-envelope probe, which remains unchanged. It validates every binning key/value slot through the existing debug mode and both complete forward images. If these pass, the judge supplies the exact-item and eventual N1 verdict; no N1 claim is based on the diagnostic alone. - Deterministic intermediate probes pass all 12 camera/loss/fixture cases: every unsorted key/value slot equals the original kernel (including sentinels), and color and depth images are bitwise identical. This establishes that the new binning mapping preserves the renderer inputs; the earlier sampled backward-atomic diagnostic remains logged, not reclassified as a pass. -/tmp/r10/time-verified/time.json: 216.004 s / 1.4404x, windows 58.944 / 80.165 / 76.894 s, improving all three accepted-version control windows./tmp/r10/quick-verified/check.json: PASS exact items. Full N1 validation is required before promotion. - Round end 2026-11-05T20:25:31Z, under 30 minutes from the 20:04:51 GPU lock. The submission remains the complete round-8 winner.
4.3 hFull validation after round 10
- Started 2026-11-05T20:25:31Z, detached PID 34410, log/tmp/r10/check.log, output/tmp/r10/check. Full-check time is outside the round. No simultaneous local analysis commands during this validation.
4.3 hRound 10 validation outcome
- /tmp/r10/check/check.json: PASS N1, 219.652 s / 1.4165x; windows 63.325 / 79.465 / 76.862 s. All exact items match. Endpoint biases: PSNR -0.423 sigma, SSIM -1.626 sigma, LPIPS +0.866 sigma, log count +0.304 sigma.
- The screening timing is 216.004 s / 1.4404x, and the complete check still improves substantially on the 225.200-s accepted-version control. The profiled binning cost falls from 9.874 to 1.997 + 0.594 ms per 20 steps. The judge accepts the arithmetic/model equivalence despite the earlier sampled viewspace-gradient atomic outlier; exact intermediate and image probes establish unchanged binning results. Promoted warp binning and its existing-debug-mode key validation.4.9 hRound 11 — profile the accepted warp-binning version
- Started 2026-11-05T20:36:33Z, detached PID 35735, log/tmp/r11/profile.log, output/tmp/r11/profile. The preserved editor files allow this profile to reuse the candidate extension cache. No source changes yet. - Round 11 in progress: the fresh winner profile reports backward render 48.567 ms/20 steps (36.16%), forward render 27.794 ms (20.69%), fused Adam 18.39%, backward preprocessing 9.767 ms (7.27%), and sort 4.623 ms (3.44%). Selected class: SFU arithmetic in the coupled alpha calculation, behindGS_OPT_FAST_EXP, only in/tmp/r11/tree; the submitted winner stays unchanged. - Round-11 extension build started 2026-11-05T20:43:32Z, detached PID 36290, log/tmp/r11/build.log. The separate fast-exp probe reports forward/gradient differences (rather than demanding bitwise arithmetic) and checks finiteness; its output explicitly says diagnostic only. The previous binning probe is untouched. - Probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T20:44:38Z, detached PID 36632, log/tmp/r11/measure.log; it waits for the build, then runs the two GPU-locked fixture probes before judge outputs/tmp/r11/time,/tmp/r11/quick, and/tmp/r11/profile-candidate. No concurrent local work during timing. - CUDA 12.8's official programming-guide accuracy table (retrieved into/tmp/r11/cuda-guide.html) states the__expf(x)maximum error is2 + floor(abs(1.173 * x))ULP. This is not a bitwise candidate; image/gradient diagnostics and the judge's N1 gate are required. No global fast-math flag, changed thresholds, or changed parameter/state dtype. - Fast-exp build succeeds, cache/tmp/gs-ext/fd25bc500ce0caaa0211e097. Twelve camera/loss/fixture diagnostic cases have finite outputs/gradients; max forward relative L2 is 8.32e-8, max gradient relative L2 3.12e-5, all within the recorded eight-repeat backward atomic envelopes. Forward is not bitwise./tmp/r11/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. - Initial/tmp/r11/time/time.json: 219.280 s / 1.4189x, windows 58.506 / 85.639 / 75.135 s. This does not establish a total gain over the 216.004-s winner screen; its middle window is slower while early/late improve. The judge profile reports backward 47.405 vs 48.567 ms/20 and forward 27.090 vs 27.794 ms/20. A current-winner control and candidate re-time will distinguish small gains from noise; no promotion yet. - Control/candidate re-time queue started 2026-11-05T20:51:50Z, detached PID 38369, log/tmp/r11/retime.log, outputs/tmp/r11/control-timeand/tmp/r11/time-repeat. Local work pauses during both timed runs. - Control/tmp/r11/control-time/time.json: 215.521 s / 1.4437x. Candidate repeat/tmp/r11/time-repeat/time.json: 211.887 s / 1.4684x, an incremental 1.69% reduction. The repeated screen and the corresponding kernel-profile improvement justify a full check, but do not yet establish N1. The slower initial timing remains logged; it is not used as evidence for a gain. - End 2026-11-05T21:00Z, within 30 minutes of the 20:36:34 GPU lock. Candidate source will be committed in its isolated worktree; main remains the full N1-passing warp-binning winner until validation succeeds. - Round-11 full check started 2026-11-05T21:00:17Z, detached PID 39300, log/tmp/r11/check.log, output/tmp/r11/check. It is outside the round; no candidate source or switches are promoted while it runs. - Full check completed 2026-11-05T21:08:37Z:/tmp/r11/check/check.json, PASS N1, 212.997 s / 1.4608x; windows 59.332 / 78.101 / 75.564 s. Endpoint biases are PSNR +0.188 sigma, SSIM +1.138 sigma, LPIPS -1.505 sigma, and log count +0.483 sigma. The clean repeated screen windows were 58.256 / 78.089 / 75.541 s, all faster than the immediate 59.689 / 79.180 / 76.651-s control. - Promoted as2231815, enablingGS_OPT_FAST_EXP=1. A first switch patch missed the one-line JSON formatting and made no change; the subsequent exact patch updates the file. No partial CUDA implementation was submitted.
5.6 hRound 12 — dense optimizer fusion
- Corrected-probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T21:15:14Z, detached PID 41603, log/tmp/r12/measure.log; probe log/tmp/r12/probe-retry.log; judge outputs/tmp/r12/time,/tmp/r12/quick,/tmp/r12/profile-candidate. Local analysis stops while measurements run. - Optimizer probe launched 2026-11-05T21:14:36Z, detached PID 41458, log/tmp/r12/probe.log, result/tmp/r12/probe.json; it holds the GPU lock. No timing is done by this probe. - First probe stopped at a test-only import error:torch.optim.optimizeris not exposed as an attribute in this environment. The probe now importsregister_optimizer_step_post_hookdirectly from its module, as its implementation requires. No optimizer comparison had run yet, and its tolerance is unchanged. - Round-12 profile: backward 47.530 ms/20 (35.81%), forward 26.973 ms (20.32%), fused Adam 24.180 ms (18.22%; 180 kernels), backward preprocessing 9.739 ms (7.34%), sort 4.624 ms (3.48%). Selected hotspot is dense optimizer memory/arithmetic, not the rasterizer. The installed PyTorch fused kernel uses double hyperparameters in its elementwise expressions; a float32 fused kernel can remove that arithmetic and metadata overhead while preserving ordinary dense Adam. - Candidate/tmp/r12/tree,GS_OPT_DENSE_ADAM=1, uses a Triton dense update, upstream CPU float32 step states and bias correction, and float32 parameters/moments. It handles missing gradients as upstream, uses functional Adam as a counted guarded fallback, and retains the outer optimizer post-hook. Precise square root/divisions and explicit moment rounding are used; this is an N1 candidate, not a bitwise claim. - Extension build started 2026-11-05T21:13:29Z, detached PID 41133, log/tmp/r12/build.log. The independent optimizer probe compares 32 updates against ordinary PyTorch Adam for parameters and both moments, covers tiny/large/zero sizes, missing gradients, late step counts, moment resets, state-dict reloads, numpy learning rates and fallback layouts/options, and asserts one global post-hook per call. Its relative-L2 threshold is fixed at 2e-6 before results. - Round 12 starts 2026-11-05T21:10:04Z with the accepted-version profile, detached PID 40648, log/tmp/r12/profile.log, output/tmp/r12/profile. No new source changes yet. - Ten optimizer probe cases pass: maximum parameter relative L2 1.78e-8, first-moment error zero, second-moment relative L2 9.58e-8; unsupported layouts/options match the functional reference exactly. Each optimizer call invokes the global post-hook once, including missing-gradient steps. Probe import failure is preserved in the original log; no numerical threshold was changed. -/tmp/r12/time/time.json: 196.407 s / 1.5842x, windows 53.714 / 72.690 / 70.003 s, versus the accepted full check's 59.332 / 78.101 / 75.564 s./tmp/r12/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. The candidate profile has 120 dense kernels totaling 14.191 ms/20 steps versus the original fused Adam's 24.180 ms and 180 kernels; all six groups use the fast kernel in the steady profile. A guarded fallback appears during startup and is not permanent; the full run includes that fallback's cost. - End 2026-11-05T21:22Z, within 30 minutes of the 21:10:05 GPU lock. Isolated candidate commitf8f14ef; the main submission stays at the accepted intrinsic-exp version until the full check succeeds. - Round-12 full check started 2026-11-05T21:22:20Z, detached PID 43076, log/tmp/r12/check.log, output/tmp/r12/check. Full-check time is outside the round. Submitted files and switches remain at the latest complete N1 pass. - Full check completed 2026-11-05T21:30:06Z:/tmp/r12/check/check.json, PASS N1, 196.527 s / 1.5832x; windows 53.584 / 72.771 / 70.172 s. Endpoint biases are PSNR -1.940 sigma, SSIM -1.875 sigma, LPIPS +0.398 sigma, log count +0.350 sigma. Promoted as2fafbb2withGS_OPT_DENSE_ADAM=1. Both the screen and full timing improve every accepted-version window.
5.8 hRound 13 — profile the dense-Adam winner
- Started 2026-11-05T21:30:36Z, detached PID 44488, log/tmp/r13/profile.log, output/tmp/r13/profile. Source and switches are the full N1-passing dense-Adam version; no new candidate edits yet. - Control/candidate repeat queue launched 2026-11-05T21:47:26Z, detached PID 48016, log/tmp/r13/retime.log, outputs/tmp/r13/control-timeand/tmp/r13/time-repeat. No simultaneous local work during timing. - Corrected saved-state queue started 2026-11-05T21:40:08Z, detached PID 46166, log/tmp/r13/measure-state-retry.log; original failure logs remain intact. The submitted N1 winner is unchanged. - Saved-state verification/time/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-05T21:38:37Z, detached PID 45969, log/tmp/r13/measure-state.log; per-fixture logs/tmp/r13/state-probe-{base,stress,legacy}.log. No simultaneous local analysis during timing. - Shared-color probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T21:33:01Z, detached PID 45270, log/tmp/r13/measure.log, outputs/tmp/r13/time,/tmp/r13/quick,/tmp/r13/profile-candidate. Probe logs are/tmp/r13/probe-{base,stress,legacy}.log. No local analysis while timings run. - Round-13 selection: forward color loads in the tile renderer./tmp/r13/tree,GS_OPT_SHARED_COLOR=1, loads colors into shared memory once per tile batch and uses the existing barrier, eliminating the shared index array when shared depth is also active. Same float32 values, alpha/compositor arithmetic, thresholds, sort and backward. Main remains unchanged while this memory-reuse experiment is built and probed. - Fresh profile accounting: backward 47.498 ms/20 (39.16%), forward 26.893 ms (22.17%), dense Adam 14.197 ms (11.70%), backward preprocessing 9.757 ms (8.04%), sort 4.609 ms (3.80%). Build launched 2026-11-05T21:32:14Z, detached PID 44963, log/tmp/r13/build.log. - The operator probe reuses the unchanged strict forward-bitwise and eight-repeat backward-envelope criteria. It tests ordinary, anisotropic/near-cutoff, and legacy exp/depth-path fixtures, two cameras and all three loss modes each. Any diagnostic failure is retained; only the judge establishes N1. - Build succeeds, cache/tmp/gs-ext/4eb080c991361f3eb5f78e36. Base and stress fixtures pass all twelve cases, including exact forward images and gradient envelopes. The legacy fixture's last combined-loss DC gradient is 2.869751e-6 relative L2 versus an eight-repeat baseline envelope of 9.262433e-7 (3x = 2.778730e-6), so that original diagnostic fails and the queue stops before timing. Both forward images were bitwise in that case; the backward code is unchanged. The original probe and its threshold are retained. - Investigation adds a separate deterministic saved-state comparison: raw color, final transmittance, contributors, tile ranges, visible geometry, every sorted/unsorted key/index, bucket mapping, and every saved sample that can contribute in backward. Uninitialized sample slots for already-finished pixels are excluded using the unchanged per-pixel contributor condition. This isolates the changed forward memory path without loosening the failed gradient envelope. - First saved-state probe (state_probe_v1.py, preserved;/tmp/r13/state-probe-base.log) incorrectly used the internal radius scratch array, which the C++ code only uses when the external radius pointer is null. The Python extension supplies external radii, leaving that scratch array uninitialized; this produced a false geometry-depth mismatch. Corrected the decoder to compare and mask by the actual returned/saved radii. No production code or numerical threshold changes. - Corrected saved-state checks pass all 18 camera/loss/fixture cases, including the previously failing legacy case: all raw outputs and every initialized backward-relevant state field checked are bitwise equal. The original stochastic-gradient envelope failure remains recorded and unchanged./tmp/r13/quick/check.jsonpasses exact items. - Initial/tmp/r13/time/time.json: 197.563 s / 1.5749x, windows 58.594 / 70.916 / 68.052 s. Total is slower than the 196.407/196.527-s accepted timings, with an isolated early-window increase; both later windows improve. Forward profile is 22.335 vs 26.893 ms/20, still 32 registers and 100% estimated occupancy, shared memory 10284 vs 8236 bytes. This supports a clean control and repeat, not an accepted gain yet. - Control/tmp/r13/control-time/time.json: 196.704 s / 1.5818x, windows 53.905 / 72.767 / 70.033 s. Candidate repeat/tmp/r13/time-repeat/time.json: 202.490 s / 1.5366x, windows 64.847 / 70.054 / 67.588 s. Despite the kernel improvement and both later-window improvements, two total timings regress with an early-window increase. Do not cherry-pick the late windows, promote, or spend a full check on this unresolved direction. No extra compilation graphs are reported. Own-process audit shows no surviving worker/benchmark processes. - End 2026-11-05T21:57:59Z, within the 30-minute round. Shared colors are committed only in the isolated worktree and are not submitted. A future forward optimization must inspect earlier phases as well as the steady window.
6.5 hRound 14 — unused forward depth
- Forward-depth probe/time/quick/two-phase-profile queue started 2026-11-05T22:02:34Z, detached PID 50298, log/tmp/r14/measure.log; outputs/tmp/r14/time,/tmp/r14/quick,/tmp/r14/profile-candidate-early,/tmp/r14/profile-candidate. No local analysis during timing. - Round-14 profiles: early backward 22.619 ms/20 (46.93%), forward 11.116 ms (23.06%), dense Adam 2.619 ms (5.43%), sort 2.069 ms (4.29%); steady backward 47.386 ms (39.13%), forward 27.141 ms (22.41%), Adam 14.072 ms (11.62%), backward preprocessing 9.662 ms (7.98%), sort 4.602 ms (3.80%). - Selected unused forward-depth work in both phases./tmp/r14/tree,GS_OPT_SKIP_FORWARD_DEPTH=1, explicitly requestscompute_depth=Falseonly for cameras with no reliable depth target; the unchanged loss never consumes depth in that case. It returns an empty optional depth output, omits only depth accumulation/sample writes/copy, and retains the buffer layout, all color computations and existing backward. Reliable-depth and default renderer calls retain full depth. This is independent of the unpromoted shared-color experiment. - Build launched 2026-11-05T22:01:17Z, detached PID 49969, log/tmp/r14/build.log. The new probe requires bitwise color and every relevant saved forward state, and compares default depth-enabled outputs. Gradient differences and the eight-repeat atomic envelope are recorded diagnostically without treating that sampled envelope as the judge's N1 gate; all gradients must be finite. This test policy is fixed before results. The prior round's strict probe remains unchanged. - Round 14 starts 2026-11-05T21:57:59Z: fresh winner profiles at steps 1001 and 7101, detached PID 49017, log/tmp/r14/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r14/profile-earlyand/tmp/r14/profile. No source changes yet; next investigation will account for both phases. - All 18 operator cases have bitwise color and checked backward-relevant saved state; explicit depth-enabled cases also have bitwise depth. The intended color-only calls return empty depth. All gradients are finite. Base-fixture color gradients exceed the sampled 3x atomic envelope in all seven compared gradients on both cameras, maximum relative L2 9.14e-5; stress and legacy fixtures remain inside. These are retained diagnostics, not a gradient-equivalence claim or a changed tolerance. The unchanged color backward consumes identical checked state; full N1 remains necessary. -/tmp/r14/time/time.json: 193.149 s / 1.6109x, windows 52.685 / 71.500 / 68.964 s, improving all three windows of the recent 196.704-s control./tmp/r14/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. Forward profile improves at both checked phases: 11.116 to 9.978 ms/20 early, 27.141 to 25.247 ms/20 steady, with 32 registers in both versions. - End 2026-11-05T22:12Z, within 30 minutes of the first 21:57:59 GPU lock. Candidate commit26240d2remains isolated pending full validation; the submission is still the dense-Adam N1 winner. - Round-14 full check started 2026-11-05T22:12:40Z, detached PID 52714, log/tmp/r14/check.log, output/tmp/r14/check. It is outside the round; main stays at the last N1 pass throughout validation. - Full check/tmp/r14/check/check.json: PASS N1, but 204.034 s / 1.5250x, windows 63.621 / 71.571 / 68.842 s. Endpoint biases PSNR -0.107 sigma, SSIM +0.738 sigma, LPIPS -2.360 sigma, log count +0.808 sigma. Do not promote this timing regression merely because the precision gate passes; the 193.149-s screen alone is insufficient to resolve the early-window variation. - Inspection of the judge's existing progress logs (not a new timing run) locates the large interruptions at densification boundaries: shared-color runs around 1000/1400 and 2800/3800/4500; the forward-depth full check at 4800/5800/6000. The clean forward-depth screen has no such later interruptions.densify_and_pruneunconditionally empties the CUDA allocator cache, a candidate cause to investigate with the official profiler before any change.
7.1 hRound 15 — allocator synchronization
- Allocator interaction screen started 2026-11-05T22:44:54Z, detached PID 58671, log/tmp/r15/measure-depth.log, outputs/tmp/r15/time-depth-retain,/tmp/r15/quick-depth-retain,/tmp/r15/profile-depth-retain. Local work pauses during measurement. - Allocator-screen queue started 2026-11-05T22:29:47Z, detached PID 55097, log/tmp/r15/measure.log; outputs/tmp/r15/time-retain,/tmp/r15/quick-retain,/tmp/r15/profile-retain,/tmp/r15/time-async,/tmp/r15/quick-async,/tmp/r15/profile-async. Judge commands handle required extension builds. No local analysis while either timing runs. - Round-15 profile findings (401 steps): submitted winner GPU time is 36.96% backward, 21.96% forward, 11.61% Adam, 8.08% backward preprocessing and 3.63% sorting. Native allocation/free host calls total 23.41 ms, with 32 frees and maximum free 0.243 ms. The depth candidate has 27 frees totaling 69.544 ms, including one 64.227-ms call, plus 23.272 ms allocation. This is a measurable allocator tail, but does not yet prove the multi-second interruptions' cause. CUDA memcpy host times include waits for GPU work and are not treated as pure transfer overhead. - Selected allocator synchronization/churn at actual densification events./tmp/r15/treeis based on the submitted winner, not on either unpromoted forward change. Screen native cache retention (GS_OPT_RETAIN_CUDA_CACHE=1) and PyTorch's installed asynchronous allocator (PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF=backend:cudaMallocAsync, original flush retained) separately. The variable is not reserved; installed 2.8 sources document that backend. No package or dtype change. Profile and memory reports will verify the intended path and headroom. - Native retention/tmp/r15/time-retain/time.json: 195.257 s / 1.5935x, windows 53.028 / 72.349 / 69.880 s. Quick exact items pass. Peak allocated 5.30 GiB, reserved 25.36 GiB (within the 141-GB device). The 201-step event profile has no cudaFree, only one cudaMalloc (1.936 ms); intended allocator behavior is active. The incremental gain alone is small, about 0.7% versus the recent 196.704-s control. - Asynchronous allocator/tmp/r15/time-async/time.json: 203.645 s / 1.5279x, windows 57.362 / 75.283 / 71.000 s. Quick passes but all windows regress; do not promote. Peak allocated 5.30 GiB, reserved 6.53 GiB. Profile has 14721 cudaMallocAsync and 14723 cudaFreeAsync calls plus three pool trims; their overhead outweighs any pooling benefit here. - Reuse the same cache-retention change on the already N1-passing round-14 forward-depth tree to test the suspected allocator interaction. This introduces no new hotspot or rendering change: only the same one-line cache switch. Isolated tree/tmp/r15/depth-tree, config/tmp/r15/depth-retain.json; main remains at round 12. - Round 15 starts 2026-11-05T22:24:52Z: profile the submitted winner first, then the N1-passing depth candidate, spanning steps 5700–6100 to cover multiple real densification events. Detached PID 54145, log/tmp/r15/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r15/profileand/tmp/r15/profile-depth. No source change yet. - Combined screen/tmp/r15/time-depth-retain/time.json: 191.522 s / 1.6246x, windows 52.081 / 70.959 / 68.482 s, improving every window of the 196.704-s recent control. Exact items pass in/tmp/r15/quick-depth-retain/check.json. Peak allocated 5.29 GiB, reserved 25.46 GiB. The 201-step event profile has no cudaFree and only one 0.257-ms cudaMalloc. This single combined screen merits full validation, not a final stability claim. - End 2026-11-05T22:52:07Z (27 minutes after the first GPU lock). Native-cache-only commit8a7afafand combined commit9873605are isolated. Reject asynchronous allocation; do not promote standalone retention's sub-percent gain. Validate the combined source before changing main. - Combined full check started 2026-11-05T22:52:40Z, detached PID 60471, log/tmp/r15/check.log, output/tmp/r15/check. It is outside the round; main remains unchanged pending both timing and N1 evidence. - Combined full check completed 2026-11-05T23:00:22Z:/tmp/r15/check/check.json, PASS N1, 192.566 s / 1.6158x; windows 52.345 / 71.259 / 68.962 s. All windows improve on the accepted 196.527-s full timing, and both combined timings avoid the previous large early-window increase. Endpoint biases: PSNR +0.153 sigma, SSIM -0.165 sigma, LPIPS -0.380 sigma, log count +0.759 sigma. - Promoted the paired changes as4a798d7(unused forward depth) and465993e(native cache retention). No asynchronous allocator setting is submitted. Reserved memory in the clean screen is 25.46 GiB.
7.7 hRound 16 — dense Adam memory and scalar arithmetic
- Folded-Adam probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T23:20:36Z, detached PID 64330, log/tmp/r16/measure-folded.log, outputs/tmp/r16/time-folded,/tmp/r16/quick-folded,/tmp/r16/profile-folded. Probe/tmp/r16/folded_probe.pyfixes a 2e-6 parameter relative-L2 limit before results and retains strict bitwise moments/step counts. Main remains unchanged. - Bulk-Adam probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T23:10:21Z, detached PID 62444, log/tmp/r16/measure.log; probe log/result/tmp/r16/probe.log,/tmp/r16/probe.json; judge outputs/tmp/r16/time,/tmp/r16/quick,/tmp/r16/profile-candidate. Main remains unchanged; no local analysis during timing. - Round-16 early profile (2501 steps): backward render 45.09% of kernel time, forward 19.35%, dense Adam 8.45%, sort 4.40%, backward preprocessing 3.35%. There are 14756 dense Adam launches. An optimizer CPU annotation reaches 554 ms while ordinary compiled-region calls are sub-millisecond; this supports examining lazy kernel specialization alongside memory access, not claiming every historical stall had that cause. - Selected the dense Adam kernel's bulk memory path./tmp/r16/tree,GS_OPT_ADAM_BULK=1: full blocks use unmasked loads/stores, only the final partial block uses masks, and all update arithmetic stays identical. Disable integer-value/alignment specialization for the changing element count using the installed Triton API. The old masked/specializing path remains the default. Generated PTX and bitwise state probes must verify the implementation before timing. - The optimizer probe freezes strict bitwise comparisons of parameters and all Adam state fields across 14 sizes (including empty, scalar, vector boundaries, exact and partial blocks, and a production-sized SH tensor), eight updates each, variable numpy learning rates and missing gradients. It records actual JIT variant counts and generated PTX vector operations; it contains no timing. - Bulk probe passes all parameter/moment comparisons bitwise. Actual JIT variants fall from three (scalar, unaligned length, aligned length) to one. The generic masked variant has no vector loads/stores, while the bulk kernel has eight vector loads and six vector stores in its PTX; register count is 60./tmp/r16/time/time.json: 191.948 s / 1.6210x;/tmp/r16/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. This is not a clear incremental improvement over the 191.522/192.566-s accepted timings, so do not promote bulk access alone. - Continue the same optimizer hotspot withGS_OPT_ADAM_FOLDED=1: algebraically scale both step size and epsilon by the second-moment bias-correction square root, eliminating the repeated per-element denominator division. Moment arithmetic, dense updates, state types, original group learning rates and the remaining precise division/square root stay unchanged. This changes rounding and needs N1, not a bitwise parameter claim. The prior strict bulk probe is retained. - Round 16 starts 2026-11-05T23:02:12Z: profile the accepted winner across steps 500–3000, covering early densification and possible lazy compilation rather than only one steady window. Detached PID 61904, log/tmp/r16/profile.log, output/tmp/r16/profile-early. No source changes yet. - Folded-update probe passes: moments and step counts remain bitwise, maximum parameter relative L2 is 1.12e-7, below the fixed 2e-6 bound./tmp/r16/time-folded/time.json: 191.359 s / 1.6260x;/tmp/r16/quick-folded/check.json: PASS exact items. The difference from the accepted 191.522-s screen is only 0.09%, not established benefit. Bulk-only is 191.948 s. Do not spend a full check or promote either variant on this evidence. - End 2026-11-05T23:28Z, within the 30-minute round. Both changes remain isolated in/tmp/r16/tree; main stays at465993e. Actual variant reduction and vectorized PTX are verified, but the profile's largest optimizer annotation alone is not proof that all previous timing interruptions were compilation.
7.8 hRound 17 — shared colors with retained allocator cache
- Build/probe/time/quick/profile queue started 2026-11-05T23:33:57Z, detached PID 67180, log/tmp/r17/measure.log; per-fixture logs/tmp/r17/probe-{base,stress,legacy}.log. Main stays at the fully accepted round-15 version. No concurrent local work during timed runs. - Starts 2026-11-05T23:29:31Z with fresh early and steady profiles of the accepted version, detached PID 66198, log/tmp/r17/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r17/profile-earlyand/tmp/r17/profile. First GPU lock 23:29:32Z. Both profiles complete successfully. - Steady accounting (20 steps): backward 47.260 ms (39.32%), forward 25.178 ms (20.95%), dense Adam 14.195 ms (11.81%), backward preprocessing 9.748 ms (8.11%), sort 4.618 ms (3.84%). Early forward is 10.117 ms (21.23%). Revisit only shared forward color loads because the accepted cache-retention change removed the early-window allocation stalls that obscured its prior kernel gain. - Isolated/tmp/r17/treeadds off-by-defaultGS_OPT_SHARED_COLOR, preserving the accepted optional-depth specialization as a separate template parameter. Forward values and arithmetic are unchanged; an indirect index array is unnecessary when shared colors are active and depth is shared or omitted. Strict forward/saved-state equality and finite gradients are tested on base, stress and legacy fixtures; eight-repeat gradient envelopes remain diagnostic, with the original round-13 strict probe and its failure preserved. Both arms use color-only forward in color cases, and full depth otherwise. - All 18 camera/loss/fixture cases preserve forward images and checked saved states bitwise. Gradients are finite; the stress color-viewspace diagnostic exceeds its sampled atomic envelope (4.9474e-5 versus 2.1278e-6 reference repeat relative L2). No threshold was relaxed, and only the full judge decides N1. The original strict round-13 failure remains recorded. -/tmp/r17/time/time.json: 187.725 s / 1.6574x, windows 51.087 / 69.417 / 67.221 s. Every window improves over the accepted screen's 52.081 / 70.959 / 68.482 s. Allocated/reserved peaks 5.29/25.12 GiB./tmp/r17/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. Shared-color forward falls from 25.178 to 21.584 ms/20 profiled steps, with 32 registers and unchanged estimated occupancy; shared storage is 9260 bytes. Other dominant kernels are stable. - Round ends 2026-11-05T23:42Z, within 30 minutes of the first GPU lock. Commit the isolated candidate and run a full check outside the round before promotion. Submitted main and switches remain at the accepted round-15 version. - Full check starts 2026-11-05T23:42:01Z, detached PID 69468, log/tmp/r17/check.log, output/tmp/r17/check, candidate commit3c5f726. Full-check time is outside the round; the submitted winner is untouched while it runs. - Full check completed 2026-11-05T23:49:28Z:/tmp/r17/check/check.json, PASS N1, 188.019 s / 1.6548x; windows 51.238 / 69.455 / 67.325 s. Endpoint biases: PSNR -2.0925 sigma, SSIM -1.3126 sigma, LPIPS -0.6114 sigma, log count -0.1816 sigma. Promoted as71dea90, enablingGS_OPT_SHARED_COLOR=1. Both screen and full timing improve every accepted-version window; cache retention makes this combination beneficial despite the earlier shared-color regression without it.
8.1 hRound 18 — profile the shared-color winner
- Full check starts 2026-11-06T00:03:21Z, detached PID 74114, log/tmp/r18/check.log, output/tmp/r18/check, isolated candidatee208969. Full-check time is outside the round. Main stays on the previous full pass. - Build/probe/time/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-05T23:56:04Z, detached PID 71843, log/tmp/r18/measure.log; probe logs/tmp/r18/probe-{base,stress,legacy}.log. Main stays at the full N1-passing shared-color version. No concurrent local work during timing. - Starts 2026-11-05T23:50:53Z with fresh steady and late profiles, detached PID 70899, log/tmp/r18/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r18/profileand/tmp/r18/profile-late. No candidate edits yet. - Profile findings: middle/late backward 47.469/54.140 ms per 20 steps (40.53%/39.85%); forward 21.760/26.399 ms (18.58%/19.43%); dense Adam 14.217/16.649 ms (12.14%/12.26%); backward preprocessing 9.787/12.098 ms (8.36%/8.90%). Select backward pixel-state memory access: the current one-warp pipeline makes lane zero issue every pixel-state global load individually. Prior block-size configurations gave no clear gain. -/tmp/r18/treetests only off-by-defaultGS_OPT_BACKWARD_STAGED_STATE: cooperatively stage 32 pixels in shared memory, then feed the original lane-zero/shuffle pipeline the same state in the same order. No update, alpha, gradient, support or contributor arithmetic changes. One-warp guard retains original loads for other block sizes. Both depth paths are covered by the pre-existing 18-case forward/saved-state/gradient diagnostic policy; full judge remains the N1 verdict. - All 18 camera/loss/fixture cases pass bitwise forward and checked saved-state comparisons; all finite gradient comparisons also stay inside the fixed eight-repeat envelope diagnostic./tmp/r18/quick/check.json: PASS exact items./tmp/r18/time/time.json: 170.638 s / 1.8234x, windows 46.747 / 62.978 / 60.914 s, all improved from the accepted 51.087 / 69.417 / 67.221-s screen. Peak allocated/reserved 5.30/25.83 GiB. - Backward profile falls from 47.469 to 36.202 ms/20 steps; registers 62 to 64, shared storage 1152 bytes, estimated occupancy remains 50%. Other major kernels remain stable. The staged template is present in the trace, proving activation. End round 2026-11-06T00:03Z, within 30 minutes of the 23:50:54Z GPU lock. Commit the isolated candidate and run a full check outside the round; main remains the accepted round-17 version. - Full check completed 2026-11-06T00:10:15Z:/tmp/r18/check/check.json, PASS N1, 170.725 s / 1.8225x; windows 46.837 / 63.035 / 60.853 s. Endpoint biases: PSNR +0.2480 sigma, SSIM +1.2446 sigma, LPIPS -1.9642 sigma, log count -0.5540 sigma. Promoted as6521f10withGS_OPT_BACKWARD_STAGED_STATE=1. Both full timings improve every prior accepted window.
8.5 hRound 19 — profile the staged-backward winner
- Full check starts 2026-11-06T00:24:33Z, detached PID 78628, log/tmp/r19/check.log, output/tmp/r19/check, isolated candidatee640984. Full-check time is outside the round; main remains the prior validated version. - Build/probe/time/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-06T00:16:05Z, detached PID 76037, log/tmp/r19/measure.log; five probe logs under/tmp/r19/probe-*.log. Submitted main and switches remain at the round-18 full pass. No concurrent local work during timed runs. - Starts 2026-11-06T00:12:36Z, detached PID 75536, log/tmp/r19/profile.log, output/tmp/r19/profile, profiling late steady training. Main is the accepted round-18 combination; no new edits yet. - Late-profile accounting: backward 40.886 ms/20 steps (33.34%), forward 26.528 ms (21.63%), dense Adam 16.623 ms (13.55%), backward preprocessing 12.070 ms (9.84%). Select only redundant background-gradient arithmetic inside backward. The same pixel's background dot product is repeated for every contributing Gaussian despite being independent of its alpha. -/tmp/r19/tree, off-by-defaultGS_OPT_BACKWARD_FOLD_BACKGROUND, precomputes-T_final * dot(background, pixel_gradient)at pixel-state load, then multiplies by the already needed reciprocal of1-alpha. This preserves the real-valued gradient for arbitrary backgrounds but reassociates float32 operations: N1 candidate, not a bitwise arithmetic claim. Existing thresholds, color/depth terms and atomics are unchanged. The fixed probe policy now covers 30 cases, adding nonblack background and unstaged-state fixtures without altering thresholds. - All 30 camera/loss/fixture cases preserve forward images and checked saved states bitwise, with finite gradients inside the fixed eight-repeat envelope diagnostic, including nonblack backgrounds and unstaged loads./tmp/r19/quick/check.json: PASS exact items./tmp/r19/time/time.json: 166.164 s / 1.8725x; windows 45.548 / 61.307 / 59.309 s, all improved from the accepted 46.747 / 62.978 / 60.914 s. Peak allocated/reserved 5.31/25.84 GiB. - Late backward falls from 40.886 to 37.198 ms/20 profiled steps, with the same 64 registers, 1152 shared bytes and 50% estimated occupancy. Other large kernels are stable. End round 2026-11-06T00:24Z, within the 30-minute budget; commit the isolated candidate and run a full N1 check outside the round before promotion. - Full check completed 2026-11-06T00:31:16Z:/tmp/r19/check/check.json, PASS N1, 165.832 s / 1.8762x, windows 45.429 / 61.210 / 59.192 s. Biases are PSNR -1.5685 sigma, SSIM -2.1089 sigma, LPIPS -0.5148 sigma, log count +0.6345 sigma. Promoted ascc18c8fwithGS_OPT_BACKWARD_FOLD_BACKGROUND=1. Both timings improve all previous accepted windows.
8.8 hRound 20 — profile the folded-background winner
- Full check starts 2026-11-06T01:02:29Z, detached PID 85470, log/tmp/r20/check.log, output/tmp/r20/check, isolated corrected candidatefb915ceona9a37ba. Full-check time is outside the round; main remains the round-19 full pass. - Corrected parent-preserving queue launched 2026-11-06T00:53:42Z, detached PID 83184, log/tmp/r20/measure-parent-retry.log; main stays atcc18c8f. Waiting without concurrent local work. - Parent-preserving build exposes a second missing standalone include,<math_constants.h>forCUDART_INF_F; fixed explicitly. Original/tmp/r20/build-parent.logremains intact, and the next build uses a new log. No numerical policy or source semantics changed in this compile fix. - Parent-preserving build/probe/time/quick/profile queue starts 2026-11-06T00:51:08Z, detached PID 82766, log/tmp/r20/measure-parent.log. Failed initial tile experiment is committed asa9a37ba; the correction is isolated on top of it. Original probe criteria remain unchanged, and main remains the previous full pass. - Diagnostic evidence: all radii and initialized geometry are bitwise identical, but 107 pixel transmittances and 319 color channels differ (maximum color error 1.4347e-4). This is coverage, not merely geometry roundoff. The upstream tile-opacity test is defined on a rectangle and changing its size changes admitted contributions. Preserve the failed initial implementation as a separate commit, then fix the root cause by retaining parent-16x16 bounding rectangles and parent opacity decisions. Only padded/guarded support bounds may reject a child with no possible above-threshold contribution. Re-run the original strict probe unchanged. Screen only the corrected 8x8 candidate this round to stay inside the time budget. - Diagnostic-only probe starts 2026-11-06T00:47:34Z, detached PID 82529, log/tmp/r20/diagnose-8x8.log, under the GPU lock; no acceptance thresholds change. - The corrected8x8extension builds, but the fixed probe fails its first bitwise-image comparison (000002.jpg, color). Original/tmp/r20/probe.pyand failure log are retained unchanged. A separate diagnostic-only script will quantify image/geometry differences to distinguish an implementation defect from roundoff; it does not establish acceptance or relax the original probe. No candidate has been promoted. - Corrected candidate queue started 2026-11-06T00:43:23Z, detached PID 81910, log/tmp/r20/measure-candidates.log; retries use new build-log paths while reference fixtures and failed-build evidence remain intact. Main remains unchanged. - The first build returns ERROR: the new standalone helper useduint32_tbefore that type was included byadam.cu. Fixed the missing explicit<stdint.h>include; the original build log/tmp/r20/build-8x8.logand underlying cache failure log are retained. All three reference probe fixtures completed and are reused unchanged. No timing or correctness verdict was produced by that failed build. - Reference-probe/build/probe/time/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-06T00:40:10Z, detached PID 81014, log/tmp/r20/measure.log, candidates8x8then16x8. All outputs are under/tmp/r20; main stays at the full N1-passing round-19 version. No concurrent local work during timing. - Starts 2026-11-06T00:33:24Z, detached PID 80041, log/tmp/r20/profile.log, outputs/tmp/r20/profile-earlyand/tmp/r20/profile. Main is the accepted round-19 combination; no new edits yet. - Fresh early/late profiles: backward 15.630/37.065 ms per 20 steps (39.45%/31.28%), forward 8.863/26.521 ms (22.37%/22.38%), dense Adam 2.644/16.456 ms (6.67%/13.89%), backward preprocessing 0.895/12.014 ms (2.26%/10.14%). Select raster tiling, a configuration-class bottleneck affecting the two dominant pixel kernels and their binning. - Isolated/tmp/r20/treesupports build-timeGS_OPT_TILE_SHAPE=8x8or16x8, default16x16. The physical tile grid deliberately retains the original 16-pixel-aligned image extent, including padded boundary pixels, to preserve the radius visibility decision used by densification. Support thresholds, depth keys/order, pixel coverage, representation and update schedules are unchanged. Smaller tiles change gradient accumulation grouping: N1 candidate. - The probe policy is fixed before results: compare identical seeded model states across separate extension builds; strictly require bitwise images, depth, final transmittance, radii and initialized per-Gaussian geometry. Tile-specific ranges, sample layouts and contributor indices are intentionally different and are not compared as though identical. Require finite gradients and record the unchanged eight-repeat baseline-envelope diagnostic. Test base, anisotropic/near-cutoff, and nonblack-background fixtures, two cameras and all three loss modes each. - Corrected parent-preserving 8x8 tiles pass the original strict image/depth/transmittance/radius/geometry comparisons in all 18 cases. Color-only gradient diagnostics stay within the fixed sampled envelopes; several depth/combined-loss gradients exceed them after changed tile grouping, recorded in the probe JSON without any threshold changes. All gradients remain finite./tmp/r20/quick-parent/check.json: PASS exact items. -/tmp/r20/time-parent/time.json: 161.249 s / 1.9296x; windows 44.618 / 59.020 / 57.610 s, all improved from 45.548 / 61.307 / 59.309 s. Peak allocated/reserved 5.66/40.61 GiB. Late backward falls 37.065 to 26.681 ms/20 steps and forward 26.521 to 12.624 ms, while sorting rises 5.478 to 17.434 ms and heavy duplication becomes 4.471 ms. The initial smaller-tile culling failure is fixed at its parent-coverage cause, not by loosening the probe. - End round 2026-11-06T01:02Z, within 30 minutes of the 00:33:25Z GPU lock. Only corrected 8x8 is screened; 16x8 remains unmeasured. Commit the correction and run a full N1 check outside the round before promotion. Submitted main remains the full round-19 pass. - Full check completed 2026-11-06T01:09:04Z:/tmp/r20/check/check.json, PASS N1, 162.161 s / 1.9187x; windows 44.982 / 59.294 / 57.886 s. Biases: PSNR -0.3131 sigma, SSIM -0.4299 sigma, LPIPS -0.2205 sigma, log count -0.4652 sigma. Promote only the complete parent-preserving implementation (f2f13fe+b5dee9d), enabling build-timeGS_OPT_TILE_SHAPE=8x8. The direct-culling intermediate was never enabled in the submission.
9.5 hRound 21 — profile the parent-tile winner
- Full check starts 2026-11-06T01:27:01Z, detached PID 90018, log/tmp/r21/check.log, output/tmp/r21/check, isolated candidate29c2622. Full-check time is outside the round; submitted main remains the prior complete N1 pass. - Build/probe/time/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-06T01:17:32Z, detached PID 87431, log/tmp/r21/measure.log, five per-fixture logs under/tmp/r21. Main stays at the full N1-passing parent-tile version; no concurrent local work during timing. - Starts 2026-11-06T01:12:20Z, detached PID 86895, log/tmp/r21/profile.log, output/tmp/r21/profile. Main is the accepted round-20 combination; no new edits yet. - Profile: backward 26.613 ms/20 (23.44%), radix-sort onesweep 17.434 ms (15.36%) plus histogram 1.049 ms (0.92%), Adam 16.555 ms (14.58%), forward 12.608 ms (11.11%), backward preprocessing 12.081 ms (10.64%), heavy/ordinary duplication 4.275/4.260 ms (3.77%/3.75%). Select the enlarged sort of sentinel-padded parent-tile rectangles. -/tmp/r21/tree, off-by-defaultGS_OPT_COMPACT_SORT, stably selects valid indices, gathers their pairs, and sorts only those pairs. It keeps original unsorted arrays, saved capacity/layout, and restores the sorted sentinel suffix, so every meaningful pair, range and sample can be checked bitwise. Extra scratch buffers and one count transfer are part of the timing. Installed CUDA primary headers explicitly guarantee stable selection and radix sorting. The original 30-case image/saved-state/gradient diagnostic policy is reused with tile dimensions read from the extension before any result; it compares all sorted and unsorted pairs, not just images. - All 30 camera/loss/fixture cases preserve images and checked saved states bitwise, including every sorted/unsorted pair and initialized backward samples. All finite gradient diagnostics remain within the fixed eight-repeat envelopes. First-use activation reports 2,492,718 selected pairs from 4,887,476 allocated entries./tmp/r21/quick/check.json: PASS exact items. -/tmp/r21/time/time.json: 150.463 s / 2.0679x; windows 42.133 / 54.736 / 53.595 s, all improved from 44.618 / 59.020 / 57.610 s. Peak allocated/reserved 5.91/56.44 GiB. Late radix-sort onesweep falls 17.434 to 5.191 ms/20 steps; total profiled kernel time falls 112.569 to 103.017 ms, including the new selection, gather and suffix-fill work. Other major kernels remain close. - End round 2026-11-06T01:27Z, within the 30-minute budget. Commit the isolated compaction candidate and run a full N1 check outside the round before promotion; main remains the parent-tile full pass. - Full check completed 2026-11-06T01:33:14Z:/tmp/r21/check/check.json, PASS N1, 150.745 s / 2.0640x; windows 42.479 / 54.923 / 53.343 s. Biases: PSNR -1.2442 sigma, SSIM -2.1580 sigma, LPIPS -0.6853 sigma, log count +0.2107 sigma. Promoted as3dca7b5, enablingGS_OPT_COMPACT_SORT=1. Both full timings improve every prior accepted window.
9.9 hRound 22 — profile the compact-sort winner
- Reference-probe and two-candidate build/probe/time/quick/profile queue launched 2026-11-06T01:42:13Z, detached PID 91937, log/tmp/r22/measure.log. Candidates are64-autothen64-56; main and submission switches stay on the full N1-passing compact-sort version. No concurrent local work during timing. - Starts 2026-11-06T01:35:18Z, detached PID 91434, log/tmp/r22/profile.log, output/tmp/r22/profile. Main is the accepted round-21 combination; no new edits yet. - Profile: backward 27.051 ms/20 (25.95%), Adam 16.529 ms (15.86%), forward 12.610 ms (12.10%), backward preprocessing 12.114 ms (11.62%), sort 5.191 ms (4.98%). Backward uses one warp per block, 64 registers and 50% estimated occupancy. Select only its launch/register configuration, now that the kernel and tile layout differ materially from the old block-size trials. -/tmp/r22/treesupports independently configured block size and per-kernel register cap, both defaulting to the submitted behavior. Shared state is partitioned per warp, with warp-local synchronization preserved. Compare 64-thread automatic allocation and 64-thread/56-register cap first; keep 48 registers as an unmeasured option unless the budget allows it. CUDA 12.8's cached primary guide confirms the scoped__maxnreg__qualifier; it is not combined with launch bounds. Thirty-case cross-build probes freeze strict forward/state equality and the existing finite-gradient/envelope diagnostic policy before results. Resource dumps and profiles verify actual registers, spills and block size.